noc18-mm11 Lec 03-Energy of Vacancy Formation

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
Okay, so, last lecture we were looking at formation energy of vacancies, we are looking
at the simplest of point defects, which is a mono vacancy.
So, we looked at their energy delta free energy difference and also at the entropy, configurational
entropy which arises because of mixing.
Now, like I said in the last lecture that today I will show how we get the equilibrium
concentration.
Okay, so, we had the equation, if you remember delta G where n is the number of vacancies
equal to n H, it is delta H formation for one vacancy minus KBT, this is the longer
version of the equation, I am not using the simplified form of entropy equation, I am
using the full form that we obtained in the previous lecture.
And so, there is still another term KBT and there is n over here and there is a n over
here.
Okay, so, to find equilibrium concentration, what if you remember, how does this plot go?
So, delta G, we will come back to it later, but it is something like this.
So, we want to find the minima, this is the delta G, this is the point where we have equal
to n equilibrium of vacancies, which we will, which will, when we divide by n would become
equal to x1v, our equilibrium concentration.
So, this is the point that we are looking at the minima.
So, and this x axis is actually n, increasing number of vacancies.
So, what we need to find, to find the minima is simply take a differentiation of this with
respect to n and the point where we get 0 is the point which gives minima.
It is not, let me reiterate, it is not delta G equal to 0, but the differential of this
delta G with respect to n that will, that when gives 0 will lead the final value of
equilibrium concentration.
So, now, differentiate the earlier equation to get this, what we get is something like
this.
So, if we differentiate this equation over here, this becomes delta, this is simply minus
t n and since this is n over here, this will be, we will get a factor over here, f l1 by
n and it is 1 over, if you take the derivative of log, l n something, it becomes 1 over that.
So, this becomes n by n plus n minus, now let us go to the third term, which is minus
k B T. So, there is 2, n is at 2 places on the outside and the inside.
So, we will have to do it by parts.
So, first let us do the exterior part.
So, this becomes l n n by n.
Now, for the log part, this remains minus, but then we can take n in the, smaller n in
the numerator.
Therefore, it becomes plus, which is denoted here.
So, it becomes k B, the prefactor is k B T n and the factor in the, that has to be differentiated
as 1 by n.
So, it comes over here and then it is just inverse of this.
So, l n x is 1 over x.
So, that is what we are doing and this has to be equated to 0.
So, now what are the terms that cancel out?
This cancel out, this cancels out and this is k B. Now, over here, if you look, this
term is approximately equal to 1, these 2 cancel out.
So again, if you look at this term and this term, they will also cancel out.
So, what we are left with is this, delta H f 1 V, which is the enthalpy of formation
of 1 vacancy minus k B T l n n by n equal to 0.
Therefore, from this, what you will obtain is l n n by n equal to minus delta H f 1 V
by k B T. This is just rearranging and from here, we have x 1 V, which is our equilibrium
concentration.
We are denoting it by this, which is nothing but n by n.
We could have used a subscript eq as it is in many a places, but for now, we will just
let it be like this.
Just keep in mind that what we have derived here is the equilibrium concentration.
So, this becomes delta H f 1 V by k B T. Now, remember this is using some approximation.
What was the approximation?
Like I said, even in the previous class towards the end that we had used delta S formation
1 V approximately equal to 0.
If not, then what we will have to do is replace delta H f 1 V with delta H f 1 V minus T delta
S f 1 V.
So, if you do that, then the more accurate form of this equation would become, if you
put it over here minus this.
Since, this is an exponential, we can just multiply it the two terms.
So, the first term will have minus and minus.
So, it becomes plus and it has T over here and in the denominator.
So, it becomes independent of T and it becomes delta S f by k B times e x p, the same term
that is here.
So, this is also 1 V. Sometime I may miss it, but please keep in mind what terms are
being taken forward.
So, this is the expanded form of equilibrium concentration and remember this derivation
because in the next few cases, when we will discuss this, what we will be doing is, we
will show what is the energy of formation and in some cases, just show what will be
how it entropy energy will change, but once we have those values, we will directly insert
it over here to get the final form of the equation.
We need not go through all the derivation that we have shown you over here.
Another thing that you should note here is that, this we are using here as k B. Now,
let us say if I were using delta H f, which is energy instead of per atom as per mole.
So, if the energy is per mole basis, then what happens to k B?
You convert k B to R, which is the gas constant because we know that k B into N A, which is
Avogadro number is equal to R gas constant.
So, this k B and this k B will convert to R. N energy is given per mole.
So, that is something that you should keep in mind.
Now, another aspect that I want to go through is, now to begin with, let me draw this.
What I have been, what I had drew even in the previous lecture, so this is some form
of energy and here you have N delta H f 1 V. So, depending on and this is N. So, this
slope is equal to delta H 1 V and this is the total enthalpy because of formation of
N number of vacancies and there is a entropy term that we remember.
Let me be more accurate that we will, what I know beforehand, what you will see in sometime
is this is minus T delta S configurational.
This is not the formation entropy.
This is the configurational entropy that you have to keep in mind the difference between
the two and the sum of these two would lead to our energy, the delta G. So, somewhere
over here is what we have is the N equilibrium.
This is where what we calculated in the previous equation.
Now, what I want to show here is what will happen when N by N tends to 0 or what we are
talking about is what will happen to, what happens to entropy over here, what, how is
the slope in this particular region where N by N tends to 0.
So, again we want to find the slope.
What we need to do is differentiate this delta S configuration with respect to N. So, let
us do that and see what happens when we have N by N tending to 0.
So, let us go the usual way del by del N delta S configurational and we will, so what was
the delta S equal to?
We will use the simpler equation here without loss of generality.
You can always go back and use the extended version.
I have shown you one equation which was differentiated delta G with using the extended form of delta
S.
Now, here I am using the condensed version to show you this will ensure that both the
times you can, you will be able to do the same thing.
So, this becomes N KB ln N by N.
Now, what we have to do is differentiate.
So, simply again there are N at two places.
So, we have to do it by parts N by N into N by N plus ln N.
So, these two get cancelled and what we are left with is KB.
Now, when N by N tends to 0, what happens to uppercase N by small case N?
This quantity tends to, this quantity tends to infinity.
Now, when this quantity tends to infinity, this quantity overall which is the log of
N by N, this also tends to infinity which would mean that the slope which is equal to
minus T delta S slope of this particular quantity minus delta S TS configuration tends to minus
infinity.
So, it is very close to infinity but with a negative value.
This means that with a very small amount of increase in N by N or with a very small amount
of increase in the vacancy, the entropy would change very drastically or entropy that minus
T delta S term will reduce the energy drastically.
So, let me write this with very small addition of defects which is vacancies, energy drops
significantly.
So, what does this imply?
What is the big implication of this?
The implication of this is that if you add or in other words not add, it is very difficult
to find a defect free crystal.
Defect free crystals do not exist.
This is the implication.
This is what it is, what it implies.
Similarly this is particularly true when we are talking about for large N meaning the
total number of lattice site is large because that is where N by N tends to infinity and
that is where the slope becomes minus infinity.
So, this is one important implication and a corollary of this is now you have seen that
I have written large for very large N.
The corollary for this is that if you have a very small crystal, so like viscose or nanofibers,
then N is for small, very small nanoscale materials, it is possible to have defect free
system.
So, the first implication and the second one are kind of inverse of each other, but they
are coming from the same equation or the same thing that we derived that when your N by
N which is small n by uppercase N, this tends to 0 that is this small region over here.
Over there we saw that the entropy changes drastically which means that the minus T delta
another component of Gibbs free energy that drops very drastically and when that drops
what it implies is that your energy changes drastically meaning that even a small amount
of addition of defect will reduce to reduction energy.
So the system or the component will have a tendency to absorb these defects and therefore
I have written defect free crystals do not exist.
Now when I derived this we had assumed that small n by uppercase N is tending to 0 or
in other words uppercase N is a very large number.
So the other corollary from this is that when this is not true that is uppercase N is not
very large, then which is for very small nanoscale materials, it is possible to have defect free
system.
For example, our viscose and nanocrystals and that is where their special properties
originate from.
Now since they are defect free if you remember I told you that if your copper was defect
free it did not have dislocations, even dislocations this is not dislocation we are talking about
but let us say it is a dislocation free copper then the strength would be 100 times higher
than what we usually get.
So that is possible only when we are talking about nanoscale.
So this is a very big implication and this also lets us to know why there is so much
of work going on at nano length scale because you get some superior properties most of the
time superior properties.
So let us move on to an example problem.
Now that we have seen the equilibrium concentration how it is related to temperature.
Let me ask you what so the problem question would be something like that.
At what temperature does one vacancy per mole become stable in copper?
This is a question that I have taken from Professor Anand Subramaniam's lecture notes
if you can access those from you can access those from IIT website it is a very good collection
of slides and it will be useful for you for this course also.
So what is given here it is given that delta H formation 1V for copper is equal to 1.24
electron volt per vacancy and Kb is known to be 8.62 into 10 to the power minus electron
volt per Kelvin.
So this is the problem statement how do we go about solving it.
So what we know you know that this is talking about equilibrium concentration at what temperature
does one vacancy per mole become stable.
So thermodynamically stable so it is a equilibrium concentration.
What is the equation for equilibrium concentration if you remember it was X1V is equal to N by
Na.
Why we are taking Na because we are talking about one vacancy per mole.
So N is equal to 1, Na is the Avogadro number and therefore this becomes 1 over 6.023 into
10 to the power 23 and on the RHS right hand side what we have is minus delta H formation
1 vacancy by KbT delta H formation is given in electron volt per vacancy.
So we need not convert the Kb to R well let it be like this and therefore this becomes
so T is the unknown here.
Everything else is known except T.
So you can very easily convert or transform this equation to this form and when you solve
this you would see that this value comes out to be 281.16 Kelvin.
So a little above room temperature, so a little sorry not room temperature a little
above 0 degree Celsius 273 is the 0 degree Celsius so it is just 8 degrees above that.
So around 8 degree Celsius it is saying that given this delta Hf you will have this vacancy
concentration.
So that tells you how to solve it that is very well and good but you should also note
that this value does it sound right to you that at 8 degree Celsius you will have only
one vacancy per mole.
It does not I would think that this is a very low value this sounds so this is a little
too low.
Now what could be the possible reasons for it?
There may be several reasons to begin with the delta Hf value that is given here it may
be a little on the higher side.
It is possible that at what you observe is not really the equilibrium concentration because
we are talking about a very low temperature where mobility becomes very small.
So what you observe is not equal to what we have been given here and there are possible
several possible reasons for it.
So some of the reasons I discussed here and some of those I will leave up to you to think
about it.
So now let us go to another aspect of our problem of our topic and this aspect is what
is the energy of vacancy formation?
How do we usually estimate what is the amount of energy that is required for formation of
vacancy formation energy?
One of the simplest models is based on what is called as broken bonds model.
What does it do?
Let us say we have so let us say these are the atoms in a original lattice where there
were no defect and it need not always be a perfect flat system there would always be
some atomic level hills and valleys.
So that is why I have drawn something like this.
Now let us say I take one atom from here like this atom and move it over this place.
So this atom comes to this place and this place becomes vacant.
So this is a method of formation of vacancy and you can say conceptual generation of vacancy.
So vacancy has been generated.
Now what are the change in the energy because of this?
The delta hf 1v can be related to the energy of broken bonds.
So what is the energy that you need?
It depends on the number of bonds that you have breaking here.
So that is the total amount of energy that was required but at the same time when it
goes to the surface because we are not reducing the number of atoms we cannot reduce the number
of atoms.
So when it goes to the surface it will form some bonds over there.
So there will be energy bonding.
Now this is the difference in the number of broken bonds when the atom was at this side
to the number of broken bonds that has over here.
Apart from this there is also a relaxation term.
Now when we are talking about a vacancy over here it will not stay the atoms around it
will not stay tight at its own place.
There will be some relaxation like this.
So the atoms would move from the position a little bit and this relieves the energy
somewhat and because of this there will also be some decrease in the energy which can be
termed as e-relaxation.
So this delta hf which is the formation of one vacancy this can be obtained from this
broken bond model by obtaining the number of broken energy because of broken bonds minus
the energy released because of the bonding at the surface minus energy released because
of relaxation.
Now using this concept what we will show is that your mono vacancies can actually merge
to form di-vacancies.
So let us look at it a simple again the broken bond model how does it predict that mono vacancies
should merge to form di-vacancies.
So let us say this is again and let us say there is so let me draw the vacancy at the
end with a different color.
So let us say there is a vacancy here let us say there is a vacancy over here.
Now in this simple model this one vacancy how many broken bonds do you see over here
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and we are talking about a 2D plane.
So there is 6 broken bonds over here 6 broken bonds over here.
So now this is some amount of broken bonds over here some amount of broken bonds here.
But what will happen what kind of structure do you see when both these vacancies combine.
So let us say now bring the 2 bonds or the 2 vacancies together it will look something
like this the exact amount of difference in energy etc would depend on the crystal structure
which orientation we are talking about sorry not the orientation just the crystal structure.
But this is a simple model to explain the concept.
So here there are 6 broken bonds plus 6 broken bonds which leads to how many 12 broken bonds.
Over here we have how many 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8.
So there are 8 plus there are bonds broken in between these 2 which is 9 plus 1 10.
So there are 10 broken bonds at this side.
So there is a large amount of difference here.
So like I said that there are 12 broken bonds here and 10 broken bonds and how does this
lead to the concentration difference between di-vacancy and mono-vacancy we will discuss
in the next lecture.
Thank you.
