noc20-me92-lec06_ Architecture of the Brain- Continued

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
Architecture of the Brain- ContinuedWe will study the following in this lecture: The hidden brain elements Brain-stem sub elements Epithalmus and Pinial body Hippocampus Gradation of the human brain Development of CHREST Activity Questions: 1. 2.
Good morning students, welcome to the Foundations of Cognitive Robotics.
In my last lecture, I told you about the top part of the human brain.
Now today, I am going to take a look inside what is there in a human brain.
Some of the things that are hidden from the top, we are going to find out that what is
there inside.
To begin with, I will first talk about how this entire brain system has evolved.
There are some parts of the brain which are quite primitive part.
Some parts which are relatively more modern and some parts which are very very modern.
Generally, it is considered that this part of the brain, this is more or less the primitive
part of the brain.
So, this is the primitive part, very primitive part.
You can even see it in some of the very primitive organs, organisms also, so this is the primitive
part.
Whereas, there is some part which is somewhere here, you may say that which is relatively
in the middle phase of development, so it is not very modern but it is something which
has developed after the primitive part.
So, this is relatively modern, I would say and I just put it as relatively modern, relatively
and there is some part which is very modern, so this is the part which is very very modern.
You can just call it to be a very modern part of the brain.
Now when I have discussed about the brain structure in my last class, I have mostly
focused on this very modern part of the brain that is the teleencephalon part of the brain.
Now of course, if I look at it from the other way that is from the primitive side, then
there is this important part which we will be calling as the brainstem part of it which
includes these areas like the hindbrain, the midbrain, so that is the brainstem part of
it.
This is what we will be focusing more today, so the area which is above the spinal cord
and then on top of that the brainstem part there are also areas which are like diencephalons
and also there are some parts on top of that which are you know some part of the teleencephalons
which also we will be discussing today which are all relatively modern, so that also we
will be discussing today.
So, these are the three things, one by one we will start from the very primitive part,
we will talk about the brainstem part where we have these rhomboencephalon part of the
hindbrain and the mesencephalon part of the midbrain, then the diencephalon and then we
will gradually go towards the top where we have the basal ganglia and we have cingulates
cortex and such areas, so we will talk about them next.
Now, if I actually look into the different brains, if I try to compare the brains of
say something like the very higher order animals like say the mammals and compare it with reptiles
like say turtles, now you would see that these three important parts of the brain that is
this teleencephalon, midbrain and the cerebellum part of it, they are mostly present in almost
all of these, okay. So, it is not that the mammals are only having teleencephalon, the
same is also present in birds, you know it is also present in turtles, it is also present
in amphibians and in fishes and the same thing is true for the midbrain and the cerebellum
part, only thing is that the proportion of each one of them is quite different from species
to species, so that is something that we have to be very careful about when we look into it.
If we look at how a turtle responds and also if you look at that how for example,
a mammal like monkey is responding, if you compare between the two, you would see that
in case of a turtle and in case of a macaque, the common part is that both takes let us say,
the input from the vision both take it towards the hippocampus, so that is common between both
of them. However, whenever we are talking about a monkey, it goes through so many different regions
in the brain, so the path of the signal is quite complicated. On the other hand, if you look at the
turtle, that path is very simple and straightforward relatively in comparison with the macaque.
So, that is where you may say that even if both of them are having the same elements like say,
the teleencephalon where the hippocampus is there or the you know sensory organs but in one case,
they actually go through a vast many regions of the brain, different ganglias or ganglia like you
know nuclei are involved in it whereas, in the turtles case that is not involved. So,
the visual association is much less that is what possibly is the major difference between the way
the signals are processed by the turtle and the signals are processed by the macaque.
Now, all these things have very important consequences as far as the behavior of
different types of animals are concerned. They are cognitively different because of
that they have different ratios or proportions of the brain areas and also they have different
associations of networks in the brain area. Now, let us look into the brain structure and
let us see that what are the hidden elements and then we will go back to the slides and we will
see how we can correlate between the two. If I look at the brain structure, this is
what if you remember we have discussed in the last class also, you can see that if you try
to remember that this was the prefrontal cortex and this is the frontal lobe part and then you
can see the back side we have the parietal lobe and at the very back we have the cerebellum part
ok. This is all as far as if you take the brain if you look at it from the top this is what you
are going to see. Now, let us try to remove it and let us see what is there inside.
So, let us try to do that very carefully and let us try to separate through the longitudinal
fissure you remember this is the longitudinal fissure. Let us try to separate one brain out
at least that is what I would be trying to do and I will keep the rest out. Now,
if you look at this part which is you know you can still remember that this is where was our
frontal cortex areas and you can still remember that in the back side we had this temporal lobe
part of it and what is there inside which is hidden is actually the brain stem part of it.
So, you can see that in the brain stem we have these areas which is known as medulla of lancata,
then we have this area which is known as the pons area, then we have the midbrain here this
you can see this is the midbrain area and then you can see this beak here this is the area which
contains the hypothalamus that is the easiest way to note down the hypothalamus and this is
always indicating towards a gland here which is so very important pituitary gland which actually
controls the behavior you know in terms of the hormonal behaviors.
Now, and on top of these hypothalamus we have the thalamus here and in this side we have the
pineal gland which contains the melatonin. So, this is a very primitive structure of the brain
and beyond these we will be getting more and more relatively modern structure I will talk
about them one by one, but this is something that we have to keep in our mind that the brain stem
and the cerebellum which was somewhere in this side this were some of the very early developments
of the brain. If you look at the brain then from bottom up then as I told you that this is the
brain stem part which starts with the pons you know pons is somewhere here pons means a bridge
so that is somewhere here. So, below that you have this medulla oblongata. So,
medulla oblongata then pons and then the midbrain and then the thalamus. So,
that is the very primitive part. Now, from there if you look at this
like something more we have added here what we have added here is the hippocampus and the
amygdalas and then from here if you go further up you can see the fluid ventricles, fluid
ventricles are needed to supply the nutrition to the brain that is added. Then if we further
go here what we can see that from the fluid ventricles we are actually coming to the basal
ganglia part of it. So, once we are in the basal ganglia we are nearly reaching towards the modern
part of the brain and then from basal ganglia on top of it we have the white matters as I told you
earlier that these are highly myelinated nerves and then above the white matter we have the gray
matter the cortex part of it and you can see this cerebellum in the bottom. So,
the best way to actually keep an idea about the brain structure is thus you can practice it that
how to grow it from the bottom till the top. Now, once you practice that how this entire
brain from the lower part which is connected to the peripheral nervous system through the
spinal cord how from there the brain stem forms midbrain etc and then beyond that how it is
connected once you know you have got an overall idea about it then we can actually let us try
to go one by one inside this element. So, let us first focus on the brain stem itself
on different parts of the brain stem different components and what is their functionalities.
If I look at the brain stem we can see that this is the area that we are referring to and a very
important area here is pons and also the medulla oblongata is somewhere here and the midbrain. So,
that is the part that we are talking about which is basically posterior or the you know the back
side part of the brain adjoining and structurally continuous with the spinal cord.
Now, this part the entire brain stem part has important you know roles in terms of
the regulation of cardiac and respiratory function, consciousness and the sleep cycle. So,
all these things you know whatever is the autonomous part of the nervous system they
are definitely controlled from here. So, it consists of the three regions as I told you
medulla oblongata, pons and the midbrain and this is indeed even if it is very primitive this is
indeed a very important part of the brain as all the nerve connections from the motor and
sensory systems of the cortex from the top that also passes through it to communicate
with the peripheral nervous system. Apart from the fact that it controls many
of the voluntary movements of the nerves but also you have to also make it a point to see
that all the sensory nerves the somatosensory connections they are actually coming through
this medulla oblongata and then the pons and the midbrain and then they are coming to the
different regions through the thalamus to the different regions of the cortex.
So, essentially you know everything that is happening in the top part of the brain they
are all getting connected through this area. So, some of the sensor signals this part itself
processes and for some it works like the passage the connectors from which this all
the signals will be going towards the top part of the brain that is something you have to keep
in our mind. The first important sub element of the brain stem is the medulla oblongata.
It is the lower half of the brain stem which controls the autonomic functions and connects
the higher levels of the brain to the spinal cord even though it makes up just 0.5 percent of the
total brain weight but yet it has a very very important role. So, it regulates some of the
very basic functions that is needed to leave the autonomic nervous system which includes
respiration, cardiac function, vasodilation and all natural reflexes like vomiting, coughing,
seizing and swallowing. Say for example, the respiration is carried out by the you know
this kind of with the help of chemoreceptors, cardiac centers are actually controlled through
sympathetic and parasympathetic systems which this medulla controls, vasometer through the
pressure receptors, baroreceptors, the blood pressure and the reflex centers through the
they control these all these reflex actions that I was talking about.
On the top of the medulla oblongata, we have the pons region which is a relay station between
the forebrain and cerebellum that passes the sensory information from the periphery to the
thalamus and it is a Latin word of bridge because it is joining between the thalamus area midbrain
thalamus area and the area below that is the medulla oblongata and the spinal cord. Now,
it also has nuclei that regulates sleep for example, respiration, swallowing, bladder control,
hearing, equilibrium, taste, eye movement, facial expressions, facial sensation and posture.
So, here the pons control some of the non-autonomous sensory systems also not just
the autonomous sensory and it also contains the sleep paralysis center of the brain and
plays a role in generating the dreams that is about the pons. Now, we come to the midbrain
region. So, we have talked about the medulla, we have talked about the pons and now we are
in the midbrain region. Midbrain or so called mesencephalon is a portion of the central nervous
system which is associated with things like vision, hearing, motor controls, sleep and wake
system, arousal and of course, the temperature regulation. In fact, this system is one of the
most archipelagic in origin sharing its general architecture not only with our other primate you
know other groups of primate species, but also with many of the vertebrates also and a very
important region in the midbrain where we have the substantial nigra, they actually creates
dopamine and that plays a role in motivation and habituation of species from humans to the most
elementary animals such as insects. So, that is one of the important source from midbrain
onwards the dopamine production. So, that is the importance of the midbrain.
We have talked about the midbrain part which is somewhere here and now we will be going to
the thalamus part of the brain which plays a very very important role I will tell you later
on in terms of cognitive processes. So, it is in the top of the midbrain and it is below the you
know the cortex areas etcetera. So, somewhere in between which connects between the lower part of
the brain and the upper part of the brain that is where is the thalamus is coming into the picture.
The thalamus as you can see that it has two parts in it the right thalamus and the left thalamus and
it is just in the middle part it is just at the central part which connects between the cortex
part and the cerebellum and on the other hand the brainstem and everything. So,
it is located above the brainstem and between the cerebral cortex and midbrain which have
extensive nerve connections to both that is what is thalamus and it is the largest structure which
is in fact derived from the embryonic diencephalon part of it. You remember I have talked about that
just below telencephalon we have the diencephalon. So, this is the diencephalon part from which
actually these you know the thalamus is actually derived. Now, the main function of the thalamus
is to relay motor and sensory signals to the cerebral cortex of course, as I told you that
it works like a junction station and except the olfactory signals. Olfactory signals are
directly connected to the brain the cortex part, but except that all other sensory signals actually
travel through the they have to travel through the thalamus that is very important.
Now, this thalamus also have some additional parts outside that is the epithalamus region and the
most important thing is the pineal body and the habenula nuclei and caudate nucleus. Out of them,
I will just only talk about the pineal body which is a very important one in terms of of
course, reptiles it plays a very important role in terms of the color change for example,
for the higher order animals also pineal body has some important functions.
Now, you can see the position let us say in that entire picture you can see that
the this particular gland the pineal gland is somewhere here you can always see that
it is opposite to the hypothalamus that big birds big and opposite to it you can see the small
region here that is where is the pineal gland. Now, this is part of what you call epithalamus
and it is a dorsal posterior segment of the diencephalon. So, it is the posterior the
backside of diencephalon and that includes the habenula and other interconnecting fibers also.
So, the pineal gland which is a very small pine cone shaped endocrine gland and these
actually controls the you know hormone called melatonin and this hormone related to you know
serotonin it is secreted by the pineal gland and it stimulates color change in the skin of reptiles.
In case of mammals the same gland is actually involved in terms of the sleep-wake and the
reproductive cycles in mammals they have a the pineal gland has a very important role to play.
So, this is in one of the epithalamus systems that this pineal gland comes into picture.
We have seen the thalamus part of the brain now let us look into this birds big part of it which
is known as hypothalamus all our well-being our homeostasis that is controlled by the hypothalamus
it is also one of the very primitive parts of the brain. So, let us look into the functions
of the hypothalamus and as I told you that in from close very close to the beak we have
pituitary gland which is actually controlled. So, hypothalamus controls the pituitary glands
they actually sequence the hormones and that actually controls many of our organic behavior.
So, let us look into the hypothalamus. Hypothalamus as I told you the main role
is to keep the body in homeostasis condition. So, this is a homeostasis condition that means
your body temperature your things like for example, appetite, heart rate, blood pressure
everything it is kept under control by the homeostasis. So, it actually gives you a sort
of healthful balanced bodily state that is the role of the hypothalamus. So,
it has a very very important role and as you can see I told you that this big region that
is where we have the hypothalamus and it is so close to the pituitary gland that is what it
controls directly. So, it is a part of the part where you know many essential functions of the
body such as the body temperature, the thrust, appetite, weight control, emotions, sleep cycles,
sex drive, childbirth, BP, heart rate, production of digestive juices and the balancing of body
fluids these are all the role of the hypothalamus. So, it has a very important role to play.
Now, hypothalamus has actually it is not a single monolithic thing it has many important what you
call nuclei inside the hypothalamus. Let us look into this nuclei. So, some of the important nuclei
are for example, this nucleus paraventricular nucleus. So, this is one of the important
nucleus paraventricular nucleus then also you have dorsomedial nucleus, mammillary body,
then there is a ventromedial nucleus. So, and here there is a supraoptic nucleus.
So, all these they play different important roles. For example, whatever you know information the
contextual information that comes through your cerebral cortex, amygdala and the
hippocampus region that actually comes to the hypothalamus. And these different regions that
I have talked about they actually also gets input from the sensory inputs. The sensory inputs are
coming from the bottom side. So, sensory inputs are coming towards the hypothalamus and from the
cortex you are getting the input. So, from both the sides you are getting the inputs based on it,
you are actually taking a decision and that what is my this state tells me that what will be my set
point for example, set point I will call it. And so, let us just try to keep this in our
mind that this is the part which will be part of the set point and this is the part which are
going to give us the inputs. So, we compare between the set point and the input that is
what the hypothalamus is going to do and then it takes the actions and these actions go to
the visceral motors, somatic motors, neoendocrines, behavioral responses.
So, some actions goes towards the motors and towards the muscles and some towards the
secretions of different types of hormones that further controls the organs. So,
that is the role that is played by the hypothalamus. We have talked about thalamus
and the hypothalamus. Now, we will gradually enter towards the cortical region, the cerebral cortex
region of the brain and we will be just at the base of the cerebral cortex region of the brain.
So, if you look at it what I am talking about we have covered all these regions and now,
we will be talking about this region where just at the base we are having some people
call it as a limbic system, the border system, but a very important part some of the very
important parts of the border systems will be the three things. One is that we will talk about here
the basal ganglia part and we will also talk about here the hippocampus part somewhere here
and we will talk about on top of it just below corpus callosum we have actually what you call
the cingulate particularly the anterior cingulate ok. So, the entire cingulate cortex that is the
part beyond which the actually all other cortex that I had already discussed the frontal,
prefrontal, parietal cortex etcetera is there. So, we have just then reached the cortex part
of the brain. Let us look into their functions and their you know characteristics.
One of the most important part here is the basal ganglia part which is essentially a
group of subcortical nuclei of varied origin and you will find generally in the brains of
vertebrates including the humans and this is situated at the base of the forebrain and at
the top at the top of the midbrain that is where is the basal ganglia part of it. Now,
this is associated with a variety of functions. It controls for example,
the voluntary motor movements you will see that if this is lost in many of our voluntary actions
that are lost. Procedural learning for example, habit learning, eye movements, some people say
good bit of cognition and emotion these are the things particularly there is an area which is
adjacent to the basal ganglia is the amygdala that controls many of our emotions.
So, what happens if the basal ganglia does not work then you get two different types of disorders
like the Parkinson's disease and the Huntington's disease. Now, in the case of Parkinson's disease
you will be having a gradual loss of the ability to initiate the movement whereas,
in case of Huntington's disease you will be unable to prevent parts of the body from
moving unintentionally. So, that is what is the Huntington's disease if this is in fact a very
fatal disease. Now, in most regions of the brain the predominant classes of neurons actually
glutamate as the neurotransmitter and it actually have a excitatory effect.
On the other hand in basal ganglia great majority of neurons in basal ganglia actually use something
called GABA gamma amino butyric acid and that works like a neurotransmitter that have
inhibitory effects on their target. So, by nature this is somewhat different because it works on
the GABA. So, if you just see some of these basic disease for example, what happens in
the Parkinson's disease. So, you can see it in a very small video.
Parkinson's disease or PD is the second most common neurodegenerative disorder after
Alzheimer's disease and affects 1% of individuals over the age of 65. It is classified as a
hypokinetic movement disorder and occurs due to degeneration of dopaminergic neurons that
project from the substantia nigra in the midbrain to the basal ganglia. The initial
precipitant of neuronal death is unknown and by the time symptoms emerge between 50 to 80% of
dopaminergic neurons have already died. The cardinal features of PD are tremor, rigidity,
akinesia or bradykinesia and postural instability easily remembered with the mnemonic TRAP. The
most essential feature for diagnosis of PD is bradykinesia which is characterized by a reduction
in both speed and amplitude of voluntary movement. This is most striking during repetitive
movements like finger tapping where taps are slowed and become progressively smaller in
amplitude or writing where letter size decreases across the page also known as micrographia.
Bradykinesia is also manifested as a loss of facial expression or hypomimia, reduced
volume or hypophonia and slowing with a variety of other activities including walking, dressing
and turning in bed. The tremor in PD is typically a unilateral rhythmic resting tremor between 4
to 6 Hertz and can classically start as a pill rolling tremor of the thumb and forefinger.
Rigidity is an involuntary increase in muscle tone present throughout the range of movement
and can be tested by passively moving the arm, neck or leg. If rigidity is smooth and
consistent throughout it is called lead pipe rigidity. If however there is a ratchet like
quality it is called cogwheeling which is thought to be due to rigidity superimposed
on an underlying tremor. Parkinsonism also causes characteristic gait abnormalities like stooped
posture, small shuffling steps, reduced arm swing and freezing. So make sure to ask your
patients and watch out for falls. PD is treated with levodopa which is a precursor of dopamine,
the neurotransmitter that is deficient in PD. An excellent response to levodopa in a patient
with asymmetric tremor predominant Parkinsonism is supportive of the diagnosis of PD. It is
important to keep in mind that PD is the most common form of Parkinsonism but patients may
develop Parkinsonism from other causes including medications such as antipsychotics, other
degenerative disorders such as multiple system atrophy or progressive supranuclear palsy and
Wilson's disease which causes copper deposition in the basal ganglia. Alright so we have reached
up to the basal ganglia which is at the base of the cortex. Now in the cortex particularly a near
the temporal lobe we have a very important region called hippocampus which is very very important
in terms of the memory of the brain system. So let us look into the hippocampus region.
We will now look into the hippocampus region which has a major role in learning and memory
and though even though it is situated in the temporal lobe it is essentially a part of the
border part of the brain in the limbic lobe and it has also roles in terms of spatial navigation,
emotional behavior so not just the memory and regulation of some of the hypothalamic functions
and it is the biggest source of the theta region. This is important you have to keep in your mind
at a later stage we will see in terms of the origin of the theta region when it is used.
Hippocampus is one of the biggest source in terms of the theta region. You can see the position of
the hippocampus here so it is you know that hypothalamus region and then on top of it you
can see the hippocampus. So that is the way so it is you know this is it has connections
with thalamus and also with the hypothalamus this entire region together you have the hippocampus.
Well the next important one is actually the cingulate cortex without which we cannot in
fact develop the cognitive model of brain. So cingulate cortex plays a very important
role in developing the cognitive model of brain. Now this is on the medial side or inner side of
the cerebral cortex as I told you that cingulate inner side and it consists of cingulate gyrus
that is the top part upper part the peaks and its continuation into the cingulate sulcus.
So you remember I hope that the gyrus and the sulcus the peak and the valleys the peak
and the valleys. So both of them you know you will see in the cingulate cortex. Now
this is just above the corpus callosum on the medial side of the brain and although
it does not fall into any of these typically frontal parietal occipital part because it is
just above the corpus callosum, corpus callosum if you remember actually joins the left and the
right side of the brain etc. But it is an essential part of this limbic system.
It is used in for example things like error detection. Also it has a very important role
in social evaluation that means you know what is our role in the society it continuously testing.
Increased level of consciousness that is what without cingulate cortex you can think of it
and it has been shown that this area is greatly active in people who are emotionally more aware
than other people. This part is also responsible for things like pain, memory and learning which
are controlled in this region. We have talked about some of the hidden brain elements. We have
also earlier talked about the cortex. Now it is the combination of all of these things together
that actually makes the whole brain function. Towards this direction different people have
tried to develop different models. There are some very early models in 1960 where people
tried to actually you know we call it the McLean model where it is developed in terms of the brain
is developed as a tri-union model of three parts that is the reptile part of the brain,
then the paleomammal part of the brain and that is the very early mammal part of the brain and
then the primate part of the neomammal part of the brain. However today we know that these are
not exactly the same but we can still say as I told you earlier that like the brainstem part
and the midbrain part this is the part which is like you can consider it to be the primitive
part of the brain. Then you have the more and more as the evolution progress you get more and
more developed part on the top side of it. But still this model gives us some important
behavioral matching. So, even historically and it is a useful concept to begin with let us look
into this model and then we will see what are some of the more advanced model towards this
direction. If you think of the gradation of human brain as I told you this McLean's model
and that talks about this a tri-union triune brain for example okay the triune brain part
in evolution. Now it as I told you that they try to explain the brain in terms of three parts the
reptilian brain composed of the basal ganglia and the brainstem part which has the medulla oblongata
pons and midbrain etc and that is involved with all the primitive drives related to trust,
hunger, sexuality and territoriality as well as habits and procedural memory okay.
So, that is the one part reptilian brain then the paleomammal brain which includes the
hypothalamus, hippocampus, amygdala, cingulate cortex etc which is the center of our motivation
like you know emotions, memory, dopamines for example, motivation and behavior such as parenting
that was one of the suggestion. Of course, today we know that parenting is not only for the mammals
but also for the reptile birds for example there are these parenting behaviors and then this model
said that there are neomammalian parts consists of the neocortex which enables more higher order
things like language, abstraction, reasoning and planning. This is somewhat true that really the
cortex part the top part that is involved with many of these important parts of the work.
So, this was the first attempt to describe that how different parts of the brain are
involved with different nature of works. There are in fact some commonly studied
conscious and unconscious brain events on the basis of this. For example,
I you can see the whole list and you can just read it for your reference some of the conscious
brain events could be something like immediate memory, explicit cognition and things like you
know strategy control, things like rehearsed items in working memory, wakefulness and dreams,
intentional learning, normal vision. So, these are all part of the conscious brain events.
If you look at the unconscious brain events then longer term memory that is one of the
unconscious brain you do not know but it is happening continuously. Procedural memory,
the brain is keeping the procedural knowledge continuously in some area even without discussing
with you apparently. Automatic control for example, for all the automatic nervous systems
you know the parasympathetic nervous systems for example, then the deep sleep,
coma, sedation. So, these are the some of the things which are controlled by the unconscious
brain elements. So, brain events. So, this is what you know we can keep in our mind and you
can try to find out that what areas of the brain actually control the conscious versus
the unconscious brain events as a sort of an exercise.
We will now talk about three of the greatest minds in brain science who have actually who
have very important contributions in terms of developing the cognitive architecture of the
brain. As I always told you that if you have to develop a cognitive robot you have to understand
that what is the cognitive architecture of the brain itself. So, these three people have you
know phenomenal contribution in the field. Let us look into their proposed models and let us
look into some of the modern views towards that. We will first begin our journey with Francis
Crick. Many of you have heard of Francis Crick as the discoverer of DNA. In fact,
got his Nobel Prize for this, but between 1979 to 2003 Crick championed something else.
He worked with his collaborator Christoph Koch and he developed a framework for thinking about
the conscious mind where from the consciousness rises. His aim was to map all the concepts
associated with the concepts associated with the consciousness to properties of synapses to
properties of action potentials, action potentials and neurons. So, in fact, this is what is called
NCC neural correlates of consciousness in the brain. So, he is the first person who started
focusing on the fact that it is there is some biological connection between the consciousness
and the biological elements and in order to know that you have to start with the neuron itself,
the neurons, action potentials, synapses and how the neurons network. That was the first
initiation towards this field. The next is also by another very famous Nobel
laureate in neuroscience that is Gerald Edelman. Now, Edelman expressed consciousness in terms of
the morphology of the brain. His theory is known as neuronal Darwinism is based on three basic
things that is you know it is based on the developmental selection, experiential selection
and the re-entry part of it. Now, when a you know for example, a child is first developing,
at that time the child is having billions of neurons in him. But at the first phase,
this is the first phase of developmental selection, it involves the somatic selection of
neurons. So, during the growth and development, so you can see that this is where the first
neurons are coming and at the developmental phase, some of these neurons are selected and
the networks are getting built and that is what is the somatic selection phase,
that is what is the developmental phase. After the developmental phase, then there
comes the continuous process of synaptic selection that means the joint selections
and the reinforcement like you can see that this particular region, this particular region,
they are more reinforced whereas this region is not reinforced. So, this reinforcement starts
and that actually develop a new spatio-temporal event, a new spatio-temporal map in terms of
different sections or groups of neurons, that is the second phase. So, this is the phase where
this experiential growth is happening and finally, there is a very interesting process
of re-entrant mapping that happens and what it tells is that consciousness is essentially a
dynamic process where this re-entry has to happen. Re-entry means a group of neurons which will
continuously crosstalk between each other irrespective of what input is coming to one
and or to the other. It will continuously you know kind of a touch with each other and that
actually this re-entry would actually help it in terms of predicting what will be the output of
the system. So, there are several re-entry region and what Edelman said is one of the
important re-entry region is possibly the thalamus region of the brain.
Now, beyond Edelman there is another person who had enormous contribution,
his name is Herbert Simon, another Nobel laureate of course, in a somewhat different
area in economics in 1978, but he is considered to be a pioneer in artificial intelligence,
in decision making, cognitive psychology and computer science. So, together with Aaron Newell,
he built actually computer programs which can simulate the human cognition especially ones
that would solve problems with a trial and error like a generate and test system,
these are called general problem solver. He has proposed a concept of blackboard
architecture in which various items could be written to blackboard by different let us say
group of neurons, nuclei and it was visible to other systems that could read and write on the
blackboard. As a model for human consciousness, this blackboard resembles the theatre of
consciousness. So, that was one of the important contribution. Herbert Simon has also contributed
towards developing a very interesting algorithm suitable for AI and this algorithm is also known
as crest algorithm that is chunk hierarchy and retrieval structures. Now, this is a symbolic
cognitive architecture for the first time somebody has talked about cognitive architecture,
which is based on the concepts of limited attention, limited short-term memories and
chunking. So, short of learning, it is essential in the architecture and it is a model as the
development of network of nodes which are connected in various ways. Let us say,
you consider this graph that first of all you are getting inputs from all the different sensory
organs, eye, ear, hands, etc. Now, what in the crest model he proposed is that there will be
some feature which will be extracted from this mechanism and then a very interesting thing
happens. So, that is the first part. A stimulus is perceived and converted into a set of features.
Then, these features are actually sorted by the tests of the discrimination. So,
there is a discrimination network which sorts these features and send them to pointers to a
node within these limited term memories. So, then these are the long-term memories.
So, from this long-term memory, they actually send the indicators of these long-term memories
to the short-term memory. So, that is what it actually goes here to the short-term memory.
So, discrimination network thinks of what are the points where you have to connect it,
then from the address of those points comes to the short-term memory. And then,
finally, an action might be taken by the system if it is a new learning process or else you start
a new feature to extract. And many of this process can be actually done parallely like
eye movement and learning and many of the other process you can do it parallely.
So, that is what was the first algorithm for the first time an algorithm model had come up where
you do first collect the features from the input, then you take them through a discrimination
network, check whether you have already associated points, nodal points with this experience and
then those things where the associations are that is the only thing you declare to the short-term
memory. And if it is new, some new learning takes place and again you go ahead for the new inputs.
That is the way he tried to simulate the brain. Now, there are counter examples of Simon's
this kind of AI vision because there is no place of body in his vision.
Now, it seems all right that when we move, we walk, we talk, we write, we dance,
all these things are controlled by the brain. So, that is fine that the brain quite obviously
controls the body. But the question is how could the body influence our thinking?
And it is something which is very important because perhaps our thoughts are not as free
and independent as you would like them to be. They are indeed highly constrained,
shaped by our bodies. So, body not only constrains but also enables the thoughts in the way
towards the which the body gets advantage out of it. So, the crucial notion is to explain this
process of embodiment that is the counter to the Simon's AI logic. In fact, so there are these two
logics. One group is this AI group. So, this is the AI group where the body is just a peripheral
extension and the central part is the brain itself. Whereas, the other group, for example,
the Rolf Feier and John Bongard's group, they talk about how our body, how our different
somatosensory experiences as you can see all around us, they actually shapes our thought
process in the brain. So, both the approaches we will actually try to cover while designing
the cognitive robot.
