"You can literally walk into a retail store every single day of the year and steal $949 worth of merchandise and you will never do a minute in jail.No compounding consequence, the voters I believed were duped because the summary and title said it was the Safe Neighborhoods and Safe Schools Act. So that's all you see in this Prop 47".
Siyamak sits down with John McGinness, former sheriff of Sacramento County and a radio host. There is currently a movement to change Prop 47. And it is about to get enough signatures to be on the ballot this November.
"Under California law, ironically, rape of the unconscious is not a violent crime. Assault on a peace officer with anything other than a fully automatic weapon is not a violent crime. Domestic violence with the word violence right in the crime title is not a violent crime. So we really truly need some truth injustice in the state of California".
You can literally walk into a retail store
every single day of the year
and steal $949 worth of merchandise
and you will never do a minute in jail.
Is it a day or is it per time?
No, no, no, it's per incident.
You can go back.
So you can steal $949 and walk out of that store
and go back in and do it again?
Yes, no compounding consequence.
The voters, I believe, were duped
because the summary and title said
it was the Safe Neighborhoods and Safe Schools Act.
So that's all a person looks at.
If you get that sample ballot
and you see this Proposition 47,
the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act,
I'm voting for that.
My guest today is John McGinnis.
He's the former sheriff of Sacramento County
and a radio host in Sacramento.
A lot of people are saying Proposition 47
has impacted California by causing the retail theft
to increase significantly and drug addiction
and homelessness are on the rise because of Proposition 47.
John is here to tell us his perspective on Prop 47
and there is currently a movement
to change Proposition 47.
And this movement is about to get enough signatures
to be on the ballot this November.
Under California law, ironically,
rape of the unconscious is not a violent crime.
Assault on a peace officer with anything other
than a fully automatic weapon is not a violent crime.
Domestic violence, with the word violence
right in the crime title, is not a violent crime.
So we really, truly need some truth and justice
in the state of California.
Now, do you have any hopes for the future of California?
I do.
The information that's been shared
as a result of this effort to fix Proposition 47,
I think, has gone a long way to open the eyes
and the ears and the minds of California voters
and I hope it stays.
The mayors of these blue cities have come out
in support of the initiative to fix Proposition 47.
So it's not a right-wing initiative
by any stretch of the imagination.
I'm Siamak Karami.
Welcome to California Insider.
John, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Thank you very much.
Great to be with you.
You know, we want to talk to you about Proposition 47.
There's some movement in this state
to get it back on the ballot, to change it.
Yes.
People have been complaining that this proposition
has caused a lot of addiction in the streets.
People are doing drugs in the streets.
It's contributed a lot to the homeless situation
that we have in different counties,
from San Diego to San Francisco to Sacramento,
where you're from, and L.A.
You were a sheriff of Sacramento County,
so you've kind of seen the law enforcement side of this.
Can you tell us more about what did Proposition 47 do?
Proposition 47 reduced the consequences
for a significant number of criminal offenses.
Methamphetamine, heroin, cocaine, fentanyl,
the date rape drug, of all things,
all were felonies to possess
prior to the passage of Proposition 47.
And many of us have a bit of a libertarian streak,
in other words, believe that let people
do unto themselves what they choose,
even if it's a bad idea.
But it's foreseeable that the abuse of these drugs
will cause problems for other people
with whom the offender shares geography.
And so the idea of reducing the consequences unto itself,
very few people were being incarcerated
for personal possession and use of hard drugs at that time.
But there was a program, there still is a program,
but it's widely underused now, known as Drug Court.
So a person who is arrested for, back then,
for possession of methamphetamine, let's say,
would actually go to court and stipulate as to their guilt,
and then take advantage of this program
to actually go through a rehabilitation effort.
And it worked very effectively.
There was a tremendous amount of success
associated with that.
People would graduate from the program
and go on to live healthy, productive lives.
I've just talked to two people in the last couple of weeks,
one of whom is a journeyman electrician,
has a beautiful young family now,
and he said he wouldn't be there but for Drug Court
because he was arrested for being under the influence of
and in possession of methamphetamine.
Obviously, this is pre-Prop 47.
He went to court.
He said, yes, I'm guilty,
but I want to try to get this reduced from my record
and not go to prison,
and I'm willing to go through
whatever recovery programs the court has.
So he did, and as a result of that,
he turned his life around.
Another gentleman who had a very similar experience,
he went on to get his teaching credential,
and he's now a PE teacher, a physical education teacher.
He's a very, very healthy, robust-looking guy,
and he's living the dream.
He's very, very happy.
So they both lament the fact that now
nobody's arrested for possession of hard drugs.
They're given a citation,
and they overwhelmingly fail to appear in court
as a result of that citation.
They just disregard it completely, but it's a misdemeanor,
so they're never in California
gonna do any jail time for that,
so there's no impetus for them to enter
into treatment or rehabilitation.
So those people are all lost,
and that's why you've seen
this tremendous spike in homelessness.
Homelessness isn't really the issue.
I believe it's a symptom of a larger problem,
and that is addiction that has a grip on people
in large numbers in this state,
and it's destroying the quality of life
for people around them, but it's also destroyed their lives.
So I think there's a lack of compassion
in a system that doesn't call for some assistance
to people who are living that lifestyle
to help them get back to a productive way of life.
In addition to the drug crimes,
it lowered the consequences for theft.
It raised the threshold to differentiate
between misdemeanor petty theft and felony theft to $950,
and it also did away with compounding consequences.
So prior to Prop 47, there was a penal code section
that actually, it was Penal Code Section 666,
that said if a person was arrested for
and convicted of theft, a subsequent theft
would be a felony no matter the value
of the merchandise or the item stolen.
And there was discretion.
There was prosecutorial discretion
as well as judicial discretion in that.
So very few people went to prison for it,
but it was a reminder that you would face
larger consequences if you make this your lifestyle.
If you live as a thief to get by, it's not gonna work,
and we will impose consequences on you.
Well now, there's no compounding consequences at all.
So you can literally walk into a retail store
every single day of the year and steal $949 worth
of merchandise, and you will never do a minute in jail.
There's no, it never compounds to a felony.
There's no aggregation of those events.
So part of what we wanna do with the fix of Prop 47
is bring back more serious sanctions
for those who are repeat offenders.
And in the case of the drug abusers,
give them the impetus to go to drug court and treatment.
And in the case of the serial thieves,
let them know that that's not an acceptable way to live.
And there's never been a time in history
when it was okay to steal, never.
Go back to biblical times.
Go back to 1745 BC, the Code of Hammurabi
was established to identify what was not acceptable behavior
and what the sanctions would be for breaking the law.
So now all of a sudden, in 2014 in California,
the voters were told that if they pass this,
you'll make a safer environment.
Well, and I think there was deception
because the Attorney General of the state of California
has the responsibility of applying something called
a summary and title to these propositions.
The summary and title for Proposition 47
was the Safer Neighborhoods and Schools Acts.
Well, there's nothing about this proposition.
Who would know what for that?
Yeah, exactly.
We all want that, right?
If I believed it was the Safe Neighborhoods
and Safe Schools Act,
I would have voted for it enthusiastically.
But I took the time to read the proposition
and saw that it was anything but.
And in fact, there's an irony.
It's a very sad irony associated with it.
It passed on November 3rd or 4th,
I can't remember the exact date, of 2014,
but it took effect immediately.
So the very next day,
Los Angeles County Sheriff's deputies
were dispatched to a big box store up in Santa Clarita.
I don't know if it's a Lowe's or a Home Depot,
it doesn't matter.
So this guy goes in to steal from this big box store.
And prior to the passage of Proposition 47,
burglary is defined as entering a lockable structure
with the intention to steal or commit a felony.
So if I'm invited here to this building,
but my plan is, before I come in,
I'm gonna come in here and steal something.
I'm gonna steal something from you.
And I've established that plan before I come in.
I'm not just a thief, I'm a burglar.
Well, Proposition 47 changed that.
It did away with commercial burglary as a felony.
So the Sheriff's deputies that responded
to that business in Santa Clarita
were prepared to book this suspect for commercial burglary
because there was evidence that he had planned his theft.
He entered the store with the intention to steal
and actually committed that theft.
And they caught him, right?
The store employees caught him and detained him.
The deputies get there and they're ready
to take him to jail.
And they were actually called by a supervisor who said,
hey, Proposition 47 passed.
So now you can't book him for commercial burglary.
You have to give him a citation and release him.
He had that citation in his pocket
when the suspect went to a local school bus stop
where he found a young woman seated,
waiting for a bus in a residential neighborhood.
Remember, this is the Safe Neighborhoods
and Safe Schools Act.
He abducted her, took her into a nearby field
and raped her and left her for dead.
So that is the very day after.
And that would not have happened
if Proposition 47 hadn't passed.
Now, would he go on to live a good life?
Probably not.
But just the irony of what that so clearly illustrates.
This was anything but an effort to increase the safety
in schools and neighborhoods.
So it's taken 10 years,
but I think the public has become very much aware of it.
And not only are they aware of how this is playing out,
but they're beginning to understand
that they were deceived.
They were deceived by the members of the legislature,
the governor and the attorney general
who promoted this and supported this.
This was supported by then Lieutenant Governor Gavin Newsom
and Governor Jerry Brown,
as well as the majority of the legislature.
So was the idea this
because some people were going to prison
and a lot of people were going to prison
and then when people would go to prison,
they will end up learning bad things there,
they will become worse.
Was the idea to stop that cycle?
I honestly, I'm not quite sure
what motivated them to do that.
Some of the justification is
that it's very costly to incarcerate people.
And it is, I think that needs to be looked at.
I think the cost of incarceration-
It's a hundred something thousand dollars per year.
It's along the lines of what it costs
to send a kid to Harvard.
So it should obviously, it's way out of line.
It shouldn't be that much.
But I think if you enforce the law efficiently
and frankly, relentlessly,
you wind up with fewer people committing crimes
and therefore fewer people incarcerated.
And I'll give you an illustration of that.
Way back when there was a very sad case,
ironically it was in Sacramento County,
where a young girl was killed by a drunk driver.
She was a pedestrian on a major thoroughfare
and got hit by a drunk driver.
Her mother was a woman named Candy Lightner,
who started an organization called MAD,
Mothers Against Drunk Drivers,
because she was so outraged by the fact
that DUI offenders would be given
very light treatment in California.
They were not sentenced to harsh consequences
for what is known to be very dangerous behavior.
There's a good case that serves as an illustration
that when you have laws that are clearly understood
by the masses and enforced to the letter,
you can actually reduce the incidence of criminal behavior.
I'll offer a case of DUI in California
as an example of that.
Way back when in the early 1980s,
a very sad case, a little girl was walking
on a major street in Sacramento County
and she was hit by a drunk driver and killed.
Her mother, Candy Lightner, was so offended
and outraged by the fact that there were
minimal consequences imposed on people
who were engaged in knowingly very dangerous behavior,
drunk driving.
So she started an organization
called Mothers Against Drunk Drivers.
Candy Lightner took on a huge notoriety for it.
She's had some personal problems of herself
since that time, regrettably,
and I don't know how she's doing now.
She actually moved to Texas.
But she did make a significant imprint
on the state of California and called for
and got more significant penalties for impaired drivers.
And so some of the critics at that time
were saying that you're not gonna have the capacity
to house all these people who are locked up for DUI.
Well, the reality is DUI incidence dropped.
When people understand that this is unacceptable behavior
and you will face consequences for it,
they change their behavior.
And I think we've seen that in a number of categories.
So my belief is if we get Proposition 47 amended
to where it actually has some teeth in it again,
where the law has teeth again,
I think you will find fewer people breaking the law.
I think you'll see incidence of drug abuse diminish
and incidence of retail theft drop
because it's gotten out of control,
completely out of control.
And the prevailing belief is you can steal whatever you want
and you're going to be held harmless.
And there's frankly, regrettably,
a pretty good basis upon which people believe that today
because the law has been so badly gutted
that it's very difficult to impose consequences
on repeat thieves.
So I'm very hopeful,
and I've had a chance here in the last several weeks
to be among a lot of people who want to change this,
who really truly want to make a change.
And I'm heartened by a couple of things.
There's criticism that this is a right-wing initiative to,
it's a hardcore right-wing propaganda concept.
But I find it interesting,
a lot of people that have come up to an opportunity
to sign this petition to put it on the ballot
have actually disclosed voluntarily that they're Democrats.
And then I look at the mayor of San Diego,
the mayor of Santa Monica, the mayor of San Jose,
the mayor of San Francisco, London Breed,
all of these mayors are very, very proud Democrats.
They've all supported this.
And the reason I believe they're supporting it
is they've realized what Proposition 47
has done to their cities.
If you look at municipal government,
they really rely upon the tax base
that is developed and created by people
engaging in commerce in their communities.
So if you have people avoiding the hotels,
people not able to go engage in retail shopping
and support retail business,
and you have a quality of life that's diminished
by the loss of recreational facilities
like parks and other amenities
that are now have become homeless encampments,
which they're not just an eyesore.
These are places where regrettably
the people who occupy them now urinate
and defecate in those facilities regularly.
They discard their hypodermic needles.
We all know the dangers associated with that.
So it's a health safety.
It's a public health and safety crisis.
So I think it's very, very compelling
that the mayors of these blue cities
have come out in support of the initiative
to fix Proposition 47.
So it's not a right-wing initiative
by any stretch of the imagination.
And I believe, I actually believe we have enough signatures
to get it on the ballot in November.
That remains to be seen with certainty.
If it does get on the ballot, I think it passes.
There's been a lot of debates on this in the capital,
and we've been reporting on that.
Some of our reporters have been closely watching this.
And some of the legislative leaders
and also the governor,
they don't believe it's the Prop 47's fault
that is causing the retail theft.
They think there is a group of organized thieves
that are doing the retail theft.
What are your thoughts on that?
I think there are organized thieves
that are doing retail theft,
but I think they're doing it because of Proposition 47.
Because as a result of Proposition 47,
first of all, that felony misdemeanor threshold
has gone up, that's undeniable.
It went up to $950.
And the fact that there's no opportunity
to aggregate those offenses,
you go back every single day of the year
and engage in the same behavior,
you're not held accountable for all of those thefts combined.
It doesn't become a felony.
So I don't think everybody who's stealing,
by any stretch of the imagination,
is part of an organized crew.
But certainly it invites that,
and you did not have that before 2014.
Because generally speaking,
most retailers had their own in-house loss prevention people,
that is to say people who were
discreetly watching for thieves.
They would detain those thieves
and hold them for law enforcement.
Law enforcement officers would come
and actually advise that suspect of their Miranda rights
and give them an opportunity to answer questions
if they chose to do so with a Miranda advisement.
And if it was a simple petty theft,
they would give them a citation and release them.
If there's evidence that they entered the store
with the intention to commit a theft, a burglary,
they'd be booked in jail.
If the dollar amount was over the felony threshold,
which was at different times $200 up to $450,
they would be arrested for that.
Or if they had a prior theft incident on their history,
they would be taken to jail
for theft with a prior, a felony.
That's all gone now.
That all went with Proposition 47,
and coincidentally, you have a spike
of these retail thefts ever since.
I don't think it is a coincidence.
I think it's a cause and effect.
In addition to that, if you ask the average person
who has been in California for over 10 years,
how many homeless encampments,
how many tents did you see in urban and suburban areas?
I can answer the question for you.
You didn't see any because it was not allowed.
Municipal parks, county parks, regional parks
were not there for the use of overnight camping,
and people would be arrested if they camped out there.
It was just simply not allowed.
That's all gone by the wayside
as a result of Proposition 47,
and the incidents of death on the streets
and addiction have just spun out of control.
So I would argue with anybody
who asserts that Proposition 47
has not played a role in this.
I can't get into their head
and say what their intentions were.
I have a hard time believing that smart,
reasonable people would not foresee
what this has produced because it looked very clear
to those of us that actually read the initiative,
read the proposition, and opposed it publicly at the time
for these very reasons,
and that's all now come to fruition.
So I think we've really done a disservice
to the state of California, and it's very interesting,
and I find this to be a very compelling statistic.
You're no doubt familiar with In-N-Out.
They're a very, very successful
fast food burger chain, right?
It's owned by one company, family owned, and started.
It's one of the best burger chains here.
It absolutely is.
They do very well.
They've never closed a store in their history.
They've only grown.
Well, they just closed their Oakland store,
and it was not for a lack of business.
On the contrary, it was near the airport
and near a business that led a series of law offices
where I actually spent some time,
so I'm familiar with the venue,
and it was busy all the time,
but they closed it because they had concern
for the welfare of their staff and the patrons
because crime had gotten so bad there,
so there is no longer an In-N-Out restaurant
in the city of Oakland.
Similar thing is true of a Denny's
that had been in Oakland for years, and it had to close.
So that is all a product of runaway crime,
and you can deny it all you want,
but the reality is people feel it.
They know it, and the people up and down the state,
I think, are sensing it,
and it's not limited to a particular party ideology.
I think it's a broad cross-section of understanding
that this has been a terrible failure
and it has harmed a lot of people.
Maybe the people that put this proposition together,
they didn't really have the underground
practical experience.
I don't know, but I think it's pretty safe to say,
and again, if you study history at all,
there has never been a time when the propensity
to misbehave on the part of human beings was not known,
and there wasn't some effort undertaken to address that
and to minimize the incidence of that behavior
and to impose consequences on those who engage in it.
It goes back, as I say, biblical times.
The Ten Commandments, those are rules, right?
And so now we have modern statutory law,
and there's never been a time when it seemed advisable
to reduce the consequences of those kinds of conduct
that would have a foreseeable adverse impact
on everybody who's affected by it, the business community.
Frankly, the public coffers are drying up
because they don't have the revenue they once had.
The ability for people to live their lives
and recreate and enjoy life in a community, that's gone.
I think it's very important to acknowledge
that the offenders themselves are suffering
as a result of this, too.
If you think about, think of a young teenager,
and they're at that point in life where we all were,
where you're probably considering maybe
not using the best judgment,
and you're tempted to steal something.
Maybe the other kids are doing it.
Why not do it, too?
Are they better off if they're caught
and held accountable for it on the first incident,
or are they better off if they get away with it
time after time?
What's the likelihood of them
having a bad life going forward?
My belief is, firm belief,
is that we have created a generational layer
of people who have not had the benefit
of the justice system serving them properly,
because when they broke the law,
they weren't held accountable,
and they became serial, habitual thieves,
and their lives are not gonna be good.
Are you concerned with stock market volatility?
The market's closing in on their worst year
since the financial crisis.
Two of the major indices had their worst day since 2020.
U.S. financial markets had their worst day
since the start of the pandemic.
Do you really trust this economy?
News are growing that the U.S. economy
could be headed for a recession.
Inflation soaring to its highest level in nearly 40 years.
Prices for gas and groceries are so high.
Inflation sending already sky-high prices
soaring even higher across the board.
What if you could invest in a portfolio
with a higher fixed rate of return?
That's not correlated to the stock market.
You can turn your monthly income on or off,
compound it, whatever you choose,
and there is no loss of principal
if you need your money back,
and absolutely there are no fees.
Just log on to investverify.com.
Folks, I personally invest my own money with Verify.
Log on to investverify.com or call 888-VERIFY24.
Now let's go back to the interview.
Now, when you mentioned $950, is it a day or is it per time?
No, no, no, it's per incident.
You can go back.
You can walk into the same store.
Exactly.
That's why I say it was taken all the...
So you can steal $949 and walk out of that store
and go back in and do it again.
Yes.
No compounding consequence.
The old penal code section that called
for felony consequences for repeat theft is gone.
That went away with Proposition 47.
So part of what we're trying to bring back
in this effort to amend Proposition 47
is after two convictions for theft,
the third one becomes eligible for incarceration
as a felony, after you've done it twice
and been convicted twice.
So it's not a draconian measure.
It's, they still get two chances.
It calls for two times for them
to break the law to this degree.
Same thing's true with the drug case.
But it also will, if it passes,
and I believe it will, frankly,
and I'll say that on the record, I think it will pass.
It calls for the opportunity to aggregate those thefts
like you're talking about.
So if somebody walks into a Target and steals
and walks right next door to Home Depot and steals
in the same course of action,
those can be aggregated and processed.
They can get to the felony threshold that way.
So it is, the idea is to deter that kind of activity,
to deter that behavior.
My sincere hope, if this works effectively,
is that you'll actually have fewer people breaking the law.
That's the purpose of statutory law,
is to disincentivize and discourage criminal behavior.
If when you get out and you leave here
and you get in your car, you drive down the road,
you're gonna check your speedometer
and check the speed limit
because you don't want a citation, right?
You don't want that fine.
That's a very simple version of it,
but I think you can play it out
to more serious kinds of criminal activity
and it very much applies the same way.
You incentivize compliance
by imposing consequences for non-compliance.
Now, John, before we get into discussing
what you guys did to get these signatures,
and can you tell us more about
what were you thinking when this passed?
Did you think it's gonna become like this?
I absolutely did and I set it on the record
because I took the time to read it.
I read the entire proposition.
I saw exactly what this would do
and this was following a number of years
where we had imposed most serious consequences
on criminal offenders and actually saw a benefit to that.
We actually saw a crime going down
as a result of what had happened.
So I looked and said, wait a minute,
the one that really hit a nerve with me
was the possession of a date rape drug.
What purpose does that serve
other than to take advantage of somebody
who's incapacitated by virtue of a drug
that the suspect administers to them
against their knowledge and then takes advantage of them
in the most egregious way you could imagine.
So to minimize the consequences for that,
it also reduced the consequences
for the theft of a firearm in many cases.
So as long as I can remember,
the theft of a firearm, value notwithstanding, was a felony.
So it could be a really poor quality
$50 Saturday night special.
If you steal that, it was a felony.
Well, that got lumped in with all of the other merchandise.
So stealing a gun up to $950 in value,
unless it's taken in a burglary or a robbery,
but if you leave it in a car, for example,
and somebody steals it, that's now a misdemeanor.
And I think both sides of the ideological spectrum
on firearms should agree that should be a felony.
I would think that the people
who want to enhance gun control
would believe that's terribly wrong.
You need to discourage that behavior
because you're gonna arm felons.
And people who are very pro-Second Amendment
would say, wait a minute,
you're depriving somebody else
of their Second Amendment right to self-protection
and you're also representative of a crime
that would increase the likelihood
that a violent crime would follow, right?
I don't think most guns are stolen by gun collectors.
They're stolen by people
who want to commit crimes with those guns.
So the absurdity of how this was written,
and as I looked at it and I saw more and more challenged,
I went public and in a loud way
and I elicited the help of a lot of other people
in the state to get the word out.
And actually the major newspapers in California
opposed Proposition 47,
but the voters I believed were duped
because the summary and title said
it was the Safe Neighborhoods and Safe Schools Act.
So that's all a person looks at.
If you get that sample ballot
and you see in this Proposition 47,
the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act,
I'm voting for that.
So people need to really pay attention
to these ballot propositions.
They do.
Read the descriptions in detail.
They do.
I guess the description is pretty accurate, right?
The description will give the details.
If you read the full proposition itself, yes,
but it does take some time.
So I just, Proposition 1 was just on the ballot.
Proposition 1 put the state in a position
of significantly more bonded indebtedness.
And there's a little bit of duplicity there as well.
They called that an effort to reduce veteran homelessness.
Well, as you read through 67 pages of language
on what this proposition would do,
there's really nothing for veterans in it.
And it did, it created huge bonded indebtedness.
They call it about $8 billion,
but it goes beyond that because there's debt service
on that and there's interest on that.
It's probably about 10 to $12 billion
in bonded indebtedness that I think will do nothing
to reduce homelessness.
That's what it was supposed to do.
So again, now that one was very, very close.
And I think, I choose to believe that the closeness
of the outcome of Proposition 1's election
was related in some part to the awareness
that people now have because of Proposition 47.
I think there were more people that read it
and paid attention.
So it passed by, I think, 20,000 votes.
Very, very close.
And Governor Newsom, I think, spent $12 million on it.
More, I think his PAC had $20 million.
And then the last few days, he got to 26 million.
Okay, it was a huge amount of money.
I think it was 14,000 on the opposition side.
But I still kind of see a moral victory in that one
because it was very close.
It's still, a moral victory is still a loss.
But I think if Proposition 1 had been on the ballot
two years ago, it would have passed by a landslide
because people would just look at it.
Hey, I feel bad for homeless veterans.
I want to help.
And I'd check a box on that not knowing what it did.
But I went through 67 pages of it
and I wrote 12 pages of handwritten notes out of it.
And I shared that with my radio audience
and implored them to not be fooled and not vote for it.
My hope, and I want to believe it very candidly,
is that there is a sense of awakening that is coming
and perhaps we'll make wiser decisions going forward.
And John, can you tell us,
you've been involved with this signature collecting process
for this Fixing Prop 47.
You call it Fixing Prop 47, right?
Yes, Fix or Amend Proposition 47.
That doesn't eliminate Proposition 47,
but it does make,
I think it ameliorates a lot of the consequences.
So it's been a great experience
and it's been about six or seven or eight weeks now.
And I've lost track of time, frankly,
but it's what I have been doing.
I've kind of put my business on hold
and I've called for volunteers to help with it.
And I've worked with some incredibly great people.
Some of the district attorneys in this state,
including the DA in San Diego County,
the DA in Fresno County,
the DA in Sacramento and Placer County,
Eldorado County, Yolo County,
they have all stepped up and really helped out with this.
And some of their staff have been incredible
on their own time,
going out and helping with the signature drive.
And there's a number of people,
ordinary citizens who have seen what's happened here
and they've volunteered to come out and help us with this.
And it has been remarkably gratifying to see nice people.
We had, I think the biggest single signature event
in the state of California, perhaps ever,
but certainly on this effort was at the Roseville Auto Mall,
which is a suburb of Sacramento.
The auto mall is,
they've got a variety of different car dealers
represented there.
They graciously gave us their venue.
I broadcast my show live there
and we had 3,000 people come out.
There was a 45 minute wait to sign.
And I did, I think it did impact some of those car dealers
that blocked their driveways and so forth.
So I do, I feel bad for that,
but I appreciate their generous sharing of their resources.
And the beauty of it was and continues to be,
because I'm getting calls still,
this brought out the best in people.
It really, the people that came out to help,
and again, it's not limited to Republicans,
not limited to any particular political ideology.
People from a broad cross section of thoughts and ideals
were present.
They're all universally polite and pleasant
and want to do the right thing to help their community.
So there's a very nice little community in Sacramento
called Land Park.
And they are experiencing something
that's very illustrative of what they're dealing with,
that what this all represents,
because their community is,
if you can envision just like little gingerbread houses,
just there's not a yard or a home
that's not well kept in that entire community.
Beautiful place, uniquely so.
But the surrounding area is really, truly decaying rapidly.
A lot of businesses have closed.
The retail stores have to lock up their merchandise.
And so they're seeing the effects of that.
And the people who live in this community
want very much to keep this at bay
and preserve what they have.
So I refer to them as my Land Park Army.
And they've come out and helped very, very,
very selflessly to get signatures.
And I gotta give a shout out to,
by the way, I didn't know these people prior to this effort.
And now we're friends.
We've actually covered some of their stories
on the show as well.
Yes, and they're great people.
And a gentleman by the name of Garrett Hamilton,
who's an Assistant Chief Deputy District Attorney
in Yolo County.
He's taking vacation time,
not to go to Hawaii or to go skiing in the mountains.
No, to go out and work on this effort.
He's driving around everywhere,
picking up petitions, coordinating the signing events
and giving of himself
because he has a front row seat as a prosecutor
to see exactly how badly things have deteriorated
and what an absolute undeniable failure
Proposition 47 has been.
So rather than just wringing his hands
and complaining about it,
he's jumped in to try to help.
And I think that's laudable activity.
And doing that to help the state, right?
Essentially doing-
Precisely.
Put another nickel in his pocket.
This is to make the state of California a better place.
You were sheriff 14 years ago.
How's it now versus when you were doing the sheriff role?
It's changed, not because I'm no longer the sheriff,
but the respect for law enforcement has changed enormously.
And frankly, the effectiveness of law enforcement
has been compromised.
A couple of things have happened.
Proposition 47 is a big part of that,
but there's also something called the Ferguson effect.
If you remember the Ferguson shooting,
Michael Brown, that,
and then of course, George Floyd thereafter,
and a number of other significant events.
There was a shooting of a young man in Sacramento
that was similar.
Stephon Clark was very widely criticized.
It turned out to be absolutely a lawful shooting
on the part of the police.
Everything about it,
it was cleared by the local district attorney,
by the attorney general of the state of California,
as well as the U.S. attorney,
all said, no, this is an appropriate use of force.
But there was a long delay
in getting that investigation resolved
and sharing that information publicly.
So there was a lot of unrest in the city
and the surrounding areas, in fact, all over the state,
and perhaps across the nation.
It has sent a chilling effect on law enforcement,
plus the fact that we're dealing with ongoing early release
of offenders in the state of California.
Proposition 47, and then the next thing that came along
was Proposition 57, which reduced the time
that convicted felons would spend in custody.
And if you have time, I'll tell you a story.
There was a young man by the name of Brock Turner.
I don't know if that name rings a bell to you,
but he was the Stanford swimmer
who found a young woman right off a campus
who was, by her own admission, inebriated.
She'd had way too much to drink and was largely passed out.
He saw her and decided that would be a good person
to take advantage of by sexual abuse.
So he did so.
And so he was convicted of that
and sentenced to six months in jail.
And she actually shared a Victim Impact Statement in court
that greatly detailed the extent
to which he destroyed her life.
And she was also very forthcoming and said that,
hey, I put myself in this position.
I voluntarily and regrettably put myself in a position
where I could be taken advantage of.
But that doesn't give him a pass.
This was in Santa Clara County.
And the voters in Santa Clara County
were so outraged by this
that they actually recalled that judge from the bench.
They said, this is unacceptable.
He's not administering the law properly.
They removed that judge from the court.
Ironically, on that same ballot, Proposition 57 was there,
which was billed as an effort
to keep the most hardened prisoners in custody.
That was what they called it,
the most hardened criminals in custody.
What it did was give the Department of Corrections
and Rehabilitation the authority to release people early.
So what happened on that same ballot
where the judge was recalled for that sentence,
which I believe was improper, was way too light.
And by the way, the reality was,
six months becomes three months
because they get good time credit.
So think about this.
Think about a school kid getting out for summer vacation
in late May, early June.
Think how fast that time goes
before they have to go back to school in the fall.
That's how long Brock Turner spent in jail
for violently, sexually violating this young woman,
which is just egregious.
It's a horrible thing.
But the voters didn't read the ballot language
because the voters in Santa Clara,
if you just take that as a snapshot,
while they discharged that judge in that county,
they also passed Proposition 57,
which normalized that kind of a sentence.
That's the consequence now.
Under California law, ironically,
rape of the unconscious is not a violent crime.
Assault on a peace officer with anything other
than a fully automatic weapon is not a violent crime.
Domestic violence, with the word violence
right in the crime title, is not a violent crime.
So we really, truly need some truth and justice
in the state of California.
I'm hopeful that there's going to be,
this has sparked something now
that will bring about a collective interest
in how business is done.
And of course, looking at all of this
in the context of this very recently published audit
on the expenditure of homeless dollars,
that is to say dollars theoretically expended
for the purpose of reducing incidents of homelessness,
that has done absolutely nothing.
And there's no idea where that money went.
It's not properly tracked.
It's not memorialized.
Nobody knows to the tune of $24 billion
where those proceeds went.
So I want every Californian to know that,
that your money is being managed in this manner.
And my regret is, my concern,
is that I think people hear about it for a second
and they go on to thinking about something else
and they don't think about it again.
They don't fully contemplate that
when they sit down with their ballot to vote.
But I want to get that awareness.
And I don't really care about political ideology.
I just don't care.
I want people who will be honest and forthright
and manage resources properly
and ensure that justice is properly served.
Now, John, from what he looks like,
you've spent a lot of your time
to volunteer for this initiative.
Why are you doing all this?
Because this is, I see it as a kind of a last-ditch hope
for this state.
I don't want to over-dramatize it,
but the state of California
has lost a congressional district.
For the first time ever,
this is not the place people are seeking to live.
We have more people leaving than coming to California.
The amenities here that drew us here,
the tremendous diversity.
I mean, you can be skiing in the mountains in the morning
and visiting at the beach in the afternoon in California.
That's still there.
It's still beautiful amenities, beautiful weather.
That hasn't gone away.
So there's a reason why people are leaving.
And if you look at the people who are leaving,
it's a lot of entrepreneurs, a lot of leaders,
a lot of people who have actually contributed
to the good things in California are now leaving.
I'd love to see that stop.
And this is kind of my hope at this point.
The state's been good to me.
I love the state.
But I am also among those who frankly
have given thought to leaving.
And if we can't get some recovery,
I think probably it's the thing to do
because you're only put on this earth
for a finite period of time.
And I would rather spend my time
fighting a legitimate hard fight to make it better
or finding someplace where things are not so crazy
because we've lost so many different dimensions here.
And by the way, to kind of build on the homelessness
expenditures and the audit of that,
I absolutely believe that everything they have done
is wrong because they're seeking to theoretically resolve
a symptom of a problem.
They're saying these people are homeless
so we're going to endeavor to find them homes.
That's not the problem.
It's a result of something that's broken within them.
They are, I think, overwhelmingly addicted.
There's a gentleman who's written a book
called Hope Dying or Hope Diminishing.
His name is Sherman Haggerty and he was a very,
very successful home builder in Texas.
And he came to California and he volunteered
at an organization called Volunteers of America.
And he actually wound up directing a portion
of that effort to help people through addiction, frankly,
and get them onto the path of self-reliance
and a better life.
His estimation is 85 to 90% of the people
that are living that lifestyle
is because of dependency, substance abuse.
So why don't we go after that rather than trying
to fix the symptom of the problem?
You still have the broken person that will not thrive
even if you provide them with a home,
which frankly won't work.
I think of the $24 billion that were spent
in a five-year period of time,
$24 billion taxpayers' precious dollars
that could have been put to so much better use.
And I'd love to see when people are in custody
for breaking the law, have them subjected to training
and an education that could help put them
in a better path.
If they're going to get out of custody again,
I want them to be armed with all of the things
that they need in order to thrive
as an independent member of society,
to learn a skill or a trade,
and learn how to present themselves for employment.
The reality is we're dealing with now third
and fourth generation people who have never known
a positive role model in their life, never.
Especially, frankly, never a positive paternal role model.
And so they think the only way you get by
is to prey on others.
And that's frankly the lay of the land.
So why don't we work on fixing some of the problems
that have contributed to this mess
rather than trying to mask over it
by addressing the symptoms?
Why are so many people leaving California?
It wasn't long ago, people from everywhere
wanted to move to the Golden State to enjoy a better life.
Sadly, the standard of living has been dropping
in the past decade.
Are you like me and wonder why this is happening?
I'm Siamak Khorami, host of California Insider.
In our film, Leaving California, The Untold Story,
I take you an intimate journey of love, loss, tragedy,
and hope as residents face the prospect
of leaving their beloved state.
Everyday people like you tell their stories
about why they have to move out of the state
even though they don't want to.
Experts and policy makers also give insights
about what's happening behind the scenes.
Together, we get to the root cause of this exodus.
Go to leavingcalifornia.com to view the first 15 minutes
of the film for free.
By watching Leaving California,
you can be part of the solution.
Again, go to leavingcalifornia.com.
Now, based on what you've seen, John,
you've been in California for a long time.
You built your career in Sacramento, right?
Right.
And what was the values of the society
back in the day compared to now?
It was vastly different.
And by the way, I think California was coming off the tracks
a little bit in the early 1990s.
But there was a time when if people misbehaved,
they would be held accountable for their action.
And there were programs to help them while in custody.
We had a jail facility that had welding programs.
They learned to weld.
They learned some basic auto mechanic skills.
We actually had a horseshoeing program.
So there's still people in different parts of the state
that have horses that need the services of a farrier.
So put people through training to give that skill to them,
they could get out.
And some of those people have actually been the subject
of some media coverage and have done very well.
But you have to hold the consequences first, right?
And so we saw a period, as I said, in the 1990s,
when that was starting to slip.
And that was when the voters, the public became incensed
and pushed for and promoted
and passed three strikes and you're out.
And what happened then?
We saw incidents of criminal conduct absolutely plummet.
But over time, we've dismissed some of that, a lot of that.
Most of the three strikes is gone now.
It's eviscerated by the legislature
and some of these votes by the public that have said,
man, we're not gonna do business that way anymore.
I think a lot of it is the proposition concept
has been abused with disingenuous summaries and titles.
And we've really truly lost our way.
We no longer have a justice system
that recognizes what its fundamental purpose is.
And all of this is very interesting
because while we've pushed tens of thousands of inmates
out of the state institutions onto the streets
in your neighborhood, the cost, the budget
for the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation,
which by the way, does neither, has gone up.
Wow.
So how does that make sense?
And I understand people are trying to do good things
and they're working hard and they're raising their kids
and they're involved in youth sports
and all sorts of activities,
structured lifestyles, very busy.
So when it comes time to being informed
and recognizing their role,
the voters' role in our society,
they're at the very top of the organizational chart
in government.
They call the shots.
They determine what propositions get passed.
They determine who represents them in the legislature.
They determine who's in the executive branch of government
serving as the attorney general and the governor of the state
and if I'm afraid we have really truly
not done well in that regard.
The information that's been shared
as a result of this effort to fix Proposition 47,
I think has gone a long way to open the eyes
and the ears and the minds of California voters
and I hope it stays.
I hope, I really truly hope that the vast majority
of people, I'd love to say everybody,
takes the time to read this auditor's report
on the squandering of 24 billion taxpayers' dollars
to fix homelessness.
If it had fixed homelessness, maybe it would be worth it.
Not only has it not fixed it, it's gotten worse.
Now John, do you think the public is the same as before?
Do you think the values of the public in California
is similar to the 90s
or do you think it's changed significantly?
Or the problems we are seeing is connected to the values
that we have?
It's a great question.
I think a lot of it has to do with the proposition process
and this summary and title.
You know, under California law,
the responsibility of identifying the summary and title,
what are we gonna call Proposition 47?
That's the job of the Attorney General of the state
and that's a partisan office.
And there was a time, I can tell you personally,
from talking to when Dan Lundgren was the Attorney General
and his chief deputy was a man by the name of Dean Shelton,
I'm sorry, Dave Sterling.
Dave Sterling was the chief deputy
and part of his job was to actually write
the summary and title on propositions.
And he painstakingly researched things
to make sure he got it right.
He had his own opinions, but he wanted to make sure
that the summary and title matched
what the proposition would actually do.
That's gone by the wayside now.
You have outright dishonesty
in terms of how these propositions are titled.
When you say that Proposition 57
will keep the most hardened criminals in custody,
when you're letting a lot of them out.
And part of what came out of Proposition 57
was suppose you have somebody
who's a career of violent criminal offender
and on their last arrest a couple of years ago,
they took advantage of a deal.
They pled guilty to a paper crime
as a part of their crime spree
and that was supposed to land them in custody
for the rest of their life.
The DA said, okay, this works.
It's cost effective for the taxpayers.
They don't have the burden of a trial.
That person is now out
because they only looked at his most recent crime.
They didn't look at his full criminal history.
If you hear about a major crime,
I challenge everybody to look at this.
When you hear about a major crime that takes place
and it's solved, the person responsible
is identified and in custody
shortly after the crime takes place.
I'm willing to bet that the vast majority,
if not all of those,
are people who are early releases from custody.
There's an absolute abundance of foreseeability
that the best predictor of future behavior is past behavior.
So if we lock people up for a period of time
and warehouse them with others
who share the same propensity for misconduct
and now we let them loose early
because somewhere along the line,
somebody thought it was a good idea
and they persuaded a sufficient number of the voters
to go along with that through a disingenuous summary
and title on a ballot measure,
that person's gonna be out in your neighborhood.
And that's what we've seen.
That is exactly what has happened.
Reoffenses are the norm.
So when I started there,
I think there was a greater recognition.
And I don't know that the electorate have changed.
I don't think they get as much legitimate information
as they once did.
I'm thrilled to see the Epoch Times
take the position they have.
They're filling a void that I think doesn't exist anymore.
In spite of all of the modes of communication
that exist now,
I don't think the public has ever been less informed.
And I find that to be frustrating.
Back when there was three local news stations,
most towns had two daily newspapers.
That was it.
And I think the people were much better informed.
They knew what was going on at City Hall.
They knew what was going on
at the County Board of Supervisors.
And if it got bad, they would let their voices be heard.
I don't think that awareness exists anymore
to a large degree.
And that's hurting us.
Do you have any hopes for the future of California?
I do.
And I hate to be redundant,
but what I have seen,
what I call the big awakening,
as a result, a couple of factors here,
a couple of dimensions.
First of all,
people are seeing what they're seeing with their own eyes,
in spite of what the governor and others may tell them
about the fact that,
no, Proposition 47 hasn't heard anything.
They're seeing that all of a sudden,
their neighborhood,
the area where their office is,
their business is,
the places they frequent,
is littered with homeless encampments and tents now.
They're seeing that.
They're also hearing the term,
rip and run retail theft,
smash and grab thefts.
They didn't hear those terms before Proposition 47 passed.
So there is a discernible change
in terms of how people are behaving.
I think they're believing what others might call
their own lying eyes.
And so as a result,
people from different political persuasions,
again, I think it's important to note,
London Breed,
the Uber left mayor of San Francisco, California,
who was a big proponent of defunding the police,
actually signed on our petition
because she's trying to balance the city's books
in San Francisco with diminishing resources
because people are not buying there anymore.
They're not staying in hotels in San Francisco
as they once did.
It's not the convention capital it once was.
It's not the tourist destination it once was.
So I had occasion to speak to a group in San Francisco,
that's been a few years ago now before the pandemic.
And it was at a venue where they tried to give me
an opportunity to park in their parking structure,
but I got there a little bit late and it wasn't available.
So as I went in and introduced myself
and I was getting ready to go speak,
a gentleman came out from behind a corner and said,
hey, I was not eavesdropping,
but I heard what you're talking about.
They told me to park, I could park on the street.
And he says, if you park on the street,
leave all four windows open
and don't leave anything of value in your car
because they will get in your car.
Then he explained to me
that he was a captain
with the San Francisco Police Department.
And I appreciated his counsel and I took it.
When I left there that night, I walked past two cars,
each of which had a one window smashed out.
So, but you think about the idea,
we're living in a world,
and again, I'm not knocking his counsel, I appreciate it.
But where a police captain is telling somebody
to not lock their car,
because it's inevitable that they will get in your car.
The question is how much damage do you want to endure
as a result of that?
So, things are broken.
And anybody who tells you otherwise is being disingenuous.
But I just sense, and I will be very candid with you,
is with an abundance of hope
that there is a bit of an awakening.
So John, do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
I have a lot of thoughts,
but I'll try to narrow it to this.
And I would just implore the viewers
and people who read the Epoch Times
to pay attention, to really use your critical analysis,
your ability to recognize when you're told something
by an office holder or a politician,
to engage in skepticism.
It's not disrespectful to do that.
Push back on it.
You pushed back on some of my assertions today.
I welcome that.
I think it's good and appropriate.
And that's your job, right?
You're interviewing.
Because we want to make sure it's,
get the right information.
Absolutely true.
And by the way, I would love to debate some of these things
with people who see it from the opposing point of view.
And I find it interesting
that they're disinclined to debate.
I want to share what I have a passionate belief in.
And I would think that those who think
that Proposition 47 was a good thing
would want to do the same,
but they don't seem to want to.
So I just implore the audience
to engage in critical analysis,
to be skeptical and to confer with others
and maybe occasionally read an opinion piece
that might be something that would open your eyes.
I found it significant
that the major newspapers in California
did oppose Proposition 47.
I think newspapers, frankly, in many of cases,
local papers have lost a lot of what they had at one time
and they've given it up.
There's a reason why it's gone.
But that was also-
They had better investigative reporting back in the day
and they were more critical.
They were more critical.
They were less inclined to-
And that's what we were doing with the show
and Epoch Times is like that.
We're actually, we're trying to hold government leaders
accountable for the public.
That's the job, right?
But I think so much in the case of the local newspapers,
they've gotten to be propaganda for their own points of view.
There was just a very recent piece that came out
by a senior person at NPR
that talked about the one-sided nature of ideology
at National Public Radio,
which is publicly funded, ironically.
It was terrible.
It had such big credibility with everyone at NPR.
Yeah, yeah, but not with good reason.
There is no critical thought there.
There's no skepticism.
There's no pushing back.
That's what we need.
That's what makes for a healthy society.
John McGinnis, former sheriff of Sacramento County.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
The pleasure is mine.
Love to be back again.