noc20-me92-lec04_ Smart Materials-III

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
Smart Materials-IIIThis lecture introduces the active smart polymers, its classification, application and a separate discussion on IPMCs. Activity questions: 1. What are the main difference between electronic and ionic EAPs? 2. What is the basic principle of operation of a
[Music]
[Music]
welcome to the course on foundations of
cognitive science in the last lecture we
have talked about one of the very
important smart materials which is
needed which is essential for Organ
smart robot development and that is
shape-memory alive today I will talk
about another interesting smart material
which is based on polymers and it is
predicted that this is the smart
material which will be inevitable in
terms of development of cognitive robots
so let us have a very good discussion on
this type of polymeric smart materials
today today we will talk about the
electro active polymers which is also
abbreviated as e AP now this
electroactive polymers they belong to
these smart materials who which is
commonly known as active smart polymers
so what are these active smart polymers
well the polymers that respond to
external stimuli by changing the shape
or size actually known as active smart
polymer so the output has to be a change
of shape or size and that external
stimuli could be of different types in
fact the best way you can differentiate
between the external civilly is that
whether it is electrical in nature or
non electrical in nature with respect to
these there are two categories of these
active smart polymers the first group we
will call them to be active polymers
which respond to non electric input
stable such as pH magnetic field and
light one of the example is polyanionic
cellulose
electric field waste actuation of
polymer is an even more important step
in terms of polymeric development
because you can easily apply electric
field on a polymer instead of using
other stimuli like let us say light or
you know some chemicals and things like
that and hints in a quick signal based
on electricity actuated polymer is a
very special class of polymer this
special group of polymer we'll call them
as electroactive polymers that respond
to the change of electrical input it is
also known as e AP now one of the
example of an active smart polymer which
is not EAP but simply active and that is
a polymer here as you can see in this
particular case and this is a based on a
so benzene actually and there is a ring
like structure in can see and this
response to you know light specifically
light or visible light or UV light and
because of the presence of this as
avenging group in this case which
actually contains MN double bonds under
visible light these double bonds have a
sis configuration in which the polymer
is bent so this is the sis configuration
you can see these active groups as
Romanian groups here which are bent now
this is under the visible light the
moment will apply UV on eight say force
against you will see that this part
where the UV light is applied has become
flat now once again so that means the
polymer will be flattening under the UV
light once again you put it at a
reasonable light it will start to bend
and again if you apply the uvula
in the next joint it will get flattened
and again so this is another visible
light and then the UV light it will once
again it will get actually the flat end
and again the visible light the bending
will start so that's how this whole ring
can actually make it smooth movement
from one side to the other by
successively making its joints convene
or transforming between C's and trans
configuration so this is an interesting
case of an active smart body now in
terms of the electro active polymers if
we compare the electroactive polymers
with the other polymers like
shape-memory alloys and electro active
ceramics you'd see that electroactive
polymers keeps the maximum amount of
strain that's why we have the highest
actually potential of application
related to these it gives about 10% of
strain as you can see here on the other
hand shape-memory alloys can give about
8 or same strain and it has a short
fatigue life also so which means you
cannot really use it for a very long
time and in it to active ceramics that
we have earlier discussed that gives a
much smaller actually percentage of
strain even though it doesn't have and
doesn't suffer for a shorter fatigue
life now the only catch is that the
force is less here for example in terms
of stress maximum stress it can generate
seas about 3 MPA compare that with the
shape-memory alloys which has about 700
mpa and you can easily understand the
changes in electroactive polymers in
somewhere in between it is having about
30 to 40 MPA if you compare the reaction
speed the reaction speed is also equally
fast like the electro active ceramics
that is between micro second to second
on the other hand the shape-memory
alloys are slower they have second to
kind of a actually reaction speed
density wise they are very low density
that's why there is very low weight
penalty by using this type of actuators
they are almost close to water density
of water in comparison to that SFA's are
heavier in attractive ceramics are also
heavier the driving voltage is not very
high it's about 2 to 7 volt whereas for
SMA also it's not very high volt or this
not mention here and electro active
ceramics are eight you require actually
quite a very high large voltage now in
terms of the consume power you can see
that these ones are having about milli
watts of power there are all others are
acquired watts of power which means this
leads very low amount of power fracture
toughness wise also they are resilient
and lastik on the other hand ceramics
are very very precise so an overall
comparison tells us that these kind of
electroactive polymers are far better
placed in comparison to the SMS or in
comparison to the electro ceramics as
far as we are considering their
application in terms of robotics
manipulation devices etc they also have
a very interesting history of
development let us try to see that how
these kind of materials have evolved we
will talk about the evolution of
electroactive polymer now one of the
very important name in this evaluation
is Ron say
you know about Ron's them from his
discovery of x-ray for which he got his
Nobel Prize now in 1880 Ronson carried
out a very unique experiment in which he
has applied electric field through the
thickness of a rubber band having one
end fixed like this end is fixed and a
mass at
to each other in the free act and what
he found is that as he is applying the
electric field the rubber band is
thinning in this section you can see
that with the help of needle like you
know probes he has applied the electric
field and it is thinning in this region
and as a result of it because the rubber
is actually incompressible in nature so
that total volume has to remain same so
as it is thinning here it actually
expands in the longitudinal direction so
it is thinning and it is expanding
thickness direction swimming and it is
expanding in the longitudinal direction
in order to keep the volume constant so
that was a very interesting phenomena
that was observed and you know really
discussed by Keplinger
and this very interesting PNAS paper in
2010
now that 1880 experiment possibly is the
fast on any electroactive polymer it is
also unique in terms of the experiment
because in this case the rubber was you
may say like a naked rubber there is no
electrode that was actually there
so simply directly the charge is
actually provided to the system now in
such systems there is one danger however
and the danger is also known as pulling
instability so what is this pulling
instability if I consider an elastomer
actuator which is subjected to high
voltage the elastomer will thin down
however the same voltage induces an
increasing electric field in the
elastomer and so an increasing
attractive force between the oppositely
charged electrons and this oppositely
charged electrons they are basically
bringing the two sides closer so that is
why it is called the pooling voltage and
at the pulley voltage there is a
positive feedback that will happen and
the elastomer will theme down
drastically finally it will result in
electrical bread
of the system let us look into some of
the other developments so as has been
shown here by Keplinger
in his unique PNAS paper that you can
actually develop a three-dimensional
structure based on an electrical poly
bar and in these you do you do not apply
any electrode essentially because the
electrodes will create the pooling
instability on the other hand you apply
high voltage through these needles much
the same way as originally rod gain at
plane I had planned so you apply the
high voltage to the needle and as you
can see that as you are applying it
there is these expansion happening in
the system and you can see that as you
are increasing the voltage you can
almost get from an angle to a very flat
structure so this is something that is
kind of a rediscovery of the Rajan's
experiment on an electric polygon there
are many other electrical polymers which
was discovered after Rajan's discovery
and interestingly each one of them has a
kind of a 50 year approximately time of
a frequency between successive
discoveries let us look into those other
discoveries of electroactive polymers in
the evolution of EAP ego cheese
discovery plays a very interesting role
in 1995 Iguchi prepared in new material
which is produced from natural regime it
is also known as Brazil regime from
Karen Mubarak so it's the Brazil wax
that's how it is generally known as and
beeswax so he has mixed these two and
where strains are solidified by cooling
while subjected to DC bias effect and
what he noticed is that if this kind of
solid electric it will generate voltage
when stress is applied and it will have
the reverse behavior of being de for
so that is what was the discovery of the
Iguchi of a new type of you know kind of
a polymeric system which is a mix of
Karen Luba and the beeswax which
actually shows a high degree of
deformation and also the other effect
that is if you you know apply stress you
are going to generate voltage you
remember we call this to be a direct
effect and we call this one to be a
reverse effect so both of them
Iguchi was able to discover in this
particular material now followed by
these there are significant discoveries
by kawaii 1969 and this is a entirely
new inorganic you may say not exactly if
we say that synthetic piezoelectric
material so this is a synthetic one
because the last one that we had
discussed was derived from natural
organic material so this is a synthetic
organic material which is known as poly
vinylidene fluoride okay in fact because
of the presence of fluorine some it has
some inorganic contributions but it's a
synthetic essentially polymer poly
vinylidene fluoride and it has shown a
large degree of piezoelectric activity
now at a later stage you kada
actually developed a piezoelectric
biopolymers on the basis of this PVD
another important landmark was from the
Kachin ski and his group in israel who
have developed actually responsive gels
but these chains were mostly camo
mechanically activated so these are gel
polymers and this shows a very high
degree of shrinkage or swelling that
means there is a bulk volume change in
the presence of an acidic or alkaline
environment
now joining these two concepts in 1980
Hokkaido University people have fast
developed responsive gels which are
based on in
through chemical activation and
following that line subsequently asada
and PC he has developed in 1989 they
have developed polymers which can
demonstrate very large strain under
relatively low activation voltage which
was followed by Varco a in 2010 in terms
of the development of electro active
polymers on a specific polymeric system
called napier now the question is where
am I going to use this kind of an
electroactive polymer why are they where
I am repeatedly telling that it is so
important in terms of a robotic
development well one of the very
important application of this type of
polymer is in terms of locomotive
locomotions our generation of locomotive
forces
so let's look into that how in robotics
you know gradually this transfer from
motor to motor less locomotion has taken
words if we look into the animal
locomotion based inspirations you will
see that starting from the motor best
legged robots like this kind of a
quadruped eight stair climb but I can
six or a snake like a CMR five or for
that matter a bipedal walking robot M -
you have also seen as he moves which are
all basically motor driven some of them
are servo motors or other Russell s DC
motors but these are all water driven
systems but taking inspiration from
animal locomotions gradually these
locomotions
have been achieved by a different manner
this different manner is if you study
the animal locomotion you will see that
they essentially use muscles for
actually motion and we'll call it
actuation now these muscles are attached
to bones by the tendons and the muscles
contract to move our bones by pulling on
them so you have to keep in mind that
these muscles
contract and he was they can only pool
they cannot push that is one of the
important aspect to be kept in mind so
this is why in any joint the muscle cell
used in pairs one muscle of the pair
contracts to move the body part and the
other muscle at that time actually
relaxes and later on the other muscle
actually contracts to return the body
part back to the original position so
the muscles that work like these are
called antagonistic pairs so we have
basically two types of muscles called
agonist muscle and antibodies muscle
well if you look at your own elbow for
example what you will see is that in our
own elbow if we actually move our arm
okay if let us say that we want to pull
our arm you would see that this is the
part which is actually fully so this is
the part which is actually agonist
you know the muscle and the back part is
actually antagonist so that's how the
motion of this giant is actually
happening by constantly the pulling of
the two biceps and the triceps muscle so
it's a very similar kind of a concept
that will be actually applying in the
case of these smart muscles also let us
see how we can apply these antagonistic
actuation by using
shape-memory alloy now here is an
example in which people have developed a
shape memory alloy based you know you
can see the agonist and antagonist
motions okay so do we so ever is pulling
these agonist and the other one is
relaxing so antagonist and look at the
trajectory that it is creating so the
other side you care you have seen that
agonist and antagonist motion and you
can see here that it's a nice rectangle
that has been drawn very similar things
is done for almost all our muscles okay
and by varying these pairs motion you
can actually do it faster or slower
there is another very interesting
application of this agonist antagonist
motion by using actually electroactive
polymers by our group in Switzerland
here PA group and they call this to be
blimp
so this blimp is essentially a
pressurized helium filled is a big fish
which is like 8 meter long and it's
actuated by
electroactive polymer using this agonist
antagonist configuration and it is
designed to work at various frequencies
voltage and phase shift between the body
and the tail actuation so you can see
that this is a a tweeter big and you can
see these muscles you know which inside
it's a very flexible inflated structure
so first they are pressurizing helium
gas into it and you can see that how
these muscles are working here and you
can see that by these inner agonist
antagonist working of the blimps EAP
electroactive polymers how they are very
nicely you know moving a detail as well
as the body in the space and is
generating the motion this is in the
laboratory you can see that how this
motion is happening also they have
tested such a system in outdoor so you
can say that this is possibly the fast
organic moiety robot which is a
fish-like robot which is based on the
muscles which are essentially
bio-inspired in nature you can see the
neck tractive polymers here so this is
where they are actually testing this
entire system outside and you can see
that how nicely this is manual varying
controlling its protein
so that's one of the example of the
electro active polymers now we will talk
about some of the classifications of the
electric two polymers that they
themselves can be grouped into two times
electronic EAP which is driven by
electric field or Coulomb force and
ionic EAP which change the shape our my
mobility or delusion of actually aisles
so as the name itself is suggesting and
it is also only true that electronic
Yippies are much faster the Coulomb
force base tables whereas ionic
guillotines are actually slower because
they depend on the mobility or the
diffusion of the ions which is a slower
process but of course they can generate
a much larger change in the system in
fact the last example that I have shown
you is based on the ionic yes now
electronic earpiece which is also known
as a Yeti
they are like dielectric EAP one of the
example another is retrospective paper
ferroelectric polymer and liquid
crystalline Ostrow on the other hand the
IEA peas are like ionic polymer gels
ionic polymer metal composite like I
PMC's Nephi on two ponds Flemmi on etc
then there are some conductive polymers
and even carbon nanotubes so this are
the groups which shows the ionic electro
active polygon we really now focus on
the ionic electroactive polymers because
as I told you that they are the
best-performing material as far as the
large deformation goes and also as far
as the power consumption goes they
consume very little amount of power and
so they have the near future in terms of
developing different types of motions in
robotic arm you know limbs are so called
arms and legs of a robot
so let's look into the ionic polymer
matrix composites or this kind of you
know ionic electric
- polymers if I compare between the EAP
czar I appeals that's what I was telling
you that ye a piece needs a high
activation voltage whereas ionic air
peas need very low voltage and they have
this earpiece have a high energy density
and rapid response time in comparison to
these I ApS have relatively slow
response times but amount of deformation
is much more and they perform better
under weight condition so if you look at
one of these ionic in attractive polymer
which is IP MC that is ionic polymer
metal composite the example here is the
natrium now this type of material they
can actually consist of a polymer matrix
which is sandwiched between two metallic
layers now nappy on specifically is
actually a pre fluorinated copolymer of
polytetrafluoroethylene or PTFE and a
pre fluorinated vinay if our sulfinate
now you have actually come across PTFE s
in your day to day life when we talk
about non-stick pans etc so PTFE
actually gives the strength to the
material so PTFE is one part as i told
you there is a copolymer so one
copolymers are made of two polymers so
one part is PTFE which gives the string
and the other part is this
perfluorinated renal ether sulfur so
this part fluorinated vinyl ethers are
heavily fluorinated essentially and it
has a sulfonate grew that sulfonate grew
is actually the source of polarity in
the system and not doubt that these
perforate groups has OAH - in it so it
means that it has a fixed o h- attached
to it always okay so this is so if you
have a material which is a combination
of the two
and then if you put them in an electrode
then you can actually generate a fixed
negative charge in one side that's what
you know is important in this kind of
material so you can see here that there
is this electrode here and there are
this fixed negative charges which is
generated with the help of the sulfonate
groups now this fixed negative charges
the moment I attach these cathode what
will happen is that the water molecules
that is present inside the IPF see they
will start to go towards massively
towards these negative you know
direction the cat so as there is the
driving of the water molecules this side
will Bend there are more water molecule
one side will they flow so probably this
one you are getting a bent thing and
with respect to time some water molecule
will back diffuse which actually talks
about a relaxation so a small relaxation
will happen but essentially you can
generate a large bending in this kind of
materials but of course one of the
precondition is that it needs to be wet
because then only the water molecules
movement towards these cathode will
create this large hydrophilic expansion
in the system now depending on the type
of lectures you can actually generate
the positive and negative bending in IBM
C's so as you can see that this is a
kind of a typical IBM see that so it
looks like under you know normal
condition and under bent condition and
you can get a large deformation out of
this system and with a low actuation
voltage and fast response you can
actually generate by changing to
different types of electrodes or an IPF
see you can generate two different types
of curvature see you can generate a
downward and you know this downward and
what kind of curvature so you can
generate double curvature in the system
by using two different types of
electrodes in the system so that is one
of the advantage of the system now this
kind of IPM sea based actuators they are
used for single link manipulator
multi-link refers vibration generation
control and for barbecue later
so most of the local motion generation
can be done with the help of this type
of IBMC based actuation system so some
of the applications you can see that
like this is in terms of a dust wiper
you can see that how these dust wipe are
actually works in terms of cleaning in
fact last Reformation and then there are
other applications also like these
sample handling in robotics this I
already told you in different
applications are possible particularly
for the planetary applications people
have already used this type of electro
active polymers now I will just conclude
this particular session length of the
lecture by comparing because we now are
in a process that we can summarize
actually that the different smart
materials besa besa biological system in
terms of their performance so this is
what we will be doing in the final
concluding slides if I compare mammalian
skeleton muscles with initially the
field activated electronic electrically
polymers and then we will compare them
with the other groups of ionic
electrical polymers now the mammalian
skeletal muscles they produce large
strips how much we always say large in
the quantification here is about 20
percent and the stress is however
moderate about 350 kilo Pascal stiffness
can be varied but the well that is used
in terms of the nutrition that is a high
energy fuel efficiency is near about 40
percent and they have a good word
density
about 40 kilo joule per kg and they have
a high cycle life because they can
actually regenerate owns these advantage
is that this type of material is not an
engineering material and they have a
narrow temperature range of operation in
the high temperature they cannot work
and they explains energy to maintain
force
you know without moving so that's one of
the problem that they don't have any cat
state now however interesting thing to
learn is that they have a very
interesting three dimensional system
which integrates both the sensor energy
delivery you wasted removal local energy
supply and repair mechanisms all in one
pack that is something that kind of a
compactness we are still not able to
achieve as far as the synthetic you know
materials are concerned now let's look
into the field activated electronic
groups fast among the synthetic
materials the first group is the field
activated electronic group like PVDF
high mechanical energy density
relatively large actuation force I make
mega Pascal range can operate for a long
time in new condition and rapid response
about millisecond range and can hold
strain under DC activation so they are
all electrically activated disadvantages
produce mostly mono polar type of
actuation and it requires a high voltage
so high voltage is the real real
disadvantage of the system in comparison
to that if I consider the dielectric
elastomer us like some of the examples I
told you in terms of wrong the initial
experiment and the other in a stahma's
they can they actually show large scales
it can be as large as up to three eighty
percent much larger than the mammalian
skeletal muscles so that's what is very
large stress is moderate only several
MPA but still it is comparable with
respect to mammalian muscle
not work density and moderate to high
bandwidth not very - this has a very
high bandwidth the field activated
groups low cost low current and good
electromechanical coupling now the
disadvantage is a what is that you need
to generate high voltage locally
of course typically requires a DC DC
conversion compliant and it's quite soft
prestressing mechanisms add substantial
mass and volume because prestressing is
important in terms of its movement you
remember that the initial Longinus
experiment there was a mass that was
used to pre stretch the rubber back now
there are potential to lower fields
using highly directed materials and
based on readily available wedge so this
is good one but still it has certain
disadvantages if I consider the
ferroelectric polymers then the strain
level is less only about 7% stress is
high 45mph in stress quite high you know
much much higher in comparison to things
which is in kph very I want density
stiff and strong coupling it also
requires high voltage and the cycle life
is one of the problem because there is
some fatigue that is observed and it has
a limited temperature range so here the
lower voltage and fields people are
trying to achieve now you know in the
few electric polymers and the energy
density is in favor and small devices
with high frequency in something that is
under focus let us look into the other
the ionic polymer group which we have
discussed at the end they have
bi-directional actuation and they have
by stability and they require low
voltage now this by stability is a very
interesting concept it means that this
kind of structures can have two
different stability
configurations and it can very fast
switch between these two different
stability configurations the
disadvantage is that they always require
some electrolyte because there is some
motion of the ions that has to occur
voltage requirement is not very high but
this electrolyte presence is important
under wet condition generally that so it
requires a protection from evaporation
low electromechanical coupling and
specifically for ipm C does not hold
strain under DC voltage for conductive
polymers they can generate high stress
but strain is moderate low voltage and
these are stiffer polymers but they have
low electromechanical coupling which
means not much of electrical energy will
be converted to mechanical energy they
are promising for low voltage
applications also there are C NTS which
require which gives a high stress low
voltage but the strain is low and I
PMC's which actually takes a low voltage
very low voltage and large displacement
but it has a low coupling steam in terms
of efficiency and usually it has no
catch state that means consumes energy
in the holding position and requires
encapsulation but it has a great
potential as bulk material
you know properties you know they can be
to improved with individual nanotubes so
this is a comparison between all the
different types of these electroactive
polymers versus the muscles so with this
lecture I will conclude these smart
materials and their applications in
terms of the development of organic
might robots in the next series of
lectures we will look into the cognitive
aspects of system and particularly we
look into the living system and the
cognitive aspect of it but we will start
with the say for example the description
of the hi
you know Joe in terms of the cognitive
capabilities that is the brain itself so
we will discuss about these parts and
because that is also a very essential
element in our organism well whatever
off thank you
[Music]
[Music]
