Old Fashioned Rice Pudding ~ Extra Creamy Stove Top Recipe

I Cook And Paint
254 followers
You will love how extra creamy this old fashioned stove top rice pudding recipe turns out. Only 6 simple ingredients and about 20 minutes is all you'll need. It's so much better than store bought and only a fraction of the price. You simply have to try it--it tastes just like rice pudding you would order in an old fashioned diner!
Get the RECIPE: https://icookandpaint.com/creamiest-rice-pudding/
#baking #rice #ricepudding
if your rice pudding doesn't turn out
extra creamy like the one you see here
then you have to try this old-fashioned
recipe it's so easy to make in about 20
minutes on your stove top and it only
costs about a fraction of the rice
pudding you buy in the store this tastes
just like the kind that you would order
in an old school Diner once you make
this rice pudding you might never bother
with another recipe again all right
before we begin you want to choose the
right pot for making rice pudding or any
pudding make sure you use a pot that
either has a nice thick bottom or at
least has a very well insulated bottom
and you want to make sure you choose
something that has a good reputation
something that doesn't burn things I'm
going to start by adding 4 cups of milk
and this is going to make enough rice
pudding for four people you can easily
half this recipe if you only want to
make enough for two you can double it if
you want to make enough for eight people
it all works next I'm going to add half
a cup of water
and not only does that give you a chance
to sort of rinse out your cup but the
water is also going to help compensate
for a little bit of evaporation during
cooking all right now I'm going to add
half a cup of rice but this isn't just
any rice this is our boreo rice it's
also known as Italian style rice
sometimes it's a very short grain rice
that releases a lot of starch which
makes it favorable for making rice
pudding let me show you the difference
between that rice and regular long grain
rice so this is the rice that you're
probably making on a regular basis to
make any type of stir fry or whatever
here's the two side by side in
comparison and you can see that this one
here is a lot shorter and this one is
not going to release nearly as much
starch you can still use this regular
long grain rice everyday rice but it's
not going to be nearly as creamy it'll
still be good and it will work but if
you have a choice use the AR boreo rice
so I'm going to go ahead and add that in
and last but not least I have here about
1/4 teaspoon of salt which I'm just kind
of eyeballed I'm going to bring this to
a boil over medium heat and you don't
have to watch this constantly you know
if your heat is controlled you can turn
around and do something else but be sure
to stir it frequently just to make sure
it isn't burning on the bottom of course
anytime you're cooking something with
this much milk there is a little bit of
a risk of it burning on the bottom and
you definitely don't want that
especially when you're making pudding
because then you get all little brown
Flex all through your your pudding and
then it's not really very good of course
if that does happen and it's a smooth
pudding you could easily just strain it
but you can't really do that with rice
pudding or you'd lose all the rice so
here we are it is starting to boil now
so I can see a few of the bubbles is
already starting in there and you're
going to see how creamy this rice
pudding turns out and we're not going to
add any starchy thickeners like corn
starch or flour not there there's
anything wrong with that but because
this rice pudding is thickened entirely
by the rice itself and egg yolks it
turns out extra extra creamy the
creamiest you've ever had you'll still
want to stir it every now and then even
while it's simmering just to make sure
that nothing's burning or no rice is
sticking to the bottom of the pot that's
why it's so important to use a good pot
for any type of pudding you make let it
simmer for about 20 to 25 minutes you
want that rice to be completely falling
apart and I have been stirring it from
time to time just to prevent any
scorching or any rice from sticking on
the bottom of the pot you might also
notice some scum forming on the top like
this it's actually not scum that's
really good good butter fat from the
milk I should mention that I'm using
whole milk here full fat milk just stir
that right back in all right while
that's simmering I'm going to take two
eggs and separate them I'm going to put
the whites into here and the yolks into
here and we only need the yolks so do be
sure you save those whites and I know
there's many probably easier ways to
separate eggs but I'm a little bit old
school when it comes to cooking use
those shells
no need to dirty any other dishes to do
this now I'm going to take these yolks
and add in about 4 to six tablespoons of
sugar and that's really going to depend
on your personal taste how sweet you
want your pudding to be you know
anywhere from 4 to 6 tablespoons should
do it you might even want to add more if
you're a real sweet tooth but here I
added a total of six tablespoons I find
that that's kind of The Sweet Spot for
this recipe no pun intended so just mix
that together until it's nice and smooth
like this should be kind of creamy
looking now let's take a look at our
pudding huh wow what did I tell you
about that fat forming on the top and
this is exactly what it should look like
we're in really good shape here this has
been cooking for about 15 minutes now
and we're almost there but not quite
just another few more minutes all right
now this has been about 20 minutes of
cooking now and this is what the surface
should look like see how on the surface
when you skim it you can really tell
that there's rice in there it's not so
liquidy anymore as soon as it looks like
that I'm just going to turn off the heat
and I'm going to temper this egg yolk
and sugar mixture into the pudding but
you want to turn it off when you do this
cuz it's a lot easier and if you're a
regular viewer of my channel you
probably know the whole story you add a
little bit of that hot pudding into the
egg yolks and you just mix them really
well like this we're raising the
temperature of those egg yolks slowly so
that when we add them into the hot
pudding they're not going to turn into
scrambled eggs so I like to do I don't
know maybe just 3/4 of a cup Worth or so
into there you don't need a lot so now
this feels kind of worm so if I had put
this in straight cold it it would have
been a disaster it would get all curdled
and you'd have scrambled eggs in your
pudding and now I'm going to bring it
back to a gentle simmer for about a
minute or two that's mostly just to cook
those egg yolks make sure that they're
safe to eat and like I said only a
minute or two we're totally using the
starch from the rice and the egg yolks
to thicken this you should only be
seeing little bubbles here and there at
this point to cook those egg yolks and
you might be looking at this right now
and thinking gee that's not thick enough
I like my rice putting a lot thicker
than that but just trust the process it
should still look very runny like this
as it cools it's going to get much
thicker so it's been about 2 minutes or
so of this gentle simmering of those egg
yolks I'm just going to take this off
the heat now and we're going to add two
more
ingredients and those two ingredients
are 2 tbspoon of butter and good quality
vanilla extract and of course I'm just
measuring with my heart so I'm just
going to mix that in and this is looking
fantastic this is exactly what this
should be looking like right now I know
it looks very thin and soupy but this
literally just came off the heat if you
ever notice that sometimes rice pudding
gets too thick as it cools that you can
almost slice it this isn't going to turn
out that way you can still serve it warm
because it is thickening by the minute
now but when it cools completely it's
going to be just the right creamy
texture that we all love in rice pudding
this is what it's going to look like
after an overnight chill in the fridge
you can see that it doesn't solidify
into a brick you're not going to have to
add any milk or cream to make it creamy
again it stays super creamy the
creamiest rice pudding you'll ever make
going to hit that with a little bit of
cinnamon so just a little Shake right
there oo that's nice oh wow look at that
I'm pretty sure that when you make this
rice pudding it's probably going to be
the only recipe you'll ever make that
vanilla flavor is just so perfect and
don't forget that you can get the
complete recipe by clicking the link in
the description wow you're just going to
love it
