While we await word on the length of Tyler Herro's absence due to a sprained ankle, Ethan and Alex evaluate the options to start, the ways to generate offense and the argument from some that Herro is "injury prone."
Sponsors: BettorEdge (5RSN), Manscaped (5RSN)
Join us on Off The Floor Discord server! Get exclusive updates/information/stats from the 5OTF crew and hang out with other Heat fans!
If you’re interested in sponsoring Five Reasons, contact us at [email protected]
welcome to latest episode of five on the
floor in the five reason Sports Network
thanks for joining us on your favorite
podcast app Google podcast Apple podcast
red circle Spotify also the five Reon
YouTube channel make sure you hit like
make sure you hit like subscribe turn
the notifications on also check out our
off the floor feed it's posted right to
the top of my Twitter page at five
reasons sports that's where you get all
Des content yeah subscription pay for
the subscription it's $2.99 per month
we're not trying to also also in the
description just so so people will know
oh it's in the Des okay pay pay for the
subscription it's in the description all
right so check it out off the floor you
get host updates you also get 247 heat
chats you get non-nba chats you get NBA
chats you get everything it's in our
Discord we're almost at 200 members so
we appreciate the support also check out
the great sponsors of the five reason
Sports Network that includes better Edge
use the code five RSN you get $20 to
play at better edge.com our contests are
only like three bucks or 10 bucks so you
do the math you're playing against
others who use it you're not playing
against a bookie or anything like that
that's why it is legal in the state of
Florida and 43 other states so check it
out at better edge.com use the code five
RSN and now today's
episode five on the floor ride for my
dogs where here the thing you can check
the score Hustle Hard couple scars
bubble frog just like bu said you in
trouble y check the plan got it all B
y'all seen the block stop with one hand
and P trust it's F have the guts we here
to bring the heat y'all can hang it
up welcome to five on the floor a daily
Insider show on the Miami Heat and the
NBA featuring Ethan scholet Greg sander
and Alex Toledo plus others from the
five reasons Sports
Network all right welcome back to five
on the floor here's today's floor plan
I'm Ethan skolnick you can follow me at
Ethan J skck at five Reon Sports we got
Alex Leo you can follow at Tropical
blanket make sure you check out last
night's episode we had Brady and Greg on
with us as well to break down the Heats
win in Memphis that got them to four and
four on the season excuse me now they've
got Atlanta up next and they continue
this stretch of nine games in 10 on the
road they've only got a home game
against Brooklyn to break that up in a
few days but the big story last night
Tyler hero came down after shooting a
floater stepped on Jaren Jackson Jr's
foot twisted his ankle badly it blew up
he ended up hobbling to the locker room
after the game in the locker room he
said that he heard a crunch and a crack
to and that essentially he would be out
for a couple of weeks now people
panicked today when they saw the report
from Anthony Chang and others that he'd
obviously released a statement to a
couple of De beat writers saying that uh
hero had left the team we expected that
to happen and had gone home to meet with
harlon selnik who is the team's
orthopedist and he was listed as a
surgeon which he is so everybody freaked
out out about that but I can just tell
you from my experience being around the
Heat and also from knowing harand they
all meet with Harland this is not
something that's unusual again the word
freaked everyone out but that they'll
he's an orthopedist they're going to
they're going to have in addition to
obviously uh meeting with Jay Sable Etc
they're going to have their uh their
players meet with the team orthopedist
uh for the best course of action so I
don't think this is anything unusual if
we get an update that says that he's
having surgery or something will'll let
you know but I would be very surprised
uh the X-ray came back negative the MRI
also so uh this just this a sprained
ankle um now we'll see the severity
could be high ankle sprain sometimes
those takes a little bit longer but he
is going to be out a couple of weeks so
this is not good I mean there's no way
around this and in the second half of
the episode we will get into the
specifics of the offense which has been
awful with Tyler off the floor like 16
points per 100 possessions worse when
he's not playing as opposed to when he
is playing and no matter what anybody
wants to say about him dominating the
ball or any of the rest of this by the
way he has the second highest usage rate
on the team not the first bam has the
first Jimmy's thirdd but he was a core
offensive player for them and he's been
good uh there's no other way to put it
like I mean you can call him Elite not
Elite whatever he's been good he's been
important and this is a team that
doesn't have a ton of scoring on it so
Alex I'll go to you first on this well
because you're the only one here uh and
but we'll go to the topic that's first
on this because this is the one that he
fans are going to Pivot to right away
who starts
and and I guess there's two questions
here who should start and who will start
in your view let's start with the who
should start they may be the same person
but who should start in your
opinion yeah unfortunately it's going to
be the same person for me um not that I
can't hear Arguments for other people
but yeah I think the one who will start
and should start is is Duncan um you you
can convince me otherwise on should just
because I can kind of see it both ways
if you tell me if you feel like you know
SPO is one to um want to keep things
that are working well keep working well
and one of the things that has been is
Duncan coming off the bench and he's
like him along with hak that's been kind
of like their their two best bench
players and so maybe he doesn't want to
mess with that because the bench units
have already been so so bad and you know
kind of just the lineups in between
throughout a game um they they haven't
been great so I don't know if he wants
to take away one of the actual good
pieces from the the bench throw it into
the starting lineup um but that's would
be the cleanest fit I think Duncan we
already know what he can do it fits
really well around their best players
and it's easy to see um how it would
work now like if you just want to make a
guy like Caleb the starter when he comes
back he kind of deserves it after the
way he played last season he would
obviously be playing a really really
different role than either Tyler or
Duncan and you wouldn't want him to
replace those guys but you know I I
could I could be convinced into saying
star Caleb too I said it before the
season I wouldn't mind him starting um
and would probably start him over Josh
um but this is a different scenario of
course it would be starting alongside
Kyle Lowry and not Tyler herro so it's a
little weird Kyle would need to keep
shooting the way he did last night um
for for that to work out and the offense
might be a little clunky but that would
be leaning defense and I think kind of
that's what they should do overall with
their lineups is lean defense so look
I'm not against a guy like Caleb
starting he I don't know when he's
coming back other than that I don't
really see who else should be starting
how about you yeah to me it's Duncan
also and there are two other options
right now well three when Caleb is back
okay so Kyle's GNA start obviously that
was happening anyway and the way he
played last night he's not being pulled
from the lineup they don't have enough
ball handling um people knew my feelings
about him starting before the season but
they are where they are and he's going
to start so now it becomes okay who
compliments him the best so there were
three options I think that they could go
with but I think it should be Duncan and
I think it will be Duncan so Duncan is
one and you hit on it um he's become
much better at creation than he was
before we went through a sequence on
playback today three straight plays late
in that game he created the play and he
used to just create it with his gravity
but now he's creating it uh with
downhill driving uh and and decisions
he's making the fight now there were
some decisions he made late in that game
that were not great um and and my
concern about Duncan is kind of
like it it's almost I to me it's
diminishing returns sometimes when he
plays more and so I'm curious to see how
spoler manages his minutes as a starter
I think he's been very effective this
year we were talking on playback okay
who has solidified themselves as players
they can TR that spure can trust and and
I think in terms of exceeding the
expectation level I think Haywood heith
and haime hawz are
onew but Duncan's been three I think
Duncan's been right there with them
where you say you've gotten a little bit
more from him than maybe we anticipated
coming into the season he did build on
what he did in the finals last year and
in the playoffs when honestly he was
more effective than stru for good
portions of it so I'm fine with Duncan
starting he's been in that role before
he started with Lowry before there's a
comfort level there and obviously
there's a comfort level with bam so I I
have no issue with him starting but I
still think he should be a player who
should be on the 20 to 27 minute range
in minutes and not much higher than that
the other options you could start
Hopkins now that that's different
because then you're asking him to spot
up shoot more um we saw him in the
starting lineup did put him in the
starting lineup in a different position
a couple games ago he plays really well
next to Jimmy in the limited time that
we've seen so far but we kind of like
him better coming off the bench right
now and kind of uh filling that
offensive role Off the Bench and also
the defense that he's provided but just
kind of plugging the holes there i'
almost rather start yic than hakz right
now that might be an out of the you know
like out of the box one that we don't
see but it would like track with the
idea that like you know when when an
injury happens like this SP bring
somebody into the starting lineup who
wasn't there before totally different
position though I mean because then
you're really talking about sliding
you're going bigger then because you're
slide you're sliding Jimmy and Haywood
down um but the other the other options
here though see the option that would
have been the obvious option before the
season that I think is not an option
right now because of the way he's
playing is Josh and you mentioned it
like I don't I'm not really even
considering that right now I don't think
SPO would go to that with the way that's
Josh is shooting right now and seems to
be having trouble finding a fit in the
offense I don't know that starting him
makes that any better we also saw that
after spoler played him for all 48
minutes of the previous four fourth
quarters he didn't play down the stretch
in this last game uh with some of the
decision making and the shooting
struggles that he's had so I I don't
think it will be Josh I don't think
right now it should be Josh I know I I
campaigned for him to start before the
season but honestly I have not been
overwhelmed in a positive way by what
I've seen and that kind of tracks with
what I heard in trading Camp even before
he got hurt which I think is one of the
reasons when Kyle wanted to start there
wasn't that much of a protest from the
heat coaching staff about that because I
don't think Josh popped in a significant
way the other guy you mentioned is Caleb
and that just comes down to when he
comes back now I know they've wanted to
use him as a Swiss army knife six-man
type fill any role Off the Bench but we
also do know that SPO likes to pull
someone like you said from out there and
Caleb is out there he hasn't played with
the exception of one game in which he
was limited you could put him in the
starting lineup without screwing with
the bench rotations too much and then
the the the the task for SPO is how to
Anchor the bench because it's pretty
clear now with t Tyler we said this on
playback too Tyler has anchored the
bench better than Jimmy has at least in
terms of the numbers like when you put
the four guys out there with Tyler
they've been better than the four guys
with Jimmy I guess he's going to have to
anchor the bench with bam now and maybe
that means subbing love in for Bryant
and playing love at the four and not
going with a traditional backup center I
that's something I was thinking about
after we did the playback that because
he has to get he has he can't sit Jimmy
and Bam we we talked about this last
year he cannot sit Jimmy and Bam
together without Tyler like with with
with he could do it and it worked okay
with Tyler anchoring the four bench guys
he can cannot do it without Tyler not
with this group he doesn't have Max
anymore he doesn't have Gabe anymore his
options are a little bit different and
it didn't even work when he had Max and
Gabe so I think that could be a lean
here where you could start Caleb leave
hakz where he is leave Duncan where he
is and then sub love in for Bryant with
that group and anchor it with bam I when
you're not Anor with Jimmy like that's I
I would say SPO thinks in layers he
doesn't think okay it's just the
starters and then eventually we'll get
to he's thinking what's the next
rotation what's the next stagger just
something that I would throw out there
but I think it's go I think because
Caleb's not healthy right now even
though he's on the trip I think it's
gonna be Duncan because it's the it's
the most seamless fit and he can do some
of the things that Tyler was doing
although not at that level yeah I'm with
you and as far as like the lineup stuff
that's I've been just non stop talking
about that because I just think they
really haven't found the right mix um
like you see a lot of these lineups and
we talked about this on playback as well
it seems like SPO had settled into um
you know a usual rotation of lineups
that we kept seeing when when everybody
was there it's like I think now is a
perfect opportunity to change to kind of
mess with that a little bit because I
don't think what they've had is worth
like you know quote unquote not messing
with right like their bench their bench
unit as a whole hasn't been good and
well I wouldn't say hasn't been hasn't
been great because some of the guys like
I said between um hakz and Duncan have
been you know great for them off the
bench and so if you want to just talk
about keeping them there I understand it
but like you know you know you were
going into whether or not love can come
in and take Thomas Bryant's back up five
minutes I think that has to do with the
lineups as well like and I I think if
you throw a lineup out there where you
know let's say m comes out first and
Jimmy's over there with Kevin Love as
the spacing five I think SPO has leaned
into that before um you know he did it
last season When Love Was there and they
found something and it was reminiscent
of what they did with Kelly the first
season I think that's something that
they should really really consider
because and again not to go into repeat
from what we were saying on playback but
I I really don't think you're doing any
favors from anybody from like the
lineups you had out there with Tyler
Duncan and Thomas Bryant um so if you
just replace Bryant with love there I
don't think you're going to be doing
those guys any favors I do I would like
to see him play but like you mentioned
then um you know he doesn't really need
to rush into that he knows what love is
going to give him and he can do that
whenever he wants you know Thomas Bryant
is supposed to be kind of an Innings
eater throughout the season he's 25
years old he was pretty productive when
he plays and I just think like you see
why um he was cast out of rotations in
the past um and even with the limited
you know kind of a limited role that
he's getting right now Off the Bench you
still see it so when he's not giving you
like a few buckets in the paint it's
like okay what are you really here for
because you're supposed to be this
offense a big man who rebounds the
rebounding is fine screening is fine but
with love you know for a fact you're
going to get a spaced out floor and you
can really pair that with Jimmy and and
I think those lineups are something that
I will be confident about because you
know Jimmy gets more space to go
downhill uh you know less crowded paint
I I love those lineups and I think
that's not that like a lineup like that
would fix everything but just in general
finding the right mix of lineups that
work together I think is going to be the
the key to this season especially with
all the playable bodies they have
because like you can't just keep playing
these lineups that are just clearly not
working and I think some of them like
don't wouldn't even work on paper so um
not to keep hammering that home but
that's where I'm at with this it's like
the Tyler thing sucks they're gonna have
to find ways to replicate it and we're
going to talk about it in the second
half but other than that use this time
to experiment with different things
different looks different lineups and
see what some of these guys can give you
I think without Caleb you have to stick
with a ninan maybe an eight man rotation
I would play yic some minutes just to
give you some offense um you know he can
move the ball I I think the offense
looks pretty good when when he's been in
there and now this is the type of chance
where like I think you want a little bit
of offensive infusion um and I don't
think Drew Smith is giving you that I
think they have a lot of defensive
pieces and now you got to mess with
different looks I think all right when
we come back from the break we're gonna
get into sort of the larger conversation
about Tyler and where they go from here
but first another word from one of our
sponsors
football season is back and you know
what that means touchdown dances Sunday
tailgates and Epic Fantasy showdowns but
fellas let's not forget the real MVP of
the Season introducing the allnew beard
hedger Pro kit by manscape your ultimate
luxury beard grooming experience this
kit is your secret weapon for staying
sharp on and off the field don't fumble
this opportunity head to manscape.com
and elevate your grooming game with the
beard hedger Pro kit join the 9 million
men worldwide who trust manscaped you
heard that right 9 million men are 109
MetLife stadiums that we shouldn't be
talking about New York so go to
manscape.com it's not even New York it's
New Jersey go to manscape.com and get
20% off and free shipping with the code
5 RSN again 20% off and free shipping
with the code 5 RSN your grass is not
artificial keep it shaved with
manscaped all right so there's a larger
uh philosophical debate going on on X or
Twitter or whatever you want to call it
I actually kind of want to uh hit on it
here because
th this annoys me Alex I'm just going to
be honest with you I don't want to
single out uh particular Heat fans many
of whom I greatly respect and may have
good opinions on other
topics this idea of Tyler hero is being
injury-prone because he's making a
basketball play getting to his
floater and steps on an ankle when we
know that Jimmy Butler steps on like
four five six ankles or or or foot feet
a year it happened anybody who's ever I
mean gez I blew out my knee stepping on
a foot I've been having surgeries every
the last 30 years okay I guess I'm
injury-prone um it's just it's it's
basketball and and this narrative that
has it I'm not surprised about the
narrative from outside of Heat fans but
that it's a narrative inside heat you
know the heat family so to speak makes
no sense to me I mean let's look at
Tyler's injuries like he's diving for a
loose ball in the playoffs last year
okay maybe it wasn't the best decision
but he's making a hustle play it wasn't
a fake hustle play he was trying to make
a play and this one he's getting to his
floater I you know to me a player is
injury-prone when they're not
conditioned and so they're they're
having a lot of like hamstring injuries
or groin injuries or they're pulling
this or they're pulling that or they
stay out longer than really they should
have Tyler hasn't necessarily stayed out
longer than he should have been again he
broke a I mean he broke a a hand last
year like is his shooting hand I I don't
I don't know why people are making this
and I'm not saying everybody it's a very
small contingent I'm sure okay but
making this a referendum on Tyler that
you can't trust him you can't count on
him that last night doesn't change any
of that and it doesn't shouldn't change
whether or not they keep him long term
am am I wrong about this but it's the
same thing with Tua and I'm like with
two I'm like okay the concussion thing
like that's a serious thing like that
you have to be concerned about that
going forward because one can lead to
another lead to another they get worse
it's easier to get them Etc but some of
the stuff on two I didn't understand and
the stuff on Tyler I don't understand at
all again am I wrong no I don't think
you're wrong I don't really understand
it either um I think people who that
already felt that way about him before
that or maybe perhaps it's like a thing
where they kind of just wanted him off
the team or any excuse to get him off
the team regardless which is fine you
can have that opinion I just don't agree
I I don't agree like I think it's been
freak stuff that happens and and like
you said I mean spring ankles when
playing
basketball um it's extremely Common Man
like there's it's a lot of feet in the
paint a lot of jumping going on guys
aren't like accounting for other
people's feet in these you know In the
Heat of the Moment like stuff like that
happens all the time especially when
you're you know driving into the paint
you know going for a rebound I mean God
knows it's how I messed up my ankle but
uh and and I've sprained my ankle a
countless amount of times not that I'm
representative of anything I'm
definitely not a high level athlete by
any means but um just in general it's
really common so I just really don't
take any you know I don't put any weight
into that at all I think Tyler was
playing ball and it's just kind of an
unfortunate thing that happened just
like the Milwaukee thing and so the the
MRI did come out negative then you said
right I I I thought I saw that somewhere
I'll have to check on that after the
podcast but as far as any significant
damage I don't believe that there is any
but how long he's going to be out again
that's dependent on where the ankle
sprain is and there there there is
different severity on that and some some
some players come back quicker than
others but this idea that Tyler would
not try to come back quicker or that he
doesn't put the work in is just wrong I
like you said everybody's injury PR
prone on a basketball court like you're
you're injury-prone as soon as you're
out there and he's attacking the
defensive player of the year I mean
that's how he got hurt I would rather he
attacked the defensive player of the
year than be afraid to attack the
defensive player of the year
and just again a freak thing happens
there and then the bigger the bigger
conversation I have is how do they
survive him survive it which we'll get
to in a second what you got really
quickly just wanted to clear up so um
Anthony changen in his article I don't
know if there's been any new information
that's come out ever since but in his
article he said the X-ray on Heroes
injured ankle returned clean and he was
set to undergo an MRI today so I don't
know if the MRI results have come out
ever since but x-ray clean MRI results
still pending at this point
I thought I saw somewhere but I didn't
get it officially that it was clear so
we'll see and again maybe it's happening
at this moment so we'll find out later
this afternoon but MRIs on ankle
injuries are not usually particularly
definitive anyway um swelling goes down
at different times for different people
and and again a lot of it is where it is
okay uh in terms of and and also of
course where what the grade of it is um
and MRIs don't always give all of that
away so we'll see I mean look Jimmy
dealt with the ankle during the play
playoffs last year and it never got
right the entire time I mean he probably
would have taken two to three weeks off
if it hadn't been never got rested post
he never got to rested so they're G to
be very careful with Tyler on this and I
guess just before we close here and
thanks to our sponsors manscape and
better Edge make sure you're using the
code 5 RSN make sure you sign up for the
off the floor Discord make sure that you
sign up we're going to start promoting
the hell out of this the next week for
our our second 2K tournament at Rock
Esports Center um down in pometto Bay
we're going to be there on the 18th for
the game I'll be there this time uh for
a watch party and then also for the 2K
tournament afterwards but I I guess it's
this and we'll we'll try to do this here
in a minute I mean let's say he's out
two to three weeks what what is the goal
here because last year he went out they
went to the
finals quation is not correlation this
is a different team this year it's
different in the regular season when you
got to be without a guy for a long time
as opposed to a short Series where
you're just preparing for the same team
all the time but I mean he misses 10 12
games here let's say which I is a
perfectly reasonable amount I think
based on what we saw and how it blew up
last night is just just to tread water
at this point I mean how much of a game
can you find without him it's really
hard man as as has been pointed out
before like their offense really falls
off a cliff without Tyler um and I think
at that point you know usually what what
you see happen with the heat over the
years like in the Jimmy era is they kind
of scale their three volume up a little
bit when a guy is out especially when
it's like a Jimmy you know that's when
you really really see it when Jimmy's
out and they play a little faster and
more and a bunch of Threes are going up
how are you gonna do that how how how
can you do that without Tyler like
Duncan might start and you could scale
and you could scale up his role a little
bit and you know that's that makes a lot
of sense like Duncan playing more
throughout this time is probably
expected like they need a guy who can
help their offense flow even if it's not
him taking the shots he he he makes
stuff happen for sure and I think that
that's what it ends up coming down to is
who are the guys in the team who can
make stuff happen for you on offense and
I'm being broad there and vague on
purpose because I just think that's what
it's about at this point and you got to
go for guys who can make plays that's
why I like the idea of yic not even
necessarily starting but just playing I
I think if this is the exact time that
we would expect him to right not
necessarily because of hero being out
but just like we we predicted for him
that he would get playing time when when
important players were out I think he
makes stuff happen on offense he looks
confident um even in the half court I
know everybody loves to point out the
transition stuff and that's amazing I
love it you know grab and go he he loves
to attack and transition but even in the
half court he knows how to make the
right play and he's not necessarily like
a big time scorer himself but the
confidence was there in the time we saw
with the shot um I like the way that he
attacks a close out I like the way he's
attacking the basket he's always looking
to make the right play so I just think
having guys like that who who will make
something happen on offense you know
maybe find the open guy it it makes
sense and not necessarily you know it
doesn't only apply to yic that's I feel
like now you're going to see hopefully
more hakz um on ball creation when a guy
when Jimmy is Off the Bench right like
you said earlier more I mean jimmmy and
Bam hard staggering not where they don't
play with each other but you know after
the starting lineup you always have to
have one of them two and and and I
already felt that way before when it
comes to you know Jimmy bam and Tyler
but now without Tyler I think you have
to do that I think you have to have one
of those two guys on the floor at all
times because this team is already not
didn't project to be a good regular
season team and it's kind of like you
know we expect them to be you know maybe
a bit better than last season but now
without Tyler the margin for Eric just
gets so much smaller and I think you
have to make up for it however you can
so more guys who make plays with the
ball you know maybe a couple of more
minutes for Jimmy and Bam just make sure
they're always one of the two is always
on the floor more minutes for Duncan and
and honestly the other thing is this is
the time to find your identity on the
defensive end get back to being great at
what you do when it comes to forcing
turnovers um you know being a good
defensive rebounding team boxing out
just kind of locking in on the
fundamentals of the things you're
already supposed to be good at because
they need to find that defensive
identity that defense defense first um
identity and then I think the offense
will become a little bit easier if
you're getting all those easy buckets
winning the turnover battle The
Possession battle but yeah that that's
that's where I'm at with it well I think
the hardest thing here you mentioned at
the very beginning is usually you would
scale up your three-point shooting but
you just lost your arguably your best
three-point shooter so
somebody somebody else is going to have
to hike the volume here and be efficient
and I don't know that a lot of their
guys are capable of that like I I think
a little more from high Smith maybe
maybe Caleb some threes when he comes
back Jimmy uh has hiked his volume a
little bit from three and been somewhat
efficient but I don't know that's what
you want him doing all the time but they
don't have a ton of Specialists on this
team who all of a sudden they're just
going going to start spreading the for
and bombing away 45 times it's just not
then it's not it's not built that way
the way previous heat teams were built
I'm with you to me it's about defense
and when Caleb comes back it's about
getting to that closing lineup where
you've got Caleb and you've got Haywood
and you got bam and you got Jimmy
anchoring that thing and you just keep
people from scoring at the end of games
make enough free throws and that's how
they won a lot of those clutch games we
know that no matter what they're doing
in a game they're going to end up in a
clutch game they cannot blow people out
they're incapable of it um and then they
start to have fourth quarter
miscues and all the rest and it just
really comes down to getting a stop or
making one shot they've done that three
times this year to win games um they're
gonna have to keep doing it without
Tyler it's not going to be easy uh
Atlanta next again thanks to our
sponsors manscaped and better Edge have
a good day everybody thank you for
listening to the five on the floor on
the Fire Ring Sports Network after all
someone needs to listen to my
dad