On July 5, 2005, a 16-year-old girl aboard the Brilliance of the Seas found herself in a peculiar situation. The cruise ship, carrying an impressive 28,000 passengers across the Mediterranean, had docked in Kusadasi, Turkey, where the girl woke up early to capture the beauty of the rising sun on her balcony. Little did she know that her camera lens would capture something far more unsettling. As the teenager focused her camera, ready to snap a picture of the picturesque sunrise, her attention was drawn to a disturbing sight. To her surprise, a large blood stain marred the canopy of the lifeboats. Alarmed by the ominous discovery, the teenager wasted no time alerting the ship's officials. The officials, along with the captain, promptly responded to the teenager's report, recognizing the gravity of the situation. They knew all too well what this could potentially signify – the Brilliance of the Seas was faced with what Royal Caribbean referred to as an "overboard situation."
Hi everyone, my name is Mark, and today we're going to take a look at another horrible case
with you.
On July 5, 2005, a 16-year-old girl aboard the Brilliance of the Seas found herself in
a peculiar situation.
The cruise ship, carrying an impressive 28,000 passengers across the Mediterranean, had docked
in Cusadasi, Turkey, where the girl woke up early to capture the beauty of the rising
sun on her balcony.
Little did she know that her camera lens would capture something far more unsettling.
As the teenager focused her camera, ready to snap a picture of the picturesque sunrise,
her attention was drawn to a disturbing sight.
To her surprise, a large bloodstain marred the canopy of the lifeboats.
Alarmed by the ominous discovery, the teenager wasted no time alerting the ship's officials.
The officials, along with the captain, promptly responded to the teenager's report, recognizing
the gravity of the situation.
They knew all too well what this could potentially signify.
The Brilliance of the Seas was faced with what Royal Caribbean referred to as an overboard
situation.
The captain carefully examined the staterooms above the disturbing bloodstains on the lifeboat
canopy.
Concerned about the potential danger lurking, he immediately ordered a thorough check of
these rooms, as well as the eight neighboring rooms on each side.
Room 9062, the stateroom of George and Jennifer Smith, was among one of the rooms overlooking
the bloodstain.
Utilizing the ship's keycard system, ship officials swiftly initiated an investigation
to determine the whereabouts of the cruise passengers.
Through this system, they were able to ascertain that many of the passengers had already disembarked
in Turkey.
However, a troubling discovery soon emerged.
The ship officials realized that honeymooners George Smith and his wife Jennifer were nowhere
to be found.
This revelation raised serious concerns and intensified the urgency of the situation.
To expedite the search efforts, ship officials began paging George and Jennifer over the
ship's intercom system.
Their names echoed throughout the vessel, creating a sense of unease among the remaining
passengers.
Jennifer Smith was at the ship's spa for her 8.30 a.m. appointment when the ship's officials
began paging her and her husband.
Concerned, the officials went down to the spa to speak with Jennifer.
Jennifer, surprised by their presence, informed the officials that she had no idea where her
husband George was.
She explained that she suspected he might have crashed in their friend's room, as they
had befriended another couple on board, and George had slept there previously.
Unaware of the disturbing bloodstain outside Jennifer's stateroom, the officials chose
not to mention it to her, fearing it would only cause unnecessary alarm.
After their conversation with Jennifer, the officers escorted her to the nurse's office,
where they gently explained the situation.
Jennifer appeared lost and desperate, according to the nurse assisting her.
Since the officials did not allow Jennifer to return to her stateroom, she found herself
in need of clothes.
Consequently, she headed to the ship's gift shop to purchase some attire that she could
wear in the meantime.
In response to the call for George and Jennifer Smith, a young man named Josh Askin, who happened
to be a college student from Orange County, California, and was on board The Brilliance
of the Seas with his family, came forward.
Josh stated that he had helped George Smith to bed the previous night.
He explained that the couple had been partying heavily and were most likely still asleep
in their stateroom.
However, by this point, the cruise officials already knew George Smith was missing.
Following this revelation, both Jennifer and Josh were taken off the ship to be interviewed
by the Turkish police.
In order to further investigate the matter, the police boarded the cruise ship.
They took photographs of the bloodstained canopy and proceeded to search the Smiths'
stateroom.
According to Josh Askin's attorney, who had reviewed the Turkish documents related
to the case, the police discovered droplets of blood on a bedsheet and a towel.
The attorney insisted that the amount of blood found was relatively small.
He asserted that it did not indicate a stabbing or serious injury.
Through interviews with Josh Askin's attorney, officials have uncovered crucial details regarding
the events that transpired on the night of July 4th to the early morning hours of July
5th, the last night George Smith was seen on board the Brilliance of the Seas.
According to the attorney, George and Jennifer embarked on their evening by heading to the
casino after dinner, eagerly hoping to rendezvous with friends they had made during their cruise.
However, despite being on their honeymoon, George and Jennifer seemed to have spent the
majority of the evening engaged in separate gambling activities.
While Jennifer was engrossed in the game of blackjack, George found himself enjoying
the company of others at the craps table.
In addition to Josh Askin, there were three Russian-American men named Greg and Zack Rosenberg,
accompanied by their fellow traveler Rusty Kaufman, in the casino that night.
According to Josh Askin's attorney, there was an incident involving Jennifer Smith and
a cruise ship employee named Lloyd Botah.
Josh allegedly observed Jennifer and Lloyd getting close while on the cruise ship.
After the casino closed at 2.30, Josh, Jennifer, and the Smiths entered an elevator to go to
the disco.
Lloyd Botah was also in the elevator, standing beside Jennifer, which Josh believed was too
close for comfort.
Josh's attorney stated, he was definitely stepping over professional boundaries.
It was awkward, but I don't know if George noticed it at the time.
However, Lloyd Botah's attorney denies any allegations of flirting between Lloyd and
Jennifer.
Rusty Kaufman and Zack and Greg Rosenberg joined George at a table in the disco.
They were seen taking shots from a bottle of absinthe, a green and highly potent liquor
that is illegal in most Western countries and is not sold aboard the brilliance of the
seas.
Royal Caribbean officials have suggested that the bottle was likely smuggled onto the ship
against the rules.
After a night of indulging in absinthe brought by Rusty, Zack, and Greg, it is widely agreed
that George and Jennifer were heavily intoxicated.
As the events unfolded, Josh's lawyer revealed that Jennifer was seen continuing to flirt
with other men.
Rusty Kaufman's attorney went even further, claiming she was shamelessly draping herself
all over them.
Over time, George began to notice his new bride's behavior and grew increasingly angry.
The tension between George and Jennifer escalated, resulting in a brief but intense argument,
and the situation reached its climax when Jennifer, fueled by anger, delivered a forceful
kick to her new husband's groin.
In a rage, she stormed out of the disco, leaving George behind.
Shockingly, it was reported that Lloyd Botah followed Jennifer out of the establishment,
according to Josh's account.
However, Lloyd's attorney vehemently denied these allegations, stating that he had left
the disco around 3.10am and headed back to his girlfriend's cabin and claimed he didn't
follow Jennifer out of the disco.
Shortly after George and Jennifer Smith got into their argument, the disco closed at 3.30am.
It was reported by Rusty Kaufman's attorney and Josh Askin that George was heavily intoxicated
and unable to walk without assistance.
Concerned for his well-being, Josh, Rusty, Zach, and Greg Rosenberg decided to help George
back to his stateroom.
However, upon their arrival, Jennifer was nowhere to be found.
George expressed his desire to locate her.
According to one account, George chained his shirt and, accompanied by Josh and the three
Russian boys, made his way to the solarium.
The solarium was a popular gathering spot for the younger crowd on the cruise ship,
especially during late hours.
Unfortunately, their search for Jennifer proved fruitless, as she was not there.
With no sign of Jennifer, the group guided George back to his room.
The time of their arrival was recorded by a computerized monitoring system that tracks
the usage of key cards to open stateroom doors.
It was confirmed that they reached George's room at precisely 4.02am.
The account of what happened next was provided by the people occupying the staterooms adjacent
to George and Jennifer Smith.
Among these witnesses was Cleet Hyman, a seasoned police officer with 31 years of experience
in law enforcement.
Cleet Hyman, considered a reliable witness, later informed cruise officials that he was
awoken a few minutes past 4am by boisterous cheering emanating from George Smith's stateroom.
The noise suggested that the occupants might have been engaged in some form of drinking game.
Annoyed by the disturbance, Cleet pounded on the wall, temporarily quieting the sounds
for a brief moment before they resumed.
Frustrated, Cleet picked up the telephone and contacted the operator to voice his complaint.
The operator assured him that the situation would be thoroughly investigated.
Even though Cleet Hyman tried to go back to sleep, he found himself unable to do so.
A sudden disturbance shattered the tranquility of the night.
Out of nowhere, while he was drifting in and out of sleep, an intense argument erupted
on the balcony.
Three distinct voices filled the air, their words indiscernible to Cleet's tired mind.
However, he made no effort to decipher their content, for it seemed irrelevant to him at
that moment.
By that point, Cleet Hyman estimated that it was 4.15am.
In the stillness of the early morning, he could discern the faint sound of voices gradually
growing louder as they moved across the room, inching closer to the door.
Reflecting on the events that unfolded, Cleet later recalled,
''You could definitely hear a voice ushering people out of the room.''
The voice was clear and purposeful, directing individuals to leave the premises.
As Cleet listened intently, he heard the repetitive chorus of ''Goodnight'' echoing through
the air.
The words were uttered as if bidding farewell to departing guests.
After the voices faded away, Cleet patiently waited for a brief period, approximately ten
seconds or so, before cautiously peering out of his door.
It was at that moment that his eyes fell upon the sight of three male figures making their
way down the hallway.
As Cleet listened intently through the thin walls, he became certain that he could hear
someone speaking in a conversational tone.
However, to his surprise, there was only a single voice audible to him.
Simultaneously, Cleet began to notice louder noises emanating from the room.
These sounds were sporadic, indicating some kind of movement.
It sounded like someone was rummaging through cupboards, opening and closing drawers, and
possibly rearranging furniture.
Depending on these noises, Cleet speculated that the room was being cleaned.
According to C.D.
Hyman's estimation, the sound of moving furniture persisted for approximately eight
minutes.
Following this, the sounds shifted towards the balcony area.
Cleet recalls two metal chairs on the balcony and claims to have heard at least one chair
being moved.
Suddenly, silence descended upon the environment for a minute or two, with no sound audible
to Cleet.
However, this tranquility was abruptly shattered between 4.20 and 4.25 a.m. as Cleet experienced
what he can only describe as a horrific thud.
The impact was so powerful that he could feel the vibrations reverberating through his bed.
Cleet Hyman said,
My first thought was that someone fell on the balcony, not off.
But because it was so loud, I discarded that thought.
Someone would have to be very heavy to make that sound.
The second thought I had is that, well, they had been moving furniture.
I thought maybe they were throwing furniture overboard.
It sounded heavy enough to be a couch.
I didn't look out.
There was total silence after that.
I didn't hear any screams, any movements, after that.
Presumably, the thud that Cleet Hyman heard was the unmistakable sound of George Smith's
body plummeting over the balcony and colliding with the canopy below.
This chilling incident raises a critical question.
Was George Smith pushed off the balcony, or did he meet his fate alone?
According to Cleet, he could typically hear them leaving their room, often accompanied
by the creaking sound of their cabin door opening.
However, in the aftermath of the thud, Cleet didn't hear the sound of any door opening.
This observation leads to a haunting possibility.
If there was indeed someone inside stateroom 9062 when George met his untimely end, that
person managed to slip out undetected without making a single sound.
After the horrific thud that Cleet heard, it took about three or four minutes for the
next sound to reach his ears.
It was the footsteps of two Royal Caribbean security men responding to Cleet's earlier
call.
They made their way down the corridor, approaching the door of the Smith's cabin.
As they neared the door, they noticed no sound coming from inside.
When they knocked on the door, there was no reply.
Assuming that the party had come to an end, the security men decided not to attempt to
enter the cabin.
They believed there was no reason to invade the guests' privacy based solely on a noise
complaint.
Cleet, for his part, chose not to engage with the officers who walked away.
According to a timeline released by Royal Caribbean, the security personnel left the
scene believing that everything was in order.
They stated that they had no justification for entering the guest cabin as they considered
the noise complaint to be a simple matter of partying.
Josh Askin denied any involvement in George Smith's disappearance.
According to him, he, Rusty, Greg, and Zach were in George's stateroom for about 10-15
minutes.
During that time, Josh excused himself to use the bathroom.
He maintains that everyone left the stateroom by 4.15, leaving only George inside.
However, Rusty Kaufman's attorney disagrees with this timeline.
He claims everything happened several minutes earlier, stating that his client and the Rosenberg
brothers were already back in Rusty's room by 4 o'clock.
The attorney even asserts that he has a time-stamped photograph as evidence to support this claim.
The last sighting of George Smith by Rusty was when the boys left him on his bed.
George was incredibly thankful for their assistance, to the point where he kissed one of the boys
and even promised to treat them to a round of drinks the following day.
According to Josh, he, along with Greg and Zach Rosenberg, went to Rusty's room.
However, Josh emphasized that he returned to his stateroom by 5.15 a.m.
On the fateful night when George Smith disappeared from their stateroom aboard the Brilliance
of the Seas, many have questioned the whereabouts of his wife, Jennifer Smith.
Witnesses have provided some insight into Jennifer's movements that evening.
According to multiple accounts, Jennifer was spotted leaving the disco at approximately
3.15 a.m., just moments before George and his friends departed.
Considering the short distance between the disco and their stateroom, it should have
taken Jennifer less than five minutes to return.
However, she never made it back to their room.
After leaving the disco, Jennifer took the elevator down to Deck 9.
Unfortunately, she was inebriated and became disoriented.
Instead of turning right, which would have led her to the Longport Corridor and their
stateroom, Jennifer turned left into the Starboard Corridor.
Unaware of her mistake, she continued walking until the hall came to an end, leading her
into an alcove.
Within that alcove stood a locked maintenance door.
Exhausted and overwhelmed, Jennifer slumped against the wall, sliding down to the floor,
where she eventually fell into a deep sleep.
A Royal Caribbean security guard discovered Jennifer slumped over and asleep in the alcove
at approximately 4.30 a.m.
Concerned for her well-being, the guard promptly contacted the nurse via walkie-talkie.
Upon hearing about the situation, the nurse recommended applying a wet paper towel to
Jennifer's forehead and attempting to wake her up.
Following the nurse's advice, the security guard gently placed the damp paper towel on
Jennifer's forehead and tried to rouse her from her slumber.
To their relief, Jennifer slowly woke up and provided her name and stateroom number,
reassuring everyone by saying,
I'm okay.
Realizing that Jennifer might need assistance, the security guard requested a wheelchair.
Two security men and a female employee were assigned to accompany Jennifer back to her
stateroom.
At precisely 4.57 a.m., they entered her cabin, only to find that Jennifer's husband, George,
was not present.
Taking Jennifer to the bed, the three Royal Caribbean officers helped her lie down on
top of the covers.
According to multiple sources familiar with the case, Rusty Kaufman, along with Greg and
Zach Rosenberg, initially drew attention to themselves while on board the Brilliance of
the Seas on Sunday night, July 3, 2005.
This incident occurred five days into the cruise.
The trio was spotted socializing in the ship's solarium, a designated area for young people
to mingle.
The solarium was strictly a non-smoking zone.
However, at least one member of the Rosenberg group was seen lighting up a cigarette.
When approached by a ship's officer and instructed to cease smoking, it is alleged that one or
more of the men responded with profanities and continued smoking, disregarding the officer's
admonishment.
The following morning after the incident in the solarium, the Brilliance of the Seas docked
in Mykonos.
Upon docking, the guest relation manager of the ship promptly contacted Zach and Greg
Rosenberg's parents.
They were escorted to the hotel office, where the manager explained the seriousness of the
situation.
It was made clear that if the young adults continued their disruptive behavior, they
would be removed from the ship.
Zach and Greg Rosenberg's parents, concerned and understanding the gravity of the situation,
assured the guest relation manager that they would take immediate action.
They promised to supervise their children closely and to ensure that there would be
no further issues.
The parents were determined to address the behavior of their sons and prevent any future
disruptions.
However, little did they know that the problems involving the Rosenberg brothers and their
friend Rusty Kaufman were only beginning.
Despite the parents' promises and the stern warning from the guest relation manager, it
seemed that the young adults were not ready to mend their ways.
After a brief investigation into George Smith's disappearance, the brilliance of the seas
set sail from Turkey with Rusty Kaufman, Josh Askins, and the Rosenberg brothers still aboard.
The atmosphere on the ship was lively, with the group enjoying their time together.
However, as the cruise ship made its way to Italy, they found themselves entangled in
another troubling situation involving a young woman.
The encounter with the woman took place in the ship's Jacuzzi, where Greg and Zach Rosenberg
met her.
They invited her back to their stateroom, seeking to document their exploits with Rusty's
camera.
According to the men involved, all interactions were consensual, and they were merely looking
to capture a memorable moment.
However, the young woman's recollection of the night painted a different picture, as
she claimed that the men had forced themselves upon her.
After the girl had come forward accusing the men of assault, the Rosenberg family and
the Askin family were escorted off the brilliance of the seas.
No charges were ever brought against the young men regarding these allegations.
The tragic death of George Smith aboard the brilliance of the seas has left his family
devastated and searching for answers.
Amidst the grief, they firmly believe that George was murdered and that the Royal Caribbean
is involved in a cover-up.
George's family has appeared on numerous television shows promoting his story, striving
to shed light on the circumstances of his demise and seeking justice for him.
However, differing opinions within the family have complicated their pursuit of truth.
In 2009, Jennifer, George's new bride, remarried, but her views on the incident differed from
those of the rest of the family.
Jennifer believes that George's death stemmed from an accident due to his intoxication.
There was a glimmer of hope for George's family when the Federal Bureau of Investigation
announced their intention to get involved in the case.
The family saw this as an opportunity to uncover the truth and hold those responsible accountable.
However, in 2015, the FBI delivered a blow to their hopes when they stated that there
was not enough evidence to prove George had been murdered.
Instead, they suggested that his death may have been the result of an accident, aligning
with Jennifer's perspective.
However, it was revealed that the FBI possesses a videotape recorded on the morning of the
search for George Smith.
The tape allegedly captures a conversation among the men who had been with George on
the night of his disappearance.
Lawyers for George Smith's family assert that this video is a vital piece of evidence
that points to the men's involvement in George's death.
According to reports, one of the men on the videotape can be heard making a reference
to George parachuting from his balcony.
This statement has raised eyebrows and intensified suspicions regarding the men's potential
culpability in George Smith's disappearance.
The lawyers argue that this comment implies prior knowledge of George's fate or active
participation in his demise.
Yet, the FBI's position is that the videotape alone does not provide definitive proof of
the men's involvement and that further investigation is necessary.