Lecture 25: Slip Systems

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
Welcome back students. So, we have looked at motion of the dislocations. The next thing
that we will be discussing is the resistance that comes to this motion. So, we remember
when we talked about the theoretical strength. So, all of the atoms have to break and then
because of that we see that sinusoidal energy values. Now, although the whole plane is now
not getting sheared and even if the row is getting sheared and even if only steps it
is moving in steps, but still there are resistance in that sinusoidal way. And this resistance
arises primarily from two sources. One is the size of the core and other is the density
of the planes, meaning lattice resistance. So, depending on what is the resistance of
what is the density of the planes, different planes have different resistance and that
is why we have certain preferred planes for glide of the dislocations and which leads
us to what we say as the slip system. So, certain planes would be preferred and we already
know that certain directions are what become the Burgers vector. So, together the direction
and the plane define the dislocation and hence we together we call what is called as now
the slip system. So, for different crystal system you would see that we have different
slip systems. So, with this introduction let us move on to understand what kind of resistance
does dislocation face in motion. So, like I said there are two-fold resistance to dislocation
motion and one is from the core that is from the dislocation structure itself and the other
is coming from lattice. And as we would look into it we will understand that these two
are actually interrelated. So, on the face of it we can say they are two different factors,
but they are one and the same thing. So, let us look at what do we mean by resistance to
dislocation motion from the core. So, what it means is that the size of the core defines
or the total amount of resistance that would be faced by the dislocation would be dependent
upon the size of the core. So, for that first let us try to understand what do we mean by
size of the core. So, I will draw edge dislocation with two different core sizes. So, once we
understand the size of the core we will move on to understand how it affects the dislocation
motion. So, over here the let us say this is the extra half plane and so it goes only
up to this point. So, this is our dislocation and what we see is that it should be symmetric
it is just that when I am drawing by hand it is not so accurate, but it should be symmetric.
So, this is one extreme where I am trying to show that the core is larger in size and I will show
the other extreme where thus I will try to show that the core is very small. So, this is the plane
of the atom, this is the plane of the atom and here is our edge dislocation. So, what do we see?
What we see is that in this one these atoms are also displaced from its position and they
have moved away from their equilibrium position and therefore, we can say that the displacements
are large even for this atom and even for this atom. On the other hand when we look at this
example here we see that these two atoms are almost not displaced they may be very minor
change in their position while there is a good amount of displacement for this particular
these two atoms the one just next to the extra half plane and again these two are almost not
moved. Now, if we were to look at displacement with respect to b. So, let us say we draw
with respect to the central line delta u by b. So, on the y-axis what we have the quantity is
delta u displacement but of course, it has to be with respect to b and similarly I draw it over
here and the x-axis is the usable distance. So, what we know is that here the displacements
are large up to a very good extent. So, the curve would look something like this.
So, the displacement is signs are different on the left and right hand side which is
represented like this. On the other hand the atom the displacement goes almost to 0
which would be represented something like this. There may be small amount of displacement
and if we define that the region up to which delta u by b is 0.1 or basically and the point
at to which the displacement is 10 percent of the Burgers vector is defined as the core. So,
we will draw a line here like this. So, let us say this is plus minus 10 percent
and here also we draw the plus minus 10 percent plus minus 10 percent or 0.1 spring. So, if we
say that the core is up to the 10 percent then what it means that the core for this particular
dislocation is all the way up to here. So, this would be the size of the core
for the left side example while here we see that it is only. So, here we are drawing up to
this point this is where it intersects and here we see that the 10 percent line intersects
somewhere here. It is not drawn very accurately but somewhere around this even from this schematic
it is clear that size of the core is very different. So, here size of core is large
and here size of core is small. Now this size of the core has a very strong effect
on how the dislocation moves. When the size of the core is very large then it is easier for it to
move. When the size of the core is small it faces much larger resistance. So, we will give some
rough estimate on how large or how much difference can it become and you would be surprised at the
amount of difference the size of core can make. But first let me just summarize what I have just
mentioned. When distortion I am writing distortion which or dislocation core is large
the dislocation is easy to move. So, clearly this one has a large dislocation core so it is easier
to move. On the other hand this will be this like just I mentioned that the size of the core is
small. So, this dislocation would be difficult to move. So, at first it may look a little counter
intuitive but yes that is the case larger the core easier to move smaller the core more difficult to
move. And when we are defining the size dislocation core we have to remember that the width of
dislocation core is defined as the distance over which displacements of the atoms are large enough
that what do we mean by large enough that we will not be able to apply linear theory of elasticity.
So, that is what has been defined as the cutoff for dislocation core. So, you remember even when
we obtained the stress field and strain field we applied linear theory of elasticity and therefore
this theory was not applicable for dislocation core. Now we can we would say in the same vein
we will define that the core is where that where the displacement is so large that
theory of linear elasticity cannot be applied. And it is generally accepted to be of the order
of b by 10. So, in magnitude wise when 10 percent of the Burgers vector value the displacement is
close to is more than 10 percent of the Burgers vector then we would say that we will not be
applying the theory of linear elasticity. And this width is usually denoted by
and just to give you like I said a rough estimate of how much difference it can make.
So, let us say if your tau is the shear stress required to move the dislocation then it would vary
like this. So, let us say this is the W this is the tau and if the width is 0 meaning basically
there is no dislocation then shear stress that would be required would be of the order of
g. And just when the width increases to b then the shear stress reduces drastically to g by 400.
So, just by additional one layer of atom thickness of the dislocation core from zero layer
we can see that the shear stress requirement has dropped by two orders of magnitude.
And if you were to make the width 5 b it will come down several order these are
some simulation experiments carried out by Prasannan Subramaniam and it is based on these.
So, the actual values may differ from material to material. So, we can say dislocation glide
occurs most easily in wide dislocations. These wide dislocations are found in metals
with simple closed packed structure and hence these materials are ductile.
On the other hand ceramics tend to have narrow dislocation and not surprisingly the dislocations
there are difficult to move and hence are have high strength but brittle. Another factor which
is where which is gets related to the next resistance next factor for resistance which
is lattice resistance is the fact that large interplanar distance of the planes
leads to wider core. So, if the lattice planes are such that it has in larger interplanar distance
then it leads to wider core and hence the dislocation becomes more easier to move and
hence the material will be more ductile in nature. So, which brings us to our next factor which is
resistance to dislocation motion lattice or the lattice resistance to the dislocation motion.
So, we know that the dislocations then they are trying to move. So, basically there will be
lattice resistance. So, there will be valley like this and which is called Pearl's Navarro Valley.
So, let us say this is the extra half plane. So, you need to move the extra half plane this is how
it would have the energy variation where we can say that this is the EEN what is called as Pearl
Navarro energy from where we can calculate the Pearl Navarro stress. So, when stress is applied
dislocations move and face additional sinusoidal resistance of lattice sinusoidal resistance which
is depicted here due to lattice. So, if you were to write down the Pearl Navarro energy which is
actually varying but if we look only at the amplitude then the amplitude can be given by this
equation and if we have the energy we know that we can calculate the shear stress which will be
by differentiating this relation with respect to b. So, tau pn which will be equal to
so when we differentiate with this minus 2 pi will come out and there will be b square which
will again be minus 1 over b square. So, this minus gets cancelled into EPN and therefore this
tau pn the shear stress. So, now we are looking at terms of the shear stress that needs to be
applied to move the dislocation. So, we have already mentioned that you need to apply a
shear stress to get the dislocations moving and that has to be applied parallel to the Burgers
vector. So, tau pn that we will get will be equal to 2g by 1 minus nu exp. Now this is a very
important equation from where we will be able to derive what should be the slip system of the
material. Here w width is you can give it in terms of the lattice parameter and the Poisson ratio.
So, a is the lattice parameter and nu is the Poisson ratio. Therefore, you can replace this
by 2 pi a by 1 minus nu and now if you want to have a slip system or you want to define a slip
system then we know that we want a dislocation or the dislocations would want to move on a plane
where least resistance is present which means the tau pn is smallest. So, now all we need to find
out is what are the condition that leads to the smallest value of tau pn. So, we can list it. So,
one of the parameters that we can for given material that can be selected is a and the
other is b not sorry not the a but the particular plane. So, I made a mistake here this a is not
the lattice parameter let me define it a is the interplanar spacing and w is the width of the
core. So, clearly what we had mentioned earlier that large interplanar distance leads to wider
core which is what we see here. So, large interplanar core means larger width and hence
easier movement of the dislocation and a is the interplanar spacing. So, again let me reemphasize
a is not the lattice parameter but the interplanar spacing. So, a is something for a given material
we can decide basically whether it should be 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 0 or any other plane and similarly b
which particular direction should be b 1 0 0 1 1 0 1 1 1 and so on. So, a and b are something that
we can select and accordingly we can see which one would give the smallest value of tau pn.
Other factors like nu is a material property g is a material property. So, we cannot change that
and therefore those remain constant. So, now let us look at what values of a and b would lead to
the smallest value of tau pn. So, a the interplanar spacing over here now if you look for tau pn to
be small this whole quantity should be small which means this is there is a negative sign. So,
therefore this quantity should be larger and this quantity should be smaller. So, what it is saying
is that a should be as large as possible should be large. So, what we want is that the glide planes
with wider interplanar spacing which at the same time when it has a wider interplanar spacing it
means that on that particular plane the density of atoms is very large. So, densest planes. So,
in other words we can either look at planes with highest interplanar spacing or we can look at
planes which have densest atomic density densest planes. So, this defines the a for a given system.
Now coming to b we have said it should be small because it is a whole quantity has to be
small as far as possible and therefore this would be small if b is small this will make it large
which means minus term would be large and therefore the whole quantity would be small.
Therefore, b should be small and when we say b should be small it means slip
you remember b Burgers vector is also called the slip vector. So, slip vector or slip should be
along direction with shortest lattice transition or in other words slip should be
along closest back direction. So, once we have a given material system and there are only
certain type of material systems and in when we limit it to metals where we see the deformation
we are mostly talking about FCC, BCC and in some cases simple cubic. So, let us look at
with the example of BCC and FCC what we have understood is that a should be densest and b
should also be densest. So, a or basically we should select the densest planes and the
densest direction densest planes would become the planes where the glide will take place
and b is the slip vector which should be along the densest direction. So, let us look at BCC
and there are primarily three main planes which we will consider.
So, that I can also draw the planes how would the planes look like in BCC we know that if you
draw the join the corners of the cube then you have atoms at the corner. So, the atoms would
look like somewhere over here, over here and over here and then the next column I want to have over
here is the number of atoms because if you want to find the density of atoms what we need is number
of atoms and the area of the region of under consideration this will give us when we divide
number of atoms n by a then we will get planar density which will be equal to n over a and then
we can also look at a value of a. So, over here for the 1 1 1 plane clearly what you have is 1 6
1 6 1 6 3 of these which brings us to 1 over 2 total number of atoms as 1 over and the area is
a equilateral triangle. So, this will be root 3 by 4 and the length here is a naught root 2
whole square. So, when you put it over here what you would see that it comes out to 1 over
root 3 a naught square and I will come to the interplanar spacing in a little later stage.
First let me compare the other planes. So, the other important planes for the
cubic system are 1 1 1 0. So, in a BCC you have atoms only at the center. So, 1 1 0 also has 1
atom at the center and 4 atoms at the corner which are quarter of the atoms. So, overall it makes up
2 atoms. So, the number of atoms is 2 and the area here is a naught root 2 times a naught
therefore, and here I am using the term a naught which is lattice parameter. So, this is not
interplanar spacing, interplanar spacing is given by a. So, this becomes a naught square root 2 and
therefore, your planar density would come out to root 2 by a naught square. Now, moving on
to the third plane which is 1 0 0 which is simplest of all these 3 it is a naught by a
naught area and there are 4 atoms at the corners. So, what we get here is number of atoms 1 by 4
into 4 equal to 1 area is a naught square and the planar density will turn out to be 1 over
a naught square. So, clearly what we see that the planar density is highest for this particular case
which is the 1 1 0 and not surprisingly for BCC 1 1 0 is the preferred slip or glide plane.
And the last thing that I was about to write here is the distance between the planes
and you can find out that for 1 the 1 1 1 planes the distance between them is a naught
by 2 root 3 or 1 1 0 it will come out to a naught by root 2 and for the 1 0 0 it will come out to
a naught by 2. So, again what we see is that this is the largest value and these are much
smaller than this. So, this has the largest interplanar spacing in the case of BCC atoms.
And therefore, this is the glide plane. So, we have looked at the glide plane and when it comes
to the tensile direction then it is again not very difficult to imagine. So, BCC we have atom
at the center then we have atoms at the corner and the atoms are actually touching the only along
the body diagonal which is along this one which is along 1 1 1 direction. And the basic lattice
vector sorry the basic translation vector from one atom to the other atom would be half of this.
And therefore, this will come out to Burgers vector equal to e by 2 1 1 1 and the glide plane
we saw was of the family 1 1 0. So, together these this forms the slip system for the BCC material.
Now, let us move on to the FCC material. So, again here the 3 primary planes which
are contenders you can imagine would be the ones with low values of the numbers
and those will be 1 0 0, 1 1 0 and 1 1 1. So, again I will start with 1 1 1 and
here it is FCC again I will have to write number of atoms area and planar density.
So, number of atoms and area of the region being considered planar density which will be equal to
n by a and then lastly what we have is a the interplanar special. So, for 1 1 1 we have atoms
over here 1 6 1 6 atoms over here we also have one half atoms over here. So, overall the number
of atoms for this one will turn out to be 2 and the area of the region considered is same as the
equilateral triangle that we said earlier for the BCC. So, it is root 3 by 4 a naught root 2
whole square and when you calculate the planar density it comes out to 4 by root 3 a naught
square and then let us move on to 1 1 0. So, this will be rectangle in shape and we have atoms
at the corners and also on 2 of the edge centers which are half and the total number of atoms
again comes out to 2 area is a naught square root 2 a naught root 2 times a naught and therefore,
the planar density comes out to root 2 by a naught square. Now, moving on to the last plane
which is 1 0 0. So, here it is square shaped a naught by a naught and the atoms are located
and the corners and one also in the face center. The total number of atoms here is 2
area is a naught square therefore, 2 by a naught square. Now, clearly the planar density is. So,
clearly the planar density is highest for this one this is 4 by 1.732. So, it is greater than 2
and this is 2. So, and this is 1.732. So, we are comparing other factors are constant 2 1.732 and
some number greater than 2. So, this one is clearly highest. Therefore, this is the glide
plane preferred glide plane for FCC system and again if you look at the value of the
interplanar spacing you would find that this is a naught by root 3 for this one it will come out to
a naught by 2 and this one will come out to a naught by 2 root 2. So, I will leave it I leave
it to you to find out how we obtain this number it is not very difficult you have to just imagine
the cube where the planes the for example, 1 1 1 means which are carrying these atoms
and count the number of planes along the along a given known length.
For example, 1 1 1 you would count the number along the main body diagonal and therefore,
you would be able to find the number of in the distance between the planes and this also
clearly is highest value for the 1 1 1. So, that is the glide plane and for the
b value we said it should be the shortest translation vector. So, again it is not
very difficult what we have to look at is the unit cell and in this particular case
you would be well aware that the atoms touch along face diagonal which is 1 1 0.
Hence closest or hence closest back direction. So, this total length is 1 1 0 and this much is
the translation from one atom to another therefore, the Burgers vector would be a by 2 1 1 0 and the
glide plane would be 1 1 1. So, now we have looked at the slip system for FCC and BCC system
we will not derive for the HCP it is you can do that as a exercise as an assignment.
I will just summarize what are the slip systems for the various cubic materials.
So, not materials but various crystal systems crystal system slip planes and the slip direction.
So, we are looking at BCC FCC and HCP for BCC we know it is 1 1 0 which is the slip plane which was
the preferred one and the direction came out to be 1 1 1 for FCC 1 1 1 is the closest packed plane
or densest plane and 1 1 0 is the closest packed direction and to be precise if I want to
I should actually write not the slip direction I should mention Burgers vector
or slip vector and therefore, this would be a by 2 a by 2 for HCP the slip plane which is the closest
to the densest plane you can easily show it is the basal plane and for the slip vector it is a by 6
1 1 bar 2 0 for HCP we use the HKIL format to define the directions and planes.
So, there are 4 numbers instead of the 3 numbers. So, overall we have looked at the slip system
we were able to derive the slip system based on our understanding of the
resistance to dislocation motion that is experienced which is coming out from the lattice
the pearls Nabarro valley that is present when a dislocation moves and we know the energy if
you know the energy variation. So, we can take the amplitude portion and we can differentiate
to calculate the shear stress the required minimum shear stress required for the dislocations to move
and then we can compare and based on that equation we derived that a should be the densest
plane and b should be the densest direction and where a defines the glide plane and b is the
Burgers vector for BCC we saw that it is clearly 1 1 0 is the closest or the densest plane and
1 a by 2 1 1 1 is the translation vector Burgers vector for FCC 1 1 1 is the densest plane
and a by 2 1 1 0 is the Burgers vector we did not derive for XCP we are mentioning that
0 0 0 1 is the densest plane and a by 6 1 1 1 bar 2 0 is the slip vector.
So, we with that we complete the slip system for the various materials we are now in a position
to understand which particular planes and which particular planes the dislocations would like to
play. So, we will look at some examples in the next few lectures to be able to appreciate it
better. Thank you.
