On Chat Box, David Cruz talks with LeRoy Jones Jr., the chairman of the New Jersey Democratic State Committee, about the signs of a divide among Democrats over issues like the Open Public Records Act reform bill, the “party line” ballot design and conflicts surrounding the contentious U.S. Senate Democratic primary race. Then, Sen. Holly Schepisi (R-Bergen) discusses lawmakers’ latest move to improve access to affordable housing, her party’s stance on OPRA reform and the status of women in the GOP.
While NJ PBS does not and cannot review every submission and is not responsible for the content of your comments, NJ Spotlight News reserves the right to delete, remove, move, or edit comments that it, in its sole discretion, deems abusive, defamatory, obscene, or otherwise inappropriate or unacceptable for any reason.
-----------------
NJ Spotlight News with Briana Vannozzi is a nightly news program that airs weekdays on NJ PBS that covers local New Jersey news. Be sure to share with us your story ideas, feedback and tips about news in your neighborhood: https://bit.ly/32zwJDT
NJ Spotlight News airs every weeknight at 6:30, 7:30 and 11 p.m. ET on NJ PBS.
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
hey everybody Welcome to chatbox I'm
David Cruz it has been a crazy week in
Trenton even by Trenton standards
there's a massive new the governor calls
it Game Changer bill on affordable
housing that he celebrated this week
even as some say it's not going to
change much we'll talk to Republican Hol
shapi about it in our second half but we
got to start with the Democrats who
thought moving on from Bob Menendez was
going to be so fraught lawsuits against
the line blocking candidates getting
into party conventions it was a lot this
week for the majority party joining us
now to tell us how he's going to pull it
all back together is the Democratic
State committee chairman theoy Jones Mr
chairman welcome back to chat box good
to see you
thank you Dave it's always a pleasure to
be here man all right appreciate that so
so you've been around for a bit in in
the last two weeks Oprah the line
lawsuit Patricia campus Medina and the
Camden convention Steve FIP Attorney
General platkin have you ever seen two
weeks so full of dramatic twist and
turns no why would you think
that but no right I mean not all of
those things together I'm just joking
I'm I'm really joking it's a lot of
activity and uh you know look this this
typically happens when uh you know you
have uh you know these these family
fights and um you know and uh you know
as time goes on uh you know all heals
wound all wounds heal and uh you know
we'll you know we'll move it on we'll be
you know we'll be on to uh the actual uh
primary election uh you know certainly
right after filing date which is Monday
and uh you know and it's game on so I
hope that uh you know it will be a an
election that's based on the issues uh
you know right now uh you know they they
haven't been uh you know it's been uh a
lot of discussion about the uh the
ballot uh design and uh you know the the
party line issue uh and it's you know
that's drowned uh you know the very
important core issues of what we should
be talking to uh our constituents and a
voting public about yeah so it started
with Oprah uh this was a bill that was
supposed to relieve some of the burden
on local clerks um it was found to have
tons of loopholes and the changes that
were actually a burden on
transparency uh it was on a fast track
on Monday and was tabled by Thursday who
who screwed that
up uh you know look your guess is good
as mine and uh you know I think uh you
know the speaker's better judgment was
at that time time uh you know to uh to
hold a bill you know perhaps take a look
at uh you know some of the uh the issues
that were raised in um you know in
testimony to uh you know ultimately do
what the legislature does is to try to
work out a uh a laudable uh um you know
resolution uh and uh you know a bill
that everybody can get behind the other
big story of the week the case against
the Partyline primary system I want to
talk about the statement that you made
about it week in a second because that
also made news but let's hear from the
governor uh when we asked him about it
this week and then we'll come back and
talk about it the base case has always
been that the Attorney General is
obligated to defend statute and then my
third part of the answer is the
following so I'm going to give you the
same the line came about for actually
good reasons you and I are neighbors you
work three jobs I'm really into politics
hey can we can I find somebody who can
be a proxy for me and and really who's
who understands what's going on here you
look at a middle sex County Convention
with 1100 people or Bergen County or you
name it so I I I'm I get why it's come
into place and I get the the value
associated with it but have I been
open-minded from the GetGo to tweaks
that can make this system even better
than it is absolutely and if the
legislature uh wants to proceed on that
process they can count on us for being
good partners so there was this Marathon
session on the suit
uh brought by Congressman Andy Kim on
Monday uh that was preceded by this
surprised letter to the court from the
attorney general calling the line
unconstitutional and saying he's not
going to defend it in court you heard
the governor there said yeah he's
supposed to defend it in court what did
you think of that attorney general's
letter and did you take anything away
from what you heard or or read about the
testimony in the case on Monday so uh
you know the the the uh the letter
obviously uh you know caught the
attention of uh you know of the judge
and uh you know there was a bit of
admonishing uh you know of the uh
attorney general foring so late into the
game uh you know I agree with the
governor I think the Attorney General's
uh personal opinion should not
necessarily be part and parcel of this
process uh you know his uh you know job
is to defend uh the statutes in the
state of New Jersey and uh you know it
was it was a quite a surprise to
everyone
um you know I hate to say this you know
because I know the Attorney General
personally it was a little shortsighted
on his part uh you know and uh sometimes
uh you know things are just left well
you know left alone and that's well
enough but uh you know he opted to you
know to take the action that he did and
I think his hand got slapped what is
that that you were trying to say in in
your statement this week ballot
uniformity what what does that mean so
uh so David if you look at uh you know
ballot design across the state you have
21 different counties right you have 21
uh you know different um uh
presentations of a ballot uh you know I
believe that uh you know there you know
there has to be uniformity uh you know
across the state I believe that uh you
know uh you know organizations you know
regardless of who they are have the
right to associate uh with candidates of
like interest and uh you know and like
mine and uh you know I do believe that
uh and I you know was purposely staying
away from trying to design the ballot
because I didn't think that that was my
role right I was offering uh you know
just uh input so because I be I believe
since this the ballot situation that
we're in right now is a creation of the
legislature then uh you know that should
go back to the legislature you know for
um you know for a uh an amending piece
of legislation and that should include
uh you know testimony from all Advocates
engagement full engagement from every uh
County Clerk uh Grassroots organization
members of the legislature that's what
we do here and that's how you correct
what exists in uh the statute today you
know by you know the amending
features so in your statement you said
ballot uniformity you didn't say uh
uniformity of this type of ballot right
you you're saying whatever we come up
with let's make sure that all the
counties use it
that exactly what I was saying what I
also did not uh you know did not um you
know suggest opposition to was the block
ballot that folks are talking about I
you know again um you know I'm a
Believer in uh the right to associate I
think that's a constitutional right uh
you know I believe in the legislative
process because that's where you get
engagement from all segments of the
community and uh and also I think there
needs to be a very expansive education
program you know to the voters because
as you know uh if there's going to be
change in uh a ballot uh you know there
needs to be time to communicate that to
the voting public they need not walk
into a uh you know a voting booth uh or
look at a vote by mail ballot and see
something totally different than they've
never seen before so I think we you know
we have to give you know uh due
deference to the voters from an
education standpoint with that I think
the legislature if if not uh you know
this if this doesn't come out of the
courts I think the legislature has to
move with uh you know with deliberate
speed to uh you know to put something in
place for our next uh you know big
election and that's 2025 right so but
not for this one which a lot of people
will say yes sure you say save it for
the next one because the candidate that
you favor uh really needs the
line I you know look I I don't think so
and I'm one of these individuals that uh
you know if there's a change right now
then uh the playing field changes I'm
still putting the same team on the
playing field and we're going to play
out of a Playbook that uh you know that
looks for a victory so I'm not one of
these individuals that is afraid of you
know any change I just believe that uh
you know there needs to be uh you know
time to you know to educate voters I
think we have the right to do that I
don't think they need to be surprised by
anything and uh you know and again
ballot uniformity is something that
should occur in every County nobody
should be subject to uh you know that
ballot Siberia that we often hear talk
about that doesn't happen in the county
that I'm in from Essex but uh you know
obviously it's happened in other places
those kind of things need to be cured
and those are the things that uh you
know I'm advocating for in uh you know a
legislative solution so I'm running out
of time but I do want to talk about the
Senate primary uh which is the backdrop
to all of this Steve FIP pulling his
support not only pulling his support of
Tammy but telling her to drop out of the
race uh how much impact do you think
that's going to have on this um you know
look I I think people are uh driven by
their own convictions I don't think uh
you know any one person uh you know will
have you know that level of influence I
thought it was surprising uh you know
that uh a u a person would uh flip on
their endorsement um you know and uh why
that occurs and you know what drove
Steve to do he did that's probably a
question for him you know I've seen uh
you know his press releases and I still
have question mark in terms of uh you
know the Loyalty that one would have to
you know that have would be questioned
when uh you know when you do something
like flipflop and you do it consistently
flip folop got
it
uh he had some valid criticism of the
Murphy campaign though stuff that people
have been saying in private uh his
biggest criticism I thought was that she
has not yet effectively articulated a
rationale for her candidacy do you agree
with
that uh you know look I I I think uh you
know she has but as I said at the outset
of uh you know this uh you know this
segment um a lot of that has been
blunted by the conversation around the
line the issues that uh you know that
Define Democrats and uh that Define
candidates particularly Tammy Murphy you
know have been drowned out by you know a
whole lot of unnecessary rhetoric yeah
and um you know and uh you know we have
to get Beyond hopefully we'll get to a
fix uh you know shortly and then we can
get to the business of talking to voters
about you know what's meaningful uh you
know for a candidate how they're going
to uh serve uh you know in the
respective office that they're pursuing
final question the image of the Camden
County Democrats five white guys
standing like this and in front of this
little uh Latina who's just trying to
get in and and function within a
democracy that's got to be the the worst
image of this entire campaign season
wouldn't you say that was not a pretty
picture uh you know if uh if that were
my organization uh Patricia would have
been uh you know you know she would have
been welcome into the room and give an
opportunity to say whatever uh you know
she felt uh a need to uh to address the
audience and and I think when you when
you do that that becomes the story and
it and and again it blunts uh you know
the uh you know the candidates and uh
you know the issues that they'd like to
talk about to Define themselves yeah
takes away from any discussion of issues
so yeah good point all right Democratic
State committee chairman LY Jones
chairman always good to see you man
thanks for coming on thank you David and
next time I will wear a tie man I'll
believe it when I see it it wasn't all
terrible news for Democrats this week
Governor Murphy assembly speaker Craig
Coughlin and others war in peran booy as
the governor signed the big affordable
housing Bill even though the bill moved
quickly through the legislature this is
an issue that has plagued the state for
more than a generation it also might not
Shock you to learn that not everyone
thinks this law is good law Holly shapi
is Republican senator who's been a
longtime critic of affordable housing
efforts including this bill and and she
joins us now Senator how you doing good
to see you good to see you David you I
haven't been a Critic of providing
affordable housing it's more the process
done how how we do it and kind of
doubling down on bad policy um I've sat
on this committee that's been grappling
with this issue uh first in the assembly
now in the Senate I also have seen it
from all sides up in a municipal
attorney in my prior life um I've also
represented developers I've been outside
counsil to nonprofits that provide 100%
affordable housing and I think the
biggest issue I have other than the
steamrolling it through um in a very
short window a lot of that this year oh
a lot of it and um doing so in a fashion
that really did not give stakeholders
I.E the
municipalities um really in ability to
address and voice their concerns in a
meaningful way um the numbers and the
magnitude of the numbers that we're
dealing with are crushing New Jersey is
already the most densely populated state
people are still reeling from round
three in the implications on their
infrastructure their communities uh
traffic all of it and now we have an an
obligation that's been codified of
almost an additional
990,000 just affordable units that are
supposed to be built in the next decade
primarily in Suburban areas where you
don't have the same sort of resources
you don't have public transportation you
don't have the school funding coming up
from the state in the event that you
need to expand your schools and it it
kind of doubles down and for me the main
concern I have is that the entire
premise of Mount Laurel was based upon
trying to write a historical wrong where
uh people of different minorities people
who were part of generational poty were
excluded from the process of being able
to have home ownership and the way that
these get built necessarily particularly
because of the numbers pretty much
precludes that opportunity for
affordable home ownership at any time in
the future because everything that's
being built is super high density
100% rentals without any sort of home
ownership opportunity for the very
populations that we're claiming that
we're trying to help one of the things
that this bill encourages is taking uh
former retail sites um former kind of
stri strip malls and um uh office parks
and turning those into affordable
housing isn't that an option in Bergen
where retail is kind of
shrinking well I mean there's always the
ability to repurpose but if you're
forcing these kind of phantom
obligations on community by community
and we have 70 of them in Bergen County
with no thought to kind of regional
planning no thought to if you have two
contiguous communities where you're
forcing a thousand new units of housing
into each
simultaneously where you have you know
two lane roads um you know maybe a
Regional
School it really does have significant
practical implications I represent an
area that has some of the most
significant flooding concerns in the
state because there's no place for the
groundwater to go into were buying up
properties pursuant to Blue acres and
under D you know Ever Changing Rags on
you know one portion of the community
and then two blocks away that same
Community after they just bought out to
try to alleviate some of the congestion
and some of the flooding due to you know
these issues is now being forced to have
to allow 34 500 units so but but what
are you saying are you are you saying
that um only urban communities should
take up the responsibility of affordable
housing or are you saying that Suburban
communities should be may be uh uh made
affordable for home sales well it's
first off urban communities get a pass
yeah and so what people don't understand
is we fall into what's called region one
we are our Suburban communities are
getting the affirmative obligations of
Jersey City of hobok and of we hawk and
of communities that have done billions
and billions and billions of dollars of
growth and high-end growth Jersey City
right now their rents are amongst the
highest in the nation and they built
virtually no affordable housing over the
past decade their obligations based upon
all that new construction that they did
none of which is Affordable most of it's
gentrifying and kicking out people who
had been in Jersey City forever because
they can no longer afford to live there
their obligation is being passed off to
the paramis of the world the Westwoods
of the world and we are now having to
absorb their obligation without any of
the state resources that they received
to do so the the mayor there by the way
this week testified and said that he
wants to take uh on that uh requirement
he says that they shouldn't be Exempted
anymore just as an FYI uh so will are
there going to be fewer legal challenges
do you think no unfortunately I think
this is going to start a whole new round
of legal challenges um one of my
concerns from a practical perspective
were the time frames that were put in
this as well because communities have a
affirmative obligations for in early
2025 to have these entire plans approved
um within I think their first council
meeting after reorg seating new council
members and potentially new mayors
they've got to affirmatively approve
numbers that were given to their
Community by DCA it's going to create a
lot of Chaos in the first quarter of
2025 and and the busiest people are
always uh the attorney so um so let me
ask you this on a couple things that are
unrelated uh to affordable housing this
Oprah bill um not so much the pluses and
minuses of it more so do you think that
the legislature uh is going to be able
to to make new rules that make anybody
happy uh and the same with the line
which the leadership from both houses um
say that the courts don't need to fix
let the legislature fix it first on
Oprah and and then on the line so on
Oprah um as we've seen as a of late even
the most
unpopular of ideas maybe to the uh
public at large uh still manage to get
through in the current
Administration um you know I personally
once again wearing multiple hats of
Representative municipalities I've seen
Oprah get abused um and particularly our
clerks get abused by people who take
advantage of the system so do I believe
there needed to be some type of reform
absolutely devil is always in the
details and I think there's probably
going to be a couple of iterations that
we see between now and we've been called
back on April 15th for a you know
special voting session and I could only
assume that uh that's going to be one of
the bills that's on it um it'll be
interesting to see what it ultimately
ends up looking like what about the line
do you think the legislature can can fix
that
or do or do you think the line is is a
good idea so I think there are the pros
and cons on that um we have seen with
and a lot of this is going to tie into
the terrible quote unquote election
transparency act which is anything but
um and the problem that we're going to
have in New Jersey is without the line
it's going to be chaos it's all going to
be about whoever has a bigest super pack
that can circumvent can shake down
people to give them as much money as
possible and so now we're going to see
the same level of money and kind of
nastiness uh it taking place in every
primary um with people being
incentivized to put up Phantom
candidates people being incentivized to
put forth um opposition pieces we saw in
my district even Josh gim
um last cycle uh there was a primary
going on for the Republican side against
Josh and Josh's super pack went out and
and interfered in the Republican primary
to try to sway people to one candidate
and I think we're going to see that
throughout every Primary in the state do
I believe that people should end up in
ballot Siberia absolutely not um do I
think it's kind of ironic and really
hypocritical that some of the people who
are thumping their chests and bringing
these lawsuits are the very people who
benefited from the line and never had
any objections to it until they found
themselves in a primary themselves you
know I I kind of call a little bit of
nonsense on that as well yeah all right
don't ask the legislature to fix
something that they just
broke all right Senator Holly shapy good
to see you again thanks for coming on
with us thank you David a programming
note here we will be hosting a special
1hour chat box in April a conversation
with the Democratic candidates for US
Senate not a debate per se this will be
a group chat with no opening statements
and no debate rules just real talk about
issues affecting New Jersey and the
nation it streams Thursday April 25th at
6 p.m. three of the four candidates have
agreed to partip ipate and some of you
asked this week if we had excluded first
lady Tammy Murphy the answer to that is
absolutely not we offered several dates
and waited several weeks in an effort to
accommodate Mrs Murphy but she has
decided to make just one joint
appearance a debate on a new york-based
network nothing we could do about that
except to say that the door remains open
to the first lady we'd love to have her
and if you see her on the campaign Trail
please feel free to tell her that you
would like to see her join us as well
we'll have more on this in the weeks
ahead and that's chat box for this week
thanks also to looy Jones for joining us
you can follow me on X David Cruz NJ and
find web extras and full episodes when
you scan the QR code on your screen I'm
David Cruz for the entire crew here at
Gateway Center in downtown Newark thanks
for watching we'll see you next week
major funding for a chat box with David
Cruz is provided by the members of the
New Jersey education Association making
public schools great for every child
promotional support is provided by
Insider NJ a political intelligence
Network dedicated to New Jersey
political news Insider NJ is committed
to giving serious political players an
interactive forum for ideas discussion
and insight online at Insider
[Music]
nj.com