noc19-ch17-lec56

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 2, 2023
This is the continuation of previous lecture on solid-liquid equilibria
Welcome back, in the last class I was discussing about solid-liquid equilibria and how do we
construct phase diagram for such a system, okay.
And so we said well we can make use of the same equilibrium criteria which is the fugacity
of a component i in the solid phase should be equal to that in the liquid phase.
And considering Lewis and Randle reference state we can represent f i l in terms of x
i gamma i f i l pure and we can consider for example solid phase to be pure.
If we do that then essentially we have you know this particular expression and this ratio
of the fugacity of component i in the solid phase divided by that in the liquid phase
for the pure case can be related to the difference in the molar Gibbs free energy for this component
in different phases.
So using this we came up with an expression which relates the composition of a component
i and the activity gamma this is in the liquid phase and that is related to the delta H of
fusion.
Delta H is you know change in enthalpy, okay for the between the solid and liquid at a
specific temperature and that and then you have this another term which relates or connects
to the delta S that is the change in entropy.
But this is at a temperature T, okay so this particular functions H and S this would be
at a specific temperature T and what we usually know is delta H and delta S at the melting
condition or at basically Tm.
So in order to find out this delta H fusion and delta S fusion at a given temperature
where basically we are interested in then we must try to use some approach to find
such a thing and one easiest way to do that is to construct a thermodynamic pathway, okay
and this is something which we have done earlier also but now we are going to apply the similar
concept to obtain this delta H fusion and delta S fusion for a given temperature using
the information of delta H and delta S at Tm.
So let me just draw first a temperature versus, okay kind of a phases so this could be your
Tm and this could be your T and this is your liquid let us say and this is your solid this
is what we want.
We want the information from liquid to solid that would be your delta H fusion at the specific
temperature T and what we know usually is this information which is your delta H at
Tm, okay.
So what we can do is we can connect this particular reference by again a simple path which is
rectangular in nature.
So now we can say that this is a path 1, this is 2 and 3.
Now in order to find this delta H fusion T, I can write this delta H fusion T is delta
H 1 plus delta H 2 plus delta H 3, okay.
Now what would be your delta H 1?
This is can simply connect to the basically Cp of the liquid phase because this is a liquid.
So liquid L dT, T to Tm this is the specific change in enthalpy along this particular path.
Similarly I can do the same thing for here.
This is the solid phase because this is a solid here and this is a liquid.
So this way I can write this as Tm T Cps, okay.
So because there is no specific phase change along this particular path 1 and 3 and this
is a single phase but only the temperature is changing.
So essentially we simply relate to the Cp, okay.
That is something which we have done earlier also, okay.
But what about delta H 2?
So delta H 2 is nothing but delta H fusion at Tm, right and that is something which we
are given or which we are aware of it.
Now given this you can plug in back this expression to obtain delta H fusion at T.
This would be your delta H fusion at Tm, okay plus Tm by T and then essentially we are changing
this limits, okay which from Tm to T and hence if you do that there has to be negative sign
here.
So when you add this negative Cpl with Cps this would be something like this, okay.
So this way we can rearrange this expression.
This plus this and this can be written in this way, okay.
So this is nothing but delta Cp Sl dt.
you have now a relation delta H fusion at specific Tm plus Tm to T delta Cp Sl dt, right.
So that is what we have as far as the delta H is concerned.
But since we are interested not just only in delta H but as well as delta S because
both are required in order to get delta G which can be connected to this composition
and activity coefficient.
So now we should ask about how do you get this fusion particularly at T we can use a
similar path and in that case I will have delta S fusion, sorry delta S at for the path
one that I can write it in terms of T to Tm in terms of Cpl by T, okay.
This simply we can write plus the second path which is along the phase transition this would
be delta S fusion Tm plus again Tm to T, okay.
So this is what we have as far as delta S is concerned, okay.
So this we have separately written for delta H and separately written for delta S.
Now we can again in a similar way as we have done that we can again rearrange this and
this we can write it as delta S fusion Tm change the limit to Tm by T and since T is
constant you will have the difference between Cps minus Cpl which would be your delta Cp
Sl and this is your dt, okay.
So we have now come up with an expression for delta H and delta S fusion at the specific
temperature T, okay.
Now you note that delta Hg fusion Tm that is the way the system is at equilibrium at
this condition you should be 0 that means delta G should be 0 and this is nothing but
delta H fusion Tm minus Tm delta S fusion Tm.
Now this relates delta S fusion at Tm as H fusion Tm divided by Tm.
So it tells you that at a fusion particularly at Tm which is an equilibrium condition you
should have this delta G must be 0, okay and that means there is a relation between
delta S and delta H in this way.
So I can now plug this expression back in and I can have a much less or rather more
simplified expression which just depends on T, okay because Tm we know, right and T of
course we would like to find, I mean we would like to fix the value of T in order to get
the phase diagram.
Tm is, we know Tm, we know delta H fusion, okay that is usually the case and of course
delta Cp Sl also we would know.
So we can find out delta S. Now given this delta S and delta H you can now plug in back
in this expression, okay.
So with these two key expressions we have, one is of course this, this could be written
as 2 and the other one is this.
Now use this 1 and 2 expression to obtain the information of ln xi.
So we can substitute now, substitute ln, substitute delta H and delta S in the expression of ln
xi gamma i, okay.
So again let me write it again here.
So this is your delta H fusion Rt divided by delta, so this is your delta H fusion at
T by Rt minus delta S fusion at T by R, okay.
Now with this we can simplify this, so I can now write delta S fusion T from 1.
We have delta H fusion Tm plus Tm by T delta Cp Sl dt divided by Rt minus, minus this term
delta fusion T by R.
So if you divide this by R you will get this information.
So this can be written as let us say delta H fusion Tm by R Tm plus 1 by R integral of
Tm T delta Cp Sl by T dt, okay.
So if you simplify this, if you take out this part you are going to get the following, okay.
So let me try to simplify this.
So if you look at it, this you have is delta fusion Tm and there is also delta fusion Tm
and Rtm, this is Rt.
So I can take out delta H fusion at Tm by R and what is common here is taken out, what
remains is 1 by T minus 1 by Tm, okay.
Similarly if you look at it delta Cp here, it seems to be common here, but let me just
write this in this way that I can write this as minus of R, this is a minus here, it comes
here and this is your Tm by T delta Cp Sl by T dt plus here this part can be written
as 1 by R T delta Cp Sl dt Tm by T.
So this is the total expression of xi gamma i.
Now if you consider delta Cp to be independent of temperature, then this further can be written
as this.
If delta Cp is constant, then you have the first term plus delta Cp comes out separately,
okay.
What remains is T minus Tm by T minus ln T by Tm.
So this is the expression which we got.
Now you can do with a bit of assumptions and you have now way to obtain information of
a composition when you have information of delta S, delta H at melting conditions, okay
and as well as you know heat capacities.
Now how do you take this forward and solve a certain problem?
So let us do this exercise to understand a bit, okay.
Now one of the thing which we can do is of course we can find out, let us say you can
find out now an equilibrium condition between solid-liquid equilibria here for example.
So these points you can find it out, right, at any given point.
So if you have the information of the melting point, then essentially you can find out this
information, okay and in that way you can also map this whole curve and obtain the eutectic
point, okay.
So let us try to do this in order to get a feeling of this whole exercise, okay.
So this is a case where we have to find a eutectic point of a binary mixture, okay,
which cadmium and, okay, and lead.
So what is the assumption that these metals are immiscible, completely is immiscible?
So solid phase are, solid is immiscible, liquid phase is completely miscible.
So this is basically the assumption which we are considering, the solid phase do not
mix at all and the liquid it mix completely.
Now information which is given to us for the case of let us say Pb, lead and this is cadmium,
so these are the information is given to us, is Tm is given.
So I am not going to, I am not going to describe completely all the data, so the whole idea
is to understand the process and subsequently you can take it on your own.
So Tm is, information is given, delta H fusion at Tm is given, okay and Cps at Tm is given,
Cpl at Tm is given in order to get this eutectic point for different phases.
So what we can do is we can perform two cases, one a is when the liquid forms an ideal solution,
okay, which essentially means that gamma i is equal to 1 and when you consider this ideal
solution that means the left hand side is simply log gamma i, right, and it is a binary
solution.
So essentially you can write this like ln of x of Pb, right, and then we can write
down the right hand side expression which is this, right.
Now in this case of course we can also consider Cpsl to be, Cpsl to be constant, then we will
have this complete information, it will be simpler rather.
So considering that Cpsl delta is constant, I can write down the final expression here
which is this, okay, this was delta H fusion R, so we can plug this information because
rest of the information is given to us and so you have simply delta H fusion Tm and this
is of that of Pb, so this is of Pb, okay, then you have this R, okay, and 1 by T minus
Tm of Pb, right, and then you have this delta Cpsl of Pb by R and the rest of the other
terms which is basically the same term as we are going to write it here, okay, which
is T minus T minus Tm of Pb by T minus L T by Tm.
Now this is equation 1, okay, similarly you can do the same exercise for Cd, okay.
Now Cd you can also write the same exercise, now the point here is which should be noted
that this particular equation gives you clearly an expression which relates a composition
of lead with the temperature, so essentially you can get a temperature versus composition
plot for Pb using this expression, okay, and similarly you can do the same exercise for
the Cd, you have to plug in all these values, so if you do that you may get something like
this, you know, that, you know, let us say composition of Pb, if it is 0.1 you may get
corresponding T, if you put some composition here, okay, you will have to solve T here,
right, so that would be let us say 548.8, okay, and similarly if you put some numbers
let us say 0.55, okay, so and similarly if you put let us say, you know, you can keep
doing that and keep getting the point here and after that there will be some issues because
you cannot go beyond a certain number because that will become the non-solvable equation
and then at certain point 0.6 you may not get this value but if you look at the other
equation it will provide the solution and 395.3 will come out for the temperature as
for the case of a cadmium, so 0.6 let means 0.4 cadmium as far as the mole fraction is
concerned, okay, and similarly if you go till 0.9 some values of 0.4 comes in, like 541.4
comes in, so this is also temperature, okay, but this temperature corresponds to let us
say Pb, okay, and this temperature corresponds to let us say Cd, okay.
Now the issue is again remember that we will be of course solving this but at certain point
this is non-solvable, I mean we will not get any value because that will lead to some issues
and that is something which some when you do that you will realize that, so if you solve
this problem by putting this temperature versus mole fraction, so you will see that, you know,
you have this data, okay, and then this is the case of solid Cd and liquid, okay, and
then some other data is there, okay, and this would be the case of solid lead and liquid,
okay.
So you will have, that means you will have the situation where below this temperature
you will have this solid Cd and Pb, which means that this is, if you draw this data
point and if it intersects at a certain point then this point would reflect to be a eutectic
point, but this is the case where we have assumed this to be ideal solution, remember
that because we have not considered gamma.
So if you consider a case where you have to consider gamma then it will become a non-ideal
liquid phase.
So now at this point we can consider different models of non-ideal liquid phase.
So if you have taken, let us say, non-ideal liquid phase would be solution or liquid here,
okay, and if you consider non-ideal liquid solution and considering 2-suffix Margules
equation, okay, if you consider this then essentially you have ln, the left-hand side
of this equation is ln xi plus ln gamma i.
So of course this will remain the same, but gamma, ln gamma can now be written as simply
A by RT 1 minus xi square, in this case binary solution.
So if you are talking about, let us say, RT, let us say, Pb, so x Pb plus A by RT 1 minus
x Pb, so and the rest of the right-hand side still remains the same, so this still remains
the same.
So you now have to solve the x as if, you know, you have to plug in the x values and
essentially A has to be known.
So if you plug in the x value for a given x you have to again solve the equations to
get a temperature out of it, you know, and if you do that it turns out that for the case
of a non-ideal, of course, it is not going to be so simple here.
So the question would be that how do you get the eutectic point.
So it will be more smooth here, okay, you will get more points for this.
So it is the wave, if you plot, let us say, mole fraction of Pb, okay, so you will have
this some kind of points which is something like this, it will come out to be something
like this, okay, and this is your point here.
So this is your liquid and of course this is you are going to be Cd, solid Cd plus liquid,
this is your solid Pb plus liquid, okay.
So the eutectic point in this case would be somewhere here, okay, and you can find it
out also and this will be, this will be the case where you will have a different value.
For example, in the first case, for the case of ideal solution, ideal liquid solution you
had x is equal to 0.549, okay, just to give you an idea and temperature is 373.9 Kelvin.
For the case of this non-ideal case the value comes out to be 0.675 and temperature is 503.8,
okay.
So this tells you that so important to consider in such a case proper models in order to obtain
the right information and thus ideal solution for such would not be appropriate but the
methodology does not change much, okay, it is more or less the same, the only thing is
that we have to consider the appropriate models for solving this phase diagram, okay.
So I think that would be the case for today and hopefully we have gone through a complete
analysis where we have looked into the how to generate solid-liquid equilibria and particularly
we looked at eutectic mixtures where you can find out also the eutectic compositions from
simple analysis as we have done.
So with this I will close today and we will see you next time.
