【ゆっくり解説】通説と史実が違う戦国武将7選!!

にっぽんぽん【ゆっくり日本史解説】
52 フォロワー
ーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー
ーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー
にっぽんぽんTwitter 【制作の裏話など】
https://twitter.com/nipponppo/status/1514134672988848129?s=21&t=KfI4G3avdKpUcCTb1LflhQ
にっぽんぽんInstagram【偉人の名言】
https://www.instagram.com/p/CcP2FQDvaxa/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
歴史は何のために学ぶのか。この疑問を持ったことがある方は少なくないでしょう。仕事では直接使うことはほとんどないですよね。
過去を学ぶことで未来に活かせると私は考えています。教養という意味でも社会で必要な知識でしょう。
先人たちはどのような暮らしでなぜそのような文化が形成されたのか。面白いことばかりです。
こういった考えから、このチャンネルでは社会人の方が、ゆっくり楽しく歴史上の偉人のことを学べ、更に、そこから日常でも役立てられるような動画を作っています。
このチャンネルを通して学び、役立てられる人が1人でも多くなるようにチャンネル運営を頑張っていきます。応援してもらえると嬉しいです。
ほぼ毎日17時に動画を配信中 にっぽんぽん 運営 山本陽太
※動画内の素材はすべて引用であり、著作権や肖像権を侵害する目的はございません。
著作権などに関するお問い合わせはこちらのアドレスまでお願いします。
[email protected]
#ゆっくり #ゆっくり日本史 #ゆっくり解説
Yukkuri Reimu and
Yukkuri Marisa.
Even when I watch Taiga dramas, there are a lot of different warlords, but there are also wonderful warlords other than the main character.
Well, the Taiga drama that depicts the Sengoku period is full of famous warlords.
Famous Sengoku warlords are often warlords who have done a lot of good and are excellent.
Warlords like the main character are often depicted only in good places.
However, there are many warlords whose achievements are not as good as rumored.
What? Is that so?
What if the warlord I admire is actually a piece of junk?
History is a strange thing, and it is often overturned by discoveries of new materials and discoveries of new artifacts.
I see. There are new ruins and new books.
In the first place, there are many warlords based on rumors and their own interpretations by the people of the Edo period, and now there are more and more credibility.
Therefore, it is natural that the image of rumors in the world and the warlords who are actually far apart will come out.
Hmm. Is that so?
So, I'm going to take a look at the Sengoku warlords who have a big difference between rumors and facts, and I'm going to explain in detail about the seven representative warlords.
So, this time, I'm going to explain about the Sengoku warlords who have a big difference between rumors and facts.
Well, take your time.
7th place, Kanosuke Yamanaka
First of all, is it from 7th place?
7th place, Shike no Saikou was just self-satisfaction?
It's Kanosuke Yamanaka.
Actually, I'm sorry, but I don't know much about Shikanosuke Yamanaka.
Shikanosuke Yamanaka was a warlord of the Sanin region from the Sengoku period to the Azuchi-Momoyama period, and he was the head of the Amago family.
Officially, his name is Yamanaka Yukimori, but the so-called Shikanosuke is better known.
The line before he gave me the Shichinan hack is famous, but it is also known as the center that devoted his life to Shike Saikou.
Yeah, that's right.
After this, I'll ask you in detail.
In the textbook before the war, it was as popular as Masashige Kusunoki as a warrior's mirror loyalist.
Certainly, Shikanosuke is a loyalist and a tear-jerker, but I wonder if he was a warrior as excellent as Tsuusetsu.
In 1565, the army led by Morimoto surrounded Tsukiyama and Dajo, where Amago Yoshihisa stayed.
Shikanosuke Yamanaka was also a member of the Amago family, wasn't he?
Shikanosuke was recognized as a warrior at a young age, and he was said to have played a great role in defeating Takano Kenmotsu in Gouketsu.
However, in the course of a year and a half, Amago Yoshihisa, who finally broke his sword, lost his happiness.
While many of the family members went down to the army, Shikanosuke is said to have left Izumo to achieve Shike Saikou.
What? Did you leave Izumo?
After that, Amago Yoshihisa, who was in charge of the Tohoku region of Kyoto, was exiled, and a new Amago family leader was elected, and he was awarded the Grand Prize of the Saikou Army.
Amago Yoshihisa was already dead, but he was elected by Shikanosuke.
The Yamanaka family, which was born by Shikanosuke, is a family that continues the bloodline of Amago, so it is natural to be interested in Shike.
The very existence of the Amago family must have been a life-changing aspect for Shikanosuke.
However, the reason for deciding on the Amago family's Saikou is inconsistent.
Yoshihisa, the leader, lived in Aki, so he should have supported Yoshihisa, who was originally a butler.
It seems as if he is ignoring Yoshihisa's existence as he carries out Amago Tsunehisa's great-grandchild Katsuhisa.
Even if he had achieved the Amago family's Saikou, I wonder what Yoshihisa was going to do with his existence.
There, Shikanosuke's pride and self-determination are hidden.
If it were true, he should have wanted to follow Yoshihisa and go to Aki.
However, Shikanosuke, who struggled against the Mouri family, should not be allowed to go to Aki with Yoshihisa.
Shikanosuke, who has no intention of doing it, may have carried out Katsuhisa in order to create a new Amago family that is different from Yoshihisa.
It's only me who can revive the Amago family.
Shikanosuke may have thought so.
Oops. I have memories of Shike, but I wonder if there was something a little overconfident.
However, if you just form the Amago family's Saikou army, you can't talk about it without a comprehensive and concrete plan.
While Mouri was fighting Otomo, it was okay until the defense attacked with Izumo, who was thin-handed, but Shikanosuke made a big mistake.
He was deceived by Amanotakashige, who protects Tsukiyama and Dajo, and met him on his way home.
By losing many soldiers in this battle, Shikanosuke lost the trust of many officers.
It's a pity to lose many soldiers.
In addition, I lost my trust.
And Shikanosuke, when the Mouri army retreated and pushed in, challenged Fubeyama to a decisive battle.
However, Shikanosuke did not realize the important thing.
Not only did the situation get worse in the previous defeat, but he also lost his confidence in himself.
In that state, he welcomed the Mouri army, but even if he was just calm, the betrayal of his allies overlapped.
Shikanosuke became desperate and let the whole army escape, but he was never able to invade Izumo again.
The Mouri army was physically impossible to attack, and the feelings of the Izumo people were far from Shikanosuke.
Shikanosuke was still persistent.
He turned to Inaba and fought a fierce battle with the Mouri army, but he could not win.
And the Yamanashi of Tanomi no Tsuna teamed up with the Mouri army, and he had no choice but to retreat from Sanin.
These defeats are not only the responsibility of Shikanosuke, but also the weakness of his ability to determine the outcome of the battle.
Even if you analyze the actions of the Saikou army, it has become conspicuous.
And, surprisingly, the last person Shikanosuke relied on was Oda Nobunaga.
Oh? Oda Nobunaga?
Is it because he was an enemy with the Mouri army?
After Akechi Mitsuhide replaced Hashiba Hideyoshi, he joined the Chinese expeditionary force and entered Kouzuki Castle with Katsuhisa.
However, luck did not favor Amagoshi.
Soon, when Bessho of Mikijou rebelled, Hideyoshi was besieged and could no longer move.
In addition, with the Mouri army approaching Kouzuki Castle, Katsuhisa and Shikanosuke were in danger.
Hideyoshi suggested that the two of them escape from Kouzuki Castle, but Shikanosuke for some reason refused.
In fact, it should have been possible if many soldiers had escaped and survived, but Shikanosuke insisted on staying in the castle.
If they had escaped from Kouzuki Castle, it would not have been a dream for Amagoshi to return.
Did Shikanosuke get tired of fighting, or did he think he was just being used by Hideyoshi?
I don't know the reason, but it may have been the limit of Shikanosuke Yamanaka.
I wonder if he had a strong obsession.
Shikanosuke Yamanaka
The commander of Sekigahara and the commander of three people.
What is the next commander?
There are three commanders related to the commander of the battle of Sekigahara.
I will introduce all of them from 6th to 4th place.
The three people I will introduce in the legend of Sekigahara, which was full of lies, are Hideaki Kobayakawa, Yoshihiro Shimazu, and Hidetada Tokugawa.
Why are these three people?
In fact, these three people are showing a completely different movement from the legend in the battle of Sekigahara.
After this, I will introduce three people at once.
6th Kobayakawa Hideaki
The 6th is Hideaki Kobayakawa.
Hideaki Kobayakawa is famous as a traitor who influences the results of the battle of Sekigahara.
That's right.
Everyone should think so.
According to the legend, Hideaki, who was watching the battle at the summit of Matsuo Mountain, did not decide whether to side with the West Army or the East Army.
He promised Tokugawa Ieyasu that he would betray the West Army, but surprisingly, the West Army was at war and the battle was one-sided.
Ieyasu aimed his gun at Matsuo Mountain from the foot of the mountain and threatened that if he did not become an ally of the East Army, he would become an enemy.
Hideyasu, who was shaken up, went down to the bottom of the mountain and charged into the West Army.
At once, the West Army turned to the East Army, and the West Army collapsed, leading to a great victory for the East Army.
I have the image that Ieyasu was afraid of the gun he pointed at and betrayed the West Army.
However, it seems that the actual Kobayakawa Hideaki was on the East Army side from the beginning.
He left only a small number of guards on Matsuo Mountain, and a total of 15,000 Kobayakawa Zeishu-ryoku were on the hill at the foot of the mountain.
And at the same time as the battle began, he attacked the Yoshitsugu Corps from behind and destroyed it.
In addition, he joined the other East Army forces and attacked the West Army forces at once and defeated them in about two hours.
From the beginning of the war, there was no way for 15,000 troops to return to the East Army.
In the first place, even if you shoot a gun from the foot of the mountain on a battlefield where the enemy is scattered, you can't hear the gunfire.
Moreover, the effective range of the gun at that time was about 100 meters.
It's hard to think of it as a threat.
I see.
The fact that Ieyasu shot a gun at Matsuo Mountain itself may be a made-up story.
Daigoi Yoshihiro Shimazu
Daigoi, who is the second commander of the Sekigahara Command?
It's Yoshihiro Shimazu, famous for the entrance to Sekigahara Shimazu.
There is something controversial about his actions.
According to the rumor, Shimazu, who was left to the battlefield of Sekigahara, where the West Army troops retreated, chose to charge forward rather than retreat, and found a way to win in the middle of the battle.
It's an episode that conveys the bravery of Shimazu.
However, if you look at the Satsuma-class missiles that gathered the strength of Shimazu's small soldiers, the situation changes.
In fact, Shimazu was originally a small number, and it was placed as a reserve force called the second preparation.
The Shimazu army was a reserve force.
According to the rumor, they didn't move no matter how many times they were asked by Mitsunari Ishida, but in fact, at first it was a strategy that didn't move the army.
It's not like you didn't join the battle because you rebelled against Mitsunari Ishida.
And when he didn't participate in the battle, the advance of the West Army began to collapse, and Kouhou's retreat was overturned by his allies.
When Kouhou was in such a state, Shimazu, who lost his place to go, had no choice but to advance.
Of course, he didn't intend to break through a dangerous enemy, and as a result, he was forced to retreat near Ieyasu Honjin.
In addition, it is said that the enemy's pursuit was not as intense as expected because there were so few soldiers.
You had no choice but to retreat to the front.
4th Tokugawa Hidetada
Now, the 4th, the commander of Sekigahara Tsuusetsu, the last to be decorated is...
Edo Bakufu, Tokugawa Hidetada, also famous as the Great Shogun of Tokugawa.
He's the only one left, so there's only Hidetada.
He's famous for his father's Tokugawa Ieyasu, which he praised for the battle of Sekigahara.
The rumor about Tokugawa Hidetada is as follows.
Tokugawa Hidetada, unlike his father Ieyasu's main force, was heading for Mino through Nakasendo.
The country was in a hurry to join the decisive battle of Keme, the battle of Sekigahara, but...
The one who appeared in front of him was Masayuki Sanada, who had returned to the West Army.
Masayuki showed off his old-fashioned stance at Ueda Castle in Shinshu and took action to interfere with Hidetada's army.
Seeing this, Hidetada decided to attack Ueda Castle forcefully without listening to the commander's words.
However, Masayuki's skillful strategy and tactics made him exhausted, and when he realized it, he was wasting precious time.
He left a few soldiers to hold down Ueda Castle and hurried to Mino, but in the end he didn't make it to the main battle and was beaten by Ieyasu.
He got caught up in Sanada's plan, attacked Ueda Castle, which he didn't have to attack, and was angry at Sekigahara.
So far is common sense, but the truth seems to be a little different.
In fact, the order Hidetada received from Ieyasu was to advance through Nakasendo and capture Ueda Castle, and then to land again.
This was also clear from the situation at the time, and it seems that the attack on Ueda Castle was a designated route.
However, Ueda Castle was captured in Uijin's Hidetada's Shikigachisetsu, and he made a huge mistake called Sekigahara Chisan.
He made a mistake in the capture of Ueda Castle, which was ordered by Ieyasu, and in any case, Sekigahara Chisan.
3rd place, Mitsuhide Akechi
3rd place is the protagonist of the Taiga drama a few years ago, Mitsuhide Akechi.
In fact, he was an extremely evil person.
What? As far as I can see in Kirin Gakuru, he's cool, serious, and has the image of a military officer who cares for the people?
In 2020 Taiga drama Kirin Gakuru, Akechi Mitsuhide became the protagonist, but in that drama,
just like Reimu, I think there were many people who had the image that Akechi had a strong sense of justice because he was pure and pure.
Certainly, there is also the aspect that Akechi and Mitsuhide had a good relationship in their own country, and Akechi and Mitsuhide had a good relationship with each other.
However, in the actual Akechi Mitsuhide, it is said that he was a cruel military officer who was no less than Oda Nobunaga.
I don't have a cruel impression at all.
Mitsuhide
In 1570, Oda Nobunaga decided to burn down Hieizan Enryakuji, and he asked Akechi and Mitsuhide to prepare.
In the Taiga drama, there was a scene where Mitsuhide desperately tried to stop the rebellion, but how was it in reality?
In fact, Mitsuhide's letter about the burning of Hieizan Enryakuji remains.
It was for the local government, but it was written like this.
What was the content of Mitsuhide's letter?
It's not that difficult.
Mitsuhide was the one who was more excited than anyone else to watch over Oda Nobunaga at Hieizan Yakiuchi.
Why did you do that, Mitsuhide?
The reason is that Mitsuhide was avoiding the promise given to Nobunaga from Sakamoto, who was at the foot of Hieizan.
In other words, he was trying to take over the authority that Enryakuji had.
Omi Sakamoto is a town full of luck and fortune.
As Mitsuhide, he must have wanted to get it no matter what.
Biwako is right next door, and it's convenient to go to Kyoto.
And when it comes to Hieizan Yakiuchi, I'm sure he killed more than anyone else and took more.
Next, Mitsuhide's remnant is felt when he attacks Yakami Castle in Tanba.
In 1579, Mitsuhide surrounded Yakami Castle to attack Hideharu, who had been resisting in Tanba.
At that time, he surrounded Tsukijiro and Saku so that the enemy officers and soldiers could not escape, and he went out to attack Hyōrō.
Hyōrō began to attack there in Yakami Castle, which was attacked by Hyōrō, and the soldiers began to lose their minds.
In this situation, Mitsuhide came up with the next plan.
He sent a secret letter to Yakami Castle and told the super soldiers like this.
If you bring me the head of the Hatano brothers, I'll save the lives of the soldiers.
Somehow, when I hear this, I can hear the common happiness.
When this happens, the super soldiers who were in prison will no longer be able to pay back.
Hideharu Hidena, who betrayed his ally super soldiers, was shot and his head was sent to Nobunaga.
And the remaining super soldiers are relieved that they were saved, but Mitsuhide didn't intend to forgive them.
In the letter to Shimojo that Mitsuhide sent to Wadaya Jūrō, it depicts a gruesome massacre.
There were already about 500 people in Yakami Castle, but the super soldiers were desperate to get out of the castle as soon as possible.
However, Mitsuhide ordered the slaughter of the number of soldiers who had shot the enemy's head.
At that time, he cornered the super soldiers with a surprise attack and shot the escaping super soldiers one by one.
Terrible.
It's not bad, it's not bad.
You're lying, you're deceiving me.
Mitsuhide, who not only deceived, but also committed a gruesome massacre.
I think it was because of the stubborn resistance of the Tanba no Kuni-shū.
Mitsuhide was often defeated by the Tanba, so it can be thought that he was desperately aiming for a chance of revenge.
The reason he was so passionate about revenge wasn't just for Oda Nobunaga.
Second Oda Nobunaga
It's finally the second one.
Which department is it?
The Sengoku Revolution was actually not that big.
The second one is Oda Nobunaga.
Following Mitsuhide, Nobunaga?
I'm surprised that Oda Nobunaga's theory and fact are different.
Speaking of Oda Nobunaga, I think everyone imagines the unfortunate situation of the Sengoku Revolution in Japan.
And he launched a new axis in the political economy, and he said that there is no enemy to go to without losing the battle.
Yeah, that's the image.
History fans and Nobunaga fans will be angry, but it seems that the real Nobunaga was not much worse than I thought.
Let's verify what happened in reality.
First of all, on the political side.
It is said that Nobunaga had a new innovative political ideology without being caught up in the old customs, but in fact, it is easy.
I only have the image of destroying the old customs.
In fact, it is said that Ashikaga received Yoshiaki and landed to revive Muromachi Bakufu.
Of course, Nobunaga didn't have the idea of holding the government and making Yoshiaki a puppet.
After all, I can see the aspect that Ashikaga tried to stay as a sub after making Yoshiaki a general.
Nobunaga is second in line.
I can't imagine.
Also, it is common to think that he was trying to destroy Muromachi Bakufu, but that may also be out of place.
In reality, Yoshiaki is just trying to get angry and eliminate Nobunaga on his own.
It's not that Nobunaga wanted to destroy Muromachi Bakufu, it's just that he suppressed Yoshiaki for self-defense.
However, I can't leave such a dangerous general in Kyoto, so I am expelling him from Kyoto.
However, it seems that he intended to destroy it as soon as Hotobori woke up.
Oh, I didn't know there was such a grudge.
At that time, I was negotiating with Morishi and the Yoshiaki Organization.
I think Nobunaga also wanted the existence of Bakufu.
As a result, it is also said that Nobunaga was forced to take over the government because Yoshiaki left the aircraft.
That was the truth.
However, of course, Nobunaga did not forget to respect the emperor and the emperor.
In the drama, it seems that he was also unreasonable to the emperor and the emperor.
Nobunaga had a very conservative idea rather than a revolutionary one.
The rest is the economic aspect.
Speaking of Nobunaga's economic policies, Rakuichi Rakuza and Sekisho Teppai,
and the denial of Erize Nirei are famous, but it seems that Nobunaga was not the first to implement them.
Rakuichi Rakuza was carried out by Mino's Saito Do, and Suruga's Imagawa Yoshimoto also carried it out as Fujiomiya Rakuichi.
I didn't doubt that Nobunaga started Rakuichi Rakuza.
Sekisho Teppai was also a prototype that Saito Do first worked on, and Nobunaga was not a pioneer or anything.
The denial of Erize Nirei, which distributed the fruit of Ryousen, was also necessary.
If Ryousen alone is distributed in the market, the number of its own will inevitably decrease.
In other words, it's a deflation that increases the value of the fruit.
Because as a result, things will not sell and become unprofitable.
Even if it was a bad war, I tried to make it worth it and distribute it.
If Nobunaga was able to make an effective economic policy, he shouldn't have to do such a troublesome thing.
Toyotomi Hideyoshi led the Japanese economy to stability by moving it from Kanda Maritime to Kokuda Maritime.
Nobunaga's father, Oda Nobuhide, gained economic power by ruling Tsushima and Atsuta.
I think Nobunaga learned how to do it well from his childhood.
The fact that Nobunaga was strong in economics was nothing more than the acceptance of the knowledge he inherited from his father.
In terms of economics, his father was a person who could do it.
Finally, in terms of military.
It's natural for the military to expand if you have economic power.
Even if I point out that part, Nobunaga is by no means an excellent commander.
Certainly, in the famous battle of Okehazama, he won a miraculous victory, but he lost a lot in other battles.
In the Echizen attack of Genki Gannen, he was defeated by the betrayal of Gitei Azai Nagamasa.
In the battle of Noda Fukushima of the same year, he defeated Miyoshi, but he was attacked from behind.
Also, in the battle of Nagashino, he defeated the Takeda army by creating a large-scale crowd.
If Takeda Katsuyori hadn't actively attacked and set up Poka, the decisive battle would probably have ended in vain.
In the Nagashima attack, he was defeated twice in a row and was cornered to the point where his life was in danger.
Now that you mention it, Nobunaga has lost quite a bit in the drama.
I feel sorry for him compared to the genius warriors such as Takeda Shingen and Uesugi Kenshin.
Even if you compare it to the history of Tokugawa Ieyasu and Toyotomi Hideyoshi, Nobunaga's weakness stands out.
Finally, the first place is...
The winner of the tiger extermination was actually not a big deal?
It's Kato Kiyomasa.
What? It's just a tiger extermination, and in the drama it's also the image of a martial arts warrior?
Kato Kiyomasa is said to have played an active role in all kinds of battles as a martial arts warrior outside of Hideyoshi.
Alongside Masanori Fukushima, he is very famous as one of the Seven Spears of the Shizugatake.
However, the number of Kiyomasa's lies remaining is actually a possibility that is not too much.
What? It's too unexpected.
First of all, Kiyomasa doesn't have a clear martial art.
In the battle of the Shizugatake, he was said to have defeated Yamaji Masakuni, the great general of the Shibatagata, but in reality he was beheaded by Gozaemon Hozumi.
Why is it that Kiyomasa has been defeated?
In fact, Yoshikawa Eiji, the writer, wrote that there was such a technique in the Shinsho Taikouki, and it became a common theory.
By the way, Kikuchikan, the writer, has expressed it like this in Nihon Katsentan.
Kato Kiyomasa was embarrassed that there was not much martial arts other than Yamaji Shogen, but Yamaji Shogen is also close to a legend.
In addition, in the battle of Yamazaki, Akechigata's Shioten Masataka was shot, and Shimazu's victory, Niiro Tadamoto and Tokkumi Ai were all just a story of composition.
No way, it's not a story of composition until the extermination of the famous Kiyomasa tiger, is it?
It's certainly a picture of Kiyomasa swinging a spear and fighting a tiger, but it seems that it was actually shot down with a gun, not a spear.
Eeeeee! It's kind of shocking.
And when Kiyomasa became the representative of the Defender Rebellion, it seems that he did not fight alone, but even so, no major injuries were confirmed.
In Odawara Jyozeme, there was no major battle as a whole, and it was in a surrounding battle, and in Chosen Shippei, it succeeded in a sudden attack, but it was far from the main battlefield and did not participate in the main battle.
It can be confirmed that he participated in the battle of Ulsan Castle, but Kiyomasa only went to jail, and it was Mori Hidemoto and Kuroda Nagamasa who actually made a great contribution, including the reinforcements.
In Chosen Shippei, I had the image that I had a hard time.
By the way, when the battle of Sekigahara took place, Kiyomasa himself was on the defense of Ryogoku.
It wasn't the Tohgun from the beginning, and he was not on either side of the Tohgun, but on the side of Hiyorimi.
However, it seems that there was a reason that he joined the Tohgun because he was beaten to death by Kuroda Jyosui, who was in charge of northern Kyushu, and he was sure that he could doubt each other if he did not surrender to the Tohgun now.
Huh? Was he threatened by Kuroda Jyosui and moved?
Kiyomasa. From what I've heard so far, Kiyomasa doesn't feel like a winner, but a simple, mediocre minister.
If there is a reason why Kiyomasa was able to succeed, it may be that he was attracted to him because he was a member of Hideyoshi.
It is common sense that he served Hideyoshi for a long time since he was a child and served him for a long time.
However, Kiyomasa is a person who ruled the country of Higo well and established Kumamoto Castle, the most famous castle in the world.
In that respect, Kiyomasa may be able to say that he has hidden his extraordinary talent.
This time, I talked about Sengoku Bushou 7, which is very different from the rumors and the truth, but how was it?
I was surprised that the famous minister I admired did not play an active role.
I wonder if the influence of the story of the drama and creation is great.
So that's it for this explanation.
Please watch it next time as well.
Please also subscribe to the channel and rate it highly.
Thank you for watching.
