Lecture-8 : Similarity Analysis I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 2, 2023
Hello, today I will discuss the similarity analysis, a very important chapter in thermomachinery.
The contents of the lecture are similarity analysis, geometric, kinematic and dynamic
similarity.
Then I will discuss about similarity rules.
I will restrict in this lecture to incompressible flows, the relation between xi, phi and eta.
Similarity is the process of describing the behavior of machines of same kind.
Suppose from the model test, how can we extrapolate the characteristics of a prototype?
In reality, all the design activity after analysis goes through the development of model,
testing those model and then project the test result for a prototype.
Inevitably, we do not land for the development of prototype.
If the characteristics of the prototype is not satisfied, we go back to the analysis
and again we carry out the analysis.
Thus the first point that I like to tell, how can we extrapolate the test result of
a model for a prototype?
The second one is, suppose for established machine, if its speed changes, if we rescale
the machine to design a smaller version, then that means if its size changes, how the characteristics
would be?
This also can be done through similarity analysis.
For similarity analysis, the following three conditions must be satisfied.
One, geometric similarity, second, kinematic similarity and dynamic similarity.
For this geometric similarity, two machines must be geometrically proportional, that means
the corresponding ratio, corresponding dimension should be constant.
For this kinematic similarity, the flow pattern has to be same, that means the velocity triangle
is similar, the ratio of corresponding velocity remains invariant and the angle of the velocity
triangle, the corresponding angles, suppose if we take a velocity triangle for the model
and that of the prototype, then the angles, corresponding angles has to be the same.
The next one is the dynamic similarity.
Suppose for true similarity, equality of Reynolds number must be satisfied.
Reynolds number, you see I have given a sketch for frictional coefficient versus Reynolds
number.
One can easily appreciate that frictional characteristics is dependent on Reynolds number.
The Reynolds number same means the frictional characteristics of both the machines are same.
Thus for true similarity, the dynamic similarity has to be satisfied.
If the geometric similarity and kinematic similarity, both these two conditions are
valid, then the two machines are called kinematically similar machines.
Sometimes equality of Reynolds number becomes difficult.
So if all the three points, that means between two machines, the geometric, kinematic and
dynamic similarity are maintained, then these machines are called homologous machines.
Equality of other non-national numbers over the Reynolds number often needs to be satisfied
between two machines.
Suppose for a propeller, Froude number has to be equal.
For high-speed compressors, Mach number needs to be equal.
Now let us consider a pump or a compressor, which is driven by an electric motor.
Since the pump has compression, needs to be driven by electric motor, so its speeds can
be adjusted.
Similarly, the flow rate can independently be controlled by a throttle valve.
Thus, what I like to tell that speeds of a compressor or pump and the flow rate can be
independently controlled.
And again, for a certain value of Q, flow rate and speeds, other variables such as head
and power are established.
Thus, Q and omega can be treated as control variables, while head and power can be treated
as dependent variable.
Thus here, I have defined for a turbo machines, what are the control variable and what are
the dependent variable.
In a similarity analysis, the effect of geometric variable must be included, such as size and
shape of a machine.
Size of a machine is characterized by the impeller diameter and the shape by length
ratio, which is represented by L by D.
Furthermore, the surface finish must be considered, which is represented here by surface
length, small e.
Apart from geometric variables, the fluid properties must be considered, such as density,
viscosity, and so on.
Moreover, we need to distinguish whether the flow is compressible or incompressible.
Thus, I like to summarize here, for a similarity analysis, we need to consider geometric
variables, fluid properties, and the fluid media, whether it's compressible or
incompressible.
Let me consider now incompressible flow.
And here, for a turbo machine, the dependent variables, such as energy transfer, efficiency,
and power can be expressed in terms of control variable, geometric variables, and fluid properties,
such as g into h is a function of Q, N, D, rho, mu, L by D, and E by D. So Q and N are
the control variable, D, L by D, E by D are the geometric variables, and rho, mu are the
fluid properties.
Similarly, eta and B also can be expressed as a function of Q, N, D, rho, mu, L by D, and E by.
Now after this, if we do, or if we carry out the dimensional analysis following Buckingham
theorem, the different non-dimensional groups can be established.
Thus, after dimensional analysis, what we'll get, xi is equal to g, h, divided by N squared, D
squared, equal to function of Q, N by DQ, rho, N, D squared by mu, L by D, E by D.
These are all non-natural groups.
Similarly, eta can be expressed as a function of these non-natural groups, and p tilde also can be
expressed as a function of these non-natural groups, where p tilde is equal to p divided by rho, N, Q,
into D to the power 5.
Now here, xi is called the head coefficient, xi is equal to g, h, by N squared, D squared.
This is a non-natural pressure, non-natural head.
Now similarly, what is the non-natural flow, that is volumetric flow coefficient, is defined by phi.
Phi is equal to Q divided by N, D to the power Q. Now phi, please follow the write-up here, you'll
appreciate, the phi can also be expressed as Cz divided by U. Cz is the meridional flow through
the machine, which is connected to the volume flow rate Q. Furthermore, what is rho, N, D
squared by mu? Rho, N, D squared by mu is a form of Reynolds number. Similarly, p tilde, p tilde is p
by rho, N, Q, D to the power 5, is the power coefficient. So thus here, after dimensional
analysis, what we have got? The xi, eta, and p tilde is the function of some non-natural group.
They are flow coefficient, phi, Reynolds number, and some geometric variable, which is L by D,
and E by D. Now for geometrically similar machines, the shape parameters L by D
are constant, and thus they can be omitted from the above relations. Again if dynamic
similarity is maintained above the geometric similarity, then the effect of Reynolds number
can be ignored. Thus the functional relationship for geometrically similar machines at high
Reynolds number, neglecting the effect of surface roughness, can be expressed as xi
is nothing but function of phi, eta is function of phi, and tilde is function of phi. So thus
in brief, for a geometric and dynamic similar machines, that means in a strict sense if the
machines are homologous, then xi, eta, and p tilde can be expressed as a function of phi.
Here I'll establish the relation between xi, phi, and eta. Let us first consider a pump
or a compressor. The net hydraulic power is given by p h is equal to rho q g into h.
Then efficiency eta can be defined as p h by p, where p being the shaft power. Note that for a
pump or for a compressor, shaft power is greater than the hydraulic power. So now through some
algebraic manipulation, I have written as p equal to 1 by eta within the bracket q n d cube
divided by q divided by n d cube. Again another bracket g h divided by n square d square,
and then multiply by rho n q d to the power 5. Now if you remember this q divided by n into d cube
is nothing but phi, flow coefficient, and g h n square by d square, this group is nothing but xi.
So thus p tilde is equal to p divided by rho n q d to the power 5 would become xi into phi
divided by eta. So thus for a pump or a compressor, I can write p tilde is equal to xi phi divided by
eta. Whereas for a turbine, eta can be defined by p divided by p h. Now here hydraulic power
is supplied to the machine, so hydraulic power is greater than the shaft power.
So thus eta can be defined as p divided by rho q g into h, and thus one can easily prove here
that p tilde here is equal to eta into xi. Thus in nutshell, for a pump or compressor,
p tilde will be equal to xi phi divided by eta. For a turbine, p tilde would be
eta into xi into phi. Thank you for listening.
