Freedom of speech, freedom of the press
These are the days of chaos
Do you know that these are the days of chaos?
I'm so agitated when I talk about this
Mr. Lai
Yes, I'm sorry
Don't worry, take your time, I know you
I'm so agitated when I talk about this
Because this is me
When I heard this news, I was so agitated
So the National Security Law is rarely implemented
What is the biggest harm to the citizens of Hong Kong now?
It's exactly this incitement
So everything is an incitement
Whatever you say is a threat, you say it's incitement
Immediately arrest you
Once you are arrested, you sit for two years
Then you go to the court
Then you can't be acquitted
Then you go to the court
The judges will judge you
They will say you are wrong
This kind of incitement has not yet reached the stage of appeal
Even less than the stage of the Sino-provincial court
But the Sino-provincial court
In fact, the incitement has already made a decision
So that is the biggest harm to the citizens of Hong Kong
So today I want to share with you this aspect
Incitement is the Ninth and Tenth Articles of Criminal Procedure
Article 9 actually has two types
The first one and the second one
The first one is incitement
They are now suing
Article 9 is the first incitement
And Article 10 is the crime
The crime is actually nothing
Either publish it
Or publicize it
Whether it's a drama or a comic
It's a way of expression
The method doesn't matter
In short, how you express it
The most important thing is the intention
So they always say Article 9 is the first incitement
It's been like this for a long time
But they will never tell you
Article 9 has two types
Do you know?
Many people don't know
Article 9, in addition to the first type of incitement
There is also a second type
It's called non-incitement
That is to say, what I say is not incitement
You can't sue me
So they treat the second type as nothing
So it's never
There is a reason
I will tell you later
So my first article is about the first type of incitement
What I said last time
My first opinion book
It's about incitement
You can't sue people for incitement
For thinking crime
I have made it very clear last time
If you haven't heard it
Please listen to the previous video
So today I will talk about the second type
The second type of incitement
Non-incitement
What is it?
This is very important
The second type of incitement
Non-incitement
Is our freedom of speech
Freedom of the press
Mutual benefit
So it will never tell you
And then it will be distorted
Why are we in such a situation today?
I will tell you some historical events
Incitement
In fact, Article 23
Everyone knows now
It's one of the seven crimes
Article 23 of the Basic Law
One of the incitement
There is a constitutional duty
To legislate
He didn't say anything wrong
But do you remember
When the National Security Law was legislated
July 1, 2020
When the National Security Law was legislated
It only legislated four laws
Separate countries
Conflicting countries
Foreign power
And terrorist activities
These four laws
In fact, there are three
Article 23 of the Basic Law
Terrorist activities are not
Article 23 does not talk about terrorist activities
So this terrorist activity is shallow
Not under Article 23 of the Basic Law
But he added it
Because terrorist activities also involve a little
In fact, this is a matter of public safety
Related
But from public safety
Affects national security
So he just
Used this nationwide law
To introduce terrorist activities
Into the National Security Law
This is also
Forced to make sense
In fact, he doesn't need this
If he does this
You can't say he can do it
The other three
The incitement of terrorism
And the power of the United Nations
Then you say
Why are there only three
Article 23 of the Basic Law
There are seven
Why are there three
Only those three
And add this
Terrorist activities
Just because
This is a nationwide law
He has these laws all over the country
Then he changed his mind
Through Article 3 of the Basic Law
Introduced into Hong Kong
As a local law
That's why
He has this law
He can introduce
If he doesn't
He can't just add it
So their
Local law
In China
There is no incitement
So he can't just
Add it to Hong Kong
But when he passed the law
Let me tell you
When the Standing Committee of the People's Congress
This
When the National Security Law was passed
They already knew
There was an incitement
So although he can't
Add it
He also knows
This incitement
Is very spicy
But they can't add it
So he just
Passed it to the Hong Kong SAR government
I can't add it
You guys take care of it
So the National Security Law
On July 1st
After the law was passed
Of course, he immediately
Judged
Tang Ying-jet
Immediately
The National Security Law
Announced him
But at the same time
They immediately
Implemented
Incitement
In the situation
Incitement
Then
After that
They used the procedure of the National Security Law
To punish him
So
So ingenious
But at that time
No one knew
No
Because at that time
No one knew
What the incitement was
What the report was
No one mentioned
Because those
Reporters don't know
What it was
So the first one
To be arrested
Who was the incitement
It was the police
Tang Ying-jet
He kept talking about the street station
On July 1st
No one knew
What the incitement was
No one knew
And so
So
Remember, that was a criminal incitement, not a National Security Law incitement
He used criminal incitement
But he used the procedure of the National Security Law to arrest him
He didn't allow him to be bailed out
He used the National Security Law judges to interrogate him
The court quickly resolved the matter
All of them were overthrown by the judges
This is the nature of the National Security Law
But think about it, it wasn't legislated at that time
Criminal charges are still criminal
At that time, it wasn't one of the 23 laws
It wasn't even one of the crimes of the National Security Law
So why did you use the criminal incitement to arrest FIB
and even Yang Chuan?
You could have used the procedure of the National Security Law
to prevent them from being bailed out
and then use the procedure to interrogate them
This is obviously a criminal offence
If I did that, you would have sued me
You would have sued me
This is how they challenged me
They were pressured by the small citizens
Remember, at that time
They were just trying to scare the small citizens
Because they knew that you didn't have the legal means
and resources to challenge me
They actually used FIB, Yang Chuan
and a few other small citizens to sue them
for criminal incitement
It was just to test the waters
Do you remember that time
In July, August
They had already started to arrest Li Zhiying
They had already opened fire on Apple
It was August, August 10
They had already arrested him
They wanted to investigate him
At that time, he hadn't been released
He hadn't been charged yet
They just used the procedure of the National Security Law to investigate him
But do you see
At that time, they still didn't use the Criminal Offences Act to sue him
Until when?
Until the end of 2021
Then they sued Li Zhiying and Apple for criminal incitement
They waited for more than a year in 2020
Why did they have to wait so long?
Because they knew that the Criminal Offences Act
If you want to use it as a National Security Law
It's not a fair and just way
It's not
It has to be passed through the Legislation
They didn't have the Legislation
So they could only scare the small citizens
They didn't dare to scare Li Zhiying at that time
Because if you use the Criminal Offences Act
Then use the National Security Law to arrest him
It will immediately cause a stir in the international community
Then people will immediately say
Hey, this is just a criminal offence
Why can you use the National Security Law?
Then they will have a big challenge
So they didn't dare to do it
They just wanted to scare the small citizens
So what was the purpose?
As a so-called test of water temperature
They tested the water temperature to see how you would react
Even if you are sued
If you are sued, you will be punished
At most, they will say
Yes, we made a mistake, maybe it's okay
Then the backlash will not be so big
So they did it on the spur of the moment
They didn't dare to do it
So this is a big conspiracy
They just wanted to test the water temperature
So they waited for Yang Chuan to appeal
Fortunately, Yang Chuan really appealed
He appealed
One of them was very brave
He appealed to the Central Court
Yang Chuan was one of the five defendants
He had the resources to appeal
But it's a pity
Because at that time, everyone didn't know
What kind of criminal offence it was
Article 9, Article 1, Article 2
What is it? What is the intention of inciting?
It hasn't been used for decades
The judges and lawyers don't know what's going on
They only know
You are inciting, why are you using the National Security Law?
He just asked such a question
He went to ask the judges
The judges said, yes, it's okay
Article 23 said so
He said, it's not okay
But they didn't know
What kind of legal process
And what kind of reasoning to defend
So there was no bulletproof
So you went to the Central Court
He appealed
He said, do you have the right to detain me like this?
You won't give me bail
It's such a simple question
Is it bail?
Using the National Security Law, you won't give me bail?
To the client
Of course, there's no reason
Your judge has to be on equal footing with me
But when I went to the Central Court
The three judges in the Central Court
Rejected him
They said, to maintain a fair trial
They rejected their appeal
They said, this incitement
Article 9, Article 1, and Article 10
Are equivalent to Article 23 of the Basic Law
The so-called city incitement
This is a big problem
When it comes to that
Now it's not the low-level judges who say so
But the three judges in the Central Court
It became an ultimate case
That was on 14th October, 1921
This is the day when the Hong Kong people took action
Because from that day on
Hong Kong's freedom of speech and freedom of the press
Were in full swing
From that day on
But at that time, everyone was in a daze
There was a newspaper reporting
The Yangtze River Dam was closed
It couldn't be repaired
It was that simple
It was written so lightly
What was the Yangtze River Dam?
Everyone didn't know at that time
It was just a simple thing
It was just reported
But we didn't know
The consequences were so serious
To what extent was it serious?
Let's take a look at the recent court documents
When the Lai Chi-ying case was tried in December
The first appeal they made
Was the Statute of Limitations
Because the Statute of Limitations
Only has a six-month trial period
Let's go back to the case
After the Yangtze River Dam case was tried
No one knew
But after two weeks
There was immediate news
It turned out that the Lai Ching-shi
Was taking advantage of the Yangtze River Dam case
He didn't mention the Yangtze River Dam case
He was taking advantage of the Ninth Article of the Criminal Procedure Act
Article 1, Article 10
To put pressure on Lai Chi-ying and Apple
That was supposed to be on 28 December
To put pressure on him
Because he had to go to court that day
To go to court
That day was to put pressure on him
He accepted it
And put pressure on him
Then it became news
On 28 December
What happened on the next day?
Do you remember?
December 29, 2021
That was the day that shocked the whole of Hong Kong
And the whole world
The National Security Police
Came to the scene to open a case
To search for news
Using the Criminal Procedure Act
They arrested four former directors
And two editors
And then immediately frozen their assets
The news immediately stopped
It was a very shocking thing
On 29 December
It was the day when Hong Kong's freedom of speech
After the news
It was a day of shock
Do you know
It was a day of shock
I am very emotional when I talk about this
Mr Lai
Yes
I'm sorry
It's okay, take your time
I know
When I suddenly heard this news
I immediately
Until that day
I was the same as everyone else
I was just listening to Hong Kong
I was very dissatisfied with the news
I was very agitated
It was as if I was being bullied
I didn't know anything after hearing it
I didn't know what had happened
Because everyone didn't know
What was going on in the news
No one would know
But from that day on
I heard
Why was there a criminal incitement
I had never heard of it
So when I heard and saw it
I immediately went to see
The Criminal Procedure Act
I didn't look at it
The first thing I noticed
The Criminal Procedure Act
Not only the 9th and 10th
There is also the 11th
The 11th, sorry
The 9th, the 2nd, the 10th
And the 11th
What does the 11th say?
The 11th is about
The monitoring of criminal incitement
There is a monitoring time
6 months
That time
There is a monitoring time of 6 months
That time I saw it
I was shocked
I immediately thought of
The news on the scene
On 29th December, you went to sue him
I immediately thought of
The news on the scene
After the blockade of Apple
Less than two weeks
Immediately
A group of directors
Resigned immediately
And he put a lot of things on the shelf
That time in June
I thought, June or December
It's about 6 months
I immediately looked at the other party's date
When I saw it, it was just 6 months
More than a few days, like 4 days
It passed
Wow, when I saw it
Hey, after the monitoring time
You can still arrest people like this
Arrest those four directors
So when I saw it, I immediately told my friends
I told everyone
Hey, they passed the monitoring time
Why no one knew
At that time, I realized that
The lawyer and the police
Arrested people like this
It's a mess
They didn't even look at the law
Just arrested people like this
So I told everyone
After I told everyone
I told my friends
I said, you have to make these things public
Some friends took me to Liandeng
I posted a post on Liandeng
I said everything
It caused a lot of discussion on Liandeng
After the discussion
There was a newspaper
It picked up
RFA, Radio Free Asia
The Chinese Ministry reported this news
And interviewed Tom Kawan
So the HK police immediately received the news
The next day after the arrest
The four directors were released immediately
This is what happened
So everyone didn't know at that time
Unknowingly
They were released after being arrested
There was no monitoring
The police didn't explain
Why did they release them?
They didn't explain, they didn't explain at all
To this day
Lawyers have not been prosecuted
Of course, they have prosecuted other cases
But they didn't use the Criminal Procedure Act
Article 9, Article 1 to sue them
To this day, they haven't
The court has already finished the trial
Why?
Because they have passed the time of monitoring
The two editors of the court have not been prosecuted
Because they haven't been late
They have always been there
So they haven't
So they have set up a trap
So that day, I began to realise
Wow, HK's law and order system
Is such a mess
It's not just that
The question I asked at that time was
Apple has already passed the time
On 28th October
They went to court to sue Li Zhiying
It has already passed, right?
Li Zhiying, on 24th December
On 24th June, he had already been suspended
On 24th June, you went to court to sue him on 27th
It has already passed 6 months
But why is it still okay?
At that time, we didn't know why
So I just put up a question mark
Until recently, at the beginning of December
When the trial started
The truth began to come out
The first thing they did was to challenge his trial
Did it pass 6 months?
They said it had just passed
Because on 27th October
It had just passed 4 days, 3 or 4 days
But now, Justice Lai said
We haven't passed
Because on 13th December
Remember, 14th December
It was the day when the Central Procuratorate of Hong Kong announced their ruling
That day, I already told everyone
That day was a shameful day for Hong Kong people
Because the Central Procuratorate of Hong Kong
Sentenced the freedom of the press and freedom of the press to death
On 14th, but on 13th
On 13th October
Justice Lai had already prepared all the documents
And submitted them to the Court of Arbitration
To address Justice Lai's criminal offences
To address his crime
On 13th, he had already submitted
Because on 13th, the Central Procuratorate of Hong Kong announced
That he would summon Justice Lai the day before
So that they could prepare the press release and so on
So he had received the letter the day before
Once he received the letter, he immediately made the documents
To address Justice Lai
And sent them to the Court of Arbitration
At the same time, he handed the documents over to Justice Lai's representative
Now, he said
I am now implementing the criminal offences
I am not waiting until 27th to go to court
I have already started the procedure on 13th
So starting from 13th
I have not passed the six-month trial
We don't have it, he is arguing like this
But this time we don't have it
If you count from 12th to 13th
He has to wait until 24th of June, that is, until 24th of October
Then it will be six months
So he has just started the procedure on the 10th
Before the deadline
He said that he has not passed the deadline
He is arguing like this
When he is arguing like this
The three judges, the three judges of Justice Lai's case
Accepted his lawsuit
He said that they wrote a letter
He only said that it was a letter
He wrote a letter to the Court of Arbitration
Saying that we are ready to add charges
It's just a preparation
Not that we have already started the process of adding charges
Why can he only say that he is ready to add charges?
Because it's not up to him
If you want to add charges, how do you add charges in the end?
The decision-making power lies with the judge
If the judge says that your additional charges are feasible
You have to be approved
But now the three judges said no
He said that he has already started the legal process
It's okay
In fact, this is not at all legal
But it's a pity
We, the legal world, don't know how to refute him
I have already published a press release
I shouted out loud
He said that this is wrong
He didn't hear me
I take this opportunity to explain to you
Why is this wrong?
Because on the 13th, it was only a letter
Yes, you said to the Court of Arbitration
I am ready to add charges
In fact, on that day, the 13th
He didn't just say that he was ready to add charges
It was as simple as that
On that day, it was obvious
He also sent a letter to the Court of Arbitration
Saying that he was ready to monitor the news
Right?
He would definitely do so
He would go through it painstakingly
But on that day, he only sent a letter to Lai Chi-ying's lawyer
Would he send a letter to the news?
He wouldn't
Because at that time, you hadn't officially executed the case
You didn't have the court's order to search him
You didn't have the court's order
To freeze the assets of立場新聞
Or to arrest them
If you had told立場新聞 in advance
That we were ready to monitor you
Then you would have been shot
Right?
So they didn't do that
Because if you wanted to get the court's order
The court's judge must approve it
Why did the court judge have to approve it?
Because he wanted to see if the request of the chief
Was it legal or not
He had to conduct such an investigation
Did he do it on purpose to frame people?
Did he have sufficient evidence
To make the request of the chief?
That's the duty of the court judge
It's not that the lawyer
Wanted to have the chief to freeze him
Then it would have been settled
So on that day
He only issued an informal case
To Lai Chi-ying's lawyer
He didn't issue it to立場新闻
He couldn't do that
This is illegal
Why could he issue it to Lai Chi-ying?
Because Lai Chi-ying was already in custody
You had arrested him
You didn't need to use a warrant
To arrest him
He was already arrested
So he was only notified
But if you notify him
It's an unofficial document
Officially, you need a warrant to notify him
So your notification is not legal
But he now regards it as an unofficial notification
It's still legal
So why did he have to wait until the 29th
To check on Lai Chi-ying and Lai Lai?
Because he had to wait
Until the 28th, when Lai Chi-ying went to court
The judge asked Lai Chi-ying's lawyer
The lawyer said that the lawyer is now
Proceeding with your incitement
Do you accept it?
Why did the judge ask him that?
These are legal documents
I've looked at them
Why did the judge ask him that?
In fact, the judge should make his own decision
It's up to him to decide
But the judge didn't dare to decide
Why?
He himself didn't know what the incitement was
He hadn't tried it
In the past 50 years, no one had tried it
None of the judges knew what the incitement was
If it's up to him to decide
He has a huge responsibility
Do you understand?
So even the judge didn't dare to make his own decision
He now has a judge in charge
I can't make my own decision
Lai Chi-ying's lawyer
Do you accept it?
When he asked him
The lawyer was also at a loss
Because he hadn't seen what the incitement was
When he saw Article 9
It turns out that Article 9 is like this
When it comes to these things
There is an intention to violate the law
It's a national security issue
So he admitted and accepted it at the time
Okay, once you accept it
I accept your accusation
That's it, clap your hands
The lawyer will check you
You, on behalf of the lawyer, accept it
Then it's done, deal
Once the deal is done
The inspection will be carried out officially
This is how the inspection will be carried out
It's not like on 13 December
The lawyer wrote an unofficial document
To the inspector and Lai Chi-ying's lawyer
Then the investigation has already started
Because if your document is in violation of the law
It has no legal basis
So in fact, to be honest
The criminal inspection of the Lai Chi-ying case
Has already passed six months
But the three high-ranking judges now
Just say no
Because they have based it on a wrong person
To make such a calculation
So I will explain to everyone
Why do you have to understand the details of this case?
If you don't understand, you will be misled
Even if you are misled, you won't know
Even the judges themselves don't know
If you are misled, they don't know
It's hard to blame them
Because they haven't been to these cases
They only know how to do one thing
To see what cases there are in the Common Law
When Lai Chi-ying's lawyer was in October
He cited some cases in the UK
The judges cited cases in the UK
The cases in the UK are not comparable to those in Hong Kong
If you cite a case, it's completely useless
You have to look at what the law says
But in Hong Kong's legal system
No one looks at the law
Because of the training of the law in the Common Law
The training of all lawyers and judges
They only look at cases
This is a very important problem in the Common Law
They use cases to decide cases
If you don't have such cases, they don't know how to decide
Some judges only look at the law
They have no idea
So they always make mistakes
So now I take this opportunity to tell everyone
Why this is a case of Lai Chi-ying
The Criminal Procedure Act
It's not just like this, it's also a criminal case
In fact, there is another reason for Lai Chi-ying's case
It's a criminal case, but no one mentioned it
I also told you in the press release
The Criminal Procedure Act
The term of the criminal prosecution is six months, right?
Apple was suspended in June 2021
By December, it has already been six months
It's not just like this
Suspension is in June
But do you remember that Lai Chi-ying's case
Has been suspended since December 2020
She is in jail
Lai Chi-ying was suspended from December 2020
Until June 2021
She has been suspended for more than half a year
Since the first day of her suspension
She has lost her freedom of life
When she lost her freedom of life
How could she continue to violate the National Security Law?
How could she continue to be in jail?
To continue to conspire
To intend to hate the HK government
She is the boss, that's right
But you can't use her boss's identity
To say that you have an intention
I have already lost my freedom of life
She has no way to instruct Apple's editors
That you have to issue this article today
She has no way to do that
So from December 2020 to November 2021
She has already spent more than a year
It's impossible for her to find out
If you use the name of the National Security Law
To suspend her, it means
To prevent her from continuing to violate the National Security Law
Right?
Then why don't you allow her to be bailed out?
If you bail her out
You can't continue to violate the National Security Law
If you bail her out
You can still continue to violate the National Security Law
To conspire
Now she has said a very funny thing
Your editors
Every week
Go to visit her for two hours
And say a lot of things
To conspire
It's okay to say that
The prosecutors and prosecutors
When you bail her out
To visit the prison
Those two things are under your supervision
If at that time
You talk to them in private
Say something to incite them
Hey, the people in your investigation department are dead
You have to put them all in jail
If you let her get away with it
Are you all conspiring?
Basically, what they said
When I listened to their interrogation
What they said
It's just a nonsense
So these must be returned
I don't know how
I don't know if the National Security Lawyer
Will continue to violate the National Security Law in the future
I will take this opportunity to explain to the people of Hong Kong
How unethical it is
Basically
So this is a love story
Back to
This
Central Court case
So until that day
From the 29th, I immediately woke up
That was my awakening period
I immediately did one thing
First
I got this
Then
The more I looked at it, the more it was wrong
Continue to look at that
The 9th case of incitement
Look
In addition to the first one
There is another one
The first one is incitement
The second one is non-incitement
Why is no one talking about the second one?
Non-incitement
So at that time
I immediately wrote a few articles
The first article
I went to the column of Ming Po
I don't know what the comment was
On the column
I published the first article
Talking about the inspection time
After talking, I told the editor
I still have a lot to say
Because the incitement is affecting the heart
Freedom of speech and freedom of expression
I want to write two more articles
He is a good person, he approved me
Continue to write two articles
I continue to write those two articles
For the second article
The second one
Non-incitement
Explain to Hong Kong citizens
What is non-incitement
And why
This court
Is completely neglected
Non-incitement
This kind of thing
I published more than 3,000 articles
Some people have seen it
But everyone should not take it lightly
Until today
The inspection of all incitement charges
Still only use
Article 9, the first one
And the first one
Until today
No case
The defense lawyer
Will use Article 9
The second one
As an excuse to defend
I don't know how to defend
I have already made it very clear in the two articles
How to defend
No one quoted
So
This time I
Will use the second one
The new opinion book
To submit to the Security Bureau
To clarify
My arguments
More clearly
Why the court
Decision
The Yangchun case
Decision
Is completely neglected
Speaking of this
Is there any question?
Then I will enter
The court's decision
How to deal with it