noc18-ce39-Lecture 23- Bidding (Part -2)

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
5 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
[Music]
good morning namaskar and welcome to the
course once again in the last lecture if
you remember we gave you an overview of
the entire bidding process especially
from the point of view of a contractor
we learnt the pre-qualification process
we learnt how to carry out the site
investigation we also learnt how to
prepare tender summary which is also
known as tender at a glance in this
class we'll continue our discussion and
we will understand how a contractor
formulates his bid price we will see
what are the different components of a
bid price and we will go into the
details of each of those components and
finally we will see how the bid price is
evaluated or rather computed by a
contractor now if you see the bid price
is essentially consisting of your total
cost and the mark-up amount so if you
look at the bid price closely this is
what it consists of total cost and
markup amount total cost consists of
your direct cost and your indirect cost
in the direct cost you have costs of
labor you have cost of equipment you
have cost of crew members you have cost
of materials and your cost of
subcontractors on the other hand if you
look at the indirect cost it consists of
project overheads common plant and
equipment common workmen so these are as
far as total cost is concerned now on
top of it a contractor also adds its
markup amount in one of the previous
lectures I told you that markup amount
is mostly equated with the term profit
but now in this lecture you will come to
know that markup amount is more than
profit it consists
of contingencies also it consists of
allowances for risk as well and it
consists of general overheads also now
we will go into the details of each of
these cost component as well as the
mark-up amount and we will see how
finally the bid price is computed let's
go back straight to the direct cost
computation now as I told you direct
cost consists of the cost of material
cost of labour cost of plant and
equipment it could consist of cost of
subcontractors also now when we
determine the cost of material it has to
actually consider the rate of the
material the rate at which you are able
to buy that material then you also have
to add various taxes recent tax is Jesus
T which is goods and service tax we also
had excise duty sales tax then you also
have to add the cost of packing and
forwarding because your metals have to
be packed and then it has to be
transported so all those costs are to be
included in your material cost the
freight charges that is transportation
cost from ferrying the metal from one
place to the other place and you also
have the provision of entry taxes
sometimes this is also known as chungee
some states they levied chunky's or
entry tax if the material passes through
that particular state so these are the
things you have to consider when you are
evaluating the cost of a particular
material now we will see the cost of
labour now if you see a laborer you can
classify them as departmental labor and
subcontractor labor departmental labor
are in the role of the contractor
whereas subcontractor laborers are hired
by the contractor through different sub
contracting agencies so when you
calculate the cost you have to take
those things into consideration now when
you actually try to find out the cost of
labor you have to find out the cost
incurred on the laborer employed at the
site it is the wages that you have to
pay the basic wage in addition to the
basic wages you also have to add cost
which you incur towards their welfare
such as the
the retrenchment benefit the insurance
health benefits and notice pay see when
you hire a worker it is not the cost of
paying wage to them alone you also have
to consider various other costs there
are many benefits that you have to pay
to your workers for example if they are
working for more than a particular
number of days normally maybe six months
you have to also pay them the bonus then
when you are retrenching a worker that
means when you are sending them out of
the project site you also have to pay
them it's not that
today you decided that you are no longer
required and you just throw them out no
it's not like that you have to get them
the notice pay you also have to give
them the retrenchment benefits I will
tell you how much does it cost
there is one slide which I have prepared
which gives you so normally the bonus is
about 20% of the wages if you have
worked for a particular contractor for
more than a particular number of days
then you have to have these Provident
Fund and family pension that is about
twelve and a half percent of your wages
then employees state insurance the
implication is about six point two five
percent if you are retrenching a worker
you have to pay them wage of fifteen
days extra then the notice pay is for
about twenty six days pay so you find in
addition to the minimum wages that you
are paying you are also considering all
these costs so whenever you calculate
the cost of labour you have to consider
all those costs also then you also have
to consider the cost of providing
housing it could be with or without
arrangement for preparing food then you
also have to take into consideration the
cost in mobilization and demobilization
suppose some workers is coming from
far-off places you have to pay the petty
contractors who is bringing those
laborers you have to pay them the rail
fare and other expenses which the petty
contractor is likely to incur so all
these are caused towards mobilization
and demobilization then we go into the
plant and equipment cost this is again
of your direct cost so here you have to
consider the cost of owning and
operating the equipment it could be for
different activity it could be for
concreting it could be for form work and
it could be for any other purpose so
whatever is the cost of owning and
operating that equipment for that
particular activity that cost has to be
considered then you also have to incur
the cost I mean you will have to take
the cost of mobilization also for
example let's say you are transporting
tower crane for a particular project
site now this tower crane may come in -
maybe 2025 trailers so the cost of
transportation could be huge then you
also have to incur the cost of providing
the foundation for that particular tower
crane so all these are part of your cost
of plant and equipment then you also
have to consider the cost of the fuel
oil lubricants which are needed by that
particular equipment you also have to
consider the cost of minor repair that
may be required for making that
equipment workable at your site you also
have to keep some inventory of spare
parts so whatever cost you are incurring
to maintain this inventory that has to
be accounted for then the cost of
operators and drivers some other
statutory expenses that may be required
that also has to be considered then
personal couriers expenses and
demobilization cost so all these are
part of your direct cost for plant and
equipment then we move on to the
subcontractor cost you know that not all
the activities are performed by the
general contractor they hire the
services of subcontractors the
subcontractors may be therefore until
termite treatment or they could be there
for waterproofing or for aluminum works
or for wood work now in a similar manner
a contractor also invites quotation just
the way a client invites a quotation
from these contractors so let's say for
example the contractor is looking for a
subcontractor for
airing out anti termite treatment work
so he will contact number of
subcontractors who are involved in these
NT termite treatment work and they will
collect the quotation they will study
the quotation and they will see whether
all the items which are needed to
perform NT termite treatment has been
considered by the subcontractors if
something is not considered those are
part of your exclusions suppose the
subcontractor says that I have not
considered the expense towards water and
power so the main contractor would add
the cost of water and power in the cost
given by the subcontractor and then only
he will provide that into his bids so
these are the things he has to consider
when subcontractor cost is accounted for
now we will see what constitutes
indirect cost we have already seen the
direct cost part now we will see
indirect cost
they are also loosely known as overheads
now they will include a large number of
expenses for example expenses towards
salaries of your staff you will require
conveyance at site so it could be cheap
it could be cars it could be buses
trucks and so on so that is part of your
conveyance expenses then you also incur
cost towards temporary site
installations for example you will have
workshop you will have offices for your
client you will have offices for your
own staff and you can have offices for
your architects so they are all part of
your temporary site installation so
whatever cost you are incurring here
that has to be accounted for under this
indirect cost then comes your cost
towards site accommodation of staff
workmen and so on you require cost
towards power cost towards water cost
towards providing civil system then you
also incur cost towards making progress
photographs taking videos you incur cost
towards travel and transfer costs of
your staff then sometimes personals from
your headquarter and regional offices
visit your site so that cost also has to
be incurred into
and taken into account in the indirect
cost there are some more items which are
to be covered under indirect cost
there could be safety equipment small
tools and tackles the cost towards
mobilization and demobilization the cost
that you incur in mess and providing
food subsidies to your workers the cost
towards providing entertainment to your
staff and to your workers the cost
incurred in providing professional fees
and the cost that you incur sometimes in
providing facilities for clients and
consultants so all these are part of
your indirect cost then there are
certain other financial cost also that
is to be part of indirect cost for
example the bid bond as I told you in
the previous lecture bid bond is nothing
but your earnest money deposit so
normally it is about two percent of the
contract value one to two percent
roughly of contract value so this also
has to be accounted for right then
sometimes the client asks you the
performance bond so the cost towards
providing performance bond also is to be
incurred here sometimes the client gives
you mobilization advance but they ask
you a guarantee from you so the charges
towards providing that guarantee is to
be included here retention guarantee
what happens from every bill the client
deduct certain amount of retention money
right now the current trend is retention
money is released in lieu of a bank
guarantee so whatever man guarantee
charges you are incurring that has to be
included in your indirect cost then
sometimes you provide guarantee for
temporary workers so cost incurred
towards this has to be included here if
you are in to export business you will
have to provide this charges for letter
of credit LC establishment charges then
you may incur cost towards interest on
payments that is due then credit for
advances labor says all these are part
of your indirect cost now I will give
you a typical breakup of overheads maybe
for typical
building projects you will find that
let's say if your total overhead is
let's say consisting of 100% stop salary
will be 20% out of that so if let's say
the total overhead is coming out to be
hundred so 20% component of that would
be coming from staff salaries this is
just giving you a typical idea so that
you can understand the magnitude of each
of these cost heads insurance charges
would be roughly 16% of your total
overhead temporary structure cost would
be roughly about 15% plant and
missionary site operations including
fuel and depreciation the cost would be
about 12% you may spend about six
percent on miscellaneous labor charges
interest charges and bank guarantee
charges would be roughly about 6% staff
accommodation would be costing you
roughly about 5% labor benefit I told
you what are the terms under labor
benefit for example it would be the
bonus it would be the family pension it
would be the ESI it would be
retrenchment benefit it could be notice
pay all put together it would be roughly
about 5% of your overheads of course
these values may change from company to
company but this is a general guidelines
you can get some idea out of different
percentages then you have conveyance at
site this is about 3% of the overheads
then others we are saying it would be
about 12% I will give you what comes
under others in different slide so this
is the break up of that 12% so 23% of
12% would be spent on providing
facilities at site 13% of this 12% would
be to our safety appliances you will buy
helmet you will buy safety belts safety
shoes and so on packing forwarding and
closing it would cost you about 12% of
this 12% staff transfer expenses would
be roughly about 10% of this 12% setting
out and test charges it would be about
9% of this
likewise small
senticles nine-percent posters in the
stationery and telephone expense it
would be 8% of this 12 percent
subsidized canteen expense would be
about 8% for nature etc roughly about 5%
travel by head office staff it would
cost you about roughly one-and-a-half
percent tendering expenses right from
buying the tender document to preparing
the tender roughly it would cost you
about 1% of this 12% photo/video charges
very nominal about 0.5% of this 12% so
this is how you split this 12% and this
is how a typical overhead component
would look like now we will see the
common plant and equipment if you
remember the indirect cost indirect cost
consists of your overheads common plant
and equipment and common workmen now
what happens there are certain plant and
equipment for which it is very difficult
for you to decide the exact nature of
cost for example let's say you have a
diesel generator set available at site
now this diesel generator set is
available for all the activities it is
being used for pumping of concrete it is
being used for providing area lighting
so it is very difficult for me to
identify exactly what proportion of this
cost is going in providing area lighting
or in providing the pumping cost and so
on so if I am unable to distinguish very
clearly where exactly the cost is being
spent I put it under common planting
equipment
likewise if a worker is involved in many
activities it is always better to put
the cost under common workmen I will
give you the example of some more common
plant and equipment let's say one
example I give you for diesel generator
set another example could be water pump
now this water pump is pumping water for
curing purpose also water is being used
for providing for making concrete as
well for making motor also so it is very
difficult for me to really distinguish
that out of X cost 0.5 X is going
Oh point 2 X is going here 0.3 X is
going here so what I am doing in order
to avoid these calculations I am putting
the entire cost of providing water pump
or for that matter DZ sets into a
separate head and I am putting it under
indirect cost now again when it comes to
common workmen I also do the same thing
for example let's say take the case of
storekeeper now a storekeeper is there
for all the activities of my project
it's not that the storekeeper is there
only for concreting activity no it's not
like that so what I do whatever expense
I incurred towards storekeeper I put it
under entire project under indirect cost
under common workmen likewise there
could be safety ste word in my project
so any injury happens to any worker he
is there likewise I will have some time
keeper security persons so all these
expenses I am putting it under common
workmen so what we have seen under
indirect cost we have seen the overheads
we have seen the common workmen and we
have also seen the common plant and
equipment now as far as the total cost
components are concerned we are true now
we will go to markup now in one of the
lectures I told you that markup is
loosely defined as profit but in this
lecture now you know that it is more
than profit you also have to consider
your general overheads your
contingencies and your allowances for
risk right now we will see each one of
these let us say first take general over
X so if you are working for a large
company you will find that you have
offices at different places you have
your headquarter you have different
regional offices now different types of
professionals are engaged in these
offices so they are there to support
site activities someone would be there
to provide help in design someone would
be there to provide help in procurement
someone would be there for tendering and
so on so you find they are there to help
you out
and you also pay their salaries you have
to pay the expense towards maintaining
that particular office you have to spend
money towards electricity charges and so
on so all these costs have to be met
from somewhere so all these costs are
coming under your general overheads
normally the general overhead for a
particular company would be in the range
of about two to three percent now every
year you calculate what is the total
expense that you incur in these offices
and you also see how much business you
did that particular year so you can get
a percentage suppose you spent one crore
towards maintaining these offices and
you did a business of hundred crores
so one percent is your general overheads
so for the next year whenever any new
bidding is taking place we will put this
amount of one percent in our markup now
the second term under markup is your
allowances for risk so when we are doing
a particular project we are bidding for
a particular project we know what are
the likely risks that you can encounter
in that this particular project this is
coming from a past experience so you can
maybe either buy some kind of a premium
or you can try to transfer these risk so
you have certain provision to overcome
these risks situations so all these
expenses that you are likely to be
incurring to overcome B's risk we are
putting under our markup then those
risks which we are unable to foresee at
this moment we are covering it under
contingencies so contingencies are the
amount that you keep aside to meet some
kind of unforeseen situations so
something which you never forecasted
let's say that occurs in your project so
if you have to overcome that you need to
have some kind of money already to be
built in your bid price so these are all
part of your markup and of course profit
is one major term of markup so now you
understand markup is essentially
consider
sting of four terms your profit your
contingencies your allowances for risk
and finally your general overheads now
markup is normally expressed in two ways
either you can express it in some
percent of your total cost or you can
express it in terms of your bid price
now there are two terms which you have
to understand let's say B is your bid
price and this is consisting of your
total cost plus markup right this is how
we defined our model bid price is total
cost plus markup amount right now this
markup I can express it in two ways
either some percentage of this total
cost or some percentage of B and this is
how it will look like so if you are
expressing this markup in terms of
certain percentage of TC total cost so
this is what it is so let's say I said
10% of TC markup is let's say 10% of TC
so how much will be my bid price it
would be B is equal to TC plus 10 by 100
of TC I am saying that let's assume
markup to be 10 percent of total cost so
my bid price is going to be 1 point 1
multiplied by TC this is one way of
representing my markup that is in terms
of total cost now in the second case I
am expressing my markup in terms of my
bid price and in that case this term we
are also referring to it as off top
right so what I am doing it here B is
equal to TC plus some percentage of B
let's say I'm saying markup is 10
percent of my bid price so I will write
it like this
some percentage it's a 10 percent of B
so if you calculate it it would be B is
equal to TC upon 1 minus markup
percentage
upon 100 so if this is 10% of B so if
you see here it would be something like
this B is equal to TC plus 10 by 100 of
total cost let us say this is in this
case it is B here so I will just do it
do the calculation for you so that you
do not get confused so in the first case
I am writing B is equal to TC plus let
us say 10 percent of TC right so in this
case we are defining the mark-up as some
percentage of total cost so it would be
B is equal to TC 1 plus zero point 1 so
it is 1 point 1 TC so this is how you
define your bid price it is 10 percent
of 1 point 1 multiplied by TC now in the
second case what we are saying is we are
saying B is equal to let us say TC plus
some percentage of let us say 10 percent
of B we are saying I am defining markup
in terms of some percentage of bid price
itself so this is going to be TC plus
0.1 times B and in this case we are
defining this markup as off top we are
calling this term as off top right so
this is B is equal to TC plus 0.1 B so B
1 minus 0.1 is equal to TC so if you see
here we we are getting B as TC upon 0.9
and which would be about 1 point 1 1 TC
so now you understand the difference in
the first case in the first case my bid
price was 1 point 1 TC in this case I
assumed 10 percent of total cost as my
markup in the second case what I did I
assumed 10 percent of B as my markup
percent and that's that's how I get
B is equal to 1 point 1 1 DC so for a
large project this would make a very big
difference so you have to be very very
clear about this now when it comes to
markup it depends on a number of factors
so let's see quickly what are the
factors which affect this fixing up of
markup see what happens if you see the
bid price of different contractors you
will notice that the difference in bid
price especially if the contractors are
all at part that means they are getting
the same metal from the market at very
nearly the same price they are getting
the same labor they are getting the same
engineers same plant and equipment
almost at the same price so still the
difference in bid price exists so why it
is so this may be purely on account of
difference in markup so some company
might have applied 10% some company
might have applied 12% some company
might have applied 15% so the difference
in bid price is essentially on account
of difference in markup especially when
all your contractors are at par so we
would like to know what are the factors
on which a contractor decides its markup
for a particular project so that depends
on a large number of factors in fact a
number of researchers have also been
carried out regarding how a particular
contractor fixes a given markup and
people have found that these are the
factors which affect the markup for
example the number of computers that you
are likely to face and the intensity of
completion so the more the computers you
are having you will find that it will
affect your markup application for that
particular project it is also decided
based on the size cost and intensity of
the project of course it will also be
decided based on the type of project for
example if the building project you are
competing for or if it is infrastructure
projects markups are going to be
different duration of the project is
also one very important factor location
of the project also decides your markup
suppose you are trying to go for a new
local
you'd like to go in for a higher markup
because you don't want to take risk
because everything is unfamiliar to you
so until unless you are assured of high
return you would not like to go there
then sometimes it is affected by the
season in which the work is done the
degree of hazard and the difficulty you
are likely to encounter in the project
that also governs the markup sometimes
who is the owner who is the consultant
and who is the designer that also
affects the markup suppose you are
trying to work for a known client you
have a very good relation you would like
to work for them even at a lower markup
but if the client is fussy they are
delaying payments you do not like to
work with them for low markup until
unless you are assured of very high
return you won't be willing to work with
them then the time available for bid
preparation also is one of the factors
if you have very less time normally you
try to go for higher markup then the
labor availability and the productivity
likely to be achieved at site also
affects your markup so that was our
discussion on markup was concerned now
we are very close to computing the bid
price because now we have completed our
discussion on direct cost indirect cost
and even the markup so in order to find
the bid price I just find another term
which is known as cover or
multiplication factor so multiplication
factors Co sometimes also known as cover
is a ratio or bid price to labour cost l
plus material cost M plus plant in
machinery cost P now this capital L is
the sum of all labor components for
different items this Capital m is sum of
metal component of all material items
all items of my project P is the sum of
all plant and machinery component of all
items in my project so what I do is I
have calculated the labor cost for all
items I have calculated the metal cost
for all items I have also calculated the
plant and machinery cost for all the
so I add all of them and these are part
of my direct cost so I know the direct
cost but my client is interested in
knowing the final rate so how do I
derive the rate now I have got the labor
component metal component plant
component and sometimes if
subcontractors are employed that cost
component is also there with me but the
client is looking for overall weight for
every item so what I do I divide this
sum of labor cost plus material cost
plus plant cost from my bid price bid
price has already been computed overall
bid price how I assumed the mark-up
either as 10% of cost or 10% of bid
price and that way I could get the bid
price from my total cost now I have to
give the individual rates for different
items see if you look at the
configuration of a a bill of quantity it
will be something like this it will be
something like this so you have let's
say this is my item number it could be
one two three four here you describe the
items description then here it would be
quantity here it would be unit of
measurement right okay now the client is
looking for the rate part and finally it
will ask you the amount right so for
each of the client each of the item
client is requiring you to fill these
values now what you have done you have
calculated the labor cost for this item
material cost for this item plant cost
for this item so this value you already
have now you have added it up right and
you have got total amount as B here this
is already found out so what I do is
this sum of L plus M plus B I divide it
from B so I find that term B divided by
L plus M plus P which is
I am calling it as cover or
multiplication factor once you have got
this covered
I can multiply each of these say I am
getting X here so I will multiply this
with X into Co so X into cover is my
this value suppose the sum of labor plus
metal plus plant for item number 1 is
100 and you have got the cover as 20 so
this cost is going to be 120 now this is
one way in which you distribute the
cover so Co is same for all the items we
call this as uniform loading but
contractors do not load this cover
uniformly for all the items here is also
a catch
not all contractors would be loading the
cover uniformly in all the items
sometimes they do front loading
sometimes they do back loading so what
happens in front loading instead of
multiplying this cover in all the items
uniformly what they do they take higher
cover and multiply it in those items
which are likely to be occurring at the
beginning of the project so what I will
do is I will see which items I will take
it up at the beginning of the project so
let's say my total cover is coming to be
10% so those items which I am likely to
do it in the beginning I will multiply
it with let's say 15% or 20% so this is
what you can see here let's say in this
particular example if you see the
uniform cover is 11.11% so I have
multiplied all these items with the same
cover 11.11 you can see I have 13 items
in my project now all of them I have
used this cover of 11.11%
this we are calling it as uniform
loading what happens in front loading if
you see all those items for example
earthwork concrete
form work I have multiplied with a
higher cover so average was 11.11 but
you can see cut work itself I have
loaded 22 point two two percent concrete
works I have loaded thirteen point eight
nine percent formwork I have loaded
eighteen point five two percent
brickwork I have loaded fifteen point
three six percent and reinforcement I
have loaded twelve point eight four
percent so this is what is known as
front loading what happens in back
loading all those items which are to be
taken up towards the end of the project
I am loading it with a higher value you
can see 22 point five nine for
plastering 22 point two two for painting
and likewise aluminum work which is to
be taken up towards the end I put twenty
point five eight electrical work I am
putting nineteen point zero five and
likewise Road works which is supposed to
be taken at the end I am putting twenty
point eight three so this is known as
back loading so depending on the
strategy adopted by the contractor they
can either go in for uniform loading
front loading or back loading in India
most of the time people go in for front
loading because that way it helps in
their positive cash flow so what happens
is if you apply more cover in the
initial items you may have more money
for less work that you have done so for
example if you have spent eighty rupees
you might get one hundred five rupees
from the client if you have front loaded
in some cases especially in countries
where rate of inflation is very high
they prefer back loading but not in case
of our country but you have to be very
very very careful if you are a
contractor in applying this front
loading because sometimes client make at
you especially for items which are very
obvious for example if you try to front
load on items such as a reinforcement
people will catch you because it is not
very difficult to find the rate of
reinforcement so if let's say the item
is cutting bending and tying of
reinforcement anyone can call up let's
say sale or Tata to find what is the
rate at which they can deliver at your
site
you can talk to any subcontractor who is
into cutting and bending and tying of
days they will easily tell you what is
the rate for Burton then you can add the
cost of cover blocks and binding wire so
you know what is the likely reasonable
cost of a reinforcement item now if you
have front-loaded it that too with a
very high margin client will catch you
and then they will pressurize you to
lower your prices so you have to be very
very careful when you are going for
front loading so in this particular
lecture I have essentially told you
about how to determine the bid price bid
price is essentially consisting of your
total cost and markup total cost is
consisting of your direct cost plus
indirect cost direct cost is again
consisting of cost of your labor
material plant crew and subcontractor
likewise indirect cost consists of your
overheads common plant and equipment and
common workmen when it comes to markup
it essentially consists of your profit
overheads that is general overheads
allowances for risk and contingencies
there are many factors on which this
markup depends we have seen all those
factors in the subsequent lectures we
will discuss more in detail regarding
how to go about all these things once
again I will try to take up some kind of
a case study in that case it would be
more clear to you so we stop at this
particular point thank you very much for
reference you may like to refer to these
books if you have any doubt regarding
the availability of these books or if
you want some more textbooks you can
always write to us so thank you very
much and see you some other time
[Music]
[Music]
