Debate unfolds: Rep. Walsh takes stand against bill targeting law-abiding firearm owners

Washington State House Republicans
23 followers
Feb 10, 2024
During recent House floor debate, Rep. Jim Walsh, R-Aberdeen, offered an amendment to HB 1903, a bill that would hold firearm owners liable in the event of a crime. The proposed legislation mandates that victims of firearm loss or theft report the incident to local law enforcement within 24 hours or face a $1,000 fine. Walsh vehemently denounces this as government overreach, condemning the measure for unfairly criminalizing law-abiding citizens.
Amendment 8861 clerk will read on page
one line 10 after within last line seven
days good member from the 19th to move
adoption of the amendment thank you
madam speaker please move Amendment 861
been moved and second we adopt Amendment
861 remarks a good member from the 19th
representative Walsh thank you madam
speaker this
amendment improves the mechanics of the
bill by making a practical
consideration of the amount of time that
a lawful firearm
owner would have to report a missing or
stolen firearm under the other terms of
the underlying Bill uh Madam speaker as
we've seen with other similar gun
control proposals the risk we run with
this proposal is to
has been stolen and actually expose them
to a uh to an
infraction if they don't uh report a uh
stolen or perhaps lost whatever that
means firearm uh in a a limited amount
of time what this amendment does is it
makes the window of time within which
the lawful firearm owner must report
that missing or stolen firearm to 7
days this is realistic this is
practical and in an underlying bill
which needs realism and practicality it
improves The Proposal please vote yes
thank you additional remarks seeing none
the question before the house is oh the
good member from the 19 representative
Walsh uh thank you madam speaker sorry
about that um
Madam speaker when we want to achieve uh
desired ends in public
policy as
in Human Resources as in business
management as in many contexts there are
two
ways we can try to affect Behavior
positive reinforcement and negative
reinforcement the underlying bill is
negative
reinforcement it is threatening
law-abiding govern owners who've been
victimized with
punishment if they don't behave in a
certain
way this
amendment
redirects the underlying policy proposal
to positive
reinforcement it
encourages good
behavior rather than punishing bad
behavior now I I I'm well aware
that certain uh of our colleagues in
this building say that strong
penalties deter criminal Behavior but I
think we emphasize the negative too much
Madam speaker and we need to emphasize
the
positive that's what this amendment does
it turns a negative situation into a
positive
resolution we need to do that Madam
speaker wherever we
can this accentuates the positive and in
that Spirit please vote Yes on the
amendment thank you additional remarks
the good member from the 19th
representative Walsh thank you madam
speaker really bad bill please vote no
um this bill is about penalizing
law-abiding Property Owners who've been
victimized one way or the other in their
property uh being lost or stolen now we
can quote
statistics about how uh gun violence is
caused by X or Y or Z Factor but that's
not the Fatal flaw in this proposal
Madam speaker the Fatal flaw in this
proposal is that it
revictimized someone who's already been
victimized now I I mentioned earlier in
the context of one of the Amendments
that there's a difference between
negative reinforcement and positive
reinforcement we all want to reduce
crime in this state Madam speaker it's a
growing
problem but I think that we need to stop
focusing on negative reinforcement about
gun ownership and find positive ways to
proactively deter criminal
action now this proposal May intend to
reduce crime Madam speaker but we have
seen
similar proposals pass into law in this
state and our crime rates are going up
not
down I recommend we put this proposal
aside Madam speaker and focus instead on
fighting crime that will reduce crime
please vote
no
