Do you want to feed 4 people for less than $1? Survival soup may do the trick. This Scottish Broth Soup is a twist on the standard methods for serving beans and rice. The combination of legumes, rice, barley, and seasonings is a wonderful, filling comfort food.
You can store the ingredients separately, create "survival soup" buckets, or store them in jars for individual meals.
Survival Scotch Broth 3/4 cup white rice 1/3 cup pearl barley 1/4 cup red beans 1/4 cup lentils 1/4 cup black beans 1/8 cup split peas 1/8 cup white beans Soak the beans (red, black, and white) and cook in 4 quarts of water until tender. Add rice, barley, lentils, peas, meat, vegetables, bouillon (or broth), salt, and spices. Cook for an additional 30 minutes.
TheProvidentPrepper.org is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. This site also participates in other affiliate programs and is compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies.
We discovered a hearty soup recipe that uses shelf-stable foods and will feed
eight people for about a buck. Yeah, you heard that right. One dollar. Check this out.
Hey, Provider Preppers, I'm Jonathan. And I'm Kylene, and today we're kind of excited. So,
one of our friends sent us this recipe for scotch broth, or otherwise known as survival soup. And
as we kind of did our research and we're looking around the internet, we found that there's some
miscalculations that have gone on with this. But in and of itself, it's actually a fabulous
meal for your food storage, especially when times get tough. It's a combination of grains and
legumes. Specifically, it has 15 pounds of white rice, and originally it had four pounds of the
would provide between 40 and 50 meals. And to get there, we needed more of the barley,
especially because the barley has lots of calories that you're looking for. So,
we bumped up this from the recipe that we had originally gotten. And then the recipe also
called for kidney beans or red beans, and we just did red beans because we like kidney beans in
very small quantities. Lentils, four pounds of lentils, and then three pounds of black beans,
two pounds of split peas, and then it called for two pounds of garbanzo beans.
I'm not much a fan of garbanzo beans or chickpeas. And we could have substituted lima beans for that,
but I'm not a fan of that. But we could both agree on white beans. And so, two pounds of white beans.
And so, that's kind of what we are looking at for this recipe. Now, why don't you help us out and
explain the nutrition behind it and all that good stuff? Okay. You can monkey around with this as
much as you want. It's, you know, this is not a set recipe that has to be followed. I mean,
you could change. If you like pinto beans, you could add pinto beans and take one of the others
out. But let's talk just a little bit about maybe some of the fallacy that some people have
purported out there. Okay. Maybe I should say something. So, they said that if you have five
buckets of this stored, that you could feed how many people for a year? Was it four people for
a year? I think so. Yes. No way. Like, just you should have 60 pounds per person of legumes,
in addition to at least three or four hundred pounds of grain. And so, that totally doesn't
make sense. It doesn't mean that you could have soup frequently if you have that? Yeah. That's
what it means. It doesn't mean that you could survive on it. Right. So, this recipe calls for
basically three quarters of a cup of the beans and then your rice and lentils and split peas.
The total calories for one batch of this is 1139 calories. So, you can see right there,
that's not even enough for one person. If you had that all day, you're still only about halfway to
where you need to be. And they said it should be for eight people. So, 1100 calories divided by
eight people. Then we cut that in half. We're in the 140 range. So, yeah. This isn't going to cut
it from a caloric standpoint. From a standpoint of protein, we're looking at a total of about 49
grams of protein, which is about what I figure I should have in a day just for me. So, again,
we're short on protein. The carbohydrates, it does have 253 grams of carbohydrates. So,
and that's, of course, where we're getting energy to fuel our bodies. But that's not
really going to get us very far. And then the fats, we're almost at zero. We're at 1.98 grams
of fat in this whole thing. So, this is a great soup, but it really can't
do what some people are saying it does out there, that it can feed you well.
So, now that your eyes are wide open and you know for sure what this really is, this is a fantastic
frugal, friendly food because it allows us to be able to, on very little cost, right,
to be able to help to feed our family. And that's one of the great reasons why we wanted to share
this recipe for the Scotch broth with you. Now, we did change this again a little bit
from the first recipe. So, what we did is we mixed together the white beans, the red beans,
and the black beans. And we soaked those for a little while because if we soak them,
then that enables us to reduce the amount of time that we have to cook. We also used a pressure
cooker. So, I cook this in the instant pot. You could use a stovetop pressure cooker. You could
also just use a pot and cook it on the stove. Or, like right now, it's snowing out there. It's
snowy. And so, we weren't able to use our sun oven, but you could also not use any fuel when
you make this if you're using a sun oven, which could be great for, you know, a lot of the year
around here. We're just having some great wet weather lately. So, the first thing I did was I
mixed the beans together. The actual recipe said to put the split peas and the lentils in there
also. I don't like those really mushy. And so, since they have a similar cook time to the rice
and the barley, we actually mixed rice, the barley, the lentils, and the split peas together.
We rinsed them really well because you always want to rinse those. And then, we added them after the
beans were soft because that'll take less time to cook. And then, we cooked it for an additional
about 30 minutes until it was all good. We added... Now, you could add anything you want to
this. But what we added was some of the dehydrated carrots and dehydrated onions. This would be great,
these bouillon cubes. I'm a little bit sensitive to chemicals, so I like to do my own broth.
And I just put in some of my homemade chicken broth that I had made. Salt and some pepper.
And I also put in a little bit of celery. And quite frankly, the soup was really good. I had
intended for Ben to get on camera and show you. But alas, he says, Mom, I really don't like being
on camera. I don't want to do this. So, he said, you can just tell them that his opinion of the soup
was that he liked it, but it was not his favorite. Now, let's talk a little bit about storing these
items. Because like I said, this is fantastic. You could use this as part of a very highly
nutritious food storage program and make this, you know, once a week or twice a week or whatever
it is that your family would like. If you are going to store this, you can store all of these
ingredients separately, which for some people works out really well. Now, if I were going to do this
recipe and with each ingredient separately, what would that recipe be? Just for one pot, we're
looking at three-fourths of a cup of rice, a third of a cup of barley. And again, this barley has a
lot of calories. So, I would probably tend to bump that up a little bit, but the recipe calls for
one-third cup. A fourth of a cup. Okay, but I'm telling you, I wouldn't bump that up. Because what happens
with the barley is when it goes in, it's nice and soft, but then it really swells and it makes
the soup really thick. And so, I like that number. But it's okay if you want to add more, right? Because
this is your own creation. That's right. And then one-quarter cup of small red beans, a quarter
cup of lentils, a quarter cup of black beans, an eighth of a cup of split peas, and an eighth of a
cup of, in our case, the white beans. Yeah, no garbanzo beans here. Sorry. Okay, go ahead. Oh, I was just
going to say, and then you're just going to need enough water. And how much water did you use in
this case? I like about a gallon of water. The recipe says for six to seven quarts of water.
I thought that was way too much water. So, if you like your soup very, very runny, that would be
great. But I like it a little bit more hearty where there's liquid in it, but it's not quite a stew.
But it's a very hearty soup without a ton of liquid. Then salt, right? And we talked about
the vegetables. Add all the vegetables that you can possibly think of and, you know, not let
stuff go to waste. That's some of the beauty of this soup. And then like the bouillon or whatever
you want to flavor it with, that's what you want to do. So, if you want, you can totally store all
of these separately and then just dish out that and put them into your soup. Another method would be
to store it all in one bucket. A lot of these, we might need these different size bags. These are
wallaby bags and they have this kit that has three different sizes in it, which is really nice.
And you could store them all in separate bags. But personally, what I would do is if this entire
bucket was just to make this soup, I would mix together the black beans, the white beans, and
the red beans in one Mylar bag. Now, by putting an oxygen absorber in there, you make sure that
you're getting rid of the critters, any bugs or insects that might be in there or their eggs.
And then I would do another bag that has the other ingredients that I would add last,
which is the rice, the split peas, the lentils, and the barley. Now, you could keep those all
separate if you want. And if you would prefer, you could add the lentils and the split peas
when you do the beans. But if you're soaking the beans, lentils and split peas usually don't need
to be soaked. So you could totally decide that. But then in the same bucket, I would put some of
the basics. Like we have these onions and these carrots and you could open this can, put some of
them in a Mylar bag with an oxygen absorber. You could put it in a quart jar. I'm not going to need
this whole thing of carrots. I don't think I would use that many. Same thing with the onions.
You could also put the salt that you needed or you could put these, right? Put it all in the
bucket with a recipe and seal it. Now, everything should last for 25 years or so, depending on the
storage temperature. You want me to put that down so you don't have to hold it? Now, there is a
question about storing pearl barley and whether or not you can use oxygen absorbers with it.
And that's a really good question because there is a site. It's the LDS site that talks about
safe long-term food storage. And in it, it says that pearl barley is not a good candidate for
long-term storage. So pearl barley, the reason why it doesn't store really long is the same reason
that brown rice won't store for a really long time. So you really have to think about that.
This is probably one of the limiting factors. So you might not want to mix this
with the other ingredients, but the moisture content is low enough that it is safe to store
with an oxygen absorber and not be at risk for botulism. So the other thing that you could do
is you could just store it in quart jars. You could put the beans, put an oxygen absorber in
the bottom, mix the beans together, and then put something like a plastic sandwich bag or
something where you've put the other ingredients so that they're not going to mix with the beans
and put it on top here. And then you can add another little bag, like a little snack bag
that has seasonings if you want. But you could store a dinner at a time just in a bottle and
put it on your shelf. So when you're ready to make this, you just pull out your bottle and it's all
there. And because you've stored it in this bottle with an oxygen absorber, you can still have super
long shelf life. What's the risk for the bottle? There's two risks, right? Light and then breakage.
Just have to manage those. Yeah, and so store it in a dark room because light will degrade the food.
And that's actually not a bad idea. If you're not going to want to make the whole pot, say that
you're only one person, you could use a pint jar, right? Just tailor this any way that you want to
so that it fits the needs of you and your family. The best place we've found to get things like the
carrots and the onions and beans and such is the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints home
storage centers. You can look that up or not. We don't have any affiliation with them, but they have
great foods at a great price. Great place to get them. So now John hasn't tasted this yet because
when he made it, or when I made it, he was gone. And this kind of thickens as it cooks. The more
it cooks, because the rice and the barley that's in it, it gets thicker and thicker. And if you put
it in the fridge the next day, you're probably going to need to add more water because it really
does get thick. And this one doesn't have any meat in it. Personally, I would have loved to put
some meat in it. Hamburger would go great in it. Chicken would go good in it, right? Whether it's
canned or such. We have both home-bottled hamburger and freeze-dried hamburger that's
shelf-stable that would work really well in here. So what do you think? It's actually very good.
What do you like about it? What do you not like about it? The texture's a little different, but...
Because of the rice, right? The cooked rice? Yes, but otherwise, it's really quite tasty.
I don't know what you flavored it with. Just, I had some of our homemade chicken broth
and salt. So that, yeah, that's perfect. It's very, very tasty. It does have a little bit of
garlic in it, freeze-dried garlic. That's good. Okay, now let me ask a question. Would you rather
have had the rice cooked separately and then pour the soup over the rice? Either way would be...
Either way would be okay with you? Just be fine with me. This is very tasty, though, and
maybe a little bit surprisingly so. Kind of interesting. Very basic. But it is very tasty.
But, yeah, I think it tasted pretty good, too. Now, when we're serving something like this,
personally, I would really like like we have the homemade bread. I mixed up this bread. It's made
with whole wheat, salt, yeast, some applesauce, and sunflower lecithin. And yeah, oh no, it has
everything bagel spice on it. But very basic. There's no white flour and it's just ground
whole wheat. And that's one of the reasons why whole wheat is a really good thing to have in
your food storage. So as far as cost goes, I made four loaves of bread and it probably cost me less
than two dollars to make four loaves of bread. Yeah. Now, tell us about the cost. Oh, before we
do that. Oh, see, I can't have that bread because whatever I do has to be, I have to use the natural
yeast because I have a gluten issue. But I don't have an issue with it if it's been fermented with
the natural yeast or the sourdough process. So these crackers I can have with the soup because
I just used the start to make those. Now, talk to us about the cost of the soup. Okay, for the seven
main ingredients, all the beans, the lentils, split peas, the rice and the barley for that bucket,
we're looking at less than fifty dollars. And that's we bought these just at the store. If you
were buying in bulk, you could probably get that price down even further. And this makes between
40 and 50 meals. So we're looking at about a dollar a meal that qualifies it as a frugal, friendly
food. So frugal, friendly. So, yes, about a dollar a batch for good food. Now, again,
you have to add something to this, things like bread, additions to the soup to get your caloric
requirements and your other nutrients. But as a great soup, this is really good and very, very
economical. I think ice cream for dessert would be wonderful with this. That's not very frugal,
friendly, is it? Probably not. And probably not very shelf stable, except the freeze dried,
I guess that freeze dried ice cream. That's right. You can all be jumping on that.
It really is pretty good. So frugal, friendly. Absolutely. Easy to make. Yes. On the stove top,
it's going to take about two hours in the instant pot. It took less than an hour. So when you're
looking at time and I didn't have to with the instant pot, I didn't have to babysit it at all.
Right. If on the stove, you're going to have to babysit it a little bit. But one of the great
things about the soup is scotch broth. It's known for adding any kind of vegetables that you have,
right. Things that were left over from the night before or like random stuff in your fridge.
You could put in there and it all rounds out the nutrition. Yeah. And that way it helps us not to
waste anything, too. This is a stove top pressure cooker, which can come in really handy because you
could use it indoors or outdoors. I prefer my instant pot because I don't have to babysit it.
But pressure cooking things like beans can really save on that cooking fuel. So whether you put it
in a bucket or just store these ingredients separately, hopefully we have empowered you
and helped you not be quite as afraid of beans and some of these other really cheap foods like
lentils and split peas. Now for the question of the day, what recipes can you provide and share
that kind of do the same thing? It's a way of using good nutritious foods very inexpensively.
So comment below and thanks for being part of the solution.