What does the new security law mean for Hong Kong citizens? | DW News

The Daily Scoop
732 followers
Mar 19, 2024
The United Nations' top human rights official has expressed concern after Hong Kong lawmakers approved a controversial new national security law.
The legislation is an extension of an existing law passed in 2020. It gives the government greater powers to suppress dissent, mirroring laws in mainland China. It was a demand of China's communist government in Beijing which has been increasing its authority over Hong Kong.
For more on this, we talk to Nathan Law. He is a former Hong Kong lawmaker and activist, now in exile in London.
Now, the United Nations top human rights official has expressed concern after Hong Kong lawmakers
approved a controversial new national security law.
The legislation is an extension of an existing law that was passed in 2020.
It gives the government greater powers to suppress dissent, mirroring laws in mainland
China.
It was a demand of China's communist government in Beijing, which has been increasing its
authority over Hong Kong.
Phoebe Kong was there for the vote in Hong Kong, and I asked her why this new security
legislation was fast-tracked.
Well, the bill was just passed in this chamber of Hong Kong legislature that we can still
hear the cheers of the 89 pro-Beijing lawmakers and the officials who are now celebrating
the passage of the law.
It took only 12 days to have the bill tabled for the final round of scrutiny in this very
chamber and get it passed since it was first released earlier this month.
That was the time when the public had the first chance to really to look into the details
of the wordings and the penalties of the over 200 pages of legal clauses.
The chief executive John Lee has just delivered a speech in the chamber and told lawmakers
and the public that the law will come into effect on 23rd of March, that is the coming
Sunday, the coming Saturday, sorry.
He described it as a historic moment for Hong Kong to finally accomplish its constitutional
duty, which was stipulated in the city's mini-constitution, Article 23.
On the other hand, political analysts also say this could be a tactic of the authorities
to get it passed so quickly that it catch almost like all of the press groups overseas
and many observers off guard that it's harder for them to liberally respond in a short period
of time.
All right.
DW correspondent in Hong Kong, Phoebe Kong.
Thanks so much, Phoebe.
We're joined now by Nathan Law, a former Hong Kong lawmaker and activist, now in exile
in London.
Thanks so much for joining us, Nathan.
Can I ask you what it is like for you to see this law be approved in Hong Kong today?
It's definitely devastating and disheartening.
I think a lot of Hong Kong people share the same feeling.
The difference is if they are in Hong Kong, they are unable to express that.
If we look through the consultation paper and the contents of the law, we can put the
legal articles aside, just look at how they express and how they see the world.
It wholesale adopts the world view of the Chinese Communist Party, which it says that
there are so many external wholesale forces trying to subvert Hong Kong, and that is completely
false.
Hong Kong has attributed all these uprisings and protests for the past years as a result
of these foreign forces disturbing Hong Kong, which is also untrue.
If you follow this world view and seeing all these international organizations and foreign
governments as your enemy, how come Hong Kong can still be open, liberal and international?
I think this is a big question laying ahead.
Nathan, tell us what this law will mean exactly for Hong Kong citizens.
This law is another patch of national security law after the implementation of the first
round of it in 2020.
It really targets foreign nationals in Hong Kong, foreign organizations operating in Hong
Kong, and also Hong Kong organizations overseas.
It also poses a lot of threat to journalists and other civil society stakeholders because,
for example, in the article of theft to state secrets, it doesn't define clearly what these
state secrets are.
An investigative journalist could fall into this legal trap easily if they discover anything
that the government wants to hide.
In general, it is another set of laws that allows the government to crack down the civil
society and it increases the power for the government, for example, to arbitrarily arrest
people to break into people's homes without a warrant and also really strengthen the penalties
of numerous different charges.
You've made it very clear quite how far this law will reach.
I mean, you have witnessed the erosion of democracy in Hong Kong firsthand.
How much worse might things get, do you think?
Well, of course, for some people, if they get accustomed to the way of living, to the
political control in mainland China, they will think Hong Kong is just another extension
of China.
But in reality, why Hong Kong is special is because it is kind of part of China, but it
has a different system.
So for me, this is definitely another big erosion and damage to Hong Kong as an international
hub, as a place which should enjoy freedom and rule of law and also eventually democracy.
And for a lot of activists in jail, they are also really concerned because there are lots
of clauses that may add up their jail sentencing.
If we look at the implementation of the national security law in these around four years, there
are 100 percent of conviction rates when it comes to the tailor-made national security
courts.
And the government has the ability to appoint judges and deny jury trials.
All these things combined, we can definitely see the politics in Hong Kong is getting much
more restricted and much more suppressive.
How do you think the international community should respond to this legislation?
We've seen a lot of governments expressing their concerns, a lot of international organizations
and parliamentarians also demanding more actions, for example, sanctioning all the individual
officials.
For me, these are definitely good way ahead.
But at the end of the day, the reason why Hong Kong has fallen into an authoritarian
police state is because China's influence has been expanding and there are just not
enough deterrents for them to grow their authoritarian in the borders and also across
the borders.
So, this is something, I think, one of the very important tasks international communities
should act on and to strategize to restrict that kind of authoritarian expansion from
the Chinese Communist Party.
Nathan Law, former Hong Kong lawmaker and activist, joining us from London.
Thank you so much for your time today.
Thank you so much.
