Did Taylor Swift Make Singapore a Mountain of Money?

InsightAsia
895 followers
2.6K Video Views·Mar 17, 2024
Singapore paid Taylor Swift to perform exclusively in the country, sparking debates among political leaders in the region. What are the economics and geopolitics surrounding Taylor Swift? Why is she considered so special?
Isn't she quite iconic?
Taylor Swift, the American singer and songwriter, has created an economy about her,
Swiftonomics, and even caused quite some geopolitics phenomena or
as many of the world's leaders scrambled to invite her to perform in their own country.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau also invited Taylor Swift to perform in Canada last
July. And over in Asia, Singapore reportedly paid Taylor Swift to exclusively perform in the country
and nowhere else in Southeast Asia. And that potentially caused some discontent
from the neighboring countries. So what is all the economics,
the geopolitics created by her all about? How did it play out in Singapore?
And for those who really don't know, what is so special about her?
Yes, it's Taylor Swift and the economic phenomenon associated with all those boosts
in spending by her fans in tourism, accommodation, transportation, F&B,
and all those related services industries due to her concerts are termed Swiftonomics.
And that is partially why so many countries eagerly invite Taylor Swift to perform,
hoping to get a lift to their economy. Singapore was made to look really bad,
as the Thai Prime Minister Sridharadasan revealed that Singapore paid a hefty sum
to Taylor Swift for her performances in the city-state on the condition that Singapore
is the singer's only stop in Southeast Asia. That, of course, stirred up quite a debate.
One Filipino lawmaker calling on Singapore to be doing not what a good neighbor would do,
prompted responses and explanations from the Singapore Prime Minister.
Taylor Swift is performing in Singapore. We negotiated, our agencies negotiated an
arrangement with her to come to Singapore and perform and to make Singapore her only
stop in Southeast Asia. And a deal was reached. And so it has turned out to be a very successful
arrangement. I don't see that as being unfriendly. Sometimes one country makes a deal, sometimes
another country does. Business Insider claimed that Taylor Swift is making Singapore a mountain
of money. Is that true? How much did the Singapore government pay and is it worth it?
Here are some snapshots of the immediate effects. For one, hotel room prices definitely have gone
up a lot. This hotel located along Orchard Road, Singapore's most established shopping area,
offered rooms priced in the range between 200 and 600 Singapore dollars per night over the weekend,
two weeks after Taylor Swift's performance. But this very same hotel only had rooms available
priced over 1,000 Singapore dollars, that's 750 US dollars per night, for March 2nd,
the first day of Taylor Swift's Singapore concert. That's almost five times the price for the same
room type just two weeks later. What do you think of this stellar rising price? So how much did
Singapore pay to ensure Miss Swift would only perform in Singapore and nowhere else in the
region? The Thai Prime Minister alleged it's up to 4 million Singapore dollars or 3 million US
dollars per show. Well, that's about 24 million Singapore dollars or 18 million US dollars for
her six performances in total. Although Singapore's Minister for Culture, Community and Youth,
Edwin Ton denied it. I can say that it is not accurate and not anywhere as high as speculated.
But even if Singapore did pay such a sum, the estimated gain seems to far exceed the cost.
According to Maybank's Directive Macro Research, Taylor Swift's concert can bring in tourism
revenue from about 350 million Singapore dollars to 500 million Singapore dollars.
That's about 260 million to 375 million US dollars. We too can do a little bit of simple
calculation here. The concert took place at the National Stadium of Singapore, which seats
55,000 people. For the six concerts, that's 55,000 times six. Suppose 50% of the concert
goers are from overseas. In fact, some sources say it's 70%. And each foreign concert goer stays
three nights in a hotel for a price of average at 250 Singapore dollars. That total cost would be
more than 123 million Singapore dollars. Now, do you think the deal is worth the price?
But of course, there are voices questioning whether it is a sound investment using taxpayers'
money to attract the superstar. The senior lecturer with the National University of Singapore raised
the question of how the benefits trickle down back to the taxpayers, and if it is a sustainable
strategy for Singapore to remain competitive that allows the transformation of the city-state
from just a stopover to a stay-over destination in tourism.
Okay, so the next big question is, why is she so special that the political leaders of so many
countries talk about her and try to get her to perform? When was the last time we saw such a
thing happening? For the Beatles or Michael Jackson? In Ms. Swift's own words, it's because
of her storytelling that connects with her fans, creating a sense of feeling that they have grown
together. Everybody in music has their own sort of niche specialty thing that they do
that, you know, sets them apart from everybody else. And my storytelling is what it is for me.
I know that without me writing my own songs, I wouldn't be here.
Well, I think she's definitely talented.
Being able to write songs and perform at age of 13. Not a lot of people can do that, right?
So now what do you think? Leave your comments below.
