This video asks and answers the following question. What if a modern main battle tank, a French Leclerc tank, went back through time to 1815 and helped Napoleon at the Battle of Waterloo? How would the course of that battle go? And would the French be victorious in this alternate timeline?
If you want to watch our videos without ads, if you want quick replies to any questions you might have, if you want early access scripts and videos, monthly release schedules - become our Patron. More here: https://www.patreon.com/Binkov
early 19th century Battle of waterl is
one of the most famous battles in
history there Napoleon suffered his
final defeat losing to the force made of
British Dutch Prussian and other allies
troops almost 200,000 Souls fought over
a course of one day on a tiny
Battlefield just miles across that event
possibly changed the course of history
for Europe but imagine this a lone
modern main battle tank travels from the
future and appears in Napoleon's camp on
the morning of the battle how would such
a piece of technology change the course
of the battle and using the tank would
Napoleon's Army have crushed the British
the prussians and their
[Music]
allies the main battle tank traveling
from the future into the year 1815 could
of course have been any of the
modern-day tanks pretty much any of
these would yield similar results for
example us Abrams German Leo 2 British
Challenger 2 French lir or even the
latest variants of Russian and Chinese
tanks just to name a few but to keep to
the spirit of the whole battle we'll
stick with the French made laclair it's
a tank devised in the 1980s and first
delivered in 1992 it's got modern
modular armor that's way way of an
overkill for 1815 essentially
impenetrable it's got a three member
crew Commander Gunner and a driver it
uses an auto loader and has 120 mm gun
its latest version delivered to the
French army is called the Clair XLR
after a prototype was tested in 2022 two
serial tanks were delivered this past
June with 16 more to follow by the end
of the year so let's imagine one of
those brand new XLR tanks got whisked
away with a trained crew and possibly
with some support as well into 1815 now
exactly when the tank arrives could
change a lot arriving days earlier it
could possibly influence Russian and
British Maneuvers before the Battle of
waterl famously Napoleon wanted to fight
one side first then the other instead of
letting prussians and Anglo Allied
armies combine he knew his troops were
more experienced and that way in two
sequential battles he actually might
have stood a chance but the smaller
battles prior to the Battle of waterl
did not produce the desired results and
he didn't weaken enough either
Wellington and his allies or de
prussians the decisive battle of waterl
had Napoleon Under Pressure he had to
attack Wellington and his forces before
prussians came to help him but that
attack had to be postponed by several
hours due to rain rain could not be
foreseen on the Fateful night of June
17th and the morning of June 18th a lot
of rain fell onto the soft soil around
the village of Waterloo itself just
miles away from Brussels Napoleon thus
had to wait even though he already had
breakfast at 7:00 a.m. the attack itself
started only after the soil was dry
enough so a few hundred cannons could be
dragged around and thousands of Cavalry
men could successfully maneuver so in
the real timeline that was around 11:00
a.m. possibly a bit later ultimately
Napoleon lost that battle after a few
failed charges against Wellington's
defending forces the French were already
weary and then the prussians came and
flanked them in an attack of course
right at the start the arrival of the
modern tank from the future would start
to change that entire course of events
now as always with these time travel
videos a lot of things have to be
ignored otherwise it wouldn't be
possible to explore the technical
effects of such a force Edition for
example if no one knew anything about
the tank and Napoleon would not trust
the tank crew then the tank would not
get used at all the opposing side would
plausibly just run away in fear seeing
such a Contraption shooting away their
mates that's not what we want to explore
we want to see how an early 19th century
force would do against the lone tank if
fighting to the best of their ability
and not running away so what's needed is
that both the French and their opponents
get worried about the incoming tank they
all get a vague idea of what a tank is
and what it can do anyway cutting his
breakfast short Napoleon inspects the
tank and its crew which traveled through
time as well magically trusting them and
ially soaking up the knowledge how to
utilize them so then the crew gets to go
ahead to participate in the battle
following instructions still all that
takes some time so it's likely the tank
itself doesn't start its Mission before
9:00 a.m. or so that's a few hours
earlier than the real timeline French
Force started its attack the tank comes
with all the equipment inside it of
course which means some personal
portable radios are also available to
the Tank's crew members so it's likely
one would be issued to the French
command so it can talk to the tank such
handheld radios do have range issues but
the whole Battlefield in waterl was
roughly 4x4 km the tank would often get
outside of radio range if it would go
around Anglo Allied flanks but it would
periodically get back into range to
report and get new orders that's still
much faster than issuing Messengers on
Horseback but let's get back to the Rain
soaked soil as we said Napoleon
postponed his real timeline attack due
to that the tank however would have no
such limitation tanks are sometimes
labeled as prone to getting stuck in mud
sure it can happen in heavy mud but the
situation wasn't that dire already from
11:00 a.m. when the real timeline attack
started guns could be moved around
Napoleon's guns from that era the 12
Pounders weighed little under two tons
complete with a barrel carriage and
limber cart sizing up the wheels and the
gun carriage and limber card one gets
roughly 980 kilopascals of ground
pressure or roughly 140 PSI each of the
four wheels would hold a fourth of that
pressure but the tank using its wide and
long tracks exerts much much less
pressure onto the ground specifically
the Clair tank exerts little under 13
PSI or some 88 kilopascals so we're
talking about 10 times smaller ground
pressure with much smaller likelihood
that one wheel will find an unlucky mud
pool and lose traction the artillery
wasn't the only issue Napoleon feared
for his Cavalry too an average horse
with a soldier weighing over 600 kilos
exerts a ground pressure of close to 30
PSI or 200 kilopascals that's more than
the tank even when the horse is standing
on all four legs in the real timeline
horse charges were done at slower speeds
than otherwise possible precisely due to
the mud in theory nighttime operations
would bring a huge advantage to the tank
in 1815 battles were not fought at night
it was impossible to coordinate
formations in the dark to search for
targets and so on but a modern tank like
lir has thermal sites which can
basically detect a humanized shape from
a few kilometers away at night and
through smoke but as we said the tank
arrives only after Napoleon wakes up
morning of June 18th still those
powerful Optics with great magnification
would help during day as well the tank
would first flank and observe the Anglo
Allied positions getting a different and
better view plausibly even going around
the opponent's compound there the first
opportunity to truly change history
would arise to try and spot important
nodes in the Anglo Allied Forces the
headquarters perhaps even spot
Wellington himself and tried to attack
him a modern tank can easily land a
precise shot from 2 to 3 km away
basically from so far away that the
Anglo allies could not even spot the
threat that being known we also said
such surprise ruins the scenario so the
Anglo Allied commanders would try to
hide from the start of the morning they
would likely dispatch more Scouts around
their camp at greater distances to try
to warn of incoming contration of Doom
from the future here we come to the
issue of ammo stocks of the laclair tank
itself was the tank prepared for its
time travel Mission if so it could have
been stocked out with a bunch of extra
rounds and ammo better radios and other
equipment but if it wasn't the usual
load out of ammo alair tank would carry
is this 40 120 mm rounds for its main
gun 22 of which would come within the
autoloaders hold and 18 more inside the
tank to be loaded Into the autoloader
Now the exact composition of the rounds
carried greatly depends on the missions
for example in 1991 Iraq the US expected
to fight against against armor only so
They Carried hardly any high explosive
rounds during the Cold War soet tank
users expected a wider range of missions
for their tanks so half of their total
ammo load was high explosive rounds with
most of the remaining half being
anti-tank heavy metal Dart ammunition
there is simply no one true answer so
we'll model it to be somewhere in
between with 15 out of 40 rounds carried
being high explosive ones five being
heat rounds which has strong anti-tank
capabilities but also does detonate into
a smaller Fireball upon impact 15 being
armor piercing fin stabilized arrows
which contain no explosive filler and
the generous five remaining rounds would
be shells intended for close defense
each holding 1,00 metal balls basically
a shotgun type shell those are
devastating against on Armored targets
but their effective range is maybe 500
yard that's not a lot of main gun ammo
knowing the lir tank is trying to
a massive Army formation
Wellington had roughly 67,000 men under
his command luckily for the French
theair as any other tank also has
machine guns peculiarly While most tanks
have a 7.62 mm coaxil machine gun lir
has a 12.7 MM one meaning a 50 cal Gan
it comes with 140 rounds ready to fire
plus another 6 60 stored inside the tank
available for reloads the good thing
about that gun is that it's coax sealed
to the main gun meaning it gets to use
the powerful main gun sites plus the 50
cal itself is a powerful round and it
can achieve very good Precision from
such a stable firing platform using it
the Gunner would likely be able to pull
off pinpoint Precision hits from a mile
away using almost individual shots
rather than bursts that would be ideal
for engaging the Anglo Allied artillery
actually it's a heavy and static Target
but the single well-placed shot in the
middle of its wooden wheel would likely
result in the wheel bursting apart and
the whole Barrel falling on the ground
with so many guns being engaged
sequentially the Anglo allies would not
be able to replace the wheels on most of
them so the tank would effectively be
putting most of the Anglo allite guns
out of action for the remainder of the
battle while keeping the barrels intact
so the French could seize the artillery
pieces later on all that might happen
over a course of half an hour the Ang
allies would of course react straight
away some of the guns would probably
even be turned to protect the rear and
the flanks knowing the tank might be
somewhere near but those guns would
essentially be useless against the
modern tank it's not even about armor it
would be about range in theory British
guns could even fire at a range of 3 km
but that was indirect imprecise fire
what was much much more practiced was
fire from 600 to 800 M away even then
such distance was usually too big to
make fire on enemy artillery pieces
worthwhile larger Target sets were
preferred so what would happen is that
of course the Ang allies would try to
fire back from a mile away there might
be some small chance to hit the tank but
it would likely take dozens of shots to
achieve a hit even with a stationary
tank the tank would be relocating every
once in a while to mess with the Anglo
allies aim forcing them to reset the
aiming procedure the tank could even try
to fire wall on the Move using its gun
stabilizer though that might result in
some shots missing which in this
specific situation with tons of targets
and limited ammo supply might not be
worth the extra benefit of presenting a
moving Target which would likely be
impossible to be hit for 19th century
guns from such distances their
cannonballs have a Cape that's not
ideal for punching through armor cast
iron is brittle and would fall apart
when it hits muzzle velocity is much
lower there's basically no part of
lair's Hall which would be vulnerable
nothing serious would happen if the tank
got hit pretty much anywhere from a mile
or more away even if it managed to get
hit in its metal tracks those would
likely hold the only real issue might be
if an extremely lucky shot managed to
hit straight into the armored glass of
the Gunner sight
the glass itself is armored and might
hold but it would likely shatter making
further aiming harder still there's the
Commander's independent site to help out
so it's extremely unlikely the tanks
sites could be completely blinded after
half an hour or so of fire most of the
British guns would be neutralized from
afar realistically some of the Anglo
allite soldiers would be so scared that
they would simply start to flee but
assuming the morale somehow holds that
the prior warnings of about the tank did
their magic the Anglo Ali troops would
lie down hide disperse as much as they
can but not too much as there's the
whole French army waiting to attack them
from the opposing side now that Napoleon
has the tank Edge he would likely even
start his attack earlier probably
waiting for the tank to return to a
communication range and get a report in
the real timeline despite Napoleon's
early scouting a lot of Anglo Ali troops
were hidden to him behind the ridge
alongside the Road and Napoleon did not
know where exactly each enemy unit was
stationed tanks report would help him
create a more accurate map of enemy
positions while Napoleon's main attack
in the real timeline was a large
infantry push in the center and to the
Eastern end of the Anglo Allied line
there were also skirmishes to the West
for the Hugon Manor a wall complex of
buildings which the British had secured
for hours in the real timeline that
place was important as the French
inability to take it for hours
potentially caus it a favorable position
to threaten the Anglo Allied force and
forcing Wellington to distribute its
reserves to the West weakening the rest
of his line but in this new timeline the
tank could participate there it could
use its high explosive rounds to shatter
parts of the wall much more effectively
than cannonballs of the time period
could and to even shatter the buildings
inside it could afford to actually drive
into the compound as there would be
little threat to the tank with most
British guns neutralized and ones that
may be remained being tied up defending
the central line the tank would likely
again resort to its coaxial machine gun
for that mission but this time joined by
its roof mounted machine gun as well the
XLR variant of the laclair has a remote
controlled 7.62 mm machine gun which
rotates independently and can be used by
the commander so the tank would storm
the compound with two machine guns
blazing Ing and likely scared the
Defenders behind the tank and partially
protected by It the French infantry
could also pour in adding Firepower
instead of hours of battle Hugon would
likely Fall within half an hour possibly
by 11:00 a.m. or so it's not known yet
how many 7.62 mm rounds does the XLR L
Clair hold but the previous generation
French tank held some 2,000 such caliber
rounds for its roof mounted gun
it's however possible that if the Anglo
Allied troops are trained enough to deal
with the tank they might try to shoot at
its sights from such closer quarter
distances a musket ball is still
powerful enough that if it manages to
get a lucky hit into the Optics of the
remote weapon module it could leave a
crack on the glass multiple lucky hits
might even be able to bend some parts
enough so that the machine gun becomes
unusable of course one can imagine just
how much luck that would require as a
side note previous variants of French
army lur do not have a remotely operated
roof mounted machine gun actually a good
deal of modern tanks in general still
don't use those most of the US Army
abrames and European Leo 2s don't have
them yet now Aur with a human Manning
the machine gun sticking out of the
turret would be in a tight spot the gun
is positioned over the Gunner's hatch so
it's the Gunner who would have to use it
but the Gunner is far too important to
be risked like that no 19th century
Soldier could replace his knowledge and
experience with tens of thousands of
enemy muskets in range at any given time
whoever would be operating that machine
gun would inevitably get shot eventually
one option might be to pick some 1815
troops to operate the gun sort of as a
fourth member of the crew that person
would be a worse Gunner hitting less
often and wasting more ammo but it would
be better better than not using 2,000
machine gun rounds at all as those
represent 70% of all the rounds carried
without relying on those the Tank's
impact on the battlefield would be
noticeably smaller but the machine
gunner would basically sit on the
Gunner's shoulders and the Gunner would
not be able to focus properly on using
his sights the main gun or the coaxil
machine gun perhaps a better option
would be not to use the roof mounted gun
until the coaxial machine gun would be
out to Amo having a manually operated
roof mounted machine gun would be less
effective for France though it wouldn't
change the ultimate outcome by noon many
French artillery pieces would be placed
at hug threatening the entire Anglo
Allied line and the main thrust and Main
artillery bombardment would happen as in
the real timeline limited by ground
needing to dry sufficiently so around
noon or so some 80 French guns opened
fire on Wellington's troops in the the
center around 1:00 p.m. the Infantry
attack started in this timeline with no
serious threat from British guns
infantry might charge even a bit earlier
that charge would be held by the tank
even that way the machine guns would do
a lot of damage though the tank would
likely have to start conserving its ammo
especially the ammo for its coaxil and
Main gun in the real timeline the
British sent its Cavalry to meet and
push back the French infantry here the
tank would likely also shine horses make
much bigger targets plus they are easier
to scare by the tank producing fairly
loud noises machine guns would still
have to shoot almost individual round
bursts but they would be hitting dozens
of horses per minute from Fairly far
away not like the French infantry which
was in reality terrified of a charging
Cavalry force and could not even aim
properly when in fear it's very
questionable if the British cavalry
charge would work as well well as it did
in the real timeline it could totally
break apart or diminish not really
pushing the French back the French own
Cavalry attack followed in the real
timeline and that would happen here too
with greater success as many of the
Anglo Allied Forces on the Eastern flank
would be beaten by that point the French
would have likely established themselves
on the ridge pushing British positions a
bit behind little after 1: p.m. at the
start of that infantry charge the French
Scouts spotted the Prussian infantry
forces closing in some 4 to 5 miles away
that meant they had another three hours
to March to the battlefield and help
Wellington in the real timeline another
big French attack happened at 400 p.m.
after the first one failed this time
somewhere between the center and the
Western flank but with the Hugon
compound taken much earlier the French
Commander nay would have positioned his
forces closer to dangle allies hours
earlier as well and he would plausibly
attack them earlier possibly after 2:
p.m. by then the French tank could have
shifted back a little towards the French
taking a brief rest before going back in
to help nay's attack such an attack
would also complicate the issues for the
Wellington's men on the eastern half of
the line as they would get less support
from the neighboring units the French
attack to the West Was spearheaded by
Cavalry formations which were in the
real timeline met with prepared squid
formations where the Infantry was
waiting for the horses with very
concentrated musket fire and bayonets
that was possible because in the real
timeline there was no artillery support
but in this timeline more French guns
would be brought closer to the front
firing on the Anglo allies plus the tank
would be there a single shot with its
canister round into one such Square
could neutralize dozens of troops at
once and likely send hundreds into Panic
similar effects could be had with a high
explosive shell in the end the tank
charging alongside the Cavalry would
bring extra Panic to the British in
itself not so well prepared to meet the
French Cavalry it's likely the British
infantry would be seriously affected
especially if the tank would actively
try to overrun large Anglo Allied
infantry groups a company of musketmen
when dispersed by a tank wanting to run
them over would drastically lose its
Effectiveness and the French Cavalry
that would follow the tank would then
likely pick up those dispersed and
panicked enemy troops the result would
likely be a route in the Anglo Allied
lines on that side of the battlefield
but as we know and as it had happened to
the French in the real timeline of the
waterloop battle such routes can be
contagious and little by little the
entire Wellington's Force may lose
cohesiveness and start to run away by
now the tank would be maneuvering around
for over five or 6 hours testing of L
clar tank in Sweden in the the 1990s
show that actual maneuvering in tough
terrain leads to just some 120 km of
range on a full tank or 75 Mi so even
though the area that the tank would wage
war on is less than 5x 5 Mi it would
have drove over that area many times
left right up and down it's very likely
that by 3 or 400 p.m. or so the tank
would be very low on fuel for example
just 20% of fuel remaining in the tank
would be Gravely risky the tank crew and
Napoleon would likely agree to park the
tank on a fairly safe top of a hill from
which it could still use its weapons
covering a large area preferably one
also monitoring the Eastern approach due
to the incoming prussians the prussians
first came in with two infantry brigades
under the commander boow one linked with
Wellington's Eastern flank but in this
reality it's questionable if there would
be such a flank to link to the the other
Brigade went straight for the village of
plans NOA taking it plans NOA would be
taken by prussians here as well but the
Brigade that tried to reach its allies
would only get shot at by the tank from
a distance of course by then the tank
would likely be almost all out of round
so those cannon shots might be heavy
metal arrows designed for anti-tank roll
basically imagine a huge ballista Arrow
going through a few rows of men marching
it wouldn't kill many but Panic with
would still ensue most of the work
however would likely have to be done by
the French infantry nearby fighting that
Prussian Brigade most of the French
Cavalry would likely still be chasing
the routing Anglo allies cutting them
down luckily for the French it was only
after 5:30 p.m. that another Prussian
Brigade Zan's first brigade came in with
9,000 infantry men around 600 p.m. it
was joined by parts of two more brigades
totaling yet another 10 ,000 men that
would make for some serious fights on
the western flank of the French army
though the tank with its long range
Optics would help there it would warn
Napoleon of incoming Russian formations
in a timely fashion possibly an hour in
advance for each using its radio some of
the French Cavalry would still be
unreachable pursuing Wellington's men
but part of it would likely be able to
turn to prussians even before most of
those formations came and certainly
there would be enough time for
Napoleon's artillery to be placed and
shoot at the prussians so despite all
the casualties the French endured up to
that point which would be high it's
likely that the final fight in the
battle would still see French units
waiting for the Prussian brigades with
the French being double or triple in
size compared to each individual
Prussian Brigade arriving in cascading
fashion it would be only a matter of
time before each Prussian attack would
fall apart even without further
involvement from the tank of course
Napoleon could order the tank even if it
is out of ammo by that point to Simply
use up half of its remaining fuel to try
to run over the Prussian companies thus
dispersing them and lowering their
effectiveness in the end the tank itself
would not have really killed or wounded
that many enemy troops directly its 15
something darts might kill perhaps a few
troops each while 20s something heat and
Explosive Rounds might neutralize Maybe
a dozen or a few dozen troops each it
several canister rounds might do
similarly tanks machine guns even if
super precise at the whopping 20% of hit
rate would still yield maybe 600 troops
neutralized with a fair deal hitting
enemy horses the total taken out of the
fight by the tank directly might be
under a th000 troops of course the tank
would have taken out most of the
artillery which would be a huge deal it
is usually said that that in the real
timeline Wellington had 177,000 wounded
or dead soldiers while prussians had
some 7,000 wounded or dead Napoleon's
troops had similar total casualties at
25,000 or so some 8,000 were captured as
the battle ended while 15,000 deserted
during or after the battle this
alternate timeline with the tank would
see those figures change probably adding
easily 10,000 dead and wounded more to
the Ang allies and certainly adding
several more thousand being captured
similar figures might be applied to the
prussians though Napoleon's own
casualties would not likely be much
lower than they were it would still have
been a very bloody battle as the tank
couldn't be at two places at once and it
would still run out of ammo and
eventually fuel as well now of course
one could talk about further what ifs if
the tank somehow came prepared with
extra fuel extra rounds and more useful
round composition yes that would have
made the French Victory a bit easier but
not by a whole lot as there's simply no
room or way to cram in more than 50%
more ammo and fuel however if the tank
came with a whole supporting unit
essentially giving it unlimited reloads
and fuel refills then Not only would the
Battle of waterl be a landslide for the
French but many battles coming after
waterl would see the French Purge
Victorious until the tank finally gets
into an accident from which it can't
recover anymore equally so if the tank
came in even earlier like days before
the battle it would have likely pursued
the enemy during the night and shaped
the battlefield in such a way that the
Battle of waterl might not have happened
at all but the series of smaller battles
might have taken its place with again
the French winning in the end and
realistically if such a tank just
appeared out of nowhere where and no
magical information was shared the
French would just think it's the work of
the devil and would likely have not used
it at all working without coordination
with the rest of the French army it
would have been somewhat effective but
not nearly as effective though one could
also argue that if the Anglo allies had
no warning about the tank they would
have just run away in fear who knows one
thing is for sure 1815 would have no
real answer to a modern-day tank tank
the tank would have won the
day and remember bov may talk about war
but only real peace can bring us all
[Music]
[Music]
together