Siyamak sits down with Tuan Ngo, a small-scale housing provider in Oakland. Today, he'll share with us the challenges mom-and-pop landlords currently face because of the widespread abuse of current housing laws and regulations in Oakland. We'll also discuss how this situation is impacting the relationship between small landlords and tenants and the affordable housing market.
"Right now it costs $50,000 to $80,000 to evict a tenant. A lot of people still have not gotten rent. Some people owe $30,000, $40,000, to $50,000 in back rent from the three-plus years during the moratorium. And the lawyers, they'll say your place was not habitable for the last few years. So they force you to settle to give up that rent, and then they want you to pay for the relocation fees and the rent in the new place for six months."
--------------------
This episode is sponsored by: 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 Midas Gold Group, the nation’s No. 1 veteran-owned gold dealer and most trusted source for gold & precious metals: https://bit.ly/Midas-Gold/
Right now, it costs $50,000, $80,000 to evict a tenant.
A lot of people still have not get rent.
Some people owe $30,000, $40,000, $50,000 in back rent
from the three plus years during the moratorium.
And the lawyers, they'll say,
your place was not habitable for the last few years.
So they force you to settle.
To give up that rent,
and then they want you to pay for the relocation fees
and the rent in the new place for six months.
That's correct.
And waive like the three years of past rent that's owed.
My guest today is Twan Goh,
a small housing provider in Oakland, California.
Today, he'll share with us the challenges
facing small landlords due to widespread abuse
of current housing laws and regulations in Oakland.
We'll also discuss how the situation is impacting
the affordable housing market
and the relationship between small landlords and tenants.
Was there a moment you started noticing
that there's something wrong here in Oakland?
Because I do provide housing,
I have to know the new laws that are being passed.
And at some point I start to question,
wait, this doesn't really work.
So I started reading the legal language
and I see that it doesn't make sense.
And I'm like, who writes these things?
I'm Sinai Korami, welcome to California Insider.
Twan, it's great to have you on, welcome.
Thank you very much for having me, I appreciate it.
We wanna talk to you about landlords in Oakland
and there was an eviction moratorium
and you're a small landlord in Oakland
and people have been impacted.
And it seems like even though
this eviction moratorium ended,
things haven't changed much.
Can you tell us what's going on?
Yeah, the COVID-19 health-related eviction moratorium
lasted about three plus years
and it ended around July, August
in the Bay Area in Oakland.
But a lot of people still have not get rent.
Some people owe 30, 40, $50,000 in back rent
from the three plus years during the moratorium
so they don't have that money.
They go to the lawyers and the lawyers
are a little bit unscrupulous and say,
well, you know, just don't pay that rent
and we'll just go to court and that could be months away
or up to a year process.
And during that process, the lawyers kinda work their magic
and throw a lot of legal paperwork at you
and basically force you into a settlement.
So the tenants go to the lawyers
and the lawyers tell them, let me show you how to-
Work the system.
And can you tell us some examples or how it works?
Yeah, so I was just talking to a friend yesterday
and his tenant hasn't paid for all this time
during the moratorium.
And now the tenant is claiming
that the plumbing doesn't work,
the windows don't work, the doors don't work,
there are rodents and mold and mildew,
everything you can imagine and say,
well, you know, you're not really providing housing
like you're supposed to according to the law
and so now, you know, I don't have to pay
and what the lawyers are gonna ask,
which they do to everybody,
is you're gonna have to waive the three plus years
of back rent that's old,
that you have to pay whatever the amount
they want to ask for, it's like 16,000 or 10,000,
whatever the negotiated amount is for relocation
to find another place and they want you to give
three or six more months of free rent
so that they could find another place
and most people are so desperate,
they will settle and they will lose the 40, $50,000
or $80,000 and that's their retirement savings
and it's just really unfair
because they provided a housing service
for all these years and worked hard
and just was not compensated.
So that we're clear,
because this is a little bit strange,
the lawyers are coming to the tenant,
they're guiding the tenants to say to the landlord,
don't pay the three years that you owe
and then also tell the landlord
about the problems the house has
and then take them to court
and then the landlord has to pay for you
to move somewhere and your six months of rent
and forgive all the previous few years.
After the eviction moratorium ended
and people owe all this rent,
the landlord or housing provider
usually work with the tenant
to see if they can get current
or just start, most of them ask the tenant
to start paying rent and go on a payment plan
for the back rent owed.
Some people would work with you
and that's the ideal situation
but there's a lot of people who know
that if they go to tenant lawyers,
most of them are pretty unscrupulous.
They have a standard form
and how they respond to your request to pay rent
is they'll say your place was not habitable
for the last few years
and that you ignored all these problems,
habitability problems, mold, mudu, rodent infestation
and so that you really shouldn't get that rent
because your place was not up to legal standards
so they force you to settle.
To give up that rent
and then they want you to pay for the relocation fees
and the rent in the new place for six months, is that?
That's correct
and waive the three years of past rent that's owed.
And people settle with them?
It's all about money.
They figured a way to get funding
and they get funding from the county
so the tenants get free legal representation
but landlords have to pay lawyers three, four, $500
or more every hour out of pocket
and the tenant lawyers,
they know that you don't have money for representation
so they'll drag out the legal process.
They'll do a discovery
to just see what's really truly going on with your unit
and they'll drag out the negotiation process
and you know if you don't settle right now immediately
and then you allow the other side to drag it out,
you'll just be 10, $20,000, easily more in the hole.
So everybody knows that it's wrong
but they have no other choice.
In a way, it's sort of like a blackmail, extortion.
And most of these landlords, you're one yourself,
like who are these landlords that are in Oakland?
Most housing providers, they're not rich.
The narrative is if you provide housing,
you must be super rich
and that you're a big real estate speculator
and you come in from outside the community
but no, most of us live there.
Many people don't speak English
and so they don't invest in stocks
and how they help provide for their family
is they buy a house, they put down a down payment
and they have a monthly mortgage on it that they pay
and then they work with their hands to provide housing.
That means they do the painting themselves,
they do the plumbing themselves,
they do the landscaping, they do the roofing
and they do it on the weekends and after hours
and that's how, with their labor,
they're able to get a little bit of extra money every month
to support their family, to send their kids to college
and to provide the next generation opportunities
that they never had.
So it's really a way for people to spend extra hour
from their main job to provide for their family.
Most people, that's how they save up for an essay
just over time, over years,
that they could, all of their hours and efforts
would add up and they would have something
so that they could care for themselves in their old age.
You guys call them housing providers
because I think landlord has this connotation
that these are like big owners, right?
It has such a negative connotation
and it distorts the picture to make it look like
you're a big outside real estate speculator
and you're just there for the money.
But you really are providing a service
and a lot of us are not lord,
we use the landlords of this old feudal terms,
we're not lords and we don't really truly own the home.
We basically have a mortgage, maybe the home's a million,
but you have a mortgage that's 800,000
and you put down 150,000 and every month you pay the bank
and the bank pay the people who build it
and you're not any lord,
you're not born with this title of some land
and a lot of women are also doing this too
so the term landlord is also a little bit sexist
and it's much more accurate to say that you provide housing
because that describes the labor that goes into this.
If it's easy, everybody would do it
but you really have to sacrifice your weekends,
your days and if somebody calls you in the middle of the
night because they forgot their keys
or the toilet stops working, you gotta be there and on it
and you have to be committed.
And you know, small housing providers,
they spend a lot of time and they underestimate
how much time it costs to actually paint
or to actually fix a roof and underpay themselves hugely
compared to say a non-profit that would provide this housing
they're much more inefficient because they have
overhead costs like office staff
and they would hire a plumber instead of doing the work
themselves and it usually costs maybe three times more
to provide the same quality housing.
So small mom and pops are able to pass on the cost savings
and offer lower rent and we need to save this
because to solve the housing crisis,
we really need to support and preserve
the most efficient way of delivering low cost,
affordable housing and there's no more efficient way
to do it than to have local residents who are willing
to work on weekends and after hours to save money
and charge lower rent than all the other housing models.
Anything run by the government is gonna cost you
two or three times more and a non-profit
still has to pencil out because they're so inefficient,
they have to exempt themselves from paying property taxes
and they also tend to evict more than small mom and pops
because they have to make their numbers.
Now Tuan, was there a moment you started noticing
that there's something wrong here in Oakland
with the housing laws and the tenant representation?
My background is not necessarily in housing,
I'm in science and biology and I do research
to do cancer drug development
and I wasn't really paying attention to the local laws
because I do provide housing,
I have to know the new laws that are being passed
and at some point, I start to question,
wait, this doesn't really work.
So I started reading the legal language
and I see that it doesn't make sense.
So then I consult with other people
and I'm like, who writes these things?
So I start showing up at City Hall
and read more and then I realize
that it's really money behind it
and a lot of it is just unscrupulous lawyers
who sell this narrative, this false narrative
that if we pass this new onus regulation
that supposedly protect tenants
but it's really a Trojan housing regulation
that benefits the lawyers and their special interests
because as you follow the money,
they're extracting money from local housing providers.
That money goes into the pockets of lawyers.
The settlement to cost,
each settlement could be 30, 40, 50,000 or more.
The lawyers also get millions of dollars
from the various cities and the county
supposedly to protect tenants with these regulations
but they don't work because we have really high rent.
If all these laws that we had,
like rent control, for decades we had it,
if it really worked, you would expect rent to be lower
but average rent is higher.
A few people that got into the unit, they benefited
but the people who want to move into the area,
the younger generation, rent is really high.
Nobody wants to build in Oakland
because they can't get the return on their money
so people invest in other areas
and we don't really have the resources we need
to grow our economy, to provide cheaper housing,
to have options for renters.
And some of these laws were supposed to protect the tenants
from bad landlords.
I think if you look at the high rent that we have,
the fact that most people can no longer offer housing
and that tenants are not served by these laws
that supposedly help them,
you would say none of them really work.
I mentioned rent control but just cost,
it says if a tenant moves into a place
at the end of the agreed upon contract term,
you really cannot evict somebody
and that actually is an interference in the market.
I agree that there are some protections that are needed
but when you go to the extreme
and nobody is offering housing,
nobody's willing to build an ADU in the back
because they're afraid that if they find somebody
and things don't work out, they can't part ways,
like any relationship.
If it doesn't work, one party should be able to walk away.
So nobody's building an ADU in the backyard
or converting part of the house, a garage,
into another rental unit despite the shortage of housing
because the laws are not friendly.
This episode is sponsored by Midas Gold Group.
Do you feel the bills are getting higher and higher
every time you check out the grocery store?
Do you feel your monthly discretionary money has decreased?
Although your income increases yearly,
inflation is eating away at your wealth.
Digital wallets and central banks' digital currencies
are destroying financial privatization also.
Only gold and silver are constitutional forms of money.
Our privacy was to be protected
against unlawful watch and seizure.
Midas Gold Group will help you
take control of your finances
and protect your wealth and your privacy.
Pulling money out of the questionable banking
and investment system is the way to privatize your finances
as the elite push us towards digital wallets
and central bank digital currency.
Protect your wealth with real money.
Deal with the best at Midas Gold Group,
a proud America first company, midasgoldgroup.com.
Click on the link below and check them out.
Now let's go back to the interview.
So from what you're saying,
it seems like these laws are protecting the bad actors
in a sense.
The state actually was gonna cover for this rent, right?
So didn't the state was gonna cover
for these three years apparently?
So there is rental assistance from the state
and also from the federal government.
But the rental assistance is nowhere near the amount
of rent that was lost during the pandemic.
In Alameda County, not excluding Oakland and Fremont,
they gave out 130 million.
But we estimate, I've heard estimates
that the amount of rent that is lost
could be 600 million to 900 million.
When you apply for rental assistance,
they only accepted people in Oakland who was low income,
who earned 20% of the area median income.
So for a single person,
your annual income is about 40,000 or less.
Then you qualify.
If you make more than that,
then you don't get rental assistance.
But when they passed the eviction moratorium,
they made it very broad so that people who are a doctor,
a lawyer, or someone who earns,
like you could earn a million dollars and say,
hey, I was impacted by COVID.
And then you just don't have to pay rent
and you get to self-certify that.
The loopholes were so broad,
were so big that you could drive like a truck through.
They allowed widespread abuse.
And so people who don't qualify for rental assistance,
who are earning a lot of income,
they could refuse to pay rent
and there's no consequence for that.
You have been pretty active speaking about this, right?
At city councils, right?
Yeah, because I work with a lot of the immigrant community.
At one point, one of them even went on a hunger strike
because he didn't receive rent
and he was owed $120,000.
And he has a family to take care of
and he had to pay for college.
And it wasn't just him,
but it was like everybody in Alameda County.
A lot of people, a lot of families,
a lot of seniors lost their retirement savings
and faced foreclosure and they didn't do anything wrong.
And they provided a service for years and years
and none of that labor was compensated.
If you walk into a restaurant
and they ask you to just provide a service
and you don't get compensated,
in the meantime, you have to pay the bank,
you have to pay property taxes,
you have to pay the utility bills and you're left hanging.
So people were pretty desperate.
And in this case,
you guys have to pay them to leave, right?
If they say, hey, my plumbing is not working,
by law, you were required to provide housing
that is habitable.
So you have to show up
and you have to fix the plumbing and pay for that.
You have to pay for property taxes,
even though you're not collecting any rent.
Even though they don't pay you any rent,
you still have to go and fix all of their problems.
That's correct,
because legally you're bound to provide housing
that is habitable.
It's completely unjust and unfair
that they force housing providers
to provide a service without any compensation.
We have seniors who don't have any money
to buy prescription medication.
It was a very bad situation.
That's why we have somebody
who was forced to go on a hunger strike.
And the community showed up in great numbers.
These people are working folks.
They normally don't rally or anything like that,
but they were really hurting.
And the damage to the housing,
this is the eviction moratorium
and the broad abuse that happened with it
is resulted in the greatest destruction
of affordable housing for us in Oakland
and in the Bay Area.
Now, Thuan, how does all this make you feel?
I think it hurts the entire community.
Not only is it just unfair
to the people who provide housing service,
it also hurts renters,
because now nobody really wants to invest locally
to provide housing,
and we have a housing shortage.
And so that means there are less options
if you're a renter,
less availability of places to rent.
And when there's scarcity, rent also goes up.
If you guys, the mom and pop housing providers
and lenders are gone, who takes over?
If we sell, there will be large outside
real estate investors who would buy.
And they tend to charge higher rent.
They are less efficient.
They have office staff, just like nonprofits.
And they raise rent as soon as the law allows it.
They will raise rent quicker,
and they'll evict much faster.
And that's kind of known.
Most people who are small mom and pops,
like somebody who has a duplex
and rent the unit next door,
tend to work with the people that they know
and are very reasonable.
But if it's a big corporate owner who owns it,
they're more likely to just file the paperwork
and evict them.
Now, are you worried yourself for your units in Oakland?
Everybody is very worried because you're at risk.
You could be sued at any time.
There's a lot of legal exposure
because it just takes one bad actor
to use all these laws against you.
Right now, it could cost $50,000, $80,000
to evict a tenant.
And nobody wants to evict a tenant.
It's sort of like the last resort
because it doesn't make sense
if you provide housing to fire your client.
I have a renter who hasn't paid rent for years.
And she has Section 8.
So Section 8 covers most of it, about 90%.
And she paid the remaining 10%.
And I just have been working with her,
and I haven't evicted her or anything like that.
And I said, please, when you can, save up and pay me back.
And I think most people who provide housing
would do the same.
What made you do that?
She's a mom, and she has younger kids.
Everybody understands we're all human.
And if you can help somebody, why not?
But I also don't want to be taken advantage of.
But if it makes sense and you can help somebody else,
why not?
Why not work with other people?
And that's just very common
in the community that provide housing.
Now, do you think these laws have made landlords like you,
housing providers like you,
kind of more afraid of working with people?
Like it's shifted from, you wanted to work with the tenants
to now you have to be more careful and watch,
be more legal, be more savvy.
That's absolutely right.
Before they passed Just Cause,
people are willing to take risks.
They're willing to rent to whoever and give them a chance.
But after they passed Just Cause and make it impossible,
when you have somebody move in,
it's impossible to part ways if there's a problem.
People don't want to take risks.
And so they take the units off the market.
They rent it out to family
instead of taking a risk with a stranger.
So that ended up hurting tenants,
especially the tenants who need to have a second chance,
who might have just moved out of jail
and want somebody to give them an opportunity
to show that they could be a good citizen
and be a part of the community.
Now people are like,
oh, well, if this person move in and they bring trouble
and I can't part ways with them,
why would I expose myself to that risk?
Especially if I have a duplex or a triplex,
why would I put my family and my kid in danger
if this person doesn't work out?
Now in terms of the immigrants,
you're an immigrant and there's a lot of immigrants
in this landlord community.
Do you think their perception of our country,
this country, U.S. has changed
or do they get upset about what's going on here?
Is it hard to believe this is happening to them?
In the U.S.?
It is.
George, who went on a hunger strike, for example,
came from China and he came here for opportunities
and freedom to provide for his kids
the opportunities that didn't exist.
And he appreciated the freedoms here.
And he came here and he could not believe
that the government here is worse than a communist country
where you wouldn't be forced to work
and not get paid for years.
For a lot of the immigrant,
it's not really the American dream that they were hoping.
And it's become what they say is a nightmare.
Now, have you talked to the city leaders?
What's the perspective on the city leaders?
Do they listen to you guys?
We rallied and protested and made public comment
and we were largely ignored for three plus years
until we showed up in greater numbers
and they could no longer justify having
the COVID-19 health-related eviction moratorium
for years and years.
And then they also had a lawsuit
challenging the legality of basically forced labor
without pay for years.
So they were at risk and everybody was showing up
at a council, filled the chamber full
and was yelling at them.
We weren't holding pitchforks, we were holding signs,
but the message was very clear that what they were doing
was wrong and was hurting people
and it was not outside large speculators in real estate,
but community members, immigrants, seniors,
longtime residents.
These are the people in the faces that provided housing
and we spoke very strongly and clearly
and they were forced to end it.
Before we continue, we would like to thank Shen Yun
for sponsoring this channel.
I lived in China for two years
and experienced two different Chinas.
One is the China we know now, unfortunately with communism
and the other is ancient Chinese culture
with 5,000 years of history, strong values,
ethics and morality that has been lost.
Shen Yun Performing Arts is reviving this 5,000 years
of Chinese traditional culture.
It takes you back in time to magical world of ancient China
with a unique blend of brilliant dancing,
beautiful customs and legends coming to life.
Go to Shenyun.com to find out the schedule
and theater information.
It's a lifetime experience you don't wanna miss.
Book your tickets today.
Now let's go back to the interview.
You know, Tuan, a lot of the laws
that you guys are facing in Oakland
is spreading towards the rest of California.
Do you have any recommendations for Californians?
Don't do what we do because we're not the shining example
that you want to follow.
We're not that shiny city that you wanna model after.
Our laws don't work because rent is high in Oakland
after years of these laws.
We have a homeless problem.
We have a fentanyl addiction problem.
We have trash everywhere.
We have a crime wave going on.
This is not the laws that you want to pass
to govern your city.
This is not going to bring business.
This endangers the community where, you know,
your family could get shot and mugged and assaulted.
Our city leaders have failed us in so many different ways.
So when it takes regular people like me
who have very busy lives to show up at City Hall
in mass numbers, you know that there's something wrong.
And you could see it on the street.
Anybody who visits us, we're known statistically
for our murder rates, for the crimes that happen.
They steal cars and they break the windows
and then they ram the cars into shops
and take out the vault from the restaurants.
All the restaurants in the city, a lot of them are closing.
A $50 meal, if you park there on that strip,
all the cars in that strip are broken into
and then all of a sudden it becomes a $550 expense
because you have to have insurance deductible
and you're dealing with insurance folks.
So a lot of restaurants are hurting or closing.
They cannot get insurance to cover their business
because who could cover a business
that gets broken into every other week?
And every time it gets broken into,
it's not just the cash that's stolen
and nobody really puts cash in their store
at the end of the night,
but it's the damage to the property.
So there's an exodus of people offering insurance in Oakland
and when one anchor store goes down
because they can't get insurance,
they take 25 other businesses with them.
So it ripples outward.
Now, Tuan, what is a perfect relationship
between landlords and tenants
or housing providers and tenants?
There would be less interference and less over-regulation.
I think we have to respect contracts between two adults
and if things don't work out, then you can part ways.
If, for example, you find a place and you rent
and there's habitability issues,
you could complain to the inspector.
You could complain to OSHA or have other ways of remedy
and not need this other layer of regulations
written by lawyers with triple damages
with all these consequences that make lawyers money
but offers less housing for tenants, higher rent,
and then excludes over small mom and pop
local housing providers who are working hard,
who are immigrants, who need a pathway out of poverty.
Ideally, the perfect relationship is
if it doesn't work out, you can part ways.
I think it's important for people to appreciate
that this is really a battle between David and Goliath
and housing providers are being taken advantage of
by lawyers and politicians and special interests
and the system doesn't work and it's usually unfair
and it harms not only the housing providers
but also renters because now nobody wants to provide housing
And it seems like, from what you're saying,
it seems that good tenants are gonna get more rules
from the housing providers and landlords.
So now you have to prove that you're a good tenant
but then the ones that didn't pay rent
and they wanna game the system,
they're gonna win along with the lawyers
that are representing them.
Yeah, so you're rewarding for bad behavior and abuse.
The policies that was adopted just had large loopholes
and they don't work.
Do you have a message for the state leaders?
Because a lot of the state leaders,
they do care about the people, they care about the renters,
they care about, what is your message for them?
If you don't want Oakland's problems,
don't adopt Oakland's policies.
They don't work, they harm the entire community,
they take away opportunities, they hurt the working class,
the immigrants, the seniors, the blue collar workers.
They don't allow people to truly own
and they don't allow you to work hard
and have an upward pathway out of poverty,
social mobility upward and provide for your family.
Thuan, when you got involved
and started talking about this,
were you worried that this is,
you're kind of going to public?
What was it like?
You know, I was always an introvert
and I just enjoy reading
and I usually don't try to get into trouble.
I enjoy my privacy, but now,
because I show up at city hall and I speak out
because I see injustice and I see dysfunction of our city,
I'm recognized a little bit more.
I lost some of my anonymity,
but I think at some point,
when you know something, you should act
and if you see something that is not right,
you should be able to speak up and help fix the problem.
Thuan Ngo, an Oakland housing provider,
was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you so much for having me.
I appreciate the time here.
If you haven't checked out CaliforniaInsider.com,
we highly recommend you do that now
because we're going to have a lot of news and videos there
and on top of what we have there right now,
we are building a really big platform
to cover what's happening in California.
So you can be informed.
We're going to have more shows, more videos
from all aspects of life in California.
Go to CaliforniaInsider.com and we'll see you there.