Homemade Irish Cream | BAILEYS RECIPE

Momma's Refreshments
442 followers
Welcome to Savage Kitchen.
Today, we are going to be making homemade Irish cream.
You might be familiar with this guy, Bailey's Irish Cream.
I'm a big fan.
I think this is delicious.
But it's also very, very easy to make at home.
It's a little more cost-effective.
You can also play with flavors
once you get your combination right.
So let's get into it.
All right, first things first, tools you're gonna need.
You're gonna want a blender or an immersion blender is fine,
some measuring cups, and a bottle or a large mason jar
to put everything into when we're done.
For our ingredients, choose your whiskey of choice.
I suggest an Irish whiskey.
I also suggest Jameson.
I, as y'all know, I love whiskey, hence the shirt.
I love bourbon, but Jameson was actually
my gateway into whiskey.
I think it's fantastic.
They have a lot of different offerings now,
but just your regular old OG Jameson will do the trick here.
Then you're gonna want some chocolate syrup,
sweetened condensed milk.
Don't at me on this one.
I get it, I don't use a lot of processed foods.
But in this, you're either gonna have to add
a lot of sugar or sweetened condensed milk.
I think the sweetened condensed milk
lends a better texture to the overall drink
than adding sugar, so I suggest this.
Then for our dairy component,
you can either use cream, heavy cream, or half and half.
I personally like to use half and half
because I think the texture is closer to Bailey's.
If you want it to be a little bit more rich and decadent,
you can use cream, and also depending on
if you start playing with these ratios
and thinning it out with other liquids,
you might wanna use the heavier cream
so that you have a thicker consistency
when it's all said and done.
So we have two secret ingredients here.
One is instant coffee granules.
Now, I don't drink instant coffee,
but I was very pleasantly surprised
to see that Folger sells these packs.
They're 99 cents, and they come in
these little single-serving packs,
so it's perfect for something like this
where you might not wanna buy a big thing of instant coffee
and not spend too much money.
And then finally, in a lot of recipes you find online,
you're gonna see them calling for vanilla.
Nothing wrong with putting vanilla in this.
But the real trick to get it tasting just like this bottle
is actually almond extract.
This takes it from, mm, that's close,
and that's really good, to, oh my God,
I can barely tell the difference.
Get yourself some almond extract.
First thing we're gonna do is mix
our sweetened condensed milk and our whiskey.
Tried this a lot now, and Irish cream will tend
to separate in the refrigerator, which is totally fine.
You can just shake up the jar.
It's not a big deal.
But if that bothers you, kind of bothers me,
if you blend together your sweetened condensed milk
and your whiskey first,
it's not gonna separate as much on you.
Next up, we are going to take a cup
and 2 3rds-ish of Jameson.
Yeah, maybe a little more.
Close enough.
Oh, it smells so good.
I genuinely, I love Jameson.
All right, now before we add anything else,
we're gonna blend this up.
Okay, next up, two tablespoons of chocolate syrup.
I have this ginormous thing of chocolate syrup
from the chocolate incident of 2K22,
which I will link above.
Roughly two tablespoons.
You know, I don't really love to measure here,
so why start now?
That's probably a tablespoon.
That's probably two.
So this gives hints of chocolate
and gets us closer in color to the Baileys.
Then we're just gonna take half a teaspoon
of the instant coffee granules.
I know that doesn't seem like a lot,
but stuff's potent.
A little goes a long way.
You can do this with just plain black coffee,
or if you really wanna be fancy,
if you have some Mr. Black,
I would add maybe half a cup of Mr. Black.
But if you do that, start with a heavy cream
because your overall consistency
is gonna be a little thinner.
So I'm just taking half of this packet,
which is about half of a teaspoon.
Now we're gonna take about a teaspoon of almond extract.
I will actually measure this one.
You can add vanilla extract also if you would like,
but honestly, I don't think it's necessary.
I think the flavor gets kind of lost.
There's a heavy vanilla component
to the sweetened condensed milk,
so just a little bit of almond extract is gonna do ya.
And then we're gonna use half and half
because this is my personal preference for this.
We're gonna do one cup.
You could also split it and do half, half and half,
half heavy cream if you wanted a non-dairy version.
You could do this with coconut milk
and then sweetened condensed coconut milk
or add sugar instead of the condensed coconut milk.
You got a lot of options here.
I haven't tried it with soy milk or oat milk.
Those might be okay.
I don't know.
Unless you're lactose intolerant,
I think you should kind of go with the OG here.
Is that everything?
Oh, smells really good.
All right, blend it up.
Now you don't wanna go too long with the blender
or the immersion blender on this
because we're not making whipped cream.
You just wanna make sure
that those instant coffee granules have dissolved
and all of our ingredients are incorporated.
Okay, into the bottle we go.
This is deeply satisfying.
That is looking just about right.
Ooh, it smells good.
All right, let's do a little taste test comparison,
shall we?
And it's a shame, really, this should be a blind tasting,
but I'm flying solo today,
so you're just gonna have to make do with me.
Okay, original Bailey's,
which by the way, Bailey's comes in
all kinds of fun flavors now.
I love the original.
Mint is pretty good,
but I think you're gonna be hooked on this homemade version.
Ooh.
Feel pretty good about this.
So right away, there's a slight color difference in hue,
not saturation, if we're talking photo editing terms.
The Bailey's has a slight orange tint to it
where this stays more in the white to brown realm.
So the reason for that is that Bailey's uses caramel
to flavor their beverage.
So if you look up the history of Bailey's,
this is actually a relatively new spirit.
This was developed in the early 1970s
and they talk about combining Irish cream,
Irish whiskey, burnt sugar, caramel,
and so that's where you're getting
some of that caramel color from.
Now, they also say other flavors,
including vanilla and chocolate,
so that's why in this version,
we added in that almond extract,
because to me, that is what comes most close
to the flavors that we get in the original Bailey's.
Okay, so let's taste this one first, OG Bailey's.
It's so good.
I find this very comforting.
It's really good.
People also tend to think of Bailey's
as like a cold weather treat only.
Nay, I say.
I love this in the summer
over vanilla ice cream as an affogato.
Delicious.
Also in a boozy milkshake, real good.
All right, so let's try our homemade version.
So good.
I would think,
I think anybody would have a really hard time
telling these apart.
You know, for me, I have this, you know,
there's no cognitive disconnect for me.
I just made it so I can taste
every single ingredient I just put in,
but really, if you step back for a minute
and just taste them, they taste almost identical.
The texture is just about the same,
meaning the mouthfeel is the same,
the flavors are the same,
that warm Irish whiskey burn is the same.
Real good.
All right, homemade Bailey's.
Let me know if you try this.
And also, don't be afraid of variations.
If you really love coffee flavors, add more coffee.
If you want it to be more chocolate, go more chocolate.
If you want to add mints, coconut, whatever you want to do,
this is a great way to experiment
with making your own liqueurs.
So make sure to like, comment, subscribe,
do all the YouTubey things.
If you want your own whiskey shirt,
you can go to Savage Kitchen.
I'll put a link below.
Those are for sale on my website.
And I'll see you guys next time.
Cheers, friends.
