noc18-mm11 Lec 09-Defects Reaction and its Thermodynamics

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 3, 2023
So, let us come back to where we left, so we, whether using Kroger Vink notation and
we started writing different defects as a reaction using this Kroger Vink notation.
So, this one was that we discussed last lecture Schotty defects.
So, as you can see its reaction it can be written as a reaction. Next is Frenkel defect.
So, now, we will try to right Frenkel defect as a reaction.
So, you remember in Frenkel defect what we have is a cation moves on into interstitial.
So, we can write something M, which is a metal which will be the cation, it will move into
a vacancy, these are interstitial. So, it will create a vacancy and this vacancy will
not have a recharge where it should have recharge and assuming that the original charge of the
metal was 2 units. So, it will become too negative charges and
interstitial metal will be in the interstitial and therefore, in the interstitial there should
not have been any charge and therefore, it will be presented at 2 additional positive
charges and to trace the interstitial site you can add here vacancy interstitial, it
will not make any difference to the overall reaction and when we look into the thermodynamics,
but this will only help us understand number of interstitial that have being used created
and so on. So, this is the Frenkel relation or the Frenkel defect or which can be represented
as the reaction. Now, we will also look at, so far we have
looked only at atomic defects; now let us look at if electrons and holes are generated,
so the advantage of this defect reaction is that even electron and holes can be represented
by these relations by these reaction and hence the thermodynamic equilibrium concentration
can be obtain. So, next let us look at intrinsic ionisation of electrons.
So, from nowhere or basically from perfect crystal, you can have one electron and one
hole created, but remember in a defect reaction we also wanted to maintain mass. So, you can
represent it something like this. So, electron with no charge effectively is moving on to
create on electron which has a negative charge and hole which has a positive charge.
Now, these electrons and holes here you will realize a non-localized. It and basically
it means that this electron is not present at any particular site they are in the conduction
band. So, this is non-localized; not one any particular site cannot be said to be processing
these electrons. So, in that since it is non-localized in the conduction band.
Now, on the other hand if we assume if these charges or electronic defects are localized
which would mean that this electron has to be at a particular site and therefore, it
can be represented by something let us say metal and let us put iron over here, so since
this iron has to this electron as well as a hole has to go somewhere, so we can say
that one of the iron atoms is taking the negative charge and one of the iron atoms is taking
as taking the positive charge; effective, remember it is effective negative or effective
positive charge. What does that mean? That from whatever it
was supposed to have it is 1 less and over here it is 1 more; which means that if we
are talking about Fe, this Fe 3 plus sin is getting converted to Fe 2 plus and Fe 4 plus.
So, you see that in the matrix Fe was in 3 plus valance a state, but because of the presence
of extra electron and extra hole basically creation of electron and hole and which are
getting localized on to this metal atom. This charge from 3 plus has been reduced to 2 plus.
So, it is 1 less than 3 plus. So, it is one represented as one negative and this is one
more than this is 4 plus which is one more than 3 plus. So, it is represented as one
dot. So, this is the intrinsic ionisation of electrons, when that is this is not localized
and when it is localized was on an in particular atom. So, it could be anything something it
could also be something like let us say metal 2 plus going to metal 1 plus 3 plus.
So, even this will be represented by something like this. So, here they have basically one
at accepting one electron here it is accepting one hole. So, all these are examples of electronic
defects which are localized. Now, let us look at how to write the defect reaction for a
non stoichiometric system. Even if it is a non stoichiometric system,
remember that site number of sites present in the system would still maintain the stoichiometric
ok. So, non stoichiometric can be occurring because let us say in a system like MO, a
part of the oxygen escapes in and forms goes into the atmosphere as oxygen gas.
So, it will become so let us say it was MO 2 minus x. So, some part of the oxygen elements
have left the system and into the atmosphere. How do we represent? So, basically oxygen
that is oxygen site which can be shall neutral charge it forms vacancy at oxygen site and
let us assume that it leaves in a neutral state meaning that it remains with the charges
remain with the site where it was there because that we have to maintain charge neutrality.
Therefore, the vacancy site will have 0 charge; effective 0 charge, but enough, but an absolute
terms there is a minus 2 charge over here. So, in absolute terms, it has minus 2 charge
and where does oxygen atom actually go it escapes as gas. So, 1 by 2 O2 gas; this right
now the charge over here is localized onto vacancy. Now this vacancy can delocalized
the charge meaning it can let go the charge and therefore, it can happen something like
this. It may further go on and it will have no absolute charge meaning in effective terms
it is positively charged, the electrons have left it in a relative term it is 2 positive
and where do the electrons go? It has got delocalized. So, this is 2 electron with negative
charges and it has gone into the conduction band of the system.
So, overall this reaction can be written as vacancy at oxygen site with 2 positive effective
charge with 2 electrons which are delocalized plus 1 by 2 O2 gas. So, the 2 electron is
delocalized, now if let us say again like the previous case this electron is not delocalized,
but it gets if electron or charges to get localized on a metal site because mostly metal
will have variable valency. So, this can be represented, so this 2 electron
you will have to move on to some metal site. So, it will be represented by something like
this, let us say that there is electron to there are 2 electron and they have moving
to two different sites. So, each. So, each of the metal sites get reduced by one charge
therefore, to begin with they are neutral oxygen site is neutral and it forms vacancy,
which has effective positive charge to positive charge plus 2 M M negative charge plus 1 by
2 O2 gas, we see that we are now able to represent this kind of defect as a reaction.
Let us talk about still another defect which is presence of dopants. So, mostly in semiconductors
you would know that dopants are added because they create charge with defects which lead
to increase in electrons or in increase in holes. So, presence of dopants as impurities,
let us look at that, so what do we know that whenever dopants are added it missing if you
can lead effect the concentration it can significantly affect the concentration of defects may significantly
affect the concentration of defects, now these dopants that have been added they can have
a valency is similar to silicon or it can have a valency different from silicon.
So, first let us distributed into these 2 categories when it has similar valency as
silicon which is which are the valency of 4 then it is called homovalent meaning same
valency as host in case of silicon it means plus 4 it means 4 and if it is different in
valancy than the host with in particular case silicon if it is different from 4 like plus
it is 3 of 5 then it is called aliovalent. Now, this aliovalent are the once which are
of interest two people in semiconductors why because they can either donate electrons
or they can accept the electrons and therefore, they can change the concentration relative
concentration of n and p, the number of electron and number of holes.
So, let us look at example this boron, boron, if it is present at a silicon site silicon
which should have 4 valence, but boron has three. So, it is trivalent and when boron
is there it means that it has effectively one negative charge and therefore, it will
emit one hole because it has effectively one charge and if you look at the charge neutrality
for this reaction then you would realize that there should be a whole generated.
So, they you can see that this equation can so easily predict that hole has to be generated
when have for each and every boron atom that sits at the silicon site. Now let us look
at the other type of example as dopant which is phosphorus which is pentavalent. So, if
phosphorus is setting at silicon site it has effectively one extra positive charge compare
to boron which are extra negative charge it as one extra positive charge which means that
there should be electron generated for this now this can also be represented by other
broken one models that it has one extra electron has which is not satisfied.
So, this extra electron will move on to the conduction band, but in terms of reaction
also you can show the same thing that phosphorus sitting at silicon will can be presented as
one with effective positive charge and therefore, to maintain charge neutrality there will be
a electron generated over here. So, again you see that this defect reaction
can be a very useful method to understand what is going on what will be generated even
in terms of holes and electrons not only in terms of defect lattice type of defects. Now
that we have looked at the defect reactions let us look at the usefulness of it in predicting
the equilibrium concentration.
So, what is the basic thermodynamics when we are using a defect reaction; what it says
what we know is that for a reaction which goes like this; a moles of A component b moles
of B component if they react and form under equilibrium they form some c moles of C component
and d moles of D component. Then what we know is that the delta G the
free energy change for this reaction can be given as this the delta G naught is at the
standard state plus RT ln a. So, what we have here is a c which means activity coefficient
of c component and to the power small c which is the number of moles. So, you have to be
careful on what which c we are writing here. So, let me we are try to be a little bit more
clear. So, this is the capital C mean c the element or the c component activity coefficient
of c component to the power c which is the this small c. Similarly, activity coefficient
of D component to the power small d that is how many number of moles of d is activity
coefficient of a component to the power a, activity coefficient of b component to the
power is small b which is how many number of moles of b are there.
So, what is a? a is activity
for respective component. Now at equilibrium we will have delta G equal to 0 meaning the
reaction has come to an equilibrium the reaction is not moving we have equilibrium number of
a component b component equilibrium component of c and d.
So, at that condition delta G is equal to zero and therefore, what we have is a relation
like this if we represent this by k meaning k is equal to this quantity, now this quantity
can be approximately said to be equal to the relative fractions. So, if there equilibrium
fraction of c component is X c to the power small c. So, again let me, so here also it
is not very clear I will just. So, we have equilibrium concentration of c to the power
c equilibrium concentration of component d to the power of d that is how many moles there
are equilibrium concentration of a to the power small a, which is the number of number
of moles. So, now we have a relation similar to that
that we had derived earlier actually there is one more step before that. So, what is
that step we know that delta G naught is equal to
here is ln missing or in other words we have K equal to exp which
is the exponent because this is log. So, we are now taking the exponent of everything
and dividing by dividing it by RT. So, what we are doing here is taking exponent on both
side and hence we get rid of the log term and we get equation for k. So, first thing
that you should note is that here this equation here we are using R meaning whatever energy
terms we are using delta S. So, delta h it has be it has to be per mole term if we again
translate it to per electron term then you can use k b.
Now, here delta S naught is nothing, but what we had earlier called as the delta S formation.
So, that is equal to delta S vibration that is the same and similarly delta minus delta
H naught here is nothing, but delta H, but minus since you are talking about minus delta
S minus delta H formation. So, whatever it is about one vacancy or it is one Frenkel
pair or one Schottky pair it can also relate to those formation energies also in this particular
case it is talking about the change in enthalpy when this reaction goes from here to here,
now this is the equation that is very similar to what we had obtained earlier, so, here
now we can write it like this. So, now when they whenever you write or defect
as a reaction you would know all this quantities a, b, c, d the upper case A, B, C, D and the
smaller case a, b, c, d and therefore, you would also know these quantities and related
to that thermodynamic quantities delta S of and delta H of also would be known and therefore,
from this if you know the right hand side you can get the left hand side and the left
hand side if there is 1 or 2 particular component that you don’t know then you can find that
1 or 2 component and are at least the relative ratio between the two.
So, that is the usefulness of writing defect as a reaction. So, instead of going through
all the entropy are the configuration entropy and all those terms we can see that we can
directly reach over here. So, another thing to understand is that when we write this equation
because we have already seen derived the similar equation using configurational entropy.
So, we know that this is not the configurational entropy, this is the vibrational entropy.
So, we have to be aware of that; that means, we write this equation like this is not a
configuration entropy all that has been taken into account over here when we get this relation.
So, instead of going through all that process of configuration entropy we can just directly
use this defect reaction and get the equilibrium concentration ok. So, now, let us apply this
knowledge to some of the some of these reaction that we just talked about.
So, let us say we go to, let us revisit Schottky defect, now how did we write Schottky defect
reaction. So, we wrote it something like this. So, Schottky defect is what do what is Schottky
defect, it is the vacancy at cation and vacancy at anion in that particular ratio and here
we are assuming it is MO. So, M plus 2 O minus 2 and therefore, vacancy at O site will be
equivalent to 2 positive charges and vacancy at metal site would be equal to 2 negative
charges and therefore, this rate constant K s would be equal to X v o dot X v m prime
double prime X o at o into X M at M. And this we know is equal to the thermodynamic
quantity which is delta S f by R times e x p minus delta H f Schottky defect. Now over
here what has to be know over here what we know here is that what is the fraction of
O on o first what is the fraction of a distraction M on M similarly what we also want to know
is the fraction X V o X V M. So there are certain essentials we will have
to make here one is that this particular defect is the dominating defect, let us say if the
vacancy were being produced by some other mechanism also then this then we will not
be able to say that this relation is the final one or the vacancy concentration would also
be influenced by the other reaction. So, we have to assume that this is the dominating
defect. So, one thing that we have to assume is that
Schottky defect is dominating
this is one assumption, second assumption is that defect concentration is very small
why do we want to say that, why we want to say that is because in that particular case
you will be able to say that fraction of oxygen site on oxygen is approximately equal to 1,
if there were too many vacancies let us say 20 percent defects many oxygen has there are
20 percent vacancies of oxygen then O and O will not be equal to 1 and then it will
we will have to evaluate it will be a lot more complicated and difficult to evaluate
the fractions of V o and V M M. So, the one of the defect one of the assumptions
is the defect concentration is this is also to ensure that activity coefficient which
has been related to X, which is the mole of fraction the mole of fraction of the defects.
So, these this equation this a quality is also true and defect concentration is small,
similarly the concert of fraction X M M is also approximately equal to 1. So, we have
these 2 assumptions. Because of this we get this relation and another
assumption in these particular cases all its not really assumption, but it is derivation
from this is that when you have all these conditions true, but it also means is that
X V o actually then should be the number of number of vacancies it is also equal to X
V M this is getting derived from the fact that number of vacancies is equal to number
of metal sorry the number of vacancy at oxygen site is equal to the number of vacancy at
the metal sites. So, this equation can also be represented
as fraction of X v o equal to fraction of X v m, now when we have this we can say that
X V o dot into X V M is equal to e x p now since this is equal. So, we can take a square
root and therefore, X V o dot X V M is equal to square root means 1 over 2 factor over
here. So, this is a relation that we had derived earlier and you see that we have been able
to derive it here to. So, this is one example, we will continue with more examples in the
next class. Thank you.
