美國麻省理工首席退休科學家潘志生(5): 震撼彈!光復香港言論自由!第一步可做咩!篤正快必煽動罪案終極法律觀點! #Lucy連線

《看中國》香港頻道
2698粉絲
1 次觀看·2024年3月15日
🔥請加入乾净世界 https://www.ganjing.com/zh-CN/channel/1f6j576aqao3taCY3b7gv3NXG1540c<br>🔥請加入我們的Patreon,http://www.patreon.com/visiontimesHK<br>🔥請首選Stripe捐款:https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/donate.html<br>🔥請加入榮譽會員: https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/subscribe.html<br><br>香港巨變、新聞自由日益收窄,同香港人一齊經歷過槍林彈戰嘅我哋,國安法後要面對更多嘅挑戰同打壓,加上FaceBook Youtube等嘅種種限制、黃標甚至關閉,「報導真相,揭露邪惡」變得越嚟越艱難。<br><br>不過,無論前路有幾咁艱難險阻,我哋永不忘初衷,荊棘路上繼續為大家深挖真相,還公民知情權!<br><br>感謝你哋一路以來嘅不離不棄,請繼續支持我哋,加入我哋嘅Patreon,成爲我哋嘅榮譽會員,願榮光早日歸於香港!<br><br>本視頻僅代表嘉賓或受訪者本人觀點。<br><br>聯絡我們 [email protected]
He just said you can't kill people, you can't beat people
He wouldn't say, I have a law, you have the right not to kill people
Would you say that? No need, killing people is a crime
It's the same as not killing people is a crime
So your law is usually just telling you how to commit a crime
It won't tell you how not to commit a crime
Article 9, Chapter 2 tells you how not to commit a crime
When it tells you how not to commit a crime, what does it represent?
It represents your right
When the law tells you that you can do this, it's not a crime
That becomes your right
What kind of right is this?
This is a so-called right of exemption
If I do this, I have the right of exemption, it's not a crime
If I have the right of exemption, you can't sue me
This legal obligation is very important
Many people don't have this awareness
What is the right of exemption? What is the right of exemption?
I call it the Safe Haven Law
This is what the Safe Haven Law means
First of all, as a very simple example
We all need to understand that when it comes to prosecution
As I have just said, everyone understands
When it comes to prosecution, there can only be six months
After six months, you can't prosecute him
After six months, I have really committed a crime
So what? But I have now passed the six-month prosecution period
You can't sue me
Although I have really committed a crime
From your point of view, I have really committed a crime
But you can't sue me
So this is the Safe Haven Law
Even if I have committed a crime in your eyes
But you can't sue me
This is my Safe Haven Law
So if you use time to draw the line
This Safe Haven Law is very clear
Six months before or after
There is a Safe Haven Law or the right of exemption
So Article 9, Article 1 and Article 9, Article 2
Are also the same right of exemption
Article 1 says it is incitement
Article 2, Article 9, Article 2
Although it is incitement
But if the incitement is to criticize the government
Then it is not incitement
Then this is not a right of protection
It is an exemption, right?
It is a safe haven
So this is a right to protect our freedom of speech
No matter how much incitement you say
I don't care how much incitement you say
In short, my intention is to criticize the government
Want it to improve
You can't sue me
No matter how evil I say
Whether it's your family
It's okay to use the roughest words to scold you
Or I use the most civilized, the most elegant, the most civilized method
Write a law like me now
Write a very long legal document
To submit to you
Have the same protection
You can't express my intention because of me
Remember, intention is the most important
The method I express is not important
I can use rough words to express
I can use Shakespeare's writing technique
To write, to persuade you
Have the same legal status
You can't sue me either
That's what it means
Article 9, Article 5 is meaningful
Otherwise, whether it exists
It is completely swallowed up by Article 9
What's the use?
So this is the meaning of a safe haven
Where does the word safe haven come from?
We are very common in the US
There is a law called a safe haven
All over the country, every state has it
It is to protect some mothers
That is, some unmarried babies
Some people are unmarried
If the baby is born
If the baby is not known how many months old
If you want to abandon the baby
If you abandon the baby, don't throw it away
Please put it in a garbage bag
You take the baby to a safe haven
For example, in a hospital
Or police station
Or fire station
Someone will receive and protect the baby
That is a safe haven
So abandoning the baby is illegal
Abandoning the mother is illegal
But if you hand the baby over to a legal place
Hand it over to them for custody
Although you have violated the law, I won't sue you
This is a safe haven
What is the purpose?
It is to protect the baby's rights
Because the baby can't protect its own rights
Then the mother can't keep the baby
Abandoning the baby
This is a harm to the baby's life
So in order to protect the baby's life
We have introduced this law
Even if your mother has violated the law
I won't sue you
Let them be safe
Protect the baby's life
So the purpose of a safe haven
Is to protect what should be protected
So freedom of speech and freedom of the press
Need to be protected
Because if we criticize the government
It is a great crime
It is very high risk
It used to be a crime
So we have introduced Article 9, Article 2
To protect us
We are not afraid
You can criticize
It is not a crime
This is to protect us
This is the essence of a safe haven
Of course, now some safe havens
Have been used
The biggest news now is
Some safe havens
For example, in the latest news
In Canada
There is a very sensational news
They want to build some
Poisonous drugs
Like phenethylamine
Build some safe havens
For them to take drugs there
What kind of drugs are there for vaccination?
It is safe, there is no charge
You can also use it as a free drug
Someone will supervise you
So that they don't need to overdose
And die
What is their intention?
To protect those people
So that they don't overdose
To protect their life
But you use a safe haven method
To protect them
For me, this is actually a cold-blooded act
Because they take this drug
Or use it for vaccination
This drug is not right
When they do this
It encourages them to do this
But that's what it means
It's an illegal thing
You use a safe haven
To protect them
The intention is not that you are not illegal
But to protect other rights
For example, the rights of newborns
Or the safety of the victim's life
Guaranteeing the rights
To build a safe haven
That's what it means
So we have completely neglected Article 9 and Article 2
We have ignored them
And then we have completely distorted them
So when it comes to the Yang Chui case in the Central Procuratorate
The case of Maria
The Central Procuratorate simply
Didn't even look at Article 9 and Article 2
They only judged that the case
Is Article 9, Article 1 and Article 10
Then they decided that
According to these two, you can't be compensated
In the Central Procuratorate
Every case of the Procuratorate
Especially such an important case
You have to look at the whole case
How can you break the law?
This is called breaking the law
Breaking the law
Judged that you can't be compensated
You have to look at whether there is Article 9 and Article 2
To guarantee what others say
Is safe
So whether you are compensated
You have to look at Article 9 and Article 2
If the parties
Quoted Article 9 and Article 2
You can't not be compensated
There is another very important principle in the Security Law
What is the principle?
Is to protect the parties
Even if the parties
Didn't quote the Security Law
Many people quoted it
Many mothers don't know the law
Or are not educated
They don't know
Also have no knowledge of the law
They just quoted it
They may not know
Even if they don't know
They don't need to quote this clause
Your judge has a duty
To quote this clause for them
To protect them
So when your lawyer goes to check
Use the Criminal Procedure Act Article 9
When checking people
At the same time
The principle of ordinary checking is
When you check people
Must make sure
Can't violate the defendant's right
And the Security Law clause
To protect them
Is one of their rights
So they have this responsibility
Not just using Article 1 to sue
They have to look at Article 2
To see if they are protected
The same principle
When you sue them
You must also look at the time of the check
Obviously those four directors
Already passed the time of the check
6 months
You still go to check them
Arrest them
Arrest them and then detain them
That is already a violation of their human rights
And the next day
If no one reports
They will still go to sue
They will still go to court
So this check
Police officers and checkers
When you go to arrest people
You must ask
Are your rights protected?
Even if the person didn't say
You still have to consider
So
立場新聞
黎智英
楊川也好
快必也好
其他人也好
When they arrest them
They don't follow Article 9 and Article 12
所以他們完全是違反了檢控守則
所以他們的檢控
一開始就已經違法違憲
所以根本整件案
就應該終止聆訊
是永久終止聆訊
因為它已經是不公平的法律程序
不用審了
立場新聞審五個月
根本是廢的
多餘的
浪費時間
浪費納稅人的金錢
因為它一開始檢控就已經違反了
為什麼呢
新聞從業員的天職
就是批評政府
就受著第九條第二條款的保障
尤其是立場新聞
他們很多敏感的文章
全都下架了
他們已經全部燒毒了
留下57張文章
有10篇刪了
剩下的那幾篇
他們都覺得應該沒有問題
全都燒毒了
你都去檢控了
然後完全不考慮第二條
第二款的
那就失職了
所以第二款是非常重要的
但是現在那個
資訊文件那裡的立法
他們怎麼說呢
第九條第二款是一條好的條文
那我們應該保存的
我們很遵守這個基本法
已經很遵守人權法的
所以第九條第二款我們保留的
我們有言論自由
我們保障的
但是他們怎麼樣呢
就將第九條第二款那些條文
就是改頭換面了
原本就是說可以向女王
來指出她的錯誤
或者向香港政府
或者指出他們的錯誤或者缺點
是說他們錯誤的
但是現在怎麼說呢
現在的條文就是說
意圖就以上所指的制度或者憲制秩序
提出意見
是提出意見
不是指出缺點或者錯誤
提出意見
那些意見還要怎麼樣呢
那個目的呢
就是要完善
該制度或者憲制秩序
是要完善
我一聽完這個完善
馬上起雞毛疙瘩
什麼叫完善呢
完善就是一個比喻
大家很熟悉什麼叫完善
完善這個立法會選舉
是不是
完善這個特首選舉
全部都是完善的
那你看到那個完善
共產黨所謂的完善的意思
就是將一些好的東西
將它惡化
將它醜化
它就不說是醜化
它就說完善了
更加好的東西
將一些醜的東西
變成更加完善
所以完善是一個偽名詞
是不是完全是騙人的
騙神騙鬼
所以你說到完善
我就起了雞毛疙瘩
現在它就說
我給你們言論自由
但是你言論自由呢
你就只可以向我們提出的意見
是去完善我們
就是我們的立法會選舉制度
還不夠完善
你再提一些更加完善的
讓我們更加保證
只有保皇黨才可以選舉的
百分之百
你提一些意見是對的
我們會保障你的
如果你說立法會選舉是錯的
違反憲法
你這樣的煽動
你又不可以說的
就是這樣
所以這個所謂完善
就是意圖就以上所指的機構
或者機關的事宜
指出問題
而那個目的就是怎樣呢
就是要該事宜提出改善意見
你可以提出這些問題
問題是可以提出的
但是你要去改善它
怎樣改善呢
你有些問題是不能改善的
譬如你現在那個諮詢文件
叫人去提意見
叫人怎樣改善它
這個諮詢文件全部垃圾
怎樣改善呢
唯一可以改善的
就是將它完全撤銷
對不對
因為這個是一個train
你那個火車
走在一個錯誤的軌道
不停地向前直衝
你然後告訴它
你要加速一點
或者減速一點
勇往直前
去完善它
儘早抵達目標
那你最終也是要撞板
唯一可以完善它
就是你馬上實際調轉車頭
退後一點
拜託你
你只可以這樣完善
如果不是完善
這個是指出你的錯誤
說你的錯誤
是要徹底地改善
所以你說完善
這個是將一個
一個原底的好的事
就將它矮化了
所以這兩個詞語
一個就是說
完善和改善
這兩個詞語
所謂改善
等同於我經常聽到
將它所謂改善
所謂的將一些東西優化
因為很多人都喜歡說
將一些東西優化
那這個所謂優化是怎麼樣呢
一些東西本來是不好的
是差的
它不是差
它都挺好的
我現在將它改成更好
更加優化
那就聽起來好聽一點
其實那個就是錯的
我現在改正它
我不說改正
那個是優化它
所以它現在就是完善和改善
用這樣的詞語
來講
你現在有言論自由
新聞自由
但是你只可以說我們對聽的
要完善我們
優化我們
改善我們的
那我們就聽
如果你講一些相反的意見
全部都是善忘
那就等於講了
等於沒有講了
如果你立一條這樣的法律
第九條第二條
立來做什麼呢
因為你如果只是向政府提意見
完善你的制度
你什麼時候都可以說
你有沒有一條法律例在這裡
我都可以說
你不會抓我
那你立一條法律
就等於是一條廢話
就正正如我剛才所說
立法的精神就是
你不會立一條廢的法律
你講了等於沒有講
媽媽是女人
所以這條就將原本
第九條第二條
那個金鐘罩
那個五四金牌
就將它完全的剷除
就將它成為了一條廢話
是沒有用的
講了等於沒有講
所以我那個文件那裡
是指出這樣
是要將它完全是
戳破它這個這樣的偽善
要求他們要將它
保留回原本原底
特別是
為什麼這個第九條第二條
是特別對新聞自由
是做一個很大的傷害
因為這個直接是
保護了新聞自由
在這裡我就再重申
新聞自由在香港
是受到多重的保障的
不是好像現在
你看看
立場沒有了
其他很多的傳媒
都沒有了
甚至是一些的專欄作家
還有專輯漫畫
每個都被它全都掩蓋了
全部就是用這些所謂
涉嫌煽動來威嚇它
就慢慢將它拆除
到一個這樣的程度
我們那個公民社會
就完全沒有了言論自由
沒有了新聞自由
所以就到今天這個死寂的環境
就完全沒有人敢出聲了
講什麼都不對
沒有人敢講的
沒有那麼需要
所以如果要回復這個社會秩序
首先第一件事
我們一定要光復
真的是光復香港
光復香港的言論自由和新聞自由
首先就是從這個
煽動意圖第九條第一本
和第九條第二本
做起
將你的憲法的地位
重新的光復
我們才有了言論自由和新聞自由
那這個新聞自由
在第九條第二本
是完全受到保障的
他們是沒有權去這樣
去指控這個立場新聞的
和《蘋果日報》的
此其一
那這個新聞自由
我上次第一條片都有講到
也都是受到《基本法》和《香港人權法案》
的雙重保障
新聞自由和言論自由
兩者是有一些的overlap的
有一些是相等的
是相同的
因為大家都是講到言論自由
言論自由
言論自由是包含了新聞自由
但是新聞自由除了是各種....
