‘This has all the hallmarks of ISIS’: Retired general reacts to attack in Russian theatre

The Daily Scoop
732 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 23, 2024
ISIS has claimed responsibility for an attack at a popular concert venue complex near Moscow Friday that left dozens dead and more than 100 wounded after assailants stormed the venue with guns and incendiary devices. The terror group took responsibility for the attack in a short statement published by ISIS-affiliated news agency Amaq on Telegram on Friday. The group did not provide evidence to support the claim. CNN military analyst and retired Gen. Wesley Clark and former CNN Moscow bureau chief Jill Dougherty join Erin Burnett to discuss.
So Matthew, what's the latest as you understand it and what are you able to tell us about this
venue and what was happening, who was there? Yeah Erin, I mean horrific scenes. I mean you
hear those gunshots there and this would have been a shopping mall and a concert venue that
was absolutely packed with people. In fact there was this Soviet era band that was playing that
night and they'd sold six and a half thousand tickets for the concert and that's when we see
those images of the auditorium that was absolutely packed. They'd gone there to see this concert,
that didn't happen, this attack happened before the band got on stage. But what we know is that
at least four individuals, according to local authorities, according to the video we've seen
as well, some of which is absolutely horrific, shows at least four of these people dressed in
camouflage fatigues, carrying automatic weapons. There are some videos that show them firing
indiscriminately into crowds of people in the shopping mall. It's absolutely terrible.
You can see the response of the emergency services there. 50 ambulances at one moment
were sent to that shopping mall on the outskirts of Moscow. Firefighters as well. Apparently now
they've controlled the blaze that has been raging through the shopping centre that was set by the
attackers. It's been localised but it's not been extinguished. 40 people, according to the
preliminary figures, have been killed. More than 100, something like 140 people now. In fact,
the authorities are saying have been injured but obviously that figure could get much, much higher.
It could go much, much higher and as you put the emphasis on preliminary when it comes to the
killed, we just don't know. You know, at first Russian authorities had seemed, you know, there
had been, you know, immediate slamming at Ukraine and it was unclear where this was going to go.
But obviously now ISIS is claiming responsibility. How does an attack like this inside Russia
reflect on Vladimir Putin, obviously in bidets following his obviously sham election?
Yeah, well, it's extraordinary, isn't it? Because Vladimir Putin, you know, sells himself to the
Russian people as the provider, the guarantor of stability and security. But, you know, Russia at
the moment looks more unstable than it has for years. There are a number of fronts in which
Russians, frankly, are dying. I mean, you talk about the Ukraine war, hundreds of thousands of
people from Russia have been killed or injured, according to Western estimates, in that conflict.
Last year there was that uprising from Yevgeny Prigozhin, a Putin ally. So, an uprising from
his own ranks and now these terrorist attacks or this terrorist attack in Moscow. It's like
all sides. Putin's facing a security challenge. All right, Matthew Chance, thank you very much.
I said, Matthew, just a return from Moscow. I want to bring in now the retired General Wesley
Clark, the former NATO Supreme Allied Commander and military analyst here, of course, and also
CNN contributor on Russian affairs, longtime Russia and Moscow bureau chief, Jill Daugherty.
So, thanks so much to both of you. And Jill, to the point where Matthew's saying, right, that
Putin prides himself and maintains his power by maintaining security. And now you have,
in the context of a war, mass mobilizations and many dead, one of the deadliest
terror attacks in Russia in decades. Can you put that into perspective?
Yeah, you know, I think it's kind of complicated, Erin, because immediately people who know Russia
are going to think of previous incidents, terrorist attacks that were used,
exploited by President Putin to take action. Could be cracking down on society,
more mobilization, whatever it is. And they go back, and I covered all of them,
1999, you know, back to 2002, 2004, et cetera. So, that's one side. But the other side of it is,
this really looks bad for Vladimir Putin, because it is a major attack. And if this
is happening on his watch, when he is supposedly the protector of Russia, it just pales in
comparison. So, I think, you know, the most important thing now that we have to watch is,
who are they going to blame for this? That's number one. And then blaming somebody, what will
they do with that? How will they exploit and use that blame? Yeah, and General Clark, you know,
first there had been, you know, from Moscow, the slamming of the Kiev regime, you know,
so it seemed that that's the direction they were going, right? Blame Ukraine. Now, though,
ISIS is claiming responsibility, and has come out and claimed responsibility, whether they did or
didn't do it, they are claiming it. Is that in line with what you think may have happened?
It is in line, because I don't think the Ukrainians are going to go after a target like
this. I think they go after oil refineries, radar sites, military targets. This is clearly a war
crime. They wouldn't do it, as much as they're angry at Russia, and as much as something like
this would bring the war home to the people in Moscow, who have been relatively supportive of
Mr. Putin. But still, I think the Ukrainian government just wouldn't do this. There's no
doubt about Ukrainians working against the Russians. There are attacks in Belgorod. There
are Ukrainian agents infiltrating Russia. There's drones coming in. The security in Russia is sort
of out of balance, I would guess, from all of this. And as Jill said, Putin's trying to mobilize
people and send them to the front. And so there's a lot going on there. But this has all the hallmarks
of ISIS. Jill, the interesting thing about this is that when you talk about the deadliest attack
in decades, no matter who perpetrated it—40 dead, the injured count is going up, the dead count very
well may rise significantly. We simply don't know. And yet silence. Putin still has not spoken
publicly, has not said anything. What do you make of that?
Well, also, we have to note that the media, the state-controlled media, are not saying much of
anything either. So I think right now, in the Kremlin, they are trying to figure out, number one,
who did this, and number two, what do they say about it? Because until they say something about
it, everyone is frozen in place. There will be a narrative. There will be something that they
will say, and then it will be spread all across the media and with all of their officials. But
we just have to wait. And General Clark, the U.S. last weekend said within, I believe it was 48
hours, that they thought there could be an attack. They said on public spaces. They mentioned
specifically music performances in concert venues. Now, they were wrong in the 48-hour timeline.
But a few days later, that exact thing occurred. And they warned Americans. They publicly put this
out there. Apparently, they warned Russia. So what do you make of the fact that it still happened?
Well, I think that there's still a lot of communications between the United States
government and the Russian government. And particularly in this case, it sounds like the
United States picked up some indicators, either listening or informants or something, and passed
the information to the Russian government. ISIS is not just a threat to Russia. It's a threat
beyond Russia. So it's in the United States' interest to take action against ISIS,
even if it were going to do a strike in Russia.
All right. Thank you both very much. General Clark and Jill, thank you.
