吳文昕：習故意摧毀經濟？中國退回毛時代 #港心•情

Hello everyone, I am Lily. Today's guest is the International Human Rights Advisor, Mr. Ng Man-Yen, an expert on China's issues. Hello, Mr. Ng. Hello, hello. Hello, everyone. Yes, China's economy is facing a great crisis. Is Xi Jinping deliberately destroying the economy and returning to the era of Mao Zedong? Yes, that's a good question. Recently, a lot of people have been talking about this topic. A while ago, about a week ago, a German newspaper, Frankfurter Allgemeine, published an article. The article said that the reason why China's economy is stagnating is because Xi Jinping deliberately delayed the development of China's economy. This is quite shocking. First, very few leaders deliberately delay the development of their own economy. Second, this statement comes from a French newspaper. Frankfurter Allgemeine is one of Germany's most important newspapers. It is one of the two major media outlets. The other one is called the Nuremberg Daily. Frankfurter Allgemeine, as everyone knows, is a financial center in Europe. It may be the fourth or fifth largest financial center in the world. This is really shocking. But I absolutely disagree. Xi Jinping's policy of delaying the development of China's economy, this is certain. This is well known. Everyone can see it now. His policy of national advance and national retreat, the three-year lockdown due to the pandemic, is also to delay the development of China's economy. China's national advance and national retreat. As everyone knows, most of China's state-owned enterprises are not doing well. Most of them are not making money. They are in deficit. You have to expand your state-owned enterprises, and then national retreat. Private enterprises have to retreat. This is what he did. Later, the three-year lockdown further delayed the economy. Why do I disagree? Actually, it's not like that. It's not that he delayed the economy on purpose. He violated the economic rules to do business. So the economy must be delayed. I just gave two examples. His policy of national advance and national retreat is completely against the economic rules. Because the fact is, the most profitable enterprises in China are all private enterprises. Alibaba, Douyin, Tencent, those big companies make a lot of money. They are all so-called private enterprises. I call them so-called private enterprises. What I mean is, they have the freedom to do business to a certain extent. They have the freedom to take full advantage of the market economy. But they have always been controlled by the Communist Party. Once the Communist Party thinks you are doing something wrong, it will immediately intervene. Do you dare to say no? Definitely not. So I say, Chinese private enterprises are like a dog's owner tied to a very short rope. A private enterprise is still held by the owner. But the rope is much longer. Maybe three times longer. But if you go in the wrong direction, the owner will also pull the rope. Within the scope of the rope, you have more freedom. This freedom is necessary. Otherwise, they can't make money. It is impossible to do business without freedom. So, they are against the principles of business and the rules of the economy. If you are for China's economic recovery, economic development, you should be just the opposite. You should push the country forward, not push the people backward. It should be the other way around. Then China's economy will definitely recover quickly. But they didn't do that. Why didn't they do that? First, they don't know much about the economy. But the most important reason is not that. The most important reason is that what they care about and want to do most is what? It is to dominate the world. That's why they want to push the country forward and the people backward. Because the state-owned enterprises are under their 100% control. They have a lot of power. If all these civil enterprises are pushed down, and all of them become state-owned enterprises, I will be more powerful. I will be more I will be more powerful. In fact, their strategy is very simple. As I said just now, they want to push all Chinese enterprises, all Chinese cultural figures, and all Chinese resources into the hands of the state-owned enterprises. What do they think they are doing? The civil society will be disobedient. For example, Ma Yun. When the Malaysian group and the KMT made a lot of money, he was getting more and more aggressive. He even dared to criticize the financial system of China and said it needed to be improved. He also said that after he retired, he would spend a lot of money to improve the education system for children in China. These two sentences can be said to be painful. It makes Xi Jinping very angry. Because if you criticize our financial system, it means you are anti-party. The Communist Party has always been in control of the children. Everything related to education must be under its control. So Ma Yun said that after he retired, he would spend a lot of money to improve the education system for children in China. He was very aggressive. In this way, China's economy can only slow down. Why does he want the whole country to listen to him? It's very simple. I just mentioned that he wants to be a dictator. Actually, it's like this. What is the idea of being a dictator? The whole of China must become an army. Everyone is a soldier. Different levels of soldiers, different missions. The whole of China is a big army. This is his ideal China. He is the commander-in-chief of this big army. He will come and go as he pleases. He thinks that because the Communist Party has always believed in one method, that is to say, the so-called superior socialism with Chinese characteristics. What does it mean? It means that we can concentrate the power of the whole country to solve problems. What he means is to turn the whole country into an army. Then we will be very strong. The U.S., although their weapons are more powerful than ours, and they have more money than us, but they are doing democracy. They can't just come and go as they please. The U.S. President has to be supervised by the Congress, reviewed by the media, and scolded by the media. How can that be? They can't just come and go as they please. Our China is not like that. We can concentrate the power of the whole country to solve problems. Then we can... Although we don't have as much money as you do, and we don't have as good weapons as you do, we can concentrate all our power to become an army to fight you. I am the army of 1.3 billion soldiers in the whole country to fight you, the army of 1 million soldiers in the U.S. Of course we will win. That's what he thinks. So, what is his idea? This is called the power concentration system. The power concentration system and the market economy are just the opposite. The market economy uses the flexibility and independence of each company. Each company considers what the market demand is. Is the market now unemployed or unemployed? To formulate a strategy which products should be produced more because they are unemployed and can make money and can meet the needs of the people at the same time. Which products are too much and will immediately reduce production? What he wants to do now is to create a planned economy. What is a planned economy? A group of so-called big experts, big experts of the Communist Party, sitting in a high position to consider the whole country's situation and decide how much steel industry should be reduced and how much paper industry should be reduced. What should be invested and what should not be invested. Don't do real estate. Real estate will not strengthen our military power. Don't do steel factories. In order to dominate the world, he thinks he is making the same mistake as Stalin. Now, Xi Jinping thinks the most important thing is manufacturing. Manufacturing. Everything is manufactured. He thinks that you should invest in it. But at the same time, he wants the country to advance and the people to retreat. He wants to listen to the Communist Party. As for other economic areas, for example, real estate. Real estate is not manufactured. He doesn't care. He doesn't care about the collapse of Hengdai and Bikgui. That's why China's economy is not good. Because his consideration is wrong. He doesn't want to develop the economy. He doesn't want to slow down on purpose. He wants to develop the CCP's military power on purpose. He thinks the best way is to organize the whole country into an army. He doesn't mean to make a whole army. He just wants the whole country… Because what is an army? The army never talks about democracy. What is an army? It requires you to obey the superiors. Absolutely obey. You can't even ask. If the superiors tell you to charge, then charge. You can't say, why do we have to charge? There is no such thing. This is the dream of Xi Jinping. With one command, the whole country will charge forward. But I am worried. For the Chinese, it is a great misfortune. Because a country is not an army. A country should be protected by the army. A country is like a family. It hopes to have a safe environment so that the whole family can live in harmony. A harmonious family. A country should be like this. For the people in the country to live in peace, to enjoy a peaceful and harmonious atmosphere, we need a strong army to protect the family. So that everyone can live in peace and harmony. This is the original idea. He doesn't have this idea. He doesn't think that the Chinese should live in peace and harmony. No. He wants to dominate the world. So he hopes that the resources of the whole of China, human resources and resources, will serve to conquer the world. This is the reason for the situation. He wants the country to charge forward and the people to retreat. He wants to implement absurd economic policies. Inevitably, the economy will be harmed. So the economy will be slowed down. This is the real reason. It is not that he deliberately slows down. This is what the German newspaper said. They believe that the stupidest economists should understand that this is wrong. This is damaging the Chinese economy. So he can't figure out why this is happening. So he thinks that he is deliberately doing this. I don't know why he is doing this. I don't agree that he is doing this on purpose. Inevitably, the economy will be slowed down. This is for sure. OK. This is the end of today's program. Thank you, everyone. Thank you, Mr. Wu. See you next time. Thank you. See you next time. Bye-bye.