Lecture 12

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Feb 2, 2024
[Music]
welcome back my dear friends and
students a very good morning good
afternoon good evening to all of you who
are taking this course uh titled
multicriterial decision making under M
and P and my good name is ragun n s
Gupta from the IM department at I khur
in
India
and the broad outline for few sets of
lectures which we have been continuing
is in the area of definitions of mcdm
Concepts utility Theory Safety First
principle and stochastic dominance and
today we'll uh start the 12th lecture
for this total series of 60 lectures
which is spread over 12 12 weeks each
week we have five lectures half an hour
each what will be the coverage for this
lecture even though many points are
written we will cover it as you know
that as you proceed nothing is left only
that uh the overall broad line is given
and we slowly proceed we'll consider the
properties of util function concept of
risk aversion uh risk neutrality risk-
seeking properties what is the concept
of marginal utility what is the concept
of absolute risk cion relative rision
we'll consider that there are two
different topics we'll consider examples
of utility theories and so and and so
forth we will be covering so obviously
this slide which you seeing we will
cover later on but this is just
given as a
precursor so considering the property uh
where we left left the 11th lecture
which was the first lecture in
the third week so we did discuss the
concept of of first the concept of non
sensation property one property two was
basically property related to a person
being risk loving person being risk
indifferent person being disater and we
did discuss in details with the fair
gamble with the outcomes increasing for
the output as well as for the sure event
and their person can decide whether he
or she will go for the gamble or go for
the
certainty event and as we have seen as
the question was asked that as the
stakes increases people do change their
decision from being a person who's
willing to take the risk to a case where
he's indifferent she is indifferent and
then being a person who's avoiding the
risk so considering those three
properties risk loving risk indifferent
risk
hater we will consider these three
things number one is basically the
person who is
recovers number two being the person who
risk neutral and the number three is
basically the person who is risk-seeking
and based on the second derivative
because the first derivative give you
the the concept of non ciation first
derivative means the D derivative of the
util function so considering the second
derivative is less than zero so you have
I use different colors in order to come
make a note of that so it is the second
derivative being less than zero gives
you the risk aversion
property the second derivative being
equal to zero gives you the risk neutral
property and the second derivative being
greater than zero gives you the
risk-seeking property and we'll see that
D diagrammatically also so these are
basically
this is the second derivative for the
third case greater than
zero this is the second derivative I'm
just repeating it please bear with me
second derivative for the second case
need risk
neutral and this being the second
derivative for the first case which is
risk averse so if we draw the
diagram and we should note down what is
there in the x-axis x-axis is the wealth
here
and y axis is the
utility so if you have
this the Rel property related to
where obviously very interestingly in
all these three diagrams the green one
the blue one and the r red one the
property of non ciation which is more I
give you more you want is the first
derivative being greater than Zer always
holds for all these three all these
three means for the red one yes I'm
putting the color tick mark
accordingly for the blue one yes and for
the green one
yes now coming back to the concept of
double derivative which is which will
denote whether the person wants to take
risk is indifferent or is avoiding the
risk so obviously if I see the secondary
derivative for the red one the second
derivative which is increasing at an
increasing rate all three are increasing
but the red one is increasing at
increasing rate which
means the red one would be the case
where it is greater than
zero so he's a person who wants to take
risk is basically a risk
low
a risk seeking
person so this is for the red one if I
see the blue one second derivative is
increasing at a constant rate so it is
zero so is basically a risk neutral so I
won't write the word risk so but I'll
only write the concept of Neal
person and for the green case the it
increases increasing at a decreasing
rate less than
zero so is basically the person who
hates risk I not using the word risk is
risk
hter risk neutral blue one and risk
lover so using the diagrammatic
representation of the util functions you
can
classify the human being as loving risk
hating risk and being risk neutral the
color schemes are giving accordingly so
the green one is basically for
this the blue
one is for this
one and the red one is basically for
this
one so marginal rate is basically the
rate of increase so if I consider the
marginal utility functions based on the
fact what we just discussed in the last
slide of the
diagram here you will have the marginal
rate is
basically marginal util function looks
like a concave
function which is a risk averse
person which means that it is increasing
at a decreasing
rate for the case where the marginal U
function looks neither concave nor
convex which is is risk neutral person
which is wants to take risk or avoid
risk both are
same and for the person where the util
function looks
convex he or she is a risk taker because
it is increasing at an increasing rate
so here U Prime greater than zero for
the third bullet
point for the second bullet point U
Prime is equal to zero
and the first bullet point is U point is
less than zero then if I consider the
margin utility rates which I have
discussed there it
becomes more detailed explanation what
have I been talking about
verbally so for the
case where you have it's increasing at a
decreasing rate it's a risk ofse person
which is
this this marginal rate it is increasing
at a constant rate which is risk neutral
perc which is double derivative is equal
to
zero and if it is increasing at an
increasing rate is a risk Seeker where
the double derivative is greater than
zero so the diagrams basically portray
it so if I
draw it accordingly
here this same thing so the red
one would be
increasing the blue one is
constant the green one is decreasing
here so the RIS CS
person the increase is happening but
happening at a decreasing rate so if I
draw the tangent so for this point
a and for this point
B so the line if the line moves like
this so from my side if I'm looking
moves like this and slowly decreases so
the rate of change if I have drawn the
angle so this if I draw a here a point
is
here and B point is see for example
here so if I draw this is angle Theta
a this is angle Theta
B so obviously Theta
a is more than Theta B and so on and so
forth so it slowly becomes horizontal so
this is a risk averse person and obvious
obviously this should be true and which
I'm pointing out sorry for my repe
pation you draw the util functions along
the y axis and the wealth along the
x-axis if I consider the risk neutral
person so increasing at a constant rate
again the weights are wths are denoted
along the
x-axis you along the y axis so here you
will basically have U Prime being zero
because constant U Prime is constant if
I go for the third
diagram which is risk-seeking
person so here if I consider again point
a point
B so if I am able to draw it this is
a and
consider this is B
so if it's Theta
B is Theta
a Theta a is less than Theta B because
it is becoming
vertical again for convenience we have
drawn W's along the
x-axis and UW along the y- axis so this
is risk-seeking person now continuing
with the other important Concepts if I
consider risk aversion risk neutrality
and risk seeking person with based on
the fact that we have considered a fair
gamble the situation along with the
concept of u double Prime the table is
made
accordingly so if I consider a risk
averse person so sloping curve going
down there obviously he or she would
reject the fair Gamble and take the sh
event so reject the fair gamble take the
sh event and obviously U dou Prime is
less than zero because the graph which
you will have is sloping
downwards if I consider the risk neutral
person he or she would be indifferent to
the fair gaml with respect to the she
event there in that case U Prime is
equal to0
and the graph is a straight line graph
cons and then finding out the second
derivative and finally for the case when
is he or she is a risk-seeking person
would select the fair Gamble and avoid
and not take the the sh event the
overall graph of u double Prime will be
greater than zero which means the graph
is increasing like
this now we'll consider the third
property third property is known as the
the absolute risk aversion property
which is property three and for the
utility function and it can be proved we
are not going to the detail proof that
the concept of absolute risk ofion and
the corresponding a prime we will also
see is given by this a prime a is
basically the ratio which again I'm
saying it can be proved of the negative
value of the double derivative in the
numerator and the
one derivative which is nons property in
the denominator so obviously we know
that U Prime is always greater than
zero and this
property of uble prime can be less than
zero can
be greater than
zero and can be equal to zero So based
on that you will basically have the a
Prime Property also which is known as
the absolute rision what is the concept
of absolute rision qualitatively we'll
come to
that so it can be proved that for an
decreasing absolute discis verion which
is for the case when you
have a prime not a a prime
as which is Da by DW is less than zero
so a prime being less than zero it is
given as the dis decreasing absolute
risk Aion so the person's absolute risk
aversion property is decreasing so Mark
the
words the risk aversion property is
decreasing in the absolute
sense if somebody wants to
consider a prime as zero which is
here then there's a constant absolute
risk conversion property
and for the third case when a prime is
greater than zero you have the
increasing absolute risk Aion property
and Mark these Concepts which I
said absolute risk aversion
property absolute risk aversion
property absolute risk ation
property and they as you see can be in
decreasing
constant and increasing based on that
you have a prime being less than
0 equal to Z and greater than
Z what does it
mean this is what the slide says here so
if I have the
decreasing absolute risk conversion
property where the
fact is
a prime is less than zero then it means
that as wealth
increases wealth means w increases the
amount held in Risky assets also
increases so it is words decreasing
absolute risk a so the risk Avion
property is decreased that means I'm
willing to take the
risk so that's why I said Mark the words
so it increases the amount the person
increases the amount in Quantum terms
held in R cas
assets if it is
constant where a prime is equal to Z
then as wealth increases the amount held
in Risk asset remains
same and if a prime is greater than zero
it means the person is increasing
absolute disc contion and as wealth
increases the amount Health in Risk
asset decreases so the these were from
the point of view of absolute disc
conversion
property so mark this decreasing
here a prime less than zero constant
here a prime is equal Z increasing here
a prime greater than Z so decreasing
constant increasing absolute disc
conversion would have these implications
main thing is Mark what is written in
the second
column which is the
definitions now we will come to the
fourth property which is basically
related relative risk aversion
property and it is concept relative
sense that was the absolute sense is the
relative
sense the formula is given
by RW is now so we already had U Prime
is greater than Z true minus sign is
also there also in a a w here also it's
there W is positive remember that
wealth and if you pay attention here U
Prime can be greater than
zero U Prime can be equal to zero and U
Prime can be less than zero So based on
that you can find out how RW which is
relative risk aversion property
would behave and how it would look
like so just remember with respect to A
and R only the factor W has been
multiplied in there in case of R other
Concepts remain the same the numerator
is U Prime denominator is U Prime
there's a minus sign everything now let
us consider the relative risk aversion
property in its more detailed sense in
the same way as we did for the absolute
risk conversion property so whatever I'm
discussing we'll do that in examples so
if I consider the
decreasing relative risk and the
relative sense that was in the absolute
sense then obviously R
Prime as given here is less than zero if
I consider in the constant sense
relative risk aversion prop property
then R Prime is equal to Z and in the
last case if I
consider in the increasing sense
relative resion property then R Prime is
greater than zero so there those were
with respect to Absolute sense now
they're in the relative
sense what do they mean
again in the sense when you have
decreasing uh relative risk aversion
property which means
RP Prime is less than zero then as
wealth increases the percentage held in
thisk CD increases that was in the
quantum sense absolute sense here
percentage
wise similarly if I have the idea of
constant relative
dision RP Prime is equal to zero then as
wealth increases increas is there in all
these two definitions of A and R but in
one case you will consider the increase
decrease and constant being with respect
to in the absolute sense here here in R
which is relative case it is in the
percentage sense so continuing the
second point so as wealth decrease
increases percentage held in this CET
Remains the
Same and finally
as for the increasing relative risk
ction property which is R Prime is
greater than zero as wealth
increases percentage held in Risk asses
decreases so this was basically
true so we will consider very
simply the ideas of some utility
functions details I'll come continue in
the next class some util functions which
are important is basically the quadratic
util function so generally
we will consider the quadratic util
function so of the form use a different
color actually it is of the
form a is this quadratic equation we
know a x² + BX +
C so this is basically the quadratic
form and you have the quadratic form as
given so constant term can be there need
not be there but in General it is given
so you'll basically have wus half of C
w² is a quadratic and remember C is a
positive constant we will see that it
will come out to be
true in the exponential sense it is
basically an exponential
function of the form shown
here minus e^ minus a w a is again a
positive
constant so it will give you the
exponential utility
function and if you have the power
utility
function I'll use
the red so it is C W gamma so obviously
C and Gamma values as they are given
both are less than
one and in many of the cases very simple
examples the util functions can also be
denoted C W to power C so there is the
same
parameter so the power util function and
this the value of gamma will dictate how
the bar U function will look like
because C is a constant it can be
multiplied and the last one is basically
the logarithm U function of Ln of
w which will be log and
remember the
properties of which will discuss if you
remember the property of um non ciation
property of risk covers risk neutral
risk um loving those this property one
property two and corresponding also the
concept of a a prime r r Prime which is
absolute dision and is derivative
relative dision and is D derivative all
these things would be considered for all
these four different util functions and
some other cases also and there you can
find out what would be basically the
corresponding values of the constant so
for the quadratic equations we are more
interested to find out value of
C then for exponential values of a power
U function value of c and Gamma and
logarithmic considering there's no
parameter we'll be interested in general
characteristics so what is important for
all these four cases is I'm just writing
property one is important to be
checked property two concept of risk
property three concept of a prime and
property four concept of RP Prime so a
prime and RP Prime are coming out from A
and
R uh with this I will end this 12th
lecture and and consider in details the
the concept of these four properties and
for this four util function which which
are there and discuss them in forther
details thank you very much and have a
nice
[Music]
day
[Music]
