Lecture 11

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
Hi, welcome. In this session, we will discuss how stock prices are determined. So, in the
previous session, one of the previous session, we have defined equity market where claims
on the net income, the holder of equities has the claims on the net income and assets
of the business. So, there we also discussed that there are two markets, one is primary
markets where new issue of a security or new issue of a share happens. And then about the
secondary markets where transaction of an already issued security happens, where brokers
and dealers are there. And in today's session, we will focus in the secondary market that
is called the stock markets and their how stock prices are determined and what are the
other factors. For example, the interest rate which we discussed in the previous sessions
and some monetary policy, how does it affect the stock prices.
So, in this slide, I have taken some screenshots of some leading stock exchanges. So, where
you can see the first one, Dow Jones Industrial Average. So, you can see this is the index.
This is actually computed by looking at the stock prices of 30 large companies listed
on stock exchange in the US. So, you can see the S&P 500, this also developed using the
stock performance of 500 large companies listed on stock exchanges in the US. So, NASDAQ also
you can see is a composite index is actually include over the stock prices of 2500 companies
listed in the NASDAQ. So, this actually built, you can see that it has been built based on
the stock prices and the index it has been built and over time it has been followed.
So, when it comes to Indian context, I think you are familiar that we have two major stock
exchanges. One is S&P that is Bombay Stock Exchange. You can see this is the stock, this
is the index, here NIFTY also is given. In the case of BSE, S&P BSE, you can see that
is a free floating float market weighted stock market index of 30 well established and financially
sound companies and there are different types of indices. For example, top 100 companies,
this is another index. So, whichever you want accordingly you can follow.
Similarly, you can see NIFTY 50 index is based on the 50 top performing companies listed
companies. This index has been built. So, I am also giving the screenshot of major stock
exchanges in the world starting from New York Stock Exchange, NASDAQ, etc. This is just
for your information. So, what is happening in the stock exchange? I am sure you are familiar
that means the transaction of already existing stocks.
Then the question comes, how do we calculate the price of a common stock? So, what we can
observe that in the market, already we observe what is the current price of a stock. But
for our analysis purpose, how do we given certain information about a company stock
or company, then how do we calculate the price of a stock. Before doing that, let us make
a quick review of bond pricing. So, here what is the price for example, let us start
with the basic which we have done in one of the previous class. What is the price of a
one year 8% coupon bond? For this, you know that we need the following information, what
is the face value, what is the coupon rate and what is the interest rate.
So, suppose the interest rate is 5%, suppose we have this information, face value we have
coupon, both we already know and the interest rate is for example 5%. Then using this formula
which we have used in the previous class, we know that the price of this bond with a
face value given the coupon rate of 4 and 5% we are going to get the current bond price
is going to be 51.43. So, then let us think about the stock price.
So, what is your willingness to pay for a stock with the following features? That means
instead of coupon, let us put that the expected dividend the stock is going to give you in
the next year is going to be $4 and expected price next year is going to be the price of
stock in the next year is going to be $50. So, in this scenario, what is your willingness
to pay for a stock with the following these features? So, it is not that easy to calculate
because you know both look like similar, but one big difference. The big difference is
that next year dividend for example, the next year dividend which I said here is $4 and
next year price both are in fact expectations. The realized price might be different. So,
buying the stock involves some risk. In this scenario, we think that computing the price
of common stock we need to look into some values that actually what is going to be the
next year dividend the expectation we need to compute what is going to be the next year
price plus we also need to see what is the discount factor.
For example, in the case of bond we have interest rate, but here in the case of stocks
we do not have any interest rate. So, we need to find out some value that can be used as
a discount. So, in order to compute the price of common stock one of the widely used method
is the one period valuation model. It shows that the price of stock at present current
that means P naught means current. The current stock price is going to be dividend that you
are going to get in the next year plus the price of stocks in the next year discounted
by 1 plus K e. So, what is this K e? So, let us point out that the P naught that I already
mentioned current price of the stock the present discounted value of the expected cash flow.
That is the current price of the stock the present discounted value of the expected cash
flows and D 1 dividend paid at the end of next year. K e the required return on investment
in equity. This is actually determined by so many other factors. What is your return
on alternative investment? For example, investment in a bond suppose you are getting 10 percentage
as the interest income 10 percentage interest from investing in a bond that actually going
to influence your K e expected required return on investment in this equity.
Obviously, you need to get more than that because this involved investment in equity
involves some more risk than as compared to the investment in a bond. So, this is the
required return on investment in equity. So, the expected return on shareholders equity
is equal to risk free interest rate. For example, 10 percentage which I mentioned here just
now plus you need some risk premium the for because you are going investing in stocks
there are uncertainties there. You do not know what is going to happen after one year
when after in the future may be the company may collapse. So, all the possibilities are
there. So, in order to incentivize you need a risk premium may be for example, you need
5 percentage as a risk premium. So, that is how this value of this K e is
determined. So, in this case K e we can also say that this is a kind of a discount rate
in this context this is going to be a discount rate also we can say. So, P 1 which we already
mentioned the expected sale price of the stock at the end of the first period.
Then now let us see illustrate using an example what is the price of a stock. So, using this
one period valuation model suppose you have been given this information that means, the
expected dividend next year is going to be 4 dollar and expected price next year is going
to be 50 dollar and assume that just for the sake of simplicity let us assume that your
K e is going to be 10 percentage may be we can build it like that 8 percentage is the
current interest rate and 2 percentage is the risk premium. So, let us make it assume
K e is going to be 10 percentage. So, plugging these values in the formula that we got here
we can calculate the price of the stock. So, we are going to get with given these features
that is the dividend and D 1 and P 1 with the K e of 10 percentage that is 0.10 percentage
then plugging this value we can see that the price of this stock in this market given for
an individual who is willing to pay who is having this K e expected value the required
return on investment in equity given this information is going to be 49.09 this is one
period valuation model. But you know that stocks is not just for a
one year investment. So, this is till its lifetime it is a long term investment that
means you are getting the share of a company as long as the company exists you are the
share holder of that company as long as you are not selling suppose you are in case you
are not selling this share at all. So, that means your ownership in that company is for
a long term. So, actually infinite time period. So, your current stock price it should reflect
not only just next year dividend and stock price expected price. But actually for the
infinite forecasting horizon we need to include. So, in this case what how we are going to
develop this formula expand this formula. This formula has two components now the first
component is the present value of future cash flow from dividend that means dividend in
year 1 year 2 plus plus you can see dividend for nth number of years. So, here we need
to discount it with the value of K e this one. So, same that K e that is the present
value of all future cash flow from the dividend plus we also need to calculate the present
value of future present value of the price of stock in nth year. So, this is the formula
that we are going to get. But one of the issue here is that if P n is far in the future obviously
it is going to be far in the future because we already say that the share means is a long
term investment in the share of the company that means not just for 1 or 2 or 3 years
also is n number of years. So, in this case we are going to see that when the P n is far
in the future it would not affect P naught at all how come. So, let us see this for example
the present value of a share of stock that sells for example for 50 75 years from now
for example let us take it for sake of simplicity we are just taking 75 years is the time period
for the stock actually should be more than that. So, suppose assume that this is 75 years.
So, a stock that is selling today with 50 75 years from now using a 12 percentage discount
rate that the K e. So, in this case what you can see that if you calculate here if plug
value here you are going to get the present value of the stock is going to be dollar 0.01
that means is less than 1 cent right 1 cent only.
Suppose if you increase it to 100 that the year this one when you going to increase it
to 100 200 500 years something like that if you are going to do then obviously you know
that this value is going to be 0.0000 right something like that is going to be like that
is going to be like that if you increase the number the times by horizon the forecasting
horizon if you increase. So, from this what we can see that in the calculation of the
current price of stock the current price of the value of the stock today is going to be
going to exclude this part is going to include mainly the first component that is the dividend
stream that is going to the cash flow present value of the cash flow from the dividend a
loan. So, accordingly it implies that the current
value of a share of stock can be calculated as simply the present value of the future
dividend stream alone. So, accordingly we can redefine this formula in this way that
is the t that means infinite time period only looking at the dividend aspects only the dividend
from the stocks. So, to summarize this point the price of the stock is determined only
by the present value of future dividend stream. So, we agreed that this is going to be the
formula for computing the stock price only looking at the future dividend stream again
we are getting here the n number of year the infinite time period that we are getting here
this also practically difficult maybe we can forecast the dividend for year 1, 2, 3, 4
maybe but beyond that it is practically difficult to know what is going to be the dividend a
company is going to give in the 3rd year, 4th year, 5th year like that right it is practically
difficult because we can only see when we see that what is the actual dividend or that
the company is giving and in order to address this you know that most companies because
they also do not want to suppose the company is doing well suppose the next year the company
is doing well and what they do that actually they are learning lots of profit and they
are having lots of they can distribute lots of dividend but sometime the company may do
bad in the year after next. So, in that case if they see that there is
going to be some fluctuation in their business. So, normally what companies do that they do
not distribute all their profits in the form of dividend some dividend they keep it as
undistributed profit that will be used for the for financing the operating cost of the
company that will contribute to the internal finance of the company and also to compensate
if there is a decline in profit in the future in order to compensate the dividend in order
to ensure that the shareholders get a fixed amount or a certain amount of dividend.
Most companies they do that they normalize their dividend distribution in order to compensate
if there is some up and down in their profit. So, in that case we can forecast that companies
we assume that companies sometime follow a try to give a constant amount of constant
the dividend at a constant rate. So, we can see that by using this one that means a constant
dividends suppose company is going to give 3 percentage this year next year also they
try to stick to 3 percentage, 3 percentage, 3 percentage next year year to after like
that. If the company is really doing well then obviously
you can say they are going to increase to 4 percentage, but they will try to stick to
that amount, but they do they would not try to give in one year they are going to give
4 percentage another year 20 percentage and next year again 3 percentage that is not a
good business model. So, looking at this idea that the practical aspect that means most
companies they try to give a constant dividend at a constant rate.
One more model that is recommended for calculating the stock price is the Gordon growth model.
So, this is a generalized dividend valuation model that requires that we compute the present
value of an infinite stream of dividend a process that could be difficult thus a simplified
model have been developed to make calculation easier. So, this assume the simple model that
is Gordon growth model it assume a constant dividend growth. So, as I already mentioned
many firms try to increase their dividends at a constant rate each year.
So, accordingly we can see that this is the growth rate dividend growth rate we can see
here that. So, this is the formula accordingly if you state this one this is the dividend
that the company given in the most recently maybe you can say that today or yesterday
or tomorrow yesterday or today that means most recent dividend g is the expected constant
growth rate in dividend ke is the which we already discussed the required return on an
investment and equity. Accordingly the Gordon growth formula is like
this that means price of stock the present price the price of stock is going to be D
naught times 1 plus g divided by k e minus g. So, the g is the growth rate the expected
constant growth rate in dividends. So, rewriting this formula we can get a very simplified
formula that the current price of the stock is going to be D 1 that is the stock price
dividend paid at the end of year 1 dividend to be paid at the end of year 1 divided by
k e minus g. So, these are the explanation for that. So, this is the formal derivation
for this formula then to get how we are getting P naught is equal to D 1 by k e minus g.
So, now let us see based on this Gordon formula how the market sets stock prices how do we
apply this Gordon formula in understanding how market sets stock prices. Importantly
in the stock market this is one of the place where demand and supply the market actually
truly the demand and supply really plays its role. So, price is set by the buyer willing
to pay the highest price given that demand and supply then the price is set by the buyer
willing to pay the highest price for that stock. So, market price will be set by the
buyer who can take advantage of the asset. Superior information about an asset can increase
its value by reducing perceived risk. So, because we have already seen that stock price
it actually reflect even the required rate of return that the k e that include not only
the return from alternative investment plus you also need a risk premium. So, superior
information about an asset can increase its value by reducing perceived risk. So, information
is important for individuals to value each assets. So, the value of your k e is subject
to the information that you are availing that you are having about a company. When new information
is released about a firm whether is firm is going to do well or the financial condition
of the firm or the business condition of the firm is bad then obviously, you know that
all these going to affect expectation and the prices of the stock. So, accordingly expectation
and prices of the stock are going to change. So, market participants they constantly receive
information and revise their expectations. So, stock prices change very frequently.
So, now let us apply given this information let us apply the Gordon formula to calculate
what will be the maximum willingness to pay for a particular stock by three individual
buyers. Suppose the information common to all the three individuals are the expected
dividend next year is going to be 2 dollar and expected growth in dividend is going to
be 3 percentage that is 0.03. So, in this case what are the information we need because
we have the dividend D 1 we have G we have and we also need information on k e right
we need information on k e, but k e varies from individual to individual because this
is based on their perception about the market and the amount that they required for them
in order to make an investment which we have already seen the expected return k e is actually
includes the expected return the return that they are going to get from alternative investment
plus the risk premium this actually varies from individual to individual.
So, let us assume that there are these three individuals with a varying level of uncertainty
about D 1 and G about their information because these are all expected right both are expected.
So, the uncertainty about the D 1 and G suppose individual A the he is very highly uncertain
about this D 1 and G he expect that may company may not give this 2 and think that 2 dividend
is not going to give and the growth rate also he expect that it may be even less than that.
So, in this case assume that the k e of this individual individual A is going to be 15
percentage and for the individual B he is medium his uncertainty level is little bit
below lower than individual A and he needs only 12 percentage and individual C he is
less uncertain he is confident that this is going to be the what these values are going
to be same. That means, this you know that the dividend
and the expected growth rate is actually a function of the general business condition
that the macroeconomic risk plus the systemic and some of the firm specific risk as well.
So, this individual suppose he is less uncertain he needs a k e of 10 percentage. So, accordingly
if you plug these values into this formula this formula we know that we are going to
get three different prices or the willingness to pay for or the p node we are going to get
three different values for all these three different individuals.
So, we can see here that what are their willingness to pay for the stock. So, if you calculate
this one you can see that the individual A his willingness to pay he price this stocks
at a dollar 16.67 individual B is going to give price at 22.2 and individual 3 his willingness
to pay is going to be his valuation his p node for individual C is going to be 28.57.
So, from this obviously, you know that whose k e is low for example, into here individual
C his k e is low he is less uncertain. So, he is willing to pay high price for this stock
that is going to be a dollar 28.57. So, from this example you can see that for a suppose
in this market there are only these three individuals and they do not know each other
and some individual who is holding this stock is willing to sell it he deliberately looking
for selling it. So, he is actually in what he will be doing
that he is desperate the individual who is who is holding this stock suppose he is desperate
that he wants to sell this stock then in this case you know that this three individual A
B C they do not know each other what is their willingness to pay. So, individual A he is
willing to pay maximum this much and individual B his willingness to pay maximum this much
and individual C his willingness to pay is 28.57 that is his maximum willingness to pay.
So, in this case what is going to be the stock price? So, obviously, the supplier of stock
the seller of the stock want to get the maximum. So, this would not be the stock price because
this individual A he is willing to pay 22. So, this individual A is out of the market
then when individual B his willingness to pay is maximum 22.22, but individual C is
willing to pay 28.57. So, assume that there are only three individuals here you know that
anyway they are not sharing each other each other's willingness to pay, but this person
he is willing to pay 28, but since the second person he is going to pay maximum this much.
So, the stock price is going to be a little bit above this one that means, for example,
22.23 or maybe we can make it as a round figure or maybe we can just make it to 22.50 suppose,
but it will be is going to be the price is going to be 22.23 right. So, because here he is willing
to pay maximum this one. So, then another there is only another individual he. So, he actually
willing to pay maximum this one in between some other individuals comes then obviously,
the stock price will increase, but here since his willingness to pay is this much and, but
second B is this 22.22. So, his actually the stock will be sold at little bit above
the stock price of 22.22. Applying this formula suppose,
so most often you see that sometime central bank the governor of RBI or any policy maker
they say that sometime they make an announcement that when the stock prices are low in the market
when overall the economy is really doing bad. So, they sometimes say that they are going to
increase the stock price through reducing the rate of interest and how we can explain this one
using the Gordon formula and let us take the our Gordon formula here. Suppose, when RBI lowers
interest rate what is going to happen here the return on bonds that means, alternative asset to
stocks declines then the investors are willing to accept a lower K e that means, the K e in this
case he is going to accept a low value. So, that means, if you reduce suppose this
K e value when you keep on reducing obviously, you know that the value of P e is going to increase.
This is one mechanism one pathway and another thing is that when policy makers when RBI reduce
the low interest rate reduce the interest rate obviously, you know that when the interest rate
is reduced the cost of borrowing for the firms reduces. That means, the cost of production
reduces and then they increase production then it will lead to higher GDP and the growth rate
in the economy also increase that means, the dividend also dividend of the company also
increase because the cost of borrowing reduces declines the that means, the profit also increase.
So, this actually means the G increases when the G increases you can see that again the stock price
is going to increase. So, when you can see when the K e that the K e when the this expectation
this value K e reduces then stock price increases similarly, when G increases then the stock price
increases. So, this is the pathway to explain how monetary policy expansion increase the stock
price. Similarly, we can also see that the same formula we can apply during the global financial
crisis you know that during crisis you know that the G rate it declines the growth rate decline
and you also know that when during financial crisis the it also led to the economic crisis
as well then you know that there is high increased level of uncertainty in the economy.
So, you need the increase in required return this also increases. So, because of both that
the G is declining K e is increasing because of both you know that the stock price is going to
decline as per the Gordon formula. Thank you.
