noc20-bt01-lec27_ Lecture 27: Yield and Sustained Yield

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 2, 2023
Lecture 27: Yield and Sustained Yield
[Music]
[Music]
a mistake we move forward our discussion
on logging I need and in today's lecture
we'll have a look at yield and sustained
yield now the basic question when we are
doing classical said we culture is this
you have a piece of land and there are a
number of trees on this piece of land
now you have got two options
option one is to clear fill this area
and extract all the timber now if you go
with this option then yield will ask
what is the total amount of timber that
will get extracted or harvested
so this is the first way in which we can
define ield what is the total value of
timber or what is the total volume of
timber that we can extract from this
forest but in a number of situations we
do not want to go with this clear
felling so we can look at option two now
in option two the owner of this forest
might say that I do not want all this
timber right away but then I have my own
needs so like every year I require some
timber for my own use I require some
timber that I can sell to them ah I
didn't get some money now if I wanted to
manage this forest in such a manner that
every year I should be getting some
amount and this amount should be steady
it should be constant so in that case
how do I manage this forest so option
two is you harvest not the complete
forest but a portion of the forest every
year and
the objective would be in a sustained
manner now what do we mean by a
sustained manner if we were to draw a
plot between the volume extracted per
year versus the year or let us say time
then sustained yield would say that the
same amount should be extracted every
year and it will be of benefit to the
forest owner if this amount could be
maximized so what we are saying here is
that suppose it is possible to extract
say ten thousand cubic meter every year
but we are extracting eight thousand
cubic meters every year now from this
forest it is possible to extract eight
thousand cubic meters per year but if we
extract it two thousand cubic meters
more even then it would have been a
sustained operation so every year we
could have gone with ten thousand cubic
meters so why not go with that so this
second definition of ield says what is
the sustained amount of timber
or rather the maximum sustained amount
of timber that can be extracted or
harvested every year
so these are the two meanings of field
the first meaning is the amount of
timber that can be harvested per unit
period generally this period is taken to
be one year so the amount of timber that
can be harvested every year or the
amount of timber that can be removed at
any time so at any time it means that we
are taking a snapshot and we are asking
the question what is the total amount of
timber that I have to understand this
problem suppose you have deposited one
hundred thousand rupees into your bank
account and this Bank is giving an
interest at the rate of ten percent per
year now let us plot the amount that we
have in the bank versus the year now in
the zeroth year you deposited one
hundred thousand rupees now after one
year the amount plus the interest so the
interest that will have is one hundred
thousand into ten by hundred is equal to
ten thousand so at the end of one year
the amount that we have in this Bank is
now 100 thousand plus ten thousand one
hundred and ten thousand rupees so at
the end of one year you have one hundred
and ten thousand rupees now similarly if
you have a forest that suppose currently
has our total growing the stock of say a
hundred thousand cubic meters and it is
having an increment of ten percent and
we'll say that at the end of one year we
have a volume of one hundred and ten
thousand so it's one and the same thing
now out of this amount suppose you were
to extract ten thousand rupees
so out of your 110 thousand rupees you
extracted ten thousand rupees from that
account for your own use so now the
amount that remains is minus ten
thousand is back two hundred thousand so
from here you have shifted back to this
point now at the end of the second year
again the bank is giving you the
interest now because the principle is
the same it is one hundred thousand
rupees so now the interest also is the
same it is again ten thousand rupees and
so the amount again goes up two hundred
and ten thousand
now in this year you again extract ten
thousand rupees and so you are bringing
the situation back to the starting
position so as long as the rate of
interest or in the case of forests the
rate of increment does not change and so
long as the your principal is not lost
such as in the case of forest if there
is no forest fire if there is no
infestation so at the beginning of every
year the situation will be the same as
what it was at the beginning of the
previous year at the end of every year
the situation will be the same as it was
at the end of the previous year so this
is a sustained yield now what will
happen if suppose in place of extracting
ten thousand rupees you extracted more
if so let us look at the second scenario
so we began with 100,000 rupees and at
the end of the first year the amount
increased to 110,000 but then in place
of extracting ten thousand rupees
suppose you extracted twenty thousand
rupees so what is the situation now now
in place of one hundred and ten thousand
you will only be left with ninety
thousand rupees because you have
extracted twenty thousand now at the end
of this year at the end of the second
year what is the amount of interest that
you will get now the interest that you
will get is on ninety thousand rupees
only you are not getting the interest or
one hundred thousand rupees
so the interest here will be ninety
thousand into 10 by 100 is nine thousand
so at the end of this year you are
getting a sum of 90 thousand plus nine
thousand is ninety nine thousand now
suppose you extracted twenty thousand
again from here so now you are getting
down to seventy nine thousand and at the
end of the third year this seventy nine
thousand will give you an amount of
seventy-nine thousand plus seventy nine
hundred which is the interest so this is
the principle this is the interest is 86
thousand nine hundred so what we are
observing here is that year after year
the amount is going down
so year after year the amount is going
down
so this is not a sustained deal now when
we look at the meaning of yield where we
say what is the amount that can be
extracted per unit time every year this
is what we are talking about what is the
amount that you can you can take out of
your bank such that at the end of the
year you'll be at the same situation as
it was at the beginning of the year now
the second meaning is what is the amount
that you have in your bank so if we ask
the question at this point of time the
amount that you have in the bank is
100,000 rupees so if you were to clear
cut the forest if you were to extract
all the amount that was there in your
bank account what would it be
so this scenario is saying that the
amount will be 100 thousand rupees at
this point of time the amount is 110
thousand rupees at some other point in
between probably it is 105 thousand
rupees and so on so this is what this
the second meaning of yield talks about
if you were to clear that the forest
what is the total amount of timber that
you will have now this sort of a
forestry when we talk about a sustained
deed it began in Europe because there
were land owners who wanted to have a
regular supply of income through their
forests so the question they were asking
was what is the maximum amount of timber
that I can extract or rather I should
extract every year to maximize my income
in such a manner that every year I
should be getting this source of income
so this is where this scientific
forestry began so sustained yield is the
yield that can be harvested every year
till perpetuity this is what they were
asking how much amount can I extract
every year in such a manner that this ex
traction can be done til infinity till
perpetuity so to answer this question a
number of methods were developed to
regulate the yield now in the case of
our bank example it is easy to compute
things because we know this a rate of
interest but in the case of a forest and
especially in the case of a forest that
is an irregular forest or a selection
forest how do you get the rate of
interest or the rate of increment is the
next question then again not all the
trees will be putting up increment at
the same rate because trees that are
very young or trees that are very old
will probably not be putting up any
significant increment whereas trees that
are in the middle age which are mature
trees they will be putting up increment
at a very fast pace now when you are
doing the extraction you are typically
removing the very old trees but when you
are removing the very old trees then you
are removing those trees that but not
putting up a large increment and you are
making space for those trees that can
put up much more increment so things
tend to become a little more complicated
as compared to the bank example because
we do not know the rate of increment we
do not know the interest rate and
finding out this interest rate is
difficult now to solve this problem
these methods were developed so we have
the area method volume method use of
formulae by number of trees and these
days we also make use of computer
simulation so what do these methods talk
about let us begin with the area method
of yield regulation now the area method
says that in the case of an even-aged
forest the area that should be harvested
every year is equal to the total area
divided by the rotation period so in the
case of an even-aged forest this method
says let's suppose this is your forest
and let us see the rotation age is 16
years
so we are saying that our is 16 years
and the total area is equal to a tote
say for sake of simplicity that this is
160 hectares area to be harvest will be
given by the total area divided by R
which is 160 hectares divided by 16
years is 10 hectare every year about
this myth now suppose you have this
forest and you do not know the age of
different sections now this method lets
you convert this forest into an
even-aged forest and ensure that it will
be maintained as any other even is
forest so let us say that on 1st of
January you clear-cut this section so
let us say on 1st of January 2020 you
cleared up this section now you sold
this timber in the market you got some
revenue at the end of the first year
that is on 31st jan 20 2008 one year so
any regeneration that was coming up is
now of the age of 1 year now on first on
31st December rather now on 1st of
January 2021 you cut up the next section
so let us say that this section was
filled on one in Jan 20 2016 was failed
on 1st of Jan 20 21
this one was felled on 1st of Jan 20 22
1st of Jan 20 23 and so on so this is 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 so this
section was felled on 1st of Jan 2035
now if we carry on these operations what
will be the situation on 1st of Jan 2036
now on 1st of Jan 2036 this section the
first section that we had failed on 1st
Ave and 2020 this is now 16 years of age
this section that we failed on 1st of
June 2021 is 15 years of age this is 14
13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 & 1 now this
is the situation on 1st of January
twenty thirty six so what do you do on
1st of January twenty thirty six you
again clear fill this section so this
date now changes to 1 Jan 2036
now let us look at the situation on 1st
of Jan 2037 now what is the situation on
1st of June twenty thirty seven this
section that we had failed on 1st of
June twenty thirty six is one year of
age this section that we had failed on
1st of January 2021 is now sixteen years
of age this is 14 now this is 15 14 13
12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 and this one is
1 now on 1st of January twenty thirty
seven what you do you clear filled in
this section so what we are seeing here
is that every year you can fill one
section that is of the age of 16 years
and at the end of the year or rather the
beginning of the next year on 1st of
January of the next year you will again
have one section of equal area the area
is 10 hectares so all of these sections
are 10 hectares
so on 1st of January of every year you
will be having an area of 10 hectares
that you can fill on that day and this
can continue till infinity so you can
you can perpetually extract this forest
of area of 10 hectares every year so
this is the area method now a very clear
advantage of this method is that it is a
very simple method because you just
divide area by the number of years and
rotation and you get the area that needs
to be filled every year it works for any
managed crop and for most of our
landlords in Europe in the 17th and 18th
centuries they used to prefer the
evilest crops because those were not the
days of biodiversity those were at the
beginning of the days of production
forestry and each hoop can be
intensively treated
because on 1st of January of every year
you are clear selling the scoop and then
you have the one fullier to work only on
that coupe so the coupes that are felt
can be intensively treated and even the
other true coupes can be very easily
tended because all of them are of the
same age however this method advantages
one it is difficult to predict the
volume because nowhere we have talked
about volume so if the landowner were to
ask you what is the what is the amount
of timber that I will be getting every
year we cannot say what is the amount of
revenue that I will be generating every
year well we cannot say then it is not
suited for an uneven aged crop because
you need to convert your forests into an
even-aged forest then only you will be
able to use this method and then it also
does not take into account other entry
cases such as differences in the site
quality so it is possible for instance
that this portion of your forest is
having more fertility and this portion
of the forest is let us say infertile
now this method will say that so much of
the area has to be filled every year but
then it belongs to a better site quality
and then there will be more amount of
timber that the landowner will get in
that year if the area is infertile he'll
be getting less amount of timber so when
we talked about that that that we wanted
to have an equal yield in every year
then the system will fail so it only
talks about a homogeneous forest in or
rather an even-aged forest in an in a
homogenous situation in a homogenous
piece of land so every portion or every
parcel of the land is having the same
fertility it is having the same amount
of water availability and so on so this
is a very simple method but
as its own disadvantages the another
method of yield regulation is the volume
method now volume method is a slight
improvement of the area method it says
that the volume that should be harvested
every year is equal to the total volume
divided by the rotation period so what
this method is saying is that you figure
out what is the total volume of timber
that you have that is what is the
growing stock that you have divided it
by the rotation period and you will
reach a point where you can say that
this is the amount of of timber that I
should be extracting every year now here
again this is a very simplified way of
putting things
it doesn't include growth and increment
of crop because whenever you are doing
these failing operations they take time
and throughout this rotation period the
crop will also be putting up growth it
will also be putting up increment but
this volume method does not talk about
that
and here again it doesn't talk about the
sight quality now let us look at some
more intricate methods so this is the
handy shaheen's
method of yield regulation now this is a
much better and a much more
scientifically sound method it's see it
is based on the notion that you can cut
more when you have more inventory than a
target normal forest and you can cut
less when you have less inventory then a
target normal forest
now what did what is it saying we saw in
the case of a selection forest that a
selection forest has an an ND curve that
looks like this so it is an inverse J
and D curve now if this is a normal
forest then if you have trees that are
the actual forest looks like this then
probably you can cut these sections and
in this section and in this section you
should not be doing the filling so that
your forest turns into a normal forest
and it goes on like this for perpetuity
now this method says that when you have
more inventory now in the case of our
selection forest we are looking at
inventory in different diameter classes
or age classes but then in the case of
indigenous method they only talk about
the total inventory the total volume of
timber that is available in your forest
now if you have a target or rather if
you know what a normal forest is or how
of an ideal forest should look like if
you know what is the total volume of
timber that you have in an ideal forest
and then if you compute the amount of
timber that is there in yo forest and if
there is any discrepancies then you
should do more amount of cutting more
amount of harvesting if your total
inventory is greater than and then the
ideal stage you should do less amount of
harvesting if your total inventory is
less than the ideal State
so essentially what it says is that the
amount of harvesting that you should do
should be proportional to the inventory
that you have the inventory is another
term for growing stock so so the total
volume of timber that you have if it
increases you should do more harvesting
if it decreases then you should do less
amount of harvesting so H is
proportional to I which means that HT by
I T is equal to H of a regular forest
divided by I of a regular forest so H is
the harvest is the inventory so this is
what it is
h / i should be a constant and how do
you get to this constant through say
numerical computations or through
setting up of a research plot however
this method also gives absolute results
when it predicts harvest even with no
mature trees available fulfilling so
suppose you have an area where you did a
clear felling and now you have planted
the the young seedlings and ii when you
put your your area into this equation
you will get that some amount of filling
needs to be done even though your plants
are only one or two years of age so this
method can give you certain absurd
results next we come to one mentals
method of yield regulation this is one
of the most highly used methods it
approximates the inventory by the area
of triangle so what it says is that if
we look at the stand age for an
even-aged forest and if we look at
volume per unit area so if this age of
the stand is more then these trees have
been have gotten much more time to put
up increment and so their volume is
mowed on the other hand if there is a
stand that is of zero years of age so
the plants have not put up any increment
the total volume is zero so essentially
what it says is that if we plotted
volume per unit area versus the stand
age we'll get a curve like this so for a
higher stand it let us say twenty years
the volume per unit area is more whereas
for a lesser age see seven years the
volume per unit area in the stand is
Lessard
then it says what is the inventory of a
regular forest now this method is now
trying to build upon on the indigenous
method and it says what is the in mint
now the forest is divided into a number
of sections and every year we will be
working on one particular portion which
is the coop now the volume of each of
these will be given by V R which is the
volume volume per unit area multiplied
by the area of this particular section
now in all of these sections the volume
per unit area is different but the area
of each section is constant so there
will be a section which is near to the
rotation H so we can say that the volume
per unit area in that particular section
on in that particular group will be
written as V small R now the the total
volume of timber in that particular
group will be given by V R into AR where
AR is your small a or the area of that
particular coop now they if you look at
this forest there will be one particular
section where the V of that section V I
is equal to 0 because it is a very young
section you have just harvested this
section and so there are no plants or
there are plants with a total area of
roughly equal to 0 and if we plotted
that the volume so there is one hoop
which is having a volume of 0 and there
is one coop at the rotation point which
as a volume of VR and the total number
of sections that we have is equal to
capital R now this
now total number of sections is capital
R which is equal to the age of rotation
and we can see that the total area of
the forest is given by total number of
sections into the area of one section
now you can draw a straight line as an
approximation and say that different
sections are having these different
volumes and total number of sections are
R so what is the average volume in one
section so that will be given by half
into let us take the two extremes 0 plus
VR into AR is the average volume or
section total number of sections is R so
the total volume is given by total
number of sections into the average
volume per section is equal to R into
half of VR into AR now capital R into AR
is the number of sections into the area
of each section is equal to capital a
which is the area of the forest so here
we get half of VR into a so this is what
the one metal from formula is saying
that the total inventory in a regular
forest because this is an ideal
situation because in practice this will
not form a triangle it is possible that
here the volumes will be less and here
the volume should be more than that of
more than that what the one mental
approximation is predicting because
earlier the growth rate is very slow as
we saw earlier in the case of a
sigmoidal curve or a logistic growth
equation that in the early phases the
growth is very slow and in the later
phases the the the growth increases
till a maximum p.m. till it reaches a
maximum value and then it again goes
down to zero so this is how the actual
curve will look the blue one is the
actual curve and the red one is of one
mental approximation now here this total
volume is the ideal volume or the volume
of a regular forest now H in a regular
forest or the amount of harvesting that
you will be doing in the regular forest
will be given by the by the coop that
has reached its maturity now in when it
has reached its maturity though we are
talking about this final group so in
this year what is the amount that you
will be harvesting the amount that you
will be harvesting in the regular forest
is given by V R which is the volume per
unit area in the in the rotation h
multiplied by K R which is the area of
this particular coop so it says that H
in a regular forest or ideal forest is
er into V R now for a regulated forest
AR is equal to capital a divided by R
because we have divided the forest into
equal area sections so now we can say
that H regular is equal to AR which is a
by r into VR now putting this into the
hunter chickens formula we get HT by I T
that is harvesting at time T divided by
the inventory at time T is given by H of
an ideal forest divided by I of the
ideal forest now H of the ideal forest
is what we saw here a by r into VR
so we put it here a by our into VR I of
a regulated forest is given by half of a
into VR so we put that here half of n 2
VR now a and E get cancelled we are and
we are get cancelled so this comes to be
2 by r so H by I is equal to 2 by R or H
is given by 2 into I by R so this is the
formula given by van mental which tells
us the amount of harvesting that we can
do in a sustained manner so that will be
given by 2 times of the growing stock
divided by the rotation period so this
is different from what we had seen in
the volume method now in the volume
approximation we said the amount that
can be harvested every year is the
growing stock divided by R but here we
are saying that it is actually 2 times
the growing stock divided by r now why
are we getting this two time because
this forest is not a static forest and
each section is putting up increments
another method of yield regulation is
the Austrian formula now the Austrian
formula says that if you consider any
forest and your forest is not an ideal
forest one your forest is putting up a
natural increment every year and
whatever increment it is putting is
something that you can be easily extract
so essentially coming back to our
example of the bank the increment that
you are getting every year which is ten
thousand rupees is something that you
can very easily extract from the bank so
this is given however you can also look
at a projected value of how much amount
do you actually need in your bank so
suppose you decide that I want to have
say 50 say only fifty thousand rupees in
my bank and I want to bring this hundred
thousand rupees to fifty thousand rupees
over a period of say 20 years
so then in each of these 20 years you
can take out some extra money because at
the end of 20 years you only require
fifty thousand rupees or else you can
even say that no I am this hundred
thousand rupees is not sufficient for me
at the end of 20 years I want to have
150 thousand rupees
so the Austrian formula looks at a very
similar situation it says that you can
always take out the increment but this
increment will be modulated by what is
your current scenario and what is the
ideal scenario that you want so it says
that the amount of harvesting is equal
to increment plus I T minus i reg
divided by P so I T is the inventory
that you have at time T I reg is the
inventory that you want in a regular
forest or that is the ideal forest
divided by a time period P over which
you want to bring your forest to a state
of the regulated forest so suppose in
this example if you wanted to put these
values we have AI T is equal to 100,000
rupees I rig
suppose I want to have more amount of
money in my forest in my bank account
suppose I want to have 125,000 rupees
and I want to change this hundred
thousand two hundred and twenty five
thousand over a period of say 20 years
so the Austrian formula would say that
the amount that I can extract out every
year is equal to the increment which is
ten thousand plus I T which is one
hundred thousand minus one twenty five
thousand divided by 20 so this is ten
thousand minus twenty five thousand
divided by two
d
is 8750 rupees so what this formula is
predicting is that I should take out not
ten thousand rupees but eight thousand
seven hundred and fifty rupees so that
every year I am adding to the increment
so the increment is large but I am
taking out a small portion so that at
the end of twenty years my bank account
gets to a level of one hundred and
twenty five thousand rupees
so similarly if you look at a forest you
can take out the increment but it will
be modulated by what you want to have at
the end of P years next is the quota
formula now the Kuta formula says that
in a periodic block a tree cut in the
beginning puts up no increment because
this tree is gone so if there is no tree
there will not be any increment so a
tree that is cut at the beginning is
putting up no increment where is a tree
that is cut in that is getting cut at
the end of the period is getting the
whole period of P years to put up the
increment so it puts up the compute
increment that is possible for it so on
average in a periodic block the trees
will put up half the increment they
could if they were left untouched so
here again we are looking at the average
values there are some trees that are
putting up increment for all the peers
there are some trees that are putting up
increment only for zero years or rather
no increment so on an average we can say
that the trees will be able to put up
half the increment over peers or fully
increment over P by two year
so in this case the total volume that is
available during the period is equal to
the volume that you have in the stand
plus the possible increment divided by 2
you are taking this half because some
trees will be cut during the beginning
of the periodic drop period and some
trees will be cut at the end of it now
the annual ield
will be given by this volume divided by
period
P so this comes to be V by P plus I by 2
where small I is given as the annual
increment which is this total increment
divided by P so this total increment was
coming up in P years so you have V by P
plus I by 2 as the N value
another method is yield regulation by
the number of trees so here again as we
saw earlier if we plot the nd curve and
if the act the actual forest is coming
at a deviation to the nd curve then the
elaboration by the number of trees we'll
see that for this DBH you can cut these
many number of trees for this DBH you
can cut these many number of trees so
essentially what we are trying to do
here is that this is nd curve it looks
like this but the actual forest is
showing something like this so these
trees can be cut very easily and these
trees should be they should be ample
amount of protection given and no
cutting done so that after a while when
this the section moves towards the right
it will come back to the normal forest
so this method is known as yield
regulation by the number of trees next
we also have yield regulation by
simulation that we make use of in these
days now yield regulation by simulation
makes use of computer programs to do the
number crunching so these are the steps
1 you input the current inventory in
terms of trees species location diameter
height and site quality so essentially
you are modeling your forests so if this
is your forest you are telling the
computer that at this point they
is a tree of this particular species of
this DBH of this height at this site
quality and so on similarly you are
giving the information for this tree you
are giving an information for this tree
you are giving an information for this
tree and so on now because we know how
different trees grow at different site
qualities over different age classes so
now you can ask your computer to
simulate how this forest will grow and
how this forest will appear say at the
end of five years now if you can do
these computations you can also do
another computation which is that of a
simulation you can ask the computer that
suppose out of all these trees I remove
a few trees so at the end of five years
suppose I get to the conclusion that
this tree is matured this tree is mature
this tree is mature and I remove these
trees at the end of five years then
after five more years that is at the end
of ten years how would this forest look
like what would be the situation and at
that point of time which is the other
tree that I can remove so you can do
these iterations again and again to
figure out which tree needs to be
removed and also what will be the volume
that you will be getting out of this
removal so essentially this depths are
you simulate your forests in the
computer input the known growth
parameters so you are telling the
computer that for this particular site
quality for this species for this DBH
and height class tree what is the growth
that normally such a tree shows so you
are putting the growth parameters then
you write rate it to generate the growth
pattern of the forest how will the
forest look after one year after two
years after three years and so on then
you make a decision about filling so you
can look at any snapshot of the forest
and
you can say that these trees are now
mature and I am going to remove them in
these years and once these trees get
removed next so you put you input this
filling decision in the model and then
you do an iteration again so then you
again tell you again ask the computer
that these trees are now removed how
will this forest again look like after
one year after two years after three
years and so on and by doing this you
can estimate which trees need to be
filled and what is the volume that
you'll be getting out of these failings
so in this lecture we looked at what is
yield so yield can be defined in two
ways one you remove all the trees from
your snapshot forest and two you do move
trees in such a manner that every year
you are getting the same amount of
timber which is known as a sustained
yield now doing these computations are a
bit intricate earlier we went with the
area method in which we said that for n
equal that for an even s forest you just
take total area divided by the number of
years of rotation and that is the area
that you are going to clear fill every
year now that had its own disadvantages
because of which we met we went to the
volume method where we said that total
volume divided by the number of years of
rotation will give you the volume that
you should be extracting every year and
then we built on these concepts and
finally these days we are making use of
computer simulations to make an exact
prediction of when what should be
removed and how much of the yield will
be be able to get so that's all for
today thank you for your attention
Jane
[Music]
[Music]
you
[Music]
