Pride & Prejudice: Best Actors?

Jane Austen
24 followers
Hello! We are back, finally. I have no excuses.
This is my own Oscars award ceremony for the best actors within the four Pride and Prejudice movies that I compared.
So, we're gonna jump right into it.
Before we get started on the actual awards, since nobody's actually getting awards, we're just gonna do that.
Before I get into it, I have a few honorable mentions.
Barbara Shelley as Mrs. Gardner in the 1980 version.
It's a very small part. It doesn't really typically need recognition, I think, in the grand scope of all of the characters in this.
But, I thought she was really great and I noticed her and not in a bad way.
So, I thought she deserved a little mention.
Good job, Barbara. We're on a first name basis.
Anthony Caff as Colonel Fitzwilliam in the 1995 version.
He also, I thought, was fantastic.
And, honestly, I've had this conversation, like, I'm not gonna say all that right now.
I'm gonna talk about that later.
Anthony Caff and Amelia Fox as Georgiana in the 1995 version.
And, if you are wondering, like, whoa, whoa, whoa, like, Georgiana is, you know, a relatively important character in the story.
Yes, she is.
But, unfortunately, she was not in all four of the films.
So, I don't have her as one of the characters that I am comparing.
Just because I can't compare her in all four films.
I thought Amelia Fox was a fantastic Georgiana Darcy.
She was the right amount of shy.
She was perfect.
On to the actual awards now.
The...
I need to stop doing this because my hands look so big.
Miss Carolina Bingley.
I'm gonna go, I think, kind of, like, in last to first, maybe.
Kelly Riley from the 2005 version.
She did fine.
She was definitely, like, kind of a snotty, spoiled, mean girl type of personality.
But I felt a little pulled out of the period with her.
Where I felt like I was watching almost, like, a more modern day rendition of Pride and Prejudice.
Lady Marcia.
Marcia.
I have no idea how to say that name.
Marcia?
She's known as Marcia.
Like, Marcia.
Fitzgerald.
FitzAlan.
FitzAlan Harold.
FitzAlan Howard.
We're just gonna call her Marcia.
She's from the 1980 version.
She gets third place.
Anna Chancellor from the 1995.
I thought did a good job at being snobbish.
And she cut all those sly little quips with Mr. Darcy and stuff.
I think she just wasn't quite on point for me.
Because sometimes it felt almost a little too over the top with her.
I don't know. Almost a...
A punch.
So, best actress for Miss Carolina Bingley goes to
Frida Innescourt from the 1940 version.
She, to me, was the perfect combination of, like, sophistication and snobbery.
She was very refined.
But she was really good at coming across as just a horrible person, too.
So, Frida Innescourt wins for Miss Carolina Bingley.
For Mr. Charles Bingley,
we have, in the 1940 version, Bruce Lester.
The 1980 version is Osmond Black.
That's not it.
Osmond Bullock for the 1980 version.
Crispin Bonham Carter from the 1995 version.
And Simon Woods from the 2005 version.
Bruce Lester is my least favorite.
He comes across as very good-natured, but he just doesn't leave any sort of memorable mark.
And then after that would have to be Simon Woods.
He is adorable.
But he comes across as just kind of goofy and dumb.
And I feel like that's not...
It's too caricature. Why is he stupid, though?
Like, I don't get why they needed to make him dumb.
Just because he puts a lot of confidence in Mr. Darcy.
He's a different personality, but he's not stupid.
I didn't get that impression from the book.
After that, it would be Osmond Bullock.
I really liked Osmond Bullock.
I thought he was very good-natured.
And he just really came across as a great Mr. Bingley.
But, I mean...
Crispin Bonham Carter is the best.
He's just perfect. He fits that part so well.
I just... He wins.
Lady Catherine Deboer.
We have Edna Mae Oliver from the 2000...
I don't think she was probably alive at that point.
From the 1940 version.
Judy Parfit from the 1980 version.
Barbara Lee Hunt from the 1995 version.
And Judi Dench from the 2005 version.
For me, dead last is Barbara Lee Hunt from the 1995 version.
I know I'm probably going to upset people.
But she, for me, was the worst.
Now, she's definitely in scenes that are so from the book.
And all of that.
But that doesn't have anything to do with her.
Her, as an actress, in this part, did not work at all for me.
She comes across as mousy.
I don't believe that she has authority.
Or that she was raised in refinement.
She doesn't have that grace, elegance, poise, and command to her.
She comes across as somebody that you would be scared to be around.
She's scary, but not intimidating.
She's scary more like she might stab you in the eye kind of scary.
But not like she could really command a room.
I don't ever.
I didn't get that feeling from her.
So, I'm sorry.
She's dead last for me.
And unfortunately.
So, when I found out that Judi Dench was going to be the casting for Lady Catherine Deboer.
I was like, that's the perfect choice.
But, unfortunately, when it came down to it.
In the way it was in the movie.
I just didn't feel it.
And I love Judi Dench.
And I thought if I was the director I would have picked her.
But it just didn't come across right for me.
And I can't quite put my finger on it.
But it just wasn't right.
And then it's down to Judi Parfit.
I thought Judi Parfit was great.
She really played the character well.
I did struggle a little bit with her age.
But, again, I'm like, you know, that probably makes sense.
That she's not as old as she's portrayed in every other version.
Because she's not necessarily that old of a woman.
But, in the end, despite the fact that they took a lot of liberty in remaking her character.
Edna Mae Oliver behaved exactly the way that I pictured her in the book.
Despite the fact that she has a little bit of a change of heart in the movie.
Versus the book.
The way she acts.
The way she carries herself.
The way she talks.
The way she behaves.
Just really, really made me feel like she was the Lady Catherine de Bourgh of the book.
Even though they changed her character some.
I feel like this doesn't go together.
But it's exactly how I feel.
And I can't explain it better.
So, I'm moving on.
Mr. Wickham.
In 1940, it is Edward Ashley Cooper.
In the 1980 version is Peter Settlin.
In the 1995 version, Adrian Lucas.
And the 2005 is Rupert Friend.
Peter Settlin, for me, he came across as roguish and all of that.
But the problem was that he did come across as roguish.
And I feel like Elizabeth is not somebody who would be easily confused.
He needs to be sly.
And that is how he is in the book.
He comes across as a very likable person.
And a trustworthy person.
So, for him to come across so roguish felt to me...
I don't know. It didn't work.
It didn't work. He was too roguish for Wickham.
He needs to be cleverer than that.
In the 1995 version would be my second least favorite.
That is Adrian Lucas.
He also came across as a little too...
Yeah, he just wasn't quite...
He was still a little too roguish for me.
In a visible way.
I didn't see Elizabeth being fooled by him.
I feel like Adrian Lucas should have been switched with Anthony Caff.
Because they both have this similar likable personality to them.
But I found myself drawn in with Anthony Caff very quickly.
Like, oh, I could totally believe this guy.
And I feel like that's the kind of character that you want to cast for Mr. Wickham.
Where you're like, he's really likable. He's a really nice guy.
And that's how you have intelligent women like Elizabeth being blindsided by him partway through the book.
And I felt like they should have switched the casting for those two.
I didn't think he was bad, but I thought that he could have been better.
Rupert Friend is just...
He comes across as very sweet and very dashing.
I could see better how they could kind of be swept up by Rupert Friend.
Which is kind of ironic.
The name is not your friend.
It's not.
Again, and I know you guys know that I like the 1940 version of the movie.
It is largely because of the casting.
So again, Edward Ashley Cooper is the best Mr. Wickham.
He comes across as very good-natured.
And I feel like I could trust this guy.
He seems like a good guy.
I don't know. I really thought he did a great job as Mr. Wickham.
Lydia Bennett.
We have Anne Rutherford from the 1940 version.
Natalie Ogle from the 1980 version.
Julius O'Alha from the 1995 version.
And Jenna Malone from the 2005 version.
Jenna Malone was my least favorite.
She was definitely the immature, giggly, outgoing younger sister.
I don't know, honestly, if it's that I don't like the actress.
Or I don't like...
I don't want to say it that way.
I don't have a problem with her.
I don't know if I just don't like her.
Or if I don't like her in this part.
But whichever it is, I just didn't like her as Lydia Bennett.
And similarly, I felt the same about Julius O'Alha.
I love Julius O'Alha.
I don't want to say this, but I didn't like her as Lydia Bennett.
She is definitely immature.
And she behaves very naively.
And I think a lot of that fits with Lydia Bennett.
Lydia Bennett, she is immature.
She's naive.
She's all of those things.
But I feel like there's a line of believable immaturity
in that particular type of setting and household.
And there is over the top.
And I feel like she was over the top as well.
And I think, honestly, what it is, is it's not how loud she was.
It's not how giggly she was.
It is the fact that she doesn't carry herself gracefully.
And I feel like that's a weird thing to say.
But neither Julius O'Alha nor Jenna Malone,
either one of them convinced me that they were in any way raised in such a circle
that they might have learned how to walk properly
or carry themselves in a graceful way.
There's no attention to any of that.
And I feel like that they would pay attention to that.
I feel like Lydia would be aware of how she's holding herself
and all of those things because she's trying to attract men.
And instead, she just seems not only immature
as far as her wisdom and decision-making goes,
but she's also immature in the sense that she doesn't seem to know
how to be in any way womanly.
I don't know.
Maybe that's the direction it's supposed to go, though.
But for me, that just was a problem.
Natalie Ogle.
I could not stand her.
Which is to say she played the part very, very well.
She was all of the things that Lydia is and we wish she wasn't.
I think she did a fantastic job as Lydia.
She just barely loses to Anne Rutherford
because Anne Rutherford is all of those things as well.
She is immature. She is loud.
She is very, very unwise in the way that she behaves.
But she does it all within the context of coming across
as a silly, immature, middle-upper-class woman.
And so while the others, I'm like,
I just don't believe that they are a Bennett.
They don't fit.
You can be poised, and you can be graceful,
and still be ridiculous.
And Anne Rutherford was the only one that showed you
how that was possible.
Kitty Bennett.
We have Heather Angel from the 1940 version,
Claire Higgins from the 1980 version,
Polly Maberly from the 1995 version,
and Carrie Mulligan from the 2005 version.
I think Carrie Mulligan and Jenna Malone,
I'm just going to say this,
I have always gotten them confused as actresses anyway.
And when they, I don't know why,
because they don't really look the same.
But for some reason, I think they behave similarly
or something like that.
And I always get them confused.
And when I saw that they were casting them together
as Kitty and Lydia, I was like,
that makes so much sense.
They already seem like sisters to me.
So I thought they worked really well together.
I'm saying that kind of out of order
because I thought Carrie Mulligan
was actually a very good Kitty.
She communicates that she's more of the follower,
but she gets caught up in all of the silliness with Lydia.
And I thought she did a really great job.
She actually is my runner up.
Claire Higgins from the 1980 version.
No, I'm sorry.
I just couldn't believe her.
She just, no, no.
However, because this is a trait of Kitty in the book,
I just have to say she is very good at coughing.
In third place would be Polly Maberly.
She did fine.
She just fell into the shadows a little too much for me.
She didn't stand out.
And she is the follower.
She is the sidekick,
but she was almost unimportant completely for me.
That leaves Heather Angel.
Again, 1940.
I thought she paired really well.
Similarly, like with Jenna and Carrie,
they paired really well together.
And I thought that Heather and Anne
also really convincing as this pair of sisters
that were really close.
She just did fantastic in that job,
being a really good sidekick as well.
Next up, Mary Bennett.
Mary Bennett, 1940 would be Marcia Hunt.
1980, Tessa Peak Jones.
1995, Lucy Briars.
And 2005, Tallulah Riley.
Tallulah Riley is in fourth place.
She was very shy,
which I thought was maybe too extreme.
Because in the book, she likes to perform.
She wants to perform in front of people.
And I thought it just didn't really work.
She was a little too shy.
In third would be Marcia Hunt.
I do think that they did a good job casting Mary Hunt
in the 1940 version.
She looked like she belonged with the other sisters.
She was still very pretty.
She just was more bookish.
However, I do think that they have a good point
in stepping away from that,
where she's not going to have spent as much time
on her hair or her clothes.
Those are not her priorities.
Anyway, I thought Marcia Hunt was good.
She just wasn't my favorite.
In second place is Lucy Briars.
I thought she was great.
She did scare me when she made a rush for the piano
at that one time.
But yeah, I thought she did great.
But my absolute favorite is Tessa Peak Jones.
In fact, I feel like she's kind of underrated in this.
But Tessa Peak Jones from the 1980 version,
I feel like she was the perfect balance
of all of the different facets of Mary.
And I love that she had her little quips
just thrown in here and there throughout.
It was very, very Mary.
Next up is Jane Bennett.
In the 1940 version, we have Marino Sullivan.
And 1980 is Sabrina Franklin.
1995 is Susanna Harker.
And the 2005 is Rosamund Pike.
So Sabrina Franklin is my least favorite.
She gets giggly and kind of silly in parts.
It does not look like the Jane of the book,
who is the least likely to make mistakes
or act improperly.
So Marino Sullivan is gorgeous.
And I don't blame Mr. Bingley at all
for falling in love with her.
She also comes across as sweet.
I feel like she just doesn't quite have
as many opportunities to show her personality
the same way as they have been able to
in the other ones.
Rosamund Pike is fantastic for this part.
I really love her.
She definitely comes across as very genteel
and very kind.
I think she definitely holds sway
over Susanna Harker when it comes to beauty.
I think Susanna Harker has more of the classic
like Greco...
Is that right? Greco-Europe?
I feel like she looks kind of like a Grecian sculpture.
Oh!
I have a really hard time with this one
because I think they both played the part
really, really well.
But I feel like Susanna Harker
had just a little bit better.
She also had more opportunity to play
the wise, careful, kind.
She played the part a little bit better
maybe just because she had more screen time.
But I'm going to give the award to Susanna Harker.
I really did love Rosamund Pike too.
Mr. Bennett.
I'm skipping Elizabeth.
She's going to be later.
So, Mr. Bennett.
Oh, I love Mr. Bennett.
And I don't like Mr. Bennett
because he's like a really endearing little old man
but also he's not really a great father.
But we're going to not talk too much
about my own feelings about Mr. Bennett.
And we're going to talk about who played him.
Edmund Gwynn from the 1940 version.
Moray Watson from the 1980.
Benjamin Wittrow from the 1995.
And Donald Sutherland from the 2005.
Moray Watson.
I thought he at times was great
but there were lots of times where I felt like
he was just reciting his lines.
I didn't feel like he knew what he was saying
or he wasn't really connecting with what he was saying
a lot of times.
So, he is in fourth place for me.
Donald Sutherland is number three.
I really, really liked him as Mr. Bennett
in so many ways.
And if he was not put up against
such amazing other Mr. Bennetts
he would definitely be a really good contender
because I loved him as Mr. Bennett
but I didn't love him as much as I loved the other ones.
That brings me to Edmund Gwynn.
I love him as Mr. Bennett.
He is so endearing.
I love his little side glances,
the little humor and twinkle in his eyes
when he says little things to Mrs. Bennett.
And he is so good in this part.
You can definitely feel this sense that
he loves to be alone in his study
and he is entertained by the ridiculousness of his family.
You get all of it.
However, Benjamin Wittrow.
Oh, he was just everything
and it pains me to not give it to Edmund Gwynn
because I love him so much
but Benjamin Wittrow is definitely number one
for Mr. Bennett.
He was really good.
I'm going to move on.
Mrs. Bennett.
Also not a great example of motherhood ideals
but she was a mother.
In the running we have Mary Boland from the 1940 version,
Priscilla Morgan from the 1980 version,
Alison Stedman from the 1995 version,
and Brenda Bleflin from the 2005 version.
Priscilla Morgan from the 1980 version was my least favorite.
At no point did I feel like Mr. Bennett
could have been so overcome by her beauty
that he was able to overlook the fact that
she was not going to be an intellectual companion
that he could communicate with.
In third place was Brenda Bleflin.
Kind of the same story.
Alison Stedman from the 1995 version
came in second.
Runner-up.
Again, I thought she played the part well.
There was someone better.
It was Mary Boland.
Mary Boland definitely had that look of a person
that I could see her as a younger, bubbly person
that Mr. Bennett could have gotten caught up
and been like, she's fun.
I like her.
Even though when the honeymoon's worn off
he realizes I can't have a conversation with this woman.
Mr. Collins.
Melville Cooper is the 1940 version.
Malcolm Rennie is the 1980 version.
David Bamber, the 1995.
And Tom Hollander, the 2005.
In dead last, I'm sorry,
is Tom Hollander from the 2005.
He doesn't fit the description at all.
And I know that sometimes you can overlook that.
But Mr. Collins is supposed to be tall.
And instead they went completely opposite
where they're like, not only is he not tall,
but he's kind of laughably short.
And they used that as comic relief throughout the movie.
And I'm like, it doesn't even make sense.
That's not a character trait of Mr. Collins.
I thought he did great with what he was given,
but I thought he was the wrong casting for the part.
Following on his tale as David Bamber, he was fine.
He, I think, was maybe a little too sharp.
And I mean, he understood more than he should have,
I feel like, in the proposal with Elizabeth in particular.
I felt like he caught on too quickly to what she was saying
and that he was actually kind of angry about it in the proposal.
He was a little too intelligent, I think, for Mr. Collins.
Melvin Cooper, oh my goodness.
He was all of those things that I pictured
when I read the proposal scene.
He, like the way he like walks down the stairs
and he like taps the vase and then he's like, ooh.
And then he just seems really, really good natured
in kind of a cute puppy dog kind of dumb way.
And also just very over the top to please and ridiculous.
He was great. I loved him.
He acted out all of the scenes the way that I would have anticipated.
I love him like running to the carriage
when Lady Catherine de Bourgh comes and stops by his house
and he's like shooing the chickens and then like he's just
ready to do whatever he needs to do to please her.
I thought he was fantastic.
And then we also have Malcolm Rennie
who is also fantastic in that part.
Like so good.
And they both fit the description.
They both work well for what I envisioned in my head.
And I, for the life of me, cannot choose.
So I have to actually give it to both of them.
And so there you have it.
Next up, since we just talked about Mr. Collins,
let's talk about his wife.
Charlotte Lucas Collins.
Karen Morley is the 1940 version.
Irene Richard, 1980.
Lucy Scott, 1995.
And Claudie Blakely, 2005.
Karen Morley, like she did a great job with the part.
She had this subtle like Mr. Collins,
like kind of like calming him down when he's being over the top crazy.
Unfortunately, she is not a believable spinster in the making.
There has to be a man willing to marry her
that's not Mr. Collins.
So I think that unfortunately like her beauty
is a little too much to be believable
for a desperate, older, single married,
single woman, single married woman.
All the single married women.
Lucy Scott from the 1995 is in third.
She was a good casting. I don't have a problem with her.
But I had better options.
Claudie Blakely from the 2005.
I know this is another book,
but the part where Lizzie's in the swing
and she's spinning around and Charlotte comes up to tell her
that she is going to marry Mr. Collins
and she has that whole scene and she's like,
don't judge me, it is such a powerful scene
and I really loved it.
It's not in the book, but I really loved it.
And I think that she did a great job at the part.
She came across as communicating all of the fears
and drive that someone in her situation would feel
and I really believed her.
I thought she did a great job.
My favorite was Irene Richard from the 1980 version.
She is intelligent, she's cunning, she's pragmatic
and she is Charlotte.
We're at the end stretch here, Mr. Darcy.
Now, before I tell you who wins,
I want to say this quick little thing.
Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
These are all my opinions on who did it best
and you can disagree with me and that is fine.
It doesn't say anything about me or you
that we have different opinions.
It's just an opinion.
So, don't feel personally affronted
if my opinion is different than yours.
So, in the running we have Laurence Olivier, 1940,
David Rintoul from the 1980,
Colin Firth, 1995,
and Matthew McFadden, McFadden, McFadden, McFadden.
I have no idea if I'm saying that right
because every time I try to find how you say it,
I hear it differently.
Also in the comments you can tell me if you know.
Okay, so Matthew McFadden from the 2005.
For me personally, Matthew McFadden is the last place.
I just didn't really like that they made him
socially awkward and shy.
I think it makes sense that somebody in that position,
he's totally capable and it's very possible
that he is an introvert.
But when you are raised with a family
where you are told you are the next head honcho
in this family,
and he would have been taught how to command,
how to run an estate.
He would have been taught how to carry himself
and how to behave with a sense of command.
And yeah, maybe arrogant,
but the way they portrayed him,
it wasn't that he was arrogant,
it was that he's just really, really socially awkward.
I just don't believe it.
How would he be able to have tenants
and how would he be able to make decisions
about stuff with authority
if he struggles to communicate?
It's just not how I pictured Mr. Darcy.
But it is a new take on him.
In third place would be David Rintoul.
He definitely had these moments where I was like,
oh, that was good.
Good job.
But he didn't create Mr. Darcy on the screen.
Really, really, really close runner up.
And this is the part I'm pretty sure
I'm gonna get a lot of hate mail.
Close runner up for me is Colin Firth.
I know, I know, I know.
He's great.
He's great at the part,
but he was not quite,
quite as good as Laurence Olivier,
who just totally convinced me that he was Mr. Darcy.
So I'm sorry.
Don't be mad at me and don't act like I'm an idiot.
I have my own opinions.
And I loved Laurence Olivier as Mr. Darcy.
He personified him so much that I can't,
I can't picture him any other way.
And I feel good about my decision,
but he doesn't get an actual award from me.
It wouldn't matter anyway because he's no longer alive.
But it doesn't really change anything
in the grand scheme of things.
So if you have posters of Colin Firth as Mr. Darcy
all over your walls, you keep it up.
You're entitled to your Mr. Darcy, however he is.
Final, final award goes out to the best,
Miss Elizabeth Bennett.
We've got Greer Garson from the 1940 version,
Elizabeth Garvey from the 1980 version,
Jennifer Ely from the 1995 version,
and Kiera Knightley from the 2005 version.
Elizabeth Garvey is number four for me.
I didn't ever get it with her,
but her name is Elizabeth.
So maybe it was meant to be.
But she's not Elizabeth.
She's a different Elizabeth, not a Bennett.
Second to last, we would have Kiera Knightley.
I was so distracted by her giggling all the time.
And in second place is Greer Garson.
I thought she was actually really great for this part.
She's great at being both graceful and mature
and all of those things.
But I really, really, really love her as Elizabeth.
I really do. I love Elizabeth.
I mean, I love, maybe she's Elizabeth.
I love Greer Garson as Elizabeth a lot.
So she is a close second.
But Elizabeth Ely created the character on film for me again.
When you have somebody that personifies it so well
that you just picture them at this point as the character,
they've nailed it.
And I wasn't convinced by...
Did I say Elizabeth Ely?
I might have said Elizabeth Ely.
I wasn't convinced by Jennifer Ely immediately.
It was through the whole thing,
she just more and more and more
was absolutely the Elizabeth that I pictured in the book.
Yeah, apparently she became Elizabeth.
Elizabeth Garvey was born Elizabeth Garvey,
but Jennifer Ely became Elizabeth Ely Bennett.
Okay.
I just can't talk is really the reason I said that.
So words are hard.
Jennifer Ely.
You win!
Best Elizabeth Bennett.
Congratulations! Yay!
Okay.
That's the end of it for this video.
Those are all of the characters.
And again, I didn't do some of the characters
because they weren't in all four movies.
And if they're not, then I can't really compare them.
That's the point of the honorable mentions at the beginning kind of.
Plus they just deserved it.
Anyway, I hope you stick around for another video.
I am trying to kind of redo or re-identify
what I want to do with this channel.
And that's why I've been a little M.I.A.
But I would love for any feedback.
I hope you have a great week, month, year,
whatever it is when you watch this.
And I will talk to you later.
Pride and Prejudice, the movies.
I need to stop doing this because my hands look so big.
