🦶We review the BEST magnesium supplement: magnesium glycinate benefits vs magnesium citrate benefits vs magnesium oxide benefits vs magnesium threonate benefits?🦶
0:00 Intro 0:23 Magnesium Deficiency Symptoms 2:39 Causes 3:30 How much magnesium per day? 4:07 Side effects and how much is too much 5:08 Magnesium oxide 7:06 Magnesium citrate 8:30 Magnesium glycinate 10:57 Magnesum threonate 13:04 Magnesium deficiency testing 15:45 My #1 Best magnesium supplement to take?
DISCLAIMER: Dr. Tomasz Biernacki received his Doctor of Podiatric Medicine degree from Kent State College of Podiatric Medicine in 2013; he completed his Surgical Reconstructive Foot Surgery & Podiatric Medicine Residency in 2017; he completed 2x traveling Fellowships in Diabetic Surgery, Skin Grafting & Nerve Surgery. He is double board certified in Podiatric Medicine and Foot & Ankle Surgery. Dr. Biernacki is a licensed podiatrist & surgeon in Michigan. This video should not be used to self-diagnose and is not a substitute for a medical exam, cure, treatment, diagnosis, prescription, or recommendation. It does not create a doctor-patient relationship between Dr. Biernacki and you. It would be best to not change your health regimen or diet before consulting a physician and obtaining a medical exam & diagnosis. Always seek the advice of a physician or other qualified health provider with any questions regarding a medical condition.
This is Tom Bernacki. What's the best magnesium? The most popular one is magnesium oxide. What
about magnesium glycinate? What about magnesium citrate? What about magnesium threonate? Why
can't you just eat magnesium? What about magnesium sulfate? We're starting now.
Historically in our diets and the water supplies, we had a ton of magnesium, but now 66 plus
percent of people are deficient. It's missing in our food supply. It's missing in our water
supply. It's really depleted. Blood tests only measure 1% of magnesium levels. Magnesium
is 66% deficient now, according to a lot of studies. It's tough to measure. We need 22
to 26 grams in our bodies, and only 5% of it or so is found in our blood. And that's
really all we measure. So a lot of studies have shown how high the deficiency is. It's
present in 600 enzymes in our body. Very critical element. It was previously in water, but now
our water is filtered. It's not in our water anymore. We're not drinking water out of streams
anymore. We're also eating processed diets. It's said that 80 to 90% of the magnesium
is taken out of our food. Most of our calories are coming now from processed breads, cookies,
simple calories. Even though we're eating 4,000 calories, and we used to just eat 2,000
calories in the 1950s and 60s, our nutrition is going over a cliff at the same time.
If you have a magnesium deficiency, you could have muscle weakness, cramps in your calves,
cramps in your thighs. This could be mild discomfort. You could have depression. You
could have anxiety. You could have a lot of worry, and all that stuff's going up these days.
You could have osteoporosis. It's said that 25% of seniors now have osteoporosis, weak joints,
high risk of fractures, a lot of problems with osteoporosis. Check out our osteoporosis guide
while I'm talking about that. You could have fatigue, muscle weakness. Do you feel like not
getting up? Do you feel unmotivated? Could be magnesium. It's related to high blood pressure.
It's related to heart problems, blood flow problems. Severe deficiencies could cause
breathing difficulties, asthma. It could cause irregular heartbeats. At risk for heart rhythm
problems, nausea, numbness, tingling, abnormal sensations can occur. Personality changes like
anxiety, mood swings, depression, all very common, all very well studied, all very well documented.
And the deficiency is high because of our poor diet. Gastrointestinal diseases like Crohn's,
celiac diseases. People who are vegans might not get as much calories or nutrition as needed.
People who drink alcohol might not absorb it very well. Diabetes, 30 to 40% of people have diabetes.
It's essentially happening everywhere across the world, especially after the COVID lockdowns,
extremely high. And as you get older, age is a big risk factor. And certain medications,
diuretics, antibiotics, all those are going up as far as use. So it is possible to supplement.
It is possible to eat foods. And in fact, I have a list of the 15 most practical foods
we count down from least practical to most practical, including the foods you probably
should be including in your diet. Check out that video below. We're going over all the best types
of magnesium supplements. And for your age, for the adult male, you want to be getting about 420
milligrams of elemental magnesium per day. For a female, you want to be getting about 320 milligrams
of magnesium per day. Now there's a great book. It's called the Magnesium Miracle by Dr. Carolyn
Dean. I try and read all these books as much as possible, but she basically goes over four reasons
you can't take it. One of them's kidney failure. One of them's myasthenia gravis, one of them's
bowel obstruction, and then some people just can't tolerate it. But outside of that, most people
should be good. 99.9% of people should be able to take magnesium. And if you take too much,
essentially you just get diarrhea or you vomited it out. The disclaimer is don't go crazy.
Always follow medical recommendations if you're worried. So what you want to do with any supplement
is make sure it's not interacting with anything else. Gradually increase it. Don't go with a crazy
amount right away. Start slow, gradually work it up and monitor your symptoms. Make sure you're
feeling good. Report to your doctor if you're having anything, but most common symptoms for
all of these is diarrhea, nausea, abdominal pain. That's when you know you're taking way too much.
I've always seen magnesium oxide on the bad magnesium list, but I've had a lot of people in
the comments saying, Hey, it's highly recommended. There's good studies. So we're going to go over
those, but generally it's not meant for absorption. Magnesium hydroxide is also
meant for to loosen the stool. It's not meant to be absorbed. Magnesium carbonate,
same kind of thing. It's an antacid. It's not meant to be absorbed and magnesium sulfate.
We're going to talk about that one as well, but not specifically for absorption.
Number one is magnesium oxide. This is the most popular and the most taken form of magnesium
in America. There's a couple of things to know about it. Number one, the bioavailability.
This is something that I've always known is that it has low bioavailability and it is less
soluble in water. It's actually good for being a laxative. Most magnesium oxide is a laxative.
If you take too much, it's going to leave your system. These laxatives have a ton of magnesium
oxide in there. Even though the bioavailability is low, you're still actually getting some into
your system, but it's used for acid reflux, heartburn as an antacid. It can be used as a
laxative. There's a lot of popular brands out there. That's really what magnesium oxide is for.
It's more of a laxative effect or an antacid. Is it the best choice to supplement your magnesium?
It's probably not. Some of the ones we're going to talk about are better. And medical studies
show that magnesium oxides does have a lower absorption rate. Due to its high magnesium
content, you still absorb some of it. Most of it is leaving, but because there's so much,
you're still getting some. The typical dosage is about 200 to 400 milligrams. There's a lot
in formulas and complexes, but it's probably not the number one choice if you're going to
supplement. Just be aware of the laxative effect and you could get GI discomfort. For some people,
that's a good thing. The reality is magnesium oxide is the most plentiful form in America and
most of the world, so you can still take it even though the percentage of absorbed is less. It is
so low cost that you can just take more and the side effects are really just that it's a laxative.
If you're constipated, it could be a good thing. It's very affordable. It's very accessible.
And realistically, just take more of it. If you take twice as much and only 50% is absorbed,
for example, just take a little bit more. As a recommendation, start taking a little bit less.
The guides recommend taking a smaller amount. So start with like 200, 300 grams. If you're
doing good, take a little bit more up to 500 grams. That's not a bad idea. Magnesium citrate.
Magnesium citrate is much more bioavailable than magnesium oxide and it's water soluble,
so it has better absorption in the gut. This is used as bowel preparation before surgical
procedures. If you take a lot, it'll clear you out. I know when I worked in the ER and people
were plugged up and had severe constipation, they would potentially take some of this. It
would clean you out. This is one that I've taken for years. A lot of my family members have taken
it. In fact, it kind of helps you go in the morning if you have problems with that. Studies
have shown that magnesium citrate is much more bioavailable than magnesium oxide. Probably a
better choice, especially if you struggle with constipation. A typical dose is 200 to 300
milligrams with very high ranges. You run the risk of getting explosive diarrhea, so just be
careful. Don't attack me in the comments if you have explosive diarrhea. So the tips are...
Now, magnesium citrate is more potent. It is more bioavailable, so you have to be careful
because taking too much will blow out your stomach. You're going to have diarrhea. You're
going to have to go on the toilet. And for older people, it could dehydrate you. So use it as a
supplement for food. So try and get at least half of it from food and then use this as a supplement
because it might be powerful going to the toilet. But otherwise, in regular dosages, magnesium
citrate is one of my go-to. It's relatively low cost in the powder form and very effective.
Magnesium glycinate. This is a great option as well. Magnesium glycinate is highly bioavailable,
similar to magnesium citrate, and it's bound to the amino acid glycine. So you're getting some
amino acid at the same time. Now glycine, in my sleep video I go over, glycine is actually a great
supplement for helping to sleep. So not only does magnesium help you sleep, but the amino acid
glycine helps you sleep. Glycine is an amino acid. It acts as an inhibitory neurotransmitter in the
brain. And when taken before sleep, it is a safe medication for anxiety and does have sleep benefit.
There's not a whole lot of long-term studies and can have some medication interactions.
If you don't struggle with constipation, magnesium glycinate is probably the better option.
It's known for its laxative effect. It calms the brain. It can help sleep. It can reduce anxiety.
It can reduce stress. So the glycine helps. The magnesium helps with all that. If you're
using it for the calming, for the anxiety, for the sleep benefits, magnesium glycinate is a very
unique option. It's a great option. It's an amino acid bound to glycine. Medical studies show that
magnesium glycinate is effective in managing the deficiencies and helps with stress, anxiety,
and sleep due to the presence of glycine. And a typical dosage is about 100 to 350 milligrams of
magnesium glycinate. It's very bioavailable and mostly won't cause diarrhea. It is highly
recommended for those who need a significant amount of magnesium and don't want to have
explosive diarrhea. Now, a new one I'm going to mention is magnesium L3 and 8. In fact, I did a
video going over all the benefits and the negatives. Essentially, this was developed by a
scientist at MIT, including a Nobel prize winner. It's magnesium combined with threonic acid, which
is a metabolite of vitamin C. Where this is notable is in studies, it's been shown that magnesium L3
and 8 can cross the blood brain barrier. I actually go over the studies where certain types of
magnesium don't get into the brain as well as magnesium L3 and 8 does. And that's been shown
in both human models and mouse models. There are cognitive effects. So some of the studies I go
over show that there are improved memory and learning functions. It actually does help the
brain. There's neuroprotective effects. It can help enhance memory and learning. The blood brain
barrier means the arteries in the brain have something called tight endothelial junctions.
That means not as much can squeeze through because the brain wants to protect itself from
toxins. And there's astrocytes and parasites to clean up anything that squeezes through
mood regulation. So it's said that they can help with anxiety and depression because more of that
magnesium is getting into the brain. And as a result can help more in sleep quality. I go over
those studies in depth. It's a little bit of a longer video, but I go over all those studies.
So you can see if it's worth the money or not. I'm actually in the midst of trying magnesium L3
and 8. I've enjoyed the benefit, but again, I'm just one person. It's hard to say for certain.
The dosage in the study is 1000 to 2000 milligrams, because a small percentage of
that is actually magnesium. Most of the weight is the threonic acid. As a result,
1000 to 2000 milligrams is really like 100 to 150 milligrams of elemental magnesium.
Now that doesn't mean you have to get it all through magnesium 3 and 8, but in the studies,
that's how much they use. Should you take more? Nobody really knows the answer for sure.
The studies still need to be worked on. Magnesium L3 and 8 is a little bit more expensive,
but it's a good option. Watch that whole video. How do you know if you have a magnesium deficiency
and how do you know that you need magnesium 3 and 8 specifically for your central nervous system
in your brain? Well, there's no perfect answer, but here's our best guess to decide if you do.
Our whole body has up to 26 grams of magnesium. Approximately 60% is stored in bone, 39% is inside
our cells, not in our blood, and just 1% is found in free or ionized form in the blood vessels. So
we're measuring just 1% of our total body's magnesium. A myth is, can blood levels measure
body magnesium? Some people say yes, but most people I think would admit that measuring just
1% of the total level is not a true test. Even though there is some debate, there are some
research techniques that allow for whole body magnesium assessments. And these are number one,
magnesium load test. This involves taking a high dose of magnesium through an IV and seeing how
much comes out in your urine over a specific time. Is this a perfect test? It's a pretty
complicated test that's pretty advanced. Then there's the magnesium isotope dilution test.
Basically you have radiolabeled magnesium that gets put into your body and you can use different
types of imaging to measure that or seeing how much comes out in your urine. Is that something
you want to do? It's not necessarily something I want to do. So rather than measuring it,
if it's safe and cost effective to take magnesium, is that probably the best way?
The tough part with medicine right now is there's tests for everything and there's
opinions for everything. But most patients I run into have to wait months to even get in to see me
or their primary care doctor. The system is not working correctly. People don't get proper tests.
They can't get their vitamin tests. Really, unfortunately, most people have to rely on
themselves to take care of themselves. And that's the way it's always been. And that's why we make
videos like this to give people additional resources to make a better decision. Rather
than getting an expensive test, realistically, if it's cost effective and relatively safe to
take magnesium in the required amounts, I just focus on doing that and see whether you feel
better or not. Most people in the comments actually let us know, Hey, I started doing
that and I feel a lot better in the areas that were mentioned in these studies.
Your brain has something called the blood brain barrier. And the studies we looked at show
that magnesium three and eight is the best at penetrating into your central nervous system
compared to the other types of magnesium that previously were recommended. Magnesium oxide
is the most available. It's the cheapest form and it is actually absorbed, but it's going to give
you that laxative effect. If you take too much, you're going to get explosive diarrhea. It helps
with heartburn in the chewable tablets, but the reality is citrate glycinate are great options.
And magnesium health three and eight is a great option as well. Check out my videos on all the
other forms and see what helps you the most. I think overall, the one I've recommended most
to family members is magnesium glycinate, but three and eight I'm testing right now as well.
So I'll let you know how that goes.