🦶We review is Milk Good for You? Is dairy bad for you? Does Dairy cause inflammation? Does milk have protein? Is Whole milk good for you?🦶
Chapters: 0:00 Intro 0:17 Milk and Dairy 1:07 Top 10 Reasons 1:26#9 Environment 3:52#8 Hormones 5:09#7 Chronic Disease 5:51#6 Bone Health 7:16#5 Acne & Skin 8:14#4 GI Health 9:49#3 Nutrition & Does Milk Make You Taller? 11:27#2 Dairy or Milk Allergy 12:56#1 Lactose Intolerance 14:38 Is Milke Bad for You? 15:05 The Big Secret
DISCLAIMER: Dr. Tomasz Biernacki received his Doctor of Podiatric Medicine degree from Kent State College of Podiatric Medicine in 2013; he completed his Surgical Reconstructive Foot Surgery & Podiatric Medicine Residency in 2017; he completed 2x traveling Fellowships in Diabetic Surgery, Skin Grafting & Nerve Surgery. He is double board certified in Podiatric Medicine and Foot & Ankle Surgery. Dr. Biernacki is a licensed podiatrist & surgeon in Michigan. This video should not be used to self-diagnose and is not a substitute for a medical exam, cure, treatment, diagnosis, prescription, or recommendation. It does not create a doctor-patient relationship between Dr. Biernacki and you. It would be best to not change your health regimen or diet before consulting a physician and obtaining a medical exam & diagnosis. Always seek the advice of a physician or other qualified health provider with any questions regarding a medical condition.
This is Dr. Tom Biernacki
And today I'm talking about the top
ten reasons you need to stop drinking milk right now.
And the one big secret and we're going to count down from least important
to most important factors and we're starting now.
So I know that's a sensationalist intro.
And listen, I personally drink milk myself.
There's so many videos right now.
What are these guys talking about?
Why do we need to stop drinking milk instantly?
And as I look through the studies and the research, there's actually
some really good reasons that we should stop drinking milk,
but there's actually some good reasons we should drink it.
So I'm going to go over everything about milk.
Dairy products are present in cheeses, in yogurts and butter,
in creams, in milk, whole milk, skim milk, semi-skimmed
There's a ton of different nutritional profiles.
There is a lot of pros and cons to each one global dairy consumption
is 800 millions of tons annually.
This is so much money to every country's economies.
If we stopped drinking milk,
it would probably put whole regions out of business.
But here are the top ten reasons to cut out
dairy number ten cultural and personal preferences.
So a lot of people come from areas that don't support drinking milk.
Being a vegan, for example, there's more political reasons to this.
I kind of won't get into those right now.
Number nine, ethical and environmental concerns.
This is an extremely important decision for many, but not at all for other people.
This is such a complicated debate.
I've seen arguments about how bad cows are for the environment,
but then I've seen arguments saying the amount of corn
needed to supply the amount of calories that the cow would have is much more.
So there's arguments on either side.
It's hard to know
what the perfect answer is, but dairy farming has been a signifier.
Environmental footprint, cutting greenhouse gases, land use, water
consumption, the market for nondairy alternatives almond milk, soy milk, oat
milk has been growing rapidly, but at the same time,
look at what goes into almond milk that creates
even more pollution and leaves even more of a footprint.
So this is a fairly complicated argument, but this is probably a major reason why
a lot of these videos are talking about why milk is so bad for you.
So cultural and environmental reasons are so important for a lot of people.
I put them at the bottom of the list.
This is a medical channel. That's what I'm going to focus on.
I am not taking a strong stand one way or the other.
I'm just going over all the details and all the recent studies.
But local farms have a different footprint
than the big mega corporations that are popping up.
They are considered to be an excellent use of land
compared to some of the alternatives, like potentially almond milk
and the land use, while not perfect alternatives.
Are they any better?
We need our nutrition from somewhere
and milk is considered to be extremely good nutrition.
Your calcium, your vitamin D, your protein.
And from that standpoint, are the resources efficient?
have seen lots of good arguments from both sides, but unfortunately,
they both devolve into political talking points at the end.
who can forget cow farts?
This is a big argument saying cows contribute to climate change by farting.
There's actually a little bit of truth to this because they produce methane.
Let me know if you want a deep dive video.
This is such a complicated topic.
even saw an article that saying cows who eat seaweed in some farms
have like 90% less carbon and methane emissions.
Maybe that's the solution.
This could be an hour long video on its own.
Tell me if you want that made.
Hit me up in the comments, if that's more important for you, though.
I love hearing the feedback.
And you know what, you guys,
there's more of you watching some of these videos than these studies can pull.
So I love hearing your input.
Number eight, hormonal considerations, The impact of hormones in dairy
on human health is still a subject of research.
While potentially significant, it's less clear
cut compared to issues like allergies or lactose intolerance.
Concerns have been raised about the contamination of milk
with hormones, antibiotics, other substances.
The farming practices claim they're doing a very good job.
It's hard to know the answer for sure.
The exact impact nobody really knows.
The answer is they're really strong studies on this.
There is not What an exciting topic.
But good hormones are vitamin D, There is an insulin like growth factor,
but this has been proven to be degraded before it enters your body
and cows do have estrogen, but that type is inactive in humans.
seems to be a strong consensus that these are safe.
Now, on the other hand, the bad antibiotics are used
in the cattle industry, but this is not to speed up milk production.
It's to treat infections in the cow like,
for example, mastitis, which is the milk production area.
There is strict regulations and the FDA does measure levels randomly.
There are artificial hormones in the past
that have been used to stimulate milk production.
But these are heavily regulated now they are regulated by the FDA,
and heavy fines are carried out in most developed countries
the number seven chronic diseases.
The link between dairy and chronic diseases like cancer
is still being explored, but there's nothing definitive.
So some of these videos talk about this,
but there's nothing definitive towards cancer and milk or dairy.
This wasn't meant to be a set up,
but milk is actually unbelievably well-studied for heart health.
It's shown to lower stroke rates, blood pressure rates.
It's very proven for diabetes.
So people who drink it actually have less diabetes cancer rates.
It's been associated with decreased colorectal cancer
for bones, it's associated with less osteoporosis.
But it's not all rosy.
There is some association with potentially Parkinson's disease,
but that might be smaller statistics.
Number six bone health debate.
The relationship
between dairy and bone health is complex and there's not a perfect answer.
Milk is traditionally touted for the bone health due to its calcium content,
but some studies have questioned the extent of these benefits.
The Harvard School of Public Health notes that dairy intake is not necessarily
essential for good bone health, but at the same time, men,
the only thing I hear about the Harvard School of Public Health
is how much contracts from big companies are getting.
And man, they have not looked good in the news lately.
I don't think anybody could argue about that.
Tell me what you think about Harvard.
I looked through the studies and they are uniformly in agreement
that milk is really good for your bone health.
For example, very large scale studies with many.
I'm talking like 50 plus studies agree that the risk of hip fracture is way lower
and this is pretty much every single review article.
So how do certain people come up with these recommendations
that milk is bad for bone health?
The only thing that I can think of is politics
or some type of financial inducement.
Am I missing something?
Can anybody actually find me any strong or high level studies that are not
just observations or some type of polls which can be manipulated?
But the bottom line is milk has calcium, vitamin D, protein, phosphorus, magnesium,
and compared to other stuff like juices that people drink filled with sugar.
To me, this is the way a better option for my kids.
Number five, acne and skin issues.
This can be important for individuals who struggle with skin conditions
related to dairy, but it may not be universally relevant.
There is so much research on milk and skin conditions.
The good news is the consensus seems to be that sugary and fatty drinks
overall are linked to skin conditions, not just milk and dairy.
The bad news is a meta analysis showed that more milk drinking causes more acne.
But if we already know sugary drinks and fatty filled drinks
cause this, then I'd assume milk would cause it as well.
In further studies looking at cheeses and yogurt showed absolutely
no correlation because those might not have as much sugar or fat inside them.
The causes are thought to be IGF one, but
other studies showed that it's broken down before it enters our body.
So it's probably the sugar, the lactose, the fat.
And skin conditions are so complicated, it'd.
this one makes sense as the more calories and fat and sugar.
Number for digestive health.
Many people find that cutting out dairy improves their digestive health.
This is a very practical reason.
So if you drink milk and you get an upset stomach, this might be a great reason.
There's lots of beneficial bacteria and enzymes in the pasteurization process.
So a lot of the times the reason we drink milk historically
there was beneficial bacteria and enzymes present in milk, but with pasteurization,
this is a process of heating milk to kill harmful bacteria.
This also destroys beneficial bacteria.
And while the safety benefits of pasteurization are very crucial,
this loss might impact digestion benefits.
And the thing is, the milk we've solved to drink, it's
not necessarily the milk or drinking now.
It's cleaned, it's heated.
There's it's not as dangerous, but it's not the same milk we're meant to drink.
The extent of this is not known for certain.
The gut microbiome is so exciting, but the bottom line is
milk can have good effects and bad effects.
Some people don't have the right
GI back anterior and it can't digest lactose properly.
That's going to make you gassy.
And some studies show this, but other studies show cheeses, yogurts
and milk can actually make beneficial changes in the gut microbiome over time.
So some people are good, some people are bad.
The bottom line is, if you're not tolerating it well,
don't keep drinking it.
But if it's working, great for you, there's nothing bad about taking it.
My wife is a dietician, so she talks about this stuff all the time to me.
Check out some of our videos together on the gut microbiome and prebiotics.
Number three, alternative sources of nutrition.
Ensuring adequate nutrition is critical.
Dairy products are a key source of several important nutrients.
They are rich in calcium.
They're essential for bone health.
They provide vitamin D, potassium and other minerals.
But a lot of the times
during the pasteurization process, a lot of these vitamins are lost.
It does reduce the levels of certain vitamins like vitamin C, the B vitamins.
The reduction is a concern overall.
You're still getting a decent amount of vitamins in there.
But again, it's not as high as it was before.
And today with supplements, multivitamins,
there are ways to make up this deficiency.
In fact, check out my osteoporosis media, all my Vitamin D videos.
I go over just how to do that, how to measure your levels,
and how to make sure you're healthy in that regard.
Since my fourth kid is coming, I'm very focused on milk drinking right now.
But the good news is the studies are actually excellent.
There's a lot of child based studies for grade schools, for high schools
that kids who drink cow's milk have better dental health,
better stature, better bone health, better appetite control.
So there's a lot of positives, yet none of this stuff's 100%.
So I don't want this to be a crazy debate.
But the studies overall look very positive.
But the downsides are, is there lactose intolerance for kids?
Is there allergies for adults or kids?
What about protein?
Proteins, great in milk.
Calcium is great in milk.
The vitamins are great in milk, there's omega three fatty acids,
potentially in milk, although probably not in the most major of levels.
So milk overall is very beneficial from a nutritional standpoint.
The downside is what's your gut microbiome like?
Number two, allergies.
For those with dairy allergies, avoiding dairy is non-negotiable
and is essential for avoiding diarrhea.
Throwing up and feeling sick
Milk is one of the most common food allergens, particularly among children.
In fact, I remember at my school there was a mom
actually trying to get milk banned, which is crazy to me
because everybody drinks milk, every kid.
Additionally, lactose intolerance affects a large portion of the world's
population, leading many to seek dairy alternatives.
Some studies suggest that modern milk processing methods might alter milk
proteins in a way that can increase allergenic potential,
particularly in people who are sensitive or have a history of other allergies.
However, more research needs to be done on have a very close friend
whose son went through a really bad allergic reaction to milk,
and this can be very complicated.
He's seen allergy specialists and the diagnosis is very complicated.
They play it safe 99% of the time because
almost 5% of kids under three can have an allergy.
But the good news is most outgrow it by age 3 to 5.
The question is what kind of crazy doctor
would risk that kid drinking milk that could end your career?
So doctors are unbelievably cautious.
I know I would be.
You never want to be responsible for somebody having an anaphylactic shock
by recommending milk.
So I'm going to ignore the diagnosis by allergy specialists.
This is such a scary and legally dangerous topic.
this.
Number one, lactose intolerance as the most common, immediate concern
affecting a significant portion of the global population.
Lactose intolerance is a highly practical reason to cut out.
Dairy has a direct and clear impact on daily health
and well-being for those affected.
It's estimated that only about 35% of the global
population can adequately digest lactose.
The sugar in milk beyond infancy.
The ability to digest lactose in adulthood is a relatively recent evolutionary
adaption and was found mainly in people with European ancestry.
intestine does not digest lactose, then it makes it to the bacteria in your gut.
And they can create gas.
They can create some byproducts, some indigestion.
And for this reason, people confuse lactose intolerance with an allergy.
It's not.
This is why a lot more people think they have allergies than they do.
Some bloating does not mean you are allergic,
but on the other hand, lactose intolerance.
This is a very crazy statistic, but 68% of people around
the world can't digest all the lactose they drink.
European people, 28%, are lactose intolerant,
so most can digest a lot in Europe, whereas the Middle East
is much more likely to not be able to consume lactose.
But a meta analysis found that on average,
people can consume 12 grams per intake
before they get lactose intolerance so they can consume some.
But if you drink too much milk, eventually get some bloating, some gas.
Tell me your experiences.
Does it make you gassy?
For me, I drink a ton of milk.
I've never had these issues,
but I am from Poland, so potentially I'm in that European.
Lucky for you.
So the reality is most of the reasons you should cut it out
is if you don't tolerate it well, milk is pasteurized,
it's much safer, it's more commercially produced.
There is still some good vitamins in it,
There's still a lot of protein in and those are good reasons to drink milk.
And hey, I drink milk.
I don't drink as much as I used to.
I enjoy a cool glass of milk with a cookie.
Probably too much. I should cut that out.
I don't think it's good for me, but I enjoy it.
Here's the big secret on milk the economic impact,
the dairy industry is a significant part of the global agricultural community.
In the United States alone.
This is billions and billions of dollars and a ton of processing.
There's studies on both sides.
But the bottom line is, when I look through these videos,
they're either financially motivated or politically motivated.
That's what everything comes down to right now.
The bottom line is, if you're allergic, if you're lactose intolerant,
if you get diarrhea and don't drink milk, cut it out.
But if you enjoy it, the reality is, is this really worth the juice?
You're getting some protein,
you're getting some vitamins, vitamin D, some calcium, drink it in moderation.
It's not the worst thing in the world, but it's hard to know for sure.
Can you trust studies when 80 to 90% of people involved
are receiving funding from one source or another?
That's the tricky thing.
Now you have to use your best clinical judgment.
So tell me what you think. Do you drink milk?
Do you hate milk If you cut it out, did it help you?
Let me know in the comments down below.
I love hearing the feedback on this
and it makes a huge difference.
We sometimes get a better answer in the comments than some of these studies.