Pappa al Pomodoro: The BEST Italian Tomato Soup! (Tomato and Bread Soup Recipe)

Healthy food
929 followers
Have you ever heard of papa al pomodoro
or Italian tomato bread soup?
It is rich, delicious,
and takes only a few pantry ingredients.
This is considered a Tuscan peasant dish.
And what I love about this soup is that
it actually is meant to use day-old bread,
stale bread, and tomato.
So we're gonna start with our day-old bread.
And if yours, like mine here, is not hard enough,
what you wanna do is start by toasting it.
So I actually cut it up into pieces here,
or you can tear it up, it doesn't really matter.
So we're gonna go in with the bread pieces about,
you know, you can cut them into one-inch cubes,
or you can tear them up.
And you just wanna make sure that it is truly hard and dry
because you don't want it to get too, too mushy
in your soup.
A little bit of olive oil never hurt anybody
unless your bread is already nice and crusty and hard.
Going in under the broiler very quick.
Honestly, it's never a bad idea to get some more color
and a little flavor from the olive oil on your bread.
Super few ingredients involved in this recipe,
but it will surprise your taste buds
in the best way possible.
A drizzle of some good Italian extra virgin olive oil.
I'm using our Nacellata Italian extra virgin olive oil
from TheMediterraneanDish.com, right here.
And it's good stuff and you want it for the soup.
I want medium heat.
I don't want the oil too hot.
And I'm going to kind of cook up my onions and my garlic
with a little bit of red pepper flakes.
So we're gonna start with the red pepper flakes right here.
I wanna see the peppers kind of pop.
Can the peppers pop?
Sort of.
Yes.
Starting to see some activity with my peppers here.
I don't want my oil too hot
because I don't want a ton of color on my garlic.
So we have some sliced garlic right here.
Then we have some onion, very finely chopped.
And we're gonna cook them down.
Mediumish heat for about 10 to 15 minutes at this point.
So just gentle heat.
Kind of tossing them around.
And all you need is for them to kind of just open up
and have just a tad bit of color,
like a golden, light golden brown.
I first learned about this soup from my girl, Christina,
who works for us here at The Mediterranean Dish.
She did a study abroad in Siena
and that's where she had this soup.
And she said it was her absolute favorite thing.
So when she was describing it to me, I'm like,
we have got to try this.
And I made it before and I can't wait to make it again.
Think the onion is looking good and the garlic.
So next comes our tomatoes.
We're using one 28 ounce can of good San Marzano tomatoes.
So they're whole peeled tomatoes
and you're gonna wanna crush them into the soup by hand.
Yes, Nonna style.
Turn my heat down some more.
You're gonna grab the tomatoes and you're gonna crush them.
I said, boop, I said Nonna style, right?
So just like, but watch yourself.
I washed my hand, don't worry.
I'm making a bit of a mess, but it's quite fun actually.
You're basically just breaking up the tomatoes by hand.
If that's not your jam, it's absolutely fine.
Crush them some other way.
San Marzano tomatoes are a little bit sweeter
than other tomatoes, which is why we like using them
in this recipe.
And now what we have left in the can is basically juice.
So we're going in.
Italian Nonna's are legendary.
They know how to come up with recipes
that use what you have on hand,
that are absolutely delicious
and made from simple ingredients.
I mean, come on, a can of tomatoes, some olive oil,
just a few flavor makers and they all bread.
Can't get any better than this.
Whenever I open a can and like,
you can't get all the sauce out,
just add a little bit of water.
You don't wanna waste it.
Go ahead and add that too, see?
A few sprigs of fresh basil, very essential for this recipe.
And yes, it goes in right now
and you can also garnish with it at the end.
Flavor in every bite.
Give it a stir and then let's bring it to a simmer
and then we're gonna add some broth.
Now we have about, oh, two and a half, three cups of broth.
Vegetable broth is fine.
Bring this party to a bubble
and we're adding in our bread as well.
We're going to go in with the bread.
Yes, you are pretty much going to dunk this bread
in the soup.
It's all going to cook together.
The bread will give it more of a stewy, thicker texture.
I'm gonna leave a little bit of the bread
to kind of garnish with.
I mean, like I said, when I made it the first time,
I was in awe of how delicious and comforting
with just such simple ingredients.
So we're lowering the heat here and we're just stirring
and we're gonna let this entire thing simmer,
gentle heat for a good 20 minutes or so.
The bread's gonna soak up a lot of the juices
so you're gonna wanna keep an eye
and add a little bit of broth as needed.
Oh my goodness, this is turning out beautifully.
The most important thing about this recipe is the texture.
The bread has now soaked up a lot of the liquid
and it should be super soft.
It should almost dissolve in such a way
that it turns the soup into a stewy
or more porridge-like situation.
You're gonna keep adding a little bit of liquid as needed
just because you still want some liquid in it.
You don't want to just be eating bread,
keeping a nice, gentle bubble.
Okay, this is the consistency I'm looking for.
It's pretty stewy looking.
If you want it to be a little more soupy,
you can add a little bit more broth to it,
but I love it this way,
so we're gonna go ahead and finish it up.
Six ingredients you have in your pantry.
You can make this delicious tomato and bread soup.
Amazing.
This is the moment of truth.
This is my girl, Christina, I told you about.
Hi, people.
She's the one who introduced me to this amazing recipe
because you had it.
In Siena in 2019, I was studying abroad in Italy
and it was my favorite thing I had there.
You did tell me that and I was like, what?
Like a soup wasn't made of, you know,
but let's see if I did it.
Yeah, you give it a try.
I hope it's good.
It's really good.
Is it?
Yeah.
Is it how you remember it though?
It is.
You nailed it.
Oh my gosh, it's so exciting.
It's delicious.
So good.
Oh, I missed.
Let's try again.
Oh, we did it.
Did you guys know this is not the only Italian bread soup
that exists that is absolutely delicious?
We also have one more called ribollita
right here on the channel.
You must check that out.
It is absolutely gorgeous.
Find the recipe for pappa al pomodoro
or Italian tomato bread soup
over on themediterraneandish.com.
I will see you later.
Ciao.
So good.
