【精彩】潘焯鴻:23條未立應變➕反駁家超擺架勢要同社會嗌交步掃把頭後塵?高傲葉劉當年推23條敗陣衰咩今被家超再推上神臺目空一切 23條有幾宗罪係咩 #Lucy連線

《看中國》香港頻道
2697粉絲
29 次觀看·2024年1月30日
🔥請加入乾净世界 https://www.ganjing.com/zh-CN/channel/1f6j576aqao3taCY3b7gv3NXG1540c<br>🔥請加入我們的Patreon,http://www.patreon.com/visiontimesHK<br>🔥請首選Stripe捐款:https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/donate.html<br>🔥請加入榮譽會員: https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/subscribe.html<br><br>香港巨變、新聞自由日益收窄,同香港人一齊經歷過槍林彈戰嘅我哋,國安法後要面對更多嘅挑戰同打壓,加上FaceBook Youtube等嘅種種限制、黃標甚至關閉,「報導真相,揭露邪惡」變得越嚟越艱難。<br><br>不過,無論前路有幾咁艱難險阻,我哋永不忘初衷,荊棘路上繼續為大家深挖真相,還公民知情權!<br><br>感謝你哋一路以來嘅不離不棄,請繼續支持我哋,加入我哋嘅Patreon,成爲我哋嘅榮譽會員,願榮光早日歸於香港!<br><br>本視頻僅代表嘉賓或受訪者本人觀點。<br><br>聯絡我們 [email protected]
Xi Jinping said that he would set up a response and refutation team
Response and refutation means to respond to some social disputes
or topics that have been raised
Refutation means to refute
That is to say, the two are actually in different situations
One is to respond to some social doubts or social voices
The other is to refute
Refute what he thinks is wrong
However, the word response and refutation
is very easy to remind people of
what happened in 2002, which is about 21 years ago
That is, the situation when Yeh Lau Shuk-yu pushed Article 23
What exactly is Article 23 of the Legislation?
What is Article 23 of the Legislation?
What is the content of Article 23 of the Legislation?
Is the National Security Law really repeated or not repeated?
Then, is there a law that has been covered up?
Or what is wrong with Yeh Lau Shuk-yu in 2002?
Let's review and get his questions out
Don't let Yeh Lau Shuk-yu think he is very good
Let's take a look at Yeh Lau Shuk-yu in 2002
What is his image?
What attitude did he have to face the people?
As a result, he had to leave his job and hide in the United States
Of course, when Beijing likes him
After a while, many of Hong Kong's goldfish memories have disappeared
Sometimes people think that Yeh Lau Shuk-yu is very familiar
Is this really the case?
Now Yeh Lau Shuk-yu is more famous
More proud
More open-minded
He doesn't want people to talk about him
Show everyone Yeh Lau Shuk-yu in 2002
But now if Li Ka-siu does this
That is, in terms of Article 23 of the Legislation
Not to seek social consensus
I thought Yeh Lau Shuk-yu was going to quarrel with society
So I was afraid that the situation in 2003 would reappear
Of course, now Hong Kong citizens are afraid of the National Security Law
But the problem is that this will make the grievance even bigger
Article 23 is Article 23 of the Basic Law
There were originally 7 crimes
Legislation by the SAR
This is the Basic Law
After the Hong Kong Small Commissioning Act was designed, consulted, designed and drafted
It is a decision
Let Hong Kong people legislate
Let Hong Kong people legislate independently
Article 23 of the Basic Law
It is a principle of legislation to write down the 7 crimes related to national security
Our government always says
Hong Kong's constitutional responsibility is to carry out Article 23 of the Legislation
This is true
This is really right
On the other hand, there is another point
Article 23 is not implemented by the Chinese law in Hong Kong
It's not called copy
It is in accordance with the situation of the SAR
Based on these 7 crimes
It is the SAR's own legislation
This is what the Legislative Council of Hong Kong knew at the time
Hong Kong knows that there is a consultation process in the Legislative Council
It's not like the mainland of China
The consultation process may not be directly expressed by all the people
Hong Kong is a smaller city
People can express directly
But the situation of consultation collected by the mainland of China
May be from the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress
Representatives of the National People's Congress
Organizations in various regions under the National People's Congress
Even the politicians help to collect opinions
It's completely different from Hong Kong
The mainland of China itself has a law on these 7 crimes
If you think about it
If the Basic Law
I don't want to incite
I have to make it clear
If the Basic Law thinks it can directly copy
Or copycat the 7 crimes in the mainland
Then the Basic Law will never need to call Article 23 to be legislated
Because at that time, as long as the 7 crimes related to these 7 crimes
Directly follow the Basic Law
Hong Kong's legislation
Directly use the legislation is OK
No need to legislate by yourself
But now it's called self-legislation
There is a constitutional right to legislate
This is actually the case
Because Article 23 is written
On the other hand, in fact, this self-governing legislation
In fact, I also hope that the law can pass
After the overall consensus of the Hong Kong society
There is a version of the 7 crimes in Hong Kong
What are the 7 crimes?
Count by one by one
The first one is related to this
It's a half-nation crime
Half-nation crime
Then we will talk about what is the content
Half-nation crime
The second one is the division of state crime
The third one is the subversion of state power
Subversion crime
The fourth one is related to this incitement crime
What is the difference between subversion and incitement?
Talk to you later
The fifth one is related to this confidentiality crime
The sixth one is related to foreign political organizations
Foreign political organizations' activities in Hong Kong
And the seventh one is the association of Hong Kong organizations and foreign political organizations
There are 7 crimes
Among the 7 crimes, not many are repeated in the current national security law
For example, the national security law is related to terrorist activities
None of the 7 crimes
That is, among the 4 major crimes of the National Security Law
This one is related to this terrorist activity
In fact, it was not designed in the National Security Law
It was added to the National Security Law
And there is a subversion and incitement in the National Security Law
In fact, there is no incitement in the National Security Law
It is a written crime
There is subversion
It is actually a repetition of the crimes in Article 23
But the incitement crime is in Article 9 and 10 of the current criminal proceedings law
Or the confidentiality crime in Article 23
It turns out that we have an official confidentiality law
Or it is related to foreign political organizations
Or foreign political organizations' activities in Hong Kong
It turns out that there is a chance to be covered by the Association Act
It turns out that the 7 crimes in Article 23
In fact, the legal system that we started in Hong Kong during the colonial period
There are already some related content in some of the crimes
Appeared in some of the laws
That is, we don't have a law called Article 23
Or a supplement to the National Security Law
And then put all the related crimes in it
It's not like that
Our approach is in different laws
For example, the National Security Law
Or the Criminal Procedure Act
Put the relevant articles of different crimes in it
But are the articles in it enough?
Is it clear?
Has the definition changed?
This can be discussed
In addition
One of the things to consider in Article 23
Is the law in our legal system
And the basic principles
Will there be major changes after Article 23
For example, some confidentiality related to the National Security Law
Or even slander
Article 9 and 10 of the Criminal Procedure Act
Now slander
That is, to incite people to oppose the government's policy
To make the government unable to operate
This is slander
For example, let's talk about this slander
Slander itself
That is, the slander of the 7 crimes
It turned out to be in the Criminal Procedure Act
There is a clear clause
That is, even if you are against the policy
Even if the policy is openly opposed
If your purpose is to point out the problem of this policy
Or hope that the policy can be improved
In fact, it has been eliminated
So this is why I am so bold
For example, on Facebook
Or even on live broadcast
Talk about the current policy
But Article 23
Will there be slander or incitement?
Will it change?
Will there be no elimination?
Will this incitement
The definition of the crime itself
More extensive
Or more detailed
This is to be seen
But it is also a place for us to discuss
Or this is related
This is the subversion of national power
Or this is a confidential crime
These two are a bit similar
But in fact they are separate
For example, confidential crime
It is related to the confidential documents of the government
In the past, in the era of Liu Shuyi
It is included in the discussion
That is, the government has documents
Or information that is confidential
But if this confidentiality
If it is disclosed
Of course there is a crime
But if it is disclosed
It is more beneficial to society than harmful
Is there a crime?
This is a matter of conscience
Simply put
For example, the government originally has an internal document
It will collect this
This may not be right or wrong
Just take it as an example
In the confidentiality team
It turns out that someone picked it up
Someone picked up a public bag at the bus stop
Then he opened it to see
There is a confidential document in the public bag
Confidential document
The confidential document says that the government is preparing to issue a real estate tax
When will it start?
But the confidentiality document states that it is internal
Cannot be released to the public
Then this person can think about it
He considered whether to put this confidentiality
Put it out on social media to let people know
If it is put out, it will cause panic
Many people immediately buy a house
In order to avoid
When we sell a house
Implemented this real estate tax
Caused us to pay a lot of taxes
When the house is sold, we have to pay the tax
If so, why not
When the real estate tax is not paid
Sell it first
So there is no need to pay taxes to the government
This is
Is there any consideration
Publicly confidential people
Is it beneficial or harmful to society as a whole?
This may be harmful because you can reduce taxes
It may also be beneficial
This discussion
Whether it is harmful or not
May be judged by the court
But the 23rd Legislation may not have this judgment
Regardless of whether it is harmful or not
Anyway, this document
Is a secret
Secret
I can sue you as soon as you make it public
Regardless of whether there will be public interest
Consider
May be written like this
I don't know yet
But we temporarily feel
There is nothing to discuss
Not without any scope
Very clear and direct
Like Li Ka-siu's message
This is a national security
This must be done better
There is a loophole now
We are not just talking about these words
When you think you have to protect the loophole
Should we do this?
What results do we have?
Is it possible to write in this direction?
Will it be better for society as a whole?
This can be discussed
What is the result?
As a result, Li Ka-siu said
The proposal has not yet come out
In the whole process of legislation
It was said that it would take a year
Before the end of 2024
Complete this 23rd Legislation
Now it is possible that the government
There are some considerations in time
Because if the end of the year coincides with the U.S. presidential election
The whole period overlaps so much time
The U.S. seems to be on March 2
Super Monday
Is it March 2?
In short, the super Monday in early March
In theory, the candidates for the Democratic-Republican Party
Have already been born
It seems that Biden
It's March 2
Anyway
There is a super Monday in March
After the super Monday in March
The candidates for the Democratic-Republican Party
Will be born
Now it is obvious that it is between Biden and Trump
I don't know if there will be any special circumstances
We can't guess
But if the presidential election
It's already settled
The candidates for the presidential election
It's already settled
The candidates for the presidential election
It can be based on events all over the world
Is to carry out
Propaganda in the election
If
When the U.S. starts in March
The presidential election
It's already settled
Then we started
Constantly have 23 articles thrown out
Until they want to vote
Before voting in November
How big do you think the impact of this period will be?
It will definitely be big
Because this will be
Considered as a propaganda
And an event in the election
So Hong Kong said
I want to bring it forward
It will be passed during the summer vacation
I want to bring it forward during the summer vacation
Try to reduce the coverage period
Hurry up
Hold on
Put the cover
Wear it
Put the cover
The Legislative Council also has a legislative timetable, which includes when to announce the details of the draft,
when to do the white paper draft, and whether to do the public consultation-type white paper draft.
Now that we've said we won't do it, if we don't do it, we'll go straight to the blue paper draft.
How can citizens express their opinions? How can they participate in the discussion?
This is what the government should tell us.
Then when to read one, read two, read three.
Including whether the Legislative Council will be opened or not.
Including whether citizens can participate in the trial.
Whether the Legislative Council says, hey, I'm not going to do the trial, I'm going to vote.
These are the things that the government can tell the citizens.
The biggest problem is that the draft hasn't come out yet.
That is, I think the government is still dragging it out.
It's still in the draft.
When it's not written yet, it's obviously not born yet.
He suddenly said, I'm going to set up a counter-refutation team.
To refute the voice of opposition in the room.
Here's the problem.
If there is a bill, if there is a voice, including a space for discussion.
Is this a bad thing?
No, it's not.
This is what civil society should do.
It should be put forward.
This law will affect us in the future.
And affect our next generation.
We should put forward our opinions in the Legislative Council.
When we put forward our opinions, the government used the word refutation to say.
What is the difference between the 23 drafts of the Legislative Council at the time and the situation in 2002?
Let's go back to 2002.
Although there were democratic parties and pro-establishment parties in civil society.
But the society at the time was not as intense as it was in 2014.
It's not like that.
In 2002, most of the society was still silent.
That is, there were not many people who had a clear and strong intention in politics.
On the contrary, everyone was very quiet.
It's like the majority of people are silent.
Everyone lives in peace and quiet.
The 23 drafts of the Legislative Council were one of the things that provoked the civic awareness of Hong Kong people.
Because in the 23 drafts, everyone knows that their own future life will be affected.
It will affect everyone's next generation.
So many people are concerned.
When people are concerned, different organizations and even the Legislative Council have different opinions on the different drafts.
The explanation method at the time was called explanation.
There were three people in charge of explaining.
But the explanation work was not to explain to you, but to scold you back.
It was constantly quarreling with you in the form of a fight.
It did not mention the content at all.
The 23 drafts of the Legislative Council used this attitude at the time.
Some people now think that if the Legislative Council was established at that time,
there may not have been so many incidents in Hong Kong in 2014 and 2019.
Maybe not.
But the biggest problem is that if the Legislative Council was not established or the Legislative Council was unsuccessful,
it was not the result of Hong Kong people's opposition.
No.
At that time, Hong Kong people raised questions, doubts, and discussions.
In fact, Liu Shuyi should have made it clear to everyone at that time.
Because of this, he gained social awareness.
So maybe the situation at that time was not so bad.
It was because of Liu Shuyi.
At that time, he was the main official of the Security Bureau.
When explaining the policy and the law, he did a very bad job.
Not only did he do a bad job, but he also had a very arrogant and provocative attitude
to confront the people.
At that time, you can see that he was exactly what he looked like at that time.
At that time, he was arrogant and arrogant.
He couldn't stand anyone he talked to.
He couldn't stand anyone.
If you are right, he won't answer.
If he sees you have questions,
he will question you and blame you.
This is Liu Shuyi at that time.
It was because the consultations were not done well,
and the society could not form a consensus.
As a result, the government did not withdraw the legislation.
Liu Shuyi had to leave the Hong Kong government because of this.
He had to be fired and persuaded to leave.
Because he made the Hong Kong government at that time,
the local government at that time, greatly disunited.
Whether the citizens support the authority or support it,
it fell sharply.
It was Liu Shuyi's arrogance at that time,
his arrogance, his arrogance,
his attitude of looking down on people.
As a result, Liu Shuyi hid for a while
and studied in the United States.
When Liu Shuyi and Beijing talked,
Beijing liked him again.
When Liu Shuyi came back,
everyone could forget the situation
of Liu Shuyi at that time.
On the contrary, he felt that he had matured.
It was as if he had been persuaded by other officials.
The reason he came out
was that the next government,
not the next government, but the two governments,
all of their questions were not very good.
Whether it was from the government,
or from outside, it was not very good.
As a result, people thought that
maybe Liu Shuyi was persuaded by them.
Because of this, Liu Shuyi became popular.
But recently, the level of support has been very low.
You can see that in the district council election,
all the candidates supported by Liu Shuyi
were defeated.
The situation is very serious.
You can see that everyone is looking down on Liu Shuyi.
Liu Shuyi didn't care about this problem at all.
Now, Li Ka-shing used a method
to respond to the refutation team.
What is the difference between responding to the refutation team and Liu Shuyi?
At that time, Liu Shuyi always quarreled with Liu Shuyi.
One day, when Liu Shuyi raised a problem,
Liu Shuyi treated Liu Shuyi as an enemy.
Liu Shuyi did not discuss with Liu Shuyi rationally.
Instead, Liu Shuyi treated Liu Shuyi as an enemy.
Liu Shuyi ignored Liu Shuyi.
If Li Ka-shing used this mentality
to respond to the refutation team,
would he repeat Liu Shuyi's words?
Of course, Hong Kong people
don't dare to speak so loudly.
But now,
do you want to suppress everyone's speech?
As a result, it will arouse more public opinion.
Will the situation be like a garbage collection?
When the government thinks
it has thought very clearly and done very well,
for example, the Ministry of Environment
will hold a 19-to-29-page
commentary on garbage collection.
The Ministry of Environment
even printed out a list
of Lebanese, Indonesian,
and Filipino people.
If you see a garbage can on the street,
it is not a CCTV
to warn everyone of the heavy punishment.
Or if there is no railing,
it will make a poster
for a temporary advertising
and publicity
near the light pole.
If you throw garbage,
the government will punish you.
Does the government think
it has done a good job?
In fact, the general public,
even the cleaners
in the hospital yesterday
have doubts
about how to deal with garbage
after garbage collection,
how to deal with garbage bags,
and how to deal with the garbage bags
that have just been sold.
These are all the results
But if the government
in the process of explaining
and even in the process of legal consultation
believes that I don't need to explain
or consult,
anyone who raises a problem
will challenge me.
And what I think is all right,
it is all irrefutable,
it is not allowed to challenge,
it is not allowed to question,
anyone who questions is my enemy,
so I have to refute him.
Is this a good attitude?
I have given all the articles
to everyone to see,
almost all the articles have been explained to the public.
The reason for the harmful relationship
between the articles,
the reasons for the legislation,
I have explained to everyone.
But everyone still thinks
that I have explained,
but everyone still thinks
that I have not heard,
But if ordinary Hong Kong citizens
raise a normal discussion opinion,
you should also refute this word,
that is, what anyone says
is not clear enough for me.
The articles I think,
the legislative principles I think,
or all the areas I think,
I think it is the most transparent,
I will not be wrong.
It must be wrong for you to raise a problem
and make a counter-suggestion,
it must not be good enough,
so I have to refute you.
I think there is a possibility
of a repeat of the past.
So I still hope,
we can't stop the 23 laws.
How will we change
among the 7 crimes?
For example, there are 1-2 crimes
in the National Security Law that have been repeated.
Or what is a rebellion,
what is a subversion of the regime,
what is incitement,
what is a divided country,
among the criminal acts,
the definition of illegal acts
is not included.
Why is it included?
For example, in the mainland,
the definition of violence
is not included
in the definition of incitement.
It only defines illegal acts.
Whether it is violence or not,
it will still be a crime.
This is also the truth of the society
at the time of the 23 laws.
Under what circumstances
should violence overthrow the regime
before it should be a crime?
We need to discuss this.
We also hope that the government
will announce the 23 laws as soon as possible.
If the 23 laws have not been announced
by the end of January or early February,
the 23 laws will be passed by June.
Even the legislative process,
whether it is 1st, 2nd, or 3rd reading,
whether the 2nd reading will pass the
3rd reading of the committee,
it may take 6-7 meetings to complete.
If the 23 laws are not announced
by the end of January,
even if it is by the end of March,
the 23 laws will not be announced.
If the 23 laws are passed by June,
it will be a very urgent process
and there will be no room
for social discussion.
So we hope that the government
will announce the 23 laws as soon as possible.
Don't treat those who have
an opinion on the 23 laws as enemies.
Don't try to refute them.
We should explain to everyone
and even have an open meeting
to discuss
under what circumstances
the 23 laws
may cause problems
in the future.
The government should have
an open meeting to discuss
and not use the attitude
of refuting the 23 laws.
It is also not the attitude
of completely failing
and falling apart.
Although many Hong Kong people
even the new generation
do not remember
or do not know
that the 23 laws
are very important
and no one will like them.
At that time, the 23 laws
were so unscrupulous
that they had to leave Hong Kong
and leave the government
to go to the United States.
You can see that
the 23 laws
made the society worse.
Even if the society
does not dare to oppose
the 23 laws,
how can the government
have an effective policy?
Because my family is far away,
I have more time to go out
or face some emergencies.
So I have more work
and more things to do
in the New Year.
So my live broadcast time
will be shortened.
I hope to finish it in an hour.
So I talk less.
I try to talk to everyone
and jump faster.
The purpose is
to finish it in an hour
so that I can take time
to do some things.
Maybe I will go to the hospital
at noon or afternoon.
Let's talk about COVID-19.
The cause of COVID-19
comes from the family.
During Christmas,
the couple got COVID-19.
They went to a nearby doctor
to see the doctor.
The couple saw two doctors.
The doctor noticed
that the couple was already
diagnosed with COVID-19.
But the doctor didn't give
the COVID-19 special medicine.
So the couple went to
another private doctor
to get the COVID-19 special medicine.
After taking the medicine,
the couple was no longer
diagnosed with COVID-19
for about 10 days.
The red line was gone.
The couple got better.
The couple also paid attention
to their father's condition.
For example,
if he coughed,
if he was tired,
or if he went out
to drink tea.
The situation was not that bad.
It was like a normal recovery.
We didn't hear him cough.
But sometimes,
he would cough.
We didn't pay much attention.
Although we kept asking,
we didn't realize
that the virus
was still attacking his body.
But the biggest problem
was that he didn't cough.
He just coughed.
The condition of his body
was not that bad.
It didn't affect his daily life.
It was like a normal recovery.
We paid attention to this.
We measured his blood oxygen level every day.
Recently, it has been cold.
We paid special attention to this.
About 3-4 days ago,
his father suddenly lost his appetite.
He didn't want to eat.
Of course, he didn't want to eat.
So we monitored his blood oxygen level.
His blood oxygen level dropped.
His fingers were very cold.
He couldn't move his fingers.
His blood oxygen level
Mass
