Hey, do you know Istanbul?
I've heard of the name, but what about it?
Istanbul is the largest city in Turkey, but there is a plan to make it an island.
What? Make it an island?
Was it that easy to make an island?
I don't think it's that easy.
In fact, President Erdogan, who has succeeded in many large-scale infrastructure development, is pushing this plan.
Moreover, the islandization of Istanbul has an impact on world trade, and the United States and Russia are also paying great attention to it.
Are the United States and Russia paying attention? Why are they interested in the islandization of Istanbul?
So this time, I'm going to explain why Turkey is following Istanbul as an island.
Thank you.
Well then, have a good time.
Istanbul was the city of Turkey, wasn't it?
I have a strong image of mosques and palaces.
Istanbul is located in the northwest of Turkey and has a population of about 14 million.
More than half of Turkey's economic activity is in Istanbul, and it is a city larger than Ankara in the capital.
The size of the city is the largest in Europe and the seventh largest in Asia.
What do you mean by Asia in Europe?
Why are you comparing it in two regions?
That's because Istanbul is a city across Europe and Asia.
Istanbul is a city that spans the Bosporus strait and spreads to the east and west.
The eastern side of the strait is the Eurasian continent, and the western side is the European continent.
In other words, the east of the city is Asia, and the west is Europe.
So you have a house in Asia and you might go to a European workplace.
The northern part of the Bosporus strait is the Black Sea, the southern part is the Marmara Sea, and if you go south of the Marmara Sea, you can go from the Aegean Sea to the Mediterranean Sea.
Istanbul connects two continents and connects two seas.
It's the only unique city in the world.
Asia and Europe, the Black Sea and the Mediterranean Sea.
Istanbul is the intersection of these.
So I wonder if it became such a city with so many foreign affairs.
Istanbul is a very important city internationally due to its unique geographical location, especially the Bosporus strait.
One of the reasons for its importance is the Danube River.
Danube River is a river in Europe, isn't it?
It's a beautiful and big river.
The Danube River is the second largest river in Europe and is the key to European water supply.
Through the main cities of Europe, such as Vienna and Budapest in Hungary, the Danube-Main-Rhine Canal was opened in 1992, when it flowed towards the Black Sea.
The Danube River flowed through the Main River and connected to the Rhine River.
The Danube River flowed through the Rhine River and led to the Rotterdam Port, the largest port in Europe.
It's a super-important transportation route for Europe.
A lot of ships that pass through the Danube River come out of the Danube to the Black Sea.
And they go out into the world through the Bosporus strait, that is, Istanbul.
I see, thanks to the Danube River being connected to the Black Sea, a lot of ships from Europe are passing through the Bosporus strait.
Istanbul is very important, isn't it?
It's not just for Europe, it's important for Russia.
Russia wants a port that doesn't freeze for a year, that is, a port that is in contact with the Black Sea, and it has a history of taking some kind of policy.
The ships that come out of the Black Sea from Russia will pass through the Bosporus strait in the same way.
That's why Russia is also interested in the Bosporus strait.
Even Russia?
The Bosporus strait is so important that I feel scared.
The Bosporus strait has three or more times as much traffic as the Suez Strait and four times as much traffic as the Panama Strait.
It's the world's largest international waterway with the most traffic.
But the Turks don't make much profit from the Bosporus strait.
Why are they providing such an important route for free?
The reason is in the treaty that determines the rules of the Bosporus strait.
Time goes back to the end of the Ottoman Empire during World War I.
The Ottoman Empire, which fought as an ally with the German Empire, was defeated in the war and was disbanded.
With the disbandment of the Ottoman Empire, the present Turkish Republic was born.
And in 1923, the Treaty of Lausanne was signed as a treaty of peace.
It's only been 100 years since Turkey was founded.
Turkey is a surprisingly young country.
In the Treaty of Lausanne, the test of the newly formed Turkish Republic was recognized.
The test of Turkey was also recognized in the Bosporus strait.
In addition, it was decided that the Bosporus strait, which would liberate the Bosporus strait from all ships, would be non-armed.
Non-armed? What do you mean?
The winner of the World War I, that is, the United Nations, did not deploy troops to the strait, but the Turks did not deploy troops to the strait.
As a result, any country's warships and merchant ships were able to pass the Bosporus strait freely and for free.
However, in the 1930s, the Italian fascist government became more powerful and strengthened its military strength around the Aegean Sea, the Turkish coast of the Mediterranean Sea.
If the Bosporus strait is non-armed, isn't it dangerous for the Turkish Republic?
The Turks also thought so and consulted to change the terms of the Treaty of Lausanne.
Then, the Montreux Treaty was signed in 1936 to resolve the Treaty of Lausanne.
This Montreux Treaty is still in force.
Does that mean it's still in effect?
What is it about?
First of all, merchant ships can freely enter and exit the Bosporus strait.
This is the same as the Treaty of Lausanne.
However, the Bosporus strait was limited to warships that could operate.
Countries other than the Bosporus strait cannot allow warships over 15,000 tons to pass.
I think some people can imagine warships as big as Mikasa in Japan.
Mikasa is that big ship on display in Yokosuka, isn't it?
In Japan, it is not a country on the coast of the Bosporus strait, so it is not possible to pass Mikasa through the Bosporus strait.
This treaty was convenient for the Turks at the time.
Because the neutrality of the Turks during World War II was almost promised.
There is no country on the coast of the Bosporus strait on the vertical side of World War II.
In other words, for the Bosporus strait, the warships on the vertical side of the Bosporus strait, which were enemies, were able to prevent them from invading the Bosporus strait.
Because the Bosporus strait is all on the side of the allies of the United Nations, it was a neutral treaty that did not apply to any country.
Instead of not being able to get money, it was very useful for defense.
The Montreux Treaty also gave a great favor to countries other than Turkey.
That's Russia, the Soviet Union at the time.
That's where Russia comes in.
It's certainly a very useful treaty for Russian defense.
During World War II, everyone on the coast of the Bosporus strait was in the same camp, so everyone was awarded the Montreux Treaty.
But after World War II, things change when you enter the Cold War.
After the war, the Soviet Union demanded that the Bosporus strait be jointly occupied by Turkey.
It demanded that the Soviet army's fleet be sent to the strait.
For the Soviet Union, the key to the anti-American strategy was the defense through the Bosporus strait.
Even though they had overcome the war twice, the tension in the Bosporus strait increased again.
Turkey said no to these Soviet demands.
The Soviet Union resisted and began active military activities at the Diet.
And for the United States, it was an important task to stop the Soviet Union at the Bosporus strait.
The threat to the United States at the time of the Cold War was the expansion of communism.
If Turkey goes down to the Soviet Union and becomes a communist country,
its influence may reach neighboring European countries and neighboring Middle East and African countries.
For the Soviet Union, Turkey was a gateway to Europe and Africa.
So the United States wanted to increase its influence on Greece, which was in the same position as Turkey,
and announced the Truman Doctrine.
Turkey and Greece received $400 million in economic support.
And in 1952, Turkey decided to join NATO.
NATO was led by the United States.
Turkey has gradually become on the American side.
But when it comes to the Bosporus strait, the United States did not have an advantage.
Why?
If Turkey becomes an ally of the United States and the strait is actually on the American side,
it's like winning.
As I said earlier, the Montreux Treaty restricts ships from countries other than the coast.
In this treaty, there are no restrictions on the types of warships that can pass,
but ships carrying a total of more than 8 inches of cannon are not allowed to pass.
The Turkish government, which has the authority of the strait, prohibits the passage of aircraft carriers.
8 inches is about 20 centimeters.
It's pretty tough that even aircraft carriers can't get through.
The American fleet was also on the list of non-allowed ships to cross the strait.
I see, for the United States, the Soviet fleet can't be too bold, whether it's on the strait or not.
However, the United States also found a way out of the treaty.
In 1960, the United States allowed a cruiser carrying a missile with a diameter of 30 centimeters at the Bosporus strait to pass.
Missile, and a diameter of 30 centimeters, it's not completely out.
The Soviet Union also thought so and protested against Turkey, which allowed cruisers to pass.
But Turkey said there was no problem.
Missiles have been used since World War II, and their history is still shallow.
In other words, the Montreux Treaty, which was signed in 1936, did not assume the existence of missiles.
That's why Turkey said there were no restrictions on the passage of missiles between the Montreux Treaty.
Yeah, that's possible.
By the way, other than the Montreux Treaty, is there no treaty or law that restricts the Bosporus strait?
There is no law, but there is no effect.
In 1994, the United Nations Convention on the Oceanic Law, or UNCROS, was enacted to define the rights and responsibilities of each country in the world's oceans, and the rules for resolving disputes.
In UNCROS, countries that face the strait are not allowed to impose restrictions on ships that cross the strait,
but Turkey says no to this.
Can you say no to the international law? Why?
UNCROS has an exception.
Those who have been allowed to operate for a long time under an international treaty that determines a specific strait are not allowed to cross the strait, but the international treaty is applied.
Turkey has been in effect for a long time under the Montreux Treaty,
so it claims that the Bosporus strait will be applied under the Montreux Treaty, not UNCROS.
I see, it sounds like the strait is clear.
And, in the first place, Turkey does not abide by UNCROS.
What? In the first place? Why don't you abide by it?
UNCROS has regulations on the strait, such as territorial waters.
Turkey, which lost the First World War, gave most of the islands it owned in the Aegean Sea to Greece.
Most of the islands in the Aegean Sea now belong to Greece.
If Turkey abides by UNCROS, it will agree that most of the Aegean Sea belongs to Greece.
Turkey does not abide by UNCROS.
I see.
That's why the Montreux Treaty is still in effect.
However, under the Montreux Treaty, Turkey cannot make a profit from a large number of ships passing through the Bosporus Strait,
and for the United States, it is difficult to use the Montreux Treaty because it wants to prepare the military in the Diet.
So the Istanbul Islands Plan was considered.
In other words, it is a plan to build an artificial strait in Istanbul that allows ships to pass through other than the Bosporus Strait.
When a new strait is built in Istanbul, will it be released from the Montreux Treaty?
The Montreux Treaty is targeted at the Bosporus Strait, and the situation at the time of 1936 is the premise.
If there is no regulation on missiles in the Montreux Treaty, it will be a reason why it will not be applicable to a new strait.
By creating a new strait, there is no restriction on the Montreux Treaty, and there is a route that connects the Mediterranean Sea and the Bosporus Strait.
I think that Turkey can make a profit and pass through the US military.
Not only that, but the Bosporus Strait is already at its limit.
Limit? What do you mean?
There are too many ships passing through the Bosporus Strait.
There are always a lot of traffic jams.
41,000 ships a year, more than 110 ships a day pass through the Bosporus Strait.
They arrive at the strait and line up in the waiting line.
It takes an average of 14 hours to cross the strait from there.
On top of that, the Bosporus Strait is a naturally formed strait, with many steep curves and very fast currents.
It's not suitable as a waterway for a lot of ships to pass through.
If it's a waterway that's hard to get through on a heavy traffic jam, an accident is likely to happen.
There are many ships carrying dangerous goods such as ammunition, oil, and fertilizers on the strait.
On top of that, it's not just the Strait and the Marmara Strait.
14 million people live in Istanbul.
It's also used as a route to cross.
Many ferries carry about 500,000 passengers every day.
If there are a lot of ships on both sides, it's extremely dangerous.
There have been frequent collisions between ships and ships, and there have been major explosions in the past.
In order to protect the safety of the residents, it is necessary to alleviate the congestion of the Bosporus Strait.
Is it an island in Istanbul? I really want it to come true.
The new map is a plan to build it 30 km west of the Bosporus Strait.
The length is expected to be about 45 km, longer than the Bosporus Strait, which is 30 km long.
It's technically feasible.
The new map is expected to allow 260 ships to pass per day.
It's almost the same as the traffic volume of the Bosporus Strait.
I wonder if the congestion will be reduced.
The traffic volume of the Bosporus Strait is expected to reach 86,000 seats by 2070.
That's about twice as much as it is now.
By creating a new map, we aim to respond to the increase in this traffic volume and accelerate international trade.
Wouldn't it be more unreasonable to try to respond with just one Bosporus?
In addition, the new map will be located a little away from the center of Istanbul.
If a ship carrying dangerous cargo passes through the new map, even if a large-scale accident occurs,
it is thought to be less likely to cause damage than to occur at the Bosporus Strait.
There are so many benefits! Let's make Istanbul an island!
In fact, artificial fishing has been out of date since the time of the Ottoman Empire.
The current President Erdogan has been developing infrastructure such as airports, bridges, roads, and tunnels,
and has realized the economic growth of Turkey.
And he's trying to make the new fishing plan, which is like a dream, come true.
For the 100th anniversary of the founding of the Republic of Turkey in 2023, Erdogan announced Vision 2023 in 2011.
Wow, you're in the mood. What was it about?
In Vision 2023, it is said that it will be the 10th largest economy in the world by 2023,
that it will exceed GDP 2 trillion, and that it will exceed 82 million people.
The new map is also one of the projects related to this vision.
The south of the new map is near Ataturk International Airport, and the north is newly opened by Istanbul Airport.
It's going to be an area with a new fishing area.
The island planning of the year is not a good idea.
However, I can't say that, and there are more opposing opinions.
In June 2021, the new map was officially opened,
and the city survey conducted by the Istanbul Economic Research Institute found that it was 58% opposed to 42%.
Why? I think it's a good thing.
In fact, there are many disadvantages in terms of cost, environment, interests, and defense on the island of Istanbul.
What do you mean?
The first disadvantage is that construction costs are too high.
Construction costs are said to range from $ 100 billion to $ 200 billion, which is about 1 trillion yen to 2 trillion yen in Japanese yen.
But that budget is not stated.
It's common in Japan, too. Where does the money come from?
I was hoping for investment from foreign countries, but it's not like support was announced from a specific country.
In addition, it is estimated that if the new map is made, the revenue will increase by $ 8 billion a year in traffic and revenue,
but it is also uncertain whether it will be realized.
Oh, that's not what I'm talking about.
Even if the new map is completed, the situation in which the Bosporus Strait can be used for free will not change.
Which do you use, the toll road or the free road?
In that case, it can be thought of as a situation where the free Bosporus Strait is more popular and the confusion is not resolved,
or the revenue for traffic is not as high as expected.
If there is a difference between the highway and the underpass, many people choose the highway even if it is paid,
and some people take the time to save money.
If there is no difference between the Bosporus Strait and the new map, there is no need to pay money to pass the new map.
Torco also has that concern and wants to make the new map look like a bypass.
The Bosporus Strait exam is in Torco, so it has the right to decide to do a safety test.
The ship passing through the Bosporus Strait has a longer waiting time than the satellite and safety tests,
and the Bosporus Strait is paid, but it is a bypass that can be passed immediately without a test.
By doing this, it means that incentives to pass through the Bosporus Strait are generated and used.
I wonder if it will work that well.
The second disadvantage is the negative impact on the environment.
Forest areas are also included in the route of the Bosporus Strait.
By cutting through the forest, the ecosystem of crops and the negative impact on climate are also worried,
and by increasing the number of points where different water qualities mix in the Bosporus Strait and the Bosporus Strait, it also affects the ecosystem in the water.
That's why WWF, the World Wildlife Fund, is also opposed to the construction of the new map.
Isn't it pretty dangerous to be opposed to WWF?
SDGs are screaming, and the development is not convincing.
The negative impact also affects humans.
The route of the new map includes existing lakes and dams, and it will be destroyed.
In other words, the necessary reservoirs for the citizens of Istanbul have been destroyed, and there is a possibility that they will be affected by serious lack of water.
Wow, that's not good. That's why the public opposes it.
The new map also destroys the route where fresh water is supplied.
The water quality of the Bosporus Strait mixes, and when the salinity of the groundwater rises, it also affects agriculture.
Lack of water and crop damage.
I'm starting to feel like I'm on the other side of the island.
The third reason is the real estate boom.
As I said earlier, there will be more airports around the new map.
Traffic will be better.
In other words, the price of real estate will go up.
In fact, plans such as hospitals, luxury apartments, and marinas are underway.
30% of the land in the new map is private property, but Arab and European investors are paying attention to it.
It's starting to get a little creepy.
It is said that it has land around it, even beyond Qatar, the Turkish Minister of Finance, and Erdogan.
No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
It's impossible to buy a civil ship.
And the most important point is that the military situation in the bloc has changed dramatically.
The Bosporus Strait does not allow the passage of aircraft carriers, and battleships with cannons over 8 inches cannot pass.
However, Turkey is trying not to apply these restrictions to the new map.
NATO and the United States can finally put aircraft carriers and submarines into the bloc.
In that case, Russia won't shut up.
That's right. For Russia, the current situation, bound by the Montreux Treaty, is very convenient.
Their warships are allowed to enter and exit freely, and ships from enemy countries such as the United States can prevent intrusion.
However, if the New England opens and the Turkish governor passes, the Montreux Treaty will be scrapped.
Of course, Russia is already opposed to it.
Even if the New England opens, we are in a position to apply the Montreux Treaty to the New England as well.
Either way, it will increase tension between Turkey and Russia.
So, in Turkey, about 100 people, mainly retired soldiers, have expressed their opposition to the Montreux Treaty.
It's pretty bad for a former soldier to express his opinion.
On the other hand, the Turkish government has imprisoned 10 of these former soldiers.
It means that the resistance has been sealed.
Wow, it's dark. The government really wants to implement the Montreux Treaty.
The plan to create a new England and island Istanbul.
President Erdogan himself has both good and bad points about this crazy project.
However, Erdogan, who has achieved a lot of infrastructure, promises the completion of this project.
It looks like he's pushing it forcibly.
On the contrary, the government and other parties are so serious that they expressly oppose the plan to cancel it as soon as possible.
The island of Istanbul will undoubtedly have an important impact on international trade and geopolitics.
As of 2023, which Erdogan had set as his goal, New England has not been completed.
I don't think it's an exaggeration to say that New England is holding the key to what will happen in the future.
So that's it for today's video.
Thank you for watching until the end.
I'd like you to watch the next video as well.
Thank you for watching.