Easy to find wines, but should you buy them?

Wine World
13 followers
Big sellers in many countries: are these wines dlights or abominations?
#wineculture, #wineworld
Today, we are going to taste the 10 wines
All from Burgundy
That's for $20?
That $40 wine before it provides beautiful drinking
But this is better
Now, run to wine stores
It's time to run
Wine No. 6
I thought this was a different vintage
This was the one that was slightly savory, slightly green
This one also had a hint of TCA
Which wasn't there immediately
I went back and sniffed it a second time
And now for sure
Yeah, now for sure
And so I thought this was the faulty bottle
This is faulty because of TCA
It's just a pity that it's faulty
For me, the underlying wine shows an excellent quality
It's my second lowest score
It was one of the highest score for me
Oh, really?
Do you like faulty wine?
Except for that faulty TCA characteristic
But the underlying characteristics, I loved it
I agree, it's very nice
Yeah, but it's a faulty wine
Shame
So shall we see what it is?
We should, indeed
What is it?
Oh!
Grand Cru
This is the wine with the problem
Really?
Yeah
And it's Grand Cru?
Yeah
Oh, yeah
That one needs to go back
Yeah
Joseph Drouin, Claude Vouger, Grand Cru, 2013
So $200
$200, yeah
No, no, no, that needs to go back, Jay
They're gonna give you a hard time to take it back
But take back the bottle and it's cooked
Along with all the other problems, yeah
Yeah
What a pity, I mean, we just had a Joseph Drouin wine
We thought there was a problem right up front
We knew there was potentially a problem
It's amazing how it's always the expensive one, right?
The one we really want to drink
I haven't done it intentionally
What can I say?
Wine No. 7?
The nose is very quiet
Colors kind of quite similar
Immediately again, minerally balanced
But not very complex
I thought it was delightful
Entry-level wine
Quite immediate
Not that complex
I thought it might be a different vintage
So my third lowest score
But unlike the other one, I do want to drink this
Okay
For me, this is one of the oakiest wine
Oakiest?
Yeah
I also think it's an entry-level wine
Yeah, I think it's an entry-level wine
I like the wine a lot
But happy for it to be Bourgogne Rouge
$17
Okay, not $17
No, $17 vintage
It could be $18, but maybe the $17
I thought it was maybe a different vintage
Wine No. 7
Oh, the bottle is so heavy
So it must be...
Yeah, so it's probably expensive
From this winery
Lucien Lemoine Bourgogne Rouge, 2017
I thought so
It's a Bourgogne Rouge, but the price?
It's $60
Yeah, he's full of ----
I didn't say that, but he is
I told you they paid too much for the bottle
Full of ----
Yeah, the bottle must be $40
The bottle is much more than $40
To make the bottle ruins the planet
To ship the bottle ruins the planet
And buying the bottle
Buying the bottle ruins the wallet
Ruins the wallet
I'm not impressed with Lucien Lemoine
I mean, the wines are fine
The prices are outrageous
And the packaging is ridiculous
You make very nice wine
Not good enough for the money
And the packaging is outrageous
Lucien, are you listening?
And it's Lucien Lemoine, right?
Yeah, right
Isn't one less?
One less
One means less, right?
Yeah, right
So this is Lucien Lemoine...
Too much
Too much price
Too much glass
Too much carbon
No!
No
So I got ripped off by Lucien
No, you didn't get ripped off
The wines are not a rip-off
But they're not great value
No
It's quite rare to see decently priced wine from heavy bottles
Isn't that amazing?
They make up for the lack of weight in the wine
By the weight in the bottle
No gravitas in the wine, stick the gravitas in the bottle
But it isn't the same with the people
I weigh more than most of you
But I'm still fine
No, that's okay
But that's not the same with most people
That's just a Jay thing
He's super-sized
But also super-smart, super-delicate, super-intelligent
Thank you, I love you, Peter
Which is rare
Yeah
You have a big carbon footprint
Look at the wine and the food that we eat
And the homes that we live in
Okay, let's go to the next wine
Yeah, let's move on
Wine No. 8
There was a toss-up between entry-level and one step above entry-level
Minerally, easy entry
There was some authority there
Medium length of finish, it was a toss-up for me
In the end, I went for entry-level
But very good entry-level, back to 2018
I really like the structure
And it's firm and it's still closed
Now I think it tastes simpler
You are too influential to me
I don't mean to be, for sure
And you know, I'm not always right
Nobody is, but...
Wine No. 8
Feuillet Bourgogne Rouge, 2018
It's $23
I love this for $23
I'm glad you love that for $23
There was one for, what was $20 was the...
Louis Jadot Bourgogne Rouge
This is sort of Kina, more direct Feuillet than that
Beautiful value
Yeah
Absolutely beautiful value
Man, I could drink that
I think it's a fantastic value for $23
Yeah, beautiful value
Beautiful wine
This is really impressive because Louis Jadot and Feuillet
are one of the biggest...
Very big names
So they have access to lots of fruit
That's also quite a heavy bottle, right?
This one is much lighter than...
Oh, yeah, yeah, no, no
We're not going there
Very, very nice
Great price
Great price, impressive
So now we have all five entry-level wines
Yeah, now, as I said, I thought the last two were higher level
As I said to you right at the beginning
Yeah, right
They both had power and palate authority
And there was only a few things that I was sure of
And that was that these two were at a higher level
So wine No. 9?
Very complex
I found wine No. 9 a little breathless
Slightly reduced
But then the palate was very complex
Very powerful, commanding
Good acid, good balance
I thought it was a higher appellation
I'm very impressed by the overall structure of the wine
But I do not think it's a great wine
It carries really good fruit
But for me, it's a little bit covered by too much oak
I was not perfectly happy with the winemaking
I just felt that more value, more excitement
could have been taken from that same fruit
It's a feeling, I might be wrong
I'm a novice
I mean, I can't go tell the experts like this
Oh, you look like a novice
And trust me, in tasting, these guys might be making wine every year
and all the rest of it
But I taste a lot of wine
Extremely experienced novice
That's exactly right
Extremely experienced amateur
Sounds fresh
Shall we see what it is?
For sure, it's a higher level
Okay, wine No. 9
Feuvelé, Gévret-Chambertin, Premier Cru, Lavaux Saint-Jacques, 2018
It's $120
What was the price?
$120
I'm not happy with the wine because of the fact that it...
I mean, it showed its pedigree
And Feuvelé is a great producer
We just saw for their $23 bottle
But this wine, it's reduced
At least to me, it's reduced
I'll drink some later
When it's slightly reduced, what kind of characteristics does it show?
Reduced means not sufficient air
When you aerate the wine, it goes away
But it's got a kind of breathless character like dried meat
Like dried meat?
It has a sort of breathless character
Like it's going...
Because it's reduced
That's why it's trying to breathe
The nose is not forthcoming at all
A reduction will probably pass with time
With aeration
If we decant this wine, maybe it will overcome it
But they didn't cover themselves with glory here
Whereas they covered themselves with glory at $23
For $123 or $120, they didn't cover themselves with glory
No
Then the last wine
Again, I thought this was for sure a higher appellation
I love the wine
Very cherry fruit
Powerful palatability, very minerally
And some shoulders
And I loved it
My highest score
It feels like a model of a burgundy wine for me
Like a good example
It has very nice fruit in it
But it's not super expensive yet
It's got shoulders, it's got some tannin
This one is very tannic for me
Yeah
I find it very tannic
But I find it's not tannic in a negative sense
It's tannic in a sense you need to understand the wine
That means that it needs a little time to develop the bouquet
This is a wine that needs a couple more years
I thought it was also 2018
So shall we see the buck?
Let's see it
Toumen AF Cro, Chamboule Musigny, 2018
And it's $100
Yeah, it's a beautiful wine
It's a beautiful wine!
Absolutely beautiful wine
Yeah!
But that's a simple village wine, okay?
So, well, not simple, but it's village
But it's a pretty good village
Yeah
We are quite satisfied with entry wines
I thought it was a magnificent tasting
Yeah
Unfortunately, one wine that was out of condition
Which is the most expensive wine
Isn't it amazing that that's the case?
But it's always like that
Last time, it was Chateau Margaux
And this time, it's $200 Joseph Drouin
Clos de Bourgeois, Grand Cru
This is the only Grand Cru here
For more expensive wines, this Le Jadot Bonne Clos des Ursules was great
$80, but it was great
And then we are satisfied with the quality of this Toumen AF Cro, Chamboule Musigny
Absolutely
2018
To me, that was, just by a whisker, the best wine in the tasting
These two are really great for the wines from higher appellations
Right?
And as entry wines, Louis Jadot Bourgogne Rouge, $20
And the Favely for $23
Yeah, Joseph Favely Bourgogne Rouge, Bourgogne Pinot Noir for $23
This one is really great
There's four wines that represent very good value
Yeah, price performance is great
Yeah
On these four wines
Yeah, so you know what I'm going to do now?
Yeah?
I'm going to go and ask Valerie to open a Burgundy
Since we've been drinking Burgundy
And you and I will play with it
Okay
Works for you?
Yeah, works for me
Okay
I never say no
Alright
Okay, one is Burgundy
So you have to tell me which is Burgundy
Left one's color, it's as light as the other Burgundy wines
It's very brightly ruby
Left one is Burgundy
You like it?
I didn't like the nose that much, but the palate, I love it
What's wrong with the nose?
The nose smelled not very clean
But in the palate, it's super clean
So that contrast surprises me
It's also a little bit dusty
Yeah, on the nose, I thought it was slightly reduced
But in the mouth, in the palate, not at all
It's very focused, clean, and with lots of fruit
Fresh fruit, raspberries, strawberries
Shows really fresh fruit and pure fruit
But it's not very complex
So I think it's very well-made entry-level Burgundy
$17, entry-level Bourgogne Rouge
But this one is much better than the $60 one, Lucien Lemoine
And I think one of the reasons that you find it a little...
It's very young
I think $19 is probably a better vintage than $18
I'm not sure of it
Are you sure with the price?
$17?
And this is very good for $17.99
Yeah, this is very good for $17.99
Vieilles Vignes, Bourgogne, Chaume Ronde, Tangent, Berthoud
