독일은 실제로 핵무기를 얼마나 개발했을까? 맨해튼 프로젝트 vs 우란프로옉트

리뷰엉이: Owl's Review
123 팔로워
2023. 11. 28.
영화 오펜하이머에서는 오펜하이머의 일생과 미국의 핵무기 개발 프로젝트 맨해튼 프로젝트에 대해서 잘 나왔다. 하지만 나치 독일이 핵무기를 얼마나 제작했는지는 묘사되지 않았다. 오늘은 나치 독일의 핵무기 개발 프로젝트 우란프로옉트에 대해 알아보자.
두클립 채널에서 진행한 '오펜하이머' 스포일러 라이브 리뷰를 재편집 하여 업로드합니다.
라이브 방송 채널: 두클립
출연: 리뷰엉이, 두클립, 천재이승국, 김시선, 삐맨
In April 1939, before the 2nd World War started,
Nazi Germany started a project to make nuclear weapons first.
Oh...
Before the World War?
Before the World War.
Before the World War?
That was the Uran Project.
Oh, this one.
The front line is so wide.
You have to send a bomb right here.
You have to send a tank right here.
You have to send a plane right here.
So, Heechul says,
Hey, why don't you make a few more bullets at that time?
Why are you talking about nuclear weapons?
Hey, why don't you make more tanks?
Why don't you make more planes?
It's like Avante N.
Hey, if it's that much money, why don't you ride a Granger?
Why do you ride an Avante?
I watched the movie,
and I couldn't really understand how much Germany actually made nuclear weapons.
How successful it was.
First of all, if you want to know the history of German nuclear weapons,
you have to know this person first.
This is Dr. Otto Hahn.
He's German.
Is he Korean?
No, no, he's a doctor.
His name is Dr. Tohann.
Dr. Tohann from Germany.
This man is doing this experiment.
What would happen if I hit a neutrino with uranium?
But at first, this man imagined,
Oh, because uranium is heavier than a neutrino,
a heavier atom will be born than uranium.
So he shot a neutrino into uranium.
And something amazing happened.
We all know now,
but at that time,
there was no scientist who imagined that the existing atom would be split.
The law was that the original atom would never split or change.
When this man shot a neutrino into uranium,
it split into two.
Was this a German scientist?
Yes, he was a German scientist.
That was announced in December 1938.
One was barium,
and the other was kryptonite.
Kryptonite was named after Superman.
DC had to give the copyright to that scientist.
But this is the first surprising fact.
There's a second surprising fact.
When he shot a neutrino into uranium,
a tremendous amount of energy was released.
There's a law of mass conservation.
The mass in this world doesn't appear or disappear.
That's the law of mass conservation.
There are neutrinos and uranium.
Let's say there are 10 neutrinos in total.
And after splitting,
there are three neutrinos, barium and kryptonite.
There are five neutrinos.
If there are 10 neutrinos and 10 uranium on the left,
there are five neutrinos on the right.
How many neutrinos are there on the right?
10.
As far as we know, it should be 10.
It should be 10.
But it's not 10.
For example, it becomes 9.
Where did 1 go?
According to the law of mass conservation,
the mass should always be the same,
but it disappeared as much as 1.
This phenomenon is called mass decomposition.
As much as 1 disappears,
it changes to energy.
It changes to heat and heat.
But as much as 1 is decomposed,
the energy is tremendously large.
Why?
Einstein's formula for E is mc2.
E is the square root of m times the speed of light.
If you multiply the square root of the speed of light by 10,
you get a tremendous amount of energy.
But actually,
if you just hit a neutrino on that uranium,
it doesn't generate a lot of energy.
But the problem is,
if you collect as much uranium as this ball and pop it,
the chain reaction starts,
and it's destroyed.
Dr. Otto Hahn discovered this at first,
and he announced it all over the world.
That's why Germany is ahead.
It's emphasized in the movie.
It's because Germany discovered this.
At that time, Germany and Europe were the centers of science.
The United States was the root of quantum mechanics.
It's in the movie, too.
This man went and pioneered it.
It had an effect.
He pioneered it, Oppenheimer.
It was the root of everything.
At that time, Europe was the center of all science.
That's why in the movie,
suddenly,
It's in the newspaper, too.
Yes, it's in the newspaper.
He said he developed it.
He said it could be nuclear dissemination.
Then I thought,
Oh, then it could be nuclear dissemination.
Let's move on.
So the scientists around the world who received the research results
think like this.
Nuclear dissemination produces tremendous energy?
And if it causes a chain reaction,
it could be a bomb?
Hey, hey, this could be used as a weapon.
It was a bomb!
I have a question.
Honestly, I thought something new would come out.
It's not that.
It's split up.
But no one thought about that before?
I didn't.
I couldn't.
Why didn't anyone do it?
Because there's no result.
At that time, there was theoretical physics
and experimental physics.
Theoretical physics is
I imagined it as it came out in mathematics.
Experimental physics is based on that theory.
I actually made a device.
It's like hitting particles with particles.
We're doing a lot of experiments like that.
Oppenheimer was a theoretical physicist.
That's why the teacher kept saying something.
I made a poison accident.
What kind of physics is Dr. Otto Han?
Experimental physics.
So, in conclusion,
Now I understand.
Theoretical physicists have to imagine something more radical
for experimental physicists to try it.
Even theoretical physicists
are trapped in the frame of existing discovered substances.
Right, right.
I didn't think there would be anything more than this.
I was going to try it without hesitation.
It's done.
Experimental physicists are also important.
Because experimental physicists
are actually making the device.
Oh, this is fun.
That's why the movie is a bit of a shout-out.
In other words,
theoretical physicists can be a shout-out.
Lorenz next to me?
You keep saying that later.
It's good to have experimental physics, right?
That's right, that's right.
That's why you're pointing it out.
We complement each other.
Oppenheimer talks about the limits
of being a theoretical physicist.
That's right, that's right.
Now I get it.
Now we have a chain reaction.
If we hit the uranium with a neutron,
split two atoms,
and three neutrons come out.
Those three neutrons hit the uranium again
and split into two.
I think it will create an enormous explosive force
by hitting the uranium again.
Hit and hit and hit and hit.
It's like a domino.
Domino hits two dominoes,
and two dominoes hits four dominoes.
It's four, so there's eight.
It's like two squares and three squares.
If there is such a thing, we can make the most powerful bomb that the human race has ever had.
Because the energy of the bomb is too big.
It's a bomb that can't even be compared.
So, in April 1939, before the Second World War,
Nazi Germany started a project to make nuclear weapons first.
Before the World War?
Before the World War.
That's the Uran Project.
It was already in before the World War.
The World War broke out around September 1939,
and it already started in April.
And why is it Uran?
Uranium.
And the project is in German.
The Uran Project starts.
The person in charge is Heisenberg.
Heisenberg is one of the three leaders of quantum mechanics.
He is very close to Niels Bohr.
He is also very close to Max Born.
These three fought with Einstein.
It came out as a line for a moment.
Niels Bohr was robbed.
I think there are a few scholars who beat Einstein.
Those three combined to develop Einstein.
At first, quantum mechanics was almost lost,
but the three combined and won.
For the first time in quantum mechanics, the concept of probability appeared.
If there is an electron, the probability of the electron being here is 70%.
The probability of being here is 10%.
So from Einstein's point of view,
what kind of probability is that?
Where is the probability?
It can be an illusion without probability.
How does the probability come out physically?
That's how they fought.
God plays the dice.
Einstein, who we see in the movie,
feels like he's already come down from the throne.
Because quantum mechanics and classical mechanics fought.
Einstein is the representative of classical mechanics.
Quantum mechanics is the third leader.
The three of them fight at Solvay.
Quantum mechanics won.
Since then, Einstein has been trying to lay down quantum mechanics.
He keeps saying it's not quantum mechanics.
He couldn't accept it.
It feels like it's made for evil.
Einstein actually didn't accept quantum mechanics to the end.
But in the end, quantum mechanics was established as a school.
Right after the fight.
So Einstein is a little bit of an old man.
Or a fireball that doesn't accept it to the end.
That's what it looks like.
He built a great achievement and changed the flow of business.
After that time, he wasn't a hot topic.
Later, what he said was rude.
He said, it was like that in your time.
There's an artist like that.
In science, Einstein has already become such a person.
That's why he was able to give that advice to Oppenheimer.
Right.
Because he's been through it all.
But the funny thing is,
Einstein is a person who has developed quantum mechanics.
He didn't accept quantum mechanics to the end.
Do you know what Einstein won the Nobel Prize for?
He didn't win the Nobel Prize for Relativity.
Oh, that's not it?
I thought so.
No, he won the Nobel Prize for Radiation.
Radiation?
What is the effect of radiation?
Until then, scientists didn't know exactly what light was.
Whether the light is a wave or a particle.
But Einstein proved that light and light collide and bounce off.
That means the light is a particle.
The light is not a wave.
He won the Nobel Prize for that.
It's a collision of marbles.
Right, right, right.
That's magic.
So Einstein proved that light is a particle and won the Nobel Prize.
That's quantum mechanics.
The light.
It's very contradictory.
It's contradictory.
He went right before the quantum mechanics, but he couldn't get over the threshold.
Right, right.
He won the Nobel Prize for Radiation, but he couldn't accept quantum mechanics.
And then Einstein made a counter-argument to avoid quantum mechanics.
I don't remember exactly who Einstein, Podolsky, and R were.
Three scientists came together and made a counter-argument to avoid quantum mechanics.
It was a paper that quantum mechanics was wrong, but it developed quantum mechanics again.
To refute that, he kept coming up with this logic.
He's going to study it.
He's going to study quantum mechanics.
It's getting deeper.
It's getting better.
Everyone has to have a villain to grow up.
It's a really heartwarming fight.
But it's fun to hear so far.
It's so much fun.
What's interesting here is that the person in the middle is Niels Bohr.
They have a deeper relationship than brothers.
Bromance.
It was bromance.
They study each other a lot, give each other psychological comfort, and fight Einstein together.
It was a very close relationship, but Germany invaded Denmark.
That's right. It's starting now.
Denmark is the hometown of Niels Bohr in the middle.
They invaded Denmark, and Niels Bohr melted the Nobel Prize at the Niels Bohr Institute and hid it.
Did he melt it?
He melted it. Because he got caught.
If there's a Nobel Prize, you know it's Niels Bohr.
Niels Bohr is the third leader, but why would Germany touch him?
Is Niels Bohr a Jew?
He's a Jew.
Whether he's a doctor or not, he's a Jew.
The most important thing about Hitler is the superiority of the German people.
I thought he'd use it if there was something.
Rather, the fact that there is such a person does not prove the superiority of the German people.
That's right.
He must have hated it more.
But in fact, it was one of the most fatal mistakes of Nazi Germany.
Because at that time, all the great talents left for the United States.
Talent leakage.
If you think about it that way, Manhattan Project had no choice but to win in the end.
Oh, that's what he looks like.
Even in the middle, Oppenheimer talks about it.
When Groves came, he said,
Now the United States is playing all the great scientists alone.
You have to collect them.
That's what he says.
So I think you can see that the war has been tilted from here.
Even though there were those great kids in the beginning, they couldn't collect them because of racial discrimination.
They only did it with their kids.
He said he could collect all the scientists in the United States.
Because they did it, it could have been split from the beginning.
But at that time, and in this day and age, Jews are so smart.
At that time, physics, quantum mechanics, and chemistry were all Jewish geniuses.
But no one can use them.
There was a scene where Germany went into Denmark.
So Niels Bohr melts the Nobel medal and hides.
But Heisenberg comes to the hidden place.
At that time, the general manager of the German nuclear weapon development project.
They met and talked.
It hasn't been revealed yet what kind of conversation they had.
I heard this is divided into two.
Yes, it's divided into two.
The first is that Heisenberg recruited Niels Bohr to Hitler.
Let's go to Germany and develop nuclear weapons together.
Let's finish it. We've almost developed it.
There's a story that he said this.
And then Niels Bohr got angry and went over there.
But Heisenberg has something to say about it.
After the war.
In fact, I'm a very important person.
And then Niels Bohr is such an important person.
Nazi Germans were listening.
At that time.
Oh, that's right.
So I'm talking about Nazi Germany.
I had no choice but to secretly steal the information.
I refuted it like this.
But I don't know the truth.
I don't know the truth.
But weren't you both alive after the war?
Oh, that's right.
Did you meet again after the war?
We're not getting along right after that.
So the first one was a post-mortem.
The second one is just before we're done.
Go and help the United States.
There was a story like that.
So there's a story that I'm going to delay the nuclear bomb.
And then there's a funny story about Niels Bohr.
Niels Bohr is the first captain of the Yangtze River after the disintegration.
Nazi Germany and the Allied Forces.
They're both trying to get Niels Bohr first.
But Heisenberg failed at that time.
I was going to take him.
So I sent a soldier from the Allied Forces.
I got on a plane and ran away.
At that time, Niels Bohr got on a weapon compartment.
I got on a weapon compartment and put on a helmet.
The helmet didn't fit.
I had to listen to the pilot, but I couldn't because I didn't have a helmet.
The plane was noisy.
So the pilot told me to wear an oxygen mask, but I didn't.
I don't use it.
The altitude is getting higher and higher.
And then there's not enough oxygen.
So in fact, Niels Bohr was about to die of suffocation.
There's a little bit of that line in the movie.
That's why I'm talking about it.
You're talking like a joke.
It's a sad story because the helmet didn't fit.
If you don't get enough oxygen, your cells will die.
That's right. You have to die to be normal.
He was lucky to live.
In fact, the pilot opened the weapon compartment and saw Niels Bohr lying down.
He thought he was dead.
He couldn't live.
He thought he was dead, but he woke up.
That scene is a short dialogue in the movie.
How hard was it for Niels Bohr?
Let's go back to Germany.
That was November 1942.
Germany ate as much as I did.
You ate a lot.
I ate a lot.
Germany occupied Norway at that time.
There's a water production facility in Norway.
Water is heavier than normal water.
This is a must-have for nuclear weapons.
Germany also occupied Belgium.
There were more than 1,000 tons of uranium mines.
They make nuclear weapons with that.
Austria also occupied.
There were a lot of uranium mines here, too.
There were a lot of resources.
It started in early 1939.
It was an advantageous situation.
The situation so far is what the United States heard through the intelligence.
After hearing the intelligence, the United States started the Manhattan Project.
In 1942.
It was three years later than Germany.
It was very late.
When you watch a movie, everyone tries to squeeze in.
It's three years faster.
After hearing the intelligence, the United States started the Manhattan Project.
You can't just let this go.
You can't do this.
If you make it first, you'll have to pay a lot of money.
How much nuclear weapons did Germany actually develop?
We're going to find out about that.
Germany's technology is the best in the world.
How do you know that?
At that time, there were a lot of new weapons.
The atomic bomb is one of them.
Whether it's fascism, socialism, or communism.
In this kind of ideology, the leader above is always important.
You have to look good to the leader.
The best thing for the leader is to come out quickly.
That's what I think.
Wait a minute. I was down there.
It's not a long-term project.
You need to report the results quickly.
The atomic bomb costs a lot of money.
It's a lot of pressure and a lot of risk.
I think it's going to be a little bit of a report.
It's so accurate.
That's one of the reasons why Germany couldn't make nuclear weapons.
The wire is so wide.
You have to send a bomb right here.
You have to send a tank right here.
You have to send a plane right here.
At that time, scientists said,
I think I can make a nuclear weapon with this.
I don't think so.
I don't think it's possible.
I'll study it first.
It's not like that for everyone.
I think I can do it.
I think it's possible.
It's not very likely.
Give me the research fee.
That's how it feels.
That's why Hitler doesn't pay much for research.
The government doesn't push it much.
It takes a long time to make a nuclear weapon.
Unless I'm making it for fun,
I don't usually make it.
Mr. D.O.B. used to shoot me five times.
Because it's too advantageous.
Because I'm so bad.
So the conclusion is that Germany wasn't in the right mind to do that.
That's right.
It's going to be an irony.
Germany started in 1939.
If you had eaten, you could have conquered the world.
But Germany couldn't work with the famous scientists of the Jewish world.
That's right.
They couldn't use their own resources.
They couldn't fully operate it.
Even though they had so many resources,
Because they wanted to achieve results quickly,
Their original goal was not to develop a new weapon,
If it was a nuclear weapon, they could have done it earlier.
That's right.
With the long concept of developing a new weapon,
It couldn't have been a nuclear bomb.
It didn't fit well.
Heisenberg knew that at the time.
It takes too long to make a nuclear weapon.
It costs too much.
It's not easy.
It's a big project.
That's right.
It's hard for the government to push it.
Speaking of design,
Heisenberg designed a reactor.
The design of the reactor was a mess.
Heisenberg somehow leaked the design.
Did he make it a mess?
He leaked the design and said,
Germany did this much.
Advertisement effect all over the world.
But in other countries,
It was very threatening.
Because it went to the reactor.
If the United States had known the current situation in Germany,
I don't think they would have started the nuclear weapon so quickly.
Because it's a mess.
The nuclear weapon that Heisenberg made
Heisenberg uses neutral water.
There's a scene in the movie.
Niels Bohr speaks in front of the scientists of the Manhattan Project.
Germany is using neutral water now.
At that time, Oppenheimer liked it.
Other scientists said,
Yes!
It's done!
They're stupid to use neutral water.
You shouldn't do that.
That's not how you do it.
The United States used black smoke, not neutral water.
That's right.
They used black smoke.
What is neutral water and black smoke?
It's a material called a reducer.
What is a reducer?
If you hit the neutral,
It splits into two.
There are three neutrals.
Three neutrals pop out.
The speed of the neutral is too fast.
You can't be fast.
If it's fast, it'll pop out and it won't fit.
There's a different speed you want.
You can't hit the uranium.
I hit the billiard ball.
The billiard ball I hit was too strong.
It's flying out.
Then I'll slow it down.
You can hit it at the speed you want.
You need a separate reducer.
It's neutral water or black smoke.
That's right.
The speed of the neutral is too fast.
It's a material that will slow it down.
Wow, that's fun.
If you look inside the neutral water, it's H2O.
H2O is a very light material.
When the neutral hits the H2O,
It's slower because it hits a light material.
But the problem is that it takes a long time to extract H2O.
It's expensive.
So there's that kind of realistic difficulty.
They make nuclear weapons with H2O.
The United States and the United Nations know.
It breaks down the H2O production facility in Norway.
It wasn't even a smart choice.
It even breaks down the neutral water.
Then, from their point of view, the neutral water was hanging.
It takes more time.
That's right.
But they're doing something with black smoke.
What's black smoke?
Black smoke is a pencil.
Oh, you put it in there?
Yes, pencil material.
So Boer told me a lot of important things.
He said he wouldn't participate in person.
Just by sharing this information.
It's amazing.
Germany had technology and resources.
Nuclear bomb technology development money
It wasn't as advanced as I thought.
That's right.
But all of those things are weird.
It's going in a weird direction.
No, why did you suddenly design it?
Is that what Heisenberg intended?
There's a story like that.
Was it this messy?
Yes, it is.
What is this cyclotron?
It's one of the most important equipment for making nuclear weapons.
Like experimental equipment.
It depends on whether you have this equipment or not.
Does this country have the ability to produce nuclear weapons or not?
It's hard to make this equipment itself.
Do you have this equipment or not?
How many inches do you have?
It depends on that.
Germany had only one.
Who makes it?
Experimental physicists.
If you reach a certain level of science, you can design it.
I don't know if it's up to that level.
But that machine can't be mass-produced.
If you look at it from our point of view,
If you have a neat design,
I was curious about that.
Can't the people who eat it make it?
If you have an Apple phone design,
If you have an iPhone design,
I thought I could just make an iPhone.
It's really hard to design.
If you make one, you can make it.
If you make it, you can make it.
Why is there only one?
If you want to design it,
It should be at that level of physics.
If you want to actually design it,
There should be engineering engineering.
Experimental physicists should have the ability to make it.
It's a great machine.
There's a particle.
Put it in.
Put it in here, too.
Turn it around with electricity.
It makes electricity stronger.
It's a machine that makes it hit.
That's why Heechul said,
Hey, how many bullets do you make at that time?
What are you talking about?
Hey, make more tanks.
Hey, make more planes.
It's like Armand N.
Hey, if it's that money, you should ride a Granger.
What kind of Avante?
It's that money.
There's a lot of things going on at that time.
And if you think about it,
In that huge war,
How much is our nuclear weapon?
I don't think it would have been easy
No matter how the national system is operated.
If you think about it, it was Germany and the Allied Forces all over the world.
It's only in Europe.
I've been to a few countries and I've been notified there.
If you look at Starcraft,
We're fighting 5 to 1.
If you ask me to eat ramen, I don't have time to eat ramen.
Give me a hot dog.
It's kind of like this.
While eating a hot dog, I'm talking to my girlfriend.
I'm doing it with one hand.
But it's 5 to 1.
Yes, it's 5 to 1.
But the reason I came to the General Assembly was because
There's a new weapon every morning.
At that time, it didn't even exist.
It's a weapon in your imagination.
It's hard to push it.
It costs a lot of money to push it up.
It's all out now.
I'm busy, busy, busy.
And then we're going to destroy the water supply facilities.
Until everything happens.
In reality, it's a few bullets.
That's really the limit of humans.
I understand.
Anyway, that was the situation.
So, after the war,
The United States and the Allied Forces occupied Germany.
After the occupation,
Germany's nuclear weapon production level
It was too bad.
So, to what extent?
At that time, American scientists said
He said he couldn't even walk.
I started so fast.
To what extent Germany was not serious about nuclear weapons.
It's been a month since we started the nuclear weapon development project.
The scientists who joined the project.
I'm sending them all to the war in Poland.
As expected.
But I understand that.
I understand what we said before.
If you go to war at this time,
Go and shoot a gun.
And then eight months later,
Bring it back and start the research again.
It wasn't that serious.
But Heisenberg is really
I don't know if I didn't develop it.
There's a lot of talk about what I couldn't do.
Because Heisenberg actually went to the barrel.
We can do this.
If we had actively supported it,
Hitler could have pushed it.
At that time, he had a name.
Yes.
But I don't know if it's on purpose.
He made a lot of mistakes.
So, strangely, Heisenberg
There are a lot of things I want to say.
I feel like I'm working inefficiently on purpose.
It's not a black dog on purpose.
He deliberately designed it.
He's got that much intelligence.
Because he's doing this.
He's the one who was most wary of Oppenheimer.
He's been talking to Heisenberg a few times.
In fact, Heisenberg is in his autobiography.
I hit the game board.
There are a lot of things I've written.
In every way, Heisenberg
It was hard to achieve results.
You may not have thought about it.
But you can make something and show it off.
That's right.
I made a tractor.
I made a reactor.
I can do it, but it's broken.
Then, after the war,
How did Heisenberg get disposed of?
I was taken to England.
I was interrogated in England.
I said, I'm going to interrupt you on purpose.
But now, historians have different opinions.
That's right.
Did he actually help you?
Or was he an imposter?
I don't know.
That's why it's fun to talk about it.
The story keeps coming out.
Heisenberg, which we can think of as a scientist at that time.
Heisenberg, the man with the stomach.
He's been doing something inefficient that doesn't suit him.
He's been doing all the stupid things.
So there was no progress.
That's right.
It's so much fun.
How much fun would it be to know?
It's fun every time Heisenberg comes out.
Now I understand.
That's why that scene had to go in.
That's right.
It's an important scene.
It's a big story in science.
That's why they're in there.
I brought a gift.
When you do this, you do this.
In this context, he was the savior.
That's right.
The protection came to our side.
Come to think of it,
History and science history.
I don't think it's any different from Marvel movies.
The more you know, the more you see.
Ordinary people saw the Avengers Endgame right away.
That's how it feels.
It's really fun.
That's a relief.
I can understand everything.
This has been a review.
I'll be back with another movie next time.
I'm going to develop Korean happiness.
That sounds fun, too.
When is that?
Is that only confirmed by the reviewer's video?
That's a video.
It's on the reviewer's channel.
To be exact,
There was no one in charge of the uranium project.
Oh, really?
There was no one in charge.
Heisenberg is just a representative scientist.
It's not on the top of my head.
One of the scientists who makes theoretical physics and nuclear weapons.
He wasn't really serious.
That's what the system was like.
So we each studied separately.
