noc20-ce19-lec20

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 2, 2023
Welcome back. So, let us now have brief understanding about the intensity and the magnitude scale
and how these two scales have evolved over the time. So, if you take the chronology of
the intensity scale, then in before 1931, earthquake intensities were often reported
using Roussi-Forel scale. And in the last quarter of 19th century, the use of intensity
scale become widespread. And this scale was developed by Roussi and Forel, the two scientists
from Italy and Switzerland respectively. And this scale was called Roussi-Forel scale
with 10 degree of intensity. So, we have like from Roman letters if you take 1 to 12. So,
initially the Roussi-Forel scale was been given with the 10 degrees that 1 to 10. And
was the first scale to be used widely internationally. Now, the intensity scale may mostly if you
recall the first slide of the previous lecture or the first slide of the intensity and the
magnitude lecture, then you will you can recall that particularly the intensity depends on
the damage pattern. So, whether this should be considered the
same for the different region that is in that remains a question. So, Roussi-Forel scale
was given by Roman letters from 1 to 10. And they were been like classified as been given
here. I would like to emphasize here that it will be difficult for you to remember,
but at least you can you can refer to the scale which has been given like the one intensity
means what actually micro seismic shock recorded by single seismogram or by of the same model
the shock felt by an experience observer. So, you may not not all people in that region
will be able to experience or this minor shock. So, micro seismic then we have extremely fillable
shock recorded by different kinds of seismograph and felt by small number of persons at rest
then very fillable and so on. So, you have like up to 10 which has been given and from
8 7 you can you can see that they it was strong shock overthrow the movable object fall of
plaster ringing of church bells, but without damage of any buildings and then so on.
And finally, you have the 10 shock of extreme intensity great disaster ruins that is a building
collapsing of the buildings distribution disturbance of the strata that is in the sediment stratigraphy
you have development of fissures and ground rock falls from mountain. So, this was the
classification which was been given by the Lucifer scale of intensity scale. So, based on
this and the damage pattern and the ground deformation one can classify that what was
the intensity in a in a given site by in particular earthquake. Further the next phase the scale was
improved by Mercalli who publish a modified version still with the 10 degrees. However,
even this 10 degree were insufficient to express the whole range of effects and effects here we
are talking about the damage pattern and ground deformation. So, this was still difficult to
express the overall effect by the by in particular earthquake. The extension of the scale to 12
degrees was therefore, proposed by Kankani and this was after the Mercalli and this was been
termed as modified Mercalli scale. And usually you will find in literature that this has been
given the intensity is been given in mm this is this tends for modified Mercalli scale.
So, this was modified Mercalli scale was with 12 degrees and that was done to express the wide
range of damage or the effect by an particular earthquake. So, modified Mercalli intensity scale
if we take the maximum. So, you have the intensity here which is from 1 to 2 felt by very few people
really noticeable similar to what we were looking at the Roussi-Furel one ok. Now,
then come then comes the third one is you felt indoor specially on upper floors and this is
because of the this the different buildings will behave differently that is the shorter
ones and the taller ones. And the objects where it is not no damage will be will be experienced
if the intensity is 3 and then so on you have 4 to 5 felt by many people 6 to 7 some structural
damage to buildings will be there cracks in walls and high rise structures like building
and chimney will experience the cracks. Then 7 to 8 felt by everyone difficult to stand some
heavy furniture moved some plaster falls cracks in walls are formed and slight damage to high rise
high rise buildings and chimneys. Then coming to 9 and 10 major damage collapse of weak buildings
and cracks of to to the stronger buildings. Then coming to 11 to 12 total damage or nearly
total damage. Now, very few points which you if you look at here that this scales usually talks
about the chimney and and some places the ringing of the bells and all that of church.
So, depending on that what type of construction we have in a particular region this will keep
varying from place to place. So, but mostly we we use the modified Mercalli scale to identify
the the damage related to the earthquake. So, the isosceles maps are very much similar what
we see the contour maps in the on toposheets ok. Now, considering the intensity scale and the
pattern of damage and the deformation in particular region the intensities are been assigned.
For example, if you consider this map from US then you have like the epicenter is here. So,
this region we experienced the intensity of 8. So, mostly you will you will not find on these on
on this such maps the this numbers, but usually it is been denoted by the roman letters. So,
what we can we can infer is that there was strong ground shaking and much comparatively higher
damage as compared to the the areas which are sitting little far away from the epicenter.
So, this was 8 and this whole region based on the damage pattern is been classified that this had
an intensity of 7 and then some locations were having 6 also. So, this whole region is sitting
in 6 then goes and will have lesser intensity on the cell, but if you if you look at the the
map here then we have the 8 intensity intensity here, but this region was having comparatively
higher intensity even other than the epicentral area. Now, this was this probably was because
of the local site effect because the material within the earth crust will behave differently
and you can recall the part which we discussed in the the amplification part.
So, this probably this region had and very soft deposits or alluvium which must have
resulted into the higher amplification and strong ground shaking as compared to even
the epicentral area where maximum amount of energy was released during an earthquake. So,
such lines or the very contours which are been generated by connecting the the similar pattern
of damage or effect will give you the iso seismal map. This is from 2001 Bhuj earthquake. So,
the earthquake was in this region and as you move away then the damage pattern is less or
the damage is less and it will the damage pattern varies from the epicentral area and the areas
which are sitting away from that. So, this was an iso seismal map of 2000 Bhuj earthquake.
Another one is been given here and where the intensity is been plotted on the geological map.
So, if you see here then what we have that this region which is marked as yellow is all alluvium.
So, you have the softer deposits here hence the intensity was much comparatively higher. So,
this a region was the having the intensity of 8, this was having 9 and this a region where
the the earthquake was triggered had an intensity of 10 and further you move you have 7 here. So,
you have 10 then you have getting lesser and here you are having 8 and you are having 7 here.
So, even the areas which were sitting if you if you consider this one somewhere over here is
Ahmedabad which is sitting almost like 300 kilometers from the epicentral area was also
affected and what we learn that some pockets in in this region that is the area comprising the
the alluvial plain of Gujarat experienced strong ground shaking.
This was the case in 2005 Muzaffarabad earthquake where the seismic shaking was
experienced right up to Amritsar and in the Indo-Gangetic plain far away from the much
from the epicentral area in this region. So, the intensity was almost like 4 here and 5 near
the northwest Himalaya that is in Amritsar, Gurdaspur and Jalandhar region and even in the
Kangra region in the the lesser Himalayan zone. So, seismologists developed different methods
to record the size of an earthquake based on body wave which travels deep within the
earth structure and then secondly based on the surface wave which primarily travel on the
uppermost layer of the earth crust. So, so based on this seismologists have developed
different magnitude scale to record and particular size of earthquake. So, this part we discussed in
the previous one that the you we we use mostly the arrival of P wave and S wave and the maximum
amplitude of a particular seismic wave to identify the magnitude of an earthquake. So,
this was in 1931 Wadati a Japanese meteorologist worked on the idea of earthquake scale.
Following his concept Richter developed the first magnitude scale in 1934-35 and this scale was
termed as local magnitude scale ML. It has been denoted as ML local magnitude scale which was
been modified and proposed by Richter in 1935 after the the concept which was been given by
Wadati. Now the scales again as in what we have looked at the chronology of the intensity
starting from reciprocal and modified Mercalli scale Mercalli scale and then modified Mercalli
scale. In similar way with more information and with the with the lessons which were been learned
during some earthquakes in the past the magnitude scale also got modified over the time.
So, ML had like Mercalli was local magnitude scale whereas, the Richter scale had a limitation
which which says that can be only recorded by a special type of seismograph and this seismograph
is been named as Wood Anderson torsional seismograph ok. So, again very much similar
to the what we were talking about the seismograph whether seismograph invented by Chinese
but this slightly different mechanism here. So, there will be during an earthquake of
different frequency waves are been generated and this will record the vibrations and will tell us
that what was the intensity was sorry the energy which was been released. So, mostly the Richter
magnitude scale can was so sensitive that the instrument that it can even tell us that if
there is an just if you what amount of energy is been released by even dropping a brick
from a table top. However, this instrument
had limitations to measure the large magnitude earthquakes taking place at far distance.
Now, this part if you recall the what we discussed during the different type of frequency
of seismic waves generated during an earthquake. So, we have low frequency, we have high frequency
and the low frequency waves will not attenuate very fast and will travel far distance ok.
So, this instrument had limitation to record or measure the distant traveling wave that is
in tele seismic waves we usually talk about the when we consider mostly the surface waves and
that will underestimate the magnitude mostly. So, the large magnitude earthquakes
were not been recorded precisely by this instrument and the Richter scale had the
limitation. So, it gave accurate energy released by an earthquake up to magnitude 6.5.
However, locally in the range of around 100 kilometers if this instrument has been placed
or it is been located from the epicenter, then it can measure the earthquake even up to greater than
8 magnitude. But if this the epicenter is far located and the from the instrument,
then the it may undersize the magnitude. So, the largest earthquake recorded was
Alaskan earthquake 9.64 with an Richter scale of about 8.6. Now, if you look at the record
of the earthquake that is this is not exactly the largest earthquake, but this could this can
be classified as in a second largest in terms of what we have the records available 9 9.5 was the
largest earthquake of Chile 1960 and this was 9.3 the second largest earthquake, but with the
Richter magnitude scale the magnitude which was been assigned was 8.6. So, this this has this
suggest clearly that this earthquake which was above 9 less than 9.5 was undersized.
So, with this also when you take into consideration the this information for the hazard
analysis, then you may undersize the hazard. So, Richter magnitude seismology is to use
a magnitude scale to express the seismic energy released by each earthquake.
So, again very much similar to the intensity scale this was been classified and compared
with the intensity scale that if you are having magnitude less than 2, because the Richter
magnitude and the instrument which was been devised the Wood Anderson torsional seismograph
can record even the drop of the brick the energy released due to the dropping the brick from the
table top. So, from less than 2 to 3.5 magnitude generally not felt and they are considered as a
micro earthquakes the not felt by the people recorded by local seismograph.
Then coming to the next 3.5 to 5.4 often felt, but rarely cause damage less than equal to 6
at most slight damage or to well designed buildings can cause major damage to poorly
constructed buildings over small regions. 6.1 to 6.9 can be destructive in areas up to
about 100 kilometers from the epicenter across where the population is there. So,
again this point is important, because if you are having less populated area
you may undersize not the magnitude, but you may undersize the intensity that is the
on intensity scale you may record that the damage was not much and not many people got
killed during this and the earthquake magnitude was less or the intensity was less.
Then ranging from 7 to 7.9 is considered as a major earthquake can cause a serious damage over
large area 8 or greater than they are this type of earthquakes are been considered
as great earthquake can cause a serious damage massive damage in the areas for several kilometers
across ok. So, this may you can you can think of this one, but the magnitude of Buj earthquake was
7.6 it was the major earthquake in that region. So, the great earthquakes we have the region
like Himalayas which can host the great earthquakes and cause can those earthquakes
can cause severe damage and covering larger areas. So, this is the classification of the
Richter magnitude scale. Modified Mercalli intensity and comparison with the Richter
magnitude you have is been given here. So, please refer it ok. So, you have the
here you are what you have the magnitude and this is the maximum modified Mercalli intensity
which has been given ok. So, this goes up to 11 to 12 and this can be compared
with 8 magnitude or the great magnitude great earthquakes and it will result into total damage
or nearly total damage and hence what we see is the maximum area will get affected and this is
the comparison with the intensity scale here. So, the comparison between the modified Mercalli
intensity and the Richter scale. So, this is an example of seismograph network
in Seattle USGS where continuous earthquakes have been recorded. So, these are all small
magnitude earthquakes which have been recorded on the seismograph. And as we discussed in one of
the lecture that along with the recording of the earthquake that is the arrival of P wave and S
wave the seismologist and structural engineers will be interested in recording that what was
the horizontal displacement and what was the vertical displacement in that particular region.
So, this darker parts what you see is the amplitude of the arrival of seismic waves.
So, this is an example from the volcanic eruption which was experienced along the
Mount St Helens in US and what they did was they continuously kept monitoring
the occurrence of the earthquake which was related to the movement of lava
along the conduit of this cone which was the earthquakes were been recorded here.
So, this were the number of earthquakes which were been recorded just before the volcanic
eruption in that region. Limitation with the Richter and magnitude scale as we discussed
and the Richter scale can only measure the earthquakes which are occurring in the local
area up to 100 kilometers, but the far the earthquakes taking place far away that is
the large magnitude earthquakes then has limitations ok. So, considering and taking
into consideration the limitations new scales to measure large earthquakes or distant earthquake
based on the teleseismic waves were developed. So, first it came that let us use the surface
wave and with the help of that if we can measure the large magnitude earthquakes and the
magnitude scale was been denoted as MS surface wave magnitude and then another one was which
came up was the body wave magnitude MB. Now, before I talk about the difference or
the development of the different scale the difference between the intensity like people
usually confuse that if then epicenter is here then the intensity will be much larger here
then it will further reduce and it goes something like this ok.
So, suppose you are having 10 here and then this will might be having like in between you have 9
here and then you are having 8 here and then 7 here ok for example. So, the intensity reduces
and then the earthquake which was this an epicenter. So, this varies from the epicentral
area, but in terms of the magnitude measured will remain the same as because the seismographs
will measure the amount of energy and that magnitude is been assigned based on the
arrival of an p and s wave. So, magnitude will the instruments which are located
far away from the epicenter ok, all this instruments will record and give the same
magnitude and that will not be like the in the case of the intensity.
Because intensity changes that is the seismic shaking will differ, but the magnitudes remains
the same if we are also sitting far away from the epicentral area. So, this part you should
keep in mind when we are talking about the intensity scale and the magnitude scale.
So, with the limitation of the surface wave magnitude and body wave magnitude,
surface wave magnitude scale become saturated at about 7.3 magnitude whereas, the body wave
magnitude it saturated at about 6 magnitude very much similar to the local magnitude.
Now, with this Aki in 1966 proposed a new scale and that was been termed as moment magnitude.
So, what he proposed that the energy released or radiated from entire fault that is the ruptured
area is to be taken into consideration rather than an assumed source of point.
So, this the seismic moment has been defined as you have the as m 0 m o and you have the mu here
then surface and the displacement here. So, mu is the shear modulus of elasticity and first
cost is mostly like what we take is 3.2 into 10 to the power 11 times per second centimeter square
and the u bar is your the amount of slip along a particular fault.
So, what is the amount of slip or the rupture along the rupture the displacement which has
been taken and the s is your the surface area that ruptured during an earthquake which includes the
that is the area. So, we have the length and the depth. So, the area ruptured and the depth
of the fault plane. So, this has been taken into consideration to talk about the s.
Now, with this you can calculate the moment seismic moment and further this information
can be quickly used in computing the moment magnitude that is been denoted as m w. So,
later a more refined scale was proposed by Kanamori related to the seismic moment known
as moment magnitude which came out with the empirical relation which is given here.
And moment magnitude is the scale which is now used worldwide for measuring moderate
as well as large earthquake. So, with this I will end my lecture here and we will continue
with little more details on this in the next lecture
and then we will move to the active fault topography part. Thank you so much.
