Exclusive
The New Virus Mutation in UK: How Dangerous Is It? Will the Vaccines Still Work?

China Insights with Jenny
670 followers
8 Video Views·Nov 3, 2023
Hello, welcome to FocusTalk. My name is Jenny. Today is Monday December the 21st.
Today we will be talking about the new coronavirus strain that was discovered in Great Britain.
This mutated strain has a much higher transmission rate. London has essentially been quarantined
and many European countries have suspended travel to and from Britain. We have two guests joining
us tonight. With us in the studio is current affairs commentator Mr. Tangjing Xuan. Hello,
welcome to the show. Thank you, I'm happy to be here. And joining us on Skype is Mr. Lin Xiaoxu.
Hello, welcome to the show. Hello, thanks for having me. Let's first hear from Mr. Lin.
We've seen concerns mounting over the new strain out of Britain. London and parts of the southeast
Great Britain are under quarantine. Many countries have suspended air travel with Britain.
The main thing we've heard is that this mutation has a transmission rate that is 70% higher than
the original virus. What is your opinion of this new mutation? How exactly does the 70%
higher transmission rate translate to actual spread in the population? How concerned should we be?
I believe this strain has the potential to be extremely dangerous.
It's quite different from the various other strains that we've seen in the past year.
Most of the other strains had maybe one to four gene mutations. This strain has 17 mutations
and some of those are particularly worrisome because they affect the spike protein on the
virus surface, which changes how the virus interacts with its host. Specifically, one
called N501Y controls how tightly it binds to human cells. Another called 69-70DL has been
shown to be more resistant to the human immune system. By themselves, these mutations are
concerning. But what is perhaps the most worrying is that you have 17 mutations on just one strain,
something that is very improbable from an evolutionary standpoint in such a short time.
Any changes to the virus that affect how it interacts with the host or eludes the immune
system would be extremely dangerous because the current search is all based on the original virus.
Another issue or concern is that this strain seemed to have evolved in one patient who was
infected for a long period of time and took many different drugs. So during this process,
the virus within this patient has had to go through rapid adaptations in order to survive.
Think of it as a war between the drugs and the virus where the virus is constantly evolving.
Essentially, the therapeutic treatment facilitated the development of this new strain.
I believe this patient was given convalescent plasma and took remdesivir along with other
therapeutics. So this virus had to be able to survive while being under assault by all
these treatments. This probably explains the many mutations the strain acquired.
It needed all these mutations in order to survive. Over time, it will become the dominant strain due
to its superior survivability. The number we've heard so far is that its transmission rate is 70%
higher. This is a very preliminary number and I think we have to wait for clarification on just
what this means. Because there are so many mutations and some of them, as I said, occurred
on crucial genes, the interplay of these mutations what the human response is hard to predict.
Given the specific details of these mutations, I believe this strain has the potential to be very,
very dangerous. I'll just expand on something you mentioned. There are 17 mutations on this strain,
which is very unusual. I read that this strain called B.1.1.7 was already discovered back in
September. From your description of this one patient, it seems like the virus was enhanced
as it dealt with all these drugs. We only know is more transmissible, but we are not sure exactly by
how much, especially in the real world. How about the fatality rate? Have you heard any news on this
front? So far, there hasn't been specific details on the fatality rate of this new strain,
but anecdotally, we know that young people may be more susceptible to this strain. While Boris
Johnson said that the transmission rate is 70% higher, I think there's a good chance it's much
higher than that. In one historical pandemic, one single mutation changed the transmission rate by
10 times. So when you have 17 mutations, I think it will take quite a while for the research
community to catch up. I think the 70% number may be conservative, and it's more serious than what
that number may suggest. If you look at the response of the other European countries,
they've shut down travel with Britain. This tells you that they're taking it very seriously.
If you look at the lockdowns within Britain itself, they're taking it very seriously.
So like I said, I think it has the potential to be very dangerous.
Let's hear from our other guests. What is your opinion of this new strain? How dangerous is
this new mutation, and should we be concerned about a potential second wave? First, I agree
with Mr. Lin. I think they're underestimating the danger of this virus when they talk about it just
being 70% more transmissible. I saw a Cambridge report that mentioned a study of a mutated strain
in Sweden. It had two mutated genes that resulted in doubling the transmission rate.
This strain has 17 mutated genes and actually includes the same two mutations from the
Sweden strain. So how can it be less virulent than that one? Again, this is all new for the research
community, so I just don't think they know the real-world repercussions of these mutations and
their interaction with each other and with the host. It's not as simple as saying, well, this
mutation leads to X percent change, that mutation leads to X percent change, and just add them up.
We really just don't know at this point. A major concern is that they may already be too late to
contain this new strain. When you look at what's actually happened in Britain, the new COVID-19
cases doubled in a matter of two weeks. We believe at least five countries have already seen this
strain. I expect we'll see more in the coming days. The European countries have suspended air
traffic from Britain, but it may already be too late. There is a little bit of similarity with
the original spread of this virus out of Wuhan. The spread of this strain coincided with the
Christmas season, while the original spread coincided with that of the Chinese New Year.
In both cases, you have this huge movement of people. We have anecdotal evidence that as many
as 500,000 people left Wuhan to escape the virus. There is evidence now that as many as 300,000
people left London recently, so containment may already be too late. In Germany, while we haven't
heard any official news of this new strain, fatalities from COVID-19 doubled in December
from November. Other countries have experienced a similar spike in both new cases and fatalities.
Different countries may have different rates of increase, but you can see the overall trend,
rising number of cases and fatalities. This leads to something we've always discussed,
the second wave of the pandemic. I'd like to talk a little bit about the Spanish flu,
which happened 100 years ago. After the initial outbreak around May, the pandemic actually dropped
off during the summer months, and some people thought it was over. But winter came, and the
second wave hit. In total, the Spanish flu had three waves, with the second wave being the deadliest.
So, what is happening today resembles what happened back then, and I fear we might be
seeing the start of a second wave. Of course, COVID-19 is a little different from the Spanish
flu because it never really dropped off. It more or less held steady during the summer months,
whereas the Spanish flu declined significantly. With COVID, we had the initial rapid spread,
a slight drop-off, but the cases then more or less plateaued and continued. Now, as we see the current
spike coinciding with the oncoming winter, I feel quite pessimistic about the ongoing development.
As I mentioned already, I believe the official announcement of a 70% increase in transmission
rate is conservative. But even if we concede that number for now, I want to emphasize another point.
The announcement also said that this strain is not more fatal than the original, so their fatality
rates are similar. There is an interesting aspect to this. The vast majority of viruses fall into
two categories, highly transmissible or highly lethal, but not both. For example, Ebola has a
fatality rate approaching 90%, but it's hard to transmit. If we had many viruses that were both
lethal and easily transmissible, we'd see deadly pandemics occur much more often. So coming back
to this strain, if we hold the fatality rate the same but increase the transmission rate, then even
at the very minimum, it will be more lethal version overall just because it will impact more people.
Given this mutated, more dangerous strain, the key question is whether the existing vaccines
will still work. The timing is very curious because we have news of this new strain just as
the vaccines are being administered. I would assume that since this new strain is so new,
there just isn't enough evidence to say whether this vaccine will or won't work.
Are we back to square one on the vaccine? What are your thoughts?
We know that the current vaccines were designed and developed based on the DNA of the original
strain of the virus. Given the high number of mutated genes on this new strain,
the effectiveness of these vaccines against the new strain is definitely an open question.
As I mentioned, my main concern is that this strain has been put through the wringer. This
strain developed in a patient that received all the current medication, so its survivability is
extremely high. It's probably developed the means to elude many of the treatment methodologies
currently used by the medical profession, so I'm a little skeptical when I hear drug companies
claim that the existing vaccines will be similarly effective against this new strain.
As we know, there are currently two approved vaccines, one by Pfizer and the other by
Moderna. Is there a difference in the approaches taken by these two companies that might suggest
that one might be more effective than the other? No, there really wouldn't be a significant
difference between the two vaccines because the fundamental issue is the same. They used the
mRNA of the original virus as the sample, so when there are changes in the underlying DNA,
the mRNA will also change and the outcome cannot be predicted with complete certainty.
I'll give you an example. Queensland University in Australia developed a vaccine using a molecular
clamp that was based on parts of an HIV protein. Based on their experience, they did not feel the
human body would respond to such a tiny molecular structure. However, during the testing phase,
they found out that trial participants had produced antibodies that showed up on HIV tests.
In other words, if this vaccine had been rolled out, many people would have tested falsely positive
for HIV. This is just an example of the unpredictability of how the human body
may respond to even the tiniest changes at the molecular level. We just don't know for sure until
we thoroughly test, which explains the normally very long time period required for vaccine
development. So when Moderna or Pfizer or anybody say that their vaccines are effective against the
new strain, like I said, I am skeptical. If this is the case, what are the available
options to us at this point? We are seeing lockdowns by neighborhoods in Britain and
essentially a global quarantine of Britain itself. Do you think this will be effective?
Do you see more lockdowns coming? Personally, I don't think the lockdowns are very effective.
Of course, people need to be vigilant as they go about their daily business and protect themselves
and others. So personal hygiene, masks, hand washing, social distancing, all these things
are important. The key point I want to make is that people should not be pinning all their hopes
on the vaccine. New strains are constantly developing in nature and we have to consider
the possibility that the vaccines cannot catch up. Yes, please, what are your thoughts?
I want to get back to something you said earlier. This strain was already discovered by September,
but at that time the number of cases were very small. Why is it that it's only now, three months
later, that we're seeing an outbreak of this strain? It isn't clear to me whether this strain from
September hasn't itself evolved over time. So when we are told that 17 genes have mutated on this
strain, are these the exact mutations on the strain from September? Or has it changed in a significant
way, become more transmissible since then? I also want to add to what the other guest said about the
vaccines. To me, there are two possibilities. One is that the current vaccines just don't work.
The virus doesn't trigger the production of the antibodies or the antibodies aren't effective
against the virus. This is one possibility and it's fairly straightforward because the end result
would be as if you were never vaccinated. The second risk is potentially even more dangerous
and is something we've talked about. Antibody Dependent Enhancement or ADE.
As we know, the basic idea is that when the human body receives a vaccine,
you're priming the immune system to recognize a certain molecular signature and generate
antibodies to fight it. ADE can happen when the body recognizes the virus and generates the
antibodies, but the antibodies interact in a way with the virus that makes the situation worse.
This can happen if there's a mismatch between the vaccine and the actual virus.
This has happened in the past with both measles and the dengue virus. The vaccine makes it worse.
As we know, the vaccines have only just been distributed on a large scale and the timing of
the vaccine with the outbreak is very curious. They occurred nearly simultaneously. We know
Britain was the first country to adopt the vaccine. They did it even before the US and
Britain just happened to be the country with this new strain outbreak. Of course, we don't have
proof that this is ADE, but the timing is very suspicious. Do we know whether the current
outbreak in Britain has infected people who received the vaccine? I imagine it might be
too soon to know for sure since the vaccines were just distributed. Yes, we need a period of time
to figure out exactly what's going on. Of course, Britain only just started to distribute the
vaccines, so we just don't know for sure whether they are or aren't effective against this new
strain, or even more concerning, whether they may cause ADE. We need more time, but time is precious.
We know that the most critical time to stop this virus is within the first two weeks of any outbreak
before it takes hold in the population and spreads. We may have already passed this window.
If this new strain is able to elude the vaccines, then we may in fact be staring at the start of a
I want to go back to what we talked a little about, the idea of lockdowns and quarantines.
A lot of evidence has shown that they don't really work. I just saw a report that Holland also has
this strain within its borders, but they don't know if it came from one traveler, if it was maybe
already in the population. At this point we only know that Britain is seeing a large number of
cases, so I think the quarantines of Britain by other countries may already be too late and will
probably be ineffective. What do you think? I agree. Lockdowns and quarantines generally have
not been effective. The best example is probably right here in the US. We see this in the experiences
of the blue versus red states. Yes, I saw that someone had compared Florida and California.
In general, the democrat-controlled states have been much more rigorous in terms of shutdowns,
quarantines and so on, but the infection rate and overall impact, both in terms of cases and
fatalities, are higher in the blue states. Of course there are other factors, but I think it's fair to
say the evidence is inconclusive. We just don't know how effective lockdowns really are when it
comes to the spread of this virus. We will be paying very close attention to the news of this
strain in the coming days, and I think the next few days and weeks are critical in determining
whether we're in the beginning of the second wave. I'd like to thank our two guests for
joining us tonight. Thank you for watching.
