Lecture 02: Stress Based Approach (Inglis)

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
1 Video View·Dec 1, 2023
Hello everyone, welcome back to our course on Mechanical Behaviour of Materials part
2. So, in the last lecture, we discussed about the calculation of the theoretical strength
and then we observed that you know there is a discrepancy between the theoretical strength
and the stress we calculate in the lab or practically we obtain. So, typically it is
in MPa, but the theoretical strength is in Gp. And then I mentioned that this discrepancy
is because mainly because of the two reasons. One is your dislocations, presence of dislocation
which we already discussed in the course 1, Mechanical Behaviour of Materials part 1.
And then I mentioned about the presence of other defects such as cracks and porosities.
And this led to the genesis of fracture mechanics. And then I also introduced the term of stress
concentration, where we were talking about the stress based approach or English criteria.
And another one is your Griffith criteria, which is energy based approach. So, in today's
lecture, we will talk about the English criteria or stress based approach in fracture mechanics.
So, let us start lecture 2 is stress based approach. So, let us first understand what
do we mean by stress concentration. So, let me draw a plate and then I am drawing some
imaginary lines. We have light stresses sigma and now I am drawing some line of forces or
in some books you are going to see that it is also called as stress trajectories. So,
what I am doing in this plate when we have sigma as applied stress, I am distributing
it with these lines, some imaginary lines and we call these lines as a line of forces
or stress trajectories. So, I can draw many lines like this in a given plate. Now, let
me introduce a crack or say hole or porosity here and let us see what happens to this line
of forces or stress trajectory. So, I have the same plate, but let me now magnify it
a bit so that you can understand it better. So, I am just increasing the size of the plate
and I am introducing now a crack here. So, this is the crack. We are in the same sigma.
So, applied stress does not change. Let us say width is also not changing. I am just
magnifying this image left on the left on the right side and just magnifying it for
better understanding. So, width also does not change. Now, let us see what happens to
the stress trajectories. So, let us say I am now taking this point number 1 here. So,
this line number is 1 and we can do this for all the trajectory lines or line of forces
on the left side. Remember, you have this crack is an empty space, it is air. So, it
cannot sustain any load. So, all these trajectories as soon as they see the presence of crack
or porosity, some voids in the material and we know that they cannot take load. So, they
are going to deviate. So, you are going to see the line of forces becoming something
like this. So, there is a deviation in the path. Why? Because this particular crack here,
this cannot sustain this load. So, you can see here it was a full material than the line
number 1, but now there is a deviation and you can do this for all these lines. So, this
is line number 2, similarly line number 3 and you can repeat it and so on. So, you can
have now like away from the crack tip is going to just go like what we have seen in the left
hinge. So, far away from the crack tip there is no deviation that means there is no effect
of the presence of the crack. So, far away from the crack tip it is going to behave like
there is no crack. So, here you are going to have uniform distance what we have in the
previous case without any crack. And what you see here that all these line forces
have been squeezed in this particular area, is not it? Because the crack is,
the crack cannot sustain the load or this stress trajectory, they are going to bend
in front of the crack tip. So, there is a squeeze region. So, this is number 1 observation that the
line forces are squeezed. The second observation if you see the distance between the lines
is much finer at the crack tip and as you move away it is increasing and finally it becomes
like there is no crack in the material. So, you also see bending here in this region,
but the bending, the strength of bending or magnitude of bending is much smaller
than what you observe at the crack tip. So, the distance between the lines is imaginary
lines again remember these are imaginary lines. So, the distance between these imaginary lines
is higher as you move slightly away from the crack tip. Now, third observation is,
so you see there is a strain energy release, this part is not taking any load. So, there is a
releasing strain energy here, you are releasing the strain energy in this part and we are going
to utilize this concept when we talk about the Griffith criteria. So, overall if you see we can,
let me write down the some of the observations what we have discussed.
So, the local stress is proportional to the spacing between line of forces or we call it
stress trajectories. So, higher the spacing then the concentration is going to be lower.
What does it mean? It means that in the squeeze region you are going to have stress concentration,
stress is concentrated in that particular region. So, the local stress is going to be higher at the
crack tip and as you move away from the crack tip your local concentration or stress, local stress
value is going to be smaller. And as you move away from the crack tip it is going to be equivalent
to the applied stress which is sigma here. So, that is one. Now, other observation is
since the tensile stress cannot be transmitted through a crack the line of forces are
diverted around the crack. And you have seen that the line number one you can imagine it
was coming down it saw the presence of a crack so it is going to divert, get diverted and then
get concentrated in front of the crack tip. Now, this is going to lead to the squeeze region
and you can see the line if you just count you just imagine it count the number of line of
forces in front of the crack tip right is going to be much higher than if there was no crack
right at the same position right. That means you are going to have a stress concentration now. So,
if the applied stress is sigma you are going to observe a stress value which is higher than
sigma at the crack tip. So, this leads to stress concentration.
So, the presence of crack has resulted in the stress concentration in front of the crack tip.
So, even if the applied stress is sigma it can be much higher than the sigma value. This means
there is a possibility that the local stress in front of the crack tip is equivalent to the
theoretical strength we calculated right. So, if that is the case locally it is going to fracture
isn't it and that is what we discussed right that there is a discrepancy because one of the reason
was dislocations and another one is crack right. So, whenever there is a presence of crack locally
you are going to have stress concentration and this stress concentration can lead to a value
of stress at the crack tip which is much higher than the applied stress okay. So,
even if the applied stress is lower than yield point locally it can be higher than yield point
even it can go up to the theoretical strength value which can lead to the fracture okay.
So, even if the sigma is in MTA locally it can be in GPA okay and that is the whole concept of
stress based approach okay. So, overall if you see you can write that due to the presence of
crack or in the presence of crack leads to attenuation of stress to cohesive stress
or theoretical stress what we have calculated say brittle material okay. So, locally you are
going to increase the stress that means there is a stress concentration locally which can
be a very high value even the theoretical stress value and then it can lead to the fracture.
So, this is all a fundamental understanding visualization somewhat qualitative right.
So, what Griffith did? Griffith gave a quantitative analysis to this phenomena
sorry not Griffith English I mean so English gave a qualitative a quantitative analysis
that was in 1930. So, he proposed a quantitative analysis of stress concentration okay.
So, now let us assume that you have a plate which is infinite and I will tell you what does
infinite means and typically whenever we mention an infinite plate we will make something like this
some wavy structure. So, you have an infinite plate and then you have a through thickness crack
or elliptical hole right. So, you have elliptical hole in an infinite plate.
Now this term infinite plate I am going to use for some of the lectures it means whenever we
say something is infinite plate it means two points first stresses due to the presence of
of or stresses at the hole is not influenced by the boundaries right. So, stresses at the hole
so this is your elliptical hole right are not influenced by the boundaries.
So, these are your boundaries. So, whatever stresses you are going to observe say in this
region in this region they will not be affected by the boundaries that is point number one
and second the dimension of the hole is much much smaller than the dimension of your plate
and dimension of the plate we can denote in terms of width right width of the plate.
So, hole is much smaller than the plate width. So, it means w is much higher than
2a where w is your width of the plate and 2a is the length of this elliptical hole.
So, let me just draw the window here now suppose this is your hole same one right.
So, this one we will denote as a 2a remember that it is not a it is 2a. So, whenever we give you
numerical I am going to mention a or 2a or if I say it is a central crack then we should know that
this is length is given is 2a and all the formula you are going to see eventually will have a.
So, you need to know the difference between 2a and a. So, whenever you do assignments
please be very careful about it and height is say. So, you have an elliptical hole
height is 2b and length is 2a. So, this 2a is that and then you are having stress here
as sigma and this hole is through thickness hole that means it is going through the thickness. So,
if you see a plate you can see the hole from this side and you can see the hole from the
other side also. So, through thickness hole or through thickness crack also that means it is
going through the thickness. So, overall if you see the English assume that it is an infinite plate
that means the stresses at the hole are not influenced by the boundary as well as the
plate width is much higher than the length of the crack. So, the formula he proposed
at the crack tip for stress. So, stress at the crack tip if I denote these as sigma
tip it will be sigma tip equal to sigma 1 plus 2a by b where sigma is your applied stress
and we also call sometimes sigma as far field stress far away from the crack.
So, far field stress are also applied stress. Now, if you see this equation applied stress is
sigma and then you have a factor of 1 plus 2a by b which is going to have some value and which
is going to be also higher more than 1 because 1 plus 2a by b and it is an elliptical hole. So,
2a is going to be higher than b also. So, overall if you see at the crack tip the value of sigma
tip is going to be higher than the applied stress. So, just now we learned the qualitative way.
Now, Inglis gave a quantitative approach to the whole concept of stress concentration and
proposed a formula for sigma tip or stress at the crack tip. So, what is stress concentration
factor? So, if I denote this as kt this is going to be sigma tip by sigma, sigma tip is the stress
at the crack tip. So, if you have a crack the stress here this is your sigma tip and sigma is
the applied stress far away from the crack or elliptical hole whatever. So, that stress is far
field stress that is sigma. Now, suppose this elliptical hole becomes sphere circular. So,
2a is equal to 2b. So, if you see the formula sigma tip is sigma 1 plus 2a by b and if I take
circular crack now. So, this is your circular crack here 2a is equal to 2b. So, this particular
equation now if I use this circular crack instead of elliptical crack this will be sigma
1 plus. So, this will just cancel it will be 3 sigma. So, 2a is equal to 2b that means a equal
to b. So, I am just replacing b as a. So, this gets cancelled out and then sigma tip equal to
3 sigma that means if I apply say 10 MPa and you have a presence of circular hole
at the tip of the circular hole your stress is 30 MPa. So, it is being magnified and that is
the concept of stress concentration. Now, imagine if you increase the major axis
right related to b. So, you are increasing continuously the a value and you are relatively
to b which is higher the elliptical hole is going to become a sharp crack and it is going to have
some curvature say rho. So, what is the formula now? So, as major axis increases relative to b
the elliptical hole becomes a sharp crack having a radius of curvature at tip equal to rho.
So, increasing continuously a so it is going to become a sharp crack with radius of rho. So,
in this case sigma tip can be written as sigma 1 plus 2 into 1 a by rho because
we know rho is b square by 3. So, I am just replacing b in terms of a and rho. So, this is
your equation here whenever you have a crack having a curvature of rho.
So, for circle again if you see a is rho because the radius of curvature for a circular hole
is your rho a. So, in that case also if you see a and rho will get cancelled out. So,
sigma tip will become 3 sigma which is equivalent to what we have just discussed.
So, for circular case a is equal to rho. So, sigma tip becomes sigma 1 plus 2. So, 3 sigma.
So, same. So, it is same as this one on the top. So, it validates one way of validation.
Now, if the crack is very sharp. So, for very sharp crack we can write rho is much less than
a because it is very sharp. So, radius of curvature is very small. So, we can write
as an approximation sigma tip as 2 sigma root over a by rho. Now, see a here is not the full
crack length, a is your half crack length. So, again do not make mistake, a is different than
2a. So, 2a was the full crack length and half crack length is your a. So, this is the stress
at the crack tip because of the presence of stress and it is related to the crack length
as well as the curvature. So, overall if you see the stress at the crack tip is going to be
dependent upon the size of the crack which is in this case a as well as the curvature of the crack.
If the curvature is higher than sigma tip is going to be lower and if the curvature is smaller
then the sigma tip is going to be higher. Similarly, if we increase the crack length
your sigma tip is going to be higher and which makes sense. So, suppose let me give you
qualitative way of understanding what happens when you increase the crack length. So, suppose you
have a width of same width 2 plates I am taking and let us say the width is same w. Now, if I
introduce a crack here and then another crack of higher length. Now, if you remember the concept
of stress trajectories or line of forces and if I just do the same concept, apply the same concept
with these all these lines here and applied stress is also same. So, I am keeping width
same sigma is same only thing I am changing here is the crack length. So, what is happening? So,
the sigma is same the number of trajectories all these imaginary lines it is going to be same.
So, let us say same number of trajectories and all these trajectories are say coming down and
they see there is a presence of crack. So, if you just visualize it what you are going to see
the number of line of forces is going to be much higher here because the number of line of forces
the way they are going to deflect is going to be much higher in the case number 2 then case number
1. That means the stress concentration in the larger crack is going to be higher this is the
visualization what we are doing. What English did is the he gave a formula which is 2 sigma
root over a by rho. So, now you understand the qualitative way of understanding with respect to
the line of forces as well as the quantitative way given by English of stress concentration.
So, overall if you see the stress concentration is going to be depending upon the crack length
depends upon crack length as well as shape. So, sharper the crack higher the stress concentration
sigma tick is going to be higher you see the above formula. That means if you have a you know
elliptical hole and crack, crack is going to give you higher stress concentration and the third is
sigma tick is the maximum stress. So, if you see the plate I have drawn here
sigma tick is what sigma tick is going to be the stress here sigma tick in both cases.
So, in this particular plate the highest stress what you observe is the sigma tick which is at
the crack tip. Later on I am going to show you the profile of the crack sorry stress at the crack tip
stress at the crack tip in the crack plane etcetera. And you will see there also that
the sigma tick is going to be the highest. So, these are the three points we can note down
based on the English criteria. Now, what happens when sigma goes to 0?
We can imagine sigma tending to 0. So, the stress at the crack tip is going to
be infinite. That means if I have a crack which is very, very supersarge. So, that now it is
tending to 0 as soon as you apply a load it is going to fail because the sigma tip the stress
at the crack tip is infinite. It does not happen like that. So, what is happening? What is the
minimum curvature you can observe? So, if you see the bonding the minimum curvature will be in the
order of r naught the distance between the two atoms. So, if I explain it so I am trying to say
that if rho tends to 0 sigma tip tends to infinite. So, for infinitely short crack sigma tip is going
to be very, very high and that is what I have been saying that it can go to the theoretical
strength also and then it can lead to fracture. But no material is there which can sustain the
infinite stress that means as soon as I applied the load it is going to fail. But in real situation
if you see the if I just draw the structure what we have seen before suppose this is your
atomic structure. So, this is what I was talking about. So, this area is your crack here.
So, the minimum curvature what you observe here. So, this is your crack profile. So,
the minimum curvature will be in the order of r naught, not 0. So, there will be some value
of sigma tip it is going to be much higher. I agree but it is not going to be infinite
and actually you can calculate that now. So, what I was saying that for brittle material
minimum crack tip radius will be in the order of atomic radius or distance between the atoms
atomic distance. So, let us assume that rho is equal to r naught and r naught I have already
mentioned it is an inter atomic distance. So, if that happens let us calculate what could be the
fracture stress there. We know sigma tip is 2 sigma a by rho and rho here we are replacing by
r naught. So, sigma tip becomes like this where sigma is your applied stress. We also know what
is the theoretical strength if you remember this is e gamma by r naught. Now, this material is
going to fail if sigma tip becomes theoretical strength then that bond is going to fracture.
So, let us equate the sigma tes sigma th and sigma th from this equation now we can write
root over e gamma by r naught 2 sigma a by r naught. And so, here r naught, r naught will
cancel. So, let me replace this by rho for now because if it is equal to r naught then it is
fine if let us put it in a general way that rho is in the order of r naught we do not know yet.
So, now sigma can be written as root over e gamma rho by 4 r naught a or we can just write
a sigma fracture because we have replaced sigma tip by sigma th. So, you can actually calculate
what is the fracture stress for brittle material. You know later on I am going to also talk about
the ductile material. So, in ductile material typically because of the plastic deformation
your crack tip is going to get blunted. So, your rho is going to be much higher than
r naught much, much higher than r naught. For brittle material there is very less or
approximately no plastic deformation. So, rho is in the order of r naught. So,
the formula what I have derived here is basically for a brittle material it is easy to derive the
equation of fracture stress for brittle material which is given something like this which is
related to e gamma rho by 4 r naught a and if you know the rho you can calculate actually the
fracture stress. So, now we have understood the concept of
stress concentration and it is happening now because of the presence of crack, elliptical
hole, circular hole, porosity whatever. Some defects are there and because of that there
is a stress concentration. So, let us solve some numericals to understand further.
So, suppose you have two plates, plate 1 and then you have a circular hole here and another one is
and you have elliptical hole here. So, you have case 1, case 2, case 1 is circular hole,
case 2 is elliptical hole. Let me put some values and we are having a applied load of
10 kilonewton in both the cases. The width and thickness remain same in both the cases,
let us say 10 millimetre, width is say 3 millimetre. So, I have fixed applied load
10 kilonewton then I have fixed the dimension also, both are same in both the plates.
Only thing I have changed here is the crack, the hole. So, in one case you have elliptical hole,
in one case you have circular hole. So, let us see the circular hole has a dimension of say
2 millimetre. So, I am again fixing or making the major axis as 2 millimetre,
same as the circular hole and this one as 1 millimetre. So, now interesting, dimension is
fixed or same for plate, load, applied load is same for both the plate, only thing is the
configuration of the hole is changing, that too I have made the same length, the major axis here
in the diameter here. So, let us see quantitatively what is happening now in terms of stress.
So, sigma which is the far field stress or applied stress can be calculated by load versus area. So,
area is this one, which is 10 into 3. So, 10 kilonewton which is 10 into 10 to power 3
divided by 10 into 3 and if we calculate approximately it will be 333 MPa. So, applied
sigma of far field stress is 333 MPa in both the cases. Now, let us see case 1 which is the circular
hole. So, sigma max which is equal to sigma tip, I have already mentioned that the maximum stress
is going to be at the sigma tip or at the tip and this is sigma 1 plus 2a by b and for circular
hole this is 3 sigma, we have discussed this. So, sigma max in this plate 1 is going to be 999
MPa approximately. So, in this whole plate 1, the maximum stress you are going to observe is 999
and that is going to happen at the tip of the hole circular hole. Now, let us see case 2 which
is the elliptical hole. So, here also what is the maximum stress that is going to be at the tip
and it will be same equation English one. So, sigma 1 plus 2a. So, here let me write 2a is
equal to 2 millimeter and 2b equal to 1 millimeter. So, 2a equal to 2 and then here it is 1 by half.
So, 5 sigma. So, sigma max is 5 sigma and this will be 1665 MPa. So, what do you see keeping
everything same, I am just changing the configuration. So, the circular hole is 999
and if I make it ellipse, it is going to increase because it is going to more go towards the track.
Okay, that is observation number 1. Observation number 2 is what is the applied stress is 333
MPa. Now, because of the presence of hole, we are going to attenuate the stress right locally at
the thread tip. So, in one case it is 999 see 3 times higher, in another case it is 5 times higher.
So, a stress concentration right you are going to see the stress concentration at the thread tip
that is observation number 2. Now, if I give you that hey my the plate or the material of
this plate has a yield stress of say 300 MPa or say sorry 400 MPa right yield stress.
Now, what is the applied stress 333 MPa. So, ideally I would say oh it is not going to
plastically deform isn't it because the yield stress is 400 MPa but the applied stress is 333
MPa. But remember locally you are going to have a stress which is much higher than 400 MPa.
So, the question is it is your material is going to deform this case 1 and case 2. So,
answer is yes right because although the applied stress is less than the yield stress which is 400
MPa locally your stresses are much higher than 400 MPa. So, you are going to get plastically
deformation locally. So, this is another observation. So, overall if you see the
stress based approach right we have discussed about the qualitative way as well as quantitative
way and the conclusion is that the there will be a stress concentration at the crack-tip the
maximum stress is going to be at the crack-tip and it is going to be higher than the applied
stress and if that happens there is a possibility that at the crack-tip you are going to go to
either since it is higher it can be more than the yield point or it can also go to the theoretical
stress. So, if it is more than the yield stress it is going to get plastic deformation and if it
is higher than the cohesive stress it is going to fracture right away. So, that is what is all about
for Inglis criteria or stress based approach. So, in the next lecture we are going to start
talking about the energy based approach which is Griffith criteria. Thank you.
