In this episode we take a look at and listen to DPA’s new shotgun mic, the 2017. This sibling to the 4017b shares the classic and characteristic sound of DPA mics, but has a completely new design both in terms of feature set, capsule, and internal electronics. In this episode we listen to some raw sound samples from the 2017 as well as a variety of similar mics, walk through the 2017’s feature set, and rigorously compare it to the 4017b. Let’s take a closer look!
If you’d like to learn how to make great dialogue audio for your film and video projects, please have a look at my courses including processing dialogue audio in Adobe Audition and DaVinci Resolve/Fairlight, recording sound, how to use the Zoom F4, F6, F8, and F8n, and how to get the most from the Sound Devices MixPre series of recorders. Our latest courses cover Sound for Live Streaming with the ATEM Mini and an Intro to Izotope RX. See https://school.learnlightandsound.com for more info!
Gear used or mentioned in this episode. The links below are Amazon.com, B&H Photo, Sweetwater, DVEStore, Perfect Circuit, Trew Audio or other affiliate links. As an affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases:
The intro and outro music for this episode is from Musicbed - “Dynamo” by Virgil Arles. Take your films to the next level with music from Musicbed. Sign up for a free account to listen for yourself: https://geni.us/G7by
In this episode, just a quick look and some samples from the DPA 2017 shotgun microphone.
Now DPA makes another shotgun microphone called the 4017.
It also is a modular microphone, meaning you can attach different preamplifier units to
it.
And the question I think a lot of people are going to have, well, what's the difference
with the 2017?
Is it basically just a 4017 that's not modular and that doesn't have a high pass filter and
doesn't have a presence boost?
And the answer is no.
It's actually a completely new design.
And that is something that you can see over on DPA's website here, for example, they kind
of compare the two, the 4017 and the 2017.
So it is a new design.
One huge difference, of course, is the price.
It's a $995 microphone versus the over $2,000 for most kind of configurations of the 4017.
So let's first get you some raw samples, unprocessed of the 2017, the 4017B and the
Sennheiser MKH416.
It was easier to know it than to explain why I know it.
If you were asked to prove that two and two made four, you might find some difficulty
and yet you are quite sure of the fact.
It was easier to know it than to explain why I know it.
If you were asked to prove that two and two made four, you might find some difficulty
and yet you are quite sure of the fact.
It was easier to know it than to explain why I know it.
If you were asked to prove that two and two made four, you might find some difficulty
and yet you are quite sure of the fact.
It was easier to know it than to explain why I know it.
If you were asked to prove that two and two made four, you might find some difficulty
and yet you are quite sure of the fact.
It was easier to know it than to explain why I know it.
If you were asked to prove that two and two made four, you might find some difficulty
and yet you are quite sure of the fact.
It was easier to know it than to explain why I know it.
If you were asked to prove that two and two made four, you might find some difficulty
and yet you are quite sure of the fact.
Let's talk you through some other things, some additional samples and some of my impressions.
First of all, this is another small shotgun microphone with the DPA sound.
DPA sound to me is pretty transparent, pretty neutral, pretty true to life versus something
that's a little bit more, I always feel like, for example, the Sennheiser is a little bit
colored in a really positive way.
In most cases, it sounds good, but I feel like the DPA is a little bit closer to real
life and that kind of manifests itself in a few different ways.
Let's take a look.
The 2017 is small and lightweight, 184 millimeters long, 115 grams, way smaller and lighter than,
for example, the Sennheiser MKH416, so it is a lot easier to boom out on the end of
a pole if you're going to be doing that all day long.
We did do our practical noise floor sample.
Let me just roll that so you can see what that's about.
This is not a scientific test, this is a practical test of, in practical terms, where the noise
floor comes out.
All right, this is our practical noise floor sample.
I'm at 47 dB on the DPA 2017 and we're in our typical position here.
I've got sound blankets to either side, sound blanket on the table in front of me, sound
blanket back by the camera, blanket on the floor behind me, and this is what it sounds
like.
I'm going to go ahead and leave a few moments of silence and we'll be able to measure that
as our practical noise floor.
Here's a sample of handling noise with a Rikote shock mount.
More specifically, that's the Rikote shock mount that comes with the Cyclone, which is
also very similar to the NanoShield.
So in short, it appears to me that if you put this on a quality shock mount, you're
not going to have a lot of huge issues in terms of handling noise when you are booming
it by hand.
Sibilance, it seems, again, as a microphone that's fairly neutral, it handles sibilance
nicely.
I have a lot of sibilance in my voice.
It of course picks it up, but it also doesn't overemphasize it like so many microphones
do.
She sells seashells by the seashore.
By the seashore, she sells seashells.
When you're booming a mic, usually plosives are not an issue because here, for example,
we're booming it.
It's just right here out of the frame.
Typically that's not going to be an issue, but just for grins and giggles, here's a sample
of that.
Peter Piper picked a peck of purple pickled peppers.
Now off-axis coloration is kind of a big deal with shotgun microphones.
In fact, let's get you a couple of samples.
I'm going to go out by Interstate 80 in the United States here, plenty of traffic, and
hear how the 2017 does relative to the Sennheiser MKH416.
All right, in this case, I'm using the DPA 2017.
I've got Interstate 80 about 100 meters that way.
Let me give you some on-axis capture audio of the Interstate, and now off-axis of the
Interstate.
Now what we're looking for here is does the off-axis sound just reduce in level, or does
it change qualitatively, like does the tone change?
Back to the Interstate, and then off-axis to the Interstate, although I have a truck
over here now.
I've got another road there.
That's a noisy truck.
On versus off-axis, so that was the tractor-trailer driving by just there.
Some vehicles.
Those are smaller passenger vehicles.
Okay, in this case, we're using the MKH416, and my test here, or sample here, is we've
got Interstate 80 just over there.
I've got a road that comes here, another road that goes across there, and what we're trying
to assess here is off-axis sounds.
Do they sound natural and just quieter, or do they sound tonally different?
So that's the real question.
So let me turn the microphone towards I-80, Interstate.
Okay, so you're hearing some vehicles pass there.
Now they're off-axis.
I'm going to go ahead and be quiet for just a moment here so you can hear what they sound
like.
Now I had another vehicle that was on-axis.
Now off-axis.
Did you notice as it drove by, it had sort of a weird, it was almost a phasing effect,
like a whoosh.
It just, it changed in some way.
All right, here is the DPA-2017.
It is directly on-axis right now, and what I'm doing here is a couple things.
Number one, we're in an incredibly reverberant space, so that's one thing, just so you can
get a sample there as well.
And then I also wanted to kind of give a clearer example of the off-axis coloration, so let's
go ahead and do that.
I'm going to go ahead and turn the microphone to 90 degrees off-axis, and you're getting
a lot more reflected sound right now, and the sound coming in from the sides as well.
And then we're going to go ahead and keep turning the microphone so that it's 90, or
sorry, 180 degrees off-axis, completely talking into the back of the microphone, and let's
kind of make our way back.
Here we are now at 90 degrees off-axis, and we're making our way back so that we are directly
on-axis at zero degrees.
So there's a sense for how colored the off-axis sound is on the 2017.
All right, in this case, we're working with the 4017B from DPA as well.
We are directly on-axis right now.
I'm going to go ahead and turn so that we are 90 degrees off-axis, so we're talking
into the side of the microphone, plus you're picking up any reflected sound in this incredibly
reverberant space.
We're now at 180 degrees off-axis.
I'm talking into the back of the microphone, coming back to 90 degrees where we're talking
into the side of the microphone, and then finally back on-axis at zero degrees so that
you can hear what, overall, the coloration sounds like when you're off-axis from the
4017B.
All right, now we have the Sennheiser MKH-416 directly on-axis right now, and I'm going
to go ahead and start turning that so that we're talking now into the side of the microphone.
We're off-axis 90 degrees, and let's go ahead and keep turning that around so that we are
at 180 degrees off-axis, talking into the back of the microphone.
Go ahead and bring it back this direction so that we're talking into the side of the
microphone, and then finally back on-axis at zero degrees so you can hear the off-axis
coloration of the Sennheiser MKH-416.
In terms of RF interference, if you have radio frequency stuff going on around the microphone,
what happens?
We tested with three different things.
We tested with a wireless transmitter, a microphone transmitter, specifically the Sound Devices
A10 transmitter set at 483 megahertz, also with a phone with Wi-Fi and with LTE right
up next to the microphone, and we did not experience any sort of radio frequency interference
issues.
So, in our initial tests at least so far, RF doesn't appear to be a problem.
The microphone comes with a two-year warranty, and at the time of this review, is priced
at $995.
No microphone is perfect, but I had a really hard time finding things that I didn't like
about this microphone.
I guess if I had to really stretch, it doesn't have a low-cut or a high-pass filter.
It also doesn't have the presence boost filter, or I guess switch, so that when you stick
the microphone in a Zeppelin-type cover for use outdoors, it doesn't have a way to kind
of compensate for that.
You have to do that in post instead.
Not a huge deal, but if that's a really important feature to you, that's where something like
the 4017 with the B preamplifier might be a better choice.
Okay, so here's the complicated part.
How do I feel about this?
So I purchased the 4017B with my own money several years ago, well before this was available.
I also own a Sennheiser MKH-416, which I purchased with my own money.
This is on loan to me from B&H Photo.
They haven't told me that I have to say anything in particular, not paying me to make this
video.
They were just kind enough to loan it to me.
So what are my recommendations?
I think, obviously, price-wise, this is much closer to the Sennheiser MKH-416.
My sense is that the off-axis coloration on the DPA is a little bit better.
In other words, the off-axis sound just sounds quieter, not colored, not as if its tone has
shifted or it sounds otherworldly.
You get a bit more of that, I feel like, with the Sennheiser MKH-416.
This is a nuance.
For some people, it's not going to be a big deal.
For others who care about this, it could be a big deal, and it could be the reason
why a 2017 might be a better choice for you.
I would say if I were spending my money, I would probably choose the 2017 over the 416.
The reason I own the Sennheiser 416 is that it's so well-known, and it's a good microphone
to use as sort of a comparison basis when I'm evaluating other microphones.
So that's my overall take.
If I were buying today, would I buy this or the 417B?
I would probably buy this, to be honest, although I really do like that presence boost filter.
It's really nice to be able to hand over audio to a post team that's ready to go.
And if I'm booming outdoors and I have either my NanoShield, my Rycote NanoShield, or the
Cyclone on to protect it from the wind, being able to restore or boost some of those higher
frequencies that get cut by the wind protection is a really nice thing.
So if you've got the budget, if I had the budget, I would probably buy a 417B again.
If not, if I was on a tighter budget, the 2017 is a pretty amazing mic for the money.
So hopefully that was helpful for you.
If you have any questions, go ahead and leave those down below.
And if you've not already subscribed, make sure you do that.
Get out there and make some great sound.