Have you ever wondered how evolution operates at a cellular level? Dr. Biology has a conversation with evolutionary biologist William Ratcliff in an episode that investigates the process of how single-cell mutations can make the leap to coordinated groups of cells and ultimately to complex multicellular organisms. And we are learning all of this from a simple selection experiment involving yeast. Listen in and learn more about this long-running experiment that is giving us an idea of how single cells made the leap to multicell organisms.
this is askabiologist a program about
the living world and I'm Dr biology for
our show today we're going to do some
time traveling or at least use our minds
to travel back not thousands not
Millions but billions of years back to
when life was just beginning on Earth
and there were some single cell forms of
life but nothing more it's an
interesting time and one that scientists
are exploring in their own Laboratories
today with a series of experiments where
they're learning how single cells evolve
over time and see how cells might have
made their big leap from a single cell
to a multi-cell organism one of those
scientists is William Radcliffe an
evolutionary biologist and also an
astrobiologist he's an associate
professor at Georgia Institute of
Technology he's here at ASU giving a
talk titled how to make multicellular
life from scratch a 5,000 generation and
Counting directed Evolution experiment
today we're getting a snapshot of Will's
work as well as an idea of what Earth
might have been like a few billion years
ago welcome will and thank you for
taking time to sit down and talk about
this simple task of evolving from a
single cell to a multi-cell organism and
then complex forms of life like we see
today thank you Dr biology it's a
pleasure to be here and I'll just say
that any step that appears to be complex
when you break it down into enough small
steps each single one can be quite
simple but very important ones I guess
that's right okay let's do what we
talked about let's go back a few billion
years and describe what Earth was like
and I'm going to give you a little jump
start sure we're going to already have
single cell organisms so going back to
Earth a couple billion years ago like
walking into an alien planet the
evolution of multicellular life so we're
talking organisms that are big enough
that you can see them with a naked eye
and have complex feur features that
single cells don't have has
fundamentally transformed life on our
planet let me give you an example so
close your eyes and think of a pristine
natural Forest right there's light
filtering through the trees it's dancing
on your face you hear buzzing of insects
maybe they tripping of birds all right
get rid of the trees those are
multicellular
organisms you hear a rain of insects as
they fall
down a flapping of birds maybe a thud as
a monkey falls into the forest floor
sorry monkey those are all multicellular
animals get rid of those what's left
probably a bunch of mushrooms likely
toxic don't eat those let's get rid of
them and we also have to get rid of the
lyan what are we left with on Earth not
much in the oceans you have some
seaweeds we can get rid of those but my
point is if you get rid of multicellular
organisms Life as we know it changes
both because the organisms themselves
are much more complex than their single
sou ancestors and we don't have that
available to us anymore but also because
multicellular life has created its own
ecosystems in fact they're so familiar
to us that we call them by the name of
the dominant multicellular organism a
forest a grassland a coral reef those
are the names of the multicellular
organism that has created that Niche and
in the absence of multicellularity we
don't have those environments either
let's talk a little bit about this
single cell right there are some parts
that's right all right so let's talk
about some of the parts that we already
have right because that was a lot of
work just as you said maybe a lot of
little steps that were simple but what a
billion and a half years to go from the
origin of Earth to the origin of life
that's a time that we have trouble
pinning down and part of that is that we
just don't have very good evidence we
don't have rocks that go back past three
and a half billion years and so what we
see is a sort of sudden emergence of
microfossils that look like cells and we
can actually tell that they have carbon
in it that came through life Pathways
because carbon that came from the air
and went into cells gets treated a
little bit differently than carbon
that's just messed around with by normal
non-living chemistry so we're pretty
sure that by three and a half billion
years ago we already had cells that
pretty much are the same as modern
bacteria okay I know this is one of
those things that also because we don't
really have any fossil evidence but what
were the steps do you think to making
that first single cell yeah in fact
these are some of the biggest steps in
biology you need some way of encoding
information and having the sort of
instruction manual for a cell so that's
a genome you may have heard that word
there's DNA and that's the chemical
which stores information and you need
some way of taking that information and
reading it out and using it and so
there's this thing that happens where
you'd make a copy of a gene and that
copy then gets turned into a protein and
the protein is sort of like the
functional building block made of sticky
Legos that goes around inside the cell
and makes things happen and so you need
some way of having DNA copies of it that
can go off and and do stuff and that's
not a trivial thing to sort of put
together it turns out that all living
things from bacteria to plants to humans
we all actually share the same exact
genetic code which in some ways is like
a language it's a sort of arbitrary way
of taking chemical information like
letters and turning them into words that
combine
together into sentences make biological
sense and can put together functional
building block proteins that can go and
do specific tasks inside the cell and
the fact that all living things share
the exact same with just a few tiny
modifications genetic code is one of
these just gold standard pieces of
evidence that all life on Earth shares a
common ancestor it all came from the
same Source now when you're talking
about these letters and genes we're
talking about DNA or deoxy ribonucleic
acid and the nucleotides that it's made
from just so everybody knows there's
adenine a cytosine C guanine G and
damine T so we have our instructions but
how do cells get work done they must
also need some energy yeah life fits
into the niches where there are
energetic gradients and dissipates that
energy itself life is a cataly
to dissipate energy and by doing the
dissipation of the energy it is able to
sort of do biological work let me give
you an example here so we have a planet
which has a liquid water surface we have
oceans and we have a sun and that sun is
actually a gigantic battery it's
throwing all these photons at the planet
now let's say that we don't have
photosynthetic life yet we don't have
life that that can actually use that
life for energy directly we still have
water molecules and those water
molecules can be blasted apart by
ultraviolet radiation if you know water
molecules H2O right you knock it apart
into H2 and O and the hydrogen the H2
it's so small it's the smallest element
in the periodic table and it's very
light and it can actually Escape out
into space and as a result you end up
getting a relatively small but
meaningful amount of oxygen now that
oxygen it wants to do chemical work
oxygen can oxidize and what you end up
having in the planet is a core we
haven't talked about this yet but the
center of the planet is made out of
metal iron and if you know Iron you know
what happens when it gets wet in the
presence of oxygen it rusts that
actually releases a huge amount of
energy and so what you have is a planet
that acts like a battery because you
have in the oceans hydrothermal vents
they're like underwater volcanoes a
connection between the core and the
surface and you have rusting of that
core iron engaging with the oxygen of
the atmosphere and as a result you have
a flow of electrons from the center of
the planet up through the surface and
out into space and that continues for
essentially billions of years and
provides a you know modest but steady
source of energy that if you're a little
precellular critter living at that
interface in these hydrothermal vents
there's just a steady source of energy
that's pretty similar to what you see
inside one of your
cells let's step back we've got energy
we've got parts of our cell we built our
cell but it's just a single cell that's
right how long does it take and
what does it take to make that leap to
multicellular life so it's a good
question and it turns out that it's not
something which has happened just once
or twice
multicellularity this way in which you
build a body from multiple cells and
that body begins to gain its own
adaptations and traits that make it
capable of doing things that single
cells can't do anymore that transition
has happened many times in the history
of Life at least 50 times separately the
very oldest ones go back back almost to
the origin of cellular life itself
cyanobacteria Pond scum if you will
became multicellular about 3 billion
years ago then much more recently you've
had things like the brown algae a big
CLA of seaweed that you'll see if you go
to the beach and you find these big
brown kelp washing up those are some of
the New Kids on the Block they've only
evolved multicellularity roughly 200
million years
ago okay it took billions of years to go
from a single cell to a multi-cell
organism
you're running an experiment with single
cells to see what happens when you keep
going through this
process how are you g to compress
billions of years uh yeah great question
so I think there's a bit of a bias
towards looking back in time and
assuming that just because something
arose a long time ago it necessarily
took a very long time to get there so we
have this thing called the Cambrian
explosion and you can't see me but I'm
doing air quotes right now because
whenever a geologist tells you it's
something something happen fast you need
to like critically think about what they
think fast is but if you look in the
Rock record you'll see a world when
which there aren't really that many
large animall likee things roughly 530
million years ago and within the span of
5 10 15 million years the oceans are
just populated by all of these very cool
looking animals and in geological terms
10 million years is so fast it's an
explosion in human terms that's still
pretty slow but that being said I don't
think that we are setting our sights
quite as high as building something as
complicated as a fish or something with
a spinal cord or something with eyes
that's a very high bar and indeed those
types of traits probably do take quite a
long time to evolve what we're looking
at are the earliest steps in going from
a single cell organism to a small group
of cells that stay together to form sort
of a clumpy thing and then over
Generations we're going to watch the
cells in that clumpy thing begin to take
on different roles and different
behaviors and watch watch the groups
themselves begin to gain multicellular
adaptations which means traits of the
group which don't really have a single
cell analog they're different from the
cells in the same way that your ability
to run fast or jump high depends on the
muscles in your legs but it's different
from the shape or strength of a muscle
it's an emergent property of having
these cells interact together and so
we're watching those same Dynamics play
out but on a much smaller much simpler
scale so what is your favorite organism
snowflake yeast yeah no no no my
children my children yes yes yes so here
we are working with yeast some people
probably use yeast on a regular day I
think many of us do you enjoy bread beer
wine or other fermented foods yeast are
a critical part of that and the yeast
that we use certainly are formally
domesticated by humans because of their
ability to make alcohol and to leav do
yes and I have to say I do love my bread
now as far as the experiment you're
let's see here 5,000 generations and
Counting we're actually around 8,000
Generations by now 8,000 the title to my
talk says 5,000 and that's the data that
I'm showing but we're actually racing
ahead of that in terms of our
experiments but it takes a long time to
analyze the data that we're collecting
and so we tend to sort of get a nice
round number stop there and spend years
analyzing the data that got up to that
point but the experiment continues every
single day well let's talk about some of
the evolution that's going on with your
yeast right so the first step that I'll
tell you about is we use this system to
understand how a group of cells can be
something which is able to undergo the
process of darwinian evolution which is
actually something we can't take for
granted we know that cells can because
cells reproduce that's a critical step
they get mutations which can change
their traits that can make them to grow
faster or prod do something which makes
them survive better and they can pass
those traits onto their offspring and as
a result those traits can persist in the
population that's what we call Evolution
but the evolution of multicellularity
requires those properties reproduction
heredity to be properties of the group
and that's something which in organisms
like you me and plants is very different
from what their single celled ancestors
would have done and so there's this sort
of Gulf how does a group of cells which
doesn't already have a mechanism of
coordinating reproduction a mechanism of
coordinating development which can be
passed on to offspring how do they
nonetheless gain the ability to evolve
at the group level so we spent many
years decoding this with our yeast model
system and it turns out that they get
the ability to evolve as a group totally
for free we thought you had to get it
through biological Solutions but you get
it totally for free as a side effect of
physics so imagine if you have a cell
and it starts making Offspring and those
offsprings stick to it and you're
getting a clump it's sort of like you're
building a little tree on your desk with
ping-pong balls right and every time the
ping-pong ball divides you add another
one pretty soon you have this cool
little tree like group and it's going to
get densely packed on the inside and if
you keep trying to jam ping-pong balls
in there pretty soon you're going to
break it in our yeast that's exactly
what happens the cells divide and they
eventually break and when they break
they break off a little branch and that
little Branch it's a baby snowflake it
looks like it's parents it has the same
shape it's just a lot smaller and it's
no longer very densely packed so it
grows back up to its parot size and it
begins doing the same thing breaking
growing breaking growing and if I take
one snowflake put it into a test tube
and come back the next day there'll be a
million and they all look just the same
as their parent so we have a life cycle
of reproduction we don't yet have
heritability like how can we get new
multicellular traits we don't have any
development yet turns out that physics
also lends us a helping hand here
because if you can get mutations at the
Single Cell level which change the
behavior of the cells you change their
shape you change the angle at which they
bud you change the strength of a cell
cell connection those change the way
that the group as a whole looks and
behaves it's not directed it's not
controlled in the way that development
in an organism like us is controlled by
these very sophisticated processes in
your cell it's all happening in a way
that's completely emergent that is it's
not directed it just happens in the way
that if you pile sand up on a table
eventually it's going to spill down
right you're not telling it to it just
happens because of physics so it turns
out that we can get multicellular traits
arising as a emergent property and
natural selection sees them and can act
upon them and we get this process of
open-ended multicellular adaptation
where our groups are essentially getting
better and better at growing as a
multicellular organism because through
this process of natural selection acting
on emergent physical properties of
groups and by doing that when they get
bigger they get heavier
they do they do yes which is part of the
key that's part of the key so the way we
do our selection experiment is very
simple cuz I've learned the hard way
that if you make a a fancy selection
experiment you're going to mess it up
you have to remember we have to do our
selection on our yeast every single day
seven days a week 365 days a year you
don't know that Christmas exists they
don't take holidays and so you know
sometimes you're tired sometimes you've
been out late celebrating an academic
achievement and maybe you've had a few
too many yeast drinks that leave you
feeling pretty bad in the morning
morning and if you have a complicated
experiment you're going to mess it up so
our experiment is very simple we take
our yeast and they grow in an incubator
where the incubator spinning and at this
point all that matters is how quickly
they grow that they make little
multicellular babies then at the end of
the day they go through a race to the
bottom of the test tube and the biggest
fastest sinking ones they win the race
and they go on to the next day's media
and everything else is poured down the
drain sorry for them but that's the end
of the road for them and so we're
selecting on bigger tougher
multicellular groups we're also
selecting on the ability to deal with
the fact that once you get big diffusion
begins to be a problem there's a lot of
food in the media outside but the inside
doesn't have it right the inside of that
group is starving you have a circulatory
system that's solved the problem of
diffusion in your body our yeast don't
have that but we want to incentivize
them to come up with some way of solving
these problems and so we're pushing on
size we're making them try and figure
out ways to get physically stronger to
get bigger and we're also making them
deal with the fact that they're growing
slower and maybe they can figure out
ways around that and and they do they
figure out things that took human
physicists hundreds of years and they
figure it out in a matter of months one
of the things that they do is that they
evolve to get about 20,000 times bigger
than their ancestor 20,000 times 20,000
times bigger they start out forming
groups of about a hundred cells and
after 600 rounds of this selection which
is about 3,000 generations for our yeast
they are now roughly half a million
cells per group way bigger and they're
also correspondingly much much stronger
as a material the technical term for
this is toughness it turns out that
toughness in Material Science is how
much energy it takes to break something
but taking its size out of the equation
so the toughness of a toothpick and a
2x4 are the same 2x4s just take more
energy to break cuz there's more
material there our Things become t ,000
times more tough as a material in fact
they go from being a 100 times weaker
than gelatin to being as strong and
tough as wood and they do it through
some really cool physics all right so
now we've talked about shape we've
talked about oh size how do you get that
much bigger yeah so snowflake you start
out growing like a tree with cells that
branch and like a tree if you break a
cell cell Bond like cutting a branch off
that tree that Branch just Falls right
off but to get stronger and bigger they
need to figure out some way that they're
not one cell fracture away from breaking
the whole group what happens is they
actually make their cell cell connection
stronger and their cells
longer and they can actually Stay
Together long enough that the cells
begin to wrap around one another like
Vines and when they do that the whole
group becomes like a group of velcro
right they're in the physical sense
entangled and now to break a branch off
you're not breaking one Bond you have to
break the bonds of every cell to every
other cell and you're ripping them all
apart and you have to break tens of
thousands of cul bonds and that makes
the whole thing tens of thousands of
times stronger and larger right because
you have to remember that you've got
them in these incubators that are
constantly moving they're shaking right
that's right if you can't figure that
out that's right you're not going to be
able to grow bigger and there's a
fundamental limit exactly there is a
complete cap in the absence of it so the
cells than these
these cool newer cells that have figured
this out they're longer they're
elongated they're elongated and they're
Twisted through the yep they actually
stay fairly straight but what happens is
the group stays together long enough
that the cell makes sort of like a
horeshoe shape when it does that it
grows over another branch and if every
branch is making a horseshoe shape
around one another you can think of like
a velcro in your sneaker and the cells
are kind of doing that thing where
they're wrapped around one another and
it makes them as strong as a little ball
of wood huh yeah very cool yeah so we've
grown but you also mentioned diffusion
as being yes oh yes just getting big in
any shape isn't going to work it could
work but it's not ideal because how do
you get that food the media if it's a
big ball and that's what they are
they're a big ball exactly exactly how
do you change your shape to still be big
but so there's two general Solutions
here you can either change your shape so
that every cell is near the surface
which is something like what a fern Leaf
would look like right it's big it's flat
and there's a lot of surface area there
everything's in close contact with the
environment the other way to do it is
something like what an animal would do
which is to move the environment through
you if you move the environment through
you then you don't have this problem of
diffusion limitation this was very
surprising to us and this paper
everything else I've told you about is
published research and you can read
about it on the internet you can go to
my website Ratcliff lab but this is
actually unpublished work but I'll tell
you about it anyway because we're going
to be submitting it soon and we've
talked about it at conferences and I'm
talking about it tomorrow so it turns
out that have you ever seen a sea
sponge sea sponge looks sort of like a
peanut and the cells inside a sea sponge
have little like lassos and they're
moving the water through their bodies
and they're filtering out bacteria if
you looked at a sea sponge from the side
it would be shooting water out the top
like a little volcano it turns out that
our yeast they don't have any way of
directly moving water they don't have
these things called the flagellum which
acts like a little lasso to move water
and yet when we look at them they are
flowing water through their bodies
extremely quickly like faster than many
organisms with these specialized water
moving devices and as a result the cells
on the inside have perfect access to
food and don't starve at all we can
actually grow them under controlled
conditions and get them to be the size
of a marble and they're still growing
just as fast as if they were the size of
a a period on the page wow yeah so we've
talked about and you've described the
structure changes and what been
happening what about those genes ah good
question are we getting cells
specializing in dividing labor which is
one of these Hallmarks of
multicellularity and to be honest I
think it's one of the things that makes
multicellularity exciting if
multicellularity was just big blobs of
cells that were all the same as one
another I don't think we'd care about it
that would be more along the lines of
really impressive pwn scum which is cool
don't get me wrong that's cool but it's
not the same as an organism with parts
that work together towards a group level
goal that's something that the single
cells couldn't have done and that's the
superpower of
multicellularity and so this is also
work that's in progress this is
unpublished research we've used a very
cool technique called single celled RNA
quencing what we can do is we can look
at our readout of what genes are being
turned on in individual cells and we can
do this in a pretty high throughput way
so in the ancestor line in a 1,000
generation line in a 2,000 generation
line we do this all the way up to 5,000
Generations we take the organisms we
break them down to single cells and we
do a little readout of what genes those
cells are expressing and turning on and
the ancestor they're all the same as
would be expected because it's basically
only one generation away from being a
single- cell organism it's just forming
a group and by a thousand Generations we
actually have two distinct cell types we
have the normal ancestor likee cells and
we have a cell type that looks quite
different on a graph of gene expression
it's in its own distinct place and those
cells are mostly overexpressing cell
wall material so we have some cells
they're hitting the gym they're getting
really strong but it's only a subset
right 10 15% of the cells are doing this
and if we stain cell walls we actually
see that they're not randomly localized
throughout the groups these are the
oldest cells in the groups the cells
that have the biggest number of branches
coming off of them the ones that are
actually under a lot of physical strain
and when our groups break that's where
they tend to break so it seems like
there may be a bit of a sort of simple
intelligent strengthening of critical
cells which allows them to get stronger
as an organism and that cell type
persists all the way up to 5,000
Generations around 3,000 Generations we
get a third cell type and actually
there's something interesting happening
here between 2,000 and 3,000 Generations
is when our yeast become really big it's
when they go from being a few hundred
cells to being a few hundred thousand
cells right much much bigger and it
turns out that getting really big comes
with a serious cost it's not a growth
rate cost like we discussed earlier
because they're moving fluid through
their bodies and they're not really
growth limited but there's another cost
in our experiment which is that our
groups have to reproduce and make
Offspring because every day we only
transfer about 1 in 32 of the groups
that we're in our population as a whole
and if a group just grows indefinitely
and doesn't make babies then it just
gets thrown away eventually and it and
all of its cells are gone so in fact
every day if a group wants to persist it
has to have at least 32 offsprings
otherwise every day there's a smaller
and smaller number of them reproduction
is a very important thing in our
experiment and to get strong and build
big groups they do this by sacrificing
the way that they reproduced which is
this physical strain building up and
breaking branches when they get so
strong that they don't break branches
anymore that's kind of a problem they
win in the race to the bottom of the
test tube but they lose in that they
don't make babies very well anymore and
it looks like this third cell type is
something where cells actually commit
suicide about 20 to 25% of the cells in
the group turn on genes that cause them
to die and this starts to break little
tiny branches that are not part of the
strong interior entangled part of the
cluster which those things can't really
leave anymore but cells that are on the
edge now separate and so you have these
groups now that are turning on all these
cell death genes which cause cells to
die and instead of breaking off giant
chunks of maybe 10,000 cells to
reproduce they are shedding 2 three four
five cell babies and it's shedding many
many of them and that's the way in which
they engineer reproduction so they kind
of getting a new life cycle by using a
simple form of cellular differentiation
very cool I love that yeah very cool I
will say that one we have yet to
functionally validate that result so
that's a hypothesis this is what we
think is happening it sure seems that
way but I want to just say that it's
something which we need to do a little
bit more research before I'm 100%
convinced of that result ah this is part
of the scientific process exactly that's
how science works okay so where do you
think you're going to be and um let's go
ahead six years yeah yeah yeah and
you'll be at what 16,000 Generations in
the experiment probably yeah what do you
want to see I'd love to see something
more complex than just a blob of C I'd
like to see multicellular development
coordinated growth getting a shape that
is a little more interesting than just
something which looks like an asteroid
which is kind of what they look like
when I'm looking at under microscope
they look kind of like asteroids and
we're actually getting tantalized ing
evidence this is just the very
Beginnings but if we let them grow where
there are these strong flows where
they're actually pushing water through
their bodies they actually begin to grow
in a different way and form a hole in
the center and look sort of like a
doughnut which is actually very
interesting shape in developmental
biology going from a clump to a doughnut
is actually a pretty big deal yeah it be
a huge deal yeah yeah I'm interested in
understanding better the way in which
cell specialization evolves in different
parallel evolving populations right now
we've only looked at one population but
we have five that are evolving in
parallel they have the same starting
point but independent evolutionary
trajectory let's see what happens right
yeah is it the same thing does it do
exactly the same thing or is it
different you know there's all sorts of
possibilities there exactly so what
we'll do is we'll have to have you back
in six more years sounds great I'm going
to do this until I retire or die so
plenty of time all right well we'll go
for retirement sounds good all right
well before my scientists get to leave
ask a biologist I always ask three
questions right so are you ready sure
okay when did you first know you wanted
to be a scientist or in this case did
you know you wanted to be an
evolutionary biologist SL
astrobiologist what happened so I knew I
wanted to be a scientist when I was a
kid because I just loved learning about
science science like I couldn't get
enough we had a once a week science
teacher that would come and tell us
about science in my grade school and I
would just like be so excited on those
days I had home kits and books and I
would do those and honestly I loved
spending time in nature and just looking
at organisms and if you think about it
all of the drama that you see that
humans have with respect to the way that
we interact the highs of of success the
lows of failure those things happen but
on a even greater scale in living
systems where the stakes are often life
or death so as soon as you start to sort
of notice the world around you you
realize that it's just this NeverEnding
fascinating tapestry of interactions and
I think I knew I wanted to be a
biologist when I started to connect
those interactions and understanding how
living things fit together in their
environment with the way that they got
there in the first place and thinking
about the history and how those things
in fact got to be the way they are how
did that Beetle get those jaws and
become a predator ripping apart other
insects while it's close relative is a
pollinator and completely completely
gentle you know those are great
questions so I I think I knew at a young
age but I don't think I knew I wanted to
be a scientist until the end of college
when I was like what am I going to do
you just didn't know you wanted to be a
scientist or you didn't know you wanted
to be a biologist I didn't know I wanted
to be a research biologist ah I did a
plant biology undergraduate degree again
for my love of nature but I didn't
really know what I wanted to do after
college and I sort of lucked into our
research lab my favorite Professor I
went and talked to him like what should
I do and he was like I just got a grant
why don't you start working in my lab
okay and then the rest was sort of
history but it wasn't something which I
was planning to do for a long time even
though the interest was always there
well with all your enthusiasm I really
hate to introduce this next question
because I'm GNA take it all away oh know
now this is just a thought question
right if I took this away from you and
I'm going to take away teaching because
almost every scientist that I've had on
loves doing the teaching so you're not
going to be a scientist you're not going
to be
teaching what would you be or what would
you do if you could do anything I'm G to
give you some abilities that you may not
have oh that's such a cool question okay
it's a
tossup between professional
beekeeper I'm a hobby beekeeper in my
backyard I up until this last year which
has been sort of a rough year for me I
had about 30 be colonies and I make
about 1,000 pounds of honey a year and I
really love bees they're just such fun
organisms to spend time with and they
have such alien cognition and I just
love seeing the world through their eyes
it's a very fun thing to just immerse
yourself in a bee Colony not literally
that would be painful so yeah I've
thought about it would be fun to scale
that up although I think what I've
learned with scaling as a scientist is
that you become a manager and not the
actual actor and so I probably wouldn't
be able to spend time with bees if I was
actually a professional beekeeper but if
that wasn't the case I would if I could
have any
skills and I'm not a
scientist okay I would be
a uh this is going to sound weird but I
think I might want to be an engineer
developing Frontier artificial
intelligence technology okay because I
think that stuff's really fun to think
about and I like to play around with it
as a hobby I'm not sure that it's the
right thing for society but at a purely
intellectual curiosity level I think
it's really fun and interesting to play
with right I mean it's something we need
to confront it's coming it's here the
genie out of the bottle all right last
question
okay what advice would you have for a
young
scientist or perhaps someone who's doing
something that's not in the Sciences but
always love science and they want to get
into a science career I think my advice
would be
to figure out a way to start a research
project it could be a hobby project it
can be something you do at home better
if you have someone who understands you
know that field that can act as a mentor
but doing science and learning about
science the way that we teach science
especially the undergraduate or lower
levels it's very different from the kind
of hands-on experience that you get if
you actually do a project because a lot
of doing science is confronting unknown
is learning things on the Fly is dealing
with failure is iterating it's a very
different experience than getting the
distilled version of thousands of hours
of work from hundreds of people and
saying here is the answer to this
question right and because there is no
book on the Shelf with all the answers
no the vast majority of scientific
questions are yet to be even posed and
so there is a huge amount of exciting
work to be done out there and I think
for me it's really fun and exciting to
be able to actually be on the frontier
of Science and asking questions and you
know doing that sort of like work that
doesn't already have an answer I think
there's a real joy to that and so for
those who are interested in a scientific
career if you have the opportunity
whether it's through if you're an
undergraduate student working in a lab
if you're just a member of the community
I'm sure there are all sorts of
opportunities to get involved a lot of
clubs like beekeeping clubs will have
scientists that are affiliated you can
get a certificate and do a project you
could be a master gardener I mean
there's a lot of ways to do this and I
think when you're doing science when
you're asking questions posing
hypotheses and testing those hypotheses
with a controlled experiment or other
means of testing a hypothesis you are a
scientist even if you don't have formal
training you are a scientist if you do
science absolutely and along those lines
do you still have your snowflake yeast
kits I do yes all right well we'll be
sure to put the link in so someone can
go if they want to they can play with
not necessarily your children but my
yeast children yes your yeast children
well thank you so much for being on
askab biologist been a pleasure thanks
for having me you have been listening to
askabiologist and my guest has been
William Radcliffe an evolutionary
biologist and also an
astrobiologist he's currently an
associate professor at the Georgia
Institute of Technology and I suspect
some of you have more questions that
have cropped up during this episode that
we may not have answered so we'll be
sure to include some links in the show
including one to Will's Lab website so
that you can learn more about his work
and explore the world of yeast that's
also where we'll put the link to get the
yeast kit the asob biologist podcast is
produced on the campus of Arizona State
University and is recorded in the
grassroot studio
housed in the School of Life Sciences
which is an academic unit of the College
of liberal arts and
sciences and remember even though our
program is not broadcast live you can
still send us your questions about
biology using our companion website the
address is askab biologist.
asu.edu or you can just use your
favorite search engine and enter the
words ask a
biologist as always I'm Dr Dr biology
and I hope you're staying safe and
healthy