noc19-me23 Lec 8b 30 10 2018 JRK

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 3, 2023
Friends, welcome back, we were last time talking about translating customers voice and we were
trying to understand the tool called as Quality Function Deployment.
So let me recap little bit about Quality Function Deployment.
Quality Function Deployment is a tool which is used in converting the perceived needs
of the customer to yield a competitive advantage.
That means to say you are trying to understand whatever customer wants, many of them will
be qualitative that converting it into a quantitative way and when you convert it into quantitative
way you will also have to see what is already available in the market so that your product
can go one step ahead of it so that you can reach out to the customers and do a wonderful
justification to whatever it is.
So that is what I said customer to yield a competitive advantage, that is what it is.
Quality Function Deployment utilizes designing attributes to portray each of the item's useful
necessities.
For example, when we talk about a pen, when we talk about a car, when we talk about a
chair, we always say okay in a chair I would like to have this 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8,
9, 10 requirements and again these requirements will have to be ranked and certain requirements
where you feel it is important may be the customer feels it is not important.
For example, even today we do not have a customized chair which can suit individual's requirement.
We all do a compromise in our sitting posture to the existing chair whatever available with
us.
Even now it is a challenge, even now a table is a challenge, even now a pen is a challenge,
even now a shoe is a challenge.
So there are several challenges but we are happy with whatever product is available and
then we try to make the best use of it and we are happy with that.
So that is what we are trying to say portray each of the item's useful necessity.
The building quality are connected to the customer's prerequisites okay.
So this is what we are trying to say, building qualities whatever we are trying to build
in our product we will try to make sure that it fulfills all the prerequisite.
Before this we discussed about the Kano's model.
In that Kano's model you have an expectation feature and you have a wow feature.
So that is what it is customer's requirement.
The item's engineering characteristics are additional benchmark to distinguish those
qualities that must be coordinated or surpassed.
It is stressed that the engineering characteristics are a characteristics of the functional requirement
and not the customer requirement.
So we also try to see majority of the customer requirement are converted into a functional
requirement.
For this what we do is QFD we use the house of quality, we will see what is house of quality.
House of quality is a multidimensional technique that demonstrates the relationship of the
customer's necessity to the designing qualities of the item.
It epitomizes the different parts of the customer's necessity for the item and their sentiments
for the contenders item.
So that means to say the state of the art with their competitor.
It translates and provides judgment to the relationship of every engineering characteristics
to that of the customer requirement.
So we will see what is that house of quality.
This is how the house of quality looks like.
So what we do is first we write down all the wants.
What does a customer want?
That is what is wants.
And then what we do is we start seeing that how are these customer requirements achieved.
How?
And for this how you will have technical measures.
So then before even getting into this we also try to give something called as customer importance.
Customer importance are among this 10-15 parameters which are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 we rank them and then
we try to move them up and down and then we try to list them how are these achieved.
What customer wants and how are they achieved.
This is where is the customer.
So you have written all customer requirements, how are they achieved and existing products
which are available in the market how are they compared with the existing product whatever
is there or with the requirements or I would say that these are the competitive products
which meet the customer requirements and how are they achieved.
So you have a relationship between them.
From now what you do is based on this you will try to choose one or two parameters best
in each row and finally you try to set the target values.
Moment you set the target values now you know how are you going to achieve.
And on the top roof whatever you have is a correlation matrix.
This matrix is going to talk about the relationship between the technical parameters itself.
So this is what is called as QFD.
QFD is otherwise called as and the house of quality.
This is a very very powerful tool which Japanese started then Americans picked over then later
electronic industry picked over and they really enjoy the benefit out of this quality function
deployment house of quality tool.
The regions of the house of quality are objective, expresses the goal of the item.
Then list of the characteristics, get a rundown of qualities of the item as characteristics
by the customer.
It should be soft, it should be hot, it should be sweet, it should be spicy whatever it is
you get please note it down all.
However possible the customer requirement ought to be gathered at their largest.
So please don't call from two people for example nowadays it is a most interesting fashion
you can see while booking hotels you look at the star rating.
So last time I booked a hotel which had a star rating of 5 out of 5.
So then I was pretty happy I booked the same hotel and I went to that hotel and somehow
I was not very happy with the star, I was not happy with the hotel accommodation.
So then I came back and then I was looking at where did I make a mistake, I picked a
hotel where it had a star rating very high.
Then I saw that the star rating is very high and the rating was given by only one person.
So when the lot size is very small the qualities or the result whatever you get are not reliable.
So we are always required to collect the largest, take a large data points and then pick up
the requirements.
These customer requirements are additionally used to assess the applicant's idea produced
to fulfill each functional requirement.
So customer requirement and functional requirements are different.
CR will lead to FR.
Importance of rating the customer you have given 10 as I already discussed you have given
10 items.
So now what we do is we try to give them with a weighted number.
Why are we doing this?
Because see if you try to say qualitatively I have to convert into quantitative and moment
I wanted to convert into quantitative it is easy I play with numbers and all these importance
or all these things this will always lead to weightages.
When I do it as a multiplication factor with some other numbers A, B and C so now I will
know what is the difference and by looking at the numbers I will be able to pick up how
significant is this parameter with respect to your output.
They are doled out to the items attribute demonstrating their relative significance
as shown by the customer.
The quantity is required to achieve the product characteristics.
So these are the building quantities communicated and are quantified as far as possible.
Although it is not standard to do as such it is proposed that the designing attributes
be assembled by their functional attributes.
Correlation matrix.
Correlation matrix was on the top.
The correlation matrix demonstrates the level of communication amongst the item built-in
qualities.
It gives some thought of the level of grouping that will exist when the endeavours to fulfil
the designing quantities.
So you can move them up and down and then try to take it and moment you move them up
and down what you can do is you can try to have a sub-module ready so that you can start
producing it.
So target values this is what I told you and then finally relationship matrix.
So relationship matrix is an efficient means of recognizing the levels of impact and the
impact between each designing trademark and the customer necessities.
This non-linear values help in identification of those quantities having the highest absolute
importance.
Customer competitive assessment we have already discussed and the technical competitive assessment
also we have discussed.
So I will keep moving.
Then absolute importance.
If you go back to the QFD if you want to see where is the absolute.
So here is the absolute importance and the relative score.
Absolute importance is the aggregate of the product of the numerical value of each element
in a column of the relationship matrix with its corresponding customer importance rating.
This is a preliminary step in obtaining the final result.
So that is absolute importance.
Next is relative importance is the assurance of the level of the added up to the numerical
score for each engineering characteristics.
High value elements here are characterized that are to be worked on and the lower one
are given a second importance and start doing it.
So you keep iterating step by step by step by step so you will try to get the requirements
and I would like to tell you that quality function deployment.
So first QFD is drawn at various levels.
So it will be drawn for a system.
Then it will be drawn for a subsystem.
Then it will be drawn for a subsystem much more smaller subsystem and then it will go
towards a part and then you will try to do QFD.
So at every QFD what happens this will lead to a next level QFD that will lead to a next
level QFD.
So you keep iterating this QFD and when you start working on it you will try to get the
best out of it.
So when we see the house of quality so these are the customer requirements with weighting
factor.
So I was talking to you about weighting factor.
These are customer requirements.
You gave a weighting factor.
So you got that.
Then the next one is this is how is your product rating this is what it is and then these are
all the engineering characteristics.
This is a correlation matrix which tries to tell me how is this fellow related with this
fellow.
So for example A related with B, C, D and E. How is A related with E and how is A related
with D you can start giving it and the same way how is D related with A also you can see.
So this is a correlation matrix and then these are the engineering characteristics.
How do we achieve what customer wants and these are the relative values for example
how for this customer requirement how do we meet out this engineering characteristics
how do you meet it and then what is their ranking with respect to this.
So you can have 9, you can have 3, you can have 2 whatever it is.
Then these are relationship matrix which we talked about and based on all these calculations
what we do is we have a calculated value at the bottom.
So wherein which we try to look at this and try to solve how to try to solve the look
at it and give priorities and then solve the requirements by that we increase the product
specification.
When we look at the product design specification it amidst the way towards finishing the house
of quality.
The product development group ought to likewise be creating the data that will shape the product
design specification PDS.
PDS contains every one of the certainties identified with the item's result.
It is the list of all functions specification is list of all functions what the item needs
to do and is the center control system and fundamental reference hotspots for the whole
item improvement movement.
The product specification should state the following things.
What is the product title?
What purpose or function the product is to perform?
For example I asked a student a question what are you doing?
The student said I am a research scholar.
Then I asked him how are you doing?
He says that I am happy.
Then I asked him what do you mean by happiness?
He says I recently published one paper here one paper here I am sending one paper there.
So then I asked him is this writing papers is the only thing as part of research?
He said no.
Then I asked him tell me what are you doing?
He says that I do this I do this but I could not understand what he does.
So then I told him see now it is time that you should write down what is that you want
to achieve in your PhD and where are you now and how are you going to achieve the rest
of the targets.
So that is what I told him.
So then he started thinking he started listing it down believe me within the next one year
he was able to complete his thesis and graduate.
So specification is very important.
You should know to put what are the targets and how are we going to achieve and how is
it.
So the purpose and the function of the product is to be performed.
See if you say what do you expect from a pen?
People say I expect this pen to write fine anyhow this pen writes.
I want to write the pen smoothly so now comes the question what is smoothness?
So then I say that okay I want this when I use this pen the ink should not flow out my
hand should not get it should not get wet and it should not get the ink should not make
my hand feel dirty or so all those things.
So that is what is a pen should write clean neat without spilling ink.
So now you see you have put many of those things in the purpose and the function of
the product.
Against what type of products will it be competing and who makes them?
For example you might say these pens are available in abroad when I was young people used to
hold that paper made pen and then they that used to write so smooth and in India we did
not have and that way I am talking about 20-25 years back we were never even aware of a concept
of use and throw.
So now when today when I have to make a product I should always look at what is national what
is international who makes it and how do they make it.
Next what market will it serve?
So if I make a pen am I going to give it to school children?
Am I going to give to college children?
Am I going to give it to executives?
For example Rolls Royce car is very clear I am my class of customers are going to be
a light so the basic starting price of my car is 25 lakhs.
So you should be very clear what are you doing?
What market will it serve?
Why there is a need?
That is also a question.
The anticipated demand and the target price this also you should know.
Product identities and the relationship of the company's current product line with respect
to it.
For example it is interesting for a you take Tata Motors Tata as a group Tata Motors Tata
is very famous for iron and steel Tata Motors.
Look at their spectrum they also make salt Tata salt.
If a big company comes and when they had to enter into market it was very difficult for
the Tata company to convince customers to say that see we also make products in the
domestic domain.
People did not accept it in the first one because Tata tea, Tata salt people did not
accept in the first go.
It took lot of time for customers to accept and then they started accepting and today
they have their own niche market.
So the relationship of the company's current product line also plays an important role
while releasing the product.
So these are all important product definitions which should be stated.
So the components of the product design specification general say the purpose of the product I have
just classified it you can just go through it I will pick up something and discuss.
So the purpose of the product it should be very clear and then the target cost to the
customer should also be clear.
When I say I want to make a pen and you should have a pricing for it when you have a pricing
for it then you start reverse working it.
For example when Tata Motors started making a nano car they first fixed the overall price
of 2500 dollars and they said okay or 1 lakh rupees and then they started saying this is
the maximum Indian middle class family can give and now I will try to make a car for
them.
So then what they did was they listed down all the subsystems and then they put the weightages
of all the subsystems and then they corresponding to their weightages they started dividing
their 1 lakh whatever it is 1 lakh or 2500 dollars correspondingly and then they also
found out okay this is only with respect to what is the weightage of that particular product
in the overall performance of the car then correspondingly they made a costing and then
next what are all the very salient one which they cannot undergo any risk.
For example radiator, engine they cannot take risk they can spend more money.
So then they did one another costing keeping importance then they tried to have the matrix
ready with them and then finally they decided if there is a component A in the car this
will be the maximum price they can give okay.
So I have said purpose and need purpose and need are different so need benefit for the
user then time for product to first reach customer that is also very important if I
decide to buy a car and then I pay booking for the car and I wait for long time and then
I realize that okay the car is supposed to be delivered after 18 months.
So people will say no I don't need it and today in this e-world and digital world where
supply chain is very strong people don't even feel like waiting for even 24 hours.
People today buy fast food for 30 minutes I order 30 minutes I get a delivery so that's
what it is.
So in general purpose you will also try to do a benchmarking this is very important when
you are looking for a product you should always do benchmarking look at your customer see
what they do and never try to mimic them go ahead of them.
So benchmarking is that is what you know what your customer makes or your competitor makes
draw a line and break that line and go further okay service life market evaluation and trademarks
as far as performance is concerned look at their functions look at their features you
try to get the performance then comes constraints.
So cost is a constraint this is a interesting thing which people are now talking about disposal
and recycling after these laptops are over they have lot of rare earth materials how
do we discard that is also required in the product specification today how are we going
to recycle and discard then manufacturing facilities process capabilities in house in
country out of country these are some of the constraints which you have to look forward
for example people try to try to make lot of wood and furnitures the wood is a constraint
in our country so it has to be imported okay or thermal power plants coal is a constraint
the good quality coal is a constraint in India so it has to be imported so these are
all certain things we should see how do we go about why in the product specification
itself and keep continuing the constraints testing facility today I was trying to work
on a machine and I was trying to buy a XYZ stage where in which the company said I have
0.2 micron resolution of the stage.
So my first question came to me I will buy this because this is what is the resolution
I want for my machine but then I asked a question for myself suppose if the person
who delivers it comes and says here is a machine of 0.2 please validate it I do not have a
capability to I will validate it so now what is the point if he says 0.1 okay if he says
1 micron it is okay because I do not have the capability so testing is other thing which
is very very important when we make a textile cloth there are sequences or there are characteristics
tests which are to be performed it has to withstand 10,000 times cyclic load so those
test facilities should be there and based on the test facilities only we should try
to do a product design specification same with aesthetics energy consumption all these
things are some of the components of product design this is a consolidated one so you can
pick up and when you try to take a product you can pick up and then try to go through
the list and start filling up the details for each item and then you can try to have
your own product specification or customer requirements so this is what I was trying
to talk about this is the first level house of quality from the house of quality it led
to a design and then starts the next house of quality then it led to services and this
love services led to process and you can see so moment you start working on several
levels of house of quality I am sure you will try to get the meet out target because at
every stage you try to meet out a score and a target one so your product is good and every
stage you will try to beat a customer and go further so by doing this step by step by
step you can try to get so that is what it is called as four phase of quality function
deployment or house of quality so this can be a system this can be a subsystem this can
be a part this can be a process whatever it is okay so you see we can start working from
a whole system and we go to the last point and see what is that required so now let us
see an example of quality function house of quality deployment and house of quality
example so you see here there are legends used okay this legend says strong relationship
moderate relationship weak relationship then this is strong positive correlation positive
correlation negative correlation so where is the correlation correlation all comes in
the top so correlation comes here and then relationship comes here you get relationship
okay and this is all their competitive analysis and these are the companies right and these are
the target values whatever we have put here and these are the difficulties in achieving the target
this is the maximum relationship value you get then you have a weightages and then you have
relative weightages with that you try to draw a house of quality so here is an example we are
trying to talk about chocolate chips cookies has to be made the customer requirement was
as functional requirement customer requirements are these are the demand from customers it has
to have a good texture it has to be generous portions generously for the portions and it
tastes good it has to be low price it has to be an appetizing appearance it has to have an
appetizing appearance okay so here you will have the quality characteristics so these are the
quality functions color these are the quality or the functional requirements color then you
have the tensile yield strength tensile ultimate strength then you will have weight size thickness
sale average hedonic scale rating cost per cookie density of the chocolate chips so all these things
are the functional requirements and these are the customer requirements so here you see that
you have written 1 2 3 4 5 and then maximum relationship value in each row you have given
and then what had happened then you have given weightages of each one so from this what do we
do is we try to take the relative weightages so the relative weightages you will get 6.7 13.3 and
33.3 okay so you multiply and then you sum it up and then you divide and find out what is this
ratio so you get it then it is 26.7 and then you have 20 okay so these are relative weightages what
you get so use you take this total and then divide it by the sum and then you get it here
so now let us see the relationship so the good texture it has a strong relationship with respect
to the output so what do I do I try to give 9 marks so then I will try to have a tensile high
strength I give 9 marks okay so then so this weight so generous portion and weight they have
very weak this thing they have relationship so generous as a size it is very high then you will
also have thickness it is very high then tastes good this is 9 points and then a lower price cost
per cookie it should be as low as possible and then appearance I should be a color is 1 and
then the density also plays a very important role so now let me look at the relationship between
these two fellows so the yield strength the tensile yield strength and the ultimate they
have a strong relationship so I will give them double plus okay and then I have the weight with
respect to size weight with respect to size they have a double plus then I have weight with respect
to thickness okay so I have a negative influence size with respect to thickness so they have a
negative correlation size diameter with respect to thickness okay then I also have a negative
for this density versus size okay so then I can also have very strong negative correlation very
strong negative correlation is cost and density is very strong like I have right so in a similar
way I have a positive correlation between this and then I have a positive correlation between
this okay and then here is a negative positive positive okay so you can keep adding it so I have
just put a relationship very this thing so now what has happened so you have got so you have
now your competitor analysis you are doing 5 is the best and 0 is the worst so you are trying to
compete with the competitors and see how is your rating or this particular company how is their
performance which meeting out the customer requirements so you are trying to get this
done okay so now what has happened you are trying to look at the difficulty level how difficult it
is in getting these things so you can now start giving numbers so 5 7 5 2 3 5 8 6 and 3 okay so
these are the difficulty levels so easy to accomplish very easily which I do the change
I can try to meet out the customer requirements so I have just given the rating so now what do I
do is I try to see the relationship values so these relationship values you can again start
giving these relationship values like some values you can start giving so here I give 9 9 9 I give
1 then these are all random I am giving it based upon the requirements 9 3 9 9 and 3 okay so then
it is weightages per importance now I am trying to multiply this and try to get the weightages
right column by weightage and importance so I get here 180 okay so you can keep doing 60 and then
you can keep doing all these values I get a value of 60 here okay now what do I do I try to see
their influence on the total score so I try to get the relative importance of 16.8 then maybe I
get 5.6 so it goes on so I get a 5.6 right so this is over the relative weightages and then
from here I try to pick the values and start working on it so this is how you try to fill
out the house of quality in quality function deployment so like this if you start filling
up all the relationship you can start getting a complete value you get all the numbers and
from these numbers you can start giving the relative weightages from this relative weightages
you know the significant parameters and you start attacking the significant parameters to
meet out the customer demand and here is or it talks about how is the company's performance with
respect to your product so with this we would like to come to an end for this quality function
deployment so to recap first we saw how could we describe the voice of customers then we saw what
is quality function deployment then we saw what is house of quality then we saw elements of house
of quality then we saw how do we get the specific a product specification and then the last one we
saw what are the four phases in QFT so as a small take-home example which the student is supposed
to try and need not submit with us try to find out what are the features expected from a teacher
okay so you are supposed to develop a Kano model and then you are also supposed to develop a QFD
for it what are the features okay so features expected from a pencil again you are supposed
to do a Kano model and then a QFD model okay so Kano model so something like this you have this
so you have this and this is happy and this is sad okay so you are supposed to do this model
and try to figure out and you are also supposed to do a quality function deployment okay so you
have to go ask at least for these two you are supposed to talk to 20 people and try to take
the voice of the customer and convert it into a Kano model and then QFD model so voice of customer
and quality function deployment and see how difficult it is how iteratively it changes okay
so with that two examples we come to an end to this lecture thank you.
