Lecture 2: Smart Materials-I

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Dec 1, 2023
[Music]
thank you
welcome to the second lecture on
foundations of cognitive robotics
in the last class
I talked about a basic introduction of
cognitive robotics
where I told you that what is the source
or inspiration of these term cognitive
and how cognitive robotics is different
is unique from other branches of
robotics
I also told you if you remember that
what are the different types
or characteristics of
interactions that are possible
in a
robotic system in order to develop an
intelligent robotic system
and
we have made these graduations
from strong to weak artificial
intelligence strong to weak AI
like for a strong AI system
I told you that embodiment is not a
precondition
you can have simple coupling
you can have historical coupling with
the environment and that will be good
enough for a strong AI system
whereas for a weak AI system
where we are talking about
things like cognitive robotics
physical embodiment is very much
required
now there are two subcategories under
physical embodiment which are organismic
embodiment
and organized in embodiment
and I will talk about these different
types of embodiments in this particular
lecture also I will tell you that how we
can develop such
cognitive robots
using certain special class of materials
called smart materials
and thus we will be able to build up
organismic robots
and there will be a hope of developing
cognitive robots through that
so in this second lecture on foundations
of cognitive robotics
we will focus on
organismoid embodiment Okay so
all other couplings the structural
couplings or historical embodiment
and the Very futuristic embodiment which
is organisms make embodiment these are
the things which will not focus at this
moment organisms might embodiment which
is the basic requirement for a cognitive
robotics will be in the focus first
now
when we'll talk about organos
organismoid embodiment
what is it that comes into your mind
fast
remember
in our last lecture I have shown you a
small video
from Honda
on the performance demonstration of a
robot which is a humanoid robot
that's the ASIMO robot
now this particular robot
how do you classify it
would you classify it to be an
organismite robot
and if you classify these to be an
organismoid
wouldn't it be a good idea to actually
look into that how much humanoid organ
like you know it is basically developed
in the light of developing a human-like
robot so how much human like is this
particular robot
so let's look into Honda specifications
and let's see that how much human like
is this acid
so we will talk about the building
blocks
and in this direction let's look into
what goes into the ASIMO robot
now Honda Engineers have created Smo
with 34 degrees of freedom
is 34 degrees of freedom essentially
means that there are 34 independent ways
in which the SEO robot can
move its different
limbs or body parts
and that actually helps it to work and
perform many tasks
much like a human exactly not like a
human but much like a human you have
seen in the last class in the last video
that I have shown that how it was
delivering a glass of drinks to the lady
now this Asimo apart from the fact that
it is made of 34 degrees of freedom
structurally it is made of a lightweight
material which is a magnesium alloy
structure
and it is combined with powerful
computers
and it is these two combinations that
means
by choice of a lightweight material and
by choice of this 34 degrees of freedom
we are able to see the performances of
the ASIMO robot
well you may be interested to know that
in comparison to the ASIMO robot
what are the degrees of freedom to a
real human
and then only we'll be able to
understand judge the performance of
ASIMO robot
compare
between the degrees of freedom in an Smo
robot which is 34 and asked in human
beings
you will see that how astounding our
creation is in comparison to one of the
best robots that we have created so far
so if you look at the degrees of freedom
that we have first of all we divide it
into five major elements that is the
head part the arms part the hands part
the spine and the legs
now in the head part the head part
you have the neck joint which has three
degrees of freedom that is flexion
extension lateral bending and axial
rotation so that gives us the three
degrees of freedom for the head
next is the arms and in the arms we have
three different types of joints now the
shoulder joints which has two movements
forward backward and off down and also
the rotation so total three degrees of
freedom
and then the elbow joint in which we
will consider only one degree of Freedom
although in some literature you will see
that people add one additional degree of
freedom but because it is somewhat
constrained so we will keep only one
degree of freedom for the elbow
and in the wrist joints we have three
degrees of freedom that is up down left
right and rotation so in all there are
seven degrees of freedom in each of the
arms and that means for the two arms we
have 14 degrees of freedom
now we come to the hands the most
dexterous part of our body
we have
in four fingers
four degrees of freedom H that means 16
degrees of freedom to grasp an object
and then the thumb
it has five degrees of freedom
so combination of all of them makes it
21 degree of freedom
and for the two hands that would mean 42
degrees of freedom
it's very very clear that we are so far
behind in terms of creating so many
degrees of freedom in the hands of a
robot today
now we come to the spine
the lumbar spine combined has
essentially three degrees of freedom
that is flexion and extension lateral
bending and rotation so that's the three
degrees of freedom the spine is having
and finally the legs if you consider the
Lakes it has three elements the hip
joint which has three degrees of freedom
forward backward left right and rotation
the knee joints which has essentially
one degree of Freedom that is forward
backward and the ankle joint which has
two degrees of freedom forward backward
Left Right rotation so
here we are getting 6 degrees of freedom
and for the two legs that would become
12 degrees of freedom in all we are
having approximately 74 degrees of
freedom in human beings
there is also some more thing to compare
how about the weight of the ASIMO robot
with this 34 degrees of freedom and how
much of power it requires
let's go back to the specifications of
the Honda robot and let's check that if
you look at some interesting
specifications of Asimo which I gathered
from the Honda's website its height is
about 4 feet each
is just like the height of a child
weight is 50 kg well that is little high
in comparison to a child
walking speed and running speed is
slightly in the higher side as we can
see 2.7 kilometer per hour walking speed
and running speed is about 7 kilometer
per hour
graspin Force little bit in the Lower
Side about 0.5 kg or 500 gram per hand
I am sure that a kit can lift slightly
more wet than 500 gram
actuator Y is 34 degrees of freedom
comes in the expense of 34 Servo Motors
in fact that's what keeps the maximum
cost to this robot
and the control unit is having
the working and operating control unit
Wireless transmission units Etc
it has sensors for example in the foot
it has torso level sensors in terms of
gyroscopes and acceleration sensors
and again the negative side is the power
it needs a
51.8 volt lithium ion battery it's very
very substantial also lithium and
battery is quite dangerous underweight
condition
and the operating time that we get that
is also very low if you look at it is
just one hour
so
at the operation system is you know
workstation or a portable control
so what we can figure out from the
specification is that
there are at least three points in which
Asimo is still far far away
from a good organism's Point robot
one is in terms of of course the degrees
of freedom
the Smo has 34 degrees of freedom
whereas you know in nature the human
that it mimics that has 74 degrees of
freedom and it has a substantially High
weight
is more than 50 kg in spite of using
very advanced class of materials
also it needs a very high power
and it can work only up to an hour or so
so these are some of the limitations
of the best currently available robot
which is close to an organism
so all these things
what does it point to what does it lead
to it tells us that we need to improve
in terms of
the overall weight or the bulkiness of
the robot
and also in terms of the overall power
consumption of the robot
so what is the solution in front of us
if we
look into the new developments of
muscles in this new age
we will see that there is a new branch
of Robotics fast expanding which is also
known as Soft Robotics
now under Soft Robotics
the robotic arms are meant to stretch
and squeeze at every point along their
neck
and their movement cannot be described
with simple geometric relations because
it is too complex it's a large
deformation motion much unlike the way
we are used to do it let's say for a
rigid robot system with the help of
kinematic chains it's very difficult to
describe this kind of a flexible robotic
link with this type of robotic system
so here you can see a octobot or a
octopus morphology you know kind of
thing which is mimicked in an octobot
system
now one of the thing if we compare
between the robots and the Animals you
would see that
robots traditional designs of Steels Etc
is far far stronger than any natural
naturally living material
let's say the nearest will be the tooth
or the Necker
and if you go for softer
materials like say wood or ABS plastic
then possibly it will be closer to the
cortical bones or a squid beak
if you make your robot even softer like
high density polyethylene or
polytextrafluoroethylene or polyurethane
then you will come closer to cancellous
bowls ligaments 10 Downs Etc
if you can make your robot farther soft
like say silicon rubbers
then you will get some of the muscles
like cardiac muscles and even in a
softer range almost close to hydrogels
you will start to get the skeletal
muscles
so thus this you know comparison is
aptly telling us that the direction to
which we have to take our Soft Robotics
but is wet is the only concept
no we have to also keep in our mind that
we have a constant of the power we have
the concern of this so many number of
Servo motors which makes it you know
very very expensive to afford
now you look at the different variations
of soft robots like
this one is a caterpillar inspired
Locomotion and then a multi-gate
quadrupt robot again based on soft
material and active camouflage one you
can actually play with metamaterials and
Optical optically coupled properties to
develop active camouflage walking in
hazardous environments type of robots
and then warm inspired Locomotion in
robots
and then particle jamming based
actuation
rolling powered by a Pneumatic battery
and hybrid hard hard and soft robot kind
of combinations
and then we have this snake inspired
Locomotion jumping powered by internal
combustion then there is a manta ray
inspired Locomotion and an autonomous
fish all these are various types of soft
robots that are coming up very fast and
with the intention that how we can
reduce the weight of the robot
but also as I told you that functionally
you need to improve you need to replace
these classical Servo Motors in order to
make it more sustainable feasible low
power consuming Etc
so
we need to think of the development of
muscle based flexible robots
the first stage towards that is the
development of pneumatic artificial
muscles or pams
and this PA aims
were the first step where the air
pressure is used in terms of compressing
and getting a muscle-like motion from
the system
now however the compressor itself is
quite heavyweight
so we need to change from a compressor
based system
to let us say a solid state kind of
actuator system and one of the very
interesting candidates towards these is
ionic polymer Matrix Composites or ipms
is
these are a general class of
electroactive polymers like here you can
see a four finger electroactive
polymeric gripper which can grip up to
the extent of 10.5 gram of rock and this
is used by NASA in a EAP gripper for uh
you know extra outside the Earth uh in
one of the planets planetary missions to
collect the debris I can show you that
how this EAP would work
you can see that such a large
deformation you are getting from the
retractive polymers and then how each
one of the four fingers have to work
together the last deformation and then
they have to grab the object
which is white you can see that just it
has deformed a lot so that is something
without the use of any motor is really
challenging
just by deforming it to the help of
direct transformation of electrical
energy to mechanical energy and then
placing it at a different location you
can do much more complicated words with
the help of this kind of ipmc rockers
today
we have
even more interesting group of materials
which can perform amazing fits
and they can be easily embedded and
integrated in order to form actuators
which would go very well with Soft
Robotics and can really make our dream
of developing cognitive robots
these are the groups of materials which
are known as smart materials
now before we talk about such smart
materials we have to keep in our mind
that the mechanisms also has to be made
compliant for example here you can see
that these this is a gripper and the
gripper ends you can see a large
deformation you can make with the help
of these ah closing down between the two
now what here has been done using the
fingers can be also done with the help
of smart materials and then you can
actually get a very large deformation so
even though the smart materials can be
used at the back end in order to get a
large Amplified motion you need to make
such Contraptions of compliant
mechanisms for grippers
now let's talk about the smart materials
in this group of materials
the features of such materials are
that they are basically functional in
nature
and the basic energy forms that gets
interchanged in such materials are
between thermal energy to mechanical
energy between electrical energy to
mechanical energy
magnetic energy to mechanical energy or
sound energy to mechanical energy
as I told you earlier also that NRG can
only be transformed so in this case we
have to manipulate between these
transformations in order to get our
intended type of actuations or type of
sense
now this materials Behavior which is why
they are so much important for Soft
Robotics is that there and allow us to
biological materials like they have the
nature of adaptivity cellular function
self sensing actuation and control
and moreover the sensors and actuators
are highly invaluable
so as different energy forms are
interchanged in a smart material
let's look into
these different types of smart materials
from an input output classification
point of view
there is a broad group of smart
materials like piezoelectric in this
case the input is electrical energy and
the output is mechanical deformation
mechanical energy
and then we have magnetostrictive
materials where the input is uh for
instance for the group of ferromagnetic
materials the input is magnetic energy
and the output is once again mechanical
energy in the form of mechanical stress
and deformation
and then for shift memory Alloys it
remembers its original shape after being
deformed and it can go back to the
original shape so this is by actually
exploiting the change from thermal
energy to mechanical energy
and we also have some special groups of
rheological materials which are like
electromagnet or neological materials
where it's the viscosity that changes in
the material
so thus there are these different types
of materials and if we look at these
from an input output point of views
the inputs can be categorized in terms
of electric field magnetic fields Trace
heat or light for that matter even like
can used as input and outputs can be in
terms of charge magnetization strain
temperature and Light
now if you look at these let's say like
in a matrix form then we diagonal terms
are something which are the material
properties which is very common in
material so they are not very smart for
parties but it's the off diagonal terms
particularly these green row column and
this gray row which is a very useful
nature to us
for example electric field as an input
and as an output it is creating strain
is what is known as reverse
piezoelectricity that is what is used in
piezoelectric materials or even in the
ipmc example that I have shown you a few
minutes before
and this is one such kind of off
diagonal property of a smart material
similarly if you can achieve the
deformations using magnetic energy
then it's called Zool effect magnetic
restriction so this is also another app
diagonal time for heat for the shift
memory Alloys its thermal uh you know
thermally induced phase transition and
for light it is photostriction
now this green column this is
corresponding to the actuator
development
many of these materials can be also used
as sensors
and here this gray row is very important
like if you use for example stress as
the input mechanical stress
and by exploiting the direct
piezoelectric effect you can build up a
sensor which will give you current or
charge as an output
similarly using binary effect in some
materials you can get magnetic field
change magnetization change as an output
change of stress creating strain is a
very normal thing of elastic modulus
there is no smartness but
if I change the stress and if the
temperature changes there is a thermo
mechanical effect that is related
and similarly in the electric property
changes there is a photoelastic effect
which is also equally interesting in
terms of developing sections
now
if you compare these materials
in terms of actuators and compare them
with the traditional actuatives like
Motors like pneumatic actuators or
hydraulic actuators we are interested to
know
that in which way smart materials are
actually better in which way these smart
material based actuators
will be
outstanding in comparison to all the
traditional actuators
if you look at the response types you
can see that all these greens are the
traditional actuation system which is in
terms of seconds or milliseconds and
here for smart materials you get it in
terms of
0.1 milliseconds so it is even one tenth
of a millisecond and that shows that why
they are very fast so they are response
time is faster that makes them closer to
this kind of organismoic robots and also
another interesting properties they are
accuracy if you look at their accuracy
they are far far accurate than most of
these actuators that we are talking
about at least 10 to 100 times more
accurate these smart materials
so in terms of the speed in terms of the
accuracy
they are you know an order of several
orders of magnitude better
than the traditional actuators
now
the flip side is that
that is plus paint is lower or the force
is also lower
but these two things you can actually
compensate by using suitable mechanical
amplifiers or by Distributing the
actuators the smart material base
actuators uh you know in terms of just
like our muscles you can distribute it
and you can extract more energy from the
system
now if you look at the piezoelectric
materials because in this talk I today's
lecture I'll mostly focus on
physioactive materials as you can see
here that if I apply force and if I
deform the piezoelectric material you
are getting a voltage that is produced
in the system
so this is what is the reverse
piezoelectric uh is is the direct piece
electric effects where you are applying
the force mechanically and you are
getting the voltage output
look at this piezoelectric materials
closely
we will first see that they are not that
very new it was developed around 80 80
as you can see that Pierre and jackpuri
has developed the first actually found
out this piezoelectricity which is
basically electricity for pressure
and contemporary electricities were like
electricity from static electricity from
friction it was a contact electricity or
electricity by heating up crystals which
are spiroelectricity so
when they found out that he will
pressure in the crystal can generate
electricity his piece of means pressure
that's what this new group came into
picture
and as a result of that Pierre kui and
Paul zakuli both of them got Nobel Prize
in physics in 1903 on the direct
piezoelectric effect the direct effect
signifies if you apply pressure on the
piece elliptic material you are getting
electricity out of it
similarly
at a later stage Gabriel lip man
theoretically predicted that the reverse
is also possible if you apply electric
field you will get a mechanical
deformation for which he got his Nobel
Prize in 1908 that's on the reverse
piezoelectric effect
now
why physioelectric material
is
so exotic
what is there so especially the
physioelectric material that actually
give it this property that as you apply
the mechanical force you are getting an
electrical charge out of it
well one of the very important group of
these electric material are these pair
of Skies named after a Russian geologist
which was discovered roughly around 1950
or so
and this pair of skies are generally
Eternal structures that means it is made
of three components like in this example
barium titanium and oxygen so there are
three components which forms this
Crystal this piece electric Crystal
now what is so special about this
components is that
you if you look at the structure the
crystal structure of this material
you would see that bariums are at the
vertices of this tetrahedral
the tetragonal structure and you would
see that the oxygens are at the face
centers everywhere
and the titanium
which is the source of this kind of
piezoelectricity is deep inside the
geometric Center of this tetra
now this titanium is very precariously
positioned because if I apply
a little bit force of this Christian
from any direction
the titanium will get displaced from its
Center at the moment it will displaced
as the criteria has a high degree of
electropositivity it will generate
actually a dipole moment in this Crystal
and thus
is little mechanical deformation the
crystal is charged
and if you imagine that in any uh bulk
material there are hundreds or millions
of crystals each one of them will get
charged because of this information
although the dipoles could be random in
nature and you need to electrode to make
it specially moving towards a particular
direction but those are the things I'll
talk about at a later stage
now this is about the barium Titanic
structure
similar physioelectric effect you'll be
able to see in lead circular Titanic
physically in lithium niobium family in
late in iobion family in Atria manganese
family and in ammonium cadmium family
the thing that you differ may be the
curry temperature
the cooler temperature tells us that
Beyond
beyond what temperature
beyond what temperature
the Piezo electricity would not be
there so the piezoelectricity will be
accent in a system so that's what is the
Puri temperature which you have to keep
in our mind that you will not see the
muscle the artificial muscles that we
are trying to build in action if the
temperature goes a particular RP on a
particular level
now what is the constitutive equation of
such piezoelectric structure
as I told you that for the direct effect
where you are applying mechanical stress
that is there in this large x that X is
the stress so you are applying stress in
the crystal means you are you know
increasing X and as you are increasing X
you will see that the charge is
appearing in the system
remember if you apply or increase the
electric field then also there will be
charge appearing but that's something
which is pretty common isn't it for a
capacitor type of a material you know
things like a dielectric material so
that's not what the smartness is the
smartness is where you are applying the
mechanical stress and getting a charge
out of it only a very few group of
materials will show these and the degree
up to which it will show is governed by
the small D which is electromechanical
coupling coefficient the higher the D
the more will be the electric charge
that will be generating in the system
how can we use this that you are
applying stress and you are finding
charge because they have a great use in
terms of development of sensors so the
dialect effect is generally used for
sensor development
now for the conversation
where you are applying the electric
field not the mechanical field
mechanical field creating small X that
is the mechanical strain is quite
natural for any material but you are
applying electric field and finding the
mechanical strain that's something here
isn't it and that is what is the basic
uh you know equation that we will be
using for developing these artificial
muscles and by applying electric field
mechanical deformations and that is what
is the converse effect of the reverse
effect the electrical stimulus creating
the strain once again here you can see
the same electromechanical coupling
coefficient that means the more I the
more the materials D will be the more I
will be getting the strain out of the
same electric field
so these are the two very basic
equations which will continuously guide
us in terms of the development of
actuators and sensors by using these two
effects
I will now show you some applications of
these electricity
the first application is actuator
is actually pretty common in terms of
every day you might have seen it you
might not have noticed that is in
Printers say for example if you look at
Fields you will see that
that he was getting this actual
deformation by using two materials one
smart one non-smart like these two
things together you can make a belting
alphabet
and these bending you can actually put
it in terms of controlling the flow of
you know King jet filter so each one of
them is actually cooking a droplet of a
pigment which gets stuff
so this is one application another
application using terms of amplification
of Piezo actuate so if you look at the
Piezo actuator here the central part is
where the actuation is taking place
and this actuation in the central part
is very small but because we have used a
special agolite structure
a little bit of deformation here can
create a large deformation along the
semi-minor axis of the ellipse which is
what is this Amplified Piezo actuators
too
and look at the very last one this is
where the physioelectric material is
actually in an offset with a composite
here also because of this offset by
actuating these you can get a large
deformation out of the system
all these three things you can use some
way or the other in terms of developing
the actuators
so in this talk
I have told you about one basic block of
a smart material which is a
piezoelectric material and how this
physioelectric material can be used in
terms of developing an actuator at this
actuator in turn can be used to replace
those Servo Motors that I have shown you
in that assemble and to make a robot
more organismoid or organic light
product
there are many other smart materials and
in next few lectures I'll quickly cover
some very prominent smart materials too
thank you
[Music]
thank you
yeah
[Music]
