By next year, China could face a staggering situation with up to 120 million people at risk of starvation. This alarming conclusion was reached by a Chinese economist who analyzed China’s unemployment rates using official statistics but applied his own methodology. I have reviewed his calculations and found them to be both solid and rational. Today, I want to walk you through his process so you can understand why this conclusion seems reasonable. While the math might be a bit dry, the findings are crucial. So, please bear with me for a while, as I believe this information is important.
Hello, everyone! Welcome to Inconvenient Truths. I am your host Jennifer Zeng. By
next year, China
could face a staggering situation with up to 120 million people at
risk of starvation.
This alarming conclusion was reached by a Chinese
economist who analyzed China's unemployment rates using official statistics but applied his own methodology. I have
reviewed his calculations and found them to be both solid
and rational. Today, I want to walk you through
his process so you can understand why this conclusion seems reasonable.
While the math might be a bit dry, the findings are crucial.
So, please bear with me for a while, as I believe this information is important.
Now, let's take a detailed, step-by-step look at how the economist, Lao
Man, arrived at this conclusion.
Most of the calculations were conducted by him, with a few
completed by myself. First, let's
let's look at the employment data published by China's National Bureau of Statistics.
This is the official data in Chinese.
Translated into English, it reads: In 2022,
the urban employed population was
459.31 million,
the rural employed population was 274.2 million,
totaling 733.51 million. Additionally, official data states that as of the end of 2022,
China's urban surveyed unemployment rate
was 5.5%. It's widely believed that this unemployment figure is
highly unreliable. Firstly, what does surveyed unemployment rate mean?
It means that officially designated
surveyors visit urban and rural households nationwide, including dormitories in
factories and enterprises,
as well as dormitories and shacks where migrant workers might gather.
They then ask if anyone there is unemployed.
This method of survey is absurd, just like asking passengers on a moving train
if they were able to buy a ticket, right? Another astonishing aspect is that the National Bureau of Statistics considers
even working one hour
per week as employment. For example, an
adult who does a one-hour live broadcast on Douyin,
the Chinese version of TikTok, and earns only 50 cents
is considered fully employed by the official standards.
So, the official so-called surveyed
unemployment rate is like a joke, utterly
untrustworthy. Therefore, we must
calculate based on other data. Let's first
calculate the total number of working-age laborers.
In 2022, China's total population was 1.41175 billion.
According to data from the Ministry of
Public Security, the urban population ratio in China is
47.7%.
Based on this ratio, the urban population can be calculated as 1.41175
billion *
47.7% = 673.4 million people.
The rural population is 1.41175 billion -
673.4 million = 738.35 million people. At
this point, I must explain that in China, everyone has a so-called household registration .
If you are born in a city and registered there,
you are considered an urban household
population. If you are born in the countryside, or born in the city but your
parents are registered in the rural population, you are considered a rural household
population. Even if you work or move to a city, unless you obtain a city hukou quota and change your registration to a city hukou, you
are always considered a rural hukou. Since the CCP's establishment, this household registration system has divided people into
two major classes: urban and rural populations, and
for many years, it restricted the free movement of
people. Before the so-called reform and opening
up, if you went to an unfamiliar city without a hukou,
it was very difficult to survive, as all living supplies
were allocated based on hukou quotas,
such as how many kilograms of rice or pork
you could buy per month. People without a hukou couldn't buy these at all, even if they had the money.
Therefore, at that time, people could not move freely between cities or between cities and rural areas.
Now let's return to the calculation of the unemployment rate.
Another important point is that for rural and urban household registrations,
the CCP uses different criteria to determine the employed
population. For those with a rural hukou, as soon as they turn 15
years old, the government considers them adults.
If they don't continue their studies, they are deemed
part of the labor force and are never considered
unemployed until they die. Chinese farmers are never unemployed because
the government believes they can always farm at home,
so there's never an unemployment issue.
This is also why the CCP only calculates the
urban surveyed unemployment rate and not the rural surveyed
unemployment rate. However, in reality, there isn't enough land
for all farmers, so the surplus labor force
has to go to the cities to work. Now let's calculate the theoretical total number of employed people in rural areas.
This should be the total rural population, minus the population aged 14 and below, and those in high school and above.
According to the 2020 population census,
the proportion of rural residents aged 14 and below is 19.27%, so their
total number should be 73.835 million × 19.27% = 14.228
million. According to data from the Ministry of Education,
the number of students in rural areas in high school and above accounts for
5.72% of the total population.
So, their number is 73.835 million × 5.72% = 4.223 million.
Therefore, the total number of rural
adult labor force should be:
73.835 million - 14.228 million - 4.223 million =
55.384 million This is Lao Man's calculation.
Now let's look at the related official data.
The number of employed people in rural areas
in 2022 is 27.42 million, according
to the National Bureau of
Statistics. This is the number of laborers recognized as still working in agriculture in rural
areas. According to the "2022 Rural Migrant
Worker Monitoring Survey Report" published by the National Bureau of Statistics,
the total number of rural migrant workers in
cities is 29.562
million. Adding these
two figures together gives us 56.982
million. This is very close to Lao Man's calculation.
So, why can't rural areas accommodate so many laborers, and why do nearly
300 million of them need to leave their homes and work in cities
as migrant workers? According to
data from the Ministry of Land and Resources,
China currently has a total of 2.22 billion mu of
arable land. Mu is a Chinese unit for the area.
One mu is about 0.0667 hectares.
So 2.22 billion mu is
about 147.7 million
hectares. However, in China, after deducting various expenses,
one mu of land can only yield a profit of 1,000
yuan per year. But the cost of living for a person is at least
10,000 yuan. This means that every 10 mu of land can barely support one person.
So, 2.22 billion mu of land can only support a rural population of 200 million.
That's why nearly 300 million people
must go out to work and send money back home to barely
sustain a living. China's rural resident population is
491.04 million,
but the land can only support 200 million people.
This means that for the 290 million people living in rural areas, they must rely on the money sent
by those working outside. Currently,
the number of people working in cities is around 290 million. In other
words, every migrant worker supports one person back in the rural area.
Without these workers, the 290
million people in rural areas
would have starved to death long ago. It's also worth
mentioning that in rural areas,
farmers basically have no government welfare and rely solely
on family support and relief. This leads to a very
cruel reality: If a migrant worker
loses his or her job in the city and can only return to the rural area,
the land there cannot sustain him or her.
The person who was previously supported by this worker
will also starve to death. In other words, for every lost job of a migrant worker, two people in rural areas will
starve to death. That is the cruel reality.
Now let's look at the urban situation. Since official figures are unreliable, we have to calculate it ourselves.
First, we also need to calculate the "working-age labor force" of the urban hukou
population. Considering the concept of retirement in urban hukou population,
the formula for calculating the urban working-age labor force and the result are:
673 million total urban hukou population - 119 million minors -
38 million high school and above students
- 107 million retirees over 60 = 409
million
However, according to the National Bureau of Statistics,
the urban employed population in 2022 is
459 million, which is 50 million more than the working-age labor force we calculated.
Why is that? This is because,
the 459 million urban employed population, actually includes
296 million rural migrant workers. Subtracting these
296 million, the urban employed population is left with 163
million. This 163 million is the number of formally employed people. So, the employment
rate as a percentage of the total urban working-age labor force is:
163 million / 409 million =
39.85% Accordingly, the unemployment rate is
a staggering 60%! However, in addition to formal employment, there is another form of employment in urban
areas. It's called flexible employment. This
includes delivering food, live streaming online,
driving for ride-sharing services, providing
domestic tutoring, and working as self-media creators, among
other new forms of employment in the digital age.
In Western countries, this status is known as self-employed,
while in China, it's termed as flexible
employment. So, what's the number of people engaged in flexible employment in China? This figure
was only announced once by the official agency during
the 2021 press conference on the national
economic operation. The head of the National Bureau of
Statistics suddenly declared that the total number of
people in flexible employment in China
had reached 200 million. If we consider
these 200 million people as fully employed,
although some of them might have very low incomes and rely on family support to survive.
But if we count them as employed, then the total number of employed
people increases to 363 million. The number
of unemployed people would then be
46 million. Based on this figure,
the urban unemployment rate would be / 409 million =
11.2% This is the urban unemployment rate calculated
using the most lenient
criteria. Among the 200 million so-called flexibly employed,
the largest group is live streamers,
those who make videos on platforms like TikTok
to earn money. In this regard, I suppose I am also one of this kind.
Just a joke.
According to data disclosed at the 2021 Live Streaming and Short Video Summit by the China Performance Industry
Association, the total number of various types of live streamers in China
has reached an astonishing
130 million. The people you see in this video all belong to this group of
people.
However, about
20%, or 26 million,
of these streamers earn less than 2,000 yuan per month. Note the word "below" here,
even zero income is considered below
2,000 yuan. This group could be classified
as truly unemployed at any time.
This means that with the economic downturn, as the live
streaming industry becomes more competitive, these 26
million bottom-tier
streamers could join the ranks of the unemployed at any time.
This implies that the
number of unemployed urban population would increase
from 46 million to 72 million. If so, then
the urban unemployment rate would reach
17.6%. And an unemployment rate above 15%
already signifies an economic
crisis level. China's dual urban-rural system creates a huge gap
between urban and rural hukou populations.
There are fundamental differences in healthcare, pension, and education systems, but
there's one area where urban and rural residents are
highly aligned: Neither have any
employment security. In rural areas,
nearly 300 million surplus
population depend on nearly 300 million migrant workers working hard in cities
and sending money home, just to barely
survive. While in the city, there are 200 million people
in the so-called flexible employment, and
46 million unemployed. These people have no stable source of income and could starve to death at
any time. Lao Man believes that, with the economic downturn, the number of
300 million migrant workers cannot
possibly be maintained. Even if it decreases by only 10% next year,
30 million migrant workers returning to their hometowns
would correspond to 30 million surplus rural population,
resulting in 60 million people
facing starvation. Moreover, among the
200 million people in flexible
urban employment, next year will see at least an additional 20 million unemployed, adding
to the already 46 million unemployed, amounting to over 66 million people. 60
million starving rural residents plus 66 million starving urban residents,
a total of 126 million starving people,
such a dreadful situation is bound to become a reality
by next year at the latest. Considering the current fiscal capability of the CCP, Lao Man says
he can conclusively state:
The CCP has no ability to provide any relief
for these 126 million
starving people. And a person can starve to death in just seven days without
food and water. Therefore, by next year, Chinese society will face a situation
where 126 million people
could starve to death. What kind of horrifying
scenario would that be? Lao Man believes that large-scale incidents of mutual harm
among the lower classes will erupt explosively because
all disasters that
are logically deduced will inevitably occur in reality, and this time
will be no exception. Well, this could be the dire situation if China's economy declines by
10%, and since all the unemployment figures are based on official data,
I find them to be very solid and reliable.
During his visit to the U.S., Xi Jinping unexpectedly stated that the CCP does not
have plans to attack Taiwan in 2027 or 2035,
claiming the world has misunderstood him. Judging from
Xi Jinping's unexpectedly big smiles during his visit
to the US, under pressure from China's economic downturn,
he is begging the United States
to ease up its stance on China. That's why he has temporarily given up
the wolf-warrior
persona to reassume
the role of the giant panda. However, a comment from an analyst
struck me deeply. He said, with an army of over a hundred million unemployed,
if you don't let them fight against the U.S. or Japan,
they will turn around to fight against the CCP.
So, how will the CCP resolve this inevitable surge of unemployment and the problem of
120 million starving people?
This is indeed a very concerning issue that
could also significantly impact the global
landscape. Well, that's all for today. Please like, share, and
comment on my videos. If you haven't already,
subscribe to my channel or check if you are still subscribed,
as YouTube keeps unsubscribing people for me.
Also, you can visit my website at jenniferzengblog.com for membership
or
donations to support my efforts. In these rapidly changing times, I believe independent voices like mine are very important.
Thank you. See you next time!