Is This Medieval Paper? Full Test & Review: Nomad Craft Co. Handmade Antique-Style Recycled Paper

Motivation Monday
96 followers
#Life Hacks #Four Keys Book Arts #medieval paper #Check #full review #Handmade recycled paper #classic style
Hi everybody, I'm Dennis. I'm back in the binder here today, but I'm going to be doing something
a little bit different. Instead of making books, I'm going to be looking at paper. In a recent
video Adam Savage made his own handmade book and he used an interesting handmade medieval
antique looking paper and I thought I need to get some of that for myself. I've ordered some
and I have it here. So what we're going to do in today's video is take a good look at this paper,
test it out with a bunch of different materials. So whether you're a book binder like me
or an artist or just want to print up some neat stuff on old looking paper,
then I think this video is going to be really interesting for you. So let's take a look.
So this paper is made and sold by Nomad Crafts Company. I'm not affiliated with them at all. I
paid for this myself, so I'll be giving you my actual opinion. This pack is the A4 size. I paid,
I think it was $36 Canadian for this. In the US it retails at about $30. I will put a link in
the description if you are interested in getting some for yourself. There's supposed to be 75
sheets of paper in here, so let's open it up and take a look at them. I've got some information
in here. So this paper is described as being a vintage handmade deckled edge paper. It claims
to be 150 gsm, acid-free, that it'll work with any medium, watercolor, pen and ink, etc. Described
as having a slick and smooth surface and no bleed through. So what I'm going to do with this paper
is give it a full test drive with a number of different media. I've got paints and inks,
as well as evaluating it for its weight, grain direction, and its suitability as a book binding
paper. So let's take a look at it. So first impressions, you can see that these definitely
do have a deckled edge. That means that they have this untrimmed sort of loose shaggy edge,
which is a hallmark of handmade paper. Flipping through, I can see there's really quite a lot of
variation in the color. A lot of them seem to have like water spots. And of course, these are
advertised as being a medieval, vintage, antique looking paper. So in that sense, I think it's
exactly what I would expect. It definitely looks old. The color, very much a tan brown sort of
color. As far as the surface being slick and smooth, I would say not at all. It's quite textured.
I mean, it does look handmade. You can see the impression of the screen that was used to lift
the paper pulp out of the water. And each of these sheets, they have a crease in the center of every
one, like they've already been folded. So if you're thinking of using this paper for prints or art,
I can see that being a big drawback. Though for my purposes, I think it's okay. I mean, they're a nice
size to fold into signatures to make a book, although the fold's not in the center.
Yeah, the fold is definitely off-center. Some of the pages have an impression of, looks like a clip
of some sort. So maybe these were actually hung to dry. So insofar as the appearance of the paper,
I would say pretty much as advertised. Very antique looking. Very handmade looking. A lot
of variation in there. I would say the the surface finish, not really what I expected.
I wouldn't say rough, but definitely not smooth. So what I'd like to do now is give this paper a
proper test drive. I want to test it for acidity, which it claims to be acid-free. I want to test
the paper grain direction, and then get into using some writing materials and art supplies
on this paper and put it through its paces, see how it performs. I'm going to grab a couple of
pieces at random here to be my test subjects. Let's take that one and that one. The rest I'll
put aside. And I happen to have a brand new cutting mat here. So the first thing I want to do
is check and see what the actual GSM is of these papers. It claims to be 150. So I'm going to cut
two samples, 10 centimeters by 10 centimeters, from each of these sample pages. And I'll weigh
those, and then with a little bit of math, I'll be able to calculate the actual GSM weight of these
two papers. So there we are, a couple of 10 centimeter squares. All we need to do is put
our paper on the scale, see how many grams a 10 by 10 centimeter piece weighs, and then multiply
that by 100, and we've got our gram weight. So this one's coming in at 133 GSM, a little bit lighter
than advertised. Let's try the other one. Wow, this one's 165 GSM. If I put both samples on at the same
time though, I get 300 GSM divided by the two pieces. So on average, 150 GSM. That makes sense.
And with handmade papers, there's always going to be some variability, so I think that's acceptable.
To test for acidity in this paper, I'm going to be using this, which looks like a Sharpie, but it's
actually a pH testing pen. The way this works is where you draw a line, read it when it's dry, and
if it turns yellow, it's acidic. If it's purple, it means it's neutral or alkaline. To demonstrate,
I've got some Permalife paper here. This is an archival quality paper, pretty much guaranteed
to be acid-free. And for my sample of an acid, I've got an old paperback book, which you may
recognize this film. You can see the paper is already quite yellowed. In fact, the paper is
pretty similar color to our sample papers. So first, I'll try the Permalife paper. I'll just make a
small mark up here in the corner. We can see that's turned pretty distinctly purple. And if we try our
paperback here, right, so that's clearly quite acidic. So what we're looking for, make a mark on
there, and to see it turn purple. Let's see what it does. Hey, that looks pretty good. Let's try
the other sample piece as well. Yeah, so I would say confirmed. This pen isn't a super scientific
test, but it gives a really good indication that this paper is, in fact, more or less acid-free.
The next thing I want to do is check this paper to see if it has a grain direction.
I'll turn back to my original sheet, and I know that this is the long grain direction.
So I'll just make a couple of cuts on the corner. I explained this grain direction test in my
beginner bookbinding series. If you haven't seen those videos, I'll put a link in the description.
You can check them out. Basically, I'll use a little bit of water to dampen the paper on just
one side, and I'm going to look for any curling that occurs. And so you can see the paper isn't
curling dramatically more in one direction than the other. It appears to be pretty equal. So I'm
going to say that this paper does not have a grain direction at all, which is good. It means you can
use it in whichever orientation you want, either in the long grain direction or the short grain
direction, the way it was originally folded. Okay, so I'd say we've got the physical properties of
paper sorted out. Now it's time to see how it performs with some writing and art materials.
Let's take a look at those and see what I'm going to use to test it.
So as you can see, I've got a pretty wide array of art supplies and writing materials here. I've got
a number of different fountain pen inks inked up in these various pens. I've got some broad nib
calligraphy pens, pencils, charcoal. I've got both technical pens and some art markers up here.
Over here we've got watercolor paints. We can systematically go through using each of these
and see how this paper performs. I'm going to start simply just a pencil. This is a Palomino
Blackwing. I'm going to start just by just writing the type of paper on here for posterity.
And right away, writing in pencil on that seems really nice. Maybe we'll do a little sketch
something on here. A little jar that's on my windowsill. And this isn't an art tutorial.
I'm just fooling around, seeing how this pencil works on our paper. I can try blending some of
this. It fills in some of the texture on the paper, makes it a little bit more even, so
it's not too bad. And this being a toned paper, I could probably use a white pencil to do some
highlights. This actually works pretty well, so it's not too bad. Basic little drawing,
so you get an idea of the texture. It's a nice paper for pencil. I suspect for charcoal
would be much the same. Let's try that. Simple. So you can see some of the texture of the paper
there. Gives it a nice rough feel. It's a very vintage look. I quite like it for dry media like
that. I don't have any colored pencils here, unfortunately. Or do I? Let's put those there.
Add a little tint to my bottle here. I don't know, maybe this just needs to take a little bit more
time, but I think I just feel like the texture is a little bit too heavy for the pencil to
to work through. I don't know. You colored pencil artists out there, you let me know if
you think a nice textured paper would be the way to go. Let's try a few different colors.
So that's colored pencil on there. So for dry media, I think this paper is pretty adequate,
you know, as long as you understand that it's a fairly rough texture. Let's move on to maybe some
pens and see how that goes. I think I'll start with my technical pens and then move on to the
wetter inks after that. So for my technical pens, I've got a Staedtler pigment liner. It's 0.3 mil
and a really fine line pigment micron 0.005. Maybe do a little outlining or cross hatching on my
sketch here. Now maybe it's the pen, but it feels a little bit dry. Like the paper is maybe coated
somehow. Of course, I'm drawing over my pencil and pencil crayon already. So let's let's maybe
try something fresh over here. Let's draw a book, a little sketchy sketch. This is how I do a lot
of my design ideas, actually. It's not bad. Paper feels just a little bit like it's coated a little
bit. Let's try the other pen. Yeah, I think it was the pen. This this feels a little bit better.
Yeah, I think for a dry pen, for like a dry ink like this, this feels pretty good.
I don't know, we're just making it up as we go here. It's more about the paper than the
drawing, right? That's not too bad. Try a few of these other pens now. I've got a couple of gel pens
here. It's a black Sarasa pen and this is a Gelly Roll, a white one that I borrowed from my daughter's
art kit. You know what? This gel pen feels really satisfying on this paper, I gotta say.
Let's try this white one. Add some highlights here. I do like a toned paper for doing white
highlights. Yeah, it's okay. It's not bad. Cool. Let me show you that. So the paper is doing well
with this ink. I think you can do some really cool sketches on here. Let's go back to our colored
pencils. Good stuff. Oh, I've got this green pen too. Let's try that. This is a Pilot Hi-Tech
Point. Yeah, the paper's not drawing up and blotting the ink terribly. I've seen that happen
sometimes. So the next thing I want to try is some other kinds of markers. I got a couple of Copics,
which I understand are some of the better ones. The paper seems very absorbent and the color...
Yeah, we're not really getting any pure color. I think for marker you'd probably want to work
more on a pure white paper for colored marker, but I may be wrong. I mean, marker artists can
fill me in. Let's try some of these other guys. The paper seems very absorbent. You can see the
ink is just flowing out and being sucked up by the paper like a blotting paper.
I guess it depends on the marker. What is this guy? Azure? Oh, it's a Royal Langnickel marker.
I mean, there's some interesting shading happening here. And of course, blending
seems to be working pretty well here. Let's try just some aimless doodles. I mean, yeah, I mean,
the markers make marks. So we're getting close on these.
Oh, and one of the other things that this paper claimed was that it had no bleed through. So let's
flip this over and have a look. I would say that that is false. That with the alcohol markers,
definitely getting some significant bleed through. The dry media and the technical pen ink,
that seems to be fine. No problems there. But the alcohol markers are definitely having their way
with this paper. Let's move on to paint and then we'll finish off with some fountain pen inks and
see how this paper handles those. I think maybe for the watercolors, I'll test some of my little
squares and just do a little painting there. I'm not much of a painter, so don't expect great
results. But we'll see how the paints go onto the paper and what happens. So I guess I'll start by
doing a bit of a wash on here. It's looking pretty blotchy. It almost looks like the surface of the
paper is starting to roll up a little bit, get a little bit loose. Yeah, and the fibers of the
paper are pulling up. And the more I rub it, it seems to be peeling away. And as I am not a
watercolor painter, I'm not an expert, but I'm going to surmise that that is less than ideal.
I mean, I could try the same thing on a piece of watercolor paper and see what that looks like.
And we'll do a little side-by-side here with exactly the same brush, exactly the same paint.
So obviously the color of the paper is going to make a big impact, but the actual watercolor paper
has a much more even look. If I wasn't actively trying to roll up the surface of this paper, it
might be okay, but it just doesn't have the same sort of hard, finished surface that a watercolor
paper does. Let's try a different color, though, and give it a fair shake. Add a little yellow and
make some green down here. It's definitely more absorbent than the watercolor paper.
It just seems to be sucking up the paint.
Which, now I'm getting more variation in my color because I had to go back and pick up some more.
So there's our side-by-side. Now we'll just keep fooling around with colors here a little bit.
And we'll do the same over here. So apart from the surface texture of this paper and the color,
which is sort of tinting our entire little painting here, I'm getting a lot of warping
with this paper. There's a little bit happening with our watercolor paper's control piece here,
but it feels like it's a little bit more extreme. So I'm going to say that you can apply watercolors
to this paper. It doesn't really seem to be bleeding through, but it doesn't seem ideal.
So just based on that little sample, I'm going to say that if you're adventurous, you can use
watercolor on it. But if you're looking to buy it as a primarily watercolor paper, probably
not for you. Okay, let me move on to trying some fountain pens. When I'm all done, I'll give you
my final thoughts. So I've got here a whole variety of fountain pen inks. I took the time to
ink up a whole bunch of pens. As I'm going, I'll try some writing samples with different pens,
different size nibs, different inks, and see how those perform on this paper. First combo,
we're going to start with basic black. I've got platinum carbon ink here, and I've got my
Pilot Metropolitan inked up with black. It's a fine nib, and let's just write the name of this
paper on here to begin. First impression, much like the technical pens, is that this paper feels
really dry. Like, I know this pen pretty well, and it usually flows a little bit better. For example,
this is just a standard copy paper, and it's, you know, I don't get too much skipping.
But if I try the same thing here on the Nomad paper, it just feels drier. It feels like it's
skipping out a little bit. What it's not doing, and I thought it might, would be to really bleed
through a lot. It's really quite the opposite that I had expected. It's, uh, feels a little
drier than what I thought it might have been. Okay, let's try another pen. Here I've got
Noodler's Turquoise ink, which in my experience is a really, really wet, juicy ink. And I've got
it in a TWSBI, uh, I forget the model. I don't know. It's a fine point. Probably misspelled
turquoise. So this is a really wet ink. It smudges a lot. Me being a lefty, I don't actually use it
very much. So I'm actually getting some of that smudging here. I mean, I'm pretty happy that it's
not bleeding out through all the fibers. And like I said, this is a pretty wet ink, but some of the
fibers of the paper are actually pulling up and getting stuck in the nib. So let's give this a
real challenge. Here I've got, uh, this is a Fountain Pen Revolution pen with, uh, like the
Superflex stainless steel nib, I believe. And the ink that I've got in it, it's, uh, Platinum
Forest Black. I really like this pen. I use it a lot, and I like the flex. Let's see what it does
on this paper, though. Just railroading all over the place. That's not the pen. I can show you on,
uh, this copy paper. The pen writes really well. It's nice and juicy. No problems with flow in this
pen, but as soon as it touches this paper, it wants to run out. Just railroading all over the
place. So, I don't know, it feels, it feels like the paper is somehow coated. And so wet media
is just not really having a good time with it. This is another really wet ink. I don't know what
this pen is. Maybe someone could help me find out. It's an Aero, E-R-O. I actually bought it in a
thrift store for a couple of bucks, and I've got it inked up with, um, Noodler's Apache Sunset,
which, again, is, it's a great ink. Very nice shading ink. Very wet ink, in my experience.
It's not too bad, but again, I can feel the surface of the paper sort of abrading. So,
not ideal. Let's take a closer look at that. So, those are fine tip pens. Let's, uh, let's move
on to some. We've got a broad nib here, and a couple of parallel pens. Let's see what this paper makes
of these bad boys. Uh, this pen, uh, it's a Pilot Metro with a stub. I forget which size. It's like a one,
1.1 millimeter, or something like that. And the ink in this guy, I think, is the J. Urban, Lidite.
I like this one for doing, like, a sort of a calligraphy script. You know, I kind of like how
this combination is working with this paper, between the stub nib and the ink. Um, and the
paper's not really got any significant feathering that I can see. Not from this distance. Maybe on
the zoom, you guys can tell me. And bleed through? Non-existent. Looks pretty good. Let's try these
parallel pens, and give it a real test. Uh, this one, I forget the size. This is like, I don't know.
Oh, there it is. 2.4 mil. And this one's inked up with Rohr and Klinger Alt Goldgrund, which is
just a gorgeous ink. But I find it to be very wet and smudgy. I've got my weird left-handed
calligraphy style happening here, but so be it. No, this is much worse. Let's try pulling. This,
uh, the broad nib is just really... Yeah, this isn't working too well with the parallel pen.
I find that the Alt Goldgrund doesn't play well with a lot of types of paper, unfortunately. Such
a gorgeous ink. If I push, which with my particular weird left-handed style, I do kind of a lot. It's
just, it's tearing up the paper. Yeah, it's just, I've got fibers right in the pen, which is less
than ideal. This is not the smooth surface paper that, uh, that was advertised. So I'm going to
give up on trying to make that work. This is the 1.5 mil, and this is inked up with Red Dragon.
You can definitely use the fine corner of the parallel nib. Uh, this is better, actually.
It's better than I expected. The Red Dragon is a better behaved ink, in my opinion.
This is working a little bit better. It's still not ideal. The paper is still a little bit soft,
and not, it can't really stand up when it's wet to the nib. So I'm going to say, for calligraphy,
really depends on the ink that you're using. I've got a dip pen here.
Glass pen. Whoops! So I can try another kind of ink in there. Let's go for this
Diamine. Is it Diamine or Diamine? I don't know. Diamine Meadow. Nice bright green ink.
Not terrible. Feedback that I get from the paper, it just feels, feels fairly rough, and
like it wants to tear apart when it's wet. It doesn't have really good wet properties,
in my opinion. I've also got some Higgins Calligraphy ink that I could try it with
another dip pen. It's got a little, the ink reservoir cap on it. See what that does with
this Higgins Calligraphy ink. Less than ideal, I would say. This does seem to have some feathering
where the wet ink is bleeding in, being absorbed by the paper. And again, I don't have any fibers
caught in there right now, but it really did feel like it was tearing up the surface of the paper.
And I just thought, there's one more test that I want to try with this. I want to see what this
paper does if I try and run it through my printer. Okay, here's our printout. I gotta say,
it looks pretty good. This is a design of book plates that I, that I've made. Incidentally,
this exact file is available for purchase. You can download it and print these yourself
from my Etsy shop. But if we take a close look, I think the detail turned out pretty well.
I had no trouble feeding this single sheet through the printer, and it looks nice and sharp. In fact,
you can see, see my little logo right there. No bleed through. So you can definitely print
these both sides. And if you had a book that you wanted to print in, in this format, you can
absolutely do that. This paper doesn't have a grain direction, so you could print it up and
bind it along the center crease. Or even if you wanted to make, I guess, an A8 book, that size
would work as well. In fact, I think that looks really cool. Okay, so what's my final opinion on
this Nomad handmade paper? Well, it's not a do-all paper. It's not going to do everything that you
want. I think it's particularly good for dry media. So for pencil, pastels, colored pencils, just fine.
I think you'll be very satisfied with it. Just keep in mind that it has a slightly rough texture.
And you can get away with using gel pens. Certain ballpoint pens would be just fine on here,
as well as some technical pens. Mixed results with the markers, that's really up to your personal
style. But it does bleed through pretty heavily. The bleed through wasn't quite as bad with the
fountain pen inks. You can see there's really nothing that came through here at all. But I was
pretty dissatisfied with the surface quality of the paper when working with fountain pens. Likewise
for watercolor, I don't think it's really a great watercolor paper. The surface just can't stand up
to the moisture. Where I was really impressed was with the print quality from my laser printer. For
any kind of printed material, I think this paper would work really well, especially where you want
to achieve that antique look. I'm thinking bookbinding, but for art projects or even role
playing maps or handouts, it would be really good for that. So overall, I think this paper is a
really good value for handmade paper. Handmade papers can be pretty expensive, and $30 for 75
sheets, that seems like a pretty good value to me. This has been a different sort of video for
the channel, so if you got something out of it, then please give it a like. It really does help.
And if you hit the notification bell, then you won't miss out on any of my new videos.
If there's other kinds of paper that you'd like to see me test drive, then do let me know down in
the comments. I'll see if I can source some of those. And if this video is well received, I might
do more like it. So that's all for now. Thanks very much for watching. I'm Dennis, and I'll see you in
the next video.
