Stock Up, Stock Down for the Marlins 1 Week into the Spring | Gone Fishin'

Five Reasons Sports Network
15 followers
In this Episode, Eric Wiedeke (@EricWiedeke on Twitter/X) discusses the start of the spring for the Marlins, early returns, who has impressed, and who hasn't thus far #Marlins #MLB #Miami #Sports #Baseball
hello and welcome to another episode of
gone fishing on the five reason Sports
YouTube channel my name is Eric weeda
you can follow me on Twitter SLX Eric
weeda uh and do be sure to like comment
and subscribe on the video helps grow
what we do at the channel over here at
five reasons um the number one stop for
South Florida Sports whether it's the
heat the Panthers the Marlins the
Dolphins in Miami uh the University of
Miami any and everything South Florida
Sports they got it with the best
coverage at five reason Sports so do be
sure to like comment subscribe and hit
the notification Bell for uploads on all
the sports so I want to get right into
it right away I'm doing stock up stock
down on Marlin spring training week one
we are four games in and I am ready to
overreact to four spring training games
because that's what we do here and
that's what the fans want to see uh so
getting right into it stock up is Troy
Johnston Troy Johnston the Marlin 2023
minor league player of the year uh four
for seven through the spring thus far
you can make the argument that he should
be five for seven in that first
preseason or in the first uh spring game
hit a liner off the pitcher's glove that
got deflected in the infield made a nice
play on him got him for the out he's
also walked and scored a run and played
some pretty solid defense at first
baseman making one highlight play and
Diving
stop uh by Johnston there so he's done
his part to make the roster a little bit
more on the outside looking in to this
point because of the fact that he came
into the roster as a guy not on the 40
Man uh but Johnston will be a guy to
continue to monitor obviously only four
games in um but if he does keep up keep
this pace up he will be making it a very
tough decision for Peter Bendix and
Company so the second guy on this list
here is the guy that I think a lot of
fans were not very familiar with uh
prior to this prior to this spring um he
was a guy that quite honestly was not
even on uh my radar as a middle infield
possibility just because of Nick Gordon
and John birdie and Xavier Edwards and
Vidal bruhan and Tim Anderson now um but
he's put himself firmly in that mix and
that is Tristan gray Tristan gray two
for seven so far in the spring two
monster home runs in a walk to this
point great spent spending the last two
years years in the miners with the Rays
uh 30 home run Seasons each year in the
miners with the Rays uh the last two
seasons huge left-handed power bat and
he's showing that off here uh this is a
guy that you know could potentially make
the
roster again more of a long shot kind of
along the lines of a guy like
Johnston but you look at a left-handed
power bat and how that plays in Lone
Depot and then you look at a guy that
plays shortstop he's a bit of a bigger
guy so you do wonder about his ability
to maybe play some other spots on the
infield potentially third
base and then you know I I don't think
anybody has an issue with the
left-handed power bat dhing in Lone
Depot considering that left-handed power
tends to play there with the more
favorable porch over in
right uh so gray will continue to be a
name to monitor here for the Marlins and
then the third guy that I want to give a
shout out to is going to be AJ Puck AJ
puck in his first start against the Mets
two winnings no hits no runs three
strikeouts and a walk uh AJ Puck was a
guy that you know looking coming into
the season when I heard that he was
going to be stretched out to a starter I
wasn't exactly sure uh how seriously to
take that um especially when you
consider the Marlin's rotation situation
and kind of the guys that are competing
for those last spots between Cabrera Max
Meyer and Trevor Rogers I thought you
know AJ Puck might be more of an
afterthought uh among those guys but he
looked really solid against the Mets
here obviously just one spring start to
this point so it is to be taken with a
grain of salt um but AJ Puck if he does
stack up starts like this all throughout
the spring you have to you have to
really wonder how much pressure is going
to be put on on guys like Edward Caba
who's pitching today against the Astros
uh Trevor Rogers and Max Meyer uh to
potentially make that rotation so AJ
Puck while I wouldn't put him on watch
yet to be in the starting rotation uh I
do think if he puts together two or
three more starts like this he firmly he
firmly implants himself in that
conversation and so now it's time for a
little bit of negativity here it's going
to be the stock
down uh the first guy here I don't like
to pile on um especially with a guy
that's taken so much flak in his first
two years here uh arguably one of the
less liked Marlins among the fan base
when you consider his production or lack
thereof and his contract and that's
obviously a Garcia uh over six so far in
the spring here three
strikeouts uh you know again this is
this is we're getting to that point now
where the Marlins are three year this is
this is year three of that four-year
deal and so the the implications of
potentially eating the money um are
starting to the consequences are
starting to become a little bit less and
less not to say that I think that the
Marlins are going to cut him at this
point I still would lean towards him
being on the 26-man roster but I do
think that if he continues to struggle
we're at the point with Avi where it
becomes a real possibility for this for
this ball Club um like I said there's
still an opportunity for him to uh turn
things around like I said only six hat
bats to this point three strikes Stouts
can he turn it around and be great in
the spring and and cement himself on the
roster
absolutely um but the clock is ticking
on Garcia at this point uh one for his
playing time and two for his spot on the
roster although I think his playing time
is in a lot more immediate danger uh to
start the season the second guy that has
struggled to this point is Trey Mancini
manini was brought in as a minor league
free agent with a spring
invite and manine is a guy that if you
look at the back of the baseball card it
tells you that he has been successful
and he can be successful in this league
um but the Trey Mancini comeback tour so
far has not been fantastic 0 for six
with four punch outs for the
veteran uh first baseman Mancini has not
looked great and when you compare that
to a guy like a
Johnston and when you pair that with the
fact that he's a non-roster invt which
means that cutting him has almost zero
ramifications to the team uh he's a guy
that might want that might feel a little
bit more pressure to kind of turn it up
and really
um really get that production going for
for Trey so he's a guy that I I kind of
have circled right now that the clock is
is maybe running a little bit quicker
for him just because there's just not as
much uh consequences for the Marlins if
they do decide to move on from Trey
manini uh but like I said the back of
the baseball card has told you he has
been and can be a productive player in
this league still only 31 years old so
it's not like uh you know this guy is 36
37 on the back on his last legs uh but
manini 0 for six4 strikeouts he has
struggled mightily thus far at the dish
and then the last guy was a guy that
came in with a little bit of quiet hype
uh Josh Simpson the left-handed reliever
uh spent time with the Marlins last
season in the miners um this was a guy
that had a massive strikeout rate some
really funky stuff a great curveball uh
but it just has not translated to this
point here in Spring one and twoth
thirds Innings pitch three hits four
earned runs he's hit two batters and
walked three so a really really tough
tough start to spring for Josh Simpson
and when you consider how strong that
the Marlins Bullpen is projected to be
this year and how deep it's project to
be with guys like uh Tanner Scott Andrew
nardy Anthony Bender uh George Sorano uh
you know and and some of those and some
of that cast of characters JT
shagwa there's you know he's a guy that
that
he's it's it's it's becoming time to go
for him because not time to go as in
time to leave but it's time for him to
pick it up a little bit because of the
fact that he is facing an uphill battle
considering that he wants a spot in
probably one of the positions where the
Marlins have the most depth on the team
uh so Josh will have some work to do to
dig himself out of that hole um and some
news and notes while I was away Jesus
Lardo was named the opening day starter
uh this week by Skip schacher I just
want to extend a hearty congratulations
to Jesus lazardo obviously the hometown
kid getting to pitch opening day for his
childhood team uh story book uh really
happy for him excited to see it and he
absolutely deserves the opportunity uh
to to go out there on opening day with
the ball for for this ball Club he's
been fantastic in his time here so far
um and hopefully there's more opening
days with Jesus cardo Yet to
Come uh and then lastly the Marlins did
signed Tim Anderson on a one-year $5
million contract uh Tim Anderson slots
in as the everyday Short Stop he did
struggle last year in 2023 but you go
back to 2019 through 2022 and Anderson
was a hit machine hitting over 300 in
each of those four seasons and winning a
Silver Slugger along the way Anderson is
a guy that brings some veteran presence
to the clubhouse he's been there done
that knows what it takes to be
successful in this league um you know
and hopefully getting out of a situation
like Chicago where by all accounts the
clubhouse culture last year was just
absolutely toxic I mean we saw a guy and
Jake Berger really really turn his
performance up when he came from Chicago
to Miami um and Berger signed off on Tim
Anderson as well so it'll be interesting
to see um you know what that looks like
with with Tim Anderson in the infield
and in the mix and hopefully on the next
edition of this stock up and stock down
uh I have Tim Anderson uh I have some
Tim Anderson stats to go off of and and
potentially talk about uh with you guys
so I will see you next week with another
round of stock up and stock down on the
Miami Marlins to this point as always my
name has been Eric WEA like I said you
can follow me on X Twitter Eric weeda
and do not and do not forget to like
comment and subscribe on this video to
help grow the channel thank you guys for
watching and I will see you next time on
gone fishing
thanks
