許銳宇:港府財赤收移民稅?反令資金加速撤離

《看中國》香港頻道
2696粉絲
2 次觀看·2024年1月13日
🔥請加入乾净世界 https://www.ganjing.com/zh-CN/channel/1f6j576aqao3taCY3b7gv3NXG1540c<br>🔥請加入我們的Patreon,http://www.patreon.com/visiontimesHK<br>🔥請首選Stripe捐款:https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/donate.html<br>🔥請加入榮譽會員: https://www.secretchina.com/kzgd/subscribe.html<br><br>香港巨變、新聞自由日益收窄,同香港人一齊經歷過槍林彈戰嘅我哋,國安法後要面對更多嘅挑戰同打壓,加上FaceBook Youtube等嘅種種限制、黃標甚至關閉,「報導真相,揭露邪惡」變得越嚟越艱難。<br><br>不過,無論前路有幾咁艱難險阻,我哋永不忘初衷,荊棘路上繼續為大家深挖真相,還公民知情權!<br><br>感謝你哋一路以來嘅不離不棄,請繼續支持我哋,加入我哋嘅Patreon,成爲我哋嘅榮譽會員,願榮光早日歸於香港!<br><br>本視頻僅代表嘉賓或受訪者本人觀點。<br><br>聯絡我們 [email protected]
Hello everyone, I am Lily.
Today's guest is the former Hong Kong MP for Shatin District, Mr. Hui Rui-Yu.
Hello, Mr. Hui.
Hello everyone, I am Hui Rui-Yu.
It is now 11 o'clock in the UK.
Let me greet everyone first.
Yes.
Now, the Hong Kong government's fiscal budget has fallen to more than HK$600 billion.
It is less than 10 months short of the government's budget.
It has broken the lowest level since 1997 when the main power was transferred.
Many citizens have jobs.
What will happen if the government collects the increase tax?
Mr. Hui.
As you can see, Hong Kong's fiscal budget is now at the 5th year.
As you know, the Beijing government has been promoting
that Hong Kong is a city with a warm and positive atmosphere.
There is no way that the fiscal budget will continue to fall.
Will the Beijing government put more pressure on Chen Maobo
to solve the fiscal budget issue?
I think there will be political pressure.
So Chen Maobo is now thinking of a lot of ways to try to reduce the fiscal budget.
Politically, he can talk to the Beijing government.
This is certain.
But we have to look at Chen Maobo's political pressure and political demands.
What policies will he come up with?
We have to look at Chen Maobo's personal experience and personality.
If this person's personality is under political pressure,
what will he do?
As we all know, Chen Maobo is an example of a group of people in Hong Kong.
Hong Kong people know this.
Why did he say that?
Chen Maobo used to be very poor when he was young.
So he is very good at making money.
So he will do a lot of ways to make money.
In his career, he is a so-called social elite.
But he is not really in the academic field.
In the past, his academic achievements were not very outstanding.
He is not like Carrie Lam.
She was the top scorer every year.
She was very proud.
She wrote a lot about her goals and ambitions.
She is not that kind of elite.
So these two things combined make Chen Maobo
At this moment, I think he is a man with no achievements.
He is a man with no achievements.
He is a typical little Hong Kong boy.
He has a lot of friends.
I hope he can get some benefits in the middle.
So if this kind of person faces a political pressure from the central government
and asks him to reduce the fiscal system,
what will he do?
Because if you want to reduce the fiscal system,
it will offend people.
It will offend people for sure.
If you want to open it,
I just said that the host said that there is a tax on assets.
If you want to open it,
there are two main taxes.
One is the tax on the poor.
One is the tax on the rich.
The tax on the rich is traditionally a tax on the rich.
It is not a tax on the poor.
I will talk about what this is later.
The second thing is the so-called tax on the poor.
It is a tax that most citizens have to pay.
Now everyone has heard of it.
For example, the tax on water,
the tax on public rent,
the tax on garbage collection,
and even the tax on sales.
Everyone knows that there is a sales tax when they travel to Japan.
Why is it a sales tax?
It is for all citizens to collect.
And the amount collected by each person
may be the cost of daily living.
It is a tax on the poor.
I think Chen Maobao is not very offended by these taxes.
It will not offend some of the economic and political powerhouses
who have a lot of interests with him.
So it is most convenient to open the tax on the poor.
I think he will think of a lot of ways to collect.
So in the future, will there be a lot of tax on water,
sales tax, public rent?
If the financial system continues to have political pressure
from the Beijing government,
these taxes will come out slowly.
Everyone may have to start facing this problem.
These problems are mainly aimed at the so-called poor.
Another tax is the tax on asset growth.
One of the taxes that everyone pays attention to
is the tax on the increase in assets in the flow of rain.
If there are many citizens who have been selling rain for a long time,
the increase in the number is very exaggerated.
If you collect 10% or 20%,
this is a very large number.
But in the traditional sense,
the tax on asset growth,
especially in the flow of rain,
is the same as in the UK.
In fact, the people who collect
are those who own more than a second-tier property.
In the UK, if you own a property,
and you own it,
even if you sell it,
the money you bought
and the money you sold
is the difference,
even if you make money,
the British government will not collect your tax.
In fact, in Hong Kong,
there are more than 1.6 million people
who own a second-tier property in the private market.
These people actually own a second-tier property.
In theory,
the tax on asset growth in the traditional sense
will not affect these people.
But in Hong Kong,
for example,
people who own more than two-tier properties
are actually more than 900,000.
And these people include
their friends,
their middle- and high-level civil servants,
and their business partners.
If you do this,
if you really do this tax on asset growth,
do it in the most traditional way,
that is,
eliminating the tax on the property of your personal residence,
and collecting more than a second-tier property
tax on asset growth,
will offend all their friends,
and those who have a lot of money,
middle- and high-level civil servants,
will offend them all.
So if you say that Chen Maobo wants to do this tax on asset growth,
in terms of his personal character,
I think he will resist.
If he can not do it, he will not do it.
But for the poor people's tax,
he will do it more freely.
So this is a part of the source.
In terms of taxation,
it must be to reduce civil servants' salaries
or cut large government funds.
You know that if civil servants' salaries are cut,
it will offend civil servants' colleagues.
If you offend large government funds,
you will offend a lot of your colleagues.
Because a lot of people rely on large government funds
to make a living.
So,
plus Chen Maobo is a leftist,
and has a personality that does not want to offend people.
So I think he will do his best
in terms of taxation.
If you really want to tax,
you have to tax the poor and civil servants.
This is more in line with his personal character.
If Chen Maobo himself does not want to tax,
but the central government may impose a tax on him,
what should he do?
I think the Beijing government
must have a political mission for him.
He must reduce the number of civil servants at any time.
But you said that the Beijing government
clearly stated in which area
how much money you will cut,
how much taxes you will collect.
I don't think he gave such a specific instruction.
But many times,
the central government is worried about the issue of Hong Kong's immigration.
Whether it's the Hong Kong government or the Beijing government,
they don't like it.
Or they want to punish them.
Many times, the British BNO visa holders
can't get the MPF after coming to the UK.
So many people are worried.
Because many people left Hong Kong,
bought their own buildings,
and then brought the money to the UK or Canada.
Basically, the money will always stay in Hong Kong.
For this reason,
many pro-establishment parties think
that this money is the most prosperous time in Hong Kong,
which made them earn a lot of money.
Hong Kong has benefited you.
Now, at this moment,
you don't have the time to move the money to Hong Kong,
but to other places to contribute to their economy.
This is unreasonable.
So many people are worried
whether he will come up with something
to make these immigrants
receive their money.
From the asset increase tax we just talked about,
will there be some tricks
or some administrative means
to make it possible
to receive the so-called immigration tax?
Think about it.
There is a space for operation.
How to operate?
First, you know,
as I just said,
in the traditional sense,
the first floor,
that is, your own property,
will not be taxed.
Right?
But is there a way?
I believe that many immigrants
to other countries
actually sell their property
as their own property.
Theoretically,
even in Hong Kong,
in the future,
even if there is an asset increase tax,
it should not be taxed on them.
Right?
But if the Hong Kong government
has some administrative tricks
to make these people receive money,
what will they do?
I have thought about it.
There are two ways.
The first is to say,
OK, you sell the property in Hong Kong,
but you don't buy another new property in Hong Kong.
Then when you buy a new property,
you don't know
when you sold the first floor,
the Hong Kong government
received your asset increase tax.
Do you understand what I mean?
That is to say,
if the Hong Kong government
really collects this asset increase tax
for private housing in the future,
maybe it will
receive your asset increase tax
when you sell it.
But if it finds you
in Hong Kong,
try again,
buy a second floor,
it will give you
the asset increase tax
that you received
on the first floor before.
This is the first situation.
The second situation is that
you sell Hong Kong's
only residence,
in the case of an asset increase tax,
you still have to live in Hong Kong
for two or three years.
Even if you don't buy a second floor,
as long as you live in Hong Kong
for two or three years,
you can still get
the asset increase tax
on the first floor.
Because it is impossible
that even if the Hong Kong government
wants to increase
the asset increase tax,
it will not be able to
avoid the asset increase tax
on the first floor
of a private residence.
Why?
Because if you think about it,
you bought a house
very early on,
and now the house
has increased a lot of money,
you still have to live, right?
If you only have one private house,
after you sell it,
you buy a second floor in Hong Kong,
then you have to sell it
according to the current market price.
If you buy the first floor,
because the price of the first floor has increased,
the government will charge you a large tax,
then you don't have enough money
to buy a second floor,
which is a relatively equal-quality house.
So in terms of operating principle,
if a person continues to live in Hong Kong,
he is a private property,
the Hong Kong government
will not be able to charge
the asset increase tax
on the first floor of their private residence.
Because of this situation,
it will be difficult for him
to resume his career in Hong Kong.
So even if the Hong Kong government
wants to charge the asset increase tax,
I believe it is inevitable
that it must exempt some people
who have a private residence in Hong Kong
for them to live in.
This group of people
will be exempted from the asset increase tax.
This is inevitable.
But he will come up with some means
so that even if some people
have a private property,
Hong Kong people who want to emigrate abroad
can still receive their tax.
If some people want to emigrate abroad,
it doesn't matter if they don't have the right thing.
You have a house,
you are worried that the Hong Kong government
will use some administrative means
to charge you the asset increase tax
for that house as a residence.
The operability is the same.
He will set two conditions.
The first one is that
you have to buy a second floor house in Hong Kong
so that you can receive the asset increase tax.
Or you have to ask
if you want to live in Hong Kong
after you sell that house.
If these two conditions are met,
if he really wants to emigrate,
even if he buys a house,
he will buy it abroad,
not in Hong Kong.
And if he goes abroad,
he may not be able to live in Hong Kong
for a period of time.
In the end,
these Hong Kong people,
even if they want to emigrate,
in the end,
even if they sell
their only private residence,
they will not be exempted.
If he really wants to ask the Beijing government
to do more things
to target the so-called immigrants,
this thing has an operability.
But will this thing be done?
I don't think the chance is too big.
Even if he really does it,
it may be symbolic.
In the UK,
the tax on second-class residents
can go up to 18-20%.
It's a lot.
For example,
if you make 10 million,
you lose 2.5 million.
But in Hong Kong,
even if he really pushes the tax on second-class residents,
I think it's just a number.
For the time being,
it won't be too high.
It's also very likely
that he won't push it.
Because everyone knows
that he is a landlord.
He collects taxes for himself.
Many middle- and high-level civil servants
and many friends in the business world
own a lot of people.
They should own second-class property or more.
In fact, if the tax is raised too much,
it will affect them more than ordinary citizens.
In addition,
his wife and son are British.
So I think it's a very interesting phenomenon.
For example,
hundreds of thousands of Hong Kong citizens
immigrated to the UK.
It turns out that before each immigration,
they will be charged with immigration fees.
Your family is a British citizen.
He will also worry
if doing this will cause world poverty.
In addition,
Chen is a very dangerous person.
So try not to offend people.
People on the left and right sides.
Even if the central government
gives him a strong political pressure,
he will think about how to deal with it.
It's better to offend people.
Especially don't offend
some middle- and high-level civil servants
and some friends in the business world.
So I think the so-called real estate tax
should be collected as formally as possible,
at least in the first stage.
Maybe he will add one more thing.
He will make some administrative measures
to punish some Hong Kong immigrants
who will be charged with immigration fees.
Politically, we can take a good look at it.
Maybe he has a chance to do it.
But he won't charge too much.
Because if you charge too much,
you are punishing your friends
and yourself.
For him.
So from my personal point of view,
even if there is a real estate tax,
it should not be like the UK
to charge more than 10% or 20%.
Will the Hong Kong real estate tax
be greatly affected?
It will definitely be affected.
Even if it is charged
in a very formal way.
Think about it.
Some people charge very little in the beginning.
People will expect
to charge more in the future.
So some people who plan to emigrate in the future
must speed up the process
to sell their property.
In the future,
they will make some administrative measures
to force some people to emigrate.
In the future,
they may charge 5%,
15% or 25%.
In short,
if a real estate tax is charged,
no matter how little it is charged,
it will make people
want to leave the real estate industry faster.
And those who own more than the second floor
will be investors.
This will make investors
more cautious when selling their property in the future.
Because every time you make money,
it will be cut by the government.
And the future expectation is that
it will be cut more and more.
So this thing,
no matter how little you charge,
once you do it,
it will make the current real estate market
go up and down.
Think about it.
Why does the government have a fiscal deficit?
Because the government's income
after calculating the interest rate,
the second important tax
is the land income.
In the past, the real estate market
was so good that
they turned the farmland into residential areas.
They are not going to do it anymore.
If they make a real estate tax now,
no matter how little it is charged,
it will further hit the real estate market,
and further hit their financial income.
If this is the case,
it may be a loss.
On the political level,
they have the pressure
to reduce the fiscal deficit.
But on the economic level,
if they make a real estate tax,
will it really help the government's income
to bring the fiscal deficit back to normal?
I don't think so.
So I think
this is also a reason
why they don't dare
to make a real estate tax on a large scale.
I don't even think they dare to do it.
Because in terms of economic benefits,
it's not good to do this.
Yes, it's the opposite effect.
It's the opposite effect.
But if they can really
use administrative means
to collect the taxes
of those who will emigrate,
it's a good thing politically.
It's a good thing to the Beijing government.
If they can do it,
they won't have too much political risk
and won't offend too many
of their friends around them.
If they can do this, they will do it.
But if they have done it,
they won't do a lot.
It's symbolic.
In fact, I think it's
a way to push
foreign investment
or those who want to invest
in Hong Kong real estate.
Right?
That's for sure.
Think about it.
Basically, this real estate tax
is targeted at investors.
If you own more than
a second-tier property,
you will fall into
the tax net of this real estate tax.
So, the real estate market
is already going down.
If you make this real estate tax
further,
it will make the investment
in the real estate market
go down further.
It will make the real estate price
go down further.
There will be pressure.
Then real estate companies
won't dare to invest in real estate.
They won't keep the real estate price.
It will further reduce
the fiscal loss
of the Hong Kong government.
This is actually
a one-off thing.
Yes.
Even if it's a small amount,
I think it's a big sum of money.
Because the economy is so downtrodden now.
A small sum of money
may not be a big sum of money.
But,
for example,
if you make HK$1 million,
you will get 5%,
HK$50,000.
Many people can afford it.
But it will give the market
a signal that
this is just the beginning.
In the future,
there may be more and more.
There will be more and more
administrative institutions
to punish those who want to emigrate.
So, if you want to leave,
sell as soon as possible.
If you want to buy a property in Hong Kong,
and you see that
it has fallen to a price
that you think is worth investing in,
let these people recover.
Even if the real estate price
goes down further,
they don't dare to sell
the money they have in their hands.
Because they are afraid
that their income
will decrease more and more in the future.
Right?
In this case,
this is a Pandora's box.
You can't just open it.
If you open it,
it will bring
very troublesome consequences.
So,
this is where
Chen Maopao has to consider.
So,
I think this is
I am a rational person.
I don't think
he will
rush to
push for
real estate tax,
especially
when it comes to
real estate.
Yes,
if all the Hong Kong people
have left,
it seems that
the CCP
doesn't really
care.
If they
push for these taxes,
those taxes,
and now
there is
emigration tax,
etc.
If you emigrate,
you have to collect your taxes.
It is equivalent to
emigration tax.
Although there is no
name for it now,
right,
Mr. Hui?
Do they
not care
if you leave?
They won't
want you to leave.
But when you leave,
they won't
deliberately
make any measures
to keep you here.
For example,
Hong Kong people
left because
of the National Security Law,
left because
of the
police brutality.
They know
the reason,
but they won't
do anything
to reduce
the reasons
you don't like,
to keep you here.
If someone really leaves,
they will
send special forces
to replace
you.
That's
their idea.
Yes,
like they said,
if you leave,
you won't
stay.
If you don't
stay,
all the people
will leave.
They will
take the
mainland people
back.
The mainland people
don't have
much talent.
Because
Hong Kong
used to be
a financial city,
an international financial
city.
If the
mainland people
don't come down,
there won't
be this
brick wall.
What will
they do in the
future?
You have
to think about
it.
Nowadays,
some industries
in Hong Kong
can still
make money.
But
think about
three years
later.
Many times,
I tell my
friends,
if you really
want to emigrate,
you have to
think about
now.
Five years
later,
what will you
become in
Hong Kong?
Three years
later,
what will you
become in
other places?
Compare
your life.
Of course,
some people
in Hong Kong
can still
make money.
Their
careers are
good.
I think
they can
last
a while.
But
if
some
children
have to
work
in other
places,
they can
still
make a
living.
You
have to
think about
it.
You
can see
the financial
situation
in Hong Kong
now.
Many
experts
say
it
can't
last
forever.
It
is
hard to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
to
make
it
back.
It
is
hard
