noc20-me92-lec02_ Smart Materials-I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 2, 2023
Smart Materials-IThis lecture introduces the soft robotics and a category of smart materials, namely Piezoelectric materials which can be used either as sensor or actuator. Activity questions: 1. Identify the real-life applications of soft robots? 2. Name the prominent ma
Welcome to the second lecture on Foundations of Cognitive Robotics.
In the last class, I talked about a basic introduction of cognitive robotics, where
I told you that what is the source or inspiration of this term cognitive and how cognitive robotics
is different is unique from other branches of robotics.
I also told you to remember that what are the different types or characteristics of
interactions that are possible in a robotic system in order to develop an intelligent
robotic system and we have made these graduations from strong to weak artificial intelligence,
strong to weak AI.
Like for a strong AI system, I told you that embodiment is not a precondition.
You can have simple coupling, you can have historical coupling with the environment and
that will be good enough for a strong AI system, whereas for a weak AI system, where
we are talking about things like cognitive robotics, physical embodiment is very much
required.
Now, there are two subcategories under physical embodiment, which are organismic embodiment
and organoid embodiment and I will talk about these different types of embodiments in this
particular lecture.
Also, I will tell you that how we can develop such cognitive robots using certain special
class of materials called smart materials and thus we will be able to build up organismic
robots and there will be a hope of developing cognitive robots through that.
So, in this second lecture on Foundations of Cognitive Robotics, we will focus on organismoid
embodiment.
So, all other couplings, the structural couplings or historical embodiment and the very futuristic
embodiment which is organismic embodiment, these are the things which we will not focus
at this moment.
Organismoid embodiment, which is the basic requirement for a cognitive robotics will
be in the focus first.
Now, when we will talk about organismoid embodiment, what is it that comes into your mind first?
Remember, in our last lecture, I have shown you a small video from Honda on the performance
demonstration of a robot which is a humanoid robot that is the ASIMO robot.
Now, this particular robot, how do you classify it?
Would you classify it to be an organismoid robot?
And if you classify this to be an organismoid, would not it be a good idea to actually look
into that how much humanoid organ-like, you know, it is basically developed in the light
of developing a human-like robot.
So, how much human-like is this particular robot?
So, let us look into Honda specifications and let us see that how much human-like is
this ASIMO robot.
So, we will talk about the building blocks and in this direction, let us look into what
goes into the ASIMO robot.
Now, Honda engineers have created ASIMO with 34 degrees of freedom.
This 34 degrees of freedom essentially means that there are 34 independent ways in which
the ASIMO robot can move its different limbs or body parts and that actually helps it to
walk and perform many tasks much like a human, exactly not like a human, but much like a
human.
You have seen in the last class, in the last video that I have shown that how it was delivering
a glass of drinks to the lady.
Now, this ASIMO apart from the fact that it is made of 34 degrees of freedom, structurally
it is made of a lightweight material which is a magnesium alloy structure and it is combined
with powerful computers and it is these two combinations that means by choice of a lightweight
material and by choice of this 34 degrees of freedom, we are able to see the performances
of the ASIMO robot.
Well, you may be interested to know that in comparison to the ASIMO robot, what are the
degrees of freedom to a real human and then only we will be able to understand, judge
the performance of ASIMO robot.
If you find out that how many degrees of freedom are there in human, you will see that
for example, our head in the neck joint, it can have three independent movements, up or
down, left or right and a rotation, so it has three degrees of freedom.
Similarly, in the shoulder, it has again three degrees of freedom, the elbow joints have
one degree of freedom.
The wrist joints in comparison have much higher degrees of freedom, 7 degrees of freedom in
each one of the wrist, so for the two wrists that will make it 14 degrees of freedom.
Maximum number of degrees of freedom is there on the fingers, that is why our fingers, in
comparison to ASIMO's, ASIMO looked like so much like a robot because if you look at
our these fingers, we will be having 13 degrees of freedom in each hand, so that means total
26 degrees of freedom.
Then the hip is having 2 degrees of freedom, the crotch joint in the leg is having 3 degrees
of freedom, knee joint 1 degree of freedom and the ankle joint will be having 6 degree
of freedom each, which means two ankle joints will give you 12 degrees of freedom.
So in all, it is about 57 degrees of freedom, so compare our 57 degrees of freedom to the
ASIMO robots 34 degrees of freedom and you would be able to know that how much still
we have to achieve in the robotics.
There is also some more thing to compare, how about the weight of the ASIMO robot with
this 34 degrees of freedom and how much of power it requires.
Let us go back to the specifications of the Honda robot and let us check that.
If you look at some interesting specifications of ASIMO, which I gathered from the Honda's
website, its height is about 4 feet 3 inch, it is just like the height of a child, weight
is 50 kg, well that is little high in comparison to a child, walking speed and running speed
is slightly in the higher side as we can see 2.7 kilometer per hour, walking speed and
running speed is about 7 kilometer per hour, grasping force little bit in the lower side
about 0.5 kg or 500 gram per hand, I am sure that a kid can lift slightly more weight than
500 gram.
Actuator wise, this 34 degrees of freedom comes in the expense of 34 servo motors.
In fact, that is what gives the maximum cost to this robot and the control unit is having
the walking and operating control unit, wireless transmission units etc.
It has sensors for example, in the foot, it has torsional level sensors in terms of gyroscopes
and acceleration sensors and again the negative side is the power, it needs a 51.8 volt lithium
ion battery.
It is very substantial, also lithium ion battery is quite dangerous under wet condition
and the operating time that we get that is also very low, if you look at it is just 1
hour.
So, at the operation system is you know workstation or a portable control.
So, what we can figure out from this specification is that there are at least 3 points in which
ASIMO is still far, far away from a good organismoid robot.
One is in terms of course, the degrees of freedom, it has 34 degrees of freedom, whereas
the organ or the you know in nature the human that it mimics that has 57 degrees of freedom
and it has a substantially high weight is more than 50 kg in spite of using very advanced
class of materials.
Also it needs a very high power and it can work only up to an hour or so.
So, these are some of the limitations of the best currently available robot which is close
to an organismoid robot.
So, all these things what does it point to, what does it lead to, it tells us that we
need to improve in terms of the overall weight or the bulkiness of the robot and also in
terms of the overall power consumption of the robot.
So, what is the solution in front of us?
If we look into the new developments of muscles in this new age, we will see that there is
a new branch of robotics first expanding which is also known as soft robotics.
Now under soft robotics, the robotic arms are mean to stretch and squeeze at every point
along their length and their movement cannot be described with simple geometric relations
because it is too complex, it is a large deformation motion much unlike the way we are used to
do it.
Let us say for a rigid robot system with the help of kinematic chains, it is very difficult
to describe this kind of a flexible robotic link with this type of robotic system.
So here you can see an octobot or an octopus morphology kind of thing which is mimicked
in an octobot system.
Now one of the thing if we compare between the robots and the animals, we would see that
robots traditional designs of steels etc. is far stronger than any naturally living
material.
Let us say the nearest will be the teeth or the knacker and if you go for softer materials
like say wood or ABS plastic, then possibly it will be closer to the cortical bones or
a squid beak.
If you make your robot even softer like high density polyethylene or polytetrafluoroethylene
or polyurethane, then you will come closer to cancellous bones, ligaments, tendons etc.
If you can make your robot further soft like say silicon rubbers, then you will get some
of the muscles like cardiac muscles and even in a softer range almost close to hydrogels,
you will start to get the skeletal muscles.
So thus this comparison is amply telling us that the direction to which we have to take
our soft robotics.
But is weight is the only concern?
So we have to also keep in our mind that we have a concern of the power, we have the concern
of this so many number of servo motors which makes it very expensive to afford.
Now you look at the different variations of soft robots like this one is a caterpillar
inspired locomotion and then a multi-gate quadruped robot again based on soft material
and active camouflage one, you can actually play with metamaterials and optically coupled
properties to develop active camouflage, walking in hazardous environments type of robots and
then worm inspired locomotion in robots and then particle jamming based actuation, rolling
powered by a pneumatic battery and hybrid hard and soft robot kind of combinations and
then we have this snake inspired locomotion, jumping powered by internal combustion, then
there is a manta ray inspired locomotion and an autonomous fish.
All these are various types of soft robots that are coming up very fast and with the
intention that how we can reduce the weight of the robot, but also as I told you that
functionally you need to improve, you need to replace these classical servo motors in
order to make it more sustainable, feasible, low power consuming etc.
So we need to think of the development of muscle based flexible robots.
The first stage towards that is the development of pneumatic artificial muscles or PAMs and
this PAMs were the first step where the air pressure is used in terms of compressing and
getting a muscle like motion from the system.
Now however, the compressor itself is quite heavy weight.
So we need to change from a compressor based system to let us say a solid state kind of
actuator system.
And one of the very interesting candidates towards this is ionic polymer matrix composites
or IPFCs.
These are a general class of electroactive polymers.
Like here you can see a four finger electroactive polymeric gripper which can grip up to the
extent of 10.5 gram of rock and this is used by NASA in a EAP gripper for you know extra
outside the earth in one of the planets, planetary missions to collect the debris.
I can show you that how this EAP would work.
You can see that such a large deformation you are getting from the electroactive polymers
and then how each one of the four fingers have to work together the last deformation
and then they have to grab the object which is white.
You can see that just it has deformed a lot, so that is something without the use of any
motor is really challenging just by deforming it with the help of direct transformation
of electrical energy to mechanical energy and then placing it at a different location.
You can do much more complicated works with the help of this kind of IPMC rockers.
Today we have even more interesting group of materials which can perform amazing feats
and they can be easily embedded and integrated in order to form actuators which would go
very well with soft robotics and can really make our dream of developing cognitive robots.
These are the groups of materials which are known as smart materials.
Before we talk about such smart materials, we have to keep in our mind that the mechanisms
also has to be made compliant.
For example, here you can see that this is a gripper and the gripper ends, you can see a
large deformation you can make with the help of these closing down between the two.
Now what here has been done using the fingers can be also done with the help of smart materials.
And then you can actually get a very large deformation.
So, even though the smart materials can be used at the back end in order to get a large
amplified motion, you need to make such contraptions of compliant mechanisms for grippers.
Now let us talk about the smart materials.
In this group of materials, the features of such materials are that they are basically
functional in nature and the basic energy forms that gets interchanged in such materials
are between thermal energy to mechanical energy, between electrical energy to mechanical energy,
magnetic energy to mechanical energy or sound energy to mechanical energy.
As I told you earlier also that energy can only be transformed.
So in this case, we have to manipulate between these transformations in order to get our
intended type of actuations or type of sensing.
Now this materials behavior which is why they are so much important for soft robotics is
that they are analogous to biological materials like they have the nature of adaptivity, cellular
function, self-sensing, actuation and control.
And moreover, the sensors and actuators are highly embeddable.
So as different energy forms are interchanged in a smart material, let us look into these
different types of smart materials from an input-output classification point of view.
There is a broad group of smart materials like piezoelectric.
In this case, the input is electrical energy and the output is mechanical deformation,
mechanical energy.
And then we have magnetostrictive materials where the input is for a group of ferromagnetic
materials, the input is magnetic energy and the output is once again mechanical energy
in the form of mechanical stress and deformation.
And then for shape memory alloys, it remembers its original shape after being deformed and
it can go back to the original shape.
So this is by actually exploiting the change from thermal energy to mechanical energy.
And we also have some special groups of rheological materials which are like
electromagnetorheological materials where it is the viscosity that changes in the material.
So thus there are these different types of materials and if we look at this from an input-output
point of view, the inputs can be categorized in terms of electric field, magnetic field,
strength, heat or light for that matter, even light can be used as input.
And outputs can be in terms of charge, magnetization, strength, temperature and light.
Now if you look at these, let us say like in a matrix form, then the diagonal terms
are something which are the material properties which is very common in material.
So they are not very smart properties, but it is the off-diagonal terms, particularly
this green row column and this grey row which is of very useful nature to us.
For example, electric field as an input and as an output it is creating strength is what
is known as reverse piezoelectricity, that is what is used in piezoelectric materials
or even in the IPMC example that I have shown you a few minutes before.
And this is one such kind of an off-diagonal property of a smart material.
Similarly, if you can achieve the deformations using magnetic energy, then it is called Zuhl
effect magnetostriction.
This is also another off-diagonal term.
For heat, for the shape memory alloys, it is thermal, you know thermal induced phase
transition and for light it is photostriction.
Now this green column, this is corresponding to the actuator development.
Many of these materials can be also used as sensors and here this grey row is very important.
Like if you use for example, stress as the input, mechanical stress and by exploiting
the direct piezoelectric effect, you can build up a sensor which will give you current or
charge as an output.
Similarly, using Villery effect in some materials, you can get magnetic field change, magnetization
change as an output.
Change of stress creating strain is a very normal thing of elastic modulus, there is
no smart material.
But if I change the stress and if the temperature changes, there is a thermo mechanical effect
that is related to it.
And similarly, if the electric property changes, there is a photoelastic effect which is also
equally interesting in terms of developing sensors.
Now, if you compare these materials in terms of actuators and compare them with the traditional
actuators like motors, like pneumatic actuators or hydraulic actuators, we are interested
to know that in which way smart materials are actually better, in which way the smart
material based actuator will be outstanding in comparison to all the traditional actuators.
If you look at the response times, you can see that all these greens are the traditional
actuation system which is in terms of seconds or milliseconds.
And here for smart materials, you get it in terms of 0.1 millisecond, so it is even one
tenth of a millisecond.
And that shows that why they are very fast, so their response time is faster that makes
them closer to this kind of organismoid robots.
And also another interesting property is their accuracy, if you look at their accuracy, they
are far more accurate than most of these actuators that we are talking about, at least 10 to
100 times more accurate these smart materials.
So, in terms of the speed, in terms of the accuracy, they are you know an order or several
orders of magnitude better than the traditional actuators.
Now, the flip side is that the displacement is lower or the force is also lower, but these
two things you can actually compensate by using suitable mechanical amplifiers or by
distributing the actuators, the smart material based actuators, you know in terms of just
like our muscles, you can distribute it and you can extract more energy from the system.
Now, if you look at the piezoelectric material, because in this talk I will, today's lecture
I will mostly focus on piezoelectric material.
As you can see here that if I apply force and if I deform the piezoelectric material,
you are getting a voltage that is produced in the system.
So, this is what is the reverse piezoelectric, is the direct piezoelectric effects where
you are applying the force mechanically and you are getting the voltage out of it.
Now, if you look at this piezoelectric materials closely, we will first see that they are not
that very new, it was developed around 1880, as you can see that Pierre and Jacques Pouilly
has developed the first actually found out this piezoelectricity, which is basically
electricity from pressure and from temporary electricities were like electricity from static
electricity from friction, it was a contact electricity or electricity by heating up
crystals which was pyroelectricity. So, when they found out that even pressure
in a crystal can generate electricity, this piezo means pressure that is where this new
group came into picture. And as a result of that Pierre-Ecqui and Paul-Jacques Pouilly,
both of them got Nobel Prize in physics in 1908 on the direct piezoelectric effect.
The direct effect signifies if you apply pressure on the piezoelectric material,
you are getting electricity out of it. Similarly, at a later stage,
Gabriel Lippmann theoretically predicted that the reverse is also possible. If you
apply electric field, you will get a mechanical deformation for which he got his Nobel Prize in
1908 that is on the reverse piezoelectric effect. Now, why piezoelectric material is so exotic?
What is there so special in a piezoelectric material that actually give it this property
that as you apply the mechanical force, you are getting an electrical charge out of it.
Well, one of the very important group of piezoelectric material are these perovskites
named after an Austrian geologist which was discovered roughly around 1950 or so. And
these perovskites are generally a ternary structure that means it is made of three
components like in this example barium, titanium and oxygen. So, there are three
components which form this crystal, this piezoelectric crystal. Now, what is so
special about this component is that if you look at the crystal structure of this material,
you would see that bariums are at the vertices of this tetrahedral, this tetragonal structure.
And you would see that the oxygens are at the face center everywhere and the titanium which
is the source of this kind of piezoelectricity is deep inside the geometric center of this
tetragonal. Now, this titanium is very precariously positioned because if I apply a
little bit force on this crystal from any direction, the titanium will get displaced
from its center and the moment it will displace as the titanium has a high degree of
electropositivity, it will generate actually a dipole moment in this crystal and thus a
little mechanical deformation the crystal is charged.
And if you imagine that in any bulk material there are hundreds or millions of crystals,
each one of them will get charged because of this deformation. Although the dipoles could
be random in nature and you need to electrode it to make it spatially moving towards the
particular direction, but those are the things I will talk about at a later stage.
Now, this is about the barium titanate structures. Similar piezoelectric effect you will be able to
see in lead zirconate titanate, PZT, in lithium niobium family, in lead niobium family,
in yttrium manganese family and in ammonium cadmium family. The thing that would differ
may be the Curie temperature. The Curie temperature tells us that beyond what temperature the
piezoelectricity would not be there. So, the piezoelectricity would be absent in a system.
So, that is what is the Curie temperature which we have to keep in our mind that you will not
see the muscle, the artificial muscle that we are trying to build in action if the temperature goes
a particular beyond a particular level. Now, what is the constitutive equation of
such piezoelectric structure? As I told you that for the direct effect where you are
applying mechanical stress that is there in this large x, that x is the stress. So,
you are applying stress in the crystal means you are you know increasing x and as you are
increasing x you will see that the charge is appearing in the system. Remember, if you
apply or increase the electric field then also there will be charge appearing, but that is
something which is pretty common is not it for a capacitor type of a you know things like a
dielectric material. So, that is not what the smartness is, the smartness is where you are
applying the mechanical stress and getting a charge out of it. Only a very few group of materials
will show this and the degree up to which it will show is governed by this small d which is
electromechanical coupling coefficient. The higher the d the more will be the electric
charge that will be generating in the system. How can we use this that you are applying stress
and you are finding charge? Well, they have a great use in terms of development of sensors.
So, the direct effect is generally used for sensor development. Now, for the converse effect
where you are applying the electric field not the mechanical field, mechanical field creating
small x that is the mechanical strain is quite natural for any material, but you are applying
electric field and finding the mechanical strain that is something new is not it.
And that is what is the basic you know equation that we will be using for developing these
artificial muscles and by applying electric field mechanical deformations and that is what
is the converse effect or the reverse effect, the electrical stimulus creating the strain.
Once again here you can see the same electromechanical coupling coefficient that
means the more the materials d will be the more I will be getting the strain out of the
same electric field. So, these are the two very basic equations which will continuously guide us
in terms of the development of actuators and sensors by using these two effects.
I will now show you some applications of piezoelectricity. The first application of
actuator is actually pretty common in terms of every day you might have seen it you might not
have noticed that is in printers. Say for example, if you look at this you will see that you are
getting this axial deformation by using two materials one smart one non smart like these
two things together you can make a bending out of it. And this bending you can actually put it
in terms of controlling the flow of you know inkjet printer. So, each one of these is actually
pushing a droplet of a pigment which makes the printer. So, this is one application.
Another application is in terms of amplification of piezo actuator. So, if you look at the piezo
actuator here the central part is where the actuation is taking place. And this actuation
in the central part is very small, but because we have used a special egg like structure
a little bit of deformation here can create a large deformation along the semi minor axis of
the ellipse which is what is these amplified piezo actuators do. And look at the very last one this
is where the piezoelectric material is actually in an offset with a composite. Here also because of
this offset by actuating this you can get a large deformation out of the system.
All these three things you can use some way or the other in terms of developing the actuators.
So, in this talk I have told you about one basic block of a smart material which is the
piezoelectric material and how this piezoelectric material can be used in terms of developing an
actuator. And this actuator in turn can be used to replace those servo motors that I have shown
you in that assembly and to make a robot more organismoid or organic like robot.
There are many other smart materials and in next few lectures I will quickly cover
some very prominent smart materials too. Thank you.
