Siyamak sits down with Diane Dixon, assemblymember with California’s legislature. Today she will talk about the new ballot measures that will make it easier to raise taxes in California, and what challenges California is facing with possible deficits in the future.
"The bad news is that the deficit is going to be greater the tax. The state income tax revenues will be lower. The state doesn't know what's coming in. They keep pushing it away."
California taxes. We're one of the top states in the country for taxes.
The State Department of Finance is projecting deficits for the next several years. Here's why.
Money income leaving California, because it goes with the taxpayer, going to Arizona,
going to Texas, going to Nevada, going to Florida, to the low-tax states. You're only
going to spend what you make. California spends what they think they're going to make,
and then they hope for the best, and they'll just push it to the next year.
My guest today is Diane Dixon, Assemblymember with California's Legislature. Today,
she'll talk about the new ballot measures that will make it easier to raise taxes in California,
and what challenges California is facing with possible deficits in the future.
If I were the governor, it would drive me nuts. I told you we are in a deficit,
no more new spending. Why doesn't anybody send them a bill that reduces spending? We're going
to eliminate this program. We did an audit. They're not effective. They're not solving the
homeless problem, so we're going to cut money out of here and give it directly to the counties to
improve homelessness. That'll never happen, because the state wants the money.
I'm Siamak Korami. Welcome to California Insider. Diane, it's great to have you. Welcome.
Well, Siamak, it's great to be here. I love APOC News, and you're providing a huge service
to the information-needing public, so thank you, and thank you for inviting me here.
Thank you, thank you. We want to talk to you about some very important topic that we haven't
covered in a long time. It's taxes, and California taxes. We're one of the top states in the country
for taxes, and there are a couple of- If not the top, one or two.
It's either Hawaii or the second one. New York, Hawaii, and California.
And there is a couple of laws that are coming, and you've been vocal about these laws,
and they're going to be ballot measures. Can you explain what these are?
Sure. California legislature, the dominant party, has never met a tax they didn't like,
so this has been going on for several years to raise taxes, raise taxes, raise taxes.
The two, as you mentioned, ACA1, which will become ballot measure something,
and then there's another ACA13. They could be confusing, so let me explain them a little bit.
ACA1 would lower the Proposition 13 requirement of, mandated in the Constitution,
two-thirds vote to increase any tax, okay? ACA1 would reduce that two-thirds
to 55%. Let me explain why that's important. Two-thirds is hard to get. A tax increase,
the imposition of new taxes, a tax increase on people, should be hard to do.
Otherwise, it'll be done regularly, and the sky's the limit.
So is the two-third from the public vote, or is it from...
Yes, the people voting. Right now, it requires any tax, fiscal-related measure, requires a two-thirds
vote. Locally and statewide?
No, I'll get to local, but this is state.
Statewide, okay.
ACA1 would reduce the two-thirds to 55%, and the language in the proposition
says this is for affordable housing. We all know that there's a housing crisis,
so this is to tug a little bit on our heartstrings. Yes, we have to build new housing,
and public infrastructure. Oh yes, we do need roads and highways. So that's kind of the
selling proposition to get people to think, well, oh, I guess the money that's... If they
raise my taxes, I guess it's going to a good purpose. There are other ways to get to that
money, and I'll get to that. But changing the two-thirds requirement that's been in place
since Prop 13 was passed and put into the state constitution in 1978 to protect taxpayers,
to make it more difficult to pass tax increases. At the local level over the last 40 years,
each individual city, many, many, many cities and counties in California, the local governments
have independently, and especially in Orange County, California, where we are, most Orange
County cities, I think nearly all 34 of them, have individually passed a requirement that
requires a two-thirds vote for that government body to raise money, well, to submit it to a
voter approval. So this is all to be, any tax increase must be approved by the voters, the
taxpaying public, because the tax increase comes through their property taxes. I opposed ACA 1
because I don't, let me put it this way, it is chipping away, it is destroying the protections
to taxpayers that Proposition 13 created in 1978. There has not been an increase in property tax
process since 1978, when it was frozen at two-thirds, and then the method of property taxes
were, it was. So this has to do only with property tax then? Correct. Okay. Yeah, that's where the
money comes from. Okay, on the bulk of the money that funds the state of California,
funds local government, comes from property taxes. Okay, so they want to, ACA 1 would change that
from two-thirds to majority, to 55 percent. So wham-bam taxes get increased. Where, why it is so,
I say bad for the people, is that every property owner, as well as people who rent their property,
will be impacted by higher property taxes, because now it's only 55 percent. Wham-bam,
you can get it passed by any government, any, the state legislature would love, would love to pass a
new tax, and the only thing that keeps them back is getting that two-thirds vote. It's hard to get
two-thirds vote. So doesn't it increase rent then? Precisely, so the landlord, so if homeowner would
get a higher property tax, it will increase their property taxes on the tax bill that they pay, and
their property taxes. Not everybody owns a home. Anybody who rents a property or a business, a
small business, you know, your local hair salon, barbershop, restaurant, shoe repair, stationary
store, their rent will go up. And who pays their rent? The consumer. So consumer price is the price
of goods and services to cover the landlord's increased property taxes. The landlord passes
in and down to the cost of goods sold, and there goes the price of consumer goods. It trickles down.
We all pay. So essentially from what you're saying, which it just came to me that rents will go up
for, for average people that can't afford to buy real estate. Correct. And the ones that are buying
real estate, potentially their tax will go up. Of course. It will make housing more expensive. Yes,
and during this period of time where housing is not affordable, the whole focus of government is
to create more affordable housing. You have one arm creating, wanting to create more affordable
housing, and the other side saying, well, we're going to tax them more so there'll be more money
for building affordable housing, but it's going to be more expensive. It could be sales tax. It
could be any tax. And that is the wisdom of a two-thirds vote. Make it difficult to increase
taxes. Taxes should not be easy to levy. Should be difficult because we all have, and it's,
and it's regressive. It hits lower income people more. Especially with the property tax and sales
tax, right? And disproportionate in the cost of goods. Because their rent will go up. Gas taxes,
everything else. It's two-thirds vote, but this is creating a majority vote that would affect
property taxes. Okay. The other measure, ACA 13, on the same ballot, November in 2024,
is kind of a tricky, I call it a trick. It would increase, this is going to be confusing for
people. I hope people will be so confused they vote no on both, really. This would make it,
there's a key word. It's very hard to understand these ballot measures, like what is no mean, what
is yes mean. They purposely make it, they purposely make it confusing. And this one will be even more
confusing. ACA 1 would increase taxes, vote no. ACA 13, vote no. For this reason, it would require
a two-thirds vote to limit taxes. So it's a complete inverse. So instead of protecting
taxpayers on the increase, we'll say, no, we don't want to protect you. We don't want to protect our
taxpayers because we want to be able to increase taxes and require a two-thirds vote. If you have
an idea, C-Mac, that you want to limit taxes and protect people, we're going to make you have to
get to two-thirds vote. In other words, it'll be again easier to increase, to keep taxes high,
because if you want to reduce them, it requires a two-thirds vote. It's, excuse me, it's very
confusing. It will be very confusing to people. Hopefully they'll just vote no on both. To understand the
language of this. That one word, limit, requires a two-thirds vote of the people to limit taxes.
And people may skip over that word. Yeah, yeah. So they may read two-thirds vote to increase taxes and
people say, oh, that's a good thing. That, well, that's strange. That's the opposite of ACA 1.
No, to limit, meaning taxes will always be high. It will be hard to reduce taxes. Bottom line,
it will be hard to reduce high level of taxes because it will require a two-thirds vote to
limit it, to reduce them. Now, Diane, you have been in the assembly for, it's been almost a year now, right?
Nine, well, I was elected a year ago almost, yes. So where does all this money go?
Well, first of all, it's not enough. You may remember we have, we're operating in a deficit
situation, $20 billion deficit. And you know how they deal with that. I come out of local
government. I served on the Newport Beach City Council for eight years. I served as mayor for
two years. I was chair of the finance committee for five years. So I'm very familiar with budgeting.
At the local level, it's very different from the state level. So at the local level, you get in the
revenues, you project your revenues, that's all you could spend. There's no such thing as deficit
spending at the local level. It's prohibited. You either have the money or you don't. Yes,
prohibited by the state constitution for cities. At the state level, they don't, the constitution
mandates a balanced budget. That is true. A balanced budget must be passed by the legislature
by June 15th of every year. And they work around in different ways. But anyway, June 15th,
they have it. We have a deficit, very real thing. So you know how they paper over the deficit.
They just push out from the next year, the proposed budget year, the new budget year.
Well, we won't spend 50 million, 100 million on this in 2024, the new budget year. We'll spend
that in 2025. So the new budget for 2024 gets balanced by pushing out to future years. They
don't cut the program. They just push out the budget. They cut it from the year after. Yeah.
Well, they don't cut it ever. I've never seen a program. So they try to raise more money. Is that
what they're trying to do? No, they just hope that more money will come in. It's kind of a
fool's errand because we're projecting deficits. The state department of finance is projecting
deficits for the next several years. Here's why. Simple mathematical equation. The IRS does an
annual analysis of where federal income tax revenues come from. And they could project,
there's a chart, the Wall Street Journal had this chart of all these arrows, money income,
leaving California, federal tax income, leaving California, and go in the taxpayer money. Because
it goes with the taxpayer, going to Arizona, going to Texas, going to Nevada, going to Florida,
to the low tax states. Those states do not have, either they have no income tax,
state income tax, or they have a very low. Arizona, I think, has 2.25%.
So the IRS released this information last spring that showed that California,
high, well, I don't know if they're high, but federal income tax earners have left California
and they've taken $50 billion with them to these other states in their federal tax
payments to Arizona, Texas, Florida, Nevada. $50 billion. What did I tell you how much our deficit
was? $30 billion. So it could continue to rise. People, over 350 companies, businesses, forget
how many people have moved out of California. That's not only business corporate tax that pays
to the state of California, that's employee income tax. It's moving not only their furniture,
they're taking their income to other low tax states. So back to the state budget question.
We have a $30 billion deficit. I might have said 20, it's $30 billion. And they just push out the
spending. They say, okay, we'll keep it flat this year when we have a deficit. So we push it to 2024
or 2025. So this budget year looks balanced. No cutting of programs. I'm not aware of any program.
So the program gets pushed into, or the payment gets pushed?
It's a continuing funding of an existing program. So there's no elimination of programs. It's not
zero-based budgeting. You know what zero-based budgeting is?
So every year it has to balance, right?
Well, no. Zero-based is you start from zero and build the budget from what's essential.
Oh, so it comes from the year before, okay, or whatever it's left.
Yeah. So they just continue it. They don't get rid of it. There's no 10% reduction. I worked
for a business, a corporation, a Fortune 300 company for 30 years. Every year that department
had in budget time said, okay, everybody has to cut 10%, whatever the economy's doing and for
whatever, or 5% or 3%. There'll only be 1% salary increases. This is how businesses operate.
And everybody goes, oh my gosh, we've got to do this. We've got to cut out this program.
Hopefully we don't have to eliminate any headcount, but we may have to.
If it's a recession, for example, then it's pretty tough times. But every department had in a
business, a business owner has to deal with a budget that fully is funded from the revenues
that are coming in. And then you have taxes to pay and all other kinds of costs. So the operating
costs of a business, you're only going to spend what you make. California spends what they think
they're going to make, and then they hope for the best and they'll just push it to the next year.
So then they hope the next year, if they didn't make that much, they hope the next year they'll
make more. Yes. And there won't be a deficit. But at the time we passed the 2024 budget,
the projection is that next year, the deficit, they don't even know yet,
that the deficit will be at least $10 billion. Let me tell you why no one knows.
Folks, you've probably been hearing me talk about WireEFI for a while now.
WireEFI has been getting a ton of phone calls from you, and I thank you for supporting an
investment that actually helps people. A lot of people are talking about this investment,
and I like to review the basics with you. First off, yes, it's true. You can earn up to 10.25%
fixed rate of return that's not correlated to the stock market or to the Fed. You can turn
your income on or off, compound it, whatever you choose, and there are absolutely no fees.
There are no restrictions on your principal if you ever need your money back, and you'll get
your monthly statement with no surprises. If you are not sure if you can trust this economy,
this secure collateralized portfolio may be a very good option for you. Just go to investwireefi.com
that's invest, the letter Y, then reefi.com. Folks, I take my endorsements very seriously.
If you're looking for a solid investment that helps people, contact my friends at WireEFI
and then tell them CMI Kurami sent you. Now let's go back to the interview.
Let me tell you why no one knows. The Franchise Tax Board, which is the state taxing authority,
and I guess the legislature did this before I got there, postponed the payment of the 2022
state income tax that was due April 15th, 2023. It was required to be paid October 15th,
2023. That was a week ago, two weeks ago. Then suddenly there was a news flash out of the
governor's office or wherever it came from, Franchise Tax Board, that said taxpayers have
more relief until November 15th, 2023 to pay their 2022 income tax. Okay, a couple of points
to be made. The state doesn't know what's coming in. They keep pushing it away and some-
But they've already budgeted their expenses, but they don't really know the income.
You're absolutely right. And some people are speculating that suddenly the governor has gone
to China, he's on a traveling, he's doing other things because the bad news is that the deficit
is going to be greater. The tax, the state income tax revenues will be lower. I mean, frightening.
I don't know that. I don't have the facts, but why would they have pushed it out? Because they
didn't want to get the bad news and he wanted to be out of the country with the bad news. That's
total speculation, but that could be the case. Anyway, it's still going to be less. More people
have left. High income people, middle income people, middle income jobs are disappearing
thanks to overregulation. That's a whole other topic we could talk about. But in any event,
back to your original question, where does the money go? It funds programs that audits are
few and far between, if at all. Now, for example, out of all of the $315 billion budget,
$20 billion in the last few years has been spent on homelessness. Do you think we've seen $20 billion
of improvement in homelessness in the state of California? I don't think so. The numbers are up.
Right. So it's just lack of transparency. So these programs, there is no auditing from the
legislative body. You know why I've learned? Because there are numerous different agencies
that this money gets chopped up in. It's not aggregated into a line item in the budget. This
is what you see at the local level. Line item, homelessness. You know exactly what the city is
spending. That's a true story. You know exactly. It used to be zero when there wasn't any homeless.
Now we've got all this homeless. And it went from, at the time I was on the Newport Beach City
Council, it went from zero to $5 million. Now I don't know what it is. So there are multiple,
dozens of agencies at the state and county level that are dealing with homelessness. And so I was
just at a meeting this morning. I asked this question, has anybody totaled up what everybody
is getting? Nobody knows. And there have been audits, requests, but it never, I haven't seen
the audit report. So that's a problem. Where does the money go? Back to the budgeting process. So I
will give credit where credit is due. So the governor, we adjourned for an interim session,
like we're in the district now until January. The governor had 30 days from September 15th,
14th to October 15th to approve or veto about 1,100 bills. And he did veto quite a number of
bills that cost money. And this is what's kind of, I don't know what to say, it's backwards
in how the state budgets. Because during, we heard the first part of last year, this year, 2023,
that the state had a $30 billion deficit. In parallel, the legislature is, each member of
the legislature is introducing legislation, is going through the policymaking process.
I sit on appropriations. Every bill that costs money comes before appropriations. So I see every
single bill that costs money. 2,600 bills all cost money. 1,100 of them got to the governor. They all
cost money. Many of those, he used the same phrase in his veto message, this costs money, we're in a
deficit, I'm vetoing it. So I'll give credit where credit is due. But I think I read somewhere that
$19 billion of new spending has been, he signed. I think that's correct. I need to check on that
for sure. So he still signs programs that are going to cost money. Everything costs money.
I've never seen, I'll say this, it's a partisan comment. I've never seen a Democrat vote no on
anything that costs money. How much, how much of thinking goes into like, how much of financial
thinking goes into the legislature? None, none, none. I've not heard anyone stand up or in a committee
hearing where some debate goes on, discussion, I wouldn't call it debate. I bring those things,
those issues up on appropriations and in local government committee I sit on. Specifically,
there's a bill he did veto, so I'll give him credit. It would have been a huge cost. The
unemployment insurance fund had fraud in the COVID period where money was just...
A lot of fraud.
Yeah, going to prisoners and credit cards and all this.
Which we covered in this show, a few episodes.
Oh, you did? Okay. So the fund is $19 billion unfunded. That was a loan from the federal
government. The state is not paying that back. Small business is paying that back.
And the fees that the small business pays to the state of California for their unemployment, for
every employee they pay into unemployment insurance. So during an appropriations hearing,
this was in early September, Senator Portatino from up in Pasadena had, because of the actor's
strike was going on, wanted to amend the unemployment insurance law to allow for
unemployment insurance payments to striking workers. No state allows striking workers,
because a strike is a voluntary activity. If you have a debate or negotiation with
the union that you belong to with the employer, you're choosing to go on strike.
Unemployment insurance for people who are laid off or cannot work for some reason, but striking
workers are voluntarily not working. His bill would have included striking workers to receive
unemployment. I mean, what kind of an incentive? It really tips the scales. You have employers
trying, working out negotiations with a union, but they're all getting paid to strike essentially.
And so what kind of incentive is that to resolve this conflict? I spoke on both the floor,
I guess, and the appropriations committee, because a member of the committee said,
well, the state of California has enough money, even though we have a deficit, they said we have
enough money. This doesn't cost very much. Nothing costs very much in these little bitty pieces,
but it all adds up. So the state should pay for these striking workers out of the unemployment.
And I say, excuse me, the state doesn't pay for unemployment, doesn't pay for the deficit,
the $19 billion deficit. Business pays. Big business, little business, small business
pays unemployment insurance. The worker does not pay. They pay to the state and then the state
pays them. Correct. But business pays, not the state of California. The money comes from
businesses. Business, not the state of California, not tax money. Every paycheck they're
paying is fine. So thankfully, that would have been a huge, it would have been tumultuous if
that had been passed because that would just destroy the whole balance of labor management
relations because incentivizing workers to strike because they get paid. There's no hard time. The
whole point to resolve a strike is the workers want to get back to work. In fact, I heard this
story by a union member, many union members, every union member I know and talk to a lot,
and they're all good people. They want to work. So they were telling me about a story that,
I guess this was in Washington, that there was a convention of the union, whatever building trade
that was. And Nancy Pelosi, a majority leader, speaker, was speaking to the group. And she
says, and we increased unemployment insurance. You're going to get more. And that when they
said boo, the whole audience, thousands of workers, union members she was speaking to,
they stood up and said, we just want to work. We don't want to get unemployment. We want to be
working. So there's a whole misconception about people seeming to want all these government
payments. They want to work. People want to work. And so we layer on and layer on all these
government payments, disincentivizing people from working. And there's a whole other list
of examples of how welfare laws, et cetera, just disincentivize, demotivate people from working
because they just sit home and receive automatic payments into their bank account. They don't even
have to go to the bank to deposit the check. We've made it too easy not to work. But anyway,
back to your overall question, where does the money go? Into programs. Nobody knows how
effective they are. If they were in business, everything in business, everything gets measured.
The data. Is it working? Are people served? Is it improving? Are we doing it better? That doesn't
happen in government spending. It's just it's because people who are elected typically,
the more money into their favorite program makes everybody seemingly happy. The people that voted
for them or like the people that support people, their constituents. Well, that brings up another
point I have found just in nine months. So it's a big generalization that public policy is really
created because by exception, what I mean by that is a legislator may know one example,
one person that was mistreated or badly informed or told something that wasn't accurate or
one person. And then they come and they present in a tearful manner, emotionally at a hearing,
a committee hearing. And then the law changes. One person had an experience under a current law.
And so the whole everything changes. Because one person had an experience with the system.
Yes. That might have been unfair or something bad. And they come to the lawmakers and create.
Instead of trying to see where is how can we fix within the current framework. But no, we need a
new law because it gets interpreter. They have lawyers that help make their case. So it's just
it's legislation, public policy by exception. It's exception to the rule. Some one person,
some small group had a problem. We have to change the whole law that affects everybody.
And it was surprising to me. It's also surprising to me back to your budget question.
There there are budget better than Congress, I've learned. The current debate in Congress
on the Republicans is that they don't and I agree they don't like these omnibus bills. We don't know
what all the different bills are. There should be 12 different bill packages instead of in December
they get an omnibus bill and they have to vote for the budget and nobody knows what's in it.
I don't like that either. In California, the budget process, there is a good part of it.
It is broken into about 12 different subcommittees and there's a subcommittee chairman
and it's by topic, natural resources, housing, health care, all the way down the line. And that's
good because it really dissects the budget. And the assembly person Ting from San Francisco has
been longtime chair of the budget and he does a good job keeping it in order. Although it does
allow for tax increases, it does allow things to be increased and it's just hard to make
everybody happy to tell you the truth. I mean and he does a pretty good job but from a process
standpoint it's better than Congress because it is the overall budget. Yes it's broken into 12
pieces but there is a bad part of the state budget. So because I mentioned earlier that by June 15th
the budget has to be constitutionally required. The legislature must approve a budget, pass a
budget to the governor. Because years ago before this, this was recently and since year 2000,
like 2004 or 5 or 6, the legislature could be going on until September and the budget's not
passed you know. So it has to be passed. However, they know that they haven't gotten everything
analyzed and determined. So in March or April or May all of us were given bills that are empty
bills. They're called trailer bills and they're empty. And I voted no on every one because I don't
know how much they cost. But ultimately they will have, for the 12 subcommittees I said, they will
have the budget, there are 12 of them, they'll have the budget or however many the subcommittees are,
they'll fill in the blanks with the subcommittee recommendation. So I voted no because it's a
blank check literally. Do you even know what they're about? No, you don't. So it's just a
blank check? It's a blank bill. It has a bill number and then when the budget subcommittees
have done their work and they do a lot of work to figure out what goes in that bill,
then they load it up into that bill and it comes before each house of the legislature.
I think out of the 12, I voted no on all of them except two bills I voted yes. One related to
health insurance and another one I think was a public safety. So those are called trailer bills
and they're passed after June 15th. It goes on through August. But they have to conform to
what the legislature passed on June 15th and it's all within that same number, that same budget
number. So they fill in the blanks until the end of the session. Why are so many people leaving
California? It wasn't long ago people from everywhere wanted to move to the golden state
to enjoy a better life. Sadly, the standard of living has been dropping in the past decade.
Are you like me and wonder why this is happening? I'm Siamak Korami, host of California Insider.
In our film, Leaving California, The Untold Story, I take you on an intimate journey of love, loss,
tragedy, and hope as residents face the prospect of leaving their beloved state.
Everyday people like you tell their stories about why they have to move out of the state
even though they don't want to. Experts and policymakers also give insights about what's
happening behind the scenes. Together, we get to the root cause of this exodus. Go to
leavingcalifornia.com to view the first 15 minutes of the film for free. By watching Leaving California,
you can be part of the solution. Again, go to leavingcalifornia.com.
Dan, going back to ACA1, ACA13, as I'm thinking about it more, we want to allow affordable housing,
but from what it sounds like, this is going to increase the housing cost for everybody that's
renting or owning that is going to buy a home because their taxes will go up. Correct. Can you
explain this more, how it works? Sure, happy to. So, ACA1 specifically is a bond measure
and that would fund affordable housing and public infrastructure to allow cities to issue a bond
measure. Now, in the case of many cities in Orange County where we live, the local governments,
city councils, have passed charter amendments in their own city to say we shall never increase
taxes on our residents without a two-thirds majority, supermajority. It's also called
supermajority. Majority, a simple majority, is 51 percent. A supermajority is two-thirds.
Cities have said in their, put in their charter, we will never tax our people without a vote,
a supermajority of two-thirds. So, not only does the agency have to pass that proposed
tax increase by a two-thirds vote, if it were to pass the city council level, it has to be passed
by the two-thirds majority of the voting people, okay? So, ACA1 would, they could pass a bond
measure or a sales tax. That would require any tax related, typically. But the state will do
the property. Yeah, a state changes the voting requirement, but cities levy the property taxes,
or levy, not, well, yeah, it determines the vote. There's no voting on property taxes at the city
level. If it's a bond measure that would affect their property taxes, that's what the city votes
on, okay? So, the way this legislation on ACA1 is cleverly written, it gives the cities the
opportunity to pass a bond measure to tax their residents at 55 percent. So, it will be up to the
cities. With 55 percent of the vote. Yes, as opposed to two-thirds. And they oppose, supposedly, they're
going to use the money to build affordable housing. Okay, so this is a little clever, a little
hook here. Cities don't build houses. Most cities don't build housing. Private industry, private
business, that's our economic system. Government does not build housing. So, this
isn't really talked about a lot. I've talked about it a lot, but a lot of people
haven't really focused on this. Our city is going to now start building public housing. Now, in the
United States, 60 years ago, the federal government poured money into state and local
government when there were riots and things like that, just to build more public housing. Public
housing doesn't work in the United States. Public housing is government-owned housing. Would you
ever want to live in a government-owned house? I mean, you wonder about DMV, the Department of
Motor Vehicles, and the unemployment insurance. I don't think government should be in the housing
business, but this is bringing to California local governments the opportunity to say, oh goodness,
we could raise all this money in a bond measure and then we can either dole it out or we could do
it ourselves. I personally do not think government should be building housing. Private industry
should be building housing. So, essentially, the rents and the housing costs for all the Californians
or all the people that live in those cities will go up. Yes. And the money will go to the
government. If the city decides to do that. Yes, because how do you pay for the bond
measure, which is hundreds of millions of dollars, and then it gets tacked on the easy tax collection
mechanism is to put it into the property taxes. And so property owners, such as you own a building
or you own a home, you will see a higher property tax on your next bill. It goes up to pay for this
bond measure. If you are a tenant, either a renter of a home or renter of a retail shop,
your landlord is going to be paying a higher property tax bill. And so that landlord will
be pushing his higher, his or her higher costs down to their tenant. So it will be across the
board regressive to people in this high inflationary period who can't afford it. I hear people saying,
you know, now they're beginning to really realize they have to stop their spending
and or they're on credit cards. I don't think the full realization of difficult economic times
they project in the first of the year, there'll probably be a recession now with all this hyper
spending and military spending and the world conditions right now that we're living in in
late October, there'll be difficult economic times ahead, sadly. Now Diane, what do you recommend to
the legislative body and your colleagues now that you've been there nine months and you've kind of
been in the private space, you've been in the city, like a municipality, and now you're seeing
the state budgeting. Can you tell us what you recommend? Well, the easiest thing to do,
and there are some more, not complicated, but more steps, easiest thing to do is here's,
the governor says that this is as much as we can spend, there's a deficit, we have to cover the
deficit and spend not a penny more. And that should be it. So if you were in business as a
department head, you cannot submit a budget for your department if it exceeds what the boss said.
You have, this is what you have to spend. The governor has said this is all you can spend.
There is a zero percent increase in spending, zero percent, because we have a 30 billion dollar
deficit. So don't send me bills passed by two houses of the legislature that say a million
here and a million there and 60 million here because I'm going to veto it. Now he can say
that and people, the legislature keeps sending him these bills. If I were the governor, it would
drive me nuts. I told you we are in a deficit. No more new spending. Cut spending. Why doesn't
anybody send them a bill? That reduces spending. We're going to eliminate this program. We did an
audit. They're not effective. They're not solving the homeless problem. So we're going to cut money
out of here and give it directly to the counties to improve homelessness. That'll never happen
because the state wants the money. That's a whole other political story. But why can't the state
operate like local government? It's not unique to business. This is the projected revenues. This
is all we could spend. If the revenues exceed our projections, then lo and behold it goes
into a reserve fund, a rainy day fund. Wouldn't that be great? We don't have a rainy day fund.
In fact, Governor Brown, who preceded Newsom during a good budget year after the 2008 recession when
things clicked up again, there was a budget surplus. He took that surplus and put it in a
rainy day fund. And Governor Newsom has used that rainy day fund. It's a savings account. So that's
what the legislature should propose. No additional spending. Should cut spending so
that we resolve this deficit problem. Diane Dixon, Assemblywoman in California. It's great to have
you on California Insider. Well, it's been an honor to be here and I'm happy to come back anytime.
There's a lot more to talk about. Excellent. Thank you. If you haven't checked out CaliforniaInsider.com,
we highly recommend you do that now because we're going to have a lot of news and videos there. And
on top of what we have there right now, we are building a really big platform to cover what's
happening in California. So you can be informed. We're going to have more shows, more videos from
all aspects of life in California. Go to CaliforniaInsider.com and we'll see you there.