Siyamak sits down with Christian Pineda, a former homeless shelter employee in San Diego. His experience could reflect what's going on across California and homeless shelters. We also had a chance to talk with Scott H Silverman, who's an addiction recovery expert and has been in the homeless nonprofit industry for many years.
“Inside the shelter, it felt like for every $100 that was donated 75 went to admin, 25 to the people. No one's talking about there's a huge elephant that people need to fix,” Mr. Pineda said, “If we just keep on throwing money at this every year, if the money goes up and the homeless population goes up as well, does the math really add up?”
Ep 412 Homeless Shelter Insider: How Helping Homeless Has Become A Lucrative Business | Christian Pineda | Scott H Silverman #californiainsider#homelessness#sandiego#siyamak -------------------- This episode is sponsored by: 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸 Midas Gold Group, the nation’s No. 1 veteran-owned gold dealer and most trusted source for gold & precious metals: https://www.midasgoldgroup.com/
🔴 Watch our Documentary "Leaving California" at www.LeavingCaliornia.com
Inside the shelter, it felt like for every $100 that was donated, $75 went to admin,
$25 to the people. No one's fixing, no one's talking about it. There's a huge elephant
that people need to fix. I mean, if we just keep on throwing money at this every year,
if the money goes up and the homeless population goes up as well, does the math really add up?
My guest today is Christian Pineda. He's a former homeless shelter employee in San Diego. His
experience could reflect what's going on across Californian homeless shelters. I also had a
chance to talk about this story with Scott Silverman, who's an addiction recovery expert,
and he's been in the homeless nonprofit industry for many years.
Many people in the homeless arena, the providers, are funded because there's homeless. Well,
if there were no homeless, we wouldn't need homeless providers. And they'll always be
homeless, but it shouldn't be in the tens of thousands. The people that ran the services said
to me, if you help our clients get jobs, what are we supposed to do? I'm Siamak Korami. Welcome
to California Insider. Christian, it's great to have you on. Welcome. Thank you so much for having
me. You know, we want to talk to you about a topic that we've been covering. We've been covering
homelessness a lot on the show. This is a really big problem we're facing in California. We've
had different kinds of experts come from different perspectives tell us what's going on,
because this is a really important issue. We're spending a lot of resources on it. People are
suffering in the streets, whether it's San Diego, Los Angeles, San Francisco, and Sacramento, and
other counties. You worked at a homeless shelter for a while. We want to hear an insider
perspective of what you saw. Can you tell us what role you played, and how you got involved with
this? And what was it like? Sure. So I started in January of 2020. I started off being a volunteer,
and then COVID hit in March of 2020. And I continued during that year. And in that year,
I got my license in July for real estate. And I figured, well, I want to do something that's
impactful and helpful toward the people that I live with around San Diego. I want to be a little
bit different from the other realtors. And so then I worked for the homeless shelter, trying to be a
housing specialist, trying to get affordable rentals for all the people inside the shelters.
Once I became an employee of the shelter, a lot has changed my mind of what my initial
impressions were of the entire system going on. It was a lot of chaos. I didn't feel like
things were really going smooth with my upper management and staff, a lot of wasted resources.
There was a lot of people abusing the system. Overall, it was one of those things that's
life-changing and eye-opening. Can you tell us more about what was it like? So you start working
for this place, and you're finding your role was to find housing for people once they're in the
shelters? Yeah. So everyone inside the shelter have some sort of income, whether it's from a VA
disability, SSDI, or W-2 job, or side gig jobs. And in order for them to live there, they must
look for work and meet with their counselor on a regular basis. Now, looking for work is almost
like a W-2 job, a 9-to-5. They don't necessarily need to get the job, they just need to look for it.
And then once they have enough saved up, then we can go find a rental that fits their budget
and the area that they want, and things like that. And what was that process like? So this
shelter you work with, we won't name them, but it's a San Diego shelter that had like about 400
homeless people in it, right? What was that process like? At times, it was chaotic and crazy. It felt
like a two-tiered system in terms of who gets to stay, who gets to live. They didn't man-take
drug tests, no sobriety tests. So in theory, they could walk outside, take as many drugs as they want,
drink as much as they want, go back inside to the shelter, and sleep it off, and nothing's
changed. It's almost as if the homeless shelters are keeping them in perpetuity, you know, in
like homelessness, because they don't really address the root problem of what's going on,
of the behaviors that these people have done over the years, which has turned into habits,
which has got them there in the first place. And now, out of the people you dealt with there,
we keep hearing that there's a lot of addiction, drug addiction and alcohol involved with the
homeless population. From one side, we hear that, and then from another side, people say,
no, that's not the root cause. The root cause is housing. What was it like for out of the 400
that you saw? Was this normal for people, a lot of people, to do drugs? What was it like?
I would say about a good half of them are on some sort of drugs, whether it's prescribed or from
the streets. On occasion, we did have some people sell narcotics inside the facility,
and obviously they were kicked out. And the staff would then make a new bed, and within 24 hours,
you get someone else who's also addicted in the same bed. There's no way to really tell
if the person's on drugs, unless they're acting really hysterical. Because like I said,
there's no sobriety tests, no mandatory drug tests. It's almost like they're the enablers,
the shelters. They're enabling the people to just live there, free Wi-Fi, free shelter,
free laundry, free food. So long as you don't fight, meet with your counselors, don't do drugs,
don't drink, and you're all set. But they say, don't do drugs, don't do drugs there.
Correct. If you do drugs outside, then you're fine. Yeah, you're fine. No worries. A lot of
people that have financial challenges and difficulties, they were there too.
Where were the families and people that had difficulties and challenges? Oh, of course,
yeah. It ranges everyone from everyone to just having a hard time in life, to just no financial
literacy whatsoever. For example, some of them think that plan, the lottery, is a way of income
or a retirement plan. And obviously, as everyone knows, that's a fallacy.
Playing the lottery is their retirement planning. Yes. Not once a week, but on a daily basis,
maybe multiple times a day. Christian, tell us some of the stories of the people that you were
helping. There was a different range of people, right? Some people probably had misfortune.
And was it easier to help those people out? Sure. I mean, so everyone's going to be different.
I remember helping this one man. He didn't have a job. But I saw he had a cell phone. And I said,
well, do you have a car? He said, great. So I showed him Grubhub. And now he does the Grubhub
food. So he runs around town. He's dropping off food. And so I would say those are probably some
of the smaller stories. I would say about 95% of the people who have financial problems actually
don't necessarily want the help. There's this other man living there. He's making $6,500 a month.
He was making more than me. And I asked him, all right, well, where's all the money coming from?
It wasn't from a 9 to 5 job or a W2 job, right? Anything like that. It was from reselling shoes,
sportswear, like memorabilia, hats, anything that he can really sell, like jewelry as well.
And I didn't believe it at first. And he showed me his bank statement for the past six months.
I says to my staff, why is he allowed to live here? And my manager says, well, he meets the
requirements. He doesn't fight. He doesn't drink. He doesn't do drugs on site. He meets with the
counselors. And he supposedly looks for work. There are other people. This really stuck in
my mind because I never thought that this would happen, is that sometimes U.S. citizens do not
get priority for shelter. There's this Russian man that I met. He crossed the San Ysidro Port
of Entry, didn't have a visa. He was trying to claim asylum. And he showed me his I-94 paperwork.
And I'm reading. I'm thinking, huh, this is very interesting. And it has a court date with location,
time and date. And right after I read the I-94 paperwork, he says, Christian, where can I find
some cash? Where can I find some jobs? And I didn't really know what to tell him at the moment.
So I looked up Russian restaurants. And so I suggested to him, well, what if you go to the
restaurants? What if you go talk to them? I'm sure they have people who came from Russia
trying to become a U.S. citizen just like you. And a few days go by, and I'm looking for him.
And he told everyone that he bought a plane ticket to Chicago, probably never to be seen
or heard from ever again. And that's the thing that really surprised me, is that homelessness
is also in factor with immigration as well. And this man was in mid-30s, able to work,
able to hold a job. But yet he got priority over someone on the street.
And this shelter you were in, it was full, right?
Oh yeah, about 400 people. They all had bunk beds. It was chaotic at times because the homeless
people would protest the living conditions based upon the staff. They would urinate in
plastic bottles. Sometimes they would defecate on the floor. So you really had to watch where
you're walking. Almost like a zoo. What about the people that were having financial problems?
Were there people that would come and they would use the shelter and then they would move on?
I would say the abusers rotate every about six months. And it could be maybe they don't like
the food. Maybe they don't like the staff. Maybe they don't like the location. But if they rotate
the shelters every six months and they return to the same shelter, then inside that system,
it's as if they're a brand new person. So you can go from shelter to shelter,
but in the meantime, you're taking somebody else's spot that exactly needs that.
Exactly. Yeah. And so this is kind of how I think that the shelters kind of keep the people
homeless in perpetuity. Because to a group of people that are able to work, what was the
percentage that you saw, based on your experience, what group could work out of the 400?
I would say a good 25 to 30 percent would work, could able to work. There are people even as
young as 25 in there that were able to work. And for whatever reason, they just wouldn't do it.
Everyone's different, right? But for this one person that I interviewed, he told me,
why should I work when I have free shelter, free Wi-Fi, free food, free laundry? Anything that I
need is right here. And if I don't fit the mold of the system, I'll go to another shelter and just
return and just do it again all over. So in theory, that person can live for free wherever.
And what about the other team members you had, the staff members of this non-profit,
the management, the leaders? What was their mindset? What were they thinking of this situation?
Their thinking was housing first, housing first. If we get them into some sort of box,
whether it's an apartment, a home, a condo, a townhome, anything like that, as long as we put
them in some sort of box, then we've solved the homelessness crisis. But that doesn't really
address the root cause of why they're in the shelter in the first place. So if the shelters
are enabling the people to do drugs and drinking, and then we go find them an apartment or something,
and they continue the same behavior that turned into habits, are we truly helping those people
who are less fortunate, who really need our help? So in your opinion, people are coming to these
homeless shelters, and there's 400 space there. Some people are just going from shelter to shelter,
they don't really have a plan, and they could potentially work. Is there a big percentage,
you said 25 to 30 percent could work? Yeah, definitely. I would say for those people,
the 25 to 30 percent, there's no disabilities, right? They're able to function like an average
person. They just, for whatever reason, thought that playing the lottery was their income,
or that playing the lottery is the retirement plan, or they didn't want to work at all.
Because they have everything that they need right there. And they could still do drugs and drink,
just don't do it on site. Is there a time limit for them? How long they can stay in a shelter like
that? It's about six months, so long as they maintain the requirements. Now the person that
showed you his income, was he selling things out of the shelter, or was he selling things from other
places? So he rented the storage unit, and he showed me pictures of the shoes, the hats, the watches,
the memorabilia, anything that he could basically sell his hands on, he'll be able to sell. And then
he comes back to the shelter to sleep. It was the wildest thing I've ever seen.
At the time, he was making more than me. And I'm thinking, well, what am I doing here?
And he was openly admitting that he didn't have a financial problem. He's essentially taking
somebody else's place that is sleeping in the streets right now. Yeah, he was bragging about it.
He told me, Christian, I have a different lifestyle than most. And in my mind, I'm thinking,
yeah, what else is new? This episode is sponsored by Midas Gold Group. Do you feel the bills are
getting higher and higher every time you check out the grocery store? Do you feel your monthly
discretionary money has decreased, although your income increases yearly? Inflation is eating away
at your wealth. Digital wallets and central bank's digital currencies are destroying financial
privatization. Also, only gold and silver are constitutional forms of money. Our privacy
was to be protected against unlawful watch and seizure. Midas Gold Group will help you take
control of your finances and protect your wealth and your privacy. Pulling money out of the
questionable banking and investment system is the way to privatize your finances as the elite
push us towards digital wallets and central bank digital currency. Protect your wealth with real
money. Deal with the best at Midas Gold Group, a proud America first company. Midasgoldgroup.com.
Click on the link below and check them out. Now let's go back to the interview.
What about the people that your colleagues, the people that work with you in this shelter,
what were their thoughts about this? So it seems like 20 to 25 to 30 percent of people kind of
taking advantage of the system. What were they thinking? So they were thinking, well, we need to
help them by any means necessary to just get them in sort of an apartment, some sort of rental.
They weren't necessarily, you know, let's get them to the doctor's appointment, the dentist
appointment, ignoring the huge elephant in the room of why they're there literally in the first
place. And the thing that I've really noticed about, you know, the staff is they never asked,
why do you want to live in the shelter? Because for the homeless people on the streets,
it's like another world. There's no rules. You can do drugs as much as you want.
You don't have to pay rent. Sure. But, you know, the people in the shelter, right, they get
everything for free handed to them. So my other colleagues, my staff, encourage the free stuff,
like the medical, the dental and all that toward those people. Towards those people that were in
the street. Yeah. To get them to come to the shelter. Correct. To bring them in. Right. So
the San Diego police has what's called the hot team. The San Diego hot team would basically
transport the people from the streets, put them in the shelters. If they agree. Right.
Because if they don't agree, they don't do that. Right. Well, then they would have to just
move them away to another. And then basically those people living on that block
will then go to another block. It's almost like a cat and mouse game.
And in a certain way, Caltrans does the same thing. Because the homeless people that live
on the side of the freeway, every so often Caltrans has to then relocate those people
who are living on the side of the freeway, giving them housing vouchers or giving them
a free ticket to the shelter. And some of those people who are living on the side of the freeway,
they didn't want to go to the shelters because they knew what type of chaos it was inside.
They experienced it. They wanted to do it all over again. And for some, there was like no way.
We have heard from some people that they don't want to go into shelters because they're not safe.
Some of these shelters are not safe. Is that true? What kind of, was it theft,
just theft or other crime too? There was stabbings too. Stabbings and overdoses.
So it got so bad that the upper management had to give staff the Narcan drug.
So if we ever do see someone overdosing, we have to give Narcan to basically wake them up
back into reality. There were people that would then smuggle in paraphernalia in order to do
those drugs. There were also people who would smuggle in some sort of knives to then shank
the other person that they didn't like. There was security on there, but it was very minimal.
What about the rule of not doing drugs? Was there a rule of not doing drugs? Were people
doing drugs in there? Definitely. Yeah. So you can't do it out in the open because then it's
too obvious. So what they would do is they would go in the bathrooms at very odd hours,
four o'clock in the morning or 10 o'clock at night when no one else is there. They would shoot up,
do whatever they need to do, snort, whatever. And there's no repercussions because literally
no one saw it. But we found needles inside the bathrooms or we found the little razors that
people use to chop up the cocaine. And that blew my mind because I'm thinking, wait, hold on.
How compassionate are we to really help these people if we're not addressing the root cause,
like the drug addiction and things like that? So Scott, great to have you back on. Welcome back.
Thank you. It's nice to be back. Scott, what are your thoughts on what Christian is sharing? Does
this reflect what's going on in the homeless industry, homeless services, nonprofit industry?
I think he gave a relatively real evaluation or observation, I should say, of what he's seeing.
And I think he talked about a 400 bed shelter. And it was interesting he didn't say the name.
I was curious why he didn't. No, he's out of the industry. We encourage him not to share the name.
Because we don't want this to be against one group of people.
Well, you know, I get that. But at the end of the day, if you and I were to go to people's
homes and steal their TV, which is not right and illegal, we would be in trouble for that. And in
some ways, to me, if somebody is getting millions of dollars a year, and their job description is
to feed and shelter and decrease homelessness, and they don't do any of that in a systemic way
to make the change, in some ways, they're guilty of not being effective. And in a business world,
if you're not effective, you don't stay in business. And I say, put some measures in place,
the folks that are doing a good job, give them more resources, and make it happen for them.
Let them be the ones who take charge and move forward. I mean, look at our
business environment, look at the changes that are being made, you know, in our business community
right now, because of what's happening with, you know, between COVID and the expense of doing
business and minimum wage going up. Some people, if they can't adjust, they're not going to be
able to stay in business. If they can't stay in business, they can't continue to hire people.
I mean, we used to, I know he talked about getting homeless people jobs,
and it's hard. And one of the things he mentioned, which I really appore is,
if you're going to stay in the system, and people are going to help feed you and shelter you,
and you have an issue with addiction, you have to be involved with some form of support. And
the fact that they don't test in a shelter. Now, he also mentioned that, you know, Narcan is now
being given to all the different facilitators. And if somebody overdoses, you can give them Narcan.
Well, if we can give people Narcan to reverse an overdose, why can't we highly suggest that they
maybe do an assessment to see if they have an addiction issue, so we can get them some help?
Do you think that this potentially is a trend where the nonprofits, the shelter community,
the homeless service providers are approaching to the homelessness from this angle?
For example, Los Angeles has the rescue mission. And I think I remember seeing, I think on your
show a couple of years ago, the chairman of the board, the president talking about how,
and don't hold me to this, but I thought he was saying that, you know, we're not doing a good job.
We're not actually even doing a poor job. We're doing a lousy job,
just because the resources aren't there. And there wasn't really a continuum of care.
So, and shelters are kind of like, you know, they're like emergency rooms, you know, it's a triage.
And they don't have the mechanisms in place. And there's no incentive for them to encourage people
not to come back. Meaning, if the tools are in place, and we're really doing our job
of providing the services on a continuum basis, where there's a connection between the triage,
stabilization, assessment, and then case management, we would see homelessness decreasing.
And we're not seeing that anywhere. But there's a couple of isolated communities around the country
that seem to be doing a really good job. And I believe Texas is one of them, I believe. And
there's one in, I think, Denver, where the leadership has made the commitment
to put whatever they need to, and it's not just the money. It's the leveraging, it's creating
systemic change. It's enforcing the rules, holding people accountable, and actually even asking the
recipients of the funding to prove they're doing a good job, or at least participating in what they
Do you think the homeless shelters should care more? Do you think they have lost the care?
What do you think is going on in the heads of these nonprofits?
I don't think it's a lack of caring. I think it's a lack of understanding
of what creating change really means. And I think that we've got it so siloed or so segmented that,
for example, somebody comes into an ER emergency room, there's an emergency doctor and staff that
makes an assessment, then they refer them to specialists. And after the specialists have
done their work, stabilize the patient, if they need physical therapy, they go to physical therapy.
If they need ongoing accountability, vital signs being checked, blood work being done,
they do that. We don't do that when it comes to helping people. They go into a benefits-driven
environment, whether it's treatment, or jail, or shelters. And then once their time is up,
they're moved on. And they don't get a handbook on what to do next. They may sit with somebody
for 30 minutes, and they'll say, well, you have to get a job. You've got to go to meetings.
You can't drink and use. And if you do all of that, you should be able to be just fine.
Well, that's not good advice for somebody who has been out on their own for years, if not longer,
with other issues that have not been managed while they're in the shelter. And, you know,
they can't, they can only do so much shelter. Shelter for me, and my understanding is,
it's a roof over your head. And it's three meals a day, basically, which means a respite to get
off the street to help get stabilized. Well, that just means to put your head on a pillow,
and breathe, and hopefully feel safe. But a lot of shelters aren't safe.
If you were to recommend a solution to this, do you have any thoughts and any recommendations for
these operators of the shelters? You know, you're the only one that
answered me that question. Nobody else wants to. And I'll tell you, honestly,
and I've been at this since 93, volunteering since 86. So I've been around it for decades,
ran my own agency, and we were called an exit program. So there has to be a continuum of care,
there has to be a prescription for somebody. After there's an assessment, and there's
stabilization, and then tools that are given to the individual, and then they're coached,
if you will, or monitored while they transition from their beginning point. And then there's a
place for them to check in, there's a place for additional resources, and there's a place for
support as they need it. And then that support can be declined or decreased once an individual
has gained the tools that they need to become more effective in their own path in their own life.
Because a lot of the people that we see that are homeless suffer from self-medication,
drug addiction, alcoholism, a myriad of behavioral health issues, untreated trauma,
and of course, living on the street, nobody gets better on their own.
They just find a way to survive, kind of like being in jail, but it's on the outside. So I
don't know if that answers your question or not, but it's the continuum of care, it's a process.
It's actually, so you're suggesting looking at the root cause of why this person is in this
situation first, assessing their situation, and then giving them the services they need,
instead of just offering a roof over their head for six months.
That's a band-aid. I mean, if you can't help somebody by understanding what they're going
through, and then giving them the path and the tools and the support, they're going to go back
to what they've always done. They don't have a choice. That's what they unfortunately organically
have grown into, if you will, is their systemic change to surviving on the street. Well, a lot
of those skills can be transferred, you know, to how to get a job, how to keep a job, you know,
how to maintain your own shelter, but without the tools. I mean, when I hear people say
to somebody, or they talk about that population, and they say all they need to do is get a job.
Well, when you've been living on the street for months, weeks, or years,
and you have gaps in your employment, and you haven't applied for a job,
and you don't feel you really need to because you're getting the services out there that are
being offered. You know, I think in many ways, the way social services, quick example, and we
talked about this when we first met. I started my own organization because the people that ran
the services said to me, if you help our clients get jobs, what are we supposed to do? And I said,
wait, what? Yeah, if you get our clients jobs, what are we supposed to do? I said,
we'll get another job. So getting the homeless jobs, essentially.
They were part of social services, in my opinion, lacks the heartfelt desire to empower someone else
to be self-sufficient. Because many people in the homeless arena, the providers are funded
because there's homeless. Well, if there were no homeless, we wouldn't need homeless providers,
and they'll always be homeless. But it shouldn't be in the tens of thousands
in cities like San Diego, or Los Angeles, or San Francisco, and it continues to grow.
And there's no end in sight. And the government's not going to fix this. I mean,
they keep throwing money at a problem that just gets worse. And, you know, as Christian said,
there's a professional level of enabling that's going on, which I agree with,
to provide this system. I mean, I remember going to San Francisco on a consulting gig
many years ago. And I sat in this room with law enforcement talking about the homeless
in what is that area? The Tenderloin. And they said, it was all law enforcement. So I asked the
captain who was running the meeting, I said, where's all the social service agencies?
Oh, they meet on a different day. They weren't even sitting in the same room. And law enforcement
were the first point of contact. And it was law enforcement's responsibility to transport somebody
to a shelter or to an emergency room or to a detox. But those providers weren't even in the
same room at that time, talking to each other on how to solve the problem. So, you know, when we
really want to do something, I mean, when you take a look at what we did with COVID, and what a
coordinated effort there was, and even in real time, they knew how many people died in each city,
each county, each state per day. So the government can do it if they want to. And to me, that was a
great example of how many lives were probably saved, because there were a lot of mandates,
you know, and now all the, you know, the fallout. California alone, they were sending billions of
dollars to people fraudulently. And even people in prison were getting salaries during the COVID
virus. I mean, so I don't understand it. I don't understand how government tries to tell us they're
doing their job, but isn't getting the job done. What do you tell to the average residents that
live in San Diego, and they have a good heart, they want to help the homeless, they live in LA,
San Diego, San Francisco, and all the cities in California, and they do have the heart to want to
not have homeless people in their community?
I encourage them to get involved. I encourage them to talk to legislative leaders once they've
been educated to find out what the systemic issues are. I just met a family who actually
serves homeless people every Tuesday out of a faith-based group every week. And while those
people are there, they have a network of 400 volunteers, and they ask everyone who attends,
they feed them dinner, they serve them, they treat them like, you know, royalty, and say,
look, while you're here, if you're enjoying what you're experiencing, and you're interested in
stepping out of your level of uncomfortability with being homeless or on the street, or if we
can help you, please go to table 14 and talk to our volunteers. So they make it easy without judging.
And the concept is great, but 400 volunteers, you think about that, it's expensive to try to
provide that kind of service. But when you think about how much we spend sheltering,
and hotel vouchers now, and just the money just getting burnt, it goes down the drain,
there's no way to really recycle it in a way that provides. And if homelessness were going down,
I could say, yeah, that system works. So it would be getting involved, but it's going to take a huge
effort. Look, Los Angeles has 70,000 homeless people, they claim. How do you fix that? I mean,
in the years that I've watched LA, you know, from San Diego, and San Diego's homeless problem is up
almost 100% since I left my agency 12 years ago. And I did that for 18 years. So to be up that much
in that period of time, if you extrapolate that data, in the next 20 years, homelessness
can become a new minority, and designated by the state. And then all of a sudden, now we've got a
whole new welfare system for a whole new population, that really, if half are able-bodied,
they could be and should be working. So I don't know how we're going to fix this with the current
people in leadership, who are signing the checks for the people who provide their services,
who don't get paid to help solve the problem. They just get paid to serve the meals and provide
the shelters. You were finding apartments for people. Can you tell us a few stories of
what kind of people you found apartments and what was the results, which ones worked out,
which ones didn't? My favorite story is mom and dad, they're both felons, both convicted felons
with about four kids. And so they changed their lives. They went through probation, went through
rehab. They no longer do that anymore. And I found them a little rental that they can afford,
because they both have full-time jobs. And I personally got them a U-Haul truck. I showed up
to the shelter. I said, guys, let's go, put everything in the back, let's move. And then
when we got there, I physically moved the boxes into the little home. And I really fell in love
with that family in particular, because they wanted to change their life around.
America is the land of second chances. And they understood that their past, their drug
convictions were not them at the moment. That's not who they are anymore because of the kids.
Did you have stories of people that it didn't work out? Oh, yeah. Can you tell us those stories?
Sure, of course. So there was this elderly man. He was about 65, 67. He was a veteran of, you know,
so he served his time. He was honorably discharged. And he had some money, you know, some nice money
in his pocket. And I says, hey, you know, let's go get you a nice rental to live by yourself,
live on your own. And he didn't want to do it. And I asked him, why? I mean, because you want
to get out of here? I mean, there's 400 other men that you live with. His whole thinking was,
if he lives by himself, then he's just wasting money, he's wasting time, he could fall victim
back to the alcoholism, back to the drugs, back to his old habits that got him there in the first
place. And he didn't really see him getting an apartment, you know, for himself, as something
that's justifiable or even good. Because he really loved free stuff, the free things there.
And you were helping people to find housing, right? This is what you were doing. Your job
was to find housing for them, right? To move to help them move out, right?
Yes, I was a housing specialist. And I held my real estate license at the same time.
So my thinking was, well, what if I could use the MLS in a way that I can have the database
that I need in order to find affordable rentals in the areas to help these people. And I can also
teach them about any things that might be, what's the word?
Financial literacy.
Financial literacy or anti-discrimination.
Because they could get discriminated when they're getting...
Yeah, we were discriminated a few times. So I had to report this to the DRE,
the Department of Real Estate, to the other realtor. I don't know the conclusion of that,
but I had to do my part in order to protect those homeless people.
Now, you got into this, you wanted to help the homeless, right? Is that why you got involved?
Yeah, initially, yeah. I wanted to go help. Maybe I was naive. I like to help people,
no matter who it is. And some of these people that I've helped, I've kept in contact after I left.
They're my friends. I've invited them to my wedding. We go to barbecues, things like that.
I mean, at the end of the day, these are people. People, people, people, right?
When I left, I still want to help people, but not in the way that is fashioned right now.
It seems like there's no transparency of what's going on really in the system.
Was there a moment you realized that what you thought it was is really not like that?
Was there a moment that you kind of realized it? Oh, most definitely. It probably was the moment when
so many things happened at the same time that could have been prevented. Overdoses,
stabbings, people defecating on the floors because they're protesting the staff conditions.
Sometimes the staff would even yell at the homeless people just because they weren't
following instructions. Whether it's, you know, can you just make up your bed? Can you pick up
trash and all that? It was almost like the staff had an abusive relationship with the people inside
the shelter. Can you tell us more? Was there a specific time you realized that, oh, this is
something different than what you thought it would be? Probably the time a staff got into
altercation with one of the homeless residents. Can you tell us more about that? So what was the story?
Sure. So he was kicked out of the shelter because he wouldn't look for work and
go with his counselor. So he tried to get back into the program. He's at the front door.
One of the staff members told him, no, I'm sorry, you can't. You broke the rules, you know, you're
out. And so the guy got really frustrated and he just sucker punched, you know, the female staff.
I'm thinking to myself, what world am I living in? And the security at the moment wasn't even there.
They were maybe 50 to 100 yards out. So they had to run to the incident to get the problem solved.
So for like a brief moment in time, that guy just swinging on the staff member like nothing.
That staff member could have died if he had a knife in his hand or a gun or like a pipe or whatever.
So you didn't expect that out of the homeless people to do that, right? Is that what caused you
to change your... Absolutely. So before I was a volunteer, I thought homeless people were just lazy.
When I got into being the employee, now I learned, okay, well, there's addictions,
there's mental illness, there's a whole lot more that's going on that no one's fixing. No one's
talking about. There's a huge elephant that people need to fix. I mean, if we just keep on throwing
money at this every year, if the money goes up and the homeless population goes up as well,
I mean, does the math really add up? I'm not sure. And then you saw that incident and you're like,
and was this guy on drugs or was it just like it was a normal encounter?
He just started punching this lady. I didn't smell any alcohol on his breath. His eyes were white.
I didn't notice any weird behavior. It was just anger management or it was a combination of like
just the anger management and the heat of the moment of why he wouldn't get back into the
program. And in terms of the staff, your colleagues, your co-workers, they must have
gotten involved because they want to help the homeless, right? Most of them did, but did it
become a job? What were they like? What was it like to them? It was a job for them. At the end
of the day, they had to pay the bills and they had mouths to feed. I mean, there are those ones
who really believed in the mission, but I think they were really blinded by what was really going
on. They were either naive or ignorant of what exactly that they're seeing and doing on a daily
basis. Why are so many people leaving California? It wasn't long ago, people from everywhere wanted
to move to the golden state to enjoy a better life. Sadly, the standard of living has been
dropping in the past decade. Are you like me and wonder why this is happening? I'm Siamak Kourami,
host of California Insider. In our film, Leaving California, The Untold Story, I take you an
intimate journey of love, loss, tragedy, and hope as residents face the prospect of leaving their
beloved state. Everyday people like you tell their stories about why they have to move out
of the state, even though they don't want to. Experts and policymakers also give insights about
what's happening behind the scenes. Together, we get to the root cause of this exodus. Go to
leavingcalifornia.com to view the first 15 minutes of the film for free. By watching Leaving
California, you can be part of the solution. Again, go to leavingcalifornia.com.
Christian, can you paint a picture of based on the four, so you guys had 400 people in this
shelter, male shelter, and then there is like upstairs you had some families.
Can you paint a picture of what type of issues these people faced? Sure. What percentage had
mental illness? I would say about maybe 15 to 20 percent have some sort of mental illness,
whether it be schizophrenia, bipolar, anything like that. And in terms of like the people who
were, I would say normal or average, I would say about 30 percent or so. And what percentage were
doing drugs? The other half? I would say 50. So yeah, 50. I would say 50 percent. So 50 percent
were doing drugs. Yeah. And what about the people that had a financial problem, that legitimately
they couldn't pay their bills, they kind of got thrown in the street, and they were there
because they were poor? Five percent. It's kind of sad to think that only five percent of that
population, no drugs, no drinking, no mental illness, no taking advantage of the system.
I would say mostly those people are going to be veterans who are honorably discharged.
They were elderly men. They just, you know, they knew what they had to do in order to get
to the next step, and they did it. And the VA does a very good job of doing that.
It takes about two or three weeks for them to get housed, if they're honorably discharged,
as opposed to, it could take someone months, just a regular person to go get housed.
And those people will come in and go really fast? They will come in and get out?
Oh yeah. I had this one interaction with this elder man. He was there for literally two weeks,
and through his DD-214, he showed me he was honorably discharged. He's ready to go.
He has some sort of income, and we were able to find him a rental that fits his budget.
I was very shocked about how well the VA system does that.
Did you encounter people that actually, because rents went up a lot, in San Diego rents almost
significantly is a lot higher, 50-60% more during that time. Did you get into people
that couldn't pay rent, and they had to come to the shelter? Did you run into those people?
On occasion, yeah. And so I tried to introduce the idea of roommates. Okay, well, so I would
basically say it like this. If you're looking to live in this area, and you want to live on your
own, well, you might want to think about maybe two or three, four people that want to live with you.
It was very hard for those people who, for the rent was very expensive, to kind of like justify
to them, hey, it's not what it was 10, 15, 20 years ago. This is where it is now because of
the low inventory of housing. Unfortunately, that's the way it was, and it was just one of
those most difficult things in order to teach them. Yes, rents are going up. It's expensive.
Nothing that we can really control is because it's based on the inventory all around in
California. So let's get creative in the way that we address this problem.
Now, by getting roommates, right? Right.
So people don't think of that, which is very interesting. So Christian, seeing all of this,
like your experience there and what you saw, and how does that make you feel as a San Diegan? And
we have a homeless crisis in San Diego now. How does that make you feel?
It makes me feel cheated in a sense that there's no transparency of where the money really goes.
I mean, it felt like for every $100 that was donated, 75 went to admin, 25 to the people.
I just want to know what sort of financial documents can they provide? And I was doing
research on them. Those documents that they have online are about four years old.
They're certainly not up to date. So when you look at Apple or Google as like a company,
you actually know the exact dollar amounts of what they spent, how many employees and things
like that. Well, why can't we do the same thing for homeless shelters? What is the salary of the
CEO? How much do they get paid? How much does it cost to run one operation? How many people are
inside that building? What does it cost for the food, sewage, electricity, things like that?
Did you ever talk to the leadership team in there?
Yes, I did. Yes.
And what were their thoughts about what's going on?
Their thing is, well, we need to be compassionate to those people, to everyone that we encounter.
And then I countered with, well, how are we being compassionate to not only the homeless people
inside the shelter, but once they leave the shelter into the streets of downtown San Diego,
where they shoot up and they do drugs and they drink, are we really, are we being compassionate
to those people as well? There's walking up and down the streets that has to encounter
a crazy man with something in his hand that might be a threat.
Do you have any advice for the leaders of this industry? You know, we have a lot of nonprofits,
a lot of them probably get into this because they want to help the homeless.
And do you have any advice for these people that are in this space?
Yeah, what we're doing now is simply not working. There's no way that this is sustainable
for many years to come on end. Why do we look at the housing first, the very end of the spectrum?
Why don't we look at the very start, the behaviors, the habits, what's going on inside,
their head and how they even get here in the first place? Because many of the people waste
their drugs on alcohol, drugs, even things that they don't even need. But no one's talking about
this because they don't mandate drug tests or sobriety tests. It might be wasteful.
So what are your thoughts on this? So how do you think we can solve this from based on what you've
seen? Okay, so homeless is a very complex issue. And it's going to be a multitude of things.
What if we were to have some sort of job training inside the shelter? And then for those employers
that like McDonald's or 7-Eleven give incentive to those companies to specifically hire those
inside the shelters. Also, in terms of the housing, what if the coastal California cities
were to buy an old yacht, park it in the bay, because it already has the rooms, it has the
bathrooms, it has the kitchens. It's basically a city inside the city. We'll move all the residents,
all the homeless shelters into the one old cruise ship. And it'll be a one-time cost.
Like a big cruise ship, like thousands of rooms. Yeah, because at one point,
we were going to shut down that location because the staff had told us,
we cannot tell the homeless people there that we're running out of funding. So we need to move
locations. And it really got to me, I'm thinking, well, why can't we tell the homeless people that
we've lost funding for this one location? Isn't that a great incentive for them to go find housing?
Another solution that I have is just mental hospitals. We got to open them up. It doesn't
matter who closed them or who shut them down, but we got to resurrect them. Because there's
mental illness, comes in many forms, comes in many people,
and it affects quite a deal of people. And when it comes to the housing issue, specifically real
estate, build, build, build. The state needs to give incentives to builders, not necessarily to
apartment buildings, but for all types, whether it's a manufactured home, whether it's a single
family residence, a condo, townhome, apartment building, duplex, triplex, quadplex, anything.
Just keep on building because the housing inventory affects literally all sorts of people,
up, down, many socioeconomic classes. Now, do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
Yes. It's healthy to be skeptical, right? If you're going to be donating your money,
do some research. Do it in a way that, how can it impact the people of your area
most successfully? I just want to let the people know that they need to pretty much ask questions
and don't just donate money just to donate money. Because then the problem gets bigger,
the budget goes up, the population goes up, and eventually this crisis is going to affect
businesses, it's going to affect tourism, crime residential areas, and at some point,
jobs are going to start to evaporate. And then people are going to think,
well, what happens? Where's all the jobs going?
Cristian Pineda, housing expert in San Diego Chula Vista, it was great to have you in California
Insider. Thank you so much for having me. If you haven't checked out CaliforniaInsider.com,
we highly recommend you do that now because we're going to have a lot of news and videos there. And
on top of what we have there right now, we are building a really big platform to cover what's
happening in California. So you can be informed. We're going to have more shows, more videos from
all aspects of life in California. Go to CaliforniaInsider.com and we'll see you there.